Check the handwriting

Trying to win via overhang

The Green Party are once again showing their commitment to principles are incredibly expendable when it comes to political gain. They are now trying to engineer an election result which would result in a Government which had more votes cast against it, than for it.

Now to appreciate the hypocrisy of this, one has to look at MMP and the major principle or virtue of MMP. It is a proportional voting system where a party gets representation in Parliament in proportion to party votes cast for it. The Greens have strongly supported MMP, and one of the reasons so many supported it was because of the 1978 and 1981 situation when National formed a Government despite having less votes than Labour.

Now the Greens are trying to engineer a deliberate over-hang situation, which would result in a non proportional result. This is their suggestion that Maori roll voters should give their party vote to Greens and electorate vote to Maori Party in order to create an over-hang.

First we need to look at how over-hang happens. It happens when a party wins more electorate seats than its share of the party vote would entitle it to.  It is hard to eliminate entirely unless you abolish electorate seats. We currently have an over-hang of one seat as the Maori Party won four electorate seats and their party vote only entitled them to three seats.

It is also possible that this election could see ACT, United Future or Progressive with over-hang if their leaders retain their seats but their party vote is around 0.7% or less.

So we already have over-hang, but it is what I call accidental over-hang. The Maori Party, ACT, United Future and Progressive all want to increase their party vote.

But what the Greens are calling for, is for Maori roll voters to vote in such a way to ensure over-hang, to gain parties of the left more seats in Parliament than their party vote entitles them to. Here is how it works. Let us say the Maori Party wins all seven Maori seats. Now if they get 6% party vote, then the Maori Party will have eight MPs – one list MP and seven electorate MPs.

The Greens are saying, those Maori Party voters should give their party vote to the Greens. Now in an extreme example if those 6% all gave the Greens their party vote, then the Greens would gain an extra eight List MPs, while the Maori Party would still have seven MPs – all overhang seats. That means a Parliament of 127.

And this could change who gets to form the Government. Let’s say National gets 51% of the vote and 62 MPs. They should get to be the Government under MMP – this is exactly what MMP is meant to guarantee.

But by this strategy of deliberate vote splitting to ensure over-hang, then Labour, Greens and Maori Party could gain 65 MPs instead of the 58 they would have on the party vote only, and get to form a Government which only a minority of NZers voted for.

So whenever the Greens talk about any sort of principle when it comes to MMP or electoral law, you should remember that they are proposing a plan which is without principle and designed to secure power for the left, even if that goes against what the majority of NZers want.

Now some people could say, hey this is a loophole in MMP, and one should exploit any loophole you can find. The fact is though this loophole is more a design issue (can’t really easily fix it), and one which no party up until now has tried to really exploit. For the last 12 years various people have tried to convince National to try and do what the Greens are talking about. How it would be done is National splits into two parties – one contests the party vote and no electorates, and one contests electorates only. They would be seperate parties but co-operate together like the Libs and Nats in Australia. This would result in National getting 30 seat overhangs. Labour would then probably do the same and you’d basically have a meltdown of the MMP system (or a 190 seat Parliament!).

So the consequences of what the Greens are trying to do are severe. They are not only trying to frustrate the will of the voters, but they endanger MMP. For let me tell you that if they actually succeeded with their plan, and engineered a deliberate over-hang which changed the election result, the backlash would be nasty and massive. MMP would go, as the main rationale of MMP would have been discredited. Now FPP supporters might like that, but for the Greens as supporters of MMP to act in such a way is unprincipled and shameless.

The Greens, like all parties, are entitled to ask voters on teh Maori roll to vote for them with their party vote. But that should be on the basis of wanting Green party policies implemented and/or to get more Green MPs into Parliament. But they are not doing that. Instead they are arguing on the basis of overhang, that people should vote Green:

The question that Maori voters are asking though is that if the Maori party wins 6 electorate seats (it thinks it can win seven) is it worth also giving a party vote to the Maori Party? Last election each seat in Parliament was worth about 20,000 votes. So the answer is yes, a party vote for the Maori Party can deliver another parliamentary seat but only if there are about another 140,000 votes to go with it and help it climb above the seat overhang the Maori Party is expected to have. In other words, Maori voters who are leaning towards the Maori Party would need to give 7 times as many votes to the Maori Party to get one seat in parliament as they would to the Green Party.

