Now dairies are to be targeted also

The Auckland City Council is not content with its silly plans to ban billboards in the CBD, but now wants to regulate how much advertising there can be even on the corner diary.

I don’t care what party these people belong to. Can someone please organise a ticket which will kick off the Council every single Councillor who votes for such regulations.

Don’t they think Auckland has some bigger issues to confront rather than telling Mr Smith how many sandwich boards he can have outside his dairy.

The next step will be for the Council to demand that it approves in advance any advertising throughout the city.

Police now on the job

Yesterday blogs covered how Police were too busy to investigate an assault, despite the complainant having gathered witness statemnets, photos, licence plates and owner registration details.

Today I’m pleased to report that the Police have phoned Mike to say they are now on the case.

To eb fair to the Police, it is not the fault of the cops on the ground when they don’t have enough officers or they are forced to spend half their time on traffic duty.

But what was regrettable in this case was you had a complainant who had done everything possible to make the investigation as easy as possible for the Police. You don’t want to discourage people who do this.

ADSL2+ from March

It’s good news that ADSL2+ will start to roll out in March. If you live close to an exchange or cabinet you should be able to get 24 Mb/sec speeds.

However unless backhaul capacity and international capacity is increased significantly, then the extra speeds will be on paper rather than in reality.

IPCC 4th report

Russel Norman extracts some stats from the 4th IPCC report. There’s a couple in turn I want to comment on:

now warming at about 0.13C per decade

So by the time our kids die, at current rates the average temperature would be 1.3 degrees higher in 100 years.

Sea level rise now about 3.1mm per year

So again in 100 years, sea levels on current rates may be one foot higher.

Now even an extra foot is undesirable I agree, but what I hope to see is sensible economic debate about the costs of reducing carbon vs the cost of adapting to warmer temperatures. A mixture of both is needed of course, but the debate always seems to focus on the former only.

The big unknown also is what will be the state of our technology in 100 years. 100 years ago there was almost no commercial plane travel, no computers, no space travel, no nuclear power, no Internet etc. We have no idea what out level of technology will be in 2100. Now this is not a reason to do nothing at all and wait for the great invention, but it is a reason to doubt the most extreme fear-mongering scenarios. With the right incentives human innovation is brilliant.

All fine here, move along

Labour wants to renege on pledge card repayment

Labour is set to renege on its commitment to repay the $800,000 it owes the taxpayer. It will refuse to pay if NZ First suceeds in legal action. Hence they are urging NZ First to take legal action.

To understand the extent of this hypocrisy one has to be reminded of Darnton v Clark. This was a lawsuit filed around nine months ago which sought a High Court declaration that the pldge card expenditure was illegal and not an authorised use of Parliamentary Service funds. Labour voted to wipe out this lawsuit (about as constitutionally offensive as one can get is to use your role as an MP to wipe out a lawsuit in which you are personally named as a respondent) through its validating legislation, and refusal to allow an amendment to leave the lawsuit untouched.

So they voted to kill off a lawsuit which would actually have answered the question on whether the Auditor-General was correct or not in his treatment of the pledge card. If Labour had a shred of good faith interest in having a definitive answer, then they would have left the lawsuit alone.

Any sucessful legal action from NZ First, will not mean that the Auditor-General was wrong on everything. The Court for example might find that one pamphlet for NZ First should not have been included. That does not mean Labour’s pledge card is suddenly valid. The AG made decisions on over 100 seperate items of expenditure. One or two may be boundary calls but that in no way means they all are.

If Labour want to avoid paying their $800,000 they they should have voted to not wipe out the Darnton v Clark lawsuit. That would have provided them with the definitive answer. The fact they did vote to wipe it out, suggests that they knew they would lose massively.

A distasteful cartoon

Two blogs have already commented on this cartoon by Trace Hodgson in the Herald on Sunday. They’re Hitting Metal and http://www.whaleoil.co.nz/node/3627.

carthodg.jpg

The premise of the cartoon is fine, comparing a political party to a gang.

