Jackson helps Obama

Having Jesse Jackson say that he wants to cuts of Barack Obama’s balls should be a huge boost in the polls to Obama.

One of the reasons Obama has been so popular is that he has not been captive to the Cult of Jesse Jackson and the associated established groups such as NAACP. Hell even I want to vote for him when Jackson attacks him.

The Press on Di Yates

The Press labels the four board appointments for Di Yates as a golden handshake:

In a bid to rejuvenate its greying ranks and stave off looming electoral disaster, Labour has been weeding out those it believes do not fit the image of youth and energy it wishes to present to voters at election time later this year. But for those given the shove it appears the Government is prepared to soften the blow by finding them lucrative positions elsewhere. At least that seems to be the conclusion one can draw from a succession of appointments bestowed on the former Labour backbencher, Dianne Yates. …

Now, however, out of the House, no fewer than four Cabinet ministers have lined up like midwinter Father Christmasses to give her jobs. The Food Safety Minister, Lianne Dalziell, appointed her to Food Standards Australia New Zealand (a prime qualification, according to the press release, was that Yates came from the Waikato, “arguably the food bowl of New Zealand”). The Minister of Finance, Michael Cullen, appointed her to Trust Waikato Community Trust. An Associate Minister of Finance, Clayton Cosgrove, and the Education Minister, Chris Carter, appointed her to the board of the education book publisher Learning Media, and Carter lined up again to give her a job on the board of the Waikato Institute of Technology.

All of these add up to about $80,000 a year, plus top-level travel and accommodation costs and various other tidbits, which will put Yates well above the income of the average New Zealand wage-earner. She no doubt has the skills that will make her admirably suited to these various positions. They will certainly cushion the pain of being nudged out of the House, if that is what happened. One Labour insider said it was the price Labour had to pay to get another Samoan into Parliament. The insider should have said it was the price the taxpayer has to pay.

What is especially outrageous over these appointments is that Yates was so lowly regarded by her own colleagues. I’m not trying to be nasty but in a poll for Cabinet she would come last or second last. She was not regarded as a strong performer by anyone in Parliament.

Having four seperate Ministerial appointments is obvious signs of a formal deal, rather than just a Minister thinking an ex-colleague would be a good fit for a Board.

I like it

Owen Glenn did donate to NZ First

There is an explosive story in the NZ Herald, with confirmation directly from Own Glenn that he did donate to NZ First – despite Winston Peters denying it, and NZ First filing a donations return which said it received no donation over $10,000.

There must be an inquiry into this. The e-mail from Owen Glenn to his PR agent is prima facae evidence of a serious breach of the Electoral Act and Electoral Finance Act. This has to be investigated to determine the true facts. If the Electoral Commission does not have the powers to investigate, then it should be referred to the Police who do. Arguably the involvement of MPs could make it an issue for the Serious Fraud Office.

The authorities should demand copies of financial records for NZ First, to determine whether any laws have broken. They should also interview Mr Glenn, his PR agent and key NZ First officials.

Other political leaders should insist this matter be investigated. Helen Clark and John Key need to put aside their desire to keep WInston happy in case they need him post-election and call for the facts to be fully investigated by a competent authority. All of Helen Clark’s calls for transparency in political funding will be hollow and hypocriticial if she refuses to comment or call for action on this.

Now having said that it must be investigated, it is possible no laws have been broken. Let us look firstly at what we do know:

  1. Owen Glenn has donated to NZ First
  2. NZ First has filed a return saying that they received no donation over $10,000 in 2007
  3. Owen Glenn has sought the role of Honorary Consul to Monaco, and has met Winston Peters to discuss this
  4. The then NZ First President Dail Jones say they received a donation in December 2006 which was between $10,000 and $100,000 – and more at the upper end

Now is it possible these can all be reconciled? Possibly – but with difficulty.

First of all it is in theory possible that Owen Glenn did donate but donated less than $10,000, thus not needing to be disclosed.

Secondly it is possible he donated up to $20,000 – $10,000 in 2006 and $10,000 in 2007.

