Dole at 28 year low

NZPA reports that numbers on the unemployment is at a 28 year low.  This is excellent news.

We’ve basically had falling unemployment continously since 1991, with the exception of around 97-98 and the Asian crisis.

Labour will be and should be pleased with their record over the last eight years.

Of course some of the reduction is because some have gone onto Invalids or Sickness benefits (or DPB) but their increase is definitely smaller than the decrease in the dole.  I suspect also quite a few have gone onto some of the free training courses offered by polytechnics and wananaga.  But that is better than just being on the dole (so long as those training courses do eventually lead to work).

The challenge now is not to be complacent.  It’s great numbers have dropped so much – but there still are too many families which are lifetime benefit dependent – kids growing up with no working role models. Again the numbers of long term beneficiaries have dropped (on the dole anyway – haven’t got other figure to hand), but every family which manages to move from welfare to work (or at least a combination of both) is a success story.

The low unemployment ties into the fact most polls show people think the country is heading in the right vs the wrong direction.  They are not happy with the Government, but they are reasonably happy with the country. We see this with Roy Morgan who has Labour 13% behind National, yet right direction 10% ahead of wrong direction.  This is why the election outcome is far from settled.  Mind you Labour’s suicidal tendencies in the last few weeks mean they may suffer a Howard – losing an election despite overall confidence in the country’s direction.

Roy Morgan has the confidence indicator at 110 (100 plus margin of right over wrong). That’s still positive but down from 121in early October.

If a confidence indicator is negative (such as in the US) then it is very very difficult for an incumbent to get re-elected.  If the confidence indicator is positive, it doesn’t mean the opposition will lose, but it does mean people have to be convinced they can change government without changing the fundamental direction of the country. Kevin Rudd managed that tightrope very well.

So it will pay to watch the confidence indicators over the next few months.  If they dip and stay below 100 it is all over.  If they stay above 100, then you can never write out the incumbents – even if trailing in the party vote.

Dominion Post Scoring the Exchanges

Every Monday, after a House sitting week, the Dom Post does a nice wee summary of the week in the House.  They award a winner, loser and wally (used to be a stronger word) of the week plus score out of 10 a two MPs clashing in the House.

Now it’s as much fun as scientific analysis, but I like them as it gives me data.  And it can be interesting nevertheless to go through the 30 scorecards for the year, and see who did well, and not do well.  I could wait for the final score next week, but thought it would be nice to publish this while the House still sits. This is the Dom Post’s analysis, but my summary.

Winner of the Week

  1. John Key x 4
  2. Helen Clark x 3
  3. Sue Bradford x 3
  4. Maori Party x 2
  5. Greens x 2
  6. David Parker x 2
  7. Winston Peters x 2
  8. Simon Power x 2

The winner breakdown by party is National 10, Labour 9, Greens 5, NZ First NZ First 3, Maori Party 2

Loser of the Week

  1. Helen Clark x 4
  2. David Benson-Pope x 2
  3. Winston Peters x 2
  4. Taito Philip Field x 2
  5. Pete Hodgson x 2
  6. Trevor Mallard x 2
  7. Damien O’Connor x 2

The loser breakdown by party is Labour 21, National 3, NZ First 2, United Future 2.  to be fair, the Government will generally tend to be on the back foot more often as they defend scandals and issues.

Wally of the Week

  1. Gordon Copeland x 3
  2. Winston Peters x 3
  3. David Cunliffe x 2
  4. Taito Philip Field x 2

The wally breakdown by party is Copeland x 3 (if I recall they thought of making Gordon the permanent recepient), Labour x 10, NZ First x 5, National x 2 and Maori x 1.

The Exchanges

Biggest thumpings – Anderton 9 vs Dean 0 (banning H20) and Ryall 9 vs Cunliffe 0 (I’m in charge now)

Most frequent top scorer – Cullen x 5, English x 3, Key x 3, Ryall x 3

Most frequent low (as in came 2nd) scorer -Cullen x 3, English x 3, Clark x 2,

Most frequent exchange – Cullen vs English x 6 – 6-5, 8-7, 8-2, 6-7, 5-7 and 6-6 for an average of Cullen 6.5 to English 5.7

Most one sided – Ryall vs Cunliffe – 9-0 and 8-0

The PMs face off – Clark vs Key – 10-10 (smacking compromise), 3-7 and 2-8 for an average of  Clark 5.0 to Key 8.3

No of Top Scorers – National x 12, ,Labour x 9, Greens x 2, NZ First x 1, Progressive x 1, Speaker x 1

No of Bottom Scorers – Labour x 12, National x 6, Green x 3, Maori x 2, Act x 1, United x 1, NZ First x 1

No of Draws -4 – Downer vs Clark, Key vs Clark, English vs Cullen and English vs King

Zero scorers – Cunliffe x 2, Chris Carter x 1, Dean x 1, Maharey x 1, Parker x 1

Next year will be even more fun to score I am sure.  Kudos to the Dominon Post for providing the  exchanges each week – it is one of my favourite features.

