NZ First on Electoral Reform

A commenter yesterday pointed out a clause in NZ First’s 15 fundamental principles, which highlights their hypocrisy on the Electoral Finance Bill:

Electoral Reform

Electoral reform will be determined by the electors. The Government’s duty will be to ensure the fair representation of all views and the holding of appropriate referenda.

So consider this:

  1. The public had no notice before the last election of electoral law changes
  2. NZ First negotiated in secret with Labour on electoral law changes
  3. There was no public policy process to allow policy to be set on which the law was based
  4. Opinion polls (Colmar Brunton) have shown the majority against further third party restrictions
  5. The Human Rights Commission called for a second round of public submissions, which NZ First ignored
  6. The public will be restrained from criticising those who voted for the law, by the law.

So is that what NZ First calls having electoral reform determined by the electors?

Herald calls on Starship to give the money back

Winston’s stunt may be backfiring. The Herald editorial is blunt:

The Starship children’s hospital should immediately return the cheque it has received from the New Zealand First Party. This money is public property.

Mr Peters has not technically broken the law but only because he has used his party’s votes in Parliament to help legalise the spending at the last election that the Auditor-General believes to be wrong. He has always disagreed with the Auditor-General’s ruling and had wanted to contest it in the courts. But he has dropped this action, he says, because he could not have gotten a decision before the election next year and did not want to face the election accused of refusing to pay back “stolen money”.

This claim that they could not have got a hearing in time is one media should treat with suspicion.  The Auditor-General ruled in the latter half of 2006.  I have not seen anything to suggest that one could not have got a court hearing within two years.  For example the lawsuit against the Electoral Finance Bill only has a six month wait for a hearing.

The other point to remember is that there was a lawsuit which would have tested whether the Auditor-General was correct.  Darnton vs Clark.  With regards to the Labour pledge card at least, this would have resulted in a court ruling whether or not the expenditure was legal.

NZ First voted to kill off the lawsuit, voting against an amendment that would have stopped the validating legislation retrospectively killing off the lawsuit.

Shadbolt threatens Government

The Invercargill Mayor is quoted in the Herald:

Mr Shadbolt said a proposed $8 million cut for the institute would lead to a loss of 1400 students and be bad for the region.

“This is a direct attack on everything we’ve done and everything we’ve achieved in the last five years and we’re not going to stop on Friday and say, ‘Oh well, that’s the end of it’,” he told Radio New Zealand.

“There’s an election coming up and we’ll be doing everything we possibly can. We’re going to launch a campaign to bring down this Government if they are going to launch a campaign to bring down our province.”

Except sadly for Tim and Invercargill, their campaign will be limited to $120,000.

Deforestation

National has just done a press release highlighting the hypocrisy of David Parker preaching overseas about the need to end global deforestation, when their own policies in NZ have led to deforestation

“Deforestation in New Zealand will top six million trees this year. This comes on top of losses of three million trees in 2004, 2005, and 2006. New Zealand planted more trees than it felled for every year from 1951, when records began, until 2003.

Deforestation contributes to global warming, so goes totally against the rhetoric of carbon neutrality.  Anyway I thought I would make a graph out of the data with the PR about net planted forest area.

forests.JPG

Another case of all rhetoric, and no action.  Actually in this case it is worse than inaction.  Their actions have caused a 50 year trend of expanding forests to slow and then reverse.

Around the blogs

Electoral Finance Bill (not) to have third reading today

NZPA reported close to midnight:

… under a deal understood to have been worked out by MPs late tonight, there will be a break in the urgency motion for the Electoral Finance Bill to be debated for the last time tomorrow [now today].

When it has been passed, urgency will resume and the remaining bills dealt with. After that the adjournment debate will be held.

The arrangement will allow Parliament to adjourn for the long summer recess late tomorrow, avoiding having to come back after the weekend. Friday is not a sitting day.

