Chorus, not Last Mile

The 2008 Heritage Index of Economic Freedom

The Heritage Foundation has released its 2008 Index of Economic Freedom.

NZ remains highly ranked in 6th place, however at 80.2 is just above the threshold of being “free” rather than mostly free.  We have dropped from 81.65 and 4th place in 2006. The number of countries in each band are:

  1. Free 7
  2. Mostly Free 23
  3. Moderately Free 51
  4. Mostly Unfree 52
  5. Repressed 24
  6. Not Ranked 6

So we should be proud to be one of the seven. Hong Kong is 1st on 90.3, Ireland 3rd on 82.4, Australia 4th on 82.0.  Of course we need to be very free and competitive to keep our standard of living.  As a very small and very geographically remote country we have a natural disadvantage which we need to work hard at, so we can keep pace with Australia for example.

The bottom country is North Korea on 3.0. Then Cuba 27.l5 and Zimbabwe on 29.8.

Amongst the top ten, NZ had the highest score of 99.9 for the business freedom category.   Only 60.5 for fiscal freedom though and 55.99 for government size (Hobng Kong is 93.07 here).  Corruption score of 96 is also highest in top ten which is good. Our category scores (and change from 2007) are:

  1. Business Freedom 99.9 (nc) 1st=
  2. Trade Freedom 80.8 (-3.2) 52nd
  3. Fiscal Freedom 60.5 (-0.9) 138th
  4. Government Size 55.99 (-0.46) 122nd=
  5. Monetary Freedom 83.67 (-0.89) 14th
  6. Investment Freedom 70 (nc) 18th=
  7. Financial Freedom 80 (nc) 8th=
  8. Property Rights 90 (nc) 1st=
  9. Freedom from Corruption 96 (nc) 1st=
  10. Labour Freedom 85.5 (-2.58) 12th=

The rankings are out of 156. So good in most areas except government size and fiscal freedom where we are near the bottom of the world.

One can get some interesting sub-category rankings.  For example:

  • Our individual income tax rank is a very low 111th
  • Corporate Tax rank is 115th
  • Weighted Tariff rank is 60th
  • Inflation rank is 55th
  • Days to open a business rank is 21st

Again we are in the bottom quarter of the world when it comes to freedom from high taxes.  We are just fortunate that most other things are very good.

Sea Shepherd antics

The mad captain of the Sea Shepherd is complaining that two of his crew have been detained after they forcibly boarded a Japanese whaling ship.

What the hell does he expect?  It’s a serious crime and hostile act to board a foreign ship without permission or authority.

And even worse they had allegedly been trying to throw bottles of acid onto the deck, and also trying to entange the screw of the ship using ropes.

I’m no fan of the hypocrisy of the Japanese on the whaling issue, but I’m even less a fan of the Sea Shepherd and its captain.

Oh dear oh dear

Domainz, like many websites, has a little program to deter spammers and automated registration bots.  They display a captcha which is a graphic of some letters, which generally only a human can read and type in (mind you I find a lot of spammers are getting good enough to get past them.

Stuart Parker has blogged the below screenshot from the Domainz site, which he got when trying to renew a domain name.

domainz.JPG

What are the odds?

Tim Blair has cancer

Hell.  Tim Blair has just blogged that he is having major abdominal surgery for cancer next week.

I absolutely adore Tim’s blog.  His wit is razor sharp, and I was really disappointed I didn’t get to meet him last year after we were both asked to speak at the CIS Consilium conference, but Tim couldn’t make it.

He has a huge readership internationally, as well as within Australia.  Mark Steyn at NRO’s The Corner talks about Tim with affection.

I, along with many thousands of others, will be hoping for a very successful outcome for Tim’s surgery.

An experiment

As an experiment (I’ll explain its purpose once it is done), I’m turning off blog comments for 24 hours from around 0000 to 2359 on Wednesday.

During that time, no comments will appear.  You can actually submit a comment but it will be held in a queue until I turn them back on.