General Debate 11 December 2007

United Future gets it wrong – again

This is getting irresponsible.  United Future has once again put out a publication that is inaccurate regarding the Electoral Finance Bill.  They have just done an e-mail to supporters (thanks to those who passed it on) and in it Peter Dunne says:

In essence, what it says is that where a lobby group is explicitly promoting a particular party, there is a limitation on how much that group can spend in support of that party.

This is 100% wrong.  Under both the current law and the Electoral Finance Bill a lobby group can’t spend a single dollar explicitly promoting a party, without it counting as part of a party’s limit (which needs their consent).

The Electoral Finance Bill covers campaigns such as the motor vehicle industry campaign against “Labour’s crazy car policy”.  That is not an explicit campaign in support of a party. It is a genuine campaign against a policy which they see as harming their industry.  And because they mention the name of the party in Government, it is now going to be seen as an election advertisement – even for ads in January.

The real irony of the United Future newsletter is this statement:

At the outset, I have to say that there have been a number of inaccurate and extreme comments about this bill and its implications that should be debunked.

Indeed, and those inaccuracies have been from United Future, Labour, Progressive and Greens who time and time again have either not understood their own legislation or are deliberately misrepresenting it.  For witness the next sentence:

For example, it does not restrict any citizen’s freedom of speech, nor does it limit the ability of lobby groups to participate in the election process.

Both statements are quite wrong of course.  An individual advocating for or against a party next year will be deemed to be running an election advertisement and need their name and address on it for stuff such as protest march placards or posts into Usenet.

And the statement about lobby groups is clearly wrong – the motor vehicle dealers being just one example.

And Peter Dunne doesn’t mention why he voted for a third party spending limit which is less than half that recommended by the neutral Electoral Commission.

More on NZ’s Climate Change Performance

I blogged on Sunday about how a Climate Change Performance Index ranked NZ only 31st out of 56, and how it had fallen nine places from last year.

Now an overall index score is by its nature a composition of various sub-ratings. And the published report did not give a breakdown, but I e-mailed the authors, and they kindly supplied the below table:

nzccranking1.JPG

The individual ratings are fascinating.  The emissions trend is about whether or not actual emissions are heading in the right or wrong direction.  And despite eight years of Labour, NZ is in the bottom ten countries.

Imagine the howls of protest from the Greens if it had been a National Government?

Even worse, if one looks at energy emissions trend, we are basically at the bottom of the world – 2nd to bottom and 4th to bottom.

So when one hears the rhetoric of leading the world in carbon neutrality, remember the actual substance is the exact opposite.

And maybe one will have a but more sympathy for the very reasonable suggestion from the NZ Institute that we should aim to be a fast follower rather than a world leader.  For let’s face it – at moment we’re not even a slow follower – in fact we’re sprinting in the opposite direction.

Maybe we would be doing better if the Environment Ministry (and the Minister) was spending more time on policy, and less time on government advertising campaigns to tell us all how much the Government cares.

Not that this means we should accept any and all policy suggestions put up.  In each case a study should be done of what are the costs and benefits.  There are real debates to be held about the amount of money you spend on mitigation as opposed to adaptation.

State funding overshadows private donations

Simon Collins in the Herald reports on a presentation by former Alliance staff and Otago University lecturer Bruce Edwards on money in politics:

Otago University political scientist Bryce Edwards told a sociology conference in Auckland yesterday that the controversial Electoral Finance Bill, now before Parliament, was based on a myth that corporate donations could “buy elections”.

In fact, declared donations over $10,000 to political parties at the last election totalled only $3.2 million – the same as the amount paid by taxpayers for free broadcasting time, and only one-eighth of what taxpayers paid through the Parliamentary Service for “party and member support” plus MPs’ travel and communications.

Dr Edwards said critics were correct that business had a strong influence on New Zealand politics. But he said its influence came mainly from the need for any Government to maintain “business confidence” in a capitalist economy.

“That’s where the political leverage of the wealthy is exerted – not in donations, which are utterly insignificant in comparison,” he said.

