More food for more schools

Well despite the best efforts of the Government in denial, you can’t keep a good idea down. The Herald reports:

1) Tasti Foods is donating 100,000 (especially produced to meet mutritional needs) snack bars to KidsCan allowing them to increase their programme from 3,000 kids to 8,000.

2) Red Cross and Countdown joining forces to provide meals at all 200 decile one primary schools. Except I presume Wigley Primary who have declared they have no problems.

The Red Cross initiative precedes John Key’s speech, but highlights I think the common sense fo his approach- correctly identifying there is a problem there, but also it is not one just for the state.

The Greens, showing their red roots, have called for the state (taxpayer) to fund breakfasts for every primary pupil in NZ. I think that would be horrendous. Let there be no mistake that the primary responsibility for feeding your kids is with the parents. Some parents are not doing this (and it is not just a case of money) but the vast majority are, so let us not expand the role of the state to providing food for all. I wonder of there is a single thing in society which the Greens don’t think the State should fund and provide?

Anyway I look forward to Phil Goff attacking the Red Cross for daring to suggest there are hungry kids. Goff has stated for a fact there are no malnourished kids in his electorate.

Fronde

Went to a nice breakfast yesterday to mark the relaunching of Synergy IT as Fronde. Consultus kindly invited me along.

The breakfast was great fun as they had a debate on whether we would all be better off if all companies were run by IT people. Willie Jackson as compere just insulted everyone with good humour. The debaters were Tom Scott, Phil Lewin and a former NZ Post CIO for the affirmative and on the negative Forysth Thompson from Fairfax, Rowan from Trade Me and Alick Shaw.

I wouldn’t do justice to try and summarise a humourous debate, but one line which stuck with me was the one from the former NZ Post CIO about what do you do if an IT projects fails. The answer is “Call it Phase I” 🙂

Free advice for Labour

A question for Labour:

Are you all bloody morons?

What has happened to the Labour Caucus’ collective brain cell. Through a mixture of over-reaction, denial and stupidity you have now managed to keep John Key’s speech and initiative on the front page of every paper for the last fortnight. What the hell are you thinking?

Let’s recap.

John Key gave a speech and it focused on the underclass and said we want to focus on how to break the cycle of failure for these families. And he put up a couple of examples of things one could do such as encouraging local businesses to assist local schools with kids who turn up hungry.

Now it wasn’t the invention of the century, but neither was it at all a bad idea. Labour’s response should have been:

“We are glad National recognises the problems of an underclass. We’ve been working on dozens of programmes to help out, but realise there is still work to be done and welcome any suggestions they want to make”

Do that, and the issue is dead within days.

But what do we have? Helen first claims the underclass was created by National, then claims they have all but fixed it. Then she refuses to go visit it. And others claim it is no more than 1,000 families in total.

But then even better after the launch of the foods for schools programme, Phil Goff comes out and declares he has never ever seen a hungry or malnourished kid in his electorate. Then one group comes out estimating as many as 15,000 kids may go to school without proper food and Clark denounces that as far too high. So what happens – another report is found suggesting 80,000. Now the PM is doing nothing but talking about this issue.

Doesn’t matter what number is right. You’ve now kept Key’s issue in the media for two weeks, and managed to portray the Government as one of denial and out of touch.

The really stupid thing is there is no need for such a defensive reaction. Key is not saying the fact these kids are hungry is all the state’s fault. In fact he is carefully shying away from making feeding of kids a state responsibility. He’s just said, hey let’s help out as a community, where for whatever reason kids are at school malnourished (because this interferes greatly with learning).

In fact this should be the sort of politics everyone wants from an Opposition. people complain about Oppositions blaming everything on the Government and never offering solutions. Well Key wasn’t blaming everything on the Government. He was just saying we have a problem and this may help.

But of course one can’t have an Opposition actually seen to be doing something, so suddenly Wesley Primary turns down the assistance saying there is no need for it. This is despite the local intermediate school having estimated as much as 25% of kids not having had breakfast or lunch. When was the last time any school turned down donations? Unheard of.

And if anyone thinks the Government wasn’t involved, I have a bridge for sale for you. Of course the Minister didn’t phone the Principal. That isn’t how it works. Either the local MP whispers in the ear of a member of the school board, or you talk to the Comrades in the PPTA who talk to the local PPTA official. And they talk to the principal. Trust me – I’ve seen this done hundreds of times.

