Poll on Brash

Telecommunications Amendment Act

On Wednesday appeared as part of the InternetNZ team before the Finance and Expenditure Select Committee regarding the Telecommunications Amendment Act. Our submission is here as a pdf.

As this is a more controversial issue than spam, censorship laws, I thought it could get somewhat more partisan than previous times I have appeared, but I was again really impressed with the session.

There were many really excellent questions from MPs on all sides, showing they understood the issues, and were very focused on how effective various solutions will be. Paul Swain, Shane Jones, Lockwood Smith, Chris Tremain and Maurice Williamson were the main contributors. We talked about the rural issues, the incentives for investment, the network bottleneck and the next generation network.

Despite spending many many hours swotting up for hardball questions, there turned out not to be any. The questions were all designed to get information rather than challenging the need for any change. So I read Bronwyn Howell’s 150 page submission for nothing 🙂

Not just from our session, but also from the others such as Orcon and Ihug, I’m feeling pretty confident about some good improvements to the bill, when it is reported back. MPs were quite shocked to hear that if you move home and your ISP is Xtra then Telecom can have your broadband reconnected the day you move in, while if you are with another ISP you can be without broadband for 1 – 2 weeks. This is a classic example of the problem with vertically integrated monopolies.

One of the points we made to the committee was how the debate over just six months has moved from is the status quo acceptable, through whether or not LLU should happen (it is), also through whether or not Telecom should have some sort of separation (it is) to what sort of separation should there be (accounting, weak operational, strong operational, structural).

Getting the right separation scheme in place is the long term solution, rather than regulation which tries to make incumbents behave better.

DPF on Agenda

Got asked late yesterday to appear on TV One’s Agenda on Saturday morning, so am flying up to Auckland this evening instead of relaxing in Wellington.

I’m to be one of the two “panelists” along with John Roughan from the NZ Herald. Gerry Brownlee is one of those being interviewed.

Seeing I will be in Auckland on Saturday will probably pop into the Young Nats conference in Ellerslie. With Don Brash appearing, it will probably have the highest media attendance of any Young Nats conference in recent times!

In-Tray and Sideswipe

Sideswipe today highlights one of the funnier comments made this week on this blog.

And NBR’s In-tray has a brief mention of (presumably) me as Ahmed P Farrar, Nigerian businessman.

The In-tray article is over the break, being a Labour parody of the Nigerian 419 scam.
Continue reading »

Food Miles

One of the arguments used by groups such as the Greens when they argue against free trade, is that of food miles – that the further food has to travel to market, the worse its impact on the environment.

Lincoln University has shown this theory to be absolutely wrong, and just an excuse for protectionism. They found that Britain uses much more energy as New Zealand to produce products, including the energy used to transport the goods.

* a tonne of milk solids – twice as much
* lamb – four times as much
* apples – 40% more
* onions – 30% more

Hat Tip: Jimmy Jangles

al-Qaeda targets France

Wise Up!

I always think that marrying a prisoner (esp one in for murder) is a bad idea. There’s been a lot of research into why women do it, and off memory it is the fact they are dependent on you and needy for you, so you feel valuable – you are the most important person in their life.

But when your husband is cheating on you, despite being in prison, and has now become a serial text messager of his genitals to other women, it really is time to wise up.

Meanwhile what does it say that for months on end Scott Watson has been able to keep accessing cellphones in prison.

Today’s Brash Coverage

Most attention is on the news that Don Brash will resume his public duties today. The NZ Herald suggests this doesn’t mean a 100% decision to stay on, but that he will decide over the next couple of weeks. They also quote from the e-mail Don sent to Caucus yesterday:

“Guys, I strongly believe that we should not respond in kind to the comments about my personal life which Labour threw in my direction in the House last week.

“We don’t want to descend into that kind of politics. I therefore ask that none of you refer, directly or indirectly, to any of the gossip/rumours about the private lives of any other politicians, or their families. It is pretty clear that the public do not like this stuff, and even if they did we should stay away from it – it can only distract attention from the important issues which should be our focus.”

