Anti Clint Rickards march

Reliable sources tell me there is a protest on Tuesday 12 June outside Police National HQ (180 Molesworth Street) at 12.30 pm.

The purpose is to draw attention to the fact that Clint Rickards is still on full pay as an Assistant Commissioner.

That issue has faded somewhat from view. I am surprised there hasn’t been a conclusion to his employment status negotiations by now.

Here and there

Eric Olthwaite at Apathy Jack blogs on what ideologies tend to be lethal and concludes “Religion and Socialism can justifiably be blamed for causing a great deal of suffering but Atheism and Capitalism cannot”.

Varsity.co.nz has a novel prank of the year.

The online education database has the top seven alternatives to Wikipedia. They are:

1 Scholarpedia – done by experts

2 Citizendium – articles are approved, users use real name

3 Encyclopedia Britannica Online – but costs

4 MSN Encarta – also costs

5 Infoplease – from Pearson Education

6 Conservapedia – unintentionally hilarious

7 Uncyclopedia – intentionally hilarious

A good first week for Xero

Well I got my share allotment and now own 5,000 Xero shares (well my name is on the share certificate but in fact 1,000 belong to Miss Ten).

NZX show the price movements and sales, and it finished the week at $1.14 so that’s a nice premium. The range of sales was from $1.09 to $1.17.

I only paid off the mortgage this year so haven’t had share investments for a long time. Quite fun to be back in the market.

Wilson and Barnett to go?

The SST reports that Speaker Margaret Wilson is expected to retire at the next election.

This is on top of Transtasman tipping the week before last that Labour Senior Whip Tim Barnett will step down at the next election, and might even return to the UK.

The SST also reports on the growing pressure for Cullen to go. I have no doubt that putting Goff into Finance would help Labour considerably in the polls.

So the current predictions for retirements are:

Definite

Dover Samuels
Russell Fairbrother
Marian Hobbs
Paul Swain

Probable

Margaret Wilson
Parekura Horomia
Rick Barker
Mahaha Okeroa
George Hawkins
Jill Pettis
Di Yates

Possible

Tim Barnett
Michael Cullen
Annette King
Ross Robertson
Lesley Soper
Ann Hartley
Mita Ririnui
Dave Hereroa

Michael Bassett on polls

Michael Bassett writes:

Any politician who says he/she takes no notice of polls is either a dilettante, or fibbing. An element of theatre is essential to good politics, and the practitioner needs polls to gauge audience reaction. In the end livelihoods depend on satisfying the spectators. In my political days we were always sensitive to polls. At first there weren’t many but after Robert Muldoon became Prime Minister in 1975 they were taken more frequently. He studied their results in detail and became clever at manipulating the poll-taking process. He knew exactly when surveys were going to occur, and would try to engineer some event that would produce a favourable knee-jerk reaction. He’d invite an American warship before a poll. That always stimulated the wilder end of the peace movement to do something that Muldoon turned to advantage. Police raids on Bastion Point Maori protestors sometimes occurred just as polls were being taken. The Springbok Tour played a similar role. David Lange was probably the most theatrical of all our modern leaders. He had a fine eye for the dramatic gesture, but he soon lost his capacity to gauge audience reaction. In his later years I remember him poring over poll results at cabinet and caucus, trying hopefully to detect trends helpful to his increasingly lonesome battle against the rest of his cabinet. Helen Clark’s government doesn’t rely on outside polling; it spends lots of our money gauging audience reaction. Lange once dismissed his internal critics as “poll-driven fruitcakes”. The present government has mastered the baking. They always try to calculate the effect of any decision to the last decimal point.

But it’s one thing to keep polling, and quite another to know what, precisely, the results are telling you. The best poll reader in my time was Richard Prebble. He was able to get inside the figures and detect the trends. He saved the Lange-Douglas government on several occasions. The Clark-Cullen government seems to have lost their earlier skill at interpreting polls. There is one fundamental that they keep overlooking: to persist with conduct when it starts to grate with voters is foolish. Ever since the 2005 election Labour’s audience has been drifting away from the theatre. A significant number of former Labour voters have now turned off tax and spend policies. Instead of 5% of taxpayers feeling the pinch of Labour’s top marginal tax rate of 39%, more than 12% now pay it. That’s a sizeable number of people who are looking more carefully at what Labour is achieving when it spends our money. Hospital waiting lists haven’t dropped noticeably, although 40% more is now spent in that sector than in 1999. Indeed, productivity within hospitals has fallen.