Hope no one suffers too much withdrawal symptoms 🙂

TUANZ: Telecom Access Network Division to be called Last Mile

TUANZ’s downstream blog has learnt from a source that the name of Telecom’s new Access Network Division will be “Last Mile”.  The equivalent in the UK is “Open Reach”.

The access network division will have to use this brand rather than Telecom’s so itshould become quite well known.

We’ll find out tomorrow if the source as correct, but they sound confident.

School in 1960 vs 2007

Got sent this by e-mail from Aussie. As with most humour, has an element of truth to it:

School 1960 vs. School 2007

Scenario: Johnny and Mark get into a fistfight after school.

1960 – Crowd gathers. Mark wins. Johnny and Mark shake hands and end up mates.

2007 – Police are called, SWAT team arrives and arrests Johnny and Mark. Mobiles with video of fight confiscated as evidence. They are charged with assault, AVOs are taken out and both are suspended even though Johnny started it. Diversionary conferences and parent meetings conducted. Video shown on 6 internet sites.

Scenario: Jeffrey won’t sit still in class, disrupts other students.

1960 – Jeffrey is sent to the principal’s office and given a good paddling. Returns to class, sits still and does not disrupt class again.

2007 – Jeffrey is given huge doses of Ritalin. Counselled to death. Becomes a zombie. Tested for ADD. School gets extra funding because Jeffrey has a disability. Drops out of school.

Scenario: Billy breaks a window in his neighbor’s car and his Dad gives him a whack with his belt.

1960 – Billy is more careful next time, grows up normal, goes to college, and becomes a successful businessman.

2007 – Billy’s dad is arrested for child abuse. Billy is removed to foster care and joins a gang. Psychologist tells Billy’s sister that she remembers being abused herself and their dad goes to prison.. Billy’s mum has an affair with the psychologist. Psychologist gets a promotion.

Scenario: Mark, a college student, brings cigarettes to school .

1960 – Mark shares a smoke with the school principal out on the smoking area.

2007 – Police are called and Mark is expelled from School for drug possession. His car is searched for drugs and weapons.

Scenario: Johnny takes apart leftover firecrackers, puts them in a model plane paint bottle and blows up an anthill.

1960 – Ants die.

2007 – Security and ASIO are called and Johnny is charged with domestic terrorism. Teams investigate parents, siblings are removed from the home, computers are confiscated, and Johnny’s dad goes on a terror watch list and is never allowed to fly again.

Scenario: Johnny falls during recess and scrapes his knee. His teacher, Mary, finds him crying, and gives him a hug to comfort him.

1960 – Johnny soon feels better and goes back to playing.

2007 – Mary is accused of being a sexual predator and loses her job. She faces three years in prison. Johnny undergoes five years of therapy.

Wanted

If you have a semi-decent singing voice, have a sense of humour, and not a fan of the Government, can you drop me an e-mail if you might have a spare five minutes for a little project.

You definitely don’t have to be a professional, just sound better than William Hung.

The Republic Debate

Mike Moore writes in the Herald today on why NZ should become a republic, and the wider issue of having a constitution. He refers to the recent changes to the electoral laws, without bipartisan support, as an example of the status quo which he labels:

The present direction is visionless, dangerously ad hoc, short-term, and confusing. Democracy is about who runs the country. A constitution is about the limits of Government.

Constitutional change ought not to be rushed or hurried, and should only be entered into after deliberate, detailed and sober consideration, consultation and reflection.

Constitutional changes, which would inevitably include a move to a republic, would set some limits on Parliament and Government.  I am all in favour of that. Under the status quo the PM effectively appoints the Head of State (GG) unilaterally, and can sack the Head of State whenever they feel like it.

Moore concludes by saying:

New Zealand’s system is not in a desperate state of disrepute or disrepair – it’s not broken. But it could be further damaged by incremental changes.

This will be very difficult to navigate and avoid capture by entrenched interests. But we can, in the words of Abraham Lincoln, “still appeal to the better angels of our nature”.

Alas, without a formal process, we risk becoming a “banana republic” – without the bananas.