I would expect the Governor-General to give royal assent to it on Friday, at which stage it will come into law. The regulated period will start on 1 January 2008, but the new laws around donations etc will come into force on the day royal assent is given.

UPDATE: It turns out there was no deal, and the House remains in urgency. When the bills put to urgency are finished with (might be today even) the House will rise and resume on Tuesday. I would expect question time from 2 – 3.30 or so, EFB third reading from 3.30 – 5.30 and then after the dinner break the adjournment debate.

UPDATE2: Have just had confirmed there never was any deal at all, that the media stories came from talk at the press gallery party last night. In fact as I understand it, the position of the leadership is that they are quite happy to still be debating the Electoral Finance Bill on Christmas Eve, and will not be making any deals to help the Government get it through quicker! I think it is great National have managed to succeed in not having the third reading until the week before Christmas.  If you’re not willing to give up some of your Xmas shopping time to fight a bill like this, then you don’t deserve Xmas! So well done Nats.

NZ First Tauranga says Kill the Bill

The Herald reports that the Tauranga electorate of NZ First passed a resolution calling on its MPs not to vote for the Electoral Finance Bill.

Party activist and executive member Ralph Maxwell said the executive comprised about 18 people. There was one abstention and one vote against the resolution. He said the bill was not supported within the party and that the caucus was supporting it because it would help their own survival.

Mr Maxwell may be wrong on one aspect.  The caucus support for the Electoral Finance Bill may in fact harm their chances of surviving the next election.

Stupid

The Manawatu Standard reports:

The man thought he was in for an early Christmas present when he got an alluring text offering him the friendly company of two young women.

They invited him around for some close attention, helpfully suggesting he get his gear off to save time. So off he went, reached the house, and threw his clothes through the front window prior to entering.

Trouble is, it was all a joke and the householder wasn’t two little lovelies pining for passion, but someone else altogether – who promptly called the police.

Seriously, how stupid (or horny) do you have to be to just walk naked into a house you’ve not been to before, merely on the basis of text messages?

Ridiculous

Another body snatching case

It’s sad that there has been another body snatching case.  Losing a family member is tough enough without having to put up with battles over the corpse.  The wishes of the deceased (who nominates a next of kin or executor) should be respected, even if you disagree.

The problem with the Police having failed to take action in the earlier case, despite explicit court orders, is that there is no incentive to obey the law now.  Yes it is nice if people obey the law just because it is the law, but for some that is not enough so you need a fear of punishment to act as an incentive.

If people saw some hefty fines, or worse, for people breaking court orders in relation to these matters, then they might not act quite so selfishly.

New Clerk of the House

Congratulations to Mary Harris on being appointed Clerk of the House of Representatives.  Not unexpected as she has been Deputy Clerk and Acting Clerk.  But it’s a key role, and hugely important.

Also worth noting is the appointment of a new General Manager of The Parliamentary Service – Geoff Thom.  Thom will be new to Parliament, having worked previously at the Commerce Commission.  He was at one time the manager of the Special Investigations Branch of the Royal New Zealand Military Police, so this may come in useful when trying to track down who actually was responsible for Labour’s pledge card 🙂

Charity Auction

Sell me Free has a kids xmas charity auction. You can bid for the stuff below, and the money goes to charity. Closes 19 December. 81 auctions in total.

  • 9 Pacific Island holidays
  • 9 domestic airfares
  • 17 longhaul airfares
  • 14 transtasman airfares
  • 4 tickets to the Sevens!
  • Weta Workshop Tour
  • Golf with Sarah Ulmer and Hamish Carter
  • Catch Up with Steve Williams on PGA Tour
  • A date with a Air NZ 767 pilot!! (women only)

A great cause with some good prizes.

NZ First paying back the money – but to Star Ship

I hear that NZ First have announced they are paying back the $158,000 – but instead of to the taxpayer – to Starship Hospital.