The Nazi swastika on the helmet is grossly offensive to both National supporters and those who fought or died in WWII. The cartoonist made a deliberate choice to include the swastika when the cartoon would have worked without it, so one can only presume he intends some significance by it.

Finally there is the suggestion that the portrayal of John Key is anti-semitic. Key is not Jewish in a religious sense, but as his mother was Jewish he is considered by some to be “technically Jewish”. I suspect such a label irritates him but the media have often focused on it, so it is relatively well known now.

Is Hodgson’s caricature anti-semitic? On the one hand Hodgson is known for doing offensive caricatures of almost all his subjects. That is his trademark. But on the other hand the massive nose, glowing eyes and fanged teeth seem to lie uncomfortably close to the traditional anti-semitic portrayal of the “devilish Jew” as described here.

At the end of the day I can’t conclude one way or another. The glowing eyes add little to the cartoon except to make Key look demonic, but it may just be artistic licence.

What definitely was over the top though is the portrayal of the Nazi swastika. The Herald on Sunday may wish to consider how comfortable it is with such a portrayal – even in cartoons.

Cactus Kate vs Rachel Glucina Round II

Not Infrastructure Bonds

Craig Foss points out that the Government’s so called infrstructure bonds are nothing of the sort – that’s just Labour spin for them. They are not tied to infrastructure projects and in fact might be used to fund student debt etc.

Craig suggests if you want to issue a real infrastructure bond for an infrastructure project, how about “Mallard Stadium” bonds!

Virtual Super 14 competition

Not the best of starting weeks. I got four out of seven results right, and two of those by the right margin. However I did not pick wins for the Highlanders, Brumbies or Reds.

I’m ranked 31,847 out of 143,733 or so – with 26 points.

No one scored a perfect 56, but 11 people scored 53.

For the bloggers challenge, the top three placed are:

Noizyboy – 37 – 2,305th place
aklr@large – 36 – 4,249th place
nzrckstr – 34 – 4,499th place

Of the 61 in the challenge I am in 15th= place.

The challenge is “NZ Bloggers” and password to join “dpf”.

The top two rugbyheads were Grant Nisbett and Melodie Robinson.

Silly threats in the UK

In the UK a couple of bloggers have been at the forefront of exposing some of the sleaze and lies of the “New Labour” Government. They constantly have broken stories which the media picks up. This means that in turn they have started to be targeted by Government supporters.

One of them, Iain Dale, recounts in the post some of the various threats he has received. They range from a two page newspaper feature to expose how his blog is funded, to a lawsuit from “someone big”.

Now the hilarious things is the anonymous person making the threats told Iain that he should make sure his house is in his wife’s name.

Incidentially, Iain is gay.

Idiots.

Hooton on Cullen on Key

Matthew Hooton writes on how Labour has tried to portray John Key over the years.

When Key first became nationally recognised in 2005, Michael Cullen’s tactic was to kiss him to death, praising him for his integrity, life story and moderation.

But when Key proved he could better Cullen in any TV debate, the finance minister’s veneer faded. Key became “adolescent”, “silly” and “hysterical”. By October last year, Cullen was labelling him a “working-class scab”.

Then Matthew quotes from last weekend when Key got criticised over the fact that even though his family was poor, he had “middle class aspirations”. Good God how dare someone has aspirations.

As the Star-Times revealed last week, Key’s critics now deny he was ever truly working class at all. “The Key family, they say, was working class only in income. Its culture and its aspirations were middle or even upper-middle class.”

Hooton then comments on the debate about is there an under-class:

Key’s underclass is not about whether people are in work or between jobs, the size of their benefit, or whether their teenage kids get into trouble from time to time.

Key’s underclass is made up of people who experience material deprivation but, more importantly, cannot even imagine the aspirations that were clearly part of Key’s home – aspirations Labour and its cronies apparently so deride.

It did the prime minister no credit this week that she so quickly became our first official underclass denier. She also offered the flawed view that, if there is an underclass, it is all the fault of the “failed policies of the past”.

Every New Zealander knows there is an underclass, if only because we know we too often avert our eyes.

If we’re not being partisan, we also know the causes are complex and probably global.

