And the result for NZers

Official Cash Rate hits 8%

Cullen sacks Coroner Garry Evans

The Dominion Post editorial really says it all when it comes to very regrettable decision of Michael Cullen to sack Garry Evans as Wellington Coroner:

Families all over Wellington who have endured the sudden death of a loved one that has required an inquest will be greatly saddened today to learn that Garry Evans has lost his job as Wellington coroner. Attorney-General Michael Cullen has terminated the appointment of a man who has presided over hundreds of inquiries and been courtesy itself to those left behind.

Mr Evans is nothing if not honest, which no doubt has not endeared him to politicians. Thus, in his 10 years on the coroner’s bench, he has forthrightly, but politely, excoriated those in positions of authority who have let the public down while also being unfailingly kind to mothers, fathers, sisters and brothers of people who have taken their own lives, suffered at the hands of the public health system or been wiped out in traffic smashes that might have been prevented.

No, it seems Mr Evans was just too straightforward for this Government to stomach.

Dr Cullen will no doubt protest that Mr Evans has served a decade in the role, is in his mid-60s and that, given those realities, the professional arrangements created by the new Coroners Act gave him an opportunity to appoint fresh blood.

His decision to effectively sack Mr Evans ignores – devalues, even – the work this lawyer has done to re-establish his office’s credibility. It also suggests – without having the courage to say so outright, of course – that Wellington public servants who have ministers’ ears have really resented his frequent blasts, always delivered with the greatest care and in elegant prose.

Mr Evans’ failing from the Government’s point of view, no doubt, is that he fell foul of Associate Health Minister Jim Anderton, who is not a man to turn the other cheek. Mr Evans is a supporter of making public more details after someone takes his or her own life. He accepts that silence about the epidemic of young, and not so young, men and women who decide life is no longer worth living has simply fostered an environment in which we have one of the world’s highest rates of suicide. Mr Anderton does not agree.

Mr Evans has done Wellington and its citizens a service by ripping strips off Capital and Coast District Health Board and its mental health services, which he deemed had let too many people down too often, as well as Transit NZ when it put money ahead of lives. No more.

This is how Wellington gained its nickname as Helengrad. The culture of retribution if you displease the Beehive.

Michael Laws to stand again

When Michael Laws, who became politically ambitious at around his second trimester, announced last year he would only do one term at Mayor of Wanganui, it was puzzling.

But it all makes sense now, as it appears he is poised to do a “I wanted to retire, but the people need me” and re-stand after all.

Those who suggest this was always part of a master plan, may not be wrong. Laws has a plan for everything.

Having said that, I actually think he introduced some necessary changes to the Wanganui Council and hasn’t done too badly. The nonsense of people trying to have him censured because he was mean to them, just increased sympathy for him.

The Carvell case

As interesting as it is to read reports of the depositions hearing, I do wish they would hurry to a decision. Of course Carvell technically broke the law by not having the gun locked away, but his law break allowed him to stop a crazed criminal from killing what may have turned out to be large numbers of people.

If it goes to a trail, the jury will, if they follow past form, ignore the law and find him not guilty because they approve of what he did.

The Crown Prosecutor has a tough job in convincing a jury that while they are not prosecuting Carvell for the actual shooting of the machete weilding criminal (as it saved lives), they do think he should have been unable to access the gun which allowed him to probably save his and others’ lives.

Dunne on Mercury Energy

Despite being a Minister in her Government, Peter Dunne is obviously unhappy at how the PM is exploiting the Mercury Energy issue. Extracts:

“I don’t know what the family’s position is, but I think there’s been a huge intrusion into their grief,” Mr Dunne told the Herald yesterday.

Asked if he thought the Prime Minister was among those wading into the situation, Mr Dunne made a general statement:

“I do think that politicians in these situations have to be very, very careful about not milking an awful situation for their own opportunity.

He said the proposals being put forward by the Government went beyond what the problem was.

“Thankfully, a case like this is very, very rare,” Mr Dunne said.

“There’s a real danger of going overboard, and creating a whole level of bureaucracy that won’t be necessary.”

He also attacks National, which is no surprise as he is a Government Minister. But to basically accuse the PM of exploiting the tragedy, is a ballsy call for a Minister.