He said there was no clear relationship between party spending and votes. For example, Act spent more than any other party except Labour and National at the last election ($1.4 million), yet received only 1 per cent of the vote, while the Alliance gained its highest vote (18 per cent) in 1993 when it spent only $500,000.

On the other hand, the weight of taxpayer funding of parties in Parliament now gave a huge advantage to incumbents.

Dr Edwards said the parliamentary funding should be much more tightly controlled to make sure it was only used for parliamentary duties, but controls on donations from supporters should be loosened.

The Electoral Finance Bill makes the incumbency advantage far worse of course.  It tries to exempt all parliamentary spending from the spending restrictions, while forcing a new candidate to make $20,000 last all of election year.

This is why new candidates such as Grant Robertson have started delivering their pamphlets this year.  $20,000 is a ridiculously low limit for electorates of 45,000 voters.  It’s 4c per voter per month.  It’s less than what Councillors get for many of their elections.

BBQ season

Had a nice BBQ at a friend’s place out in the Hutt yesterday.

There were eight adults and three kids (all under five) so I got to give in to my inner child and got to play on the trampoline (to see how high I could bounce the kids), assemble and reassemble transformers (much harder than one would think), race cars and play snakes & ladders and Connect 4 (of which I am the reigning champion).

I hope the summer stays as hot as it has been.  Normally we have to wait until Feb for the really good stuff, but hey there are some advantages to living here not in Naaru with global warming 🙂

12 days of Christmas by Dad 4 Justice

I did have to laugh at this special version of the 12 days of Christmas by Dad 4 Justice.  The final recital is:

On the twelfth day of Christmas
My ex love sent to me
Twelve Penal notices
Eleven Allegations
Ten CYFS people
Nine Dates for hearings
Eight separate motions
Seven injunction papers
Six witness statements
Five policemen……………
Four solicitors letters
Three harassment charges
Two protection orders
And a summons to stop my custody

Not sure it will be as catchy as the original!

Stuff now keeps links

This is some good news. The Dom Post web editor has told me:

… as of mid-October when we introduced a new content management system, links on dompost.co.nz, Stuff, and the other Fairfax sites should exist permanently.

The archiving isn’t retrospective, but anything we’ve added since then should still be available on the site.

This will make it much better linking to Stuff stories.  Well done Fairfax.

Clark & Rudd

Good to see Helen Clark having an early meeting with Kevin Rudd. The trans-tasman relationship is a crucial one for New Zealand, and nowhere it is more important than at head of government level.

I think both Clark and John Howard deserved praise for their very good and professional relationship, despite being from different sides of the political spectrum.

Sadly they have been rare exceptions. Shipley and Howard got one fine. But Bolger despised Keating (for good reason – he betrayed us). Lange and Hawke had a personality clash, and Fraser despised Muldoon (also for good reason).

I think Rudd will be quite a good Prime Minister. Australian Labor is quite moderate in some areas, for example:

WAYNE Swan has guaranteed he will deliver Labor’s $31 billion tax-cut plan, flatly rejecting the push from social progressives for Labor to instead spend the money on better services.

Insisting the cuts will ease pressure on inflation and interest rates by boosting workforce participation, the new Treasurer has also promised an austere first budget in May, delivering on election promises but offering no surprises outside further cuts in spending.

In an interview with The Weekend Australian yesterday, Mr Swan declared Labor “the party of middle Australia”, promising its emphasis would be on economic conservatism to build and maintain prosperity.

Under the proposed cuts, by 2010 the 15 per cent tax rate will apply to incomes of up to $37,000, the 40 per cent tax rate will be cut to 37 per cent and the 45 per cent rate will be cut to 42per cent.

In NZ one pays 15% uo to $9,500 only.  In Australia it ill be up to $37,000.

Herald calls on Logan to go

The NZ Herald does an editorial on the sad story of the Environment Ministry.  I’ll just quote their conclusion:

The chief executive cannot remain when his organisation is revealed as having, at its head and perhaps also at its heart, a culture so politicised. It was wrong to hear and act on Mr Parker’s recommendation of Clare Curran; to give her the work uncontested; to ignore Ms Leigh’s protestations.

It was wrong to discuss Ms Setchell’s appointment with Mr Benson-Pope; to effectively sack her; to twice mislead Mr Mallard for answers he gave to the House. And it is wrong for Mr Logan and Mr Mallard to think they can wait out the criticism again, as we await inquiry No 4. The former should resign, the latter ought to apologise. Then begins the job of restoring this ministry to the tasks it should perform impartially and professionally.

