Is it Labour is unpopular or National being popular?

Interesting discussion on Nine to Noon yesterday in the politics segment. Matthew Hooton challenged the conventional wisdom that Labour is so far behind just because it is time for a change.

Hooton made the point that in 1990 and 1999 the Opposition Leader polled behind the Prime Minister in the Preferred PM polls prior to the election campaign. He asserted that this was a classic case of people just wanting a change and not being particularly excited over the alternative.

He contrasts this with 2008 when John Key is currently polling ahead of Helen Clark in every public poll as Preferred PM, hence this is not just a rejection of a third term Government, but a sign of genuine good will and warmth towards the National Party Leader.

Hooton certainly is correct that no Opposition Leader has ever polled as strongly as John Key has in the Preferred PM poll.

Otago Uni on i-tunes

Now this is a great example of academic innovation.

Otago University has joined forces with i Tunes to place some of their content on i Tunes U.

What a great way to make it easy for students to be able to listen to audio material and/or view videos. I’ve just downloaded their Life at Otago video.

No Field trial before the election

The Government will be incredibly pleased. There will be no trial of former Labour Cabinet Minister Taito Phillip Field until 2009.

This means that Labour won’t have to face the possibility of Ministers testifying about what they knew, and when they knew it before the election.

However we can still remind people of how both Helen and Michael defended Field as being guilty of nothing more than trying to help his constituents.

Working with David: Inside the Lange Cabinet

Michael Bassett has finished his long awaited book “Working with David: Inside the Lange Cabinet”. I’ve been anticipating this for around 20 years since I read that Bassett took detailed notes during both caucus and cabinet meetings (technically a no no but people knew he would not publish them until appropriate time had passed).

The Wellington Regional Chamber of Commerce has a Momentum Breakfast with Dr Bassett next Tuesday.

It is at 7.15 am on Level 28 of the Majestic Centre. Tickets are $40 for members and $60 for non members (thanks to WRCC for a complementary one for myself).

From former Cabinet Minister Michael Bassett, Working with David is an in-depth insight into the Lange government of 1984-1990. This was a key time in New Zealand history for both international politics (ANZUS, Mururoa tests, Oxford Union debate) and domestic economics (Roger Douglas’s reforms) of which the real story has never been told until now. Written by Lange’s cousin, and senior Cabinet Minister in that Government, Michael Bassett, here is the “inside the Cabinet room” view of some of the most heady and turbulent times in recent history.

One can book online at the link provided. The 4th Labour Government did so many amazingly inspired things, but also stuffed some things up in a big way. I can’t wait to get a copy of the book and hear Dr Bassett on the day.

All hail the NAG

Children of NZ rejoice. The Government has today made your lives better with its new school tuck shop regulations hilariously called the National Administration Guidelines.

The NAG do not ban unapproved foods, they are still allowed to be sold once a term. So no doubt we will have roving squads of food inspectors making sure that unapproved foods are not sold more than three times a year.

Once the tuck shops have been NAGGED into line, then school libraries will be audited to make sure that only healthy approved books are being made available for lending. Unapproved books which are being borrowed too regularly will be burnt!

The fix is in

Mike Ward has succumbed to the pressure and has agreed to refuse his place in Parliament so Russel Norman can use taxpayer funded resources to campaign.

I blogged a couple of weeks ago that the Greens were trying to do two things – both of which work sit badly with me. The first is having MPs resign before for their term in Parliament is up, purely for tactical partisan reasons. You rejuvenate a party at elections, not between them.

The second is changing the order of the list post election. The Greens put a lot of stress on the fact their members rank the list, yet they have ignored the will of their members who ranked the 2005 party list – the only one which the public have had a chance to vote on with their party vote.

There is no way one can stop an MP resigning early, but one could have a simple law change to remove the ability for a list candidate to refuse to become an MP. They could still be elected and then resign, but that extra step might stop them from doing private deals to change the effective order of a list post-election.

Pressure on National re Courts Bill

The NZ Herald reports that National has offered Labour negotiations on how to progress the stalled Criminal Procedures Bill.

An interesting positioning in which you have the Sensible Sentencing Trust attacking National for opposing the scrapping of most deposition hearings, while National is being defended by lawyers from the Criminal Bar Association.