Now John Armstrong says Moore has chosen the wrong time, being election year, for such a debate:

If Mike Moore wants a debate on the wisdom of New Zealand becoming a republic or having a written constitution, he has chosen about the worst possible time to try to ignite one.

While the former Labour leader may cite the ad hoc introduction of new election finance rules as reason enough for a wide-ranging constitutional debate, there will be a distinct lack of enthusiasm on the part of most politicians to trample in what amounts to a political “no-go” area in election year.

However the NZ Herald editorial is more supportive:

Ten years ago, there appeared no particular yearning for change. Jim Bolger, the only politician of significance to have spoken in favour of a republic, probably did the cause no good by trying to force his own personal preferences on a country that showed little inclination to believe its time had come. It remains to be seen if Mr Moore’s concern, and warning of the danger of further seemingly modest incremental change, resonate sufficiently to encourage a change of heart.

Until now, New Zealanders have been content to allow matters to evolve in a manner far more natural than one embracing constitutional conventions and the like. If Mr Moore’s initiative gains traction, it will suggest an interest in more vision-based politics. It will also confirm that people sense, currently, the bigger picture is being overlooked. Either way, Mr Moore should be commended for raising this issue, especially in an election year. He is also right to note the importance of a planned approach. The process is, as he says, almost as important as the result.

The process is incredibly important.  Nothing would be worse than people feeling they are cut of the debate, and that the “elite” are dictating as to what should happen.

The dangers of parliamentary supremacy are not insignificant.  The power of constitutional conventions have been shown to be near meaningless to a Government bent on “utu”.  Muldoon in 1984 first showed us how fragile they were.  It was only the honour of people like Jim McLay which stopped that from becoming a crisis.  And we won’t always be so lucky.

Silly Frog

The Greens’ frog is having a rush of blood to his or her head.

Not only does it hysterically over-react to a call for the Iranian nuclear threat to be confronted, they breathlessly demand to know whether John Key will send troops to Iran.

First of all they seem to have conceded the next election, and assume Key will be PM. Now as this is not until probably Nov 15, some two weeks after the US elections, their hysterical scaremongering is based on the scenario that Bush will launch an invasion of Iran during his caretaker period as President.

Even putting aside their stupidity of timing, there is noone at all (except the Greens) talking seriously about invading Iran. Sure someone may drop a couple of bombs on their nuclear facilities (as Israel did to Saddam in 1979) but that is not the same as invading a country to topple its Government. And you know I can’t really see the US wanting to use our Hercules to drop bombs in the Middle East – it would take a week for them to even get there probably!

Not that I think conflict with Iran is remotely likely. Certainly not in 2008.

But I did find it interesting that Frog said:

Would he agree that Iran was “the world’s leading state sponsor of terror”? Many would say that the US was, citing their financial and technical support for Osama Bin Laden and Saddam Hussein prior to turning against them.

When Frog says “many would say” this is code for, “most in the Greens believe”. Their hysterical anti-Americanism is why Helen Clark keeps them out of office I suspect. You just can’t have people around the Cabinet table who actually believe the US is worse than Iran. The US is far from perfect with its behaviour and choices, but really someone should send the Frog to Iran to live.

Next the Greens will blame Stalin’s 20 million dead on the US, because hey in WWII they fought with Stalin as an ally, so hell that makes them responsible for everything he did since. Now NZ also fought as an ally of Stalin, so does that also make us responsible? Hell the shame, the shame.

Organ Snatchers!

NZ has a very low rate of organ donations, and one reason for this is because the explicit wishes of the person who agrees to donate organs in case of their death, can be ignored if a family member objects.

I think this is wrong in principle, and wrong in practice, as the end result is people dying because organs are not available for transplant despite the explicit consent of the person.

Andy Tookey and National MP Jackie Blue proposed a law change so the decisions of the deceased person can not be over-ridden by a relative but sadly the Government rejected the law change.