Assuming this is not a tax dodge (ie someone donating on their behalf who can claim a tax deduction) I can’t say I have huge issues with that – hell it just shows that not even NZ First trust Michael Cullen to spend their money wisely! 🙂

But let’s hope we do see proof of this, and that NZ First itself paid – not a donor on their behalf.

This still leaves United Future to pay back $50,000 or so.  Maybe they could take a break from getting misrepresenting the Electoral Finance Bill to pay their remaining $50,000 back.

How very flawed this law is

The committee stage of the Electoral Finance Bill is over, and the likely third reading is Tuesday 19 December 2007 – an entire three days before the effective holiday shut-down.

This is an opportune time to highlight some massive flaws in the Bill – not the deliberate flaws in cracking down on criticism, but the inadvertent ones which undermine the claims about stopping anonymous and trust donations and the Brethren.

You see as often is the case with any attempt to regulate election finances, the solution proves worse than the problem. Just look at McCain-Feingold in the US. And this Wired article (hat tip: Gonzo) and photo show what happens when you have bad law (and the EFB takes us much closer to US law – not further away)

ronmark.JPG

Here are some of loopholes the Government have introduced due to rushing this process, and being more concerned about advantaging Labour than having a good law:

One can still donate $250,000 a year anonymously

The worst thing about the Greens/Labour compromise to protect Labour’s anonymous donations is that they have said you can donate $1,000 anonymously to a party [Clause 25A(2)] and it does not have to be declared. They should have banned anonymity (which is different to non disclosure) for all donations except petty cash/raffle tickets etc.

You see someone could arrange for $1,000 a day to be donated anonymously through bank cheques. So long as they do not tell the party they are doing it, and the party does not know it is the same donor, then that money can be received and even worse not even disclosed. So $1,000 a day is $250,000 a year or $750,000 an election cycle.

This makes the law worse than the status quo. If someone wanted to donate $20,000 anonymously at present, they would simply make a one off $20,000 anonymous donation. And that donation would be disclosed on the party’s return – so the public would at least see they have received that $20,000, even if not from whom.

Now they are motivated to make 20 $1,000 anonymous donations over time, and the party takes the money, and the electoral commission don’t even learn about the donations, let alone have them count as part of the $240,000 cap. Again – I repeat – no one at all outside the party will know about these donations. The Electoral Commission and the public will have no idea if there have been 20 $1,000 anon donations or 1,500 $1,000 anon donations. It will be totally below the radar.

The way to avoid this was banning all non-trivial anonymous donations, but having a reasonable disclosure limit. But the desperation to protect Labour’s anonymous donations gives us this gaping loophole. They also could have fixed this by stating a person can not make multiple anonymous donations.
One can more easily give $66,000 and not be disclosed

Another loophole, brought about to protect Labour’s donors, is that you can receive not only up to $30,000 over three years [Clause 22A(1)(b)] in undisclosed donations from a donor, plus they can give $36,000 anonymously [Clause 28C(3)] through the Electoral Commission. This is because the law allows for both undisclosed donations and anonymous donations. So the Greens and Labour are allowing $66,000 to be donated to a party without the identity being known.

Trusts can still make donations

The bill which came out of the select committee had a huge gaping loophole in it. One could donate say $100,000 to Trust A, have Trust A donate it to Trust B and Trust B donate it to Party C. The only obligation was on Trust B to reveal Trust A gave it to them, and not on Trust A to reveal who they got it from.

Now this loophole got fixed at the last second (SOP 162) , but it is still relatively easy to still have trust donations – you just collect money from donors without guaranteeing (or having an understanding or agreement) to pass it on to a particular party or parties.

Here’s an example. You set up the Free Market Trust and the Trust (not any Party) seeks donors. It explains it wants to support free market policies in NZ and will use any money received for a variety of activities – it conducts some research, some advertising. The trustees of that Trust independently decide what proportion of their income gets spent on what. They may collect $1.0 million, spend $50K on admin, $80K on research, $70k on publicity and $800k on donations to parties with free market policies. If the Trust can pass a test that there was no knowledge or expectation from its donor, that the Trust would make a donation.