Beware the bloggeers

Time writer Joe Klein worries about the influence of bloggers on the Democratic Party. He writes:

The smart stuff is being drowned out by a fierce, bullying, often witless tone of intolerance that has overtaken the left-wing sector of the blogosphere. Anyone who doesn’t move in lockstep with the most extreme voices is savaged and ridiculed—especially people like me who often agree with the liberal position but sometimes disagree and are therefore considered traitorously unreliable. Some of this is understandable: the left-liberals in the blogosphere are merely aping the odious, disdainful—and politically successful—tone that right-wing radio talk-show hosts like Rush Limbaugh pioneered. They are also justifiably furious at a Bush White House that has specialized in big lies and smear tactics.

And that is precisely the danger here. Fury begets fury. Poison from the right-wing talk shows seeped into the Republican Party’s bloodstream and sent that party off the deep end. Limbaugh’s show—where Dick Cheney frequently expatiates—has become the voice of the Republican establishment. The same could happen to the Democrats. The spitballs aimed at me don’t matter much. The spitballs aimed at Harman, Clinton and Obama are another story. Despite their votes, each of those politicians believes the war must be funded. (Obama even said so in his statement explaining his vote.) Each knows, as Senator Jim Webb has said repeatedly, that we must be more careful getting out of Iraq than we were getting in. But they allowed themselves to be bullied into a more simplistic, more extreme position. Why? Partly because they fear the power of the bloggers to set the debate and raise money against them. They may be right—in the short (primary election) term; Harman faced a challenge from the left in 2006. In the long term, however, kowtowing to extremists is exactly the opposite of what this country is looking for after the lethal radicalism of the Bush Administration.

Parliament General Manager to retire

Joel George is going to retire next year as General Manager of The Parliamentary Service. He’s had a lot tougher ride in the job than his predecessors with the Auditor-General’s report into spending.

My only interaction with George was when an announcement was made on the Parliamentary Electronic Noticeboard that there would be Maori prayer sessions for half an hour (or something) every morning, and any staff member who wished to attend them to help relieve stress could do so during work hours.

I wrote to George proposing that the PS also give us time off to go to the Backbencher every afternoon, as this was also a very good way of relieving stress. I think I also suggested a subsidy would met with high levels of staff approval. I got a very unamused reply back!

Views on Mercury

The HoS editorial says there are still a tangle of unanswered questions over the Muliaga death.

The United Future leader, Peter Dunne, attempted to stem the flow of political cant by warning politicians against “milking an awful situation for their own opportunity”, though his supplementary comments suggested that he might not be above doing so himself. The result has been, not a moment too soon, a reduction in the rhetorical bile pouring from the ninth floor of the Beehive. It is all well and good for the Prime Minister to heap scorn on the “hard-nosed” attitude of Mercury Energy. But the retail electricity business is one of the nation’s most intensely competitive. The contractor who pulled the plug in Mangere Bridge was the last link in a very long chain of policy-setting and decision-making that stretches back to Wellington and, through both Labour and National administrations, to 1984.

The Government wants to toughen the requirement for electricity providers to refer customers to social agencies if there is evidence that they are having difficulty paying the power bill. But this idea sounds a good deal better than it is. It requires electricity retailers to adopt a role for which they are neither equipped nor responsible. It is no great stretch to wonder whether a supermarket checkout operator, noticing a shopper with a meagre trolleyful and an empty purse, should unilaterally get WINZ involved for fear that she will be blamed for letting others’ kids go hungry. Will a service station attendant who notices that a car’s tyres are bald and does not immediately alert state agencies that the driver may be unable to afford retreads be adjudged culpable when the car later skids in the wet and kills a pedestrian?

Despite our natural human inclination to seek simple answers to complicated questions, it is plain that this matter will not be laid to rest when the electricity retailers accede to the baying from the Beehive and change their disconnection procedures. That is something that they most certainly need to do, at least in the case of customers who are plainly making an attempt to clear arrears. But if Mrs Muliaga’s breathing machine was keeping her alive – and it is far from clear that it was – why was she not protected by the doctors who put her on it from death by power cut? As the power bill arrears increased, what proportion of family income was going to the family’s church? What was the church doing in return?