So we are at one extreme.  But in the UK, they have proposed, backed by PM Gordon Brown, going to the other extreme – every single person is deemed to consent to being an organ donor, unless they opt out.  They also will still allow a family member to object also. Already Brown is being painted as an organ snatcher.

I think this goes too far, and again it doesn’t recognise the right of individuals to make their own informed choices as to what should happen in the event of their death.

The state should only presume consent for adults in extraordinary circumstances.  In this modern age it is relatively easy to get people to make a decision themselves – NZ does it well through the driver licence system. But one shouldn’t take the absence of a response as consent.

So again my preferred position is no deemed consent, but no veto from relatives – the organs don’t belong to them – the wishes of the deceased should be respected.

Helengrad makes the dictionary

Heh, Helengrad has been listed as a word in in the latest edition of Australia’s largest online dictionary, says the Dom Post.

The dictionary reference is here:

Helengrad
noun NZ Colloquial (humorous) Wellington, seen as controlled by the government of Prime Minister Helen Clark. [Helen Clark + -grad common Russian ending meaning `town’]
 

I’m with Jim

Not often I agree with Jim Anderton, but he speaks sense on the issue of the call by the Greens for a public holiday for Hillary:

 Wigram MP Jim Anderton, the third-ranked minister in Clark’s Government, said he felt a public holiday would not honour Hillary’s memory and would set a bad precedent.

“I don’t think that that is appropriate. I don’t think he would want that. He showed no evidence in all his life that he would want to immortalise himself,” said the Progressive Party leader.

“He wanted to see his work continued. That was his strongest view and I saw that over and over. I don’t think we would be doing him any great service if we tried to somehow immortalise him.

“We have great New Zealanders. There have been a number of them and if we set a precedent that we are going to give holidays, where would you stop it?”

The idea of (re)naming a mountain still appeals to me.

Only 16% attend all youth crime meetings

The Dom Post reports that a highly touted youth crime prevention scheme has had some participants not bothering to attend meetings, and has failed to make inroads into youth crime rates according to a damning Justice Ministry report.

It goes on to say there had been only 16% had attended all meetings.  Now when I initially read this, I thought that meant only 16% of youth offenders had attended some sort of  rehabilitation meeting.  But no, it’s not even the prisoners failing to turn up, but the public servants!!

Six police officers for smacking complaint

The Press has the story of Jimmy Mason:

Professional musician Jimmy Mason flicked the ear of his son, Seth, at the Bridge of Remembrance just before Christmas after the three-year-old disobeyed his instructions while riding his new bike.

The toddler took off down a ramp and was followed by his brother, Zach, two, who was also on a new bike. Seth made the tight corner but Zach did not, and injured his eye.

“Seth just wanted to go on riding. He didn’t realise the seriousness of it with the youngest one slipping in and out of consciousness,” Mason said.

“So I turned to Seth and flicked him on the ear and told him to shut up while we fixed up the young one,” Mason said.

A nearby teacher took umbrage, an off-duty policewoman rang the incident in and in minutes later Mason was surrounded by six police officers.

“They were going to arrest me and were trying to ascertain whether it was safe for the kids to go home with me,” he said.

“It was pretty bizarre to tell you the truth.”

Mason said he took his sons biking every day and they needed to obey his instructions to the letter in order to stay safe.

“When I say ‘stop’ to the kids they have got to stop,” he said. “I said to the cops that I need to impress upon him (Seth) what he did was wrong and I need to impress it on him straight away and asked them how they suggested I do it.

“They didn’t know and I said to them, ‘Well, you’ve just told me what I did was wrong so you must know what is right’.”

Mason was not charged in the end, but given a formal warning which will go on his police record.

A formal warning is not an inconsequential thing, and it seems very unfair he has received one, on the basis of the facts outlined.  There maybe another side to the story, of course.

Also one has to ask why the hell do the Police send six officers in response?  A street brawl is unlikely to get that many!

Do robots have too much control?

Help the hungry Japanese

Sent by e-mail:

The Japanese government must believe their people are very hungry, otherwise they would not be hunting whales in the Southern Oceans.