They should abandon such arguments and retain a shred of principle. An MMP election should be decided by which parties get the most party votes. If they want to use overhang to gain power, then they should support the SM electoral system which effectively does precisely that.

Bill Sutch

It has been interesting to see the debate on whether or not Bill Sutch was a spy for the Soviet Union. I amgoing to ouch on that, but think that debate misses some crucial issues.

On the issue of whether or not he was a spy, I of course don’t know. The verdict of not guilty appears to be the correct one on the basis it was not proven beyond reasonable doubt. If one was deciding on balance of probabilities, it would possibly be a different outcome (especially as he lied denying there were any meetings and then claimed they were al to discuss Zionism!), but for criminal issues the test is beyond reasonable doubt so Sutch was not criminally a spy for the Soviet Union – mainly it seems because while there was proof of multiple clandestine meetings – there was no proof about what information was exchanged at them..

However he was an apologist and supporter of a murdering Stalinist regime. That makes him a man of incredible flawed and warped judgement regardless of whether or not he was a spy.

The SIS files on him are worth a read. He once described himself as a “Stalinist” and opposed NZ entry into WWII (the speculation being because of the German-USSR peace treaty) until the USSR became an ally.

Even after Stalin was denounced by Krushchev, Sutch defended Stalin’s actions on the grounds of economic necessity. He also disregarded instructions from the NZ Govt and voted in UN bodies with eastern bloc countries against his own Government’s wishes. He also thought the USSR invasion of Hungary was justified.

The SST reported:

He was considered to be a communist fellow traveller while working for New Zealand at the United Nations in the late 1940s, and drafted three radio talks about eastern Europe “in which he described the Soviets as liberators and generally welcomed communism in Eastern Europe”, the files say.

So as I said, he may or may not have spied for the USSR. But he was a dedicated supporter of it and apologist for it. In my eyes that is like the difference between having worked for the Nazis, or defending what the Nazis did – neither are testaments of good character.

United Future tax policy

NZPA reports on United Future’s tax policy released at their conference today. It is:

  • Income up to $12,000 taxed at 10 percent;
  • Income between $12,001 and $38,000 taxed at 20 percent; and
  • Income above $38,000 taxed at 30 percent.

They also advocate income splitting but that won’t be happening and has been analysed before. Let us first look at the cost of what United Future is proposing:

  1. Move bottom threshold from $9,500 to $12,000 is $135 million
  2. Move lowest 15% rate from 15% to 10% is $1,125 million
  3. Move 21% rate to 20% is $405 million
  4. Move 33% rate to 30% is $420 million
  5. Move 39% rate to 30% is $1,485 million

That is a total annual cost of $3.57 billion according to the Treasury ready reckoner. The NZIER calculator has it as $3.8 billion so that is close enough.

What will it mean for different people. Well let us look at a low income earner on $30,000, an average earner on $50,000 a higher income earner on $70,000 and a rich prick on $100,000.

  1. On $30,000 your tax drops from $5,730 to $4,800 – a $930 or 16.2% reduction
  2. On $50,000 your tax drops from $11,370 to $10,000 – a $1,370 or 12.0% reduction
  3. On $70,000 your tax drops from $18,570 to $16,000 – a $2,570 or 13.8% reduction
  4. On $100,000 your tax drops from $30,270 to $25,000 – a $5,270 or 17.4% reduction

I quite like the simplicity of just three rates of 10%, 20% and 30%. Not so sure about the levels they cut in at.

Dom Post editorial on Pink Vests

An excellent Dominion Post editorial on tagging and pink vests:

She [Iona Pannett] has likened the pink vest strategy to Nazi Germany’s persecution of gay men, and says it will reinforce prejudice against gay and lesbian people. That is an argument that is both flawed and ill-judged.

It is flawed because it relies on people always associating the colour pink with homosexuality, and not, for example, the breast cancer awareness programme.

Indeed. Pink is associated more with being female than being gay I would suggest.

Ms Pannett also ignores the obvious difference between taggers and the victims of the Nazis. There is an easy way for taggers to avoid wearing a pink vest – stop tagging. In Nazi Germany there was no way for Jews to avoid a yellow star, or homosexuals a pink triangle, or Roma a brown triangle.

Absolutely. Anyone who conflates a punishment for a crime with a punishment for just being born Jewish or gay or a gypsy is seriously off the planet.