Anyway it’s been sort of fun seeing a so called Labour Government act like the 1950s UK Tory Party, claiming there’s no problem here. I suspect they will wise up soon though.

Thank God for Auckland Regional Council

It looks like we owe a big debt of thanks to the Auckland Regional Council for stopping the Mallard Stadium.

Documents released yesterday reveal that the Ports of Auckland had said the project *could not* be completed on time.

The Minister, no doubt backed with advice from Fletchers, had scribbled “rubbish” on the letter.

But no not even Fletchers, who stood to make millions from the stadium, thought it could be done. They also had said it “is not realistically achievable” and there would be “massive problems” with pursuing another site at “this late stage”.

So whose advice was the Minister relying on? Judith? Helen? Auntie Mavis?

RIP Alan McDiarmid

How many carbon debits?

So how much carbon debits were created by all those Ministers who decided to take their crown limos from Parliament to Premier House? It’s a 5 minute walk and one minute drive. Include waiting and warmup time.

In other news Helen was re-elected Labour Leader today. About as surprising as the sun coming up in the East, but to be fair to Helen it is a notable achievement to be without rivals or challengers after 13 years in the job. Bolger in his third term as PM of course fell to a coup.

Not Achieved Mathematics

Under what circumstances can you claim an increase from 315 to 370 is a decline?

When you’re the Minister of Education spinning teacher vacancies!

Sorry Steve: Not Achieved NCEA Maths

maharey.JPG

UPDATE: A reader sends in this image of Steve’s exam result. Also NZPA is now reporting that his office claims that there were in fact over 400 vacancies last year and the 315 relates to the number of advertisements, some being for multiple vacancies. This just proves further Labour’s spin – instead of giving the true numbers last year they tried to make them sound smaller by giving the number of advertisements instead of vacancies. No wonder we are cynical.

Congrats to Kakariki

Islam says BDSM is okay

Hey according to the Islamic Q&A site, Allah approves of BDSM. To quote:

Q: Im a man who desires to be beaten up during sex (BDSM) is it Islamically correct to do it??

A: Every form of permissible intimacy between the husband and wife is a mutual
one with mutual understanding and agreement. If the husband and wife
mutually agree on “BDSM”, that is their choice, for which there is no
prohibition in Shariah.

So that’s Iman Panty Slut Boy to you!!

Hat Tip: Tim Blair

O’Sullivan on climate change

Fran O’Sullivan takes a measured look at the 4th IPCC report.

As I have done, she laments the tendency of some NZ greenies to label sceptics as deniers,

What the true believers are trying to do is put anybody who expresses some scepticism over man’s contribution to the global warming phenomena on the same level as Holocaust deniers.

They are painted as dangerous nutters who must be put down in case they infect the rest of us with the notion that man might not be the main culprit in global warming but that other influences such as sunspots might also be part of the mix, and that a doomsday outcome which wipes man off the planet is by no means inevitable.

So looking at the UN report, what has been little reported is how much back pedalling there is from earlier reports:

Rising sea levels are a case in point. In the 2001 report, the UN’s best high-end estimate for the rise in sea levels by 2100 was 90cm. But the best estimate in the upcoming report is said to be 43cm.

The 2001 report is also said to have over-estimated the human influence on climate change by a third.

There is a case to be made for action to both lower greenhouse emissions and mitigate the effects of climate change, but these should be based on solid analysis of costs and benefits not scaremongering over the end of the world.

Waitangi Day

A poll on Radio NZ found 55% of NZers do not consider Waitangi Day significant to them personally. Even amongst Maori only 74% found the day significant.

Now this is not a reason not to have Waitangi Day, We should. The 6th of February should always be commemorated, and it should be called Waitangi Day.

What I have always supported is having a New Zealand Day also, on a separate date. Maybe on 26 September – Dominion Day.

Waitangi Day will always to some degree be a day focused on Treaty grievances, and this aspect will dominate.

But it would be nice to have a New Zealand Day which unashamedly focused on the positives and achievements of New Zealand and New Zealanders. Doesn’t have to be jingoistic but there is so much great about this country, it would be nice to be able to celebrate that once a year. Being the first country to give women the vote, the achievements of Hillary and Blake, the film achievements of many Kiwis, our literature, our wine etc.