Logan should put his ministry ahead of himself and do the decent thing.

What do the three new Labour candidates all have in common?

So far Labour has selected three new candidates to replace sitting MPs in Labour seats.  Grant Robertson replacing Hobbs in Wellington Central.  Chris Hipkins replacing Swain in Rimutaka, and Brendon Burns replacing Barnett in Christchurch Central.

Is it coincidence that all three have worked (or for Hipkins still works) in Helen Clark’s personal office?

This shows the power of the head office.

This is not to say they are not all good candidates.  They are.  But to have three out of three all having worked for Helen is extraordinary.

Quoting newspapers

I had a couple of journalists ask me last week, what I had against the Dominion Post, and how come I quoted the NZ Herald so much more than the Dom Post.  This surprised me as I have nothing against the Dom Post. In fact it is the newspaper I buy more often than any other.

I explained (and am repeating it here) that the main reason I quote the NZ Herald way more than any other newspaper is because their website retains the stories online permanently.  This means that any links from Kiwiblog to the story will remain intact. For this reason I will always choose to link to a NZ Herald story as first preference – purely because the links remains.

I have a near daily routine for the NZ newspapers.  My online browsing in order is:

  1. NZ Herald main page
  2. NZ Herald national news
  3. NZ Herald political news
  4. NZ Herald tech news
  5. NZ Herald opinion
  6. Stuff main page
  7. Stuff national news
  8. Stuff political news
  9. Stuff tech news
  10. Stuff/Press/main page
  11. Stuff/Press/opinion
  12. Stuff/Dom Post/main page
  13. Stuff/Dom Post/local news
  14. Stuff/Dom Post/opinion

Sunday is a lot easier:

  1. Herald on Sunday main page
  2. Herald on Sunday national news
  3. Herald on Sunday political news
  4. Herald on Sunday opinion
  5. Sunday News
  6. Sunday Star-Times main page
  7. Sunday Star-Times national news
  8. Sunday Star-Times opinion
  9. Sunday Star-Times focus

Again – this is due to permanency of links rather than any like or dislike of a newspaper.

I actually think all three major dailies are a good read, with good political coverage.

The Press advises Key and Mallard

The Press has advice for John Key and Trevor Mallard on their respective “stuff-ups”:

If one of the fundamental lessons of life is to learn from one’s mistakes, a couple of Parliament’s higher-profile personalities should be starting the new week with newfound wisdom to guide them through the corridors of power, writes The Press in an editorial.

Key comes out of the DVD fiasco looking as if he would struggle to run a bath, never mind a focused, confidence-inspiring administration. But if he can comfort himself that he has been the victim of others’ failings, Trevor Mallard has no such excuse.

… His environment ministry is immersed in crisis, if not scandal, over the recruitment of communications staff, with clear signs of political interference by at least two of Mallard’s colleagues. Mallard’s initial response was to monster a whistle-blower caught up in the rather tacky business, destroying her professional reputation with a broadside delivered under parliamentary privilege.

That it has emerged last week that he based the attack on incorrect advice from his ministry seems to mean little to Mallard. He has dug himself in, refusing to apologise for what can only be seen now as a reprehensible display.

Mallard will surely know that no matter who he wants to blame for his unwarranted attack, the ultimate responsibility lies with him. But perhaps he is more an example of another interpretation of that basic lesson from life: that those who don’t learn from their mistakes tend to repeat them.

Indeed it is all about learning from mistakes.

The cunning plan to exempt parliamentary spending

This post will be a bit difficult to follow, but it is an important one. It will show how the Government’s actions on this bill are those of naked self interest and to legalise their previously illegal actions.

It all revolves around Clauses 80(d) and 81(2)(g) which exempt from the definitions of party activities and party election expenses by stating:

does not include anything done in relation to a member of Parliament in his or her capacity as a member of Parliament

Now when I first read this, my interpretation was that Labour had done this so they could argue that anything paid for by The Parliamentary Service was exempt. The reason I suspected this was their motivation, is because Heather Simpson argued (incorrectly) that this was the law when they over-spent in 2005. And as we know, their companion law has now re-legalised their pledge card and similar activities as ok for taxpayer funding.

Labour broke the law in two ways in 2005. They over-spent under the Electoral Act, and illegally used taxpayer money on their election campaign. Changing one law without changing the other doesn’t help them much.