The Herald also looks at the behaviour of Mallard and Benson-Pope and whether it represents a new low.

And the NZ Herald editorial says that Labour should not get away with not paying the money back, due to the publicity of the (alleged) affair.

The Dominion Post compares what has happened to the 1976 Moyle Affair.

Finally the Dom Post editorial has a warning for Labour:

Attention has been deflected away from the mounting body of evidence that Labour abused parliamentary funding and the parallel evidence that Labour MP Phillip Field privately benefited from his public position.

But this is grubby politics that could yet backfire on Labour. One of Mr Mallard’s colleagues is presently the subject of a particularly ugly rumour. The rumour has not been substantiated, may not be true and may never come to light.

But if it does, Labour will have no grounds for complaint.

By fossicking in the private lives of its opponents, it has made the private affairs of its MPs fair game for any who choose to profit from them.

UPDATE: Good commentary on Radio NZ this morning with Kathryn Ryan and Matthew Hooton.

MP reduction bill not to proceed

The Justice & Electoral Select committee have recommended unanimously that the Electoral (Reduction in Number of Members of Parliament) Amendment Bill by NZ First MP Barbara Stewart not proceed.

I put in a submission (word doc) opposing the bill on various grounds – the main two being it would break the electoral system, and that we already had one of the smallest Parliaments in the world.

Many of the points in my submission seem to have made it into the report, as well as the table of country populations and sizes of parliaments I compiled which is their Appendix B.

So nice to see one’s submission has been of value.

Hat Tip: No Right Turn

Others pay it back

National had a nice fresh approach in the House yesterday on teh issue of Labour’s refual to pay back the $800,000.

They looked at all the other areas where people have to pay the Government back money. They include doctors, pharmacists, rest-home providers and other health-care providers.

Also hundreds of thousands of beneficiaries, and every taxpayer.

And who thinks the IRD will let you off a debt if your excuse is your auditor never told you it was wrong.

The law is the law. If the expenditure is illegal, it must be paid back. If you refuse then it is a sign you consider yourself above the law.

Electricity Shambles

Pundits should not under-estimate how messy the sacking of the Electricity Commissioner is. Labour set up this position. This was their solution. They appointed him.

And even worse they misjudged him. As they pushed him out, they were pretending it was a retirement, and he blow their lines out of the water by saying he was pushed out because he stood up to Governemnt interefence.

It will be very hard to get a replacement as they will be seen as a stooge, and not independent.

Typekey

Common Sense Prevails

Normally we have to rely on juries for common sense in the justice system, which they supply when they time after time let off the farmer who fires some pellets at the burglars.

This tme the common sense comes from Judge Louis Bidois who discharged without conviction Constable Jonathan Erwood for driving with excess blood alcohol, after an off duty Elwood delivered oxygen tanks to a crash scene as no-one else was available.

The Judge went on to say he hoped Elwood kept his job, which I am sure he will do.

Moderation is on

Until people calm down a bit, I have turned moderation on. That means you will have a wait of a few minutes (when I am at home) to a couple of hours (when up at Vic Uni later today0 for comments to appear.

If yours do not appear then try rewriting it so it does not refer to flys, zippers etc.

Air NZ Internet options

Air NZ is consulting on what passengers want in terms of cellphone, e-mail and Internet access on planes.

Here is what I want:

Domestic

Voice Calls – not needed for domestic flights

Texting – would be very very useful to be able to send and receive texts – can advise people that you are landing etc.

E-mail – Mobile E-mail through a Blackberry would be useful

Internet – no need for an on-plane service but would be good if those with mobile broadband could access it, if they desire.

