Firefighter dies in action

The SST has the sad news that one of the firefighters caught in a factory explosion in Hamilton has died. He was senior duty officer Derek Lovell.

When I heard about the death, I reflected that it was the first time in at least a decade I could recall a death in the line of duty. And in fact according to the SST it has been 24 years since a fatality in 1984.

Let us just hope Lovell’s colleagues recover. Two of them are in critical condition, and another three seriously injured.

Gay Geek Dinner in Wellington

Mugabe clings on

Mugabe is fighting on and back to his usual tactics of intimidation.

Despite there being no release of election results, there will be a run-off election for President.

No doubt they have not released the count from the first round because they are already counting the votes for the second round.

I predict Mugabe will be declared to win a narrow victory – say 52% to 48%.

A picnic table to be avoided

An amusing news report:

Police said a neighbor in Bellevue videotaped Art Price having sex — termed as “relations” — with his picnic table on four separate occasions, WEWS-TV in Cleveland reported.

It wouldn’t be illegal if he had put the umbrella in the right place to block views!

Interesting Conference the PM is at

A very very slow news day

My God.  TV3 News just spent almost six minutes talking about a lotto draw tonight. I mean seriously – six whole minutes, and in the first segment.

They even had it ahead of the China FTA, the latest on Zimbabwe, the anniversary of the killing of Martin Luther King and the banning of birthday cakes in a school.

Entitle Me

The Ruminator

Virtual Sports Site

SPCS argues for a lower rating

The Society for the Promotion of Community Standards is most well known for arguing that ratings on films are not tough enough. But today they are reported as arguing for children aged under 16 able to see a film showing a group of Christian missionaries speared to death by an Ecuadorian tribe.

Unarmed Police?

Good detective work

More Labour Candidates

The Herald reports that to help counter the under-representation of unionists in Labour’s caucus, CTU Secretary Carol Beaumont will be the likely Labour candidate for Maungakiekie.

They also mention that Jacinda Ardern and Raymond Huo are expected to get good list rankings. Ardern is London-based.

At some stage I will set up a list of list-only candidates for parties also, to complement the list of the major electorate candidates.

Excellent Service

This is what I like about blogging.  I blogged about the John Adams mini-series in the US. The next day a book store e-mails me with a link to a book they have on John Adams. It happens to be the book the TV series is based on.

I order the book online, and it arrives the next day. Excellent service from Book Haven. And a lot faster and cheaper them importing from the US.

Paul Quinn wins in Hutt South

Congratulations to Paul Quinn, who has won the Hutt South nomination for National.

Paul will be a strong contender (but amongst many) for the List also.

Paul is an experienced company director and principal of his own strategic planning and commercial advisory services company.

He is most well known probably as a former Captain of the NZ Maori and Wellington rugby teams. Paul is also a current board member of the NZ Rugby Football Union.

US Polling

Whoops

The PM’s Office meant to send this to all Labour MPs, but accidentially sent it to all MPs in all parties:

From: xxxx <[email protected]>
To: Labour Elect Offices, All MPs-All
Sent: Fri Apr 04 14:42:56 2008
Subject: April 1 pack – destroy any mockups of April flier

Hello All

The final version of the small, red, April 1 fliers have Mike Smith’s authorisation on them.  They are safe for distribution, however some of you may have an A4 mock-up of the April 1 flier amongst other material in the white MP packs for 1 April

Please destroy these.  They did not have the mock up on them.  Also for added safety they should not be photocopied – regards xxxx

<name deleted>
Senior Communications Advisor
Office of Rt Hon Helen Clark

Now is that Mike Smith’s home address or work address on them, and will they be including these taxpayer funded election advertisements in their expenses return?

Parallel campaigning made easier

The Electoral Commission has decided that only natural persons (individuals) rather than legal persons (which includes organisations) can be found to be ineligible to be registered as third parties, and has approved the third party registration of the EPMU. This means that any person or persons, no matter their political involvement, can become a third party by forming an unincorporated society, a company, or an incorporated society.