All good comments and questions. Meanwhile in the same paper Matt McCarten has found someone new to blame for her death.

What no one has yet focused on was why the Muliaga family was struggling to pay their power bill. I’ll tell you why. The Muliaga family, like hundreds of thousands of New Zealanders are being exploited by employers who are returning large profits to investors. Ever since the Bolger National Government deregulated the labour market, wages have been dropping while profits have been rising.

McCarten is of course wrong about wages having dropped since 1991. They increased faster than inflation. What I find fascinating is no one has yet confirmed that the family were getting their full family support and accommodation supplement. This will have more than doubled their net income, if they were claiming it all.

Coddington vs Press Council

In today’s HoS, Deborah Coddington reveals the Press Council has upheld complaints against her in regards to her North & South “Asian angst” story. Coddington actually mentioned this to a group of us a few weeks ago at the Qantas Awards, so I have been wondering when it would become public.

Deborah pretty much rejects the Press Council findings, and claims that as “the council totally ignored the main complaint – that my statistics were wrong. From this omission, I can only conclude that I was correct all along, and the complainants – as I argued – wilfully used different statistics.”

What the Council it seems focused on was emotionally laden language.

I was one of the critics of Deborah for the article. I was never against there being an article on some of the issues around Asian immigration, just that this particular article did mis-use statistics. I think I was first to blog that her claim four out of five pregnant Asian women aborted their babies was wrong, and that was the rate for Asians under 20 years old only. For all Asian women it was 37%.The Press Council decision is not online so I can’t read it to see what it does or does not say on the statistics. I was not one of the Press Council complainants incidentally. The only time I have ever considered taking an issue to the Press Council was over the Rachel Glucina/Mick Jagger HoS story – and that was because I thought there was a very important principle at stake over whether journalists can deny they are journalists to get a story. But I never got around to doing that.

Coddington certainly is whatever the opposite of contrite is, concluding:

Even the complainants should be peeved by this pathetic decision. If I’d been judged by my peers – senior, investigative journalists – I could respect their conclusions, however “damning”. Instead, I was found guilty by three lawyers, a retired diplomat, a teacher, a writer for Department of Trade and Enterprise, the editor of a rival publication and just one journalist I respect – John Gardner of the Herald. But even he should have excused himself, since two of the complainants were Herald reporters.

I’ll link to the Press Council decision once it is online.

Incredibly sad story

Key on official cash rate

John Key on Thursday criticised the increase in the official cash rate, saying Bollard could have waited as some areas of the economy were showign signs of weakness, and an increase was premature.

I actually disagree with John. Having said that, I will note John is infinitely more experienced in matters of interest rates and exchange rates, so I’m not saying I’m right, and he’s wrong. Just that I disagree.

If Bollard had not let inflation previously get above the 3% limit, and sat uncomfortably high for so long, then I would agree that a hike is premature. But Bollard had been in danger of getting a reputation of tolerating inflation, beyond that allowed by his agreement with the Government. After having been slow to act last time, he needed to establish firmly that there is no way he will allow inflation to breach the limit, even if it means unpopular rate increases. A Governor needs to be respected, not popular.

Fran O’Sullivan has a useful column today looking at how far Bollard may go.

A fake rape register

It turns out the woman who made the false complaint about being raped by someone impersonating a police officer has made false rape complaints before – in fact four of them.

Her lawyer has called for Police to maintain a register of such false (which is different to unproven) complaints. I agree, and am staggered that the Police don’t already do this. He points out that her latest complaint may not have ended up costing as much as it did, if the Police were aware of her previous history.

Council for Civil Liberties president Tony Ellis has hysterically compared the idea of a register to conjuring up “apartheid-type thoughts”. What dope is that man smoking? Apartheid?

Somewhat more sanely he argues “a register might result in anyone who had previously made a false complaint not being treated equally”.

Well yes it might, but as with the boy who cried wolf, this applies to everything in life. If you go bankrupt three or four times, people are less likely to invest in your companies. If you get sacked from your last three jobs, you are less likely to be employed.

Now I would certainly not advocate that someone who has previously made false complaints, is automatically not believed. But Police should have info on any previous false complaints, so they can make a judgement call.

I agree with Women’s Refuge that there should also be a register of convicted sex offenders and abusers of women. Absolutely. Convictions for serious crimes are not a private matter, and in my opinion all serious violent and sexual criminals should be in a public searchable directory.

