New Freeview PVR

I am a very happy camper with MySky and in fact resent having to get a Freeview box also. So I haven’t.

But I must say the Freeview PVR described in the Herald sounds good:

It also features a impressive work around for timing clashes between shows.

Browning explained that – using Shortland Street as an example, if the receiver has a programming clash for a weeknight episode, it will look forward and choose between rescreenings on other digital channels, or pick the episode out of the weekend ‘Omnibus’.

Now that’s smart.

Dom Post on NZ First

Almost overlooked their editorial this morning:

The “over-enthusiastic supporter” on whom Winston Peters blamed the breach turned out not to be someone with only a tenuous connection to the party, but Tommy Gear, a friend of the NZ First leader and a man who has been paid hundreds of thousands of dollars by the Parliamentary Service for work done for NZ First.

He is more than a friend. According to the electoral roll, Winston lives with Mr Gear in Tauranga.

But if readers think it is a source of concern that a man on the parliamentary payroll is unaware of the rules governing political advertising, it gets worse.

Even within NZ First few know what Mr Gear has done to earn a salary of up to $50,000 a year. And neither Mr Peters nor the Parliamentary Service is prepared to say.

We could run a guessing competition, but I think that could get messy!

Mr Peters, who has refused to even confirm that Mr Gear works for NZ First, has responded to questions with his usual belligerence. “Print one thing wrong, sunshine, and I will sue you.” The Parliamentary Service refuses to say what Mr Gear does, how much he is payed, what hours he works, or even whether he is still on the payroll. Pay and hours are a matter for the MP and the staff member, says general manager Geoff Thorn.

That is an outrage. Mr Peters demands transparency and accountability of others but, as ACT leader Rodney Hide has rightly pointed out, he “can’t answer the most basic questions to do with public money and his own behaviour”.

Yay Rodney.

Only slightly less outrageous is the refusal of National to comment on what is clearly an unsatisfactory state of affairs.

It is hardly surprising that Mr Peters is refusing to talk about his relationship with Mr Gear. It is only a few weeks ago that he refused to reveal to which charities NZ First had given the $158,000 it misspent during the last election campaign rather than return it to the public purse.

But the main Opposition party should have something to say about public money being spent in such an unaccountable fashion. That National does not suggests either that it does not want to invite scrutiny of its own use of parliamentary funds, or it does not want to alienate a potential coalition partner.

The latter I would say. Good to see they are not staying totally quiet on this latest issue.

Salient interviews Jordan Carter

Salient interviews Jordan Carter, who is standing for Labour in Hunua. I’m even one of the topics discussed, and Jordan is very generous with his comments.

One part I’ll quote, which I agree with:

Do you think that the struggle for gay rights has largely finished in New Zealand, do you think that the battle has been won?

No, no, I think the battle for gay rights quote, unquote, will be won when there isn’t a battle for gay rights anymore. When the idea of someone being gay is no more particular or significant than them having red hair, or them being short…

I know not everyone is there, but to me someone being gay is about as significant as them having red hair. Except of course gingas deserve to be persecuted. More seriously, when I do find out someone I know is gay, it is just a feature of who they are.

Savage attack by Peters on Audrey Young

NZPA reports on Winston’s comments at the airport:

Today Mr Peters again said there was no donation.

“I don’t know whether there are any emails at all, whether they’ve been doctored whether they’re in part. I’ve never seen them,” he told reporters.

“The editor of the New Zealand Herald and the Herald journalist Audrey Young can see NZ First’s accounts and talk to our independent auditors, but when they find nothing I want them to both apologise to the public and then resign…

“Don’t you guys get it one of your colleagues is a liar and if she doesn’t like that tell her to sue me.”

In a statement to NZPA, Herald editor Tim Murphy said the paper stood by the story and Young.

“The issue here is simple: Owen Glenn says he donated to New Zealand First. Winston Peters has said and continues to say that Glenn didn’t. The story, based on explicit emails, highlights that gap,” he said.

“The responses by Mr Peters, while strident, do not explain that gap and continue to leave open to interpretation all kinds of possibilities for funding assistance for his party and its interests.

“In the circumstances, we see no value in the offer of examining New Zealand First’s `annual accounts’.”

This is an extraordinary attack on Audrey Young. He seems to be basically accusing her of fabricating or doctoring the e-mails. Now the problem with this theory is what Steve Fisher and Owen Glenn have said:

The Dom Post has comment from Steve Fisher:

Mr Fisher confirmed to The Dominion Post yesterday that he had been in email contact with Mr Glenn in February, though he no longer had copies of those emails.

Advice quoted in the emails was in line with what he been advising Mr Glenn at the time, though he could not recall “the exact wording” and did not know if Mr Glenn had given money to NZ First. He did not know how the e-mails had entered the public arena.

So Fisher is saying the e-mails are in line with his recollection.

And what some have overlooked is Audrey Young actually managed to talk to Owen Glenn on Friday about the e-mails and here is what he said:

Last night, Mr Glenn was in Monaco, and when asked why he had not said in February that he gave money, he said: “I made a decision not to say anything to anybody because there was so much controversy about everything. I was just there to open the business school so I just didn’t want to get caught up in anything … I elected not to say anything.”