Trusts can donate from their earnings

Here’s another loophole. A trust collects donations. It invests all the donations it collects in various activities. Say they collect $2 million in donations. The trustees are smart people and get a 15% return of $300,000 a year on that money. They donate that $300,000 a year or $900,000 over three years to political parties. Now so long as they never donate the capital which in turn was donated to them, they should never have to disclose who their original donors were.

The Exclusive Brethren can still spend $840,000 or more

The Exclusive Brethren will be able to spend a million dollars again if they so wish. How? Because many of their members are rich, and even the main secret seven could register as third parties and spend $120,000 each which is a total of $840,000. Ten of them could spend $1.2 million.

The law stops one rich person giving money to six poor people, so that he or she can not spend $840,000 through proxies. But the EB tend to be wealthy business owners who can each spend $120,000.

And the secret seven could even run joint ads for a total of $840,000 – the EFB in Clause 105A(3) allows for ads to be apportioned between third parties. Yes the law specifically allows third parties to pool resources and run joint advertisements.

On the other hand – a reputable lobby group such as the Automobile Association is restricted to spending $120,000 on behalf of its 1 million members if it wishes to advocate for or against parties with motorist friendly policies. They can only spend 12c per member, while individual members of the EB can spend $120,000 each.

Lobby Groups can easily become parties

Because political parties only need 500 members, and they have much much higher spending limits, a number of lobby groups may become political parties so they can spend more than $3,000 a week on advocacy such as “Support parties who support Kyoto” or “Punish MPs who voted for the Electoral Finance Bill”. They will need to have at least one candidate but that won’t be a barrier.

Remember the section on donations was cooked up in secret between Labour and the Greens. They showed it to the Select Committee at the very last minute. Despite what the Greens claim, it is primarily about protecting Labour’s anonymous donations and the loopholes they have put into the law is actually going to drive anonymous donations underground so that the public won’t even know about them anymore.

They could have avoided many of these problems if they had adopted a principled approach and had proper public consultation on the policy principles for the Bill. That would have found widespread support for banning all anonymous donations, and a law could have been drawn up which reflected that. Instead though we have a shabby self serving law full of loopholes, and which will undermine, not enhance, the integrity of our electoral legislation.

Dim-Post: John Key Watches Third Season of Lost; National Surges in Polls

The Dim-Post gives us another edition:

John Key Watches Third Season of Lost; National Surges in Polls

Wednesday December 21, 2007

The results of the latest Dim-Post/U Will Kneelsoon polls show a strong surge for the National Party and place National leader John Key neck and neck with Helen Clark for preferred Prime Minister.

Transferred to seats in Parliament the National Party would be able to govern alone, a result that has delighted Key and his deputy leader Bill English.

‘John has been putting in a lot of hard work and that’s obviously paying off,’ English told the Dim-Post. ‘He’s been walking his dog, clocked the new Half-Life episode and he’s also watched an entire season of Lost on DVD this week alone. It’s been a tremendous effort.’

Key attributed recent successes to the strength of his team. ‘I couldn’t have done it without Murray [McCully] who walked up Molesworth St and rented me the DVD, or Simon [Power] who figured out how to play movies on my laptop. This is an amazing group of people and I’m proud to be their leader.’

Independent political analyst David Farrar credited the decision to watch Lost as the crucial factor behind Keys massive rise in popularity.

‘I think that voters respond to decisive leadership and the decision to watch Lost was obviously the right one,’ Farrar said. Any clear-thinking impartial observer would have to agree that John Keys’ flawless political instincts are almost God-like while a unbiased and objective analysis of the polling data suggests that Helen Clark secretly drowns kittens.’

The National Leader is understood to have watched all twenty one epsiodes of the show in under four days. Senior National sources indicated that Key also viewed some episodes more than once and spent significant time studying background details while the show was paused. He has also spent time on the internet fan site ‘LostPedia’.