To assist our Japanese friends, we propose to send packets of instant noodles to Japan to save the whales from being eaten. To show the intent of these noodles, please attach a letter to the Prime Minister of Japan, Yasuo Fukuda, about the continued Japanese whaling in the south seas, and the world’s opposition to the wasteful and unneeded slaughter of whales.

Individual noodle packets can be sent to:
Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda
1-6-1 Nagata-cho
Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 100-8968
JAPAN

I wonder how many packets they will receive.

The quarter million toilet

Minto on property rights

John Minto has an opinion piece in the Herald responding to Mike Moore’s piece on alleviating poverty.  Minto, of course, disagrees.

The US has the highest levels of poverty in the Western world (more than 30 million) despite one of the highest per capita incomes in the world. Why would this be?

Minto is not talking about absolute poverty here, but relative poverty.  The bottom 10% of the US still have an average income massively higher than most in the third world.

In fact, 46% of those “in poverty” in the US, actually own their own home.  The “relative poverty” line in the US in 2006 is US$10,488 or around US$30 a day.

The World Bank defines extreme poverty as less than $1 a day and moderate poverty as less than $2 a day.

In East Asia, the proportion living on under $2 a day has fallen from 69% in 1990 to 27% today.

How-ever in Sub-Saharan Africa, those living in extreme poverty, less than $1 a day, has increased from 41% in 1981 to 46% in 2001.

Now this is not to say that that things are perfect in the US – far from it.  But the difference between $30 a day and $2 a day is massive.  So Minto’s rejection of “property rights” as helping poverty is nonsensical.

Moore has come to the conclusion that it is the absence of enforceable property rights that lies at the heart of poverty. This has done no good for those living in poverty in the US or New Zealand but apparently he believes it will do wonders to drive poverty from developing countries.

The opposite is true. Property rights are there to benefit the wealthy and the middle class. They mean much less, if anything, to people in poverty.

One just has to look at China, and see the massive uplift of people out of poverty, as they have moved from an economy where people have no property rights, to one where they now have a significant rule of law relating to property rights.

There is a reason East Asia has lifted so many people out of poverty in recent decades, while Africa has got worse.  It isn’t coincidence.

2007 Darwin Awards

The winners of the 2007 Darwin Awards have been announced.

  1. The 21 year old couple found naked and injured on the road. Their clothes were found on the roof of a nearby building, which it seems they rolled off during sex.
  2. The 58 year old who couldn’t drink alcohol orally due to a throat ailment, so drank two bottles of sherry by way of enema.
  3. The 24 year old girl who stuck her head into a lift shaft to yell to people downstairs.  The lift came.
  4. The drunk 23 year old who not only hopped into the bear cage, but hopped in naked.

Been a few years since a NZer got nominated.

Capitalism’s bad PR

Peter Saunders from CIS writes on why capitalism is good for the soul, despite its lack of romantic appeal:

Capitalism lacks romantic appeal. It does not set the pulse racing in the way that opposing ideologies like socialism, fascism, or environmentalism can. It does not stir the blood, for it identifies no dragons to slay. It offers no grand vision for the future, for in an open market system the future is shaped not by the imposition of utopian blueprints, but by billions of individuals pursuing their own preferences. Capitalism can justifiably boast that it is excellent at delivering the goods, but this fails to impress in countries like Australia that have come to take affluence for granted.

It is quite the opposite with socialism. Where capitalism delivers but cannot inspire, socialism inspires despite never having delivered. Socialism’s history is littered with repeated failures and with human misery on a massive scale, yet it still attracts smiles rather than curses from people who never had to live under it.

Hat Tip: Tim Blair

Parker’s problems increase

We covered last week the affidavit from the former Chairman of the Electricity Commission, setting out under oath how David Parker interfered in their decisions.

The Herald on Sunday reports how Ministers will probably have to testify in court, and if they claim Hemmingway is wrong, well two of the other Commissioners are backing what he said.

Ralston swipes Duty Ministers