So Glenn didn’t use that opportunity to deny the e-mail is authentic or that he donated.

The stakes are very high. Peters has called for the Herald Editor (Tim Murphy) and Political Editor (Audrey Young) to be sacked. But quite what for, I am not sure.

Blog Poll Results

Well many more blog polls since I last summarised the results in late April. The following results since then:

  1. 79% approve of National’s fibre to the home policy
  2. 31% think global warming is a hoax, 20% say we should reduce emissions at a rate which does not harm economic growth, 19% think global warming is exaggerated, 16% think we should reduce emissions at the same rate as other countries, 7% say reducing emissions should be our top priority and 7% say the world faces Armageddon if emissions are not reduced
  3. 57% of readers/respondents are male heterosexuals, 24% are female heterosexuals, 7% male homosexuals, 6% male bisexual, 3% female bisexual and 3% lesbian.
  4. The best post (start of) WWII PM was rated David Lange with 23% then Keith Holyoake 20% and Helen Clark 12%. Bottom was Bill Rowling and Walter Nash on 1% each.
  5. 53% would choose higher broadband data caps over 47% preferring faster broadband speeds
  6. 36% rated the Budget very poor, 30% poor, 16% average, 10% very good and 9% good
  7. The preferred next Labour Party Leader was Phil Goff on 44% then Andrew Little on 14% and Shane Jones on 10%.
  8. 68% prefer to have dinner before a 7 pm movie, not afterwards
  9. 52% want Charles as King of NZ when the Queen dies, vs 48% favouring a Republic.
  10. 95% of respondents have visited Australia, 74% Europe, 73% Asia, 69% North America, 26% Africa, 13% South America and 3% Antarctica
  11. Only 9% have a Freeview box
  12. 36% think 15 years is the starting point for rape convctions, 22% think 10 years, 16% five years and only 12% correctly stated eight years.
  13. 82% of respondents have made their mind up as to who to vote for
  14. The favourite TV channel is TV3 with 34%, Prime on 30%, TV One on 19%, C4 on 7%, TV2 on 5% and Maori TV on 5%.

As always many interesting results. All totally unscientific but useful to see how readers differ from the overall population. The TV favourability for example is very different to overall ratings.

Cash for influence in the UK

The Telegraph has a story on how evil corporates are exchanging cash for policy in the UK:

For as little as £2,000 the businesses can secure membership of the management committee in target seats and a direct influence in policy making at the party’s annual conference.

In return for the money the local parties set up Constituency Development Plans and agree to a raft of business demands. They include appointing ‘business officers’ to branch committees, encouraging recruitment for the branch from within the business, and in return for their funding, Labour MPs must do their bidding.

In return for a massive increase in financial support businesses are drawing up a shopping list of policy changes which include making it less expensive to dismiss staff, new rules to protect bosses of private equity owned firms, and push to make get rid of equal pay audits in the private sector.

The negotiations between the businesses and ministers over a new deal – known as Warwick II – will see a raft of new concessions that will further deregulate workplaces and are designed to help businesses recruit more non-union staff.

The demands are set to become ever more important to the Labour Government as ministers increasingly rely on business backing.

In 2006, 70 per cent of Labour’s donations – £8.5million – came from businesses. Since the beginning of 2001, when parties were required to declare large donations, businesses have given £55million to Labour.

The blueprint for financing local parties is contained in a business web site  which states: “A robust CDP agreement will also include targets and activities that the Constituency Labour Party pledges to undertake.

“If a Constituency Labour Party has a CDP in place with a business, then the business should take an active role in ensuring that the terms of the agreement are fulfilled; and take responsibility for writing six-monthly activity reports.”

In return the businesses will provide: “…polling or opinion surveys among the electorate; recruiting and retaining members; producing and distributing literature; informing and encouraging dialogue between the party and the community.”

This all sounds very shocking.Surely there must be an investigation into how these businesses are purchasing inappropriate influence in politics.

Be aware I have made some minor changes to the article, and people should read the original.

Pandering to Economist

Greg Mankiw writes in the NY Times about a small special interest group – economists. He give a list of eight policies that he says would appeal to the vast majority of economists.

  1. Support free trade
  2. Oppose farm subsidies
  3. Leave oil companies and speculators alone
  4. Tax the use of energy
  5. Raise the retirement age
  6. Invite more skilled immigrants
  7. Liberalize drug policy
  8. Raise funds for economic research

I support pretty much all of the above. It is of course a matter of degree. We have GST on energy and petrol excise tax to fund the roads and the ETS will be a tax on energy, so I’m not saying you want even more taxes.

Clark says nothing to do with her

NZPA reports:

But Miss Clark today said it was a party matter and did not relate to Mr Peters’ foreign affairs portfolio, in which he conducted himself with integrity.

Um, how does she know unless the conflicting statements are reconciled? Is she saying the appointment of Consuls is not relevant to the foreign affairs portfolio?

Meanwhile, Mr Peters today said he was prepared to hand over NZ First’s audited accounts to the Herald, which he has accused of fabricating the email, so it could see there had been no donation from Mr Glenn.

“I have had the records searched when this allegation was made at the beginning of the year,” he said on Radio New Zealand.

“I’ve had them searched again and these records have all been audited as well and there is no such record at all.”