‘The final episodes of season three left many unanswered riddles,’ Key told National party MPs at an improptu game of lawn cricket yesterday afternoon. ‘Who is Jacob and what was all that weird powder outside his cabin? How does Desmond’s girfriend Penny tie into what’s on the Island? And who was in the coffin at the funeral Jack attended? The Prime Minister cannot answer any of these questions, either because she doesn’t know or she doesn’t care. The people of New Zealand deserve better than that.’

‘Also what about that thing with Sawyer’s Father,’ Key added. ‘That was intense.’

Key denied that his decision to sit around in his bathrobe watching TV all day was a calculated political move. ‘Unlike the Labour Party, National is not poll driven,’ he said. ‘I am not catching up on my sleep and hosting Battlestar Galactica marathons because of polling data. I’m doing these things because I feel they are the right things to do.’

Talking of Battlestar Galactica, a few of us have been doing a Season Three marathon – this series is one of the best on TV – period. I’ve already watched Season Three when it aired in the US, but now am watching it again on DVD.  Season Four starts in early 2008 and will be the final season.

Field hearing in April

The Taito Philip Field depositions hearing will start on Monday 7 April and is expected to last for four weeks. Not bad timing – would have been nicer though a few weeks later so it was at the same time as the Budget.

He is defending himself against 15 charges of bribery and 25 charges of obstructing or perverting the course of justice.

Assuming it proceeds to full trial, any lawyers out there want to estimate likely trial dates of depositions is in April?

Another great piss-take

Oh a mate just found this on You Tube. I missed it at the time. This one is great. It was Ali Akram’s version on TV3’s Sunrise.

I’m having a big You Tube day – but so much good stuff out there. If only we had faster broadband for it all!

Hat Tip: The Standard for You Tubing it

Charles Ashe on Sustainability

Fisking the fisking of the fisking of the Greens

The Greens complained about the Herald’s editing of their 200 words on the Electoral Finance Bill. Graeme Edgeler fisked their 200 words (as did I)

Russel Norman has now fisked his fisking (and kudos to him for responding). And in response Graeme Edgeler has fisked the fisking of his fisking. I think Graeme is well ahead, as he resorts to that awful trick of quoting the clauses of the Bill.

One sad part though is when Russel plays the man, not the ball, and says:

Edge, I’m sure that you are not duped. You don’t support campaign finance reform. The right and the anti-greens are winning the PR spin, as you were sure to do with the Herald backing you.

Graeme is in fact a strong support of campaign finance reform.  His submission to the Select Committee on the Bill was quoted by officials more often than any other (I think I was second!).  He, like myself, supports the principles of more transparency and not having an arms race with fundraising.  I think overall he even supports the Electoral Finance Bill as an improvement on the status quo (I strongly disagree with him on that).  He just doesn’t like it when people get their facts wrong on what the Bill does or does not do.

But this shows the mindset of supporters of the Bill.  Anyone who points out its gaping flaws is an enemy and tool of the vast right wing NZBR/CIS conspiracy blah blah blah.

Some new blogs

Steven Price has set up a blog about media law and ethics.  He already has a dozen interesting posts up. Definitely being added to my regular reads.

Poneke has set up a blog, stating:

I’m a politically and socially aware Wellingtonian, a media professional of 20 years’ experience with catholic interests in such matters as urban  transport, climate change, Flight of the Conchords, civil society, the law, how well the news media serves the public and much more besides. Above all I am a skeptic, which is quite a different animal from a cynic.

This aim of this blog is to present a personalised, eclectic mix of essays with a literary journalism bent, media criticism and breaking news on important and not-so-important issues.

I suspect the blog will pull no punches.

The Hive is focused on Wellington and politics and the author appears to be well connected. Updated daily.