International

Voice Calls – these could get very annoying to other passengers, yet are in theory possible anyway through on-flight phones. Would be nice to allow cheaper calls through cellphones but maybe restrict use to business class where one can talk in a less intrusive way

Texting – yes very desirable

Internet (inc e-mail): An on-flight option like the Boeing service is highly desirable. I would choose an airline which has Internet availability over one which does not. Would be willing to pay around $50 to have this available for a 12 hour flight, as it means you day is not wasted.

A Boris apology

UK MP Boris Johnson offended the Papua New Guniea Government when he wrote:

“For 10 years we in the Tory Party have become used to Papua New Guinea-style orgies of cannibalism and chief-killing, and so it is with a happy amazement that we watch as the madness engulfs the Labour Party.”

His apology is a classic:

I would like to thank the High Commissioner very much for her clarification.

I meant no insult to the people of Papua New Guinea who I’m sure lead lives of blameless bourgeois domesticity in common with the rest of us.

My remarks were inspired by a Time Life book I have which does indeed show relatively recent photos of Papua New Guinean tribes engaged in warfare, and I’m fairly certain that cannibalism was involved.

It seemed a perfectly fair, florid, flowery metaphor for what’s going on in the Labour Party.

I’d be happy to show the book to the High Commissioner but I’m of course also very happy to take up her kind invite and add Papua New Guinea to my global itinerary of apology.

Brash Coverage

Again I would caution people to restrict debate to known facts, and to show some sensitivity is discussing issues.

Grant at NZ Pundit has an excellent post called “Reaching New Lows” which I heartily endorse.

The NZ Herald reports on the speculation on Don Brash’s future. It is ironic that questions of leadership had gone away after the party conference and that media had been noting Brash had been front-footing it in the House. While one’s personal life should not be a factor, it is inevitable that until Don returns to work, speculation will occur.

The NZ Herald also confirms the multiple mentions of the affair in the House by Trevor Mallard. I have also been told by journalists that Labour Cabinet Ministers has been pushing the story around the gallery very actively over the last fortnight trying to persuade someone to run with it. While Brian Connell provided the opportunity to classify it as legitimate, let there be no mistake that Labour have shattered the conventions on MP’s private lives.

Audrey Young canvasses the political ramifications.

Lonelygirl15 is a Kiwi!

Canadian School Shooting

Comments Deleted

It’s going to take me too long to individually delete the dozens of inappropriate posts, so instead I have had to delete all comments made since around 2 pm. Apologies for those who get their comments caught up in the mass deletion.

Brash on a break

I couldn’t blog this earlier as I was with clients and then at select committee, so by now most will have seen the story about Don Brash taking a few days off to work on problems in his marriage.

One of the absolute turnoffs for becoming an MP is that issues in your private life become a matter of public notice. It’s awful both for the MP but equally so for their spouses and children.

I would ask any commenters to comment in a fashion which they would like others to adopt if talking about their family.

Corruption and Morality

The NZ Herald picks up yesterday’s story that Labour have decided not to pay the money back, regardless of what the Auditor-General says in his final report.

Transparency International warns that NZ’s reputation (we are currently second least corrupt in the world) will be damaged if Labour refuses to repay taxpayer funds unlawfully spent on campaigning and changes the law to make it legal. They’re not wild on anonymous donations either but our current rating is done on the basis of current law which allows them.

They say “Any retrospective changing of the law to legitimise something that was previously illegal we would criticise in the strongest possible terms.”

This backs up my stance – Labour are not corrupt for the original decision to fund the card from the taxpayer, but they certainly will be acting corruptly if they refuse to pay it back once the final Auditor-General report confirms their illegality.

The NZ Herald editorial is headlined On a path to true corruption and warns that Labour’s plans to ban or severely restrict third party advocacy during elections is a slippery slope which can form the way the way to truly corrupt a healthy, open democracy.

Finally former Labour MP and historian Michael Bassett answers the question, whether there are precedents for the large number of scandals Helen Clark experiences with her Cabinet and MPs. The answer is no, to little surprise.

Priceless

Useful summaries

Police called in