Mr Peters said Herald reporters could look at the audited accounts and talk to the auditor, but if their story was wrong they should resign.

This is a useful offer. Peters though should not be angry at the Herald but Owen Glenn (if Glenn is wrong). He says the e-mail is fabricated by one of the participants has confirmed it is basically true.

I would make the point though that summarised annual accounts will not tell you anything about who donated and how big a donation was. For that one would need access to the bank statements and associated raw documents. If Peters is willing to have some independent body scrutinise them, then that would clear he matter up.

A month of news

Throng has surveyed the news bulletins for One News, Three News, Prime News and TVNZ 7 News at 8 over four weeks. Some interesting findings:

  • ONE News: 57% News, 27% Sport, 16% Weather
  • 3 News: 65% News, 25% Sport, 10% Weather
  • PRIME: 59% News, 36% Sport, 4% Weather
  • TVNZ 7: 74% News, 15% Sport, 11% Weather

So Prime has the second least news and most sport. One News has the most weather. TVNZ 7 the most sport and 3 News in the middle.

In terms of live crosses:

  • ONE News: averaged 3.3/bulletin, maximum: 7 in a bulletin
  • 3 News: averaged 2.6/bulletin, maximum: 6 in a bulletin
  • PRIME News: only 1 in the survey period
  • TVNZ 7: averaged 1.9/bulletin, maximum: 5 in a bulletin

This probably shows the greater resources of TVNZ. Too many live crosses do get annoying but TV does them to give you a sense of urgency and being totally up to date.

Then finally they look at how often the news is used to promote other programmes:

  • ONE News: Agenda (5 times), Breakfast, Hannah Montana, Reluctant Hero documentary, Sex and the City and South Park
  • 3 News: 60 Minutes, Campbell Live, Home and Away (twice), Rove (twice), Kath & Kim and Prison Break
  • PRIME News: Flight of the Conchords, Oprah, Sky News, WWE Raw and Hannah Montana
  • TVNZ 7: Agenda (5 times), Close Up, The View and The Bachelor

To be fair to TVNZ, Agenda is a legitimate source of news from their weekly interviews, so one does expect them to reference it.

I record both One News and Three News on My Sky and just watch the segments from each I am interested in. Normally can do both bulletins in 30 – 40 minutes.

It’s all John Key’s fault

I wondered how The Standard would find a way to blame John Key for the Tony Veitch affair. I thought it wouldn’t be possible – but no even they found a way. This was too much for Maia.

Next we await how John Key was indirectly responsible for the death of the Police Officer at the weekend. And for the high inflation out tomorrow. And for the crap weather last week.

What I have found most amusing is that they are upset John Key hasn’t responded to their requests for an interview. This is like the Mongrel Mob complaining that the Police Commissioner won’t answer their questions!

ODT Editorial on National Broadcasting

The ODT editorialises on National’s broadcasting policy:

TVNZ was to operate a dual mandate.

It was required to make market returns to the Government in the fiercely competive ratings-driven commercial environment, but it would be expected to make and screen Charter programmes.

For this, it would receive an annual hand-out in the region of $15 million – in addition to the contestable funds already allocated to New Zealand on Air for local content.

There are those who have long said that such a system was doomed to failure – that the two aims were so incompatible it could only end in tears.

Among them was former CEO Ian Fraser.

End in tears it has.

Whatever is to be made of the National Party’s new broadcasting “policy”, it has to be said that in the nine years it has had to get public broadcasting policy right, Labour-led administrations have singularly failed to do so.

It has been a failure. Ask anyone in TVNZ. The status quo is not viable, regardless of who is in Government.

The first of these, perhaps more profound in its implications than in its impact, is that TVNZ will be freed from its Charter shackles. The $15 million alotted to it specifically for its charter programming will go into the contestable New Zealand on Air fund for local programming – available to a range of independent producers.

Critics have pointed out that this can only mean a reduction of an already sparse complement of “blue-chip” Charter material – the high-cost documentaries, history series, and arts programmes.

Except that charter money did not always or arguably even often go towards these.

And that eventually, in effect, the “State” broadcaster would become another commercial channel like any other.

They also argue that with a less stringent mandate, more of the contestable funding will find its way on to the screens in the form of low-cost local content of the “reality TV” variety.

Others maintain that the funds will still be there for the same sorts of programmes, only TVNZ will no longer have preferential access to it.

Indeed. It will be just like the rest of the NZ on Air money – allocated on quality of proposal regardless of who is the broadcaster.

So under National’s policy it is a little unclear in what way this State asset will remain a public broadcaster – and exactly how the free-to-air digital channels TVNZ 6 and 7, with their predominance of local content, will be funded when the currently allocated money – $79 million – runs out in 2012; and, that being the case, why the company should remain in public ownership at all.

TVNZ at present isn’t a public broadcaster on One and Two. They are a 95% commercial broadcaster. I don’t think there is a lot of halfway house between being a public broadcaster and a commercial broadcaster. That is why I would like to see TV2 get sold as fully commercial and look at merging TV One, Radio NZ into one public broadcaster.

As for TV6 and TV7, I imagine they will be evaluated at the time on how successful they have been.

