A dilemma

A real dilemma. You are passionate about the issue of climate change. It’s your number one issue. The other thing you are passionate about is Tony Blair, and not in the good sense. You think he should be in jail.

And then Tony announces that after he is no longer PM, he wants to devote himself to saving the world from climate change.

No Right Turn gives us a pithy sound-bite of what he thinks of the idea.

What should be decided democratically?

ACT on Campus pose the question of where do you draw the line in regard to those things which should be decided democratically by society, and what should be individual choice.

So which of the following should be decided democratically:

* What everyone in New Zealand will wear tomorrow.
* What children should learn at school.
* What consenting adults be able should do in the bedroom.
* Whether it should be compulsory to wear a seatbelt.
* On what conditions people should be able to build, buy or sell a house.
* What colour people should be able to paint their house.
* How people’s healthcare should be paid for.
* How people’s healthcare money should be spent.

It’s a good question.

Why it is a PR stunt

Some people think I was too harsh labelling the Government’s new found enthusiasm for sustainability as a PR stunt. Firstly let me remind people that they have a track record of announcing bold goals and then dropping them quietly in a year or two. Who recalls getting NZ in the top half of the OECD for earnings? It was Helen’s over-arching goal, and now never mentioned.

Now let’s take one initiative – making the crown limos more emissions friendly. The Transport Ministry found a greener fleet could save 550 tonnes of CO2 emissions every-time the fleet is rotated. If that is every five years, that is 110 tonnes a year.

Now what is the total CO2 emissions for NZ. Wikipedia says 33,964,000 tonnes.

So what will this bold measure do. It will reduce emissions by 0.0003%.

Now in theory we need a 20% or greater reduction by 2012. So do you see how pitiful the announcement is.

Yes there is some merit in leading by example, but will the Government do anything beyond superficial PR stunts?

You see, if you accept that climate change is as bad as the Government says it is. If you accept that the PM’s goal of carbon neutrality is a good one, then you have to say why are they not proposing serious measures which will actually make a difference.

The reason they are not is because quite possibly people would be horrified by the cost. Helen gives us the rhetoric of carbon neutrality without being willing to be honest and say this would cost tens of billions of dollars. Because if she conceded that, then people might question whether carbon neutrality is actually such a desirable goal.

So the trick is to talk big, make some puff announcements and then blame someone else when our CO2 emissions keep on increasing.

The unforgiveable sin

So after 18 months of scandal, a damning Ingram report (Field was criticised 33 times in it), allegations of slave labour etc, Labour have finally acted against Taito Phillip Field. Because he did the one thing which can not be forgiven:

“You cannot have a situation where someone appears in the media cutting across my statement to Parliament as Prime Minister …”

In the spin obsessed world of Helengrad that is a capital offence – interfering with the media strategy.

I bet you she never sues

Mercedes Corby, sister of convicted drug smuggler Schapelle Corby, is claiming she will sue a former friend who claimed Mercedes has asked her to smuggle drugs and showed photos of the sisters smoking cannabis.

I predict the case will never make court.

I became convinced the charges against Corby were accurate when it was revealed that she had flown over to visit her sister in Bali around 30 times over the last few years. I’m sorry but a hairdresser can’t afford 30 trips to Bali, so working out the motivations and funding for the trips is not hard.

Of course the Indonesian sentences for drug crimes are ridiculously over the top, but Corby knew that when she started smuggling drugs in there.

Such timidity

The so called sustainability initiatives are so timid that they must have come from a brainstorming session of things which sound good but won’t actually achieve a thing. Let’s look at them:

* A one cent a kilo rubbish tax.
* A biofuels target of 3.4% by 2013 which will miss the Kyoto commitment period entirely
* A PR scam where six Govt Depts will plant trees to offset their carbon emmissions. This will represent (I guess – actual data welcome) less than 0.1% of emmissions I predict. At that rate by the year 3007 we may be carbon neutral.

This isn’t even tinkering at the margins. It’s less than that.