Thirdly it is possible his donation was treated as an interest free loan. The interest waived would be under the $10,000 donation threshold.

I have long suspected scenario three. However for it to be a loan not a donation there would need to be documents supporting this and dated at the time the money was paid. I am unsure you can retrospectively convert a donation to a loan after publicity about it leaks out. Also the e-mail from Glenn talks about donating or giving money – not loaning it.

NZ First may well have an explanation for the conflicting statements. But it will have to do better than Winston holding up a “No” sign at a press conference. The e-mail from Glenn is primae facae evidence of a breach of the Electoral Finance Act and it can’t be ignored.

I also refer people to the NZ Herald article from 29 February:

Asked if he was saying he had never received one dollar from Owen Glenn or any associate of Mr Glenn, he hauls a sign out from under his table.

“NO”, it read.

“Got that?” Mr Peters asked. “N-O. To every one of the allegations you have made.”

The word “No” made frequent appearances. Every now and then a variation was given. A question of whether NZ First ever asked for money from Mr Glenn drew an “Oh, get lost”.

And also:

Q: Has [Glenn] ever offered you money?

A: “No.”

Have you ever asked for it?

“Oh, get lost, Barry.”

Have you ever asked for it?

“We don’t go and ask anybody for money. That’s a fact.”

Has he ever loaned you money?

“In those two nos you get a third no if you put your mind to it.”

So Winston said Owen Glenn never offered money and they never asked for it yet Owen Glenn says he did give money. And Winston also appears to have ruled out a loan.

A fun junket

Now this sounds like a fun junket:

Associate Justice Minister Lianne Dalziel is learning first hand how a country with a reputation for heavy drinking is handling its alcohol problems.

I think this problem may require a lot more study!

Banning

A really good column by Nick Smith in The Independent Financial Review yesterday.Not online but here is the beginning:

The first instinct of any decent government should be to legalise, liberalise and, where necessary, regulate.

Conversely, the universal characteristic of a lousy government is its tendency to ban things.

On that score, the present lot is a lousy government.

Absolutely – bans should be very much a last resort.

He then looks at the party pill ban:

The same cannot be said for the party pill ban, which will increase public demand for amphetamine and its more dangerous refined product, P.

People love intoxicants; always have, always will. The history of cannabis and psilocybin goes back at least 3000 years – testimony to humanity’s abiding desire to alter its consciousness. Don’t mistake this column as advocacy for drug use; these substances are dangerous if misused, particularly in comparison to party pills.

The relatively safe party pill industry serviced a huge market, and not just the dance scene, as evidenced by the drug’s ubiquitous presence on the shelves of corner dairies and booze shops. That demand will now be met, make no mistake, by the black market. Vendors won’t be selling party pills but amphetamine, which offers a higher yield to justify the seller’s risk of arrest and imprisonment.

Amphetamine abuse – already at high levels – will soar.

The fundamental economic law of denied demand underpins my certainty the prohibition will create more illegal drug use and criminal behaviour.

At some stage it would be good to compile a list of all the things the Government has tried to ban in the last nine years.

Another apology to Crosby Textor

I covered a couple of days ago an apology to Crosby Textor from JafaPete. Now we also have an apology from National Business Review. I’m quoting the apology in full here because I think its provides useful details which set the record straight.

Last Friday an article “Searching for John Key” by Ben Thomas falsely asserted that Lynton Crosby had been fined for a dishonest push poll in a Queensland election in 1995.

Ben Thomas acknowledges that this was his error based in part on a publication by Nicky Hager.

Mr Crosby has assured us that neither he nor his firm Crosby Textor has ever been involved
in so-called “push polling,” which is a technique of mass telemarketing, influencing voters by suggesting innuendoes or outright falsehoods about candidates.

Push polling is contrary to the ethical standards of the professional association, the Australian Market & Social Research Society, in which Mr Crosby’s partner Mark Textor has been awarded senior status.