There was a good debate on the blog yesterday regarding the pros and cons of deposition hearings – including some useful contributions from lawyers at the coal face.

UN Sec Gen calls for end to food tariffs and biofuel subsidies

Some common sense and plain speaking from UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon who has called for an end to food tariffs and to subsidies for biofuels as the key way to bring down the price of food and stop millions from starvation.

Sadly this advice will be ignored by the Greens and NZ First who both support protectionist policies such as tariffs.

Also interesting debate on how much biofuels are to blame:

Hunger campaigners single out biofuels – often made by converting food crops into fuel – as a prime culprit for the crisis.

Biofuel supporters say the effect on food prices of diverting crops into ethanol production is small.

US Agriculture Secretary Ed Shafer said before the summit began that biofuels accounted for about 3 per cent of the total food price rise.

But the Oxfam aid organisation says the real effect is about 30 per cent.

It is sort of ironic that us free traders are on the side of the UN and Oxfam while the Greens seem to be in the same camp as the US – supporting tariffs and biofuels.

Broadcasting Allocations

The Electoral Commission has made its broadcasting allocations. I blogged on these a few weeks ago. These are called interim allocations as if a small party fails to register, then their allocation is reallocated. This has a minor effect at best.

As expected National and Labour got the same amount – $1,000,000 each. Last time Labour got $1.1 and National $0.9.

Tier 2 sees the Greens, Maori Party and NZ First all get $240,000 each. I think that is somewhat unfair on the Greens who clearly have polled well above the other two parties.

Tier 3 are the three other parliamentary parties of ACT, Progressive and United Future who get $100,000 each,

Tier 4 has 11 non parliamentary parties getting $10,000 of broadcast time $7,000 of production costs for their one minute opening addresses.

The Libertarianz are getting the production costs only, as they said they would not spend any money allocated to them.

So how much extra or less does each parliamentary party get compared to 2005’s initial allocation?

  1. National from $900,000 to $1,000,000 = +$100,000
  2. Labour from $1,100,000 to $1,000,000 = -$100,000
  3. Maori Party from $125,000 to $240,000 = +$115,000
  4. ACT from $200,000 to $100,000 = -$100,000
  5. NZ First from $200,000 to $240,000 = +$40,000
  6. United Future from $200,000 to $100,000 = -$100,000
  7. Greens from $200,000 to $240,000 = +$40,000
  8. Progressive from $75,000 to $100,000 = +$25,000

Most of the changes can be explained away by a party having done better or worse in the last election than in 2002, or registering higher or lower in the polls. But there are two exceptions. Let’s look at each in turn:

  1. National – doubled vote in 2005 and currently high in polls so increase makes sense
  2. Labour – 2005 vote much the same as 2002 but down in the polls so decrease makes sense
  3. Maori Party – had no MPs before 2005 so the increase makes sense as they have won four seats now.
  4. ACT – lost MPs in 2005, so the decrease makes sense
  5. NZ First – went from 13 MPs in 2002 to seven MPs in 2005 and have dropped to under 3% in the polls, so the increase does not make sense. NZ First have been very lucky.
  6. United Future – lost MPs in 2005, so the decrease makes sense
  7. Greens – lost one or two MPs in 2005, but have been up in the polls so the small gain makes sense.
  8. Progressive – went from two to one MP and are at 0% in most polls – so the increase does not make sense

So NZ First and the Progressives have got extra money despite doing far worse in the last election and in subsequent polls. So they will be very happy with the result, while Greens will be fairly unhappy.

Barrier Beaches

This is Kaitoke Beach – was two minutes from the bungalow, and as you can see almost deserted. The whole island has beaches like this.

This is one of the spots we went fishing. It is Whangaparapara Harbour on the west of the island.

And this is Tryphena Harbour in the south. Tryphena is the only place where you can get voice and data cellphone coverage – and only for around 100 metres or so!

This is the north end of Medlands Beach on the East. Quite popular in summer I am told.


Silly hysteria

A Wellington community constable is making taggers wear a pink best labelled “tagger” while they cover up their tags.

Green City Councillor Iona Pannett has compared the practice to Nazi Germany forcing homosexuals to wear pink triangles in concentration camps,

Iona should know better the difference between someone who chooses to break the law (a tagger) and someone who has no choice about their sexual orientation.