Field to be expelled from Labour

Was leaving Parliament at 545 pm and Duncan Garner next to me got a call from the PM announcing that Taito Phillip Field was being expelled from the Labour Party and would become an Independent.

At long last!! Finally.

So Kiwiblog has the scoop by a few minutes thanks to Vodafone datacards!

More info as it comes to hand. About to fly to AUckland so may not be until late tonight.

Well done to Labour for finally booting him, but absolute shame for taking so long.

UPDATE: Hold back on the congrats for Labour. They are not expelling him for being immoral or unethical. They are not expelling him for exploiting vulnerable constituents. They are not expelling him for slave labour. They’re expelling him because he speculated that he might stand for Mangere even if not the Labour candidate. Nice set of priorities.

A proposal re CYFS and CYFSWatch

It occurs to me that both CYFS and CYFSWatch are less than happy with the status quo re the CYFSWatch Blog.

CYFS has been unable to get the blog deleted. Further it has been unable to get personal details of its staff removed – something which must trouble it as an employer. And their attempts to get the site closed down have just ended up getting more publicity for it.

However CYFSWatch are not looking at all likely to get the resolution they want, which is some sort of review of CYFS. While they have succeeded in attracting many stories and many readers to their blog, their cause is not being taken up by those with the ability to get results. Why? Well CYFSWatch commented on their blog that I am almost the only media commentator who has stated some of the grievances on the blog appear genuine.

What may surprise them is that in private almost every journalist I have spoken to agrees that some of the stories are genuine and probably should be investigated. However because of the targeting of staff personally, they are reluctant to say things which may be seen as positive about the site. So the style of the site is why MPs and journalists are not rushing to take up the cause. Tough maybe, but that is how the world works.

Anyway I have an unsolicited proposal which both CYFS and CYFSWatch may want to consider so they both get something they want.

Firstly if CYFSWatch went through the blog and changed names to initials, stopped soliciting personal details such as home addresses of staff, and edited out unnecessarily nasty descriptions of staff, then that would be a sign of good faith. Make a pledge that you will concentrate on allowing people to have their say, without targeting individual staff.

In return CYFS then agrees to commission an independent review (with the reviewer being chosen by mutual consent between CYFA and a representative of disgruntled parents) of say a dozen of the cases highlighted on the blog. That independent reviewer to look into the grievances, and report back both on the grievances, but more importantly any changes which can be made to minimise future grievances (they can never of course be eliminated).

This way CYFS gets the personal details of staff members removed from public view, and CYFSWatch gets an independent look at some of the claims on their blog.

For if some compromise does not happen, then the stalemate of both sides being frustrated will just continue ad infinitum.

Atheist censored

Slashdot reports on how a popular atheist commentator has been kicked off You Tube. Why?

Well he was fine when he did videos pointing out logical defects in Christian beliefs, but when he turned his focus to Islam, he was kicked off!

Now a mirror of the video has been put up. And it consists of nothing more than a video showing quotes from the Koran. That’s it. Sure the quotes are ones which talk about killing people, but they are all actual quotes.

The double standard of so many in the media (and You Tube is media of a sort) towards criticism of Christianity and Islam is blatant. I want the right to be able to criticise both, but You Tube only acts when it is Islam.

The pinnacle of this was Comedy Central refusing to allow Southpark to show a harmless shot of Mohammed handing someone a fish, yet they allowed in the same episode Jesus Christ defecating on the US flag. Yes the double standard is that bad.

Royal veers left

Despite being the socialist candidate for President of France, Segolene Royal had been running on a fairly moderate platform. However having fallen behind in the polls she has veered sharply to the left in an effort to revitlaise her campaign.