The National Business Review accepts that Crosby Textor has not been involved in push polling, and acknowledges that it had no information at the time of publication which would support the false claim of push polling.

To the extent that it is relevant, we note that Mr Hager has also made a claim that Mr Textor was involved in push polling against a Labor candidate in an Australian by-election in March 1995.

We accept that the opinion poll in question was conducted by an independent pollster, Roy Morgan, instructed by the Liberal Party. It was not push polling, but an attitudinal survey based on a small sample (0.0061 of the electorate).

Some of the information tested was wrong, due to a mistake by the Liberal Party, which paid all the compensation as a result.

Mr Textor apologised because he felt it right to do so, but he was not responsible for the error himself.

Of course some will think the facts no place in this debate, but even Australians deserve the truth told about them!

The NBR also had this item in their satire column. I think they stole it off a blog!:

ROSENEATH, July 11, 2008—Investigative Researcher Nicky Hager was poised this week to publish his most explosive report yet showing that, under a secret health policy plan drawn up by Crosby Textor and already secretly approved by National Party leader John Key, every last man, woman and child currently alive in New Zealand could expect to be dead by 2140.

This is the shock finding of more than a half-year of surveillance of Mr Key by the author of the best-selling Hollow Men, who said this week that the “catastrophic” nature of the finding dwarfed earlier revelations of secret American bagmen, GE-contamination and the private romantic lives of conservative MPs.

“This is something the National Party really doesn’t want you to think about, but think about it you must,” Hager warned. “Under this secret policy, the horrific reality is that four million New Zealanders who are currently happily alive will all be dead and buried, in little more than a century.”

He continued, “Some of my friends in the Labour Party like to call the Tory leader Slippery John, but my name for him is The Grim Reaper John, because that is what he is: the fourth horseman of the Apocalypse, the candidate whose name is death!”

Public Sector Wages

Bernard Hickey takes a close look at public sector wages:

He finds that average wage in the public sector has increased a staggering 9% (hence high inflation and high interest rates) compared to 4.6% for all sectors.  He also finds the gap between public and private sectors wages has grown from $4 and hour to $8 an hour.

The Mission-On website

Bernard Hickey (and his teenage daughter!) review the $11.4 million Mission-On website.

Now let’s look at the performance. Sparc kindly provided me with some statistics on traffic for Mission-On, which was built on contract by a private company called Click Suite. It generated 39,132 unique browser sessions in June and has registered 15,000 kids in the four months since it launched. Sparc is targeting 30,000 by June next year. Sparc pointed out that Click Suite had told them this compared quite well with www.cleo.co.nz, www.247girl.co.nz, C4TV.co.nz and Kidspot.co.nz.

At this point I will mention that the official Neilsen Net Ratings for this blog in a month (and Neilsen are very conservative with their stats) are around four times their 39,132. In fact I get more than that in a week. And alas no $11 million of taxpayer funding.

I registered for the website as myself and tried to play a few games to get a feel for it. It’s the worst kind of patronising tosh I have seen in a long time. “It’s choice,” the website says of itself. It has one game called a “Creative Hip Hop Challenge”. One thing I do know about successful websites is they have to be driven by the users and not appear out of touch or preachy or just plain dumb. This is all three.

Ouch.

It’s also all built in Adobe (formerly Macromedia’s) Flash. Anyone trying to build a website that is picked up by Google and the other bots so people can find it knows that Flash is the dumbest way to do that. Adobe is only now giving Flash the ability to attract search engines. Flash is fantastic for making good-looking websites that make their owners look good in the eyes of their bosses. But they are websites that aren’t either popular or profitable. Flash sites are typically built by advertising, marketing or design agencies (like Clicksuite), who make advertisement or brochure sites.

But that is okay – the taxpayer will then be asked to spend money promoting the site.

So I asked my 14-year-old daughter what she thought of it. She had seen an ad for it on the side of a bus, but hadn’t visited. I asked her to check it out. She did what everyone does now. She typed the words “Mission On” into Google to find it. It came up at number 8 in the natural search rankings. Any web professional knows this is a disaster. I suspect it ranks so poorly because it is made in Flash and its search optimisation is woeful. It is also poorly ranked because few other sites have to linked to it, which is an ominous sign. My daughter eventually found it.