An underclass exists in almost every developed country, from socialist France with its massive youth unemployment to the bastion of capitalism, the United States.

It is silly to say it is all the fault of welfare changes 16 years ago or too much mollycoddling by Labour. Just as silly is to say Working for Families handouts to the middle class, or tax cuts alone, are the answer.

One reason the parole system does not work

Several people have posted comments on this blog about assaults involving Graeme Burton while in prison. As I suspected the allegations were correct, with the SST reporting Burton has:

* attacked a fellow inmate, putting the man in hospital, just months before he was released
* broken a Rimutaka inmate’s arms in 2002
* pressured another inmate to stab a named guard

One of the great myths of parole, is that it provides an incentive to behave while in prison. I even used to believe this. The trouble is, it doesn’t. Over the last few weeks I have learnt that the Parole Board does not get the full record of what a prisoner does while in prison. They mainly just get a list of courses they have completed. Little or none of the above info went to the Parole Board.

Why? Because parole is treated as a right not a privilege and they only get told information which has basically been prosecuted in court. And 95% of violence in prison is never prosecuted so the parole board doesn’t get the information it needs to judge if someone is a risk.

Every prison officer in NZ knew Burton was a violent thug who would offend again. But the system stopped their knowledge from being considered. It’s madness where the rights of the prisoners are given a higher priority than the rights of the community to be safe.

It also totally undermines one of the key rationale’s behind parole – to give an incentive to behave in prison.

So here is the first change that should be made to parole. The parole board *must* be given a prisoner’s full prison record including suspicions over involvement in crimes. Of course the board should not treat a suspicion as strongly as something which has been proven in court, but 95% of prison violence never goes to court.

Now some may argue this goes against human rights to take into account crimes not proven. But parole is not a right but a privilege. The criminal has already been found guilty beyond reasonable doubt of the crimes they are in prison for. This is about whether they get the privilege of parole. And to earn that privilege they need to have outstanding behaviour while in prison.

Unless the parole board is given full information on a prisoner’s behaviour while in prison, parole will continue to fail.

Private Schools now cheaper than some Public Schools

Zoning policies (which often stop popular schools from getting bigger) are leading to an increase in private school registrations.

Why?

Because it is cheaper to pay the up to $10,000 a year private fees than it is to pay a premium for a house in the right school zone. The premiums are estimated to be:

Christchurch $30,000
Wellington $50,000
Auckland $100,000

One thing people often don’t realise with zoning is it isn’t just about allowing studebnts to attend their local school. If only. It stops good schools from growing if there is a bad school nearby under capacity.

Here’s an example. School A is very popular because it has a respected Principal, high standards, excellent academic results and good sports and culture activities. It has capacity for 1,000 pupils and has all 1,000 place filled up with 980 from within the zone and only 20 outside.

School B used to be as popular but a change of principal has seen it decline. Staff and pupils have been leaving. It has capacity for 800 and now only has 600.

Now School A has 100 more students who would like to attend. So it applies for permission to put on a couple more classrooms so it can take 1,100. Then it can take everyoen in zone and out fo zone – ie all those who want to attend it.

But the Government looks at the city/town and says no no no. There is spare capacity at School B. We will not allow any more extensions at any school until School B is full up. Never mind people don’t want to go there anymore.

Zoning would be far less of an issue, if it was not accompanied by building restrictions on popular schools.

Kerre vs Bloggers Round III

Kerre Woodham defends and explains her column of last week calling for anonymous bloggers to be stopped.

Referring to the CYFS Watch site, she says:

I was not suggesting that those with a gripe against CYF were malicious cowards. That sobriquet was reserved for those anonymous bloggers who resorted to personal attacks and vicious abuse of CYF staff.

There’s some confusion here between what a blogger is, and people who respond to blogs. A blogger is the actual persons or person who run a blog. Here that is me. At Public Address it is the eight or so authors. And at CYFS Watch it is the anonymous person who set it up and solicited stories.

All those people who sent stories in are not bloggers. They are just people who e-mailed the blog owner with their stories.