She has released 100 proposals for France, including:

* raise pensions by 5%
* increase the minimum wage from €1,250 to €1,500
* guarantee a job or further training for every youth within six months of graduating
* reducing the number of students in classes.
* 120,000 new homes every year for the poor
* Councils to be able to confiscate empty homes
* windfall profits tax for oil companues
* government regulation of bank charges
* schildren to start school at three instead of six
* free tutoring for students that have difficulties keeping up
* tax companies in relation to what share of their profits is reinvested in equipment and jobs, and what portion is paid to shareholders.
* abolish a flexible work contract for small companies
* young women would get free contraception
* all young people would get access to a €10,000 interest- free loan
* handicapped would see their benefits rise
* lobby for the European Central Bank to consider not just inflation but also employment and growth when it sets interest rates

Of course not much idea of how this would be paid for. But you know I could almost hope she wins on this platform as introducing it would do over France nicely, and that can’t be an entirely bad thing 🙂

Immoral, Unethical and Unacceptable

Newstalk ZB reporterd yesterday that Helen Clark referred to Taito Phillip’s Field’s behaviour as having been “immoral, unethical and unacceptable”.

So the obvious question has to be asked. Why the hell is she allowing her Government to be proppsed up by an MP she considers immoral, unethical and unacceptable? Is there no level of behaviour so low that Labour will take action over Field, rather than keep taking his proxy vote?

This has nothing to do with the judicial and criminal process underway. The PM, like most of us, has been able to form a political opinion based on the masses of material in the public realm. But she will not allow the Labour Party Council or Caucus to take action to remove Field from their caucus.

So perhaps the motto for this Government should be:

“Immoral, unethical and proud of it”

Clark had the perfect opportunity to move against him when he annoucned he would not be co-operating with the Police any further. Her tolerance of this person, in return for his proxy vote, should not be forgotten or forgiven quickly.

Hey, who resurrected Muldoon?

And the next nominee for Best Actress in a drama series goes to Helen Elizabeth Clark for her portrayal of Robert David Muldoon ….

Yes the latest Muldoon tactic has been to threaten to cut off media access because Michael Cullen said something stupid, and gasp shock horror the media actually reported it.

And if people think the comparison to Muldoon is over the top, that comparison was not made just by me, but made on radio by a press gallery reporter who was actually there under Muldoon also.

I’m with Trevor on this one

The NZ Heralds reports on the TV3 scoop that the Government looks set to reject the $385 million Eden Park redevelopment plan for a $50 to $100 million minor upgrade and addition of temporary seating.

On the surface of it, I’d have to say Mallard may be right on this issue. If we can meet our world cup obligations and save the taxpayer around $300 million then I’m in favour. My only hestitation is the knowledge the bastards won’t actually give us any of our money back but find something else to splurge it on. But it might be something useful like a new road!

The sad reality is a permament 60,000 seat stadium at Eden Park won’t get the patronage it needs. The location is sub-standard.

A waterfront stadium with 60,000 seats might be sustainable, as might one at Carlaw Park. But neither of these options are viable in the time provided and are no longer options. In fact even Eden Park is approaching deadlines for it to be ready in time, so the Government should make its decision as soon as possible.

No change to laws on medicinal use of cannabis

Visiting Muslim Clerics Views

I’ve said on several occassions that NZ is very fortunate at the lack of extremist elements in the local Muslim community. However there seems to have been a regrettable lapse with the visits in 2005 of two clerics. What they preached in NZ is not known, but material, including DVDs, from their preaching in the UK and other countries include:

* told a programme last month that gays and lesbians should be put on trial for immorality, “and if they are tried, convicted, they are punishable by death”.
* claims Christian missionaries spread Aids by putting the virus in vaccines for tropical diseases such as malaria and yellow fever.
* says Jews will be exterminated on the Day of Judgment
* advocates a subordinate role for women
* urges followers to stop mixing with Christians and Jews because they were being defiled and polluted by Western culture.
* argues it was permissible to marry off a nine-year-old girl because the Prophet Muhammad had done so.
* said that Western culture was the enemy of Islam.

This makes the two clerics every bit as reprehensible as holocaust denier David Irving – in fact far more so.

The national Federation of Islamic Societies have said they would not invite them out again, now knowing what they know. Howvever the more radical Canterbury branch have said they would, and even suggests the comments are febricated by the media (despite most coming off a self published DVD).

This story is in the Press, but the expose was done by Investigate Magazine. And yes sometimes Investigate may do stories which in my opinion miss the mark, but the fact they are the only media outlet in NZ doing investigations like this one is a credit to them.