The Sensible Sentencing Trust does have an offender database, but it is somewhat clunky.

Armstrong on Clark

John Armstrong has a very balanced column on how Helen Clark has handled the Mercury Energy issue. He concludes her actions have been more driven by political necessity than opportunism.

While there have been many people critical of how Clark has milked the tragedy, I suspect her actions will have worked and she will bounce back in the polls. Those who follow the news in detail and read newspapers are tut tutting her, but for those who just watch the TV News, all they would have seen is Clark dominating the headlines for every day of the last week, and John Key being invisible.

Burke sacked from Grey’s Anatomy

Hilton back in jail

Paris Hilton is back in jail after the Judge over-ruled the Sheriff’s Department to have her serve the 45 day sentence at home.

I am surprised that No Right Turn has not been leading the campaign to have her freed though, if he is to be consistent.

You see No Right Turn has stated that it is inhumane for New Zealand to jail illegal immigrants who refuse to sign their deportation papers. He’s said that if any illegal immigrant is willing to spend three months in jail, then they should be allowed to stay in NZ, and says keeping them there longer is sadistic and vicious.

Personally I think it is about upholding the rule of law. Imprisonment is the final sanction for any law breaker. If obeying the law becomes voluntary, then we’ll have massive problems.

Now take the case of Paris – she is no threat to the community. Her crime is, just like the illegal immigrants, refusing to obey the order of a judicial body. There is no actual point to having her in jail, instead of killers and rapists etc etc. So where is teh human rights campaign for her?

But oh wait, there is a reason she is in prison. A great reason. To show that no-one is above the law. That wealth and privilege does not mean you can blame your disobeyal of court instructions on your assistants.

But just as the law applies to wealthy people, it also applies to illegal immigrants. If they have had their due process, their appeals, their multiple hearings, and they have been ordered deported from NZ, it is unacceptable to just let them ignore this if they choose not to sign their travel papers. Because it will send a signal to all illegal immigrants to do the same.

I am very pro-immigration. But it is for NZ to choose who gets to live here, and how many. We can not afford unlimited unrestricted immigration.

Most popular name in the UK this year

12 Mb/sec to all homes in Aussie

Broadband is becoming one of the biggest, if not the biggest, issue in Australia for election year.

The Australian reports that John Howard will pledge to deliver a 12megabits-per-second service to all Australian homes.

That’s a huge pledge. The cost would be in the tens of billions I would say.

Sarkozy a dictator as he is too popular

It would almost be comic if it wasn’t so stupid. Remember how in France before the elections the Socialists (and all the world’s media) kept calling Sarkozy divisive etc.

Well now he and his party is proving so popular, the Socialists are now warning of dictatorship. He is the most popular President since Charles de Gaulle.

It’s now a bad thing to be popular, if you’re from the right.

World united

Sheehan responds

Muliaga “family spokesperson” Brenden Sheehan responds to his critics in the NZ Herald.

It is a most bizarre column. He claims that Fran O’Sullivan, who criticised him, has a conflict of interest on the Mercury Energy issue because she is chairperson of the New Zealand Apec Business Coalition.

Like me, you would be thinking, what the fuck has that to do with this.

Sheehan makes the link in his mind, that as this group promotes trade liberalisation, then they must be against “any moves to greater regulation, even if that regulation will save lives”.

To say this is a simplistic view of the world is putting it kindly. It’s bizarre.

Sheehan also now just refers to the Police as lacking sensitivity and empathy. This comes after he makes headlines calling them a bunch of racists. There is a big difference. We saw the same near u-turn when he almost demanded someone be jailed for what happened, and then as facts comes out he attacks the Police for even proceeding with an investigation.

One thing I agree with Sheehan on. He says “The kids have the right to know the circumstances that led to their mother’s death”. Indeed they do. So why is Sheehan trying to stop the investigation which will determine this?

National supports Dobson hydro project

It’s great to see That John Key has confirmed National’s support for the Dobson hyrdo project on the West Coast.

Unless one starts shooting people, our energy needs will continue to grow. A hydro dam in the area needing power, is pretty much the best way environmentally to meet that power need.

Dobson would make the West Coast self sufficient in power.