Given the paucity of detail in the policy, opponents, including Broadcasting Minister Trevor Mallard, have been able to revive the spectre of a lean commercially driven TVNZ being fattened up for eventual sale.

Heh I think Trevor would have been suggesting that no matter what the policy.

The second directive that might sound warning bells for those who like their radio waves unadorned by the jingle of cash registers is the “regular publication of rating/audience/household penetration data for any broadcasting entity receiving state funding”.

This may be harmless enough, but, again, in the absence of any qualifying explanation, inferences, rightly or wrongly, may be drawn: public radio – that is to say Radio New Zealand – could be held to account against the sort of ratings and audience share it receives.

There are two issues here. The first is the right of the public to know how many people are listening to the programmes they are paying for with their taxes. The second is how that information is used.

I don’t think there is any acceptable reason for the taxpayer to not know how many people listen or view to the programmes they fund,

And the fear must be that commercial models will be used to evaluate performance.

Of course, the very point of public radio is that it should operate free of such considerations across a spectrum of genres and programmes that are ignored as uneconomic by commercial radio.

This is too simplistic a view. National Radio may not have advertising, which means all programmes are in theory uneconomic. But it is useful to know how many people listen to a programme. If a programme costs $500,000 a year and has only 500 people listen to it then one may be able to deliver better radio to more people with a programme that costs $700,000 and has 10,000 people listen to it. Ratings are not the only measurement for public broadcasting – but they are *one* of them.

Certainly, it is in the medium of radio that arguably the starkest differences between commercial and public imperatives emerge.

For few of the core activities of Radio New Zealand – documentaries, classical music, current affairs, in-depth interviews, and the magazine formats of shows such as those presided over by Kim Hill, Chris Laidlaw, Kathryn Ryan and Jim Mora – would survive under the fiscal ruler of the market.

But many would argue they constitute the very heart of public broadcasting and, as such, perform a vital role in sustaining the nation’s intellectual and cultural capital.

But if no-one is listening to them, they are not performing any role.

Tamaki now talks to airline cabin stewards

Oh this is so funny. The SST reports that Brian Tamaki is now much more relaxed about homosexuality – to the point that he will even talk to airline cabin stewards now.

I am sure gays and lesbians up and down NZ will be celebrating.

To be fair some progress is better than none. The next step is to get Archbishop Tamaki talking to male hairdressers and if he survives that maybe he could try talking to women cricket players.

Fleeing Drivers

I agree with the Police Association that here should be tougher penalties for drivers who flee from the Police. All too often it leads to a death, and the incentives need to be there so that fleeing from the Police is not worthwhile.

I like the idea of vehicle confiscation and imprisonment for those who flee. It means that if you get asked to pull over, you have a clear choice of complying or automatic loss of car and jail. Sure you may get away, but if you do not then it is 100% guaranteed you lose your car and spend some time in jail.

Peters claims reports are malicious lies

The Dom Post reports:

Mr Peters initially told The Dominion Post yesterday it was wasting its time pursuing what he labelled “malicious lies”. He then called back to warn against suggesting in today’s article that he had refused to answer questions.

Referring to reports in The Dominion Post about Tauranga man Tommy Gear, who is on the parliamentary payroll as a NZ First staffer, Mr Peters said he would not offer an explanation till the newspaper explained its motivation in running those stories.

“You’re not going to be pulling these narrow focused conspiracies against us. It’s not going to be happening … Why is your paper engaged in lying?”

Now if WInston is correct and this is all malicious lies, I am trying to think of the possible scenarios which back this up. They are:

  1. The e-mails are fakes or forgeries. If this is the case then there is a huge defamation case heading towards the NZ Herald. However Steve Fisher of Baldwin Boyle has confirmed the e-mails were in line with his advice to Owen Glenn.
  2. Owen Glenn is lying to Steve Fisher when he says he donated to NZ First. Now it is very hard to imagine the rationale you would have to lie to your own PR advisor in a private e-mail which was never intended to see the light of day.
  3. Owen Glenn is mad. He is a Walter Mitty type who lives in a fantasy world and created this whole scandal of donating to NZ First, when he never did just so he could hire PR advisors to advise him how to deny something he never did.
  4. Owen Glenn is confused. He thought he donated to NZ First, but actually donated to another political party by mistake.

Now I have to say I’m not sure which of these scenarios is most likely, but if this is all malciious lies, I look forward to finding out.

The Herald reports that Helen Clark is not likely to want to comment on the issue:

Helen Clark has refused to comment on the donation controversy, and today is likely to insist it is an internal matter for New Zealand First.

It would be an interesting standard for Helen Clark. After all she leads the party that campaigned on transparency in electoral financing.

The reality is this is not just a NZ First internal issue. Helen Clark appointed Winston Peters Foreign Minister. As Foreign Minister he was lobbied by Owen Glenn to appoint Glenn Consul to Monaco. If Glenn is a secret donor to the Foregin Minister’s party, that is an issue of great relevance to the Government. Just as the fact Mike WIlliams lobbed Helen Clark on behalf of Owen Glenn.

We still do not know if Owen Glenn did donate to NZ First. The only way it can be resolved is an independent investigation. But if he did donate, why did he donate? Would he have donated (if he did) if WInston was not Foreign Minister? That is why it is an issue for the Prime Minister.