Shea Miller is blogging at New Freeland and looks at Public Address and the left blogosphere.  I disagree with the post to some degree, but will detail why in a seperate post at some stage.  But a very considered lengthy post worth debating, as people have been.

Three Point Turn returns after a long break. As biting as always. Welcome back.

A new version of the Key DVD

As expected, someone has done a satirical takeoff of the John Key DVD. I think their version also has copyright problems, but doubt anyone will complain.

Oh and the original John Key DVD (sans music) is here if people are looking for it.

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

Connell for NZ First?

Stuff has an NZPA story which speculates Rakaia MP Brian Connell may stand for NZ First at the next election.

Certainly Winston Peters was going on and on about David Carter’s selection as the Selwyn candidate a lot yesterday. But Peters hates Carter so it wasn’t that surprising.

Considering how strongly Peters has campaigned against people defecting parties, and in fact got a special law passed to allows such MPs to be expelled, the amount of hypocrisy involved if Connell does defect to Peters will be considerable.

Clark on Media

I suggested a few days ago that if Clark suceeds in getting a 4th term despite the Electoral Finance Bill regulating lobby groups, then her logical next target will be media regulation.  And keep that in mind when you look at her words on Monday:

She said there was little point complaining to the print media’s self-regulatory watchdog, the Press Council.

That just doesn’t get you anywhere.

Sounds like she would like a system where her complaints will get her somewhere and she doesn’t have to just “shrug and say, ‘Well, that’s life,’ and get on with it.” Her Foreign Minister has labelled journalists as traitors and rails against the media and their owners.  If he demanded media regulation as the price of support, do you think Helen would resist?

Anyway let’s look at her other views on the media:

“In the small political bubble that is Wellington, and particularly Parliament, people are far too close to each other, might establish habits of drinking far too much with each other, and getting too close.

” I don’t think that’s a good idea, and I make a habit of keeping professional boundaries myself.”

I don’t disagree with Clark here but no PM has ever been drinking buddies with the gallery – they’re far too busy generally. I actually don’t think there is any significant occurrence of MPs and journalists being drinking buddies – in fact I suspect Clark’s words were aimed at one particular journalist whom is out of favour with the 9th floor.

Helen Clark said “very few” journalists had a comprehensive knowledge of New Zealand’s international relations and few media outlets sent journalists to cover her international trips.

Here I very much agree. The gallery journalists themselves get pretty frustrated that their owners often won’t fork out for what should just be routine business – travelling with the PM.

Many journalists were young, and while this meant that they had “energy and a fresh perspective”, most of them had major gaps in their general knowledge.

Wow so the gallery are inexperienced and stupid! Colin Espiner counters this ageism rather grumpily for such a young fella 🙂

Helen Clark said media also needed to consider blogging by senior political reporters on the websites of major news outlets.

“Of course, if you commit yourself to instant opinion, then when it comes time to putting in a considered piece, you might think, ‘Whoops, that was a rush of judgment,’ but it becomes hard to climb back from.”

Heh in my experience if you get something wrong on a blog, dozens of frenzied comments point this out to you in no small manner.

I love the fact some in the gallery are blogging.  Audrey Young’s blog helped bring down David Benson-Pope.  The gallery blogs all provide really useful commentary and perspective on how members of the gallery are seeing events.

I think Clark is wrong to link blogging to instant reaction.  Often a gallery blog touches on an event after it has been running for a few days.  The blog gives a more blunt appraisal often than a newspaper column, and allows for direct reader feedback.

History will judge Bush a great President?

Scott Adams puts the case for placing George W Bush on Mount Rushmore one of the great Presidents ever.  The rationale:

President Bush famously promised to do something about the Axis of Evil: Iraq, Iran, and North Korea. That was a top priority. How’s he doing so far?

Iraq didn’t have any weapons of mass destruction, but by restricting inspectors, it acted as if it did. That is almost as dangerous as having a nuclear weapon because it causes your neighbor (Iran) to build its own nukes, just to be safe. It turns out they were doing just that.