5 – 0

The Press on Mercury Energy

The Press editorial yesterday compares what is happening with Mercury Energy to the Salem witch trials:

There is an uncomfortable sense of potentially inconvenient facts being trampled down before they can have an airing. If there is any “justice” at play here, it is the type pioneered in Salem a few hundred years ago.

Probably the safest bet about the circumstances surrounding Folole Muliaga’s death is that there will be more to it than has so far been clear. The Government, the Prime Minister and all those grandstanding should now pull back and let the full truth be found – not the version of it which best suits any wider agenda.

Hear hear.

Mt Crawford Prison

The Dom Post Editorial on Wednesday discusses the proposal to scrap Mt Crawford Prison (by enlarging Rimutaka) and turn that whole area into a tourism area.

I know that prison area well having camped on their grounds (when I was in Scouting) many times, and also having explored the disused underground WWII bunker in the nearby pine forest (it used to host a battery gun to get an enemy ship entering the harbour). Also the Massey Memorial is next door.

The views from up there are amazing and spectacular. It is an irony that a bloody prison enjoys the best views and probably most valuable real estate in Wellington.

So if it was practical I’d love to see it happen. It is an absolute waste of great property. However Mt Crawford has a more secure rating than Rimutaka so one couldn’t just expand Rimutaka. You would need to build a new Wellington Prison, and that would take years with the consent process.

Caption Contest

O’Sullivan on Mercury

Protecting the vulnerable

The Government has announced some measures to help protect “vulnerable” families from having their power disconnected.

Now there would be very few New Zealanders who would disagree with the intention. As a society there is a wide consensus that every family should be able to afford to have electricity (and food, shelter, clothing, education, some medical care).

Now personally I am a fan of having just one subsidy – the family’s income, rather than dozens and dozens of subsidies for various products. Rather than have special charges for rates, for water, for electricity, for telephones, I believe in having every family with a minimum income so they can afford those essentials. Hence we have benefits and family support/working for families. The more channels you deliver support to low income families over, the more complex it becomes. I’ll blog more on this at some other date.

Now one proposal from the Govt is to have power companies advise people facing disconnection of available assistance from Government and social agencies. In fact this is already recommended best practice and Mercury it seems had not been doing this. This can be done fairly easily by power companies with info on contacting WINZ etc on overdue statements and/or a special pamphlet about routes for assistance being automatically inserted into overdue statement envelopes.

The proposal for power retailers to proactively find out whether their customers are vulnerable or not before they disconnect power is far more problematic. I think it is useful to recall that obligations should be balanced, and that vulnerable families are better placed to let a power company know they are “vulnerable” than the power company can possibly be.

And unclear to me is what does a power company do if a family is vulnerable but still does not pay their bill. If they can never be disconnected for non payment, the number of vulnerable families will increase remarkably.

The notion that no disconnection can happen without MSD/WINZ approval may turn out to be a nightmare because every future disconnection will no longer be seen as a decision of the power company, but of the Government itself.

Half Price Gym Memberships are back

As they did last year, the good folks at FitnessNZ (the association of health and fitness centres) is offering half price gym memberships if you sign up by the end of the month.

You can go to this page on their website and just click the region you live in. It will then show you a list of participating gyms for that area. You click on the gym you are interested in, and it shows you a range of prices for three, six and twelve months, along with the normal and discounted price. Some pretty significant savings there. For Bodyworks where I go that’s a $650 saving on a 12 month membership.

Each gym has a limited number of subsidised places left (they are displayed on the website), with only 1,000 places nationwide so it will pay to move quickly. You can also purchase membership for friends and family so long as they are not current (last 12 months) gym members also.

What tough issues?

Helen Clark has explained away the drop in the polls for Labour as partly being because the Government has been dealing with tough issues.

It’s the sort of statement that people nod their heads at, and empathically agree with, without actually analysing it much. You see, if you think about it, the Government hasn’t been dealing with tough issues. The Government has mainly been dealing with easy issues and turning them unpopular.

Let’s think about what is a tough issue. This is something major that blows your plans out of the water. Examples are:

* Being told the day after the election the country is about to run out of reserves
* Being told the week after the election the BNZ needs a billion dollar bailout
* Learning the projected cash surplus is in fact a projected $5 billion deficit
* The Asian crisis

They are tough issues. Now let us look at the so called tough issues this Government has had:

* Foreshore & Seabed – all they had to do was appeal it to the Privy Council instead of panic.

