The benefits of immigration

The Herald reports on an interesting presentation to an immigration conference:

Speaking on “the economic impact of immigration”, he said recent studies had found that overseas-born migrants contributed $8.1 billion to the economy in 2006, while using $4.81 billion in benefits and services. In comparison, New Zealand-born citizens contributed $24.76 billion and used $21.92 billion in benefits and services.

If correct, this is how it should be. Immigration policy is about selecting people who will be a boost to the NZ economy, not a cost to it.

It is a pity the report cited is not named, as I would be keen to read a copy of it.

School’s unfunded mandates

A group of 15 school principals have written an open letter to the Minister of Education Chris Carter saying

“We do not concur with your statements that current funding is enough to provide a quality basic education.”

So what is the problem. Hasn’t funding increased? Well yes it has, but so has the paperwork:

In an open letter to Education Minister Chris Carter, the principals detailed Government innovations they claimed were not fully funded and had increased pressure on already-stretched finances.

The list of 21 included pandemic planning, maintaining electronic student management systems and running the healthy lifestyle programme Mission On.

“We respectfully suggest you provide for the current demands before introducing new and more underfunded priorities,” the principals wrote.

So what are they doing about it?

Northcote College principal Vickie Barrie said in a separate email: “Schools will not engage in the Government’s new Schools Plus initiative until the minister has recognised the dire funding situation secondary schools find themselves in.”

Schools Plus is a major initiative that aims to keep New Zealanders in education or training until age 18.

It was outlined by Prime Minister Helen Clark in her opening address to Parliament this year, as part of a “quantum leap” in changing the aspirations for young people.

Wow, that is a slap down for sure.

Anyone seen Dad4Justice recently?

Jordan vs Roger

An interesting post from Jordan Carter on Sir Roger Douglas, whom he will be up against in Hunua. Some extracts and comments:

He is the prime salesman of the concepts which created poverty in New Zealand for the first time in two generations.

Okay so there was no poverty under Muldoon. Must remember that.

He stands for an unfair society based on concepts of right and privilege that are abhorrent to ordinary New Zealanders.

Now note here he doesn’t just attack Sir Roger’s policies but says Sir Roger is motivated by privilege. He can’t possibly concede that Sir Roger (as someone who served in Labour for far longer than Jordan) wants the same outcomes as Jordan, but just disagrees on the way to do it. No, there is an inability to credit your opponent with noble motives. You disagree with them, so they must be bad people is what he is saying.

His agenda is the same agenda he had in 1988: it is pulled right out of the deep freeze, an obsolete, out of date prescription for the problems our country faced twenty years ago. Everything has moved on except the Year Zero fanaticism of Sir Roger Douglas, ACT and most of the National Party.

Nice allusion to Pol Pot there. And note that Jordan doesn’t just paint Sir Roger as that, but all of ACT and most of National.

So I appreciate ACT’s honesty: Sir Roger and friends know what they stand for and are prepared to talk about it. Which is why having him as an opponent in Hunua is just brilliant. We’ll be able to debate reality, not the faux shadowboxing that is my National Party opponent’s only offer.

What would be nice is if he debates policies, instead of slogans.

US disengages from UN Human Rights Council

The former UN Commission on Human Rights was a sick joke which comprised some of the worst human rights offenders in the world. Hence the UN Secretary-General proposed it be replaced by a smaller Human Rights Council with not just fewer members, but an election method which would keep out the worst states.

Sadly the reforms got watered down, so that almost the only thing which changed was the title. The new Human Rights Council has been hiring defenders of dictators for its work, and instead of trying to promote free speech, is trying to close it down by pushing for religious criticism defamation to be banned.

They have terminated scrutiny of Cuba and Belarus and basically do nothing at all except spend all their time condemning Israel. Not even the genocide in Darfur gets criticism to the same degree as Israel. And these criticisms of the Council come from Kofi Annan, not the US or Israel.

The US has announced it is minimising its participation, due to the above concerns. NZ should be doing the same. The UN does good in several areas, but its Human Rights Council is a sick joke.

Obama’s blunder on Israel

Reading in the NY Times about a blunder Obama made on Israel, reminds me of why I remain unconvinced about his experience. In six months time he may occupy the most powerful job on the planet where every statement has serious consequences.

So what did Obama do wrong. He addressed a pro-Israel lobby and said:

“Jerusalem will remain the capital of Israel, and it must remain undivided.”