Nice for Wellington

Lindsay Mitchell has this graph. That big blue line at the top is Wellington, where people are now being paid an average $100 a week more than in Auckland.

I’m not sure the data source for the graph, but presume it is the Stats NZ Quarterly Employment Survey.

Hooton on how Labour can win

SST Columnist Matthew Hooton also has some advice on how Labour can win. His column isn’t obline but some extracts:

On one issue at least, Helen Clark is true to her word. In 1990, Clark vowed to be as “vicious, nasty and opportunist as anyone” to return Labour to power. Eighteen years later, her promise still holds.

Well that is one promise she has kept.

Clark also knows the power of fear. Labour’s superb “Don’t Put It All At Risk” advertising campaign in the last few days before the 2005 election, while funded with illegal spending, was more powerful even than National’s iwi/kiwi billboards.

Just as with Crosby / Texter’s “Are You Thinking What We’re Thinking?” campaign for the British Tories in 2005, “Don’t Put It All At Risk” was devoid of content and simply invited voters to define for themselves what they were most afraid of and associate it with Don Brash. Along with Labour’s letters to state-house tenants implying they would be evicted if they voted National, the campaign was the ultimate in fear-mongering, dog-whistling politics, and it won the election for Clark and Labour in 2005.

The state house eviction letters was classic fear-mongering indeed.

If “smear and fear” is successful in taking just five points off National’s support – driving it down from 53% to 48% – then Labour has a chance of forming a government whatever happens to its own vote.

With a Labour result of just 31%, the Greens on 10%, Winston Peters getting 5% and the Maori Party winning all seven Maori seats, a Labour/Anderton/Green/Maori/New Zealand First combination would hold 64 seats in parliament, enough to form a government.

Yes it is possible even from 31% Labour could form a Government. The only way one can be sure of a change in Government is to vote for the two parties which will definitely not support Labour.

These are minor shifts in public opinion in the heat of an election campaign, during which around a third of voters will engage in politics for the first time for three years, and make up their minds to swing the result. Political junkies like me, Chris Trotter and you, as a reader of these columns, don’t ultimately decide elections. Those reading the Hollywood pages this morning are the people who count.

Sad but true.

A National result of 48% would still be the party’s best result in 57 years yet, with Labour on just 31% support, Clark would remain prime minister, Michael Cullen would remain finance minister, Jim Anderton would remain in charge of our most important export industries, Winston Peters would keep the baubles his foreign minister’s job delivers, Jeanette Fitzsimons would get to decide what lightbulbs we must use and the Maori Party could deliver the foreshore and seabed to iwi.

Matthew sounds like Roald Dahl 🙂

Mallard on Agenda

Agenda was a good watch today. Jim Bolger was in great form as he told off the interview for trying to trick him, and proclaiming he is far too experience to fall into those traps. It brought back fond memories.

But the main guest was Trevor Mallard, and Trevor said some interesting things:

TREVOR Well I’m happy to have floats as long as it’s non core assets.  I mean we’re not gonna float for example the wind farms of Meridian.

My God, imagine if a National MP was saying this. It would be “Privatisation Alert, Privatisation Alert”.

I am glad to see Trevor say it is okay to float non core assets. Could someone ask him for a list.

GUYON What you’re telling me is that you want to sell the subsidiaries but you haven’t been able to.

TREVOR I’m happy for things which are not part of the core to be partially floated, at the moment there’s none of those that are big enough to be interesting, but what I’m not prepared to do is to have the state owned assets either sold and leased back the way John Key has been looking at or prepared for sale the way he indicated that he would use first three  years in government.

Trevor gets marks for always trying to score a point, and invent a policy for National. The important thing to note again is he says it is fine to sell non core assets.

GUYON Okay, can I look at the appointments to SOE boards.  You’ve recently, well not you personally, but Diane Yates has recently been appointed, the former Labour MP to the board of the SOE Learning Media, I mean isn’t this just another example of political cronyism and you’re not getting the best people on these boards you’re getting your old mates appointed to the boards of SOEs.

TREVOR Well I think if you have a really good look and analyse who I have appointed to SOE boards you’ve got one of the classic ones coming on your programme soon, we’ve gone for the talented people, the people who can do the jobs, and if you look very carefully at the chairs of the SOE boards…

This is very interesting. Trevor is ignoring the fact four of his colleagues have gives Yates a Board job, and is just stressing that he personally has not, and he appoints talent only.

This is a very clever way to get across the point he had nothing to do with her appointments and that he does not think she is talented. Otherwise he would have defended her appointments on the basis of the skills she would bring to those boards.