101 greatest things to do in New Zealand

The New Zealand Automobile Association have completed a five month survey which asked New Zealaders what their favourite areas / places in New Zealand are.

They have compilied a list of the 101 must do things in New Zealand for Kiwis.

The ones in bold are things that i have done

1.Mitre Peak and Milford Sound
2.Doubtful Sound
3.Bay of Islands
4.Fiordland National Park
5.Abel Tasman National Park
6.Aoraki Mt Cook
7.Coastal Kaikoura
8.Hanmer Springs
9.Camping

10.Tutukaka/The Poor Knights
11.Marlborough Sounds
12.Fox and Franz Josef glaciers
13.Ruapehu, Ngauruhoe and Tongariro
14.Waitomo Caves
15.Travelling the Southern Scenic Route
16.Otago Rail Experience
17.White Island (marine volcano)
18.Stewart Island
19.Arthurs Pass National Park
20.Tongariro Crossing
21.The Blue Pools of Haast Pass
22.South Westland
23.Waipoua Forest
24.Mt Taranaki
25.Lake Tekapo Observatory and Church of the Good Shepherd
26. Ulva Island (Stewart Is bird sanctuary)
27. Otago Peninsula
28. Canterbury Plains
29. Punakaiki (Pancake rocks)
30. Cape Reinga
31. Auckland Gulf Islands – Waiheke, Great Barrier, Rangitoto and Tiritiri Matangi
32. Kicking the autumn leaves (walking Outlet Track along the Clutha River, Wanaka)
33. Akaroa and Banks Peninsula
34. Glenorchy and Dart River
35. Farewell Spit
36. Queenstown (adventures)
37. Hokianga (Northland’s west coast)
38. Whanganui National Park
39. Cape Kidnappers
40. Lake Waikaremoana, Te Urewera National Park
41. Fine wines and fabulous foods
42. The Queen Charlotte Track
43. Lake Matheson (Fox Glacier)
44. Arrowtown
45. Orakei Korako (geothermal attraction, near Taupo)
46. TSS Earnslaw (vintage steamship)
47. Rotorua
48. Night skiing and riding at Coronet Peak
49. Dunedin City (architecture)
50. Mt Maunganui
51. Karangahake Gorge
52. Eastland SH35 (scenic coastal road journey)
53. Getting up close and personal with marine and wildlife
54. Hollyford Valley (and the Hollyford Track, Fiordland)
55. Hot Water Beach
56. Auckland’s west coast
57. Rotorua Luge, Skyrides, Skyswing
58. Kapiti Island
59. Marlborough wine trail
60. New Chums Beach, Coromandel
61. Christchurch City (beat that Auckland & Wellington!)
62. Mt Tarawera
63. Te Papa Tongarewa museum
64. The Bridge to Nowhere (Whanganui National Park)
65. Coromandel Township
66. Lake Taupo’s water attractions and Tongariro River
67. The Pinnacles
68. Te Mata Peak (Hawkes Bay)
69. Rotorua rafting
70. The Forgotten World Highway (between Taumarunui and Stratford)
71. Lake Wanaka maze
72. Moeraki Boulders
73. New Plymouth’s coastal walkway
74. Seafood City (Auckland)
75. Castlepoint (old seaside town)
76. Wainui Beach (Gisborne)
77. Ahipara and Shipwreck Bay
78. Buller Gorge
79. Taranaki Gardens
80. Cape Palliser (southernmost tip of the North Island)
81. Auckland War Memorial Museum
82. Raglan
83. Takaka Hill: Rameka Track Mountain (Abel Tasman National Park)
84. Whakarewarewa traditional Maori village, Rotorua
85. Waitangi Treaty Grounds
86. Rere Rock Slide, Gisborne
87. Spa and well-being (Nelson)
88. Auckland’s Sky Tower and Skyjump (not the jump)
89. Devonport and North Head
90. The Interislander
91. Auckland volcanoes
92. Central Otago
93. Port Waikato
94. Golf in an Alpine Amphitheatre (Queenstown Golf Club)
95. Hundertwasser toilet (Far North)
96. Wellington Writers’ Walk
97. Cross-country skiing (Lake Wanaka)
98. Stonehenge Aotearoa (marking the winter solstice Downunder)
99. Rugby Museum (Palmerston North)
100. Beehive and Parliament buildings
101=. Attend a Must-Do Event, North Island
101=. Attend a Must-Do Event, South Island

