New Zealand Business Council for Sustainable Development

The Herald on Sunday has an article by Peter Neilson.  Peter, a former Labour MP, is the Chief Executive of the New Zealand Business Council for Sustainable Development.  He refers to polling in the article:

New polling shows some fascinating coalition and policy combinations are possible this year….

And among all voters, Green is the most-favoured coalition partner for National and Labour, so a betting person would say John Key will need to stitch up a deal with the Greens.

Now which polling is this? One presumes it is their inhouse polling done under the brand name ShapeNZ.  ShapeNZ is not an independent company, but is run directly by the Council.

Now this is in itself nothing wrong.  It can be very logical and cost efficient for an organisation to do its own market research.  But one does have to be very careful about referring to such research.  Neilson should have referred to the fact the research was (presumably) done by his own organisation, rather than just generically refer to “polling”.

ShapeNZ use online surveys to gather information.  Now again, this is not necessairly a bad thing.  Many market research companies use online surveys for certain clients.  However if the research you are doing needs to be a random representative sample of all adult NZers (such as for political polling) then online surveys can be problematic.

In the UK, You Gov, has managed to produce consistently reliable poll results using online samples. To be successful you need to build up a very large base of people who are willing to take part in your surveys.  For example if you need 1,000 responses for a survey, then you need to get tens of thousands in your database, so you can get enough responses each time, and so they are not always the same 1,000 people and also so you can check it is balanced by gender, age, geography, income etc etc.

You also need to provide prizes or points which can be redeemed for prizes as an incentive for people to take part.  Otherwise you only get responses from those motivated by the issue.  And already you have problems in getting a representative sample as very poor families may not have Internet access and very wealthy people are probably not very motivated to take part in a survey so they can gain a $50 prize or equivalent.

Now these are not impossible to overcome.  You Gov does it well.  But as far as I know, none of the big companies in NZ use online polling for published political polling – they all use phone polling which is still the industry standard. Some of them are doing some political polling over the Internet but are not publishing the results.  My assumption is they are either trialling the technology to see how it compares to their phone polling, or it is research for a private client.

So ShapeNZ’s use of online polling on political issues is not unheard of, even though it is rare.  But there is one major difference which I think undermines the reliability of their results.

Other polling companies recruit people to their online panels trough their phone and postal surveys, plus their websites.  They are already dealing with a fairly mixed and balanced group of NZers through their work for other clients.

However ShapeNZ works only the New Zealand Business Council for Sustainable Development, as they are part of it.  I suspect many of their online survey panel members have come from those who have been visiting their website.

And here is the problem – you probably have a self-selecting sample. Those who are interested in green, environmental and sustainable issues are not the same as the total population.  Hence it is no surprise that a majority of respondents would pick the Greens as the most favoured coalition partner for National.

Now ShapeNZ probably does its best to mitigate by, for example, balancing the sample based on party vote.  So they may have a sample which is 40% Labour, 38% National etc so they can say it is the same proportion as the last election.

The problem with this though, is that not all National voters are the same.  There are “green” National voters and (for example) National voters who think climate change is  vastly exaggerated.  And the ShapeNZ survey probably only captured “green” National voters as the other sort would probably never have been visiting their website.

So overall I would be very suspicious of the poll results Peter Neilsen refers to.  Of course this is based on assumptions because he hasn’t said where these results come from.  Ideally he should make the full results public so they can be judged in context, rather than just refer to “polling”.

Mt Hillary

Open Source Software

Don Christie has a look at the politics of open source in NZ.  He finds a wide range of support for open source software from Rodney Hide to Nandor Tanczos, and in the blogosphere from myself to The Standard.

My original support for open source software tended to be more grumpiness at the price of propriety software.  But in recent years it has been far more admiration of the innovation it encourages.  Firefox and WordPress are both great examples of this, with hundreds of cool plugins produced by third parties.

The e-govt unit of SSC is pretty open source friendly and many online projects use open source software.  However as far as I know, open source is not used for the core functions of any Government agency.

One or two European countries have, if I recall correctly, taken most of their Government away from a Microsoft platform to an open source platform.  I think it is highly unlikely that would ever happen in NZ.

However what would be a useful thing to do, would be to have say one or two small Departments or Ministries (such as Consumer Affairs or Youth Affairs) move to an open source platform for say a period of at least three years.  Then at the end of the three years, one could do a cost vs benefit report of how it went, which could be considered by other parts of Government.