Some facts about Owen Glenn

Some related facts about Owen Glenn:

  1. He was not born in New Zealand.
  2. He has not lived in New Zealand for over 40 years.
  3. He is not eligible to vote in New Zealand.
  4. He is estimated to have a fortune of around NZ$1.1 billion.
  5. He donated $500,000 to Labour for the 2005 election.
  6. This is the largest known donor ever in New Zealand politics.
  7. The Labour Party amended the Electoral Finance Bill to specifically allow him to keep donating money, while restricting other foreign donations to $1,000 (by defining a foreign donation as being okay from overseas residents who are NZ citizens even though they are ineligible to enrol or vote)
  8. He gave Labour a further $100,000 interest free loan in 2007.
  9. Labour gave him a gong – Officer of the NZ Order of Merit in 2007.
  10. Labour President Mike Williams lied when he said they had not received a donation from Owen Glenn since the 2005 election, as the interest free loan counts as a donation.
  11. Mike Williams has said he will be asking Owen Glenn for money for the 2008 election.
  12. Owen Glenn says Bill Lloyd of Sovereign Yachts had been “badly dealt by” over getting cheap Government land for his business “…but it’s all been resolved through the good services of Mike Williams, the President of the Labour Party, who’s done a mammoth job.”
  13. Owen Glenn wants to be Honorary Consul for NZ to Monaco.
  14. Before Owen wanted this post, the Government had repeatedly ruled out having a Consul in Monaco.
  15. Mike Williams lobbied Helen Clark on behalf of Owen Glenn to get him made Consul.
  16. Owen Glenn lobbed Winston Peters to be made Consul and said he will be confirmed as Consul “when Peters gets off his arse”.
  17. Owen Glenn was never given any negative signals about being made Consul even though a previous expression of interest by an individual was comprehensively ruled out by the Government.
  18. Owen Glenn says he has donated money to NZ First.
  19. The then NZ First President says a five figure donation closer to $100,000 than $10,000 appeared anonymously in their bank account in December 2007.
  20. Winston Peters says NZ First has never received any money from Owen Glenn or his associates.
  21. NZ First filed a donations return claiming no-one gave then more than $10,000 in 2007.
  22. Owen Glenn’s PR firm advised Owen Glenn not to contradict Winston’s denials even though he did make a donation.
  23. The Maori Party say someone offered them $250,000 as a campaign donation before the 2005 election if it agreed to support Labour. The offer was made twice.
  24. The Maori Party say it was made on behalf of someone who “lived outside New Zealand, and had donated money to the Labour Party” and the intermediary met with him on a yacht or a boat.
  25. Owen Glenn’s PR firm says he was right to deny he made the offer.
  26. Labour and NZ First forced through the Electoral Finance Act whose purpose is “to strengthen the law governing electoral financing and broadcasting, in order to … prevent the undue influence of wealth on electoral outcomes and … provide greater transparency and accountability on the part of candidates, parties, and other persons engaged in election activities in order to minimise the perception of corruption”

McCarten on how Labour can win

Matt McCarten looks at how Labour can win despite the polls:

The polls are disastrous for Labour, no matter how you try to spin it. National consistently wins more than 50 per cent in the polls while Labour sits in the low 30s. …

Clark’s claim that the polls aren’t accurate is dubious at best. She has some legitimacy when she points out that they tend to under-count young people and the less well off, who are more likely to be her supporters. Only people with landlines are polled, which excludes many young and poor people. Anecdotal evidence suggests that about one in three people on the electoral roll does not have a landline.

Many polling companes weigh their results to counter any under-representation of key demograpgic groups. And the numbers on the electoral roll with landlines is over 90% not 70%.

But even so, this would probably make a difference of less than 5 per cent. With polls showing up to 25 points between the two big parties, that won’t be much comfort to her parliamentary colleagues.

People may be surprised by how little weighted results often differ from raw results.

But Clark isn’t giving up and at her caucus retreat, read the riot act to her MPs: buck up and fight. As the cliché goes, a week is a long time in politics and Labour has four months to close the gap. If it can narrow the gap to 10 points or less it will win.

I said a long time back that a gap of less than 10% is a probable Labour Government. A 10% to 15% gap is pretty uncertain and over 15% is very probably National.

The election finance and anti-smacking legislation have been disasters for Labour. But I’m not sure they’re as important as people make out. The election restrictions are more of an obsession for political commentators and media owners.

They are, but a constant string of negative stories does have a background effect on the public, and it makes it difficult for the Government to get momentum.

Some of our media spin doctors have fixated on the difference between National and Labour, and ignored the other parties. Take it as read that for Labour to have any chance it will need the support of the Green, New Zealand First and the Maori parties.

There is little doubt in my mind these three parties will, between them, get more than 15 per cent of the vote. The remaining minnow parties are electorally irrelevant and can safely be ignored. But if National doesn’t maintain at least a 15-point gap over Labour, it will be in trouble.

Not necessairly in trouble per se, but I agree at less than 15% Labour starts to get options.

If you didn’t have to deal with the vanities and the complicated personal relationships between party leaders, Labour’s electoral strategy would be very simple. It would be a smart move to endorse the Maori Party candidates in the seven Maori seats for the price of counter endorsement giving Labour the party vote and a pre-election coalition agreement. This would give the Maori Party a clean sweep of all the Maori seats without a fight and would increase Labour’s party vote by at least 2 per cent, giving it at least 10 additional seats in a Labour-led, post-election government.

This is true, but it would be a highly unproportional result and MMP would inevitably die as a result. Matt needs to be careful about winning battles but losing the war. Using overhang as a delebrate strategy to win an election would generate a massive backlash. As it happens I think we saw with Shane Jones and Derek Fox that the bad blood is so massive Labour endorsing Maori Party candidates is highly unlikely.