* Taito Phllip Field – all they had to do was follow Richard Prebble’s example and condemn grossly unethical behaviour instead of defending it.

* Pledge Card – do not dismiss as a beltway issue, appear contrite, do not attack the Auditor-General.

* Smacking Bill – do not demonise 80% of NZers as morons who have been brain washed by the religious right. Search for good faith compromise at an earlier stage.

This Government has never really faced a tough tough issue. The economy has grown strongly enough that they have been able to spend on everything they can think of. They’ve never had to make hard economic decisions, they’ve never really had to choose between the right thing and the popular thing.

Sarkozy look set to win a parliamentary majority

French President Nicolas Sarkozy seems to be off to a good start, with polls showing between two-thirds and three-quarters of respondents approving of his job to date.

This is reflecting in support for his Union for a Popular Movement which polls predict is on course for 420 to 460 seats in the 577-member National Assembly. The first round of voting is this weekend.

Clark on Parliamentary Prayer

NZPA reports that Helen Clark is distancing herself and Labour from the review of the Parliamentary Prayer.

I have blogged previously that I think it should be retained but modified so it can be said by MPs of all faiths, not just Christians.

But the PM sees this as a talkback issue so is scared to have an opinion on it.

Miss Clark said she thought most MPs would not want the traditional prayer changed.

Yes well thank you for that unscientific opinion poll. But what they didn’t get the PM to state was her personal view on the prayer.

I find it somewhat frustrating that on the few areas I do agree with the PM such as republicanism and the role of religion in Government, she doesn’t have the conviction of her beliefs to take a stand and show some leadership

Mind you to be fair to her, she is hardly alone on that score!

Questions on power company credit control

The Government seems hellbent on some sort of expensive cumbersone regulatiory process involving WINZ, before it has any info at all about how the power company credit control process works.

Here’s a list of questions I would want answered before I even started making decisions:

1) What percentage of customers pay on time each month, and what percentage do not

2) What percentage pay after the reminder statement, the warning letter, the phone call and finally the courier letter?

3) What percentage and number get disconnected

4) How many of those disconnected immediately pay the bill (ie were just forgetful)

5) How much are annual earnings lowered by those customers not paying on time?

6) How do the credit control procedures change from company to company. is there an existing best practice that can be emulated?

7) How long does the household stay disconnected for?

8) Does a human review the list of households for disconnection or it automated?

9) If automated, is account taken of part payments as a sign of good faith?

That’s just from thinking about it for the last ten minutes. I hope Cabinet Ministers are going to ask similar questions and make decisions based on sound information, not a knee jerk reaction to bad polls.

Barack Obama on Net issues

Yes Prime Minister on Tax Cuts

This Yes, Prime Minister episode sums up Michael Cullen’s position on tax cuts perfectly. Just substitute Dr Cullen for where it says Treasury.

Hacker: Why is the Chancellor opposed to tax cuts.

Sir Humphrey: Because he is advised by the Treasury and the Treasury don’t believe in giving money back.

Hacker: It’s not theirs, its the taxpayers.

Sir Humphrey: That is one view, it is not the view of the Treasury once they’ve got their hands on it.

Hacker: But if they don’t need it.

Sir Humphrey: Taxation isn’t about what you need.

Hacker: What is it about?

Sir Humphrey: Prime Minister, the Treasury does not work out what they need to spend, and then think how to raise the money.

Hacker: What do they do?

Sir Humphrey: They pitch for as much as they think they can get away with and then think how to spend it. If you start giving money back because you don’t need it, you’re breaking with centuries of tradition.

Even 25 years on, it is still so true. Dr Cullen does see it as his money, not our money.

Madness

The Police have had to pay $8,750 to Carol Whatuira, a prison guard, because they notified the prison she had been charged with fraud!!!

And no she wasn’t innocent of the fraud. She pleaded guilty to the charges (which were lying to Police over a fraudulent insurance claim by her sister).

Her employment contract even specifies she must inform the prison if charged with fraud.