There would be undoubted challenges, such as staff familiarity with software, training, compatibility etc.  But they might not be as large as people think.

20 out of 24 ING Kiwisaver funds losing money

ING, one of the default KiwiSaver providers, has had 20 of its 24 KiwiSaver funds lose money in the first six months, reports the Herald.

Now this is only over a very short time period, but it is worth remembering that these funds are not government guaranteed.

I’ve gone with Fisher Funds.  The advice that a financial advisor gave the staff at my company was that whatever you do, never go with one of the IRD default schemes as the long-term rate of earnings on them is not much better than sticking it in the bank, and the difference between them and a higher growth fund is massive over a 30 to 40 year period.

The Himalayan Trust

42 days jail for tagging

Well done Greenpeace

Quoting this Dom Post story:

Greenpeace spokesman Dave Walsh said the organisation had a long history and core principle of non-violence, and would continue to maintain those morals in all its actions.

“We know that Sea Shepherd also consider themselves non-violent and consider ramming other ships at sea to be non-violent, but we do not agree with their definition of non-violence,” he said.

“The sea, particularly in the Antarctic, is a difficult and harsh environment and although we will continue to take calculated risks ourselves to protect whales, we will not place the lives of others at risk. We are here to defend the whales, not attack the whalers.”

Indeed, claiming ramming a ship to be an act of non-violence is ridicolous.

Three Hillary editorials

The Dom Post:

Icon is a word that has been diminished through overuse. It is applied to anyone with even a wisp of fleeting fame. Sir Edmund Percival Hillary was one of the very, very few it can be applied to with justice. He will remain an enduring symbol of what is good in New Zealand

The Press:

Sir Edmund Hillary was the greatest New Zealander…

Sir Edmund Hillary will be remembered and celebrated in New Zealand and around the world as one of an elite band of people from any country and any age who have reached the pinnacle of human achievement. He was a widely loved and truly remarkable New Zealander whose like we may not see again.

NZ Herald:

On the cusp of the technological revolution, “Ed”, as he liked to be called, and Tenzing had surmounted one of the great challenges remaining to man. Fifteen previous expeditions had tried and failed.

The achievement placed him in the company of the renowned explorers and adventurers who had gone where no other had gone before – the likes of Columbus, Livingston, Amundsen and Lindbergh.

Useful suggestions sought

Any useful (ie sensible) suggestions for a good 30th birthday present for someone?  Has to be suitable to posting to Germany.

She is a trade union lawyer, who lived here for a year as a student, when we became great friends. I want something memorable, maybe something Kiwiish but not necessarily so. Not a photo or portrait of Wellington though as she has lots of those already!

Cost not a big factor, but don’t want to go over the top.

Global Coverage of Hillary death

Google News has 1,440 stories already published on the death of Sir Edmund. It is the lead story on the CNN site.

I do hope the Government offers a state funeral. It would be most appropriate and would give people locally and internationally an opportunity to pay their respects.

I imagine a senior member of the Royal Family would attend on behalf of the Queen.

UPDATE: The family have accepted the offer of a state funeral. Details next week.

RIP Sir Edmund Hillary

They have just announced that New Zealand’s favourite son, Sir Edmund Hillary, has died this morning aged 88.

His passing will be mourned around the world. He is unique in being the only Knight of the Garter, which is given at the personal discretion of the Queen and limited to 20 worldwide, who was not awarded it for government or royal service.

He is also near unique for being featured on the bank notes of a western country, while still alive.  Apart from monarchs, this is almost never done in case they later do something inappropriate.

I expect his funeral service will be the largest NZ has seen in modern times.  A giant has truly fallen.

Another one joins the fight

Obama bid doomed

Yes Minister indeed

I try not to quote just from PRs directly, but this one nails it:

… a media statement issued by David Cunliffe yesterday, rejecting concerns about disability funding. Mr Cunliffe said ‘claims of a funding freeze totally inaccurate’.

Yet he goes on to say: ‘as an interim measure, per unit care costs have been stabilised to manage within budget’. He also says ‘cost of living adjustments have been postponed’.

“So it’s not a funding freeze but an interim stabilisation and a ‘postponement’?

That is Sir Humphrey at his best.  An interim stabilisation is very different from a freeze – oh yes.