We are in fact already paying for adverts for it.

“Oh My God,” she yelped. “It’s all in Flash. I just never use Flash sites. You can’t navigate them, they’re usually just so crap. My browser is set to block these yucky pop-ups. No. No. No,” she said before shooing me out the door. I’m a very lucky father to have a daughter who knows so much more about web usability than I do.

Heh.

PS. One tip for Sparc. It needs to buy the Google ad word for MissionOn to create a sponsored link. It costs about 25 cents per click. Well worth the money. So good in fact that I’ve bought the MissionOn adword for Google and will link to this story once it’s published.

Now that is just evil. Very very evil. I love it.

Televised Sports events

Not content with nationalising the planes and the trains, jim Anderton has a new target – sporting events. Yes he thinks these should be confiscated off sporting codes (with compensation) and made the property of the state to broadcast on free to air TV.

Frog Blog has a thread on this, and I’m pleased to say even over there the vast majority see this as a step too far.

My favourite quote is from Toad:

With essential services I’m not a great fan of user pays (because some users can’t afford to pay) but I don’t rate television sport in that category, so tend to agree with you on this one BB. I’m quite happy to fork out my Sky sub each month so I can watch live sport.

I don’t expect to get into the ground for free to see the match, so why should I expect to see it free on television?

Indeed the next logical step would be for the state to hand out free tickets to sports events on the grounds of fairness.

42 days detention

Readers will be aware of the UK Labour Government narrowly winning a vote in the House of Commons to allow authorities to hold someone for 42 days without charges being laid.

It will now go to the House of Lords for a vote, and as WIll de Cleene points out a new Lord has oppossed the law in her maiden speech:

“I have weighed up the balance between the right to life – the most important civil liberty – the fact that there is no such thing as complete security, and the importance of our hard-won civil liberties. Therefore, on a matter of principle, I cannot support 42 days’ pre-charge detention. I do understand different views and that there are judgements honestly reached by others, and I respect these views.”

So who is the soft on law and order Lord? Her name is Baroness Eliza Manningham-Buller.

Oh yes – should also mention her former job. It was Director-General of MI5.

Dr Rodney Harrison on the Electoral Finance Act

I’ve been given a copy of a paper which Dr Rodney Harrison delivered yesterday to the University of Waikato Law School. It is a weighty 6,500 words and its subject is the Electoral Finance Act with the title:

Political Free Speech in New Zealand: Dangerous Beast or Endangered Species

Now before I quote from the paper, let me give some background on Dr Harrison. I do this because supporters of the Electoral Finance Act often try to shoot or smear the messenger with ridicolous allegations such as a client of a law firm once made a donation to National etc etc.

Dr Harrison has a PhD in Law and has been a QC since 1994. He is regarded as one of the leading public law specialists in New Zealand. The cases he has been involved in are extensive. His clients have included the Springbok Tour clowns, the Auckland Council for Civil Liberties, the Auckland Unemployed Workers’ Rights Centre, Aziz Choudry, the NZ Amalgamated Engineering Union, the Refugee Council of NZ, and Ahmed Zaoui. Again I give this so not even The Standard can dismiss him as a righwing Tory lawyer as they usually do with lawyers who write things they disagree with.

His full paper can be downloaded here:political-freedom-of-expression-and-electoral-finance-act-2007. It is a 20 page word document.

Dr Harrison does an excellent job of canvassing the arguments for and against the Electoral Finance Act in terms of the Bill of Rights. I would butcher them if I tried to summarise them here, so I merely suggest people read the paper for themselves. However I will quote his conclusion:

The restrictions imposed by the EFA on political free speech coming within the Act’s definition of “election advertisement” are inconsistent with section 14 read with section 12 of the Bill of Rights, by a considerable margin. The financial limits on expenditure which the legislation imposes, considered in the context of the greatly increased duration (in practice) of the “regulated period”, significantly restrict rather than promote participation by the public in Parliamentary democracy. By the same token, much less restrictive measures, for example much higher expenditure limits and a focus on identification of and disclosure and reporting requirements for those who would use the mass media for their political advertising, would be a sufficient and proportionate means to the ends in question.