And it is ill-judged because it trivialises the horrors of Nazi Germany.

To put it mildly. 30 minutes of embarrassment is very different from genocide.

Likening the actions of those who make criminal offenders wear a pink vest, while they clean up their scribblings, to those of a regime that murdered millions because of what they were, diminishes the suffering of those millions and the evil of those who killed them.

Ms Pannett expresses much concern for the feelings of those who might make an association between pink vests and homosexuality but does not appear to see that any could be offended by her implicit linking of Constable Gommans and Heinrich Himmler.

An apology would be in order.

Fran on tax

Fran O’Sullivan sees the significance of the Reserve Bank announcement:

… the central bank has also issued forecasts that predict a more negative economic outlook than the Treasury forecasts on which Cullen justified the size of his tax cuts.

This gives National the necessary political cover to argue a more serious tax-cutting programme would simply provide the necessarily larger fiscal stimulus to offset the more negative outlook without tempting the inflationary dogs.

Exactly.

However I would sound one note of caution. While the Reserve Bank forecasts indicate further tax cuts are possible without pushing interest rates up, there is still a potential fiscal problem. The weaker economy could turn Dr Cullen’s wafer thin surrpluses into deficits and further tax cuts without some reduction in expenditure would be a concern. One can go into deficit for short periods of time, one needs to make sure any deficit is not structural, if you have one at all.

It’s pretty basic politics. But the debate needs to move on to a higher plane. If National leader John Key retains the courage of his convictions – a quality that eluded his predecessor Don Brash – he should go further and reclaim lower taxes as the necessary element in building an internationally competitive economy. Not simply some version of tax-relief or middle-class welfare only dished out when the economy is in the soup.

This is the key point. Tax cuts should not be seen as just a different form of welfare. Splitting up the same sized cake is not going to solve our problems – it is growing the cake.

There is no real doubt that a smaller state as a percentage of GDP, leads to higher economic growth. The empirical evidence for this is massive and over many decades in many countries.

However of course there is a trade off as to the ability of the state to fund various services. That is why you don’t have the state at 5% of GDP. Getting the balance right if the challenge.

Key is a natural tax-cutter – by heart a fan of the Irish model of using low tax rates to attract foreign direct investment. Particularly for greenfields investments where the investors get a lower tax rate for investing in new enterprises that provide more jobs for our skilled people.

With unemployment forecast to rise substantially over the next few years, a serious programme based on competitive company taxes could provide another counter-cyclical stimulus. Particularly if National devised some mechanisms for foreign investors to take advantage of New Zealand’s China free trade agreement.

The luddites are against foreign investment, but they really need to look at Ireland to recognise what it can do in terms of increasing jobs and economic growth.

Mallard’s blond confusion

Some of the blogs on the left go feral whenever there is any comment on a female MP’s appearance or if they are called a female warlock. So I look forward to their comments on Trevor Mallard and Shane Jones.

We have Shane Jones on radio calling Katherine Rich Katherine Witch, but then clarifying that she isn’t a witch any more as she is leaving National’s Caucus.

And the Herald reports on Trevor Mallard:

In the House last week Mr Mallard couldn’t resist firing a barb in the direction of National’s female MPs, saying they looked very similar and it was hard to work out who was who.

“Some of us have a little bit of a problem in that a number of the women on the National Party benches look very similar,” Mr Mallard said.

“Certainly in looking at their hair colour, I can say it looks like they share their shampoos or hair dyes, and they do look somewhat similar.”

Yeah, and all those grey haired women in Labour look the same too. Well that is the equivalent of what Trevor is saying.

The blonde brigade includes Otago MP Jacqui Dean, Aoraki MP Jo Goodhew and list MP Nicky Wagner.

Indeed, they all are. At least Pansy Wong and Georgina te Heuheu are not blond or Trevor would be getting them confused also. Here are the three MPs:

Jacqui Dean

Jo Goodhew

Nicky Wagner

You really only have to meet them all once to tell them apart. There are those cunning subtle differences such as different faces.

And it seems that National’s production line of blonde women is far from finished, with three new candidates in this year’s election _ Nikki Kaye (Auckland Central), Louise Upston (Taupo) and Amy Adams (Selwyn) _ also fitting the bill.

Ms Upston and Ms Adams both brushed off Mr Mallard’s comments.

Both said they would prefer people judged them on their abilities and what they stood for, rather than their hair colour or appearance.