Mad bar owner

There must be something in the tap water down in Christchurch. A local bar, well named the Grumpy Mole Saloon, kicked out two teenage girls for kissing on the dance floor.

What is the bar owner thinking? Rather than ban it she should pay them to come back everynight. I’m sure their takings will increase.

Finally an opportunity for the Human Rights Commission to be useful.

UPDATE: Stuff has more info, plus a photo!

Blaming no 8th Maori seat on Immigration

People will have seen that last week Tariana Turia rather ungraciously blamed the failure to get an 8th Maori seat on Immigration.

Now apart from the fact we need immigration to replace our own citizens leaving for overseas, Turia is also wrong on the facts.

You see the number of immigrants in NZ does not affect how many Maori seats there will be – only the number of immigrants in the South Island. Because it is the South Island general electoral population which is used to calculate the number of seats in the North Island and Maori seats.

Around 83% of immigrants live in the North Island. A mere 17% settle south.

From 2001 to 2005 there were 430,000 new residents. Just 75,205 settled in the South Island. But 60,653 South Islanders left for overseas so net migration only added 15,000 people to the South Island electoral population.

Now in 2001 the SI general electoral population was 868,289, and divided by 16 seats is a quota of 54,268. The Maori electoral population was 371,765 and divided by the quota gives 6.85 seats – rounded to seven.

In 2005 SI general electoral population was 920,747, and divided by 16 seats is a quota of 57,547. The Maori electoral population was 416,700 and divided by the quota gives 7.25 seats – also rounded to seven. So first thing to note is the number of seats sort of did increase from 6.85 to 7.25 – but rounding meant no physical increase.

Now what if we take 15,000 net migration away from the SI population. That is around 915,000 SI electoral population which is a quota of 56,563. The Maori EP divided by this is 416,700/56,563 which is 7.37.

Hence even if there had been no net migration into the South Island, Maori would not have gained an eighth seat. Turia is wrong with her blame.

CYFSWatch spawns

Kiwiblog Jan 2007 Stats

Average Visit Duration: 393 seconds

Visits by Country

New Zealand nz 285140
Unknown Unknown ip 88430
Network net 84994
Commercial com 58619
Australia au 18794
Austria at 10497
United Kingdom uk 3267
Canada ca 2028
Germany de 1863
United States us 1722
Brazil br 1617
Netherlands nl 1608
USA Educational edu 1562
Czech Republic cz 1472
France fr 1327
Japan jp 1104
Saudi Arabia sa 1092

Visits by Hosts

tur-cache2.massey.ac.nz 3240
smtp.enterprise.co.nz 1953
pspc18-241.parliament.govt.nz 1687
smtp.enterprisemedical.co.nz 1672
inetgate.msd.govt.nz 1428
node5.moh.govt.nz 1275
smtp.enterhamilton.co.nz 1057
gate1.ird.govt.nz 1040
apngw6.apn.co.nz 1006

Most Visited Pages

/2007/01/the_cyfswatch_blog.html 2732
/humour/ 2430
/2007/01/blogger_drinks_tuesday.html 1849
/2007/01/is_this_rape.html 1783
/2007/01/last_time_theyll_leave_anderto.html 1332
/2007/01/nuking_iran_1.html 1299
/2007/01/a_very_good_speech.html 1291
/2007/01/idiotic_aussie_flag_ban.html 1261
/2007/01/important_questions_on_global.html 1015
/2007/01/that_evil_woman.html 1008
/2007/01/contacting_dpf.html 1003

Operating Systems

Windows XP 73.8 %
Windows 2000 5.9 %
Mac OS X 4.6%
Windows 98 3 %
Windows 2003 1.8 %
GNU Linux 0.9%
Windows Vista (Longhorn) 0.9 %
Windows NT 0.7 %
Windows Me 0.7 %
Ubuntu 0.5%

Browsers

MSIE 6.0 41.3%
MSIE 7.0 17.6%
Firefox 2.0.0.1 13.9%
Firefox 1.5.0.9 8.0%
Mozilla 2.8%
Safari 2.7%
Opera 2.3%