Personally I’m concerned that not only does she get rewarded for lying to the Police, but that Corrections still employs her as a prison guard. How can we take Corrections as being serious in stopping corruption when they allow someone who is party to a fraud, and thinks so little of the justice system that she lies to the Police, continue as a prison guard.

Yes she got diversion, and that would be fine in most other jobs to carry on. But one expects a much higher standard for prison guards.

No award again for Nancy Wake

If the Government doesn’t want to go the normal way of third term Governments, it could start by recognising Nancy Wake in the official Honour’s list.

Really it is pathetic to be making excuses for not honouring her, because she was *only* born here. This woman is a living legend and a hero. We should be doing everything possible to honour her and associate her with NZ. This woman is 94 years old and still boasts that she has kept her NZ passport from her infancy and self identifies as NZ over Australia. And Australia has made her a Companion of the Order of Australia.

National in its third term was just like this current Govt. More obsessed with following the bureaucratic guidelines, than doing the right thing. This is why in 1999 it got into a shitfight with Plunket over $500,000 for Plunket Line – it put its own regard for the “rules” above doing the right thing.

Will a single person in NZ be disadvantaged by giving Nancy Wake a NZ honour? No. Will it be hugely popular? Yes. So why is the Govt not doing it? Because it has third termitis.

Police racist for interviewing in English

Brenden Sheehan (whose union background is documented by Insolent Prick) has slammed the Police as racist because they interviewed family members in English and didn’t allow him to sit in on the interviews.

I am surprised that Mr Sheehan thinks that in a homicide investigation, he has some divine right to sit in on interviews. He is not the father of the children.

And as for the Police being racist because they interviewed the children in English. Well if they were tourists in NZ, I could understand such a complaint, but they have lived here for six years, and presumably attended school here for six years. If they are unable to speak in English after six years of schooling, we have a far bigger problem.

I am trying to think of a single other country where you could live there for six years, and then accuse the local Police of racism for interviewing you in the national language.

Could you imagine it in France?

Could you imagine it in Japan?

Could you even imagine it in Samoa?

And nothing in the article suggests a request was even made to do the interview in Samoan.

Meanwhile the Dom Post reports Cabinet is looking at forcing no SOE power company to disconnect power until the planned disconnection has been investigated by WINZ to assess the risks of turning the power off.

Now if there are 500 disconnections a day, I’d guess a WINZ staffer will only be able to do two assessments a day, including site visits, so that is 250 or so extra staff at a cost of $25 million or so (including overheads).

And I can’t imagine any WINZ worker will ever ever want to risk saying it is okay to disconnect, in case something bad happens. So I predict automatic financial assistance for anyone who has forgotten to pay their power bill.

I would have thought the sensible thing for Cabinet to do is to actually wait for the facts to be revealed in the investigation, before making major policy changes.

I’m not actually against power companies being slowed down from disconnecting (it should be a last resort, not a standard credit control feature), but kneejerk policy making rarely leads to sensible policy.

Democratic Presidential Debate

The second Democratic Presidential Nomination debate was held yesterday. Reason Magazine live blogged the event pretty amusingly. Some examples:

7:29: “Gov. Richardson, you’re kind of a Mexican. Should we kick out all the Mexicans?” (I’m paraphrasing.)

7:43: If we repeal the Bush tax cuts, can I have a lifetime supply of root beer and a perpetual motion machine? Because apparently repealing them would pay for everything.

8:28: Blitzer tries out the CNN version of the 24 question on… Dennis Kucinich. It’s actually not news that he wouldn’t kill bin Laden if given the chance, but it’s nice for the rest of the Democrats, who will disagree…

8:29: …Obama doesn’t disagree! No, wait, he does. He wouldn’t assassinate most people, but he would drop some bombs into Osama’s batcave.

E-mailed Joke

A guy goes to the supermarket and notices an attractive woman waving at him.

She says hello.

He’s rather taken aback because he can’t place where he knows her from.

So he says, “Do you know me?”

To which she replies, “I think you’re the father of one of my kids.”

Now his mind travels back to the only time he has ever been unfaithful to his wife and says, “My God, are you the stripper from my bachelor party that I made love to on the pool table with all my buddies watching while your partner whipped my butt with wet celery???”

She looks into his eyes and says calmly, “No, I’m your son’s teacher.”