Now that statement goes beyond the position of George W Bush, hell it even goes beyond the position of Israel itself – it is somewhere to the right of Likud. The status and possible division of Jerusalem is one of the major issues for a peace settlement, and anyone who has done more than Stage One foreign relations would know you can’t rule it out like that.

As one would expect it caused outrage in the Middle East, and the Obama campaign has started to backtrack or clarify his remarks. As he is only a candidate, no harm for now. But if he becomes President he is really really going to need an extremely strong foreign policy team to prevent him saying things like that again, because as President such a statement would have ramifications – it would be read as the US unilaterally deciding the boundaries of Israel.

Madness Part 3

And the third and final part is just as good. Read this third post by Sue Kedgley. I like this part especially:

The President of one of the main Italian NGO’s, for example, Antonio Duovati, from the Committee for Food Sovereignty, explained that New Zealand is seen, thanks to our flag waving for free trade liberalization policies, as ‘an enemy of the third world’ and a slave of America and Europe.

Oh wow we get to be both an enemy of the third world, and a slave of America and Europe. Do you get badges to go with that?

You know what is really funny. All these people decrying the effort to alleviate the food crisis – I bet you very very few are from countries starving. Sue is quoting oh gosh an Italian NGO. I bet you they are starving. Now fo course you don’t have to be starving to have a view on food policies, but I reckon the views of Sue and her Italian mates that NZ is an enemy of the third world, is not shared by those in the actual third world.

Anyway to make up for all the irresistible Greens bashing, I should point out that Frog has done a very good response to my post on trying to get an overhang in Parliament, and is what I call a partial retreat. I still think they are on somewhat dangerous grounds talking about party votes for the Maori Party being wasted, because they are only wasted if there is overhang. One you get past an overhang situation, a party vote for one Party is just as valuable as a party vote for any other party which makes the threshold. But nice to have a thoughtful response.

Lovely

And more madness

Oh it gets even better. The first blog post from Sue Kedgley sees her blaming free trade for the third world food crisis (and contradicting herself as she complains about subsidies). Now it gets even worse – Bill Gates and GE rear their head. Read Sue’s second blog post:

It was to be expected, but still a shock, to find Bill Gates and the Rockefeller foundation at the conference (they weren’t excluded like the NGOs) launching a new bold sounding “Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa.

Good God. They let Bill Gates in. How dare they. I mean his charitable foundation only spends US$800 million a year on global health initiatives – almost more than the UN’s WHO. And with the Rockefeller Foundation have only invested US$150 million to enhance agricultural science and small-farm productivity in Africa.

The cads. We should shoot them at dawn. How dare they be allowed into a conference to discuss helping solve the food crisis.

The Rockefeller foundation are also evil doers. All they have done is develop the vaccine for yellow fever, funded social sciences and funded agricultural development to expand food supplies around the world. The heartless bastards. They have been so sucessful at health and food that the UN WHO was set up on their model, and they are actually credited with funding the Green Revolution in the 1940s to 1960s which increased agricultural production around the planet.

So maybe you know they are not totally bad people to have there.

But what were these bastards doing:

In partnership with various UN agencies, aimed at ‘lifting millions out of poverty and hunger by increasing the  productivity and profitability of small scale farms in Africa.

My goodness, the very thing Sue was complaining about in her previous post – that local farming was unsustainable.

a bold journalist asked directly whether the seeds would be genetically engineered.  They then admitted that some would be, such as a new strain of Nevica rice which ‘takes the flavour of Asia and the robustness of rice in West Africa to produce a high yielding rice.

Oh my God. How sick are those people. They want to produce a high yielding rice which is more robust. We can have no part of that. Far better people starve than we use technology.

I was not allowed to speak at the conference, or attend any bilateral meetings or negotiating sessions

And I never thought I would be saying this, but let us hear three big cheers for Jim Anderton. He may have saved NZ global embarrassment.

The madness of the Greens

I encourage everyone to go read the blog post by Sue Kedgley on the World Food Conference in Rome. It is a stunning example of madness and extremism.

They argued that the main cause of the crisis was that food production in much of the developing world has been decimated by three decades of globalization and free trade liberalization policies. Previously self sufficient countries had been unable to compete with heavily subsidized, cheap European and American food and so small self sufficient agricultural sectors collapsed in country after country, leaving developing countries dependent on imports and food aid.

Now read this carefully. In the first sentence she blames the food crisis on free trade liberalization policies (never mind even the very lefty UN is blaming it on biofuels and saying free trade is the solution), and then in the second sentence she complains about heavily subsidized cheap food undermining local agricultural sectors.