The Green Party is a guaranteed supporter, and Labour just has to give tacit support to its more left-leaning and liberal voters giving their party vote to the Greens. This should help the Greens get over 10 per cent and adds another 13 Green MPs.

Votes from Labour to Greens don’t increase the chance of a left wing Government – they do make it more left than centre though. I agree with Matt that the Greens are guaranteed to go with Labour despite their protestations. They’re like the battered spouse always coming back for more!

New Zealand First, of course, is a little more complex, but personal support for Peters is still strong. National is running an aggressive campaign to prevent Peters from winning Tauranga. If Labour kneecapped its own candidate and openly endorsed Peters to win that seat back, Peters would no doubt bring his MPs into a Labour coalition.

Except Winston says he wants no deals to win. And at the moment is not the time to talk abour Labour endorsing Winston!

Of course, that kind of realpolitik strategy would have the political chattering classes in an uproar. But if Clark really wants a fourth term, the Maori Party wants a guarantee of all Maori seats, the Greens want to be in Cabinet, and New Zealand First wants to survive, this is the way do it.

In these desperate times, Labour had better start thinking outside the box – and fast.

One can’t rule it out. But of course the long term consequences might be New Zealand dumps MMP, the Maori seats are abolished and Winston loses Tauranga anyway even with Labour’s endorsement.

Ralston on Veitch

There are around 20 stories and columns on Veitch today, and frankly it is getting overkill. I’m not even going to attempt to summarise them, except I do want to quote from Ralston a bit:

A hosed-off One News reporter covering the story appeared in a “live cross” in the 6pm bulletin, denouncing Flannery for failing to respond to her questions and dismissing Rick Ellis’ short press statement on the affair as “bland”. In a wonderfully timed act of rebellion the newsroom then served its TVNZ masters with an Official Information Act request for details of the company’s involvement in the matter and comment from Flannery and Ellis.

This was Lisa Owen and if there is a journalism award for sheer guts, she should get it.  Filing an OIA on your own employer and dissing your own Head of News and Current Affairs plus the CEO is just priceless. In one sense Owen is just treating TVNZ no different to any other organisation – as she should – but still there were ways in which she could be more subtle and she chose not to.

The story has got murkier today. We now know that now only did TVNZ and Radio Sport know for over a year, so have the Police. And also the $170,000 or so wasn’t negotiated at the time but asked for some months later.

Interview with Key

HoS Assistant Editor Stephen Cook has interviewed John Key. Some interesting hints of future policy:

He alludes to the “comprehensive economic plan” National has in store, which will revolve largely around tax cuts, “reining in the impact Government bureaucracy has on peoples’ lives” and a heavy infrastructure investment programme.

The investment in infrastructure will be welcome – there is a real need for more energy capacity, more transpaort infrastruture as well as better communications infrastructure.

Key also says there will be “lots of changes around education and law and order”, but won’t go into specifics apart from promising more power and resources for police, including Tasers.

“Drugs are changing the dynamic for police officers on the street now and the number of violent attacks is increasing,” Key says. “I don’t think there is any question the police need more resourcing. We like the idea of a ratio of one police officer to a certain number of citizens.”

Keys says South Auckland remains a troubling hotspot and National is committed to an “action plan” that “is pretty comprehensive around resolving the issues”.

Again, no specifics but Key says the policy – coming off the back of his “underclass speech” last year – will deal with “everything from education through to how we deal with young people going off the rails”.

“It is a very creative policy. You will see some out-of-the box thinking here,” Key assures.

Heh, hopefully more comprehensive that Winston’s bold pledge that he will get rid of gangs.

On the economic front, he accepts National’s eagerly awaited tax package will be the central and most important plank of its pre-election policy announcements.

Again, he’s not yet in a position to reveal just how much New Zealanders will get in their back pockets, or how National will fund the cuts.

“But Kiwis aren’t fools. They know the economy is slowing down. They know the options for National are reducing. They know Labour has been on a big spending binge and are clearly on a bender to try and leave the cupboard not only bare, but without shelves.

“That is going to make life more challenging for us and that is one of the reasons we are not going to over-promise. But we certainly have a tax plan that works and is affordable.”

I imagine we will see the plan very shortly after Clark sets the date.

A scenario is not a prediction

Idiot/Savant blogs at No Right Turn:

CSIRO, Australia’s premier scientific institution, is predicting petrol will cost $10 /litre within a decade.

No they are not. That is quite misleading. They have included an A$8/litre scenario – they are not predicting that as the most likely scenario. In fact to quote the Herald:

“The future price of oil is uncertain,” Dr Wright said. “The Forum’s scenario modelling shows that if oil production peaks, prices could climb as high as A$8 per litre by 2018 in the most extreme case.”

So the “most extreme” scenario is not a prediction. The use of “will” instead of “may”compunds the error.

Annette King

Claire Trevett takes a look at Annette King – it’s a good balance piece:

It has been a month of rare public relations blunders for King, whose portfolios are critical in an election year in which law and order and rising living costs will be the main acts on the voters’ playbill. …

Her handling of the Electoral Finance Act has also lacked the robust counter-attacks she makes on National over law and order issues.

To be fair to Annette it is a pig of a law to have to defend. However her law of common sense quote will haunt her for ages.