Hat Tip: Morph Blog

Aussie Greens go bonkers

Super 14 Results Week Two

Okay 26 points again for me in Week Two. Again got four out of seven wins predicted, and on two of them the right points margin also.

I bet against the Hurricanes and they did win (sigh), against Western Force (who caned the Stormers) and against the Blues (who narrowly beat the Brumbies).

My combined score of 52 sees my global rank drop 5,716 to 37,563.

The bloggers challenge (name: NZ Bloggers, password: dpf) has 69 people in it now and I am in 20th= place.

Globally the top players are four people with 90/112 points.
The highest score for this week was Shane Philips with 42/56. Over both weeks Jeremy Greenbrook-Held leads with 65 points to 64 for Jon White. Well done guys.

It’s the annual cork count time

Corks%2010%20Feb%2007.JPG

Yep another year has gone by and DPF and friends have consumed a few hundred bottles of wine. The question is how many exactly?

The jar in the middle is the last 12 months. The left hand jar is the 2004 count with 393 corks (including 15 stelvin caps). The right hand jar is 2005 at 456 corks (including 81 stelvin caps).

So post your guesses for 2006 for total bottles of wine. Bonus points if you also get how many are corks and how many are stelvin caps.

Twisted Hankies

Tracy Watkins in the Dom Post uses a quaint phrase in her column about Labour and John Key:

It might be too soon to say that John Key is shaping up as Labour’s worst nightmare. But some Labour MPs are already twisting their hankies in frustration at the warm glow of publicity that has surrounded the National leader in the first few weeks of the year.

Mortgage Levy gone by lunchtime

The Press Editorial labels Dr Cullen’s suggestion of a mortgage levy as the fastest retreat in recent times, and definitely gone by lunchtime.

They go on to conclude:

If he were serious about getting New Zealanders off borrowing to sink money into unproductive domestic property and on to saving and investing in productive industry – as our dire balance of payments numbers tell us we should do – he would undertake a thorough-going and sophisticated reform of the tax system to make productive investment more attractive.

Cullen has for long been a sure-footed political operator. But the scornful reaction even from those who are nominally his political allies shows, not for the first time recently, that some of his skills may be getting rusty. Is he perhaps, after all his years at the top, becoming a liability?

WCC goes mobile

The Dom Post reports that the Wgtn City Council is going mobile in a big way. Over 90% of their 1,350 staff will have mobile phones only.

This is the way of the future. I recall at Parliament that almost all staff had cellphones and almost everyone had their landline set to divert to their cellphones after a few rings so in reality one could have cut out the landlines all together for most people.

The key reason to have a landline is so people can call it locally at non toll rates. But one can still arrange to have a “nomal’ phone number for your cellphone without needing the entrie cost of a landline.

Field to continue on full pay

Labour have indicated that even if Taito Phillip Field is charged, they will still continue to use his vote in Parliament and he will continue on full pay.

As ACT showed with Donna Awatere-Huata, a caucus can take action to expel an MP for misbehaviour regardless of criminal charges. The standard for retaining the trust of your colleagues should be a hell of a lot higher than “has not yet been sent to prison”. There is plenty of evidence upon which to conclude his behaviour has been inappropriate. The PM has even labelled it unethical and the EPMU concludes he is unfit for re-selection.

Yet Labour are willing to remain propped up by an unethical MP they would not re-select.. What sort of standard is that? About as low as one can go.

The irony is that Labour are praying he will be charged (hence why political sources are l;eaking that way). This means they can keep taking his proxy vote throughout the trial and up until sentence, which might not be until after the election. They can keep claiming they are unable to act before the trial (which is totally false).