Due to that decision, based on Crown Law advice, they have not made any decision on whether the EPMU is involved with administering the affairs of the Labour Party. My arguments on the issue are here.

I obviously think their decision is wrong, because it massively undermines one of the stated intentions of the Electoral Finance Act, which is to stop parallel campaigning. This has opened up huge loopholes, as both incorporated and unincorporated societies can now register as third parties regardless of their involvement in a political party.

ACT on Campus could arguably register now as a third party as one example. But it goes way beyond that. One could set up an unincorporated society called the National Future Club. Its membership could be the entire Board of Directors of National, and it could register as a third party and spend $120,000 on election ads (so long as they do not endorse a political party).

In fact just two people can form an unincorporated society. Helen Clark and Michael Cullen could form the Labour Leadership Society and that would be eligible to register as a third party under this ruling.

Another example is that the six Wellington candidates for National could form a group called “Wellington needs National”. That group could register and run a campaign attacking Labour’s politicisation of the public service, without it counting towards the spending cap of National, or of themselves as candidates. It could spend $120,000 campaigning against the Labour Party and its candidates ($4,000 cap per candidate) in Wellington.

So the ruling basically removes significant teeth from what was the stated main intention of the Act. I find it bizarre. I personally have no objection to the EPMU being able to campaign in election year. My target is the law, not the EPMU. I would in fact have no restrictions (except those of transparency) until the last 90 days. This decision will probably make things less transparent though as organisations (who do not have to reveal their membership publicly) will be formed to be able to register.

The ruling is based on an opinion from the Crown Law Office, which also famously declared that the original Electoral Finance Bill did not breach the Bill of Rights – an opinion very strongly disagreed with by the NZ Law Society and Human Rights Commission. I say this not to criticise them, but to point out their opinions are obviously not beyond dispute.

Ironically this takes us closer to the United States situation of campaign finance. Over there restrictions were put on how much could be donated and spent by political parties. This has seen the growth of 527s which can run their own campaigns, and much of the money has flowed to them. And which group was the (off memory) second largest 527 on the centre right side in 2004? It was the College Republicans who raised and spent US$13 million.

Even though I disagree with the decision, I make no suggestions of bad faith by the Electoral Commission in making their decision, and would ask others to refrain from doing so. But having said that, I am reserving the right to test this issue in court, because the electoral agencies do not always get it right. In fact the Tauranga electoral petition found several areas in which the official advice from the electoral agencies was wrong. So did the earlier Wairarapa electoral petition.

My thanks to the Electoral Commission for an advance copy of their decision.

How they came up with the logo for the Beijing games

General Debate 4 April 2008

Three to Thirteen Minutes

The Telegraph reports:

A survey of sex therapists has concluded that the optimal amount of time for sexual intercourse is three to 13 minutes.

The findings, to be published in the May issue of the Journal of Sexual Medicine, strike at the notion that endurance is the key to a great sex life.

However, the time does not count foreplay, and the therapists did rate sexual intercourse that lasts from one to two minutes as “too short”.

 

One minute? Is that even possible? Maybe when you are 16!

McCain on Letterman

The video above shows John McCain responding to Letterman’s hassles about his age. Very funny.

Later in the show he is interviewed more seriously, and talks about how the Republicans partly lost in 2006 because they let spending get out of control, and uses as an example they authorised $3 million for the study of DNA of bears in Montana. He then quipped he didn’t know whether this was a paternity issue, or a criminal issue. Audience loved it.

Hat Tip: Rob Good

Zimbabwe looking bad

Third Party Eligibility

The Electoral Commission will release next week its decision on whether the EPMU is eligible to be registered as a third party, under the Electoral Finance Act.

I have deliberately been refraining from comment on the substance of the arguments, as I don’t think it is a good look to be trying a case in the media, at the same time as a quasi-judicial body is determining the issue. But as they have now made their decision (just not released it), I think it is appropriate to  make public the points I have advocated, so that they can serve as background information for when the decision is released.