Furthermore, the extension of the definition of “election advertisement” beyond publications urging “vote/don’t vote for me/him/her/us/them”, to capture expressions of special interest advocacy in relation to actual or even potential campaign issues, must be seen as an unnecessary and disproportionate response in and of itself. When that is coupled with the vagueness of the EFA’s central definition and the issue of disincentivising compliance costs and reporting requirements, the unjustifiable nature of the restrictions imposed on by the EFA on both members of the public and political parties and candidates is placed beyond doubt.

In short, as indeed our ongoing experience this year has demonstrated, the EFA as drafted lacks a sense of proportion. Indeed, it seriously lacks a sense of humour – although plainly, someone out there has one. Those who voted it into law did so in the face of powerful appeals to reason from a wide range of bodies and individuals, including the Human Rights Commission, the New Zealand Law Society and the Electoral Commission itself. These appeals were met by a prediction, on the part of our (lay) Minister of Justice, that “the law of common sense will apply”. Unfortunately for democracy in this country, when applied to misconceived and badly drafted legislation, judicial or indeed any other form of “common sense” can only take us so far.

So far this year, the EFA has given rise to three applications for judicial review. The vagueness and unworkability of the EFA’s provisions means that we probably have not seen the last of the litigation. The ability to rely on corrupt and illegal practices created by the EFA in support of an election petition could well give rise to a further rash of litigation after polling day. The last election’s “Winston v Bob the Builder” election petition alleging candidate overspending could well be replicated under the EFA, many times over. The EFA, purportedly enacted to “maintain public and political confidence in the administration of elections”, is, judging by experience to date, well on track to have entirely the opposite effect.

Not much one needs to add to that.

Invade New Zealand website

Police Officer killed

The Dom Post reports a Police Officer has been killed in Porirua after being hit by the driver of a stolen car.

The NZ Police Force is a relatively small force and this death will touch every serving police officer. Luckily deaths in the line of duty are rare – but every one which occurs is one too many.

Editorials on Veitch

By coincidence the three major dailies have all done their editorials today on Tony Veitch.

Before I summarise them, I’ll give my 2c. I don’t think the two broadcasters are the decision makers here. I think the decision will be made for them by their staff and public. When even Matthew Ridge is saying he may not want to appear on TV with him, you have a problem. How many female TVNZ employees would be willing to help produce shows for Veitch? How many sporting stars will want to appear on a show with him joking about? Regardless of what is fair, a return to television anyway is impossible for some time. The public won’t want to watch, and their own staff won’t want to produce.

Anyway we’ll start with the Dom Post which takes the hardest line:TVNZ has only one option over sports broadcaster and woman-beater Tony Veitch. It must terminate his contract and say he will never work for the state broadcaster again, writes The Dominion Post.

No beating around the bush there.

Quite apart from TVNZ’s hypocrisy in employing him while airing advertisements that say it is not okay, ever, to beat up a partner or family member, having Veitch in living rooms nightly and fronting its Olympics team is unacceptable. His TVNZ career should be over.

Questions of what TVNZ knew may become the bigger issue if it emerges they did know in advance.

The Press looks at the victim:

The Tony Veitch case is a tragedy not for Veitch but for the woman he assaulted, writes The Press in an editorial.

She suffered severe physical injuries from his attack and had her career disrupted; her mental anguish must have been intense. He has maintained his lucrative work and still holds his positions with Television New Zealand and The Radio Network.

One can only have sympathy for her – not only having to cope with the trauma of the assault at the time – but now having to cope with most of NZ discussing it.