How novel. Some Labour MPs might agree with them.

But how will Trevor cope with three new MPs to tell apart. Well again it should not be difficult:

Amy Adams (Rakaia)

Nikki Kaye (Auckland Central)

Louise Upston (Taupo)

Now again, those subtle differences such as different faces, different heights, different hair styles may help Trevor cope.

Dunne and National

The Herald reports on the increasing signs by Peter Dunne that he wants to work with an expected National Government after the election. This is no surprise – Peter has been a Minister in a National-led Government before.

It will be interesting to see what United Future announces as its policy for post-election negotiations. In 2005 both UF and NZF said they would give first preference for forming a Government (subject to negotiating an acceptable agreement) to the party with the most votes. NZ First have confirmed that is their policy again, but I am not sure if United Future have.

May Public Polls

The monthly polling newsletter will be out over the weekend. You can subscribe to the full newsletter here.

There were seven public polls in May 2008, and the average of them shows a distinct trend. Labour have dropped almost 3%, with National, NZ First and the Greens all making gains.

Of course it is not just a National vs Labour race, but the projected seats per bloc also show a trend. The CL bloc actually led until March 2007.

Another interesting graph is this one done by Therese Arseneau, a political science fellow at Canterbury University, using the One News Colmar Brunton results:

Therese has gone back to 2002, which was a low point for National. The graph does show a very clear trend over the last six years, when you iron out the monthly highs and lows. She comments:

The trends are striking. National’s vote has been growing, on average, by just under half a percentage point (.46%) per month since 2002. At the same time, Labour’s support has been dropping by just under a quarter of a percentage point (.23%) per month.

These trends have been amazingly consistent and strong, particularly for National. Don Brash’s Orewa speech did seem to alter them for a time, sparking a boost for National (and dip for Labour) in early 2004.  This disruption was not sustained and within months of the speech, support for both National and Labour had reverted back to their steady procession along the trend lines.

The trend has also been consistent through three successive National leaders. There was a spike after John Key replaced Don Brash as leader but again, the growth in National support settled back to the trend line.

This suggests that neither event on its own was decisive to National’s renaissance. Instead, for six years now National has been heading towards victory and Labour towards defeat.

Long-term trends are the hardest ones to turn around. A massive rise in the polls can just as quickly reverse. The slow steady rise or fall is far more desirable or undesirable depending on which you are facing.

More race based seats called for

This is one of the reasons why I have concerns over the Maori seats – the precedent it creates for other races to demand race based seats. We see this with the Waitakere Pacific Board calling for Pacific Island seats to be created on all Auckland Councils.

I see the strength of NZ is that we have so many races, and have lots of inter-race marriages so more and more Kiwis have some Maori blood, some PI blood, some Chinese blood etc etc. The US is a great example of how diverse racial backgrounds can create a strong country with an African American candidate for President, an Indian American Governor, Asian American Cabinet Ministers etc etc.

But they never have special seats for Americans of one particular race or bloodline. That is divisive.

I reject this statement especially:

Board chairman Taha Fasi said Islanders were lucky enough to have more than half of voters in Manukau City wards like Otara and Mangere, but the present system would never enable them to be voted become councillors in Waitakere.

“It does not matter how good our policies would be … at the end of the day the majority of voters are mainstream Pakeha and race is always an unseen and unsaid deciding factor,” Mr Fasi said.

This is a shameful view of fellow New Zealanders. The good folks of Wairarapa elected a Maori transsexual as their MP because they thought she was the best candidate. Gisborne and Dunedin have had Asian Mayors. Maori are actually over-represented in Parliament compared to their proportion of the adult population. Auckland City has a Pacific Island Councillor etc etc.

This shameful view seems to be shared by some in Labour:

The Pacific sector council of the Labour Party said Maori, Pacific and Asian communities ought to be represented at all levels of local decision-making through a mix of elected and appointed members.

But why stop there. Should South Africans get their own seats once they make up 1% of the population? And let us not lump all Asians in together. Chinese and Indians should have their own seperate seats. And hell the Scots hate being lumped in with the filthy English, so seperate electoral rolls for them also.

Labour’s tunnel

Maurice Williamson is pointing at political infleunce in the decision to approve the $1.89 billion Waterview tunnels in Auckland. He claims it is not possibly to do with current funding, and the Government is not denying this:

“I don’t think the Government could ever fund a $1.9 billion road from just straight land transport funding,” Mr Williamson said. “That would mean the rest of the country would get nothing for nearly three years, so you have go to find an alternative source of funding.”