Inward Referrals

http://www.bloglines.com/myblogs_display 878
http://briefingroom.typepad.com 822
http://www.scoop.co.nz 749
http://72.14.253.104/search 470
http://norightturn.blogspot.com 288
http://andrewfalloon.blogspot.com 194
http://blog.greens.org.nz 186
http://asianinvasion2006.blogspot.com 153
http://www.netvibes.com 152
http://www.sirhumphreys.com 151
http://www.freespeech.org.nz/section14 148
http://newzeal.blogspot.com 127
http://www.vuw.ac.nz/staff/dean_knight/000.htm 118
http://www.investigatemagazine.com 105
http://home.nzcity.co.nz 104

Search Phrases to find Kiwiblog

kiwiblog 1208
david farrar 1206
cyf blog 605
cyfswatch 348
cyfs blog 194
keisha castle-hughes pregnant 172
jayden headley 156
kiwi blog 148
farrar 135
cyps blog 110
keisha castle hughes pregnant 106

Cute puppy photos

My friend, Accident Girl, now has two Griffon puppies as one wasn’t enough. The slightly larger and older one is female and the new smaller one male.

dogs1.JPG

They spend most of the day battling each other, and in this case over the stuffed tiger.

dogs2.JPG

And then they sleep. Very cute.

However one small problem has developed. The little male dog refuses to submit to the larger female dog and in fact seems to umm quite like turning her over and licking and nibbling in a particular area. And it has got so bad, the female now has a bald spot in that area. For some reason Accident Girl doesn’t like me proclaiming that her new puppy gave her other dog a Brazilian 🙂

Cactus Kate on John Key

Cactus Kate reviews Key’s performance as National Leader to date and his earlier career and concludes “In short, John Key must be either the luckiest bastard on the planet, or more likely completely and utterly brilliant.”

And Kate’s actually not a fan of the more centrist agenda of Key!

Will NZ First pay it back?

The NZ Herald editorial warns NZ First they are onto a hiding for nothing if they do not pay back the $160,000 the Auditor-General found last year had been illegally spent on their behalf.

NZ First certainly have a right to challenge the AGs finding in court. But it is looking farcical that five months on they still haven’t managed to make a decision and solicit a legal opinion on the issue. Either they are incompetent beyond belief or are stalling for time.

Even if they do decide to seek a legal review, it is possible that by their own actions it is now impossible. You see if one went along to the court today and said is this expenditure on these pamphlets and ads legal, the court could only answer “yes” because of the validating legislation.

Now one could try and ask the court a hypothethical question such as “if the law had not been changed, would this have been legal” but my understanding is the Court will say “Piss off Noddy, we do not give hypothethical answers on hypothethical laws”

I welcome any pointers to cases where Courts have given a hypothethical ruling on a hypothethical law. Perhaps they do if they are not very busy, but I would be surprised.

So if the validating legislation has made any court challenge from NZ First pointless, then there is no reason for them to delay paying it back.

Four new ONZ Members

Four additional appointments have been made to the top ranked Order of New Zealand.

They are Sir Brian Lochore, C.K. Stead, Sir Paul Reeves, and Sir Owen Woodhouse.

While all four are, in my opinion, worthy additions to the Order, I do disapprove in principle of them being additional appointments to take it beyond that limit of 20. The reason it is the top honour is because it is restricted.

The answer is not to not appoint people like Sir Brian and C K Stead, but to have been more discriminating with some of the previous appointments like Geering and Hunt.

UPDATE: The Press Editorial agrees with me about the quality of some of the previous appointments, but they are less subtle labeling Hunt’s inclusion as “an exercise in effrontery and political cronyism”.

Oh yuck yuck yuck yuck yuck

Rare great days

The weather the last few days has been great – just wish we had it over Dec/Jan. Last night was at a friend’s place where they have an outdoor spa and BBQ. It’s in Roseneath so a gorgeous view of the city and sunset. Spent around five hours enjoying good food, beer and wine (and company). Only interruption was doing the TV interview for the late news 🙂

We need more long weekends, especially those that coincide with good weather.

Because stupidity deserves a wider audience

Normally when people allege awful deeds against me in the comments, I respond to them there. But a couple of them this week have just been so stupid that they really deserve front page attention.

First we have Toms in the cartoon debate:

I wonder, could you speculate that DPF has been our own little Fox-lite since he got his orders at the training session run by the Moslem murderers at the freedom ranch? I mean, using the “anti-semite” as a tool to squash debate is a very neo-con thing to do.