But they made one mistake. Instead of writing the law so it explicitly said that anything approved by the Parliamentary Service could not be considered an election expense (which would help get around the case law from the 1988 Wairarapa Electoral Petition), they just made it implicit. They did not want the public odium of stating their intentions quite so blatantly.

But they then struck a problem. The Electoral Commission said that they did not know what these clauses meant, and the credibility of the law was seriously threatened. So Annette King panicked and came up with a definition of what this clause is meant to cover. She said:

“MPs acting in their capacity as members of Parliament” excluded statements they made outside the House on policy that was intended to be enacted by a future Parliament.”

Now this satisfied the Electoral Commission. It drew a line which obviously excluded from the exemption things such as pledge cards. They withdrew their damaging objections.

But just because Annette King is Minister of Justice, doesn’t mean she can’t be over-ruled. Annette was summoned to the 9th floor and chastened by H2 no doubt. She was told that her definition was unacceptable and she was told she had to go and back down on her definition, even if it means humiliating herself. And so she did:

I want to mention clause 80(d), which covers a member acting in his or her capacity as a member of Parliament. The Electoral Commission has asked Parliament to give it some clarification as to how we interpret that. We are not going to put it in law; the commission has asked for an interpretation. That is what it has asked for—it wants an interpretation.

Well, I gave my view 2 weeks ago. I gave my view, and my view, I have to stress, is my view. But what the Electoral Commission is interested in is what this Parliament thinks, what the members of this Parliament think, and it wants to be guided. The Electoral Commission said that it wants to be guided by what this Parliament says. I am prepared to say that my interpretation could be wrong. I might be wrong. In fact, I am prepared to admit that I could be wrong. I read the comments of Bill English today in a question to the House. He might be right in terms of that interpretation.

Now my first reaction to this was Annette King was being incredibly stupid. In fact I yelled at the Hansard something alone the lines of “You stupid xxxxx, you are stating that the Electoral Commission wants to know what Parliament thinks, yet you are refusing to amend the law – which is the proper way to signal what Parliament thinks.” I thought how on earth can the Electoral Commission work out from all the different views expressed in the committee of the whole stage, what the intended interpretation should be.

But then upon talking to some MPs and lawyers, I became aware that there was method to her madness. They explained that courts, where statutes are unclear, may look at the Hansard to gain clarity on the intention of the law. And the one view they most take into account is the Minister’s.

So Annette King had no choice but to make herself seem like a blithering idiot (which she is not). She had to firstly state her previous opinion was wrong, and that she now has an open mind.

Then she needed a flunky Labour MP to put forward a view during the committee stage that the proper way to interpret these clauses was that anything authorised for payment by The Parliamentary Service was exempt as an election advertisement. And Charles Chauvel I am told did exactly that (Hansard not yet available).

So the final stage is for Annette King as Minister to place into Hansard what her view of Clause 80(d) now is. And I can guarantee you it will not be to stay with her previous definition. But instead she will say having listened to the many fine speeches, she has agreed with Mr Chauvel, and the intention of 80(d) is that anything approved by the Parliamentary Service means that it automatically can not be considered electioneering, and hence exempt from the spending caps.

This NZ Herald article makes it clear that King will give another interpretation of the clause before this bill is passed”.

King will do this either at the conclusion of the committee stage, or at the third reading. Once it is too late for people to object.

 

And they will have achieved their double goal. To allow their election campaign to both be funded by the taxpayer, and secondly not to count as an election expense.

A busy month

Just done a quick post and comment count for November.

I made 256 posts in November, which is an average of 8.5 per day.

Commenters made 15,600 comments, which is an average of 61 per post, and an average of 520 comments a day.

Brendon Burns wins Christchurch Central

Brendon Burns will be delighted to have won the Labour nomination for Christchurch Central. With nine candidates, no-one would have been complacent.

Brendon is a former editor of the Marlborough Express. He’s stood twice for Kaikoura so will see this as third time lucky.

He spent a few years heading up the communications unit in the PM’s Office, and since then has been doing private consultancy work.

I met him when he was doing the comms for a Digital Cities conference, and InternetNZ hired him to do the comms works for the major (ICANN) conference held in March 2006, for which I chaired the organising committee. So have had a bit to do with Brendon, and pleased to see him win the nomination.

It’s a pity that neither Labour nor National are updating their websites with confirmed candidates. I met set up a couple of pages here, if the parties do not, so people can see who is standing where.

Another ex student politician selected

The typical career path for many non union Labour MPs is to start in student politics, then to a job in Parliament, to a brief spell outside, and then a Labour candidacy.