Finance Minister Michael Cullen has acknowledged it would be difficult to pay for the project from fuel taxes alone, and the Government is waiting for a report from a steering group on the feasibility of establishing a PPP to dig and operate the tunnels.

So why would Transit approved a project it can’t afford to fund,

But Mr Williamson claimed Transit’s decision-making had been “terribly politicised” by the presence of Labour president Mike Williams on its board and by a statement by Prime Minister Helen Clark in 2005 in support of tunnels through Waterview, which is in her Mt Albert electorate.

“You’ve got the Prime Minister and the president of the Labour Party both actively involved in getting a design of a road which in my view is politicising it to a shocking extent,” he said.

Okay, well that explains it.

A submission to Transit by the Road Transport Forum, representing freight carriers, claimed that at least $500 million could be saved by staying above ground.

“An analysis of the extra costs of the tunnel option suggests Transit NZ is prepared to spend an extra $1.6 million per house to tunnel under the houses rather than face potential planning delays.”

Hey what is $500 million between friends. Remember there is no waste in Government spending!

Herald calls on National to support Criminal Procedure Bill

An interesting collection of people and groups have been calling for National to support the Government’s Criminal Procedures Bill. At last glance they are:

  • The Chief High Court Judge
  • DPF!
  • The Sensible Sentencing Trust
  • Louise Nicholas
  • ACT
  • NZ Herald

Today’s Herald editorial says:

The National Party subscribes not only to the notion that victims relish their day in court but that every card in the judicial deck should be brought to bear on criminals. Consequently, it has stalled the Criminal Procedure Bill, which would allow pre-trial depositions to be based on written evidence, unless otherwise ordered by a judge. By now, however, National should have had a drastic rethink.

The Criminal Procedure Bill ensures this process will have to be endured just once, unless a judge decides a depositions hearing is necessary. Rarely will this be the case. The use of written evidence should not alter the present situation, in which very few cases do not proceed to trial because insufficient proof is produced at hearings. Yet somehow this does not satisfy the Law Society, which also opposes the legislation. It suggests depositions hearings are important not just for disclosure but for testing witnesses’ evidence and reliability and for confronting defendants with the case against them. This, it suggests, might persuade them to plead guilty.

These objections smack more of self-interest than reality. Essentially, they do little more than proclaim the desirability, in an ideal world, of staging dress rehearsals. This pales into insignificance alongside the many advantages of allowing depositions based on written evidence.

Some lawyers have been making very constructive arguments in the blog debate on the issue, arguing for the value off depositions hearings and how they can lead to changed pleas etc. Despite their useful arguments I have not been convinced because what has been lacking is any hard numbers on what proportion of cases does this apply to. Is it worth having 20 depositions hearings, if only one of them results in someone then pleading guilty? Some more concrete facts and figures would be useful.

Economic Euthanasia

I blogged yesterday how the UN has called for a lifting of food tariffs and biofuel subsidies to help alleviate the starvation in the third world from the high cost of food. I also blogged how this seems to be contrary to NZ First and Greens policies.

Now Trans-Tasman has just come out and they note the following:

The global food crisis should produce a unified national response to expand agricultural output. But, curiously, NZ is represented at the FAO Summit by an 11-man delegation led by Agriculture Minister Jim Anderton (who represents the smallest party in Parliament) and the Greens’ Sue Kedgely (paying her own costs), the party which in its Auckland conference at the weekend was calling for tougher conditions for NZ’s dairying industry.

The Greens have not only demanded NZ’s agricultural producers pay immediately for their greenhouse gas emissions as well as a punitive water levy (which would harm irrigators), but have insisted on bio-fuels being included in NZ’s transport fuels, and also have opposed genetic modification. This is a programme of “economic euthanasia” for the dairy industry. It is not surprising the Greens are finding it hard to lift above the modest levels they are currently polling.

I’m not sure whether the euthanasia is referring to the effects on the diary industry or the effects on those in the third world who need cheaper food, not more expensive food.