There are those who will remain loyal to Veitch that is the nature of friendship but the public should not. The severity of the assault and his attempt to close the case and protect his career by way of a $100,000 cheque are brazen. The loss of public acceptance will surely be too much for the broadcasters to ignore. …

TVNZ presents itself as the expression of New Zealand values, and campaigns against violence towards women. Veitch now represents the opposite. His continued fronting of sports programmes which includes being anchorman of the Olympics broadcasts would be a disaster for the channel’s reputation.

I think there is no question he is off the air until after the Olympics. The question is when or if he will return after that?

The Herald takes a different tack, saying leave it to the Police:

Little good would be served if two broadcasting companies permanently remove the sports presenter Tony Veitch from their programmes to try to bring an end to controversy over his assault on a woman. …

A premature move to dismiss him, though, would be seen as being for one reason only: to help the broadcasting companies’ images, not the welfare of the victim or their audiences. It could never represent the closure they might seek and should not in any case be the last word when the police have begun inquiring into what could yet be a case of causing grievous bodily harm.

I disagree somewhat. The criminal issues are different to the employment issues.

If sacking him now is the answer then someone is asking the wrong question. Veitch’s case needs resolution by an authority far higher than the employer. His former partner reportedly suffered breaks to her back from being kicked on the ground, was temporarily confined to a wheelchair and off work for a considerable period. Veitch has admitted “breaking” and “lashing out” on the night of the incident. Rightly, the police have now appointed an officer to review the matter and consider his admissions. They should make every effort to interview the victim – who this year was party to a confidentiality agreement involving payment to her by Veitch of as much as $170,000 – to reassess her decision not to report the matter to the police when it occurred two years ago.

They make the point that as the publicity has now happened anyway, the rationale for not reporting it has lessened.

Dissenting Views

Stuff has an NZPA story on the abolition of the SFO. Not surprisingly the former Director is very criticial of the move, and disagrees with it.

The worrying aspect for me isn’t that the Government took a different view to officials, but that they went out of their way to shut down dissenting views internally. The part that concerns me most is:

Ministers would not see him and a final Cabinet paper on this issue did not mention any of the SFO’s concerns, despite his requests for them to be included.

It is normal for dissenting opinions to be included in Cabinet papers.

Again I stress there is nothing wrong with Ministers not following the advice of officials. That is why we have Ministers – to decide.

But when Ministers will refuse to meet an agency CEO to discuss something as fundamental as the future of that agency? That is pigheadedness and arrogance.

And when the Cabinet paper doesn’t canvass all the pros and cons of an issues, but pretends there no no dissenting opinions – that is a very bad thing. When the agency being abolished specifically requests its views to be included – and this is denied – that is even worse.

Ministers can and should disagree with officials. But when Ministers tell officials to only include views they want to hear – then you have a significant politicisation of the public service.

Emissions Trading Scheme Poll

Exceltium have released a poll on the Emissions Trading Scheme they commissioned from Digipoll.

It is very detailed, running to 14 pages of results and the full data is over on Curiablog. There is a mass of data there for politicians and policy makers. I thought I would comment on some of the results:

Support for ETS Legislation – 34% in favour, 24% against

A plurality in favour of the legislation, but with 41% neutral it is not a heart and minds issue for most NZers.

View on climate change – 20% say world’s most important issue, 45% say an important issue, 15% say not a major issue and 16% say it is natural not manmade.

That’s a fairly big chunk in what I call the moderate middle position – it is important but not the most important issue. A significant number at 31% saying it is not a major issue at all.

Preferred policy response – 10% say NZ should be the world leader, 49% say NZ should be one of the world’s leaders and 29% say a fast follower, plus 8% say do nothing.

Again the moderate middle position is well supported.

Willingness to pay – 43% would be willing to pay an extra $10 a week in energy costs, 16% willing to pay $20 a week, 5% willing to pay $40 a week and 1% willing to pay $100 a week.

$10 a week seems to be the limit for the vast majority in terms of paying extra.

Integration with Australia – 62% say wait a month to see Australian scheme, 34% say proceed now with legislation.

Seems a no brainer to me.