Fanaticism

I got e-mailed the passages below. While it’s a bit raw I do think it makes a very good point about how fanaticism prevails when moderates do not step up to condemn and stop them, and that this does apply to Islam. Of course the majority are not extreme fanatics, but history tells us that the fanatics win, unless moderates stand up to them and condemn them:

THOUGH RATHER RAW, THIS DESERVES A MINUTE OR TWO TO READ AND FORWARD. (author unknown)

A man whose family was German aristocracy prior to World War Two owned a number of large industries and estates. When asked how many German people were true Nazis, the answer he gave can guide our attitude toward fanaticism.

“Very few people were true Nazis “he said,” but many enjoyed the return of German pride, and many more were too busy to care. I was one of those who just thought the Nazis were a bunch of fools. So the majority just sat back and let it all happen. Then, before we knew it, they owned us, and we had lost control, and the end of the world had come. My family lost everything. I ended up in a concentration camp and the Allies destroyed my factories.”

We are told again and again by “experts” and “talking heads” that Islam is the religion of peace, and that the vast majority of Muslims just want to live in peace. Although this unqualified assertion may be true, it is entirely irrelevant. It is meaningless fluff, meant to make us feel better, and meant to somehow diminish the specter of fanatics rampaging across the globe in the name of Islam. The fact is that the fanatics rule Islam at this moment in history.

It is the fanatics who march. It is the fanatics who wage any one of 50 shooting wars worldwide. It is the fanatics who systematically slaughter Christian or tribal groups throughout Africa and are gradually taking over the entire continent in an Islamic wave. It is the fanatics who bomb, behead, murder, or honor kill. It is the fanatics who take over mosque after mosque. It is the fanatics who zealously spread the stoning and hanging of rape victims and homosexuals.

The hard quantifiable fact is that the “peaceful majority” the “silent majority” is cowed and extraneous.
* Communist Russia comprised Russians who just wanted to live in peace, yet the Russian Communists were responsible for the murder of about 20 million people. The peaceful majority were irrelevant.
* China’s huge population, it was peaceful as well, but Chinese Communists managed to kill a staggering 70 million people.
* The average Japanese individual prior to World War 2 was not a warmongering sadist. Yet, Japan murdered and slaughtered its way across South East Asia in an orgy of killing that included the systematic murder of 12 million Chinese civilians; most killed by sword,shovel and bayonet.
* And, who can forget Rwanda, which collapsed into butchery. Could it not be said that the majority of Rwandans were “peace & loving”?

History lessons are often incredibly simple and blunt, yet for all our powers of reason we often miss the most basic and uncomplicated of points: Peace-loving Muslims have been made irrelevant by their silence. Peace-loving Muslims will become our enemy if they don’t speak up, because like my friend from Germany, they will awake one day and find that the fanatics own them, and the end of their world will have begun.

Peace-loving Germans, Japanese, Chinese, Russians, Rwandans, Serbs, Afghans, Iraqis, Palestinians, Somalis, Nigerians, Algerians, and many others have died because the peaceful majority did not speak up until it was too late.

As for us who watch it all unfold; we must pay attention to the only group that counts; the fanatics who threaten our way of life.

Lastly, at the risk of offending, anyone who doubts that the issue is serious and just deletes this email without sending it on, can contribute to the passiveness that allows the problems to expand. So extend yourself a bit and send this on and on and on!! Let us hope that thousands, world wide, read this – think about it – and send it on

Carvell case dismissed

Excellent news. Radio is reporting that the JPs have dismissed the case against Greg Carvell. It’s traumatic enough to have your life at risk by a machete wielding criminal. Shooting the person would not have been an easy call – no-one likes shooting a human being, and I suspect that would have added to his trauma.

Now the prosecution is over, he can get on with his life.

New driver for the PM

Caption Contest Winner

299988.jpg

The caption contest got some very good entries at first. Later on some of the comments ignored the rule about being funny not nasty. But still some good responses overall.

Some of my favourites:

“After the last couple of polling cycles, I’m a lot more sympathetic to endangered birds.”
Posted by Craig Ranapia

Kevin Brady reacted the same way when I gave him a cheque too.
Posted by Wycroft

My Wife’s From Singapore!
Posted by anon

I’ve got a prime minister! I’m sure to win the scavenger hunt now!
Posted by slightlyrighty

Got ya.. There must be a hole in the pest free fence.
Posted by fishbowl

And the overall winner goes to Pete for

Following The Funeral, Helen Rescues A Grateful Labourer From Taito’s Immigrant Work Program…