Earth to Sue – come in Sue. That is protectionism – the very thing you are in favour of. People who support free trade like me want subsidies and tariffs to be abolished. That way those countries which can most efficiently produce food, get to do so. I suspect Africa would boom in terms of food production if indeed one can get Europe and the US to remove their subsidies and tariffs.

It is scary that a long serving MP can not know the difference between free trade and protectionism. I think this shows that the anti globalisation fanatics have just started to use it as a slogan. Anything they are against they label as free trade and globalisation.

A little mapping challenge

This will probably just be of interest to people who have and can use mapping software. I’m looking for someone who falls into the above category (person or company) to contact me about what sort of cost would be involved for a little project involving meshblocks I am working on.

There are currently around 42,982 meshblocks. I have a number of locations (around 1,000) for which I have a geographical description (both an x,y coordinate and a meshblock location).

What I wish to do is determine for every meshblock in NZ, which of these 1,000 locations that meshblock is closest to. Now I could do this manually by looking them up on maps, but it occurs to me it should be something fairly simple to do by someone who knows how to use mapping software.

So if this is something you or your company can do (or know someone who can), please contact me so I can describe the potential job in more detail.

Clinton and Obama support

The NY Times has a fascinating interactive display showing how different demographics in the 50 states voted with Obama and Clinton. They do it for 16 different demographics. I’ve pasted below two of them – for blacks and whites.

The NY Times has also done this map showing support for the two candidates.

You can click on the version above for the full size one.

Reform and Regulation

The Hive on Cap and Trade

The Hive has the first of a weekly series – a short essay on an issue.

This week is on why they prefer a carbon tax to a cap and trade emissions trading scheme:

Imagine a country that had a business tax. The size of the business tax varied daily, and was subject to international forces – global supply and demand and exchange rate variation. No one therefore knows the size of the tax but estimates suggests that the size will be somewhere between $15 and $75 per tonne of carbon emission equivalent (in the short term, long term prices in the $100 plus range are regarded as conservative).

Investors don’t like uncertainty. This tax would add considerable uncertainty. Would investors invest in a country that had such a regime?

And the alternative:

Compare the cap and trade regime with a carbon tax – it is simple, predictable and the size of the tax in the immediate future doesn’t need to be large to meet our liabilities under the Kyoto Protocol. $3 a tonne starting 1 January 2009 is all that is needed.

A number of think tanks, which are normally anti tax, say a carbon tax is preferable. They also suggest that the level of the tax be tied to the increase in global temperature so if things do heat up more quickly than expected, then the tax rises proportionally, and if the increases don’t happen, the tax drops.

The Hive concludes:

So at The Hive, we agree fully with the policy that the Green Party has been advocating since the early 1990s. A carbon tax offset against reductions in general taxation is the best way forward. We just can’t understand why so many people have decided to support the cap and trade alternative. Those on the left, we understand – it will screw the economy. But on the centre and right?

I am not sure an ETS is not a better solution in the long term, but agree that in the short to medium term a carbon tax would be preferable – especially with the price of carbon credits so variable.

“Pigs”

Cactus Kate has some useful advice for girls whose boyfriends tell them they are “fat, ugly and a whore”. She suggests no second chances and preferably a restraining order.

Sadly quite a few female friends of mine have gone out with guys like that – no not ones who turn violent, but those who seem to be so insecure about themselves, that they spend most of their relationship trying to lower their girlfriend’s self esteem, presumably in the hope that the girl will never leave them as she doesn’t think she can do any better.

I’d like to say such men are a tiny minority of men, but sadly they are not – they’re a reasonably significant minority (nowhere near a majority though). I don’t believe in feeling guilt or shame for fellow members of whatever demographic group I belong to, but I almost do when it comes to guys like this. I’ve seen far too many bright, attractive (in all senses) confident women just have their self esteem demolished and endure for months or even years in a miserable relationship because they think it is better than nothing. No it isn’t.

No relationship is perfect, and without arguments. But I have a simple philosophy I expound to friends – the 90% rule. The whole idea of being in a relationship is to be happy. If at least 90% of the time you spend together does not involve being happy, then get the fuck out.

The headline Helen hates

Sir Roger’s return

Two announcements were made yesterday regarding Sir Roger Douglas. The minor one was regarding which seat he would stand in, and the decision to choose Hunua is no surprise as he lives there. His brother, Malcolm Douglas, is a former MP for Hunua and will be his campaign manager.