Recently we learned that Iran stopped its nuclear bomb program in 2003. That’s about the same time the U.S. was disemboweling its next door neighbor based on the suspicion of having a nuclear weapons program. Iran probably noticed. History will credit President Bush for removing the threat of nuclear war from the Middle East.

North Korea has also discontinued its nuke program, thanks in part, history might acknowledge, because when the U.S. invaded Iraq, it went after the leadership first, including sons. That’s the sort of thing that gets your attention if you are a dictator. As with Reagan’s Star Wars defense plan, the U.S. under President Bush seemed crazy enough to attack North Korea. The threat was entirely credible. That, plus China’s pressure, neutralized North Korea.

Meanwhile, Libya surrendered its nuclear ambitions without even being asked. Credit President Bush for that one too.

Terrorism was a priority during the Bush administration. History won’t blame him for the first attack on 9/11, but it certainly might credit him for the fact no other attacks happened during his two terms. That’s a perfect record on homeland security.

Discuss: Is the theory correct?

A new sort of filibuster

National has played some very smart cards to delay the Electoral Finance Bill without launching a fullscale filibuster against it.

Hell if it was up to me, I’d file 30,000 amendments and as each one takes a minute to vote on this would add on 500 hours to the debate and they would conclude it in around 30 weeks time.  Sure the Clerk’s Office would never ever talk to you again, NZPA would send an assassin after you for forcing them to listen to 30,000 votes and the Whips would lose their voices, but it would effectively kill the bill.

But the smart people at National have gone for a much better option.  They are delaying the bill by actually debating it clause by clause.  They have organised their MPs so each MP can speak on seperate clauses.  This makes it very hard for the Committee Chair to take a closure motion when MPs can point to speakers who have not yet spoken, clauses not yet debated and amendments not yet considered. Generally only an hour per Part of a Bill will be given but if you do what National has done, you ensure each Part’s debate lasts several hours.

And so they should.  The Government has used eight sub-parts in Part 2 of the Bill, just so it can be rushed through debate.  This deals with all the details of party donations, candidate donations, third party donations, party advertising, candidate advertising and third party advertising.  If only one hour was allowed for Part 2, then each sub Part would only get around eight minutes debate or two speeches.

National has also avoided using hundreds of time wasting  amendments.  I’d say 90%+ of their amendments have been constructive amendments based on submissions made.  The Government’s even adopted a small number of them.

Finally National has also craftily used a provision in Standing Orders where MPs can lodge questions not just to a Minister (which are restricted to 12 a day) but to any Committee Chair. So last week suddenly ten committee chairs were all asked about progress of work before their committees.  A very legitimate and cunning way to delay things a wee bit.

It will be interesting to see how the Government intends to get through the final stages, without resorting to urgency as they have promised not to do.  Assuming we trust them, this leaves two major options:

1) Complete committee stage today (they will have from 3.30 pm to 6 pm and 7.30 pm to 10 pm), have a members day tomorrow and then have third reading on Thursday.  This will then mean the 11 new bills will only be introduced and have first readings under urgency next week and with 22 hours of debate needed could keep the House going to around midday Thursday.

2) Complete committee stage today and then go into urgency on the 11 new bills and remaining business. This will take the House through until very late Thursday or maybe even Friday.  Then resume next Tuesday for the EFB 3rd reading and an adjournment debate.

Of note is that the electoral agencies asked for the EFB to be passed into law by 30 November at the latest if it was to have a 1 January commencement for the regulated period. Even that was very tight – in the UK they had months and months to get ready.  But even the incredibly tight one month deadline has been missed (and remember the Government delayed introducing the EFB for months on end while it did secret negotiations about it) and if it is only given third reading next Tuesday, that leaves only three days before basically Wellington closes down.

The sensible thing would be to delay the date the EFB comes into force until 1 April.  But no the Government is hell bent on regulating from the 1st of January.