We saw this with Grant Robertson in Wellington Central, and he has been joined by Chris Hipkins winning the Rimutaka nomination.

I haven’t met Grant (to my knowledge) but have met Chris a few times.  Both will be pretty capable politically astute MPs, and my congratulations go out to Chris for his victory.

But I think there are legitimate issues, and these selections reinforce them, about the lack of significant real world experience amongst many Labour MPs.

Labour do far better than National on ethnic and gender diversity (however National is making inroads), but National does better on occupational and life experience diversity.

Interesting Chris has a blog, but it is a private one open  open to selected invitees.  Hopefully this will change.  I think it has been a travel blog, but Google shows news of his nomination is on there.

Greens on Electoral Finance Bill

The Greens are upset with the Herald for editing part of their 200 words on the Electoral Finance Bill, which criticised the Herald editorial as being misleading.

I don’t think the Herald should have edited the contribution, but it is rich of the Greens to say the Herald was misleading. Let us look at what the Greens say:

EFB does not stop anyone saying anything anytime.

Untrue. The bill which came out of Select Committee required a protester to state his name or address if advocating for or against a party. This was added in by the Greens and allies. The latest version makes it an offence to post an opinion to Internet newsgroups advocating for or against a party, unless you include your name and address with it. The Greens voted against an amendment to allow such advocacy on the Internet, without requiring names and addresses.

EFB places no restrictions on press.

Untrue. The Greens voted against an amendment which would have exempted the press. The current Bill only exempts the press if what they write is solely to inform, entertain or enlighten.

EFB places no restrictions on paid issue advertising.

Untrue. The Labour Crazy Car policy campaign will be illegal next year as the $300,000 cost exceeds the $120,000 limit. Advertising on an issue in a way which may encourage people to vote for or against parties on that issue is now an election advertisement. This will include a campaign to support candidates who support cannabis legalisation or support parties which support Kyoto.

EFB only caps advertising spending if trying to persuade people to vote for or against a party – cap at $120,000.

Half truth. It also caps it for campaigns for or against a class of parties described by their policies. For example one could only spend $120,000 campaigning against parties which supported the Electoral Finance Bill – even if you do not name them.

Repeat, EFB only caps electioneering spending. EFB caps party advertising spending at $2.4m.

The definition of electioneering now includes placards and posts into Usenet. It also includes advocating for or against a policy in such a way which may encourage support for or against parties who agree or disagree with that policy.

National responsible for EFB. National evaded party spending cap by using Exclusive Brethren for parallel ‘vote National’ anti-Green campaign. Showed loophole in existing law.

The Greens would have more credibility on this issue if they just once mentioned that Labour blatantly broke the law, overspending by $800,000, and that this law is going to make legal Labour’s illegal actions and make illegal what was legal.

They would also have credibility of they acknowledge that National has said it supports reasonable limits on third party advocacy. The EFB just isn’t reasonable.

If don’t close loophole, parallel groups can spend unlimited millions in ‘party vote’ campaigning.

Greens also don’t mention they have ignored the advice of the Electoral Commission and set the limits at under 50% of what was recommended, to try and suppress criticism. Almost no-one is advocating no limits at all on third party campaigning. It is a red herring from the Greens. The issue is the very low limit and having it extend to all year instead of 90 days.

Result – politicians owned by those who funded their campaign, not by voters.

Yet the Greens did a deal with Labour to allow anonymous donations to remain legal. They also failed to move an amendment at committee stage to ban them. They have failed to live up to their principles.

That’s why need cap on election spending by parties and other groups. See USA for evidence – best elections money can buy.

Now this is the stupidest thing they have said. Almost every change being made will bring us closer to the US in terms of how campaigns are funded. The US has more campaign finance laws than any other country. And all the experience has been is they make the system dirtier as they force the money underground.

Human Rights Commission agreed with Greens’ changes to protect freedom of speech.

Yet he ignores they still oppose the Bill as it doesn’t retain the 90 day regulated period, and they did not give the public a chance to submit on the amended bill.

Rallies against EFB organised by Business Roundtable member. BRT members made secret donations to National via secret trusts. See ‘Hollow Men’ by Nicky Hager.

The rallies are not about the donations. They were not even in the original bill. This is a nother red herring. It is about a law which will turn everyday political advocacy in election year, into regulated election advertising – including protest march placards and posts to Usenet.

National opposed Green idea of citizens’ assembly to decide campaign finance rules.