So is it just a coincidence? Just speculating you know, and I am not saying DPF consorts with people who murder Moslems.

Its amazing what you can get away with when you are just thinking out loud.

Yes I am obviously under orders from the “Moslem murderers” at the freedom ranch. Well done Toms – you Einstein you.

Then we have Hayman in a debate over Matthew Hooton’s column:

As for silly threats seems like you are passing IP adresses to Hooten so that those that crticise this toady can be victimised. Laughable

Oh again such a towering intellect has worked it all out. Next he’ll be exposing the moon landings were faked.

I did last week mention that I had once passed on an IP address to a journalist regarding a comment made about that journalist. The brilliant Hayman deduces I must be referring to a political comment and it must be about Hooton.

Never mind that it was a female journalist, and the comment was highly personal (and defamatory), and not at all political.

Let’s not let facts get in the way. Just make up a fact and accuse me of it.

I should run a competition for stupidest comment of the week. But there would be too many entries to get through.

A new description

I need to start keeping track of all the titles the media bestow on me when quoting me. Today according to Newstalk ZB I am a “Internet specialist”. Is that like a medical specialist? I hope the pay is the same.

Other titles I have received are:

Freelance Journalist
Political Commentator
Blogger
Internet Journalist
Technology Commentator

I’m going to need to get a bigger business card to fit them all in 🙂

Incidentially the item was about the CYFS Watch Blog and how think it was unwise to repost an item Google had deleted as at the end of the day Google won’t keep playing the game of delete, repost, delete, repost, delete.

UPDATE: Now on the late TV One news on the same topic.

The answer for Mr Cohen

In Friday’s NBR there was a half page feature by David Cohen about online readership, prompted by this blog entry.

It’s not online, so I can’t link to it, but at the end the author posed the question about why Trade Me was only listed at No 2 in the Alexa ratings when they are commonly reported to make up half the NZ traffic to websites. David actually suggested I should answer this query online, so here goes:

The answer is they measure two different things.

Alexa measures websites visited by New Zealanders. Neilsen Net Ratings measures websites hosted in NZ.

So the Alexa data includes global websites such as Google and the BBC. They are reporting their data based on whether the person visiting is from NZ.

The Neilsen Net ratings measure traffic to NZ hosted sites. This data will include visits from overseas. They are looking at whether the site is a NZ site.

So Trade Me gets the most visits of any local NZ site, and is No 2 in the list of all sites visited by NZers.

I should make a cautionary note that all data is somewhat suspect. There is no canonical ranking. TTLB uses Site Meter to measures blogs relative visits, Google Analytics measures many sites, Alexa measures those who use their toolbar etc. All had their pros and cons. All can suffer from under and over counting.

It is possible that most of the visitors from parliament to this site only count as one visit because they share the same IP address for their proxy. So they get undercounted. But on the other hand someone on a dialup account who visits multiple times per day gets double counted if they have a different IP address each time.

That’s why trends are more important than individual ratings in my opinion.

Flags and Republics

I’m fairly amused by how much coverage there has been on whether the tino rangatiratanga flag will fly on the Harbour Bridge, or One Tree Hill etc. At the end of the day I don’t care greatly either way.

But there is a lesson here about why it does get so many people heated up. For decades the flag has been portrayed as the flag of Maori sovereignty. To the average NZer they read that as a flag rejecting the Treaty of Waitangi, rejecting a pakeha presence in NZ and rejecting the concept of New Zealand. It is seen as making a highly political statement. You can argue whether it should be seen at that, but it is.

A “Maori” flag which was promoted just as a flag of Maoridom, of the united Iwi etc would I predict receive far less resistance. It might even come to be embraced by all NZers over time as part of NZ. Just as the Scottish flag is part of the UK, even though it is also a symbol for some to push independence.

The story linked to above also reports on a TV3 poll which found 52% were against a referendum on a new flag. I respect the current flag as our official emblem but am certainly one of those who would like a change to something which incorporated a silver fern.

The other interesting poll result was 53% said the issue of becoming a republic should be looked at, with 39% at this stage already in favour. That is a sign to Parliament that if the private member’s bill seeking a referendum on the issue is drawn from the ballot, they should allow it to proceed.