My original letter is here.

Over the break, is a copy of my follow-up letter. It speaks for itself, and I’ll comment further once the decision is known and made public.

Continue reading »

Espiner on Electoral Act breaches by Labour

Colin Espiner has a blog post and an article on the breaches of the Electoral Act by Labour.

I was interviewed on ZB late yesterday afternoon about this. I seem to be the only person defending the decision of the Electoral Commission to warn rather than refer to the Police, in regard to Labour’s breach of the Act.

Colin in his blog says:

 

There’s a certain poetic justice to the news that Labour breached its own Electoral Finance Act with the distribution of a pamphlet boasting the Government’s achievements that did not carry the correct authorisation.

This draconian and extremely complex new law was rammed through Parliament by Labour late last year, and we all suffered through many lectures from Justice Minister Annette King about the “common sense” new regulations and how the Electoral Commission wouldn’t prosecute where offences were “so inconsequential there is no public interest in doing so.”

So who’s the first party to break the new law? National, which railed against it? Nope, Labour. It might be only a minor breach – not putting an authorising agent’s name on the brochure. But hey, a breach is a breach and there’s plenty of egg on Labour faces today. …

Cullen talks of the good advice the commission has handed down to all parties, a timely warning about being careful to dot the i’s and cross the t’s, but the simple fact remains that Labour broke the law and it’s not going to be prosecuted. Again.

Any of this sound familiar? There are a couple of precedents. Such as, ooooh, off the top of my head, the $400,000 pledge card illegal expenditure, which the police decided was illegal but decided not to prosecute because it wasn’t in the public interest.

Then there’s the police decision not to prosecute Trevor Mallard for punching Tau Henare, not to prosecute the Prime Minister over the speeding motorcade, not to prosecute David Benson-Pope for bullying, and not to prosecute the Prime Minister over Paintergate.

Meanwhile, National MP Shane Adern gets prosecuted for driving a tractor up the steps of Parliament and Nick Smith for contempt of court.

The commission decided in its ruling to let Labour off with a warning and to refer any future breaches (most likely by other parties) to the police. That’s certainly very lucky for Labour, and the problem is the commission risks looking like a Government toady for not having a little more backbone.

Certainly National can be frustrated that once again, Labour appears to have got off scot free. “Do as I say, not as I do” seems a fairly apt expression here.

Indeed, it is the hypocrisy rather than the lack of referral to the Police which is the issue for me.

Then in Colin’s article:

The Government has been left red-faced by an Electoral Commission ruling that it breached its own controversial Electoral Finance Act by distributing pamphlets without the correct authorisation on them.

Labour got off with a warning, however, after the commission decided not to refer the matter to the police.

Cullen said the Electoral Finance Act provides a very broad definition of what election advertising was.

The pamphlet contained “simple statements of fact” about what the Government had done.

What I love is Dr Cullen almost complaining that the Act provides a very broad definition of what election advertising is, as if that had nothing to do with him or the Government.

Meanwhile Audrey Young Mike Houlahan works on what may be the bigger issue. Does the taxpayer funded booklet have to be included in the party’s expense return?

Yesterday Dr Cullen indicated that he believed such literature was exempt from the expenses returns set out under the Electoral Finance Act. He told Parliament two different forms of legislation governed whether taxpayer’s money could be spend on election adverts. “The Parliamentary Service Act governs what members of Parliament can spend money on. The Electoral Commission determines what is election advertising.

“Matters that are properly authorised as being for parliamentary purposes do not count as election advertising for the returns of expenses.”

However, Electoral Commission spokesman Peter Northcote said unless a booklet such as We Are Making A Difference was being handed out by a Member of Parliament in their capacity as an MP, it would count towards election expenses.

“Just because something is funded by Parliamentary Services does not automatically mean that exemption applies,” Mr Northcote said.

If Labour’s financial agent does not include the cost of that booklet in their election return, then they should expect to be defending that decision in court.