But if he is not charged then Labour will have to make a very quick decision on whether to allow Field to resume his duties or to exclude him from Caucus.

Digital Copyright Workshops

A final reminder that Wellington workshop on the Digital Copyright Bill is on Tuesday and the Auckland one on Wednesday. It isn’t too late to RSVP. This bill will affect almost every New Zealander who has a VCR, an IPod, uses an ISP etc. Submissions are open until end of the week.

Full details of the workshops are online here.

It’s a top line up of speakers, with I am sure a wide variety of views. They include:

* Peter Dengate-Thrush, a patent attorney and barrister specialising in intellectual property law and Internet law. Former President of InternetNZ and a Director of ICANN

* Chip Dawson, President and Chairman of the NZ Software Association, Co-Chairman of ICTNZ

* Clive Elliott, a barrister and patent attorney. past co-chair of the Intellectual Property and Entertainment Law Committee of the International Bar Association, vice president of the Intellectual Property Society of Australia and New Zealand (IPSANZ) and co-convenor of the Intellectual Property Committee of the New Zealand Law Society.

* Susy Frankel, Associate Professor of Law at VUW on intellectual property law and international trade. A co-author of the textbook “Intellectual Property in New Zealand” and also an independent Hearings Officer for the Intellectual Property Office of New Zealand.

* Peter Gutmann, A researcher in the Department of Computer Science at the University of
Auckland working on the design and analysis of cryptographic security architectures. Helped write the popular PGP encryption package.

* Chris Hocquard, a principal of Dominion Law, a specialist entertainment law firm that looks after the affairs of entrepreneurs, artists, musicians and other creative people. He is
also the founder of www.amplifier.co.nz, New Zealand’s leading online music resource.

* Dr Stephen Marshall, Senior Lecturer in Educational Technology at the VUW University
Teaching Development Centre. Member of the Ministry of Education
Tertiary E-Learning Reference Group and Chair of the E-Learning Directors of the New Zealand
Universities Group.

* Brent McAnulty, Senior Counsel for Telecom, responsible for content, emerging technologies, Telecom’s television and music issues, and its agreements with media organisations. Also responsible for intellectual property within Telecom.

* Dr Owen Morgan, a leading intellectual property academic at the University of Auckland. An author of the New Zealand text, Copyright and Design. Also an advisor to the Media and Advertising Copyright Board.

* Rick Shera, a partner at Lowndes Jordan a specialist corporate, commercial and ICT law firm. Involved in many IT organisations including current Chairman of NetSafe and a former VP of InternetNZ.

* Clark Thomborson, a Professor of Computer Science at the University of Auckland, Has published more than 100 refereed articles on topics in software security, computer systems performance analysis, VLSI algorithms, data compression, and connection networks.

* Jim Thomson, solicitor for Television New Zealand, and practices mainly in the law relating
to media and intellectual property, including copyright, defamation and privacy; and information
technology, licensing, telecommunications, and competition law.Was chairperson for twelve years of the copyright committee of the Asia-Pacific Broadcasting Union, and is the founding and current chairperson of the New Zealand Media and Advertising Copyright Board

* Nathan Torkington, identifies, comments on, and commercializes technology trends for O’Reilly Media, in which capacity he blogs at http://radar.oreilly.com/ and is co-chair of the Open Source Convention He also builds Internet businesses through He Hononga Software in New Zealand.

* Bronwyn Turley, Manager of the Ministry of Economic Development’s Intellectual Property
Policy team responsible for providing policy advice to government on intellectual
property issues.

* Andy Williams, has spent time managing bands, producing music and
hosting radio and is presently the New Media Manager of LOOP Media Ltd & LOOPdigital.

The Truth

I was fascinated to read in the SST that former NBR Investigations Editor, Jock Anderson, has been hired by the “new” Truth as chief reporter.

I think that is a highly significant move that the new owner is determined to do what he says – turn Truth into an investigative newspaper breaking scandals and more stories about the way bureaucracy runs the lives of New Zealanders.

It will be interesting to see how they go.