In relation to talkback radio allowing anonymous callers Kerre says:

Talkback radio and blogs are very different beasts. There is a degree of control, for better or worse, on radio which means no one is allowed to resort to personal attacks. If I’d allowed a caller to say some of the things written on the blog, the company would go for a skate and damages would be paid out to the offended party. And even though callers might withhold their real names and numbers, they can still be traced if they need to be held accountable for their statements. Most amateur webmasters don’t exercise that same responsibility.

Kerre is right that radio gives you more control. Each medium has its pros and cons. Blog Debates *can* be of a higher quality than talkback debates as people can go away and do research and link to it when participating in the debate. Factually wrong statements get challenged far more on blogs than on talkback. Again this is not saying A is good and B is bad, just that different mediums have different pros and cons.

And despite what many think, one can trace most people if you need to, through their IP addresses. One commenter on my blog said highly defamatory things about a journalist and I supplied their IP address which allowed them to be traced quite easily. Especially when that IP address had also been used to edit Wikipedia etc.

Kerre also is unconvinced at the need for bloggers to remain anonymous for their safety:

And as for the argument that bloggers need to remain anonymous for their safety – please! That might hold true in Iraq, but I don’t think a C-grade media studies graduate has much to worry about as he taps away on his computer in Glendowie.

I’m not sure I have heard people argue it is necessary for their safety (in this country) but there are many legitimate reasons why people want to be anonymous. Those who work in the public service would be the biggest category. Others may work for a firm which does a lot of Government business. Others may have a boss who politically disagrees with them and would make life hard if he or she knew their views. These are not hypotheticals but actual cases I know of. And some just don’t want their names in Google for every future employer to see.

Finally it’s good to read that Rachel (Cunliffe I would guess) has been introducing Kerre to a wider realm of blogs. That’s great because yes there are some shit blogs out there, but there are also many amazing blogs – especially those devoted to a single issue or topic.

Coddington on Key

Deborah Coddington gives the Key speech a very big thumbs up:

When Key first came to Parliament I thought he was a yappy puppy but I was wrong. He’s got guts.

It’s very chic right now to bang on about being carbon neutral, but the people Key cares about don’t have the luxury of choosing organic food, fuel-efficient cars, double-glazed homes.

So, above all, I loved Key’s speech because at last, it seems, we have a party leader who’s not afraid of the cynics. If he can convince the Maori Party to help him, together they could turn around the lives of our desolate.

Mugabe’s Success

Zimbabwe was once a relatively sucessful country.

Today unemployment is at 80%

Inflation is at 1281%

Interest Rates are at 500%

The exchange rate is now 3,000,000 dollars for one US dollar.

Mugabe’s income redistribution plans by “sharing” farms out has certainly worked. It has redistributed almost all income overseas.

Police no longer investigating assaults

This is just disgraceful. Michael Earley was (allegedly) assaulted by a thug last week in a road rage incident. He filed a complaint with the Police.

He provided not only the numberplate of the car the assailant was in, but also a photo of him, details of two witnesses to the assault and even the name of the car owner, which he paid for himself to look up.

The Police have responded saying they are too busy to investigate the assault at this stage!!!

This is unacceptable. Assault is a serious crime. The victim has done everything possible to make it easy for the Police. All they need to do is contact the car owner and interview him.

And how many traffic tickets were being handed out over the last week, at the same time as they claim to be too busy to investigate an assault?

Violent crime investigations should always be a priority over other police work.

Visiting McGehan Close

The Herald on Sunday went with John Key to McGehan Close:

Joan Nathan was ready to detest the man who’d verbally run down her street before the whole country.

But by the time National leader John Key had finished yesterday, the McGehan Close resident was promising to vote for him, and he was arranging to take her daughter Aroha, 12, to Waitangi on Tuesday.

Also nice to see that a good idea can spread quickly, with Tasti Foods stepping forward to offer free food for hungry school kids. National has put them in contact with Wesley Primary which will be the first school participating in this programme. It’s rare you actually get to do something in Opposition, beyond criticise, so this is a very good thing.