Wait for other countries – 40% agree the legislation should only be passed as other countries pass such legislation to prevent job losses offshore, while 31% disagree.

This gets a bit murky as the key issue is what countries do you wait for? US? China? India? Or just Australia?

Will the ETS be effective – 34% agree that the ETS as written will not cut carbon emissions enough to make a difference while 27% disagree.

This shoud give the Greens food for thought – only 27% are saying they think the current scheme will cut emissions enough.

Non Labour Voters – If the Government passes the scheme ahead of the Australian one it will make 7% of non Labour voters more likely to vote Labour and 13% less likely.

A net 6% less likely. And if they do wait to see details of the Australian scheme the numbers reverse with 13% more likely to vote Labour and 6% less likely.

NZ First potential voters – 19% say best option is to pass the ETS before the Australians, 62% say encourage Helen Clark to begin multi-party talks after she talks to the Australian PM and 13% say don’t support ETS at all.

I predict Winston will back it regardless in exchange for a big lump of cash for the election campaign.

Potential Green supporters – are asked even if scheme is not made tougher, and Greens vote for it, how will that affect support – and 23% say more likely to support Greens and only 8% less likely.

Based on that the Greens can vote for it,even if they get no improvements.

If they do hold out though, they also do not get punished with 16% saying they are more likely to vote Green and only 14% less likely if the ETS doesn’t pass because the Greens refuse to support it unless made tougher.

Maori Party angry at Labour

TV3 reported tonight how angry the Maori Party was at Labour, for their role in publicising the allegations against Derek Fox. It seems a staffer for Shane Jones was circulating copies of the article in Truth to journalists before it was even published. That strongly suggests they were working with the newspaper to get the story out there.

Labour are desperate to have Parekura Horomia retain his seat, but they may win the battle but lose the war. Tariana Turia was making it pretty clear that they would find it very hard to work with Labour after the election, because of this. To quote TV3:

Maori Party co-leader Tariana Turia says Labour has all but blown its chances of a coalition deal at the next election.

So with NZ First and United Future saying they will give first preference to the biggest party, and not even the Greens yet willing to commit to Labour that means their only friend right now is the Jim Anderton Party.

The good old Captain Cook

Oh what memories this story in the ODT brings back of the Captain Cook and life in Dunedin.

The twice-yearly Cook-a-thon at the Captain Cook Tavern in Dunedin was a colourful and fun affair yesterday, marred by 10 arrests for mostly disorderly behaviour offences later in the afternoon.

More than 1000 students dressed in outfits from power rangers, male fairies, a policeman in speedos to Oompa Loompa’s to celebrate the start of the University of Otago second semester.

Hundreds queued for the 10am Cook-a-thon start, with about 500 in the tavern by noon, paying $25 for a T-shirt, jug of beer and three meals during the day.

Those not wanting to queue set up parties in Clyde and Castle Sts.

I was interviewed by the lovely folks from Road Trip Nation in Wellington yesterday, and by coincidence quite a bit of the conversation was about my university years and life at Otago. It really is a unique experience. I can never work out why people study anywhere else 🙂

Labour’s new pledge card

The Electoral Finance Act threesome

Three articles on the Electoral Finance Act to cover today.

First we have Tuesday’s story about politically loaded questions in surveys may become an expense:

However, Electoral Commission head Helena Catt said anyone who tried to use push-polling or politically loaded survey questions thinking it was exempt from inclusion in the election spending limits could get caught out.

She said the limits of the provision were still untested, despite a similar clause existing under the previous law.

“The exception is for opinion polls and surveys, so it depends how one defines those. We would have to decide what a poll or survey is under that provision, for example whether it covers push-polling or only includes polling by polling companies, and whether there is an ethical dimension to it.”

One can’t disagree with anything there. However there are some interesting issues around the Privacy Act and the Electoral Finance Act in play. Take for example phone surveys where parties call people up and ask their views on some issues. This is research which is exempted under the EFA (and the old Act also).  The reason the parties do it is that they may use the data for a future communication (which will count as spending).