King has assiduously built links with those in the mid and back benches and developed a strongly loyal following.

When Shane Jones needed a makeover, it was “Aunty Annette” who told him to have a shave and get a new suit.

Darren Hughes is another acolyte and her willingness to talk MPs through both portfolio and constituency problems has ensured few, if any, dislike her.

King is loyal to Helen Clark and is one of the first called to the Prime Minister’s office in times of trouble. But she is not so close as to have alienated those who may feel aggrieved at being overlooked for promotion in favour of other Clark favourites.

Come the time Clark decides to go, or caucus decides it for her, it is likely to be King to whom many turn for guidance and to nurse the party through its transition phase without turning into a scene from Lord of the Flies.

Her influence will also be a potent force should she decide to harness it in favour of any individual contender for the leadership.

She is unlikely to want the top job herself. Nor, despite her competence, is she suited for it.

Viciously defensive over her personal life, she will not want the scrutiny that comes with the job.

She resists media throngs, and while she can bang heads with the best of them in debates over general policies in Parliament, her disposition makes her unsuited to spear-head pointed attacks.

The most she can drum up against Bill English – even at his most irritating – is “Mr Nasty”.

But when sniffing the wind to see to whom Labour will look for a future leader, it would pay to check whose barbecues Annette King is going to.

It is true Annette has no real enemies in Labour. And even in National she is not regarded badly. They enjoy denting her reputation – but she doesn’t exude the smugness and arrogance of some of her colleagues which turns it from professional to personal.

I love the description of Darren Hughes as her acolyte. What a great term. Mind you Darren has the amazining ability to be everyone’s acolyte – almost uniquely he is warmly regarded by Clark and Goff. If Labour go into opposition it would be worth watching Darren as well as Annette for their moves.

Scandal worse than online shows

One of the problem of getting most of your news online, is that you sometimes miss out on additional info in the print edition. Having now read the print edition of the Herald, it is apparent the scandal is far more serious than I thought for NZ First – and the Government. The print edition includes extracts from the e-mails dated 21 February, namely:

Steve Fisher: Our plan worked well. There is nothing new about you in here Owen. Note that Winston says you have never made a donation to NZ First, so at all costs you must stick to that line. It was definitely the right thing to do to deny the Maori Party offer as well.

Owen Glenn: Steve – are you saying I should deny giving a donation to NZ First? When I did?

Steve Fisher: No, just stick to the line of referring stuff to NZ First. What I’m saying is we don’t want to contradict Winston.

It is harder to get more clearcut than that. Owen Glenn saying beyond any doubt he did give a donation to NZ First.

Helen Clark sacked Liaznne Dalziel for lying. Is she going to have a different standard for Ministers not from her party?

But this scandal goes beyond Winston. Owen Glenn is Labour’s major donor. He has donated $500,000 to them and lent $100,000 interest free. Mike Williams says he will be asking for more money this year.

Note the reference above to the Maori Party. While not as clearcut as the donation to NZ First, it is highly likely that Owen Glenn was the person who offered the Maori Party a six figure sum if they will support Labour.

Throw into the mix the ONZM that Helen Clark gave him and the Honorary Consulship he kept pressuring Winston and Helen for (with support from Mike Williams) and you have a very messy set of circumstances.

The focus for now is on the contradiction between what Winston Peters has said, and Owen Glenn’s e-mails. But the story doesn’t stop there.

Roughan on Obesity

A column from John Roughan I can only agree with:

One of the blessings of a change of government is that it changes the prevailing ethic. Should National win this year we might not see another headline like this week’s: “Rugby cards promo breaks anti-fat rules”. …

Freedom in fact was the default principle after 1984; if it was to be compromised the reason had to be watertight.

No regulator would have dared argue, as the Health Ministry has, that a child might buy 50 packets of chips and consume more than a kilogram of fat to get a complete collection of All Black cards.

Even five years ago somebody would have pointed out that children don’t collect things alone. They trade. Those who don’t want a collectable item give it to one who does, usually for something in return. …

The darkest hour in a phase of unbalanced ethics comes just before the dawn. Right now the promoters of health above all else seem blithely unaware that a change of government will probably soon restore some weight for individual rights and personal responsibility.

When John Key declared the other day that National would tackle obesity mainly with sport and recreation programmes to get children more active, he was quickly rubbished on National Radio by a woman who wants to ban unhealthy advertisements.

What’s the point, she said, of her putting out healthy eating messages when children saw contradictory enticements on television.

Food nazis is not a term I want to use but there is something very chilling in the attitude that the expression of conflicting interests is not permissible.

Helen Clark, who tackled tobacco advertising when Health Minister in the late 1980s, has resisted most of the excesses suggested during her premiership but at times it has seemed a close call.

Deliberately or not, she brought a wowser culture to power which prefers to address problems like obesity and binge drinking by restrictions on liberties that her outlook doesn’t value as high as health and safety.

A change of government will not put an end to public health campaigns and nor should it. We are better off for being aware of the fat in fast food, for ridicule of uncivilised drinking and the expulsion of smokers from confined places.

But it is time to for some balance. Credit us with the intelligence to make choices, especially children, before we create a community of fools.

It is about balance, and most of all not punishing all New Zealanders for the weaknesses of a few.