Good to be male

Science Myths

Below are 20 common beliefs. Only six of them are actually true and the rest are myths. Can you guess which ones are true? Answers from Live Science.

Personally I think it is every five seconds for No 14.

1. Chickens can live without a head.
2. Water drains backwards in the Southern Hemisphere due to the Earth’s rotation
3. There is no gravity in space
4. Humans use only 10 percent of their brains
5. Eating a poppy seed bagel mimics opium use.
6. A penny dropped from the top of a tall building could kill a pedestrian
7. Adults don’t grow new brain cells
8. Chicken soup can cure the common cold.
9. Yawning is “contagious”.
10. Lightning never strikes the same place twice
11. A dog’s mouth is cleaner than a human’s
12. Hair and fingernails continue growing after death
13. A falling cat will always land on its feet.
14. Men think about sex every seven seconds
15. You get less wet by running in the rain.
16. The five second rule
17. Animals can predict natural disasters
18. Seasons are caused by the Earth’s proximity to the sun
19. The Great Wall of China is the only manmade structure visible from space
20. It takes seven years to digest gum

Hat Tip: Marginal Revolution

CYFS Watch reposts a deleted post

Antarctic Lemur reports that Google has deleted one post from the CYFS Watch Blog, as a breach of the terms and conditions of their service, yet the blog owner has reposted the item.

The post deleted had the following statement:

If you read this [name deleted by DPF]….Note my name and NEVER ever forget what you did to Leighton and Royce…I’m watching and waiting and never far behind you.

I actually support Google on this one. That is too close to a threat for my liking. In fact Google have been relatively restrained by only deleting the one post, not closing the entire blog down. Ironically the blog owner by reposting the deleted item has probably opened up the grounds for the entire blog to be deleted.

If so, the only person to blame is the blog owner, not Google or CYFS or the Government. If you deliberately ignore a decision taken by the site owner, then you can’t be surprised if they take action.

It’s such a pity. I think there does need to be a commission of inquiry into the CYFS culture. There are just far too many stories about bullying, threats and intimidation when there is no need for it. But for all the good CYFS Watch has done in bringing these stories up, it harms its own case by not exercising common sense or judgement over what is appropriate to publish.

What sort of anarchist would I be?

Okay I’m not really much of an anarchist at al, but I do tend to rebel against authority.

You scored as Anarcho-Capitalist. Anarcho-capitalism is perhaps more closely linked the libertarian tradition than anarchism as it favours a free market and a stateless society. Private businesses would replace the functions of the state. This form of anarchism is largely an American phenomenon and first emerged in the 1950s (although it arguably has its roots in 19th century individualist anarchism and classical liberalism). Key thinkers include Murray Rothbard.

Anarcho-Capitalist

100%

Anarcho-Communist

50%

Anarcha-Feminist

35%

Anarcho-Syndicalist

30%

Anarcho-Primitivist

15%

Christian Anarchist

10%

What kind of Anarchist are you?
created with QuizFarm.com

Hat Tip: Kakariki

Listen to the Judge

The High Court Judge who is hearing the case of the machete wielding man who tried to rob a gun shop, has taken the very unusual step of commenting on a future case and expressing his concern that Greg Carvell has been prosecuted on firearms offences. The Judge said:

“I am most concerned that Mr Carvell, acting in his own defence and in the defence of another employee, is facing serious criminal charges,”

The Police should take the hint and drop the case. There;s not a jury in NZ which will vote unanimously to convict Carvell and from the sounds of it not many Judges that would either.

All the Police are doing with this misguided action is costing Carvell money and damaging their own reputation.

McGehan Close

The NZ Herald talks to some of the residents of McGehan Close, after John Key used it as an example of the “under class”. Somethings which the article does little to dispel with the reference to so many of the kids wearning gang colours.

But what amused me was one resident claiming he had lived in worse streets than this, the exact quote being:

“That’s all shit – there’s worse underclass streets than this. There’s definitely worse places than this – I lived in Palmy [Palmerston North],” says 27-year-old machine operator Jason Thompson.

I love the attitude. We may live in the worse street in Auckland but at least we don’t live in Palmerston North 🙂