Now if you are going to be recording down personal data about someone (ie their response to a survey), you need to identify who you are calling on behalf of under the Privacy Act. So a party member calling might say “I am calling on behalf of xxxx, the local yyyy party candidate”. That way people know who they are speaking to, and can decide whether to respond or not.

But electoral authorities are worried that by saying the name of the candidate, even if just for purposes of identification, you might then be an advertisement.  So again it is all murky.

The High Court has indicated there are limitations – in its judgment on Winston Peters’ legal challenge of Bob Clarkson’s election spending after 2005, the Tauranga High Court observed push-polling was not covered by the exemption.

The court said the exemption for polls “reflects the facts that polls by definition do not seek to persuade, but rather to ascertain public opinion”.

This is quite correct – the research must be to ascertain not persaude.

Adding survey questions to material which was otherwise an election advertisement would also not make the entire brochure exempt from the spending cap.

The Electoral Commission is considering a NZ First advertisement which includes a survey, but the party claimed it is not an election advertisement.

The advertisement, which does not have an authorising statement, includes surveys on the China free trade agreement, and any sale of Auckland International Airport or the dairy industry.

Leader Winston Peters has argued it was not an election advertisement because it did not refer to its stance on policies of a future Parliament.

I think this is a perfect example of something that is not a genune survey. The NZ First advertisements were clearly designed to persuade but to ascertain opinion. It will be very interesting to see what the outcome on these will be.

Law Lecturer Dean Knight was on National Radio yesterday talking about the EFA and the Bill of Rights Act. He blogs about it here.

One part I will quote:

Now, it must be remembered that, at that stage, when the Bill was assessed and proceedings were filed, we were talking about the First Reading of the EFB – the more egregious version. Very few commentators and scholars thought the initial value judgement was particularly robust.

However, many of the restrictions were watered down by the Select Committee and the Mark II version of the Electoral Finance Act that was actually passed did not limit the freedom of expression to the same extent. Arguably, questions of consistency with the Bill of Rights were in the zone where reasonable people could differ.

I think Dean is being very nice when he says few people thought the initial value judgement was robust. This is referring to the Crown Law advice that the original Electoral Finance Bill did not breach the Bill of Rights. It still staggers me how a bill which would have forced NZers to file statutory declarations just to express their view on a political issue could be judged not to shatter the Bill of Rights. Rather than sack the person at Crown Law who write such a flawed opinion, the Government promoted her to the Law Commission.

Dean is right when he says reasonable people can differ on whether the final version of the EFA is consistent with the Bill of Rights. By implication this suggests that no reasonable person could have argued that the original Bill was consistent. Yet that is exactly what Crown Law did.

Finally we turn to an article on Newswrire about a possible EFA breach by National MP Katrina Shanks.

A local website is The Flying Pickle. It is a local community site for the suburbs of Korokoro, Maungaraki and Normandale. Any local resident can post stories there so Katrina had been putting articles on there attacking Labour. They were under her name, but unless the website is a newsmedia site or a blog, then they may count as election expenses and need an authorisation statement by her financial agent.

All very stupid. We should encourage MPs using local sites and the transparency requirement is met by posting under her name.

I am increasingly of the view that after the election the replacement for the Electoral Finance Act will need to have a fairly conservative definition of advertising so that it doesn’t regulate every form of advocacy. I also think the transparency requirements need to be totally revised as it is ridicolous that an MP needs an outside party to be authorising their parliamentary statements.

This is what Linda Clark was talking about in her Listener article – the EFA is makng it hard for MPs and candidates to communicate with the public at they very time we want communication.

Why Australia should invade New Zealand

Tui strikes again

Chewbacca and Sunday

Stuff reports:

Coldplay frontman Chris Martin supports Nicole Kidman’s choice to call her daughter Sunday and believes “Chewbacca” would be an OK name too.

Sunday is an okay name, but if your parents named you Chewbacca I would say that no jury in the land would convict you of murder if you killed them in their sleep one night.

Unfortunate Wording