The more significant announcement is that he accept whatever list ranking the members give him. Previously indications are he would be lower down the list to give ACT supporters a target to work towards (such as “If we get 5% we get Sir Roger back), but now it seems Sir Roger will be No 3 or maybe even No 2.

To get three MPs ACT needs around 2.5% of the vote which is certainly plausible.

Who from ACT would become a Minister, if an agreement with National can be achieved, would be interesting. You see if you do only have three MPs, then they won’t all get to be Ministers. In fact realistically only one of them would be. So would Rodney (who would be in his 5th term) and Heather be content being backbenchers if they push Sir Roger to take up a ministerial role? And the converse also goes – would Sir Roger be content being a backbencher with Rodney in Cabinet?

Building the broad coalition

I have been an advocate for some time that National should negotiate post-election coalition deals with minor parties, even if National had enough seats to govern alone, so it is good to see the following in the NZ Herald:

National Party leader John Key says he could negotiate post-election coalition deals with parties such as United Future or the Maori Party even if National gained enough votes to govern alone.

My order of preference for deals is:

  1. ACT
  2. United Future
  3. Maori Party
  4. Greens
  5. Progressive
  6. NZ First

With Dr Cullen having basically spent all the surplus until 2016, minor parties may find their spending ambitions need to be curtailed (regardless of who forms the Government) and focus instead go on policies and posts rather than spending commitments.

Sunday Snippets

For that long Sunday afternoon:

The NZ Book Council have a very cool website to encourage reading. They’ve done it as a Windows operating system.

Scrubone does a fisking of No Right Turn’s outrage at National over citizen juries. Also on that issue, Russel Norman at Frog Blog agrees with some of my suggestions around Citizen’s Juries – specifically the need for multi-partisan agreement not narrow agreement.

Paul Walker responds to Matt McCarten’s hysteria over the Business Roundtable.

Whale Oil likes his stats comparison with Kiwiblog. Obviously girls and guns work 🙂

Craig Foss looks at how Dr Cullen is financing his tax cuts – he is borrowing $6.4 billion and also selling $6.4 billion of financial assets breaking one of his four tests. This last one is particularly cunning as it allows him to claim gross debt remains on track. This si why net debt is the better indicator.

Colin Espiner reviews the Reserve Bank MPS and the polls.

Bernard Hickey believes Alan Bollard has gone soft on inflation, as does the Westpac Chief Economist.

The Killdozer

Last week was the fourth anniversary of the Killdozer, pictured below.

I don’t actually remember this at the time, so was intrigued to read the background. Basically a Marvin Heemeyer was peeved with the local Council over zoing dispute so he created the Killdozer – a bulldozer with steel and concrete.

The armor was one foot thick in places with with concrete sandwiched between steel sheets. This made it resistant to both small arms fire and even most explosives.

The Killdozer was armed with a .50 caliber semi-automatic Barrett M82 sniper rifle pointing out to the rear, a semi-auto FN FNC assault-rifle pointing out to the front, a .223 Ruger Mini-14 to the right, a 9mm Kel-Tec P-11 semi-auto pistol and a .357 magnum revolver.

Heemeyer did $7 million of damage destroying 13 buildings. Finally it got stuck and he killed himself. It took 12 hours for people to cut through the armor to get his body out.

I can’t help wondering how big one would need to take on the Beehive 🙂

Alberta Campaign Finance Laws

An interesting article in the Edmonton Journal, a reader e-mailed to me.

The Government there is planning to bring in laws to restrict third party campaigns. And it is a Conservative Government doing so. Why?

Albertans for Change was a union-backed effort that ran splashy election advertising attacking the Stelmach government’s record. The ominous voice accusing Stelmach of having “no pla-a-a-a-n” was easily the most recognizable refrain of the campaign.

The exact cost of the ads – which were supported by the Alberta Building Trades Council, the Alberta Federation of Labour, the Alberta Union of Provincial Employees, the Health Sciences Association of Alberta and the United Nurses of Alberta – has never been made fully clear, but estimates have pegged it at over $2 million, more than double the NDP and Liberal budgets combined.

Just like in Australia – the biggest spenders are the unions. And they spent twice as much as the two actual left wing parties themselves.

So is the Government right to try and ban such a campaign? Well I note the campaign was unsucessful:

“It’s something that really piqued my curiosity during this last campaign, though I believe the strategy backfired on whoever came up with the idea,” Stelmach said of the campaign.