Reserve Bank Forecasts

I’ve been going through the data on which the Reserve Bank based their announcement today that they intend to lower the OCR later this year. It is not pretty:

  • Inflation projected to hit 4.7% by September 2008 – this will be the highest inflation has been since December 1990.
  • Economic Growth to slow to under 1% in 2009
  • The lowest level of house sales in 18 years
  • A drop in the TWI from over 70 to around 60
  • A rise in unemployment from 3.6% to 6%
  • A drop in house prices of 13%

I almost pity Bill English who is likely to inherit this. Not as bad as 1990 but nothing like the booming economy Dr Cullen inherited in 1999.

The summary is NZers will have almost big price rises, low economic growth, around $70,000 knocked off the value of their family home, and around 50,000 more unemployed

The MPS noted:

Faced with lower nominal income growth and higher consumer prices, households must decide whether to take on extra debt or lower their standard of living.

What a lovely choice. However the Reserve Bank hints at an answer:

Many households will need to devote a high proportion of their income to debt servicing costs, limiting their discretionary spending. High global food and energy prices will have a large impact on the spending power of households. The domestic prices of these goods will be pushed up further by a weaker New Zealand dollar. The tax cuts and increased transfers announced in Budget 2008 will provide some offset to these rising costs over late 2008 and early 2009.

So further tax cuts would provide further assistance to households facing a choice between extra debt or lower living standards. Labour is crying that further tax cuts will mean cutting of public expenditure. So they seem to be saying that households should cut their standard of living, rather than have the Government cut its expenditure!

“Buying elections”

The left often go on about how awful money in politics is, and how we need the EFA because hell we can’t have a third party spend more than $120,000 supporting or opposing a party over a year etc.

So where have been the protests from the left that Barack Obama “purchased” the nominaion by outspending Hillary Clinton? Why are they not denouncing Obama for unfairly spending more money than Clinton?

Now Obama pledged in February 2007 that he would stay in the federal public financing system if he did win the primary fight, as long as his GOP opponent did the same, which McCain has agreed to. What this means is you get around $85 million of public funding but can’t spend extra on top of that, once the nominating convention has concluded.

Now Obama is looking to renege on that pledge, and may become the first ever presidential candidate to try and bury his opponent through outspending in the general election. So again where are the howls of outrage?

Morons

NZPA reports:

Many voters were morons and he did not want them to vote for him at the general election, New Zealand First leader Winston Peters told his NewstalkZB radio audience today.

I think Winston is being far too tough on voters when he says many of them are morons. I’d do a ballpark guess and say that no more than about oh 5.72% of voters are morons 🙂

Dom Post on List Jumping

The Dominion Post is also not impressed with the Greens putting aisde their party list they were elected on in 2005, to leapfrog Russel Norman into Parliament.

Those pondering whether to cast a Green Party vote can pore over the details and the rankings, weighing the merits of those at the top of the list against what other, smaller list-based parties have to offer.

They should be aware they are wasting their time.

The appointment of Green Party co-leader Russel Norman as an MP shows that, when push comes to shove, the Greens will put party needs above voter preference and shuffle the deck to deliver the MPs the party wants rather than delivering the ones on the list the public voted for.

This is the key issue. It is nothing personal about Russel who I am sure will become an MP anyway later this year. It is about whether or not you respect the list put up at an election.

Those who argue that what the Greens are doing is not wrong, should consider the logical ultimate outcome of that argument. If List MPs are there purely as creatures of the party – to be elected and retired at whim, then why even have a public list before the election? Just tell the party they have X MPs, and they can appoint whomever they want as MPs at any time.

Putting Dr Norman into Parliament this late in the electoral cycle will not see him contribute hugely to the work of Parliament. What it will do is give him a platform from which to expound his views, and access to the resources, such as taxpayer-funded air travel, that give MPs a massive advantage in campaigning nationwide.

Indeed. This is being done not to further the work of Parliament, but to allow greater use of taxpayer resources for their election campaign.

No chance at all

Dail Jones is getting a reputation as an MP who teels the truth as he sees it, even when he shouldn’t.

There was a stunned silence last night at the filming of Back Benches during the discussion on polls. Jones said that he thought most people had made their mind on Helen Clark and Labour.

Host Wallace Chapman then asked him directly if he thought it was all over, or did Helen still have a chance of remaining PM after the election. Jones’ reply was along the lines of “No, no chance at all”.

Now bear in mind that NZ First is a Government party, and their Leader is a Minister in the Government – that is an extraordinary statement for a NZ First MP to make.