Who will take NZ First’s money

An interesting story in the NZ Herald about NZ First wanting to still find a charity which will take their $158,000 “donation” in lieu of them reimbursing the taxpayer.

Three charities have said they would also say no.  They are:

  • Cancer Society
  • Child Cancer Foundation
  • New Zealand Red Cross

Now these are arguably the three biggest charities in terms of getting donations from the public.  I suspect it is no coincidence that they have decided that they risk losing more money by accepting the “donation”, than refusing it.

I was chatting on radio about this, this morning.  I think it is risky for NZ First to continue to refuse to pay it to the taxpayer. His best chance of making 5% is by campaigning on issues like them getting 1,000 more police etc, not defending his decision to donate money owed to the taxpayer to charity.

From a reader

A reader sent me this photo of a sign he has erected on his property.

protest.JPG

It is of course illegal. He says in his e-mail:

I don’t belong to a political party and never have

I also have never given any money to a political party The reason I am doing this solely because I am incensed by labours abuse of my rights

I am registered to vote and do vote. Therefore I should have the right to say and encourage others about any belief or thought that I may have without having to register the fact in an election year.

Iraq is doomed!

Kiwisaver more than 100K over target

KiwiSaver now has 380,000 signed up, vs forecast of 276,000.  This is no surprise – the moment they announced the compulsory employer contributions, I was sure there would be a significant take up rate.

I’ve signed up for KiwiSaver.  I get an employee and an employer contribution from the Government, as well as tax deductibility on the rest of the employer contribution. Turning down free money never makes sense to me.  Now that I needed to save more – I have been contributing to a super fund since I was 18.

The fact you have to opt out (not opt in) when you start a new job will make it de facto compulsory over time.  And that is when it will get interesting as to how it affects state super.

Should she be paying?

The Press has the story of Lee Brown who gets $255 a week from WINZ as a solo dad as he is looking after two kids during the day, while his ex wife works.  Now good on him for that.

$255 a week isn’t a lot.  He does also get a house for only $84 a week which is a significant subsidy (I’d estimate at least $150 a week less than market) and he is also working eight hours a week which is at least another $100.

I wonder if his ex wife pays him for looking after the kids during the day?  I mean she is presumably working fulltime.  If the roles were reversed you would expect a father who works fulltime to pay money to his ex wife if she is looking after the kids?

Now sometimes that money has to go to WINZ to as part-subsidy of the benefit.  But as far as I can tell he is not getting paid by WINZ for care of those two children, but for a third who is at school and presumably from a different partner.

I don’t think there is anything to criticise Lee Brown about.  He seems a very devoted Dad and is working part-time.  It’s more whether the mother who is working fulltime (presumably) should be contributing?  I suspect there would be little question if the roles were reversed.

The end is nigh ….

The Victorian and Queensland governments are evaluating a device that can automatically slow a speeding car using satellite technology.

I predict someone is going to get very very rich making and selling a device which over-rides that technology. Hell I think someone will get rich by setting up a bank account where people can make anonymous donations towards purchasing a surface to air missile which will knock the big brother satellite out of existence.

Hat Tip: Cactus Kate

So why were the New Hampshire polls wrong?

With 96% of precincts reporting, we have the following results:

Republicans
McCain 37.2%
Romney 31.6%
Huckabee 11.2%
Giuliani 8.6%
Paul 7.6%

Democrats
Clinton 39.2%
Obama 36.5%
Edwards 16.9%

Now what did the polls say? Since Iowa, there were six main polls. They were:

nhpolls.JPG

The sample sizes varied but all were at least 500 which is a margin of error of 4.5%.

Using the 500 sample size, the probability for each poll that McCain was actually ahead of Romney is in order 12%, 98%, 99.5%, 61%, 93% and 86%. So five out of six were predicting McCain and the sixth was close enough that it was saying there is a 10% chance McCain was ahead.

Now on the Democratic side, the six results were saying the chance of Clinton being ahead was 10%, 0.8%, 0.02%, 3%, 0.7%, 1%. So one out of six had some doubt about it, and five out of six were emphatic that Obama was ahead.

Overall the average of the six polls vs the actual is:

nhpollsumm.JPG

So the polls were not too bad on the Republican side.  McCain and Romney both did better than the polls said but the margin between them was within 2%.