And here once again the Greens abandon any sign of principle or integrity by not mentioning Labour also voted against. And the reasons they were voted down is because the Greens want a review of the law to start just 60 days after the law is passed. How insane is that?

They know this is a flawed bad law. They know Labour has totally stuffed this up. But instead of acknowledging this, they play politics with our constitution and tell lies about it.

So for the Greens to complain about the Herald’s editorial is a classic case of the pot calling the kettle black.

UPDATE: Graeme Edgeler has done a fisking over on the Greens blog.  Much better than my effort.

November Public Polls

Later today I’ll publish the normal monthly polling newsletter. October had four public polls conducted during the month – two Morgan polls, a Fairfax poll, and a Herald poll.

 nov07polls.JPG

The average of the public polls has National 11% ahead of Labour and just able to form a Government with ACT. The gap last month ago was 9%.

nov07minors.JPG

Looking at the minor parties, and the Greens should start to be concerned.  This is a post election low for them.  Also the overall trend in the last year has been a slow decline.

We also look at the Australian polls to see which company was closest to the election result.

And in the United States former Arizona Governor Mike Huckabee is storming up the polls for Republican candidates, and now looks likely to win Ohio. Giuliani still leads nationally though.

This newsletter is only available by e-mail. If you would like to receive future issues, please e-mail [email protected] with your name, organization (if applicable) and e-mail address or go to http://listserver.actrix.co.nz/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/polling-newsletter to subscribe yourself.

2007 Trans-Tasman MP Ratings

Trans-Tasman has published its rankings for MPs in 2007.

As with last year, I like to analyse data so have put all the ratings into a spreadsheet and here are the average ratings for each party (2+ MPs), with the change from last year:

ACT            4.3        nc
Green         4.1         +0.2
Labour       4.0         -0.3
Maori         4.4         -0.8
National     4.7         nc
NZ First    4.1          -0.4
United       5.0         +0.5

So Labour MPs rated worst on average, with United Future best, followed by National. Interestingly in 2005 both National and Labour averaged 4.5.  In the last two years Labour has dropped to 4.0 and National increased to 4.7.

I also calculated averages for the Cabinet, the Government’s front bench (top 8), and National’s front bench (top 8):

Cabinet             5.1
Labour FB        6.3
National FB      7.2

Top Scores

Helen Clark       8.5
John Key            8.0
Bill English        8.0
Phil Goff            8.0

Bottom Scores

David Benson-Pope      0
Taito Philip Field           0
Gordon Copeland          0.5
Ashraf Choudary            1.0
George Hawkins            1.0
Dave Heroera                1.0
Mahara Okeroa             1.0
Judith Tizard                1.0
Nandor Tancoz            1.0
Brian Connell                1.0

Largest Increases

Paula Bennett         +2.0
Phil Heatley            +2.0
Charles Chauvel      +2.0

Largest Decreases

David Benson-Pope    -4.0
Gordon Copeland        -4.0
Mark Burton                -2.5
Tim Barnett                 -2.5

Top Performers by Party

Act – Heather Roy 5.0
Green – Jeanette Fitzsimons 6.5, Metiria Turei 5.5
Labour – Clark 8.5, Goff 8.0, Cullen and King 7.5
Maori – Pita Sharples 6.0,
National – Key and English 8.0, Power and Collins 7.5, Brownlee and Rich 7.0
NZ First – Peters 7.5, Mark 5.5
Progressive – Anderton 5.5
United Future – Dunne 5.5

HoS says it is the beginning of the end

The HoS says that if National wins the election next year, the last two months will be seen as the beginning of the end.  They note:

The political management of the Electoral Finance Bill has been a public-relations disaster.

And then on Erin Leigh:

It remains to be seen whether Leigh will have any legal recourse, but Mallard’s refusal to apologise is a serious misjudgement. He may not hide behind the technical excuse that he was relying on advice. New Zealanders’ belief in a fair go – not to mention the “buck stops here” principle – demands more.

The events of the last month have made the Government look increasingly aloof and arrogant. This fiasco has simply etched that impression deeper.

John Armstrong also writes about Mallard’s  behaviour:

All the public sees is an increasingly unpopular Cabinet minister who seems to have learned nothing from his scrap with Henare and who picks on a citizen who thought she was doing the right thing by raising her concerns about what was happening in her former workplace.

There can only be one loser from this. Mallard should have cut his losses. He should have acknowledged the error. He could have blamed the ministry. He did not even have to utter the word “apology”, although it would have looked better if he had.

Perhaps most astonishing of all, Mallard has followed National’s preferred script almost to the word.