I didn’t write his exact words down at the time, but they were definitely unequivocal about Helen losing. I am in Auckland for most of today but someone helpful might like to download the show and stick that segment on You Tube!

Citizen’s Juries

The Herald reports on how the Greens want to get a Citizen’s Jury on the issue of state funding of political parties underway as soon as possible, so National can’t abolish it after the election.

Now if done the right way, I am quite a fan of citizen’s juries. But everything about this is being done the wrong way.

The outcome has been predetermined. Instead of being set up in bipartisan fashion on matters such as the type of electoral system, it has been set up to deliver just one result – increased taxpayer funding of political parties. Labour and the Greens both want that as the outcome, tried to do it through the EFA, and having somewhat failed are now trying to do it again.

Labour are quite simply corrupt when it comes to electoral law issues, and any process which involves them as Government choosing the expert panel which advises the Citizen’s Jury should be treated as naked self interest. Hell Mike Williams will probably end up as the Chair.

The Greens are little better than Labour in this area. They have absolutely no comitment to a fair process unless it achieves the outcome they want. Look at the Royal Commission on Genetic Engineering? That had it all – independent commissioners, scientific evidence, hearings etc. And the moment it didn’t recommend what the Greens wanted – they attacked it.

So this process is a total sham. It is designed for one purpose only – to let Labour and the Greens use more taxpayer money on their election campaigns. After what Labour and Greens did with the EFA, they should frankly be seen as incompetent to have a say on these issues.

Now this is not to say the concept of Citizen’s Juries do not have a place in electoral law making. I think they do. They can provide some very useful input if done the right way. But the way I would use such Juries are as follows:

  1. The independent experts must be chosen by a super majority of parliamentary parties, not just by the Government of the day. The formula which I like is that any appointments must be agreed to by party leaders representing over 75% of the MPs and over 50% of the parties in Parliament. This means that not only must both major parties agree, but so must at least half of the minor parties.
  2. The issues, terms of references and high level process must also be signed off by that super-majority. The most unforgivable crime that Labour and the Greens have done with the EFA is to treat electoral law as a bauble for the winner, rather than a bipartisan constitutional law.
  3. Issues referred to a Citizen’s Jury should be in totality, not just a narrow aspect such as taxpayer funding of political parties. It is ridicolous to exclude from consideration all the issues dealt with by the Electoral Finance Act. In fact the EFA should be abolished immediately upon a change of Government, and a citizen’s jury could be used as part of the process of consulting on and determining its replacement.

It is a shame that what is a perfectly fine concept is being damaged by its use by the Greens and Labour in such a partisan fashion. I mean Russel Norman is already calling for its timelines to be determined so that National can be attacked over it, rather than any sense of what a proper time-frame would be.

Prime and Jews

Billboards have gone up promoting a new TV show on Prime called Mad Men, based on a 1960s advertising agency.

A reader has e-mailed me about the billboards, which say:

“Advertising agency seeks clients — all business considered, even from Jews.”

Now my first reaction was that the TV show is lampooning anti Jewish bigotry, rather than targeting Jews. The Borat movie is a prime example of that. So I’m not particularly offended by the billboard.

However upon further reflection I wondered if Prime and its advertising agency would have dared to run billboards saying “all business considered, even from Maoris” or “all business considered, even from Polynesians”. I suspect not.

And as David Cohen points out, were such anti Jewish sentiments ever part of the advertising industry in the 1960s? Like David, I suspect not.

Now as I said, I understand that the adverts are meant to be in the same category as the anti Jewish sentiment done by Borat. However I would make the point that Borat could get away with it, because Sacha Baron-Cohen is in fact Jewish, and because it was so absolutely over the top no-one could take it seriously.

Where Prime is risking trouble, is by the nature of its advertising being on billboards. The average person walking down the street may not get the context. A billboard is arguably the most intrusive form of advertising, and elderly members of the Jewish community may not enjoy seeing such a billboard, as the humour will be lost on them with their real world experiences of living in countries where Jews were banned from many many types of business.

Now that’s an open relationship

A fascinating article on Tilda Swinton’s complicated love life.

Swinton, most well known as the White Witch in Narnia, has two partners – 67 year old John Byrne and 29 year old Sandro Kopp. Swinton is 47 which using the half plus seven rule means her acceptable range should be 30 to 80.