And the unions are not happy:

AFL President Gil McGowan accused Stelmach and the Conservatives of trying to muzzle its opponents with the new laws.

“This is a disturbing development and it doesn’t bode well for democracy in this province,” McGowan said. “He’s just trying to shut down the voice of the labour movement as a voice of dissent on the left.”

Which is very bad. Shutting down chinless scarf wearers though is very good.

And with further comparisons to NZ:

Alberta Liberal Leader Kevin Taft said the Albertans for Change ads may have actually hurt his party.
“We had nothing to do with that spending whatsoever,” Taft said. “And yet, on the doorsteps, we were often getting lectures about how ‘you guys are running those terrible attack ads on Ed Stelmach.’ So we got dragged into it.”

Yes if a third party campaign spends too much money or is too aggressive, it often harms the party they are trying to support. You see voters have a degree of intelligence.

Ralston on Hippos vs Greens

Words fail me

The Herald on Sunday reports on paedophile Graham Capill:

Before being sentenced, Capill emailed friends arguing that sex with one victim was “consensual” and he hoped to be released a third of the way into his sentence.

But supporter and Richmond New Life Church elder Chris Baigent told the Herald on Sunday that was no longer Capill’s view.

It never is as parole hearings loom.

There had been some talk his offending could be categorised as “adultery” but that was more people twisting the situation rather than any view Capill held himself, Baigent said.

I think words fail me.

Capill kept in regular touch with his wife and she and some of his children were regular visitors to the prison.

“She is standing alongside him all the way. She has kept the family going and he will be welcome back into the marriage relationship when he gets out,” he said.

“The younger children miss him terribly. They are really neat kids – you couldn’t wish for a better family of kids.”

Words fail me even more.

Baigent said that two of Capill’s older children had got married while he was in prison, which had been “really tough” for the former Christian leader who wasn’t able to attend the weddings.

And am now in stunned silence.

McCarten on Labour’s lack of friends

Matt McCarten looks at the minor parties, and concludes it may be Labour, not National, that has no friends when it comes to coalition options:

However, the ultimatum by Winston Peters and Peter Dunne – that they would not support a Labour-led government if the Greens were in it – set up the situation where Labour’s hegemony of the minor parties would ultimately fracture. …

Once Clark had dismissed the Maori Party as the “last cab off the rank”, the Greens were screwed. Labour went for the short-term, expedient deal, which, at the time, seemed a master stroke. It kept the Cabinet and, by offering Peters and Dunne ministerial portfolios outside Cabinet, had a comfortable parliamentary majority. The Greens had no choice but to take a few crumbs as a consolation prize. …

At the time, Greens co-leader Rod Donald was devastated at what he thought was a betrayal by Labour. The current leadership, after Donald’s untimely death shortly after the election, understood clearly that they would not be put in the position of Labour’s footstool again. …

So we are in an ironic position where Labour needs loyal electoral allies. The Maori and the Green parties, which Labour will need to survive, are hedging their bets.

Labour’s decision to do a deal with NZ First and United Future has come back to haunt them. Neither is politically viable and won’t survive when their leaders retire. The Green and Maori parties, which will survive long term, were alienated and are now taking their revenge.

On election night, Clark may well find herself in the same position as National three years ago. Key will have many coalition options and Clark none. The irony is that her political isolation will have been self-inflicted.

I still think when push comes to shove, the Greens will fall in behind Labour, no matter what. But the Maori Party will genuinely not make their mind up until after the election. ACT and United Future are showing a clear preference for National and NZ First has said it will negotiate first with the largest party. Now that is no guarantee of a successful outcome, but Peters would be wary of putting back into office an unpopular party rejected by the electorate.

What does it take to not get bail?

There is a legitimate debate about when someone does or does not get bail, as people are innocent until found guilty. But as it can take well over a year for someone to come to trial, you need some ability to protect the community until the trial, if there is a significant risk of further offending.

Now I can’t think of much of a better case for no bail than this one of Bernard Long:

  • Found with 30 guns including sniper rifles, pistols and an AK47
  • Charged with careless use of a firearm and engendering public safety after aiming laser sights all day at various people on boats
  • A gun with laser sights was found in an insecure state, with rounds in the magazine
  • Several other fully loaded magazines were found
  • Has a previous conviction for running over a paua driver in his boat

So he has a history of harming others, he has 30 guns in his house, some of them are loaded, and he spends his nights aiming them at people with the laser sights. Yep a perfect candidate for bail.