On the Democratic side, they got fairly close with Obama.  The average was 39% and he got 37%.  Where they were far out was Clinton’s support at 39%.  The polls averaged 30% with a range from 28% to 34%.

So why did they get it so wrong? The fact every company got it wrong suggests we can ignore methodological differences between the companies.

One possibility is that those who voted were different to those who answered the poll. Now as you see in this Suffolk poll, they ask how likely people are to vote, and 96% were very likely so that mitigates that problem.  But if for example Clinton had a much better get out the vote machine, then that could be part of it.

Another possibility is the independents voted Republican rather than Democrat.  You see Clinton led in some polls amongst Democrats only, but Obama had a massive lead amongst independents.  However 43% of those who voted in the Democrat primary were independents so again that is probably not it.

A lot of people are looking at this.  Mystery Pollsters quotes the ABC Polling Director:

There will be a serious, critical look at the final pre-election polls in the Democratic presidential primary in New Hampshire; that is essential. It is simply unprecedented for so many polls to have been so wrong. We need to know why.

Next we look at the CNN exit poll.  It shows Obama beating Clinton by 11% amongst men – 40% to 29%.  However amongst women voters Clinton is 12% ahead – 46% to 34%.Mystery Pollster looks at the difference between exit polls and the pre-election polls and finds that support for Clinton was 17% higher amongst women in the exit poll than before.  So it may be as simple as women flirting with Obama and saying they will support him, but when they get to the booth, deciding to go with Clinton.

I could joke about women changing their mind, but that does seem to be the case.  Support for Clinton amongst men was only 5% higher in the exit poll than the pre-election polls.  That would not have been enough to win it for her.  It was the massive swing back of women voters it seems.

New Hampshire Results

Only 11% of precincts in (and they are probably the smaller ones) but Fox has called New Hampshire for McCain with 37% to 28% Romney. Huckabee 12% in 3rd, Giuliani 9% and Paul 8%.

Almost neck and neck on the Democrats side with Clinton 37% and Obama 36%. If it stays this close then the polls will have all been wrong, and presumably did not take account of Hilary’s get out the vote party machine. But only 11% counted. Remember last election here National led by 10% on the first results, and then lost by 2%.

UPDATE: 16% reporting and Clinton 40% to Obama 36%.

UPDATE2: Drudge has 26% reporting with Clinton 40% and Obama 35%. The gap is growing not shrinking. This could be a second Clinton comeback kid.

UPDATE3: Thanks to Stef for link to this site which is even ahead of Drudge. Clinton 39.5% to Obama 36.1% on 47% of precincts.

They also have actual vote count – 49,719 to 45,383.  Now in 2004 the Dems primary had 220,000 votes.  So far a bit over 120,000 cast.

Selling oneself on Trade Me

A unhappy bank employee is seeking a new employer by offering a year’s servitude on Trade Me.  He seems innovative:

I have no degree but I am yet to fail at a task given to me in the workplace.
“Do you know SQL?” I lied & read about it on the net that night. By the next day I was doing it for a living.

Current job not working too well:

My unfortunate lot currently is a manager who is going away for 3 months mid this year & will not allow me advancement as she needs someone to do her job while she is away (not for her pay though – dont be ridiculous!!). I would rather apply for a gun licence, wait my 2 weeks & then shoot myself in the face.

Flexible:

I am willing to do anything from flipping burgers to sorting recycling to credit analysis to event co-ordination to web site management to shaving nostril hairs…I really don’t mind. In fact, the worse the work sounds, the better the feeling will be when I say to my boss “Actually…I would rather be a sack back & crack guy for the salvation army beauticians then be the fall guy for 20,000 customers who whinge at me when your systems fail after I told you how to fix them”.

Hopefully he will get some bids.

Geniuses

I sarcastically attacked an NZPA story on the so called supressed MSD report and pointed out no one asked the Families Commission why it was not published, and linking to Lindsay Mitchell who basically said the report was rubbish.

So I was actually defending the Government from a media beatup.

But  the geniuses at Kiwiblogblog declare “Farrar’s comments are direct from National’s talking points”.  They really must have problems tying their shoelaces up if that is the quality of their analysis.

National’s talking points incidentally, which came out many hours after I blogged, are the absolute opposite of what I said.  I was clearly rubbishing the report while National is quoting approvingly from it.