She also should know the difference between half an hour of embarrassment for a tagger (which presumably is in lieu of getting a criminal record) and genocide. Comparing the two is repugnant and offensive.

Transport to Barrier

I’ll have a few posts and photos of the long weekend on Great Barrier Island. It was wonderful to get away, and I loved not having phone and e-mail. The weather was hot and sunny all four days – unbelievable good luck considering we are officially in Winter now.

One can take boat or plane to GBI. The boat takes over four hours so it was easy to choose the 30 minute flight. The aircraft are tiny – no middle aisle – everyone gets in through a side entrance.

The flight over was great as you travel so much lower down than normal – got great views of Auckland, and as we went over GBI itself, I swear we were just 10 – 20 metres above the bush.

We landed at Claris, in the centre of GBI. Rental car was waiting for us – a minor problem being it was a manual and I last drove a manual oh around 15 years ago. Luckily the co-driver was not so limited, so I got relegated to the passenger seat.

This is the main road to Port Fitzroy in the North. The main roads are sealed in the South, but are gravel in most places.

This is the bungalow we stayed at. It is solar powered and was great – two minutes from Kaitoke Beach and a fireplace for heating. Would recommend it for anyone else wanting a nice place to stay.

They had a nice special – $500 each for return flights, three nights accommodation and the rental car for three days.

Blaming the Board

Helen Clark is blaming the Housing NZ Board for their luxury conference venues. To quote NZPA:

Ministers knew nothing about Housing New Zealand’s “unbelievable” staff conferences in luxury resorts, Prime Minister Helen Clark said today. …

“These things never came to the attention of ministers,” she said on NewstalkZB.

“They didn’t know. This is a corporation which has an independent board, it has a chief executive who reports to that board.” …

Asked what she thought about the conferences, Miss Clark replied: “Unbelievable. My views are very clear on this … I do not expect them to be accommodating themselves in anything remotely like luxury accommodation.

“Frankly, I don’t know what they thought they were doing.”

So it is nothing to do with Helen, or with Maryan Street her Minister of Housing. It is all the fault of that nasty Housing NZ Board.

What a pity though that Helen’s Government appoints the Housing NZ Board. And who did they appoint to the Housing NZ Board, up until 2005?

Well none other than Maryan Street!

Oh dear.

Let us enjoy how they distance themselves from that one. My prediction is she was “confused” or was never briefed.

Keith Ng on Greens compost

Keith Ng focuses his fact checker on the Greens claims about the cost of milk increasing 60% and that it is all Fonterra”s fault and the greedy supermarkets. Some key points Keith makes:

  • Milk has only increased 28% in the last year, and is only 2% higher than two years ago, 3% higher than three years ago and only 8% higher than four years ago. In other words the cost of milk dipped last year and is now at much the same level as it has been for the last four years.
  • Dairy products make up only 1.2% of household expenditure or $11.60 a week. Capping Fonterra’s prices would save less than $2 a week per household.

Keith then looks at their call for farmers to move away from areas where we export, into areas where we import so we are self sufficient. Keith sums this up as:

Which, I assume, means that she wants New Zealand farming to diversify — away from the areas where it’s strongest, and into areas where it’s not.

He does a nice analogy:

To cutting down dairy production in favour of wheat etc. is like pouring water down the drain so you have empty vessels to catch rain with.

His summary:

This goes far, far beyond disappointing. Not only has the Greens managed to be wrong and stupid, but they’ve also managed to marry pre-Rod Donald naivety with Winston-like populism.

Did he really compare them to Winston?

It’s the kind of stunt that Winston pulls — making outrageous claims, safe in the knowledge that there will be no repercussions because it’s too ridiculous to be taken seriously.

Oh yes he did.

But even while trying to be populist, they still manage to look like the boogeyman from the ideological fringes.

Indeed.

They are right that Labour has been all talk about climate change, and that National won’t be any better. The only place where leadership on climate change can come from is the Greens. But they need to accept the simple fact that most of the people who support action on climate change are not out to destroy capitalism or globalisation.

This is not about cynical political rebranding, it’s about building a real consensus. The Greens can’t earn the trust of a broader voter base until you give up the radical part of themselves. Every time you push a radical left agenda, you’re pushing supporters of climate change action further away.

I like the implicit assertion that many in the Greens are out to destroy capitalism and globalisation.
Sadly, Keith is correct.

As I said yesterday, there are environmental areas where the Greens could have a positive influence on a National Government. But their “social justice” wing which does want to destroy capitalism is a big turn off for many.

More fun from the Chaser

Oh I do like the Australian Chaser programme. Last week’s episode had them try and recruit for Al Qaeda, as the Mormons do – door to door knocking with suits and big badges. Hilarious as they try and preach the virtues of fundamentalist Islam.

Also fun was going through the parliamentary metal detector in a suit of armour.

The fascists unite

A reader sends this in:

You may remember a couple of years ago Kyle Chapman resigned his leadership of the National Front – at the time the most successful fascist-right party operating in NZ. Chapman had led the NF to new heights in terms of media coverage and membership, possibly coming close to the 500 required to register. The NF fell apart, and the remains into lethargy following his resignation.

Kyle hit a few headlines in Christchurch last year when he made a spectacularly failed attempt at the Mayoralty, even gaining last place in his run for Community Board. He was running as part of a new party – the National Democrats, led by a fellow former NF cohort – Anton Foljambe. Both Chapman and Foljambe had stood as part of the Direct Democracy Party in 2005, but left soon after.

Now here is the interesting bit. Despite Chapman’s resignation from NF on the basis of concern for his kids’ safety (widely thought to be a lie), he has again jumped right back into the fold. Three fascist parties – the National Democrats, the New Right, and the National Front have formed an alliance to contest the 2008 election. This party is to be known as the Nationalist Alliance and will be led by none other than Kyle Chapman.

I do hope they stand a candidate in Wellington Central – it would make the Aro Valley meeting even more enjoyable than normal! There isn’t a law against setting candidates alight is there?

They do have of course the right to organise and seek election. And we have the right to mock and ridicule them.

Greens enjoying their law of common sense

The Herald yesterday reported on how easy and clear the Greens were finding the Electoral Finance Act – the law they forced on New Zealand.

The Green Party is going to extraordinary lengths to ensure it does not break new election advertising rules – including encouraging the owners of old Green Party T-shirts to get iron-on transfers with a campaign authorisation statement.

Of course they have already broken the law by using home addresses earlier in the year, and got the benefit of the doubt for their late donations return.

She said there was a need for extra caution because the controversy over the new law had put its critics on full alert for any breaches.

Who us? 🙂

Ms Turei said much of the trouble arose because the law change broke the former consensus between parties as to what was covered by electoral advertising law.

“The mistake was that this law was passed so close to an election year. There has been no time to develop a political consensus about what is and is not acceptable.”

So why did you support it? Metira makes it sound like the mistakes were someone else’s. Why did the Greens not say they would not support a law which had not been through a public policy process? Why did they not say they won’t vote for a law which was passed so close to the election year? Why did the Greens not say anything about the fact it was a naked attempt by Labour to screw over and silence their political opponents and destroyed the constitutional conventions around the Electoral Act?

Talking of the Electoral Finance Act, the NZPA database now has a massive 510 articles in it that mention the EFA. So that is an average of 100 articles a month – and 99% of them basically negative. I doubt a law has ever been so discredited.

A new level of disclosure

Disclosure of possible conflicts of interest is highly commendable, and one should tend towards more rather than less disclosure.

However ODT Political Editor Dene Mackenzie may be taking it a step too far in this story about ACT and Rodney Hide:

Dene Mackenzie is political editor of the Otago Daily Times.

He attended Rangiora Primary School at the same time as Mr Hide but they were three years apart.

I would like to disclose that a NZ Herald journalist was a teacher at Island Bay Primary School, where I attended from ages 5 to 10.

Wellington City regulating retailers

The Dominion Post editorial is sceptical of the City Council’s move to ban large retail outlets, in an attempt to protect the CBD shopping.

I discussed this issue on radio a few weeks ago with Cr John Morrison (who was reasonably ambivalent towards the policy) and commented that I had spent years wondering why there were no large shopping malls in Wellington, and I was forced to go out to North City Plaza to shop at a large mall. The answer it seems, is because the Council bans them in Wellington City.

Now I love the compact inner city we have, and mainly shop there. I love its vibrancy. But I am very sceptical that the Council should be deciding for residents where they shop.

If a commercial operator can make a sucess of a large mall in Johnsonville or Karori or Kilbirnie, then good on them. Yes competition can change things, but where would we be if decades ago Councils banned supermarkets to protect corner diaries?

Plus I believe the CBD retail “golden mile” will thrive regardless of competition. More and more people live in or near the CBD. It has easy public transport in. And having competition from a large mall in the suburbs can result in a better “golden mile” as they have to look at incentives for people to shop there.

Well done Wira

I was very pleased to see Wira Gardiner gain a DCNZM (equal to the old KBE or KNZM) in the QB Honours.

When talking about the issues of the bureaucracy in totality, it can be easy to overlook the immense contribution some civil servants make to New Zealand. They tend to only get publicity when things go wrong.

Wira has contributed significantly to both the public and private sectors over the years, and almost inevitably is the trouble shooter sent in by the Government of the day (Labour and National) when a dysfunctional Maori agency needs a correcting hand.

Depositions Hearings

The Government’s Criminal Procedure Bill would allow a Judge to decide whether or not there is evidence for a case to go to trial, based solely on written evidence – unless the Judge specifically calls for a depositions hearing.

National and the Law Society are opposed to this. I think it is actually a very laudable idea and worth supporting.

First of all, how often does a case not go to trial because of lack of proof at a depositions hearing? Almost never. Take for example the Sophie Elliott case – the accused was witnessed stabbing her, and was alone in the room with her. There was never ever even a 0.1% chance the case would not go to trial.

I am very mindful of the impact on victims having to sit through both a depositions hearing and a full trial.

The argument against getting rid of depositions hearings (and I welcome lawyers especially to comment) seems to be that they often lead to the accused them pleading guilty and/or doing a plea deal. I’m not convinced these might not happen anyway as there will still be depositions – just written instead of oral.

I’m also comforted by the fact the Judge could have discretion to call for oral depositions if the case was “borderline”. But it appears to me 95% of the cases are not borderline, will clearly go to trial and spending days in court just traumatises the family further, costs money, takes up scarce court time and does little to advance rather than delay justice.

The Law Society submission on the Bill is here. Page 40 has the arguments on this issue. They seem to be against almost every suggested change, and my suspicion is that the defence lawyers wrote the submission 🙂

So I’m puzzled by National’s opposition to the Criminal Procedure Bill. National positions itself as pro-victim and anti-waste. The Press editorial calls for the Bill to be passed, as do I.

Fitzsimons expects to retire by 2011

Jeanette Fitzsimons expects her upcoming sixth term in Parliament to be her last. She will probably stand down as co-leader in 2010.

Metira Turei would have to be the favourite to suceed her. A couple of years ago I would have put Sue Bradford as favourite, but her anti-smacking law has branded her in a way which would be risky for the Greens.

Greens get hard

It is good to see the Greens starting to put their own party’s interests first rather than continue on as Charlie Brown to Labour’s Lucy. The last two elections have seen Labour spurn the Greens in favour of NZ First or United Future.

The Green Party turned on its Labour ally yesterday, describing the Government’s softening on emissions trading as “disgusting” and indicating it was ready to deal with either of the major parties after the election.

Now let no one get excited by this. If the Greens can decide who gets to form a Government, they will always go with Labour. But it does represent an opportunity for both National and Greens to see if they could negotiate a limited agreement – maybe to abstain on confidence and supply in return for some policy wins.

As Labour and Greens occupy somewhat similar space, the Greens struggle to get recognition for some of its policy agenda, as people think Labour will probably have done it anyway. In theory they could do better with National, as any policy agreement would arguably be stuff that National was unlikely to do by itself.

Again this does not mean that the Greens will ever not put Labour in office, over National, if they have the choice. But if National can govern without the Greens – yet is willing to negotiate an agreement – there could be an opportunity to make it a win-win. The Greens get more respect and credit for their achievements than they do with Labour, and National gets to have a greener agenda.

Vanilla wins ice cream awards

TV Poll Results