Byrne also has a second partner, Jeanine Davis who is 42 which is just above his tehcnical lower limit of 40.

Sound complicated but Tilda sums it up:

“I have children with someone else, with whom I’m bringing up my children, and I’ve lived with someone else, my sweetheart for the last three years, and maybe it’s extraordinary that we’re really all friends.”

So if you invite her to dinner, how many do you invite?

Who won what?

I’ve done a quick analysis of the 51 states (including DC) and how they voted. I’ve excluded the colonies and Democrats Abroad because at the end of the day only people in one of the 51 states/DC get to vote.

Obama won 30 states to 21 for Clinton. A pretty clear victory. However he won the smaller states – worth only 227 electoral college votes, while Clinton’s 21 are worth 311 electoral college votes.

Obama had the five biggest margins – 63% in Idaho to 38% in Kansas. Clinton’s best result was 32% in Arkansas.

There were few close races – only 10 states had a less than 10% margin and only three states had a less than 3% margin.

So what might this mean for the contest vs McCain? Obama leads McCain by an average 1.4% at the moment. But as most knew it is all about the electoral college count.

The current RCP electoral map has Obama 6 (272 – 266) electoral college votes ahead of McCain – so almost neck and neck. Clinton vs McCain had a larger 30 vote gap in Clinton’s favour.

I expect Obama will now get a huge bump in the polls from having secured the nomination. It will be interesting to see how sucessfully he can unite the Democrats – especially those white working class supporters.

Who won the popular vote?

Some interesting stats at Real Clear Politics in terms of the popular vote for the Democratic nomination.

With all primaries over, Obama leads Clinton by just 0.1% in the popular vote. That is 34,000 out of 35 million cast. This excludes Michigan where Obama was not on the ballot.

If you add on estimates for four Caucuses, his lead stretches to 0.4%.

However if you add Michigan in, Clinton leads by 0.8% or 0.5% including the caucuses.

This is a bit unfair though as Obama was not on the ballot paper. However 45% voted uncommitted and if one assigns them to Obama (which is the fairest thing to do), what is the result?

It is Clinton ahead by 0.1%. However add in estimates for the four caucuses and it is Obama by 0.2%.

So it is a bit like Florida in 2000. Both sides can claim to have won the popular vote depending on how you count it. In three scenarios Obama wins, and in three Clinton wins.

I tend to think the final result I have listed – the one with Obama ahead by 0.2% is probably the most appropriate as it includes all primaries and caucuses.

Back Benches tonight

Some new MPs tonight. We have:

  1. Dail Jones, NZ First
  2. Russel Norman, Greens
  3. Jill Pettis, Labour
  4. Paula Bennett, National

Can someone please please please ask Dail Jones to explain what the close to $100,000 anonymous donation he referred to, turned out to be? NZ First have done a return saying they had no donations over $10,000 so can Dail explain what the large sum of money that unexpectedly turned up in their bank account was?

Topics are the polls, Barack Obama and food.

As usual come along between 8 pm and 8.30 pm for a 9 pm start at the Backbencher on Molesworth Street. Those out of town can see it on TVNZ7.

Obama is the candidate

Finally, after five months of primaries and caucuses, Barack Obama has become the presumptive nominee of the Democratic Party for the United States Presidency.

He passed the magical 2,118 target today with a wave of pledges from super delegates, putting himself over the line before we even get results from Montana.

It is a historic day to have an African American candidate for the most powerful job in the world. Not only was slavery legal 150 years ago in the US, but just 40 years ago African Americans were segregated second class citizens (and in NZ worth noting it was only in 1967 that Maori were allowed to vote on the general roll). The US has come a very long way in just one generation.

I am not a fan of Senator Obama’s policies, but today is a day to recognize his historic achievement. He is an extremely gifted politician who carries the burden of a huge amount of hope and promise for his supporters. He managed to defeat the formidable Clinton machine and now faces off the no less formidable Republican Party.

If he should win, it has to be recognized that an Obama presidency has the potential to be a positive catalyst for improving America’s standing within the world. A Black President would be more than just a powerful symbol for a country which is truly built on being a melting pot of immigrants. A President who attended school in Pakistan Indonesia, and has Muslim relatives would make it a lot harder to demonise the United States as the Great Satan.

There are legitimate questions over his experience and his policies, and they will be debated over the months to come. But today is Obama’s day – and one he has earnt.