The Opposition can hardly believe its good fortune. It has been trying to paint the Government as arrogant, bullying and out of touch. Along comes Mallard who obligingly displays those very characteristics.

… The plain fact is that Mallard used the cover of parliamentary privilege to discredit Leigh and punish her for having the temerity to speak out.

This is what is so surprising – that the Government keeps punishing itself.  There is a very easy way out – called doing the right thing.  Once upon a time Clark was very astute at knowing when to cut the losses.  The longer Mallard holds out regarding Erin Leigh, the longer it stays a new story.

It’s this sort of stubbornness which journalists call classic third termitis.  An obsession with proving oneself right and refusing to concede, which overrides any more strategic considerations.

Matt McCarten also senses it is bad for the Government:

The impression now cemented in most people’s mind is that Labour – supported by the Greens, New Zealand First and United Future – has forced through a partisan law for next year’s election to give them electoral advantage over National.

… Mallard’s instincts are to attack anyone who upsets him when he is under stress. Even after Hugh Logan, the ministry’s boss, said Leigh’s work was of a high standard, Mallard refused to apologise for his behaviour. This must call into question his capacity to be a leading minister.

And Kerre Woodham has a similiar theme:

Why on Earth is Labour making it so difficult for even their most ardent supporters to love them right now? Is this some sort of test of fealty? You have to stick with us even though we’re behaving appallingly?

Helen Clark is big on loyalty – which is vital if one is to have longevity in the political world – but some senior Government members are acting up so badly, they’ve descended from puerile to infantile.

… And every time John Boscowan’s name is mentioned, the Prime Minister and her number two start frothing at the mouth and inferring everyone who marched against the Electoral Finance Bill is a mindless Act supporter being manipulated by a rich puppeteer.

Personally, if I had truckloads of money, I could think of better things to spend it on than half-page ads in daily newspapers exhorting New Zealanders to rise up against the Bill, but it’s not my money and Boscowan can spend it how he will.

And while some of the marchers were undoubtedly rabid Labour loathers, not all of them were, and it diminishes the Prime Minister to imply that’s the case. Labour’s in grave danger of imploding and depriving all the political junkies the sport of a close election next year.

Kerre describes herself as left-leaning, but like Jaz Morris, is turning away from the Government.

SST on Boscawen

The Sunday Star-Times has an article on John Boscawen.   An extract:

Justice Minister Annette King said Boscawen had not been upfront about the fact he was a former “bagman for the Act party”.

“In some ways this reflects some of the campaigns we have seen in the past. Why wasn’t he honest enough to say `I’m John Boscawen and I’m an Act supporter and I’m an Act financial backer and obviously I’m proud of that’,” she said.

Boscawen, an associate member of the Business Roundtable, said he had not hidden the fact he had been a fundraiser and office holder for Act. But he said his campaign was a personal one, not a party one. “This is a huge amount of money for me. My motivation is very, very simple. This bill goes to the heart of democracy.

The notion that John has hidden his affiliations is laughable.  In his submission to the Select Committee on the Bill, he refers to his work as a previous fundraiser for ACT. His (associate) membership of the Business Roundtable is listed on the BRT website.  He has referred to his involvement with ACT in many of the ads he has run.

The article also refers to plans for next year:

And if the bill is passed next Thursday as the government expects? From the beginning of 2008, Boscawen would not be prevented from continuing his campaign.

But he would have to appoint a financial agent and be barred from spending any more than $120,000 over election year.

But Boscawen says he has a cunning plan to get around that cash barrier. He is considering registering as a political party, which requires him to have 500 financial members. That way his spending limit would be a rather grander $1.2 million.

It is a measure of how draconian the law is, that it will seriously restrict people campaigning against those who voted for the law.  MPs who vote for it, will benefit from its provisions.

Another private prosecution

I heard on the radio that Graham McCready has said he is likely to drop his private prosecution of Trevor Mallard as he believes the dock appearance has damaged him enough.

In the same week, another private prosecution of a Minister (and officials) has been launched – and this one seems less trivial.

Tuariki John Delamere was charged with fraud relating to immigration services in 2005,and earlier this year he was found not guilty on all charges after a four week trial.  The jury took only two hours to deliberate.

Delamere has filed a private prosecution against then Immigration Minister David Cunliffe, and three senior officials,  with a total of 98 charges including blackmail and perjury.

His summary of evidence runs to 34 pages, and there are 114 exhibits.

I have no idea at all about the merits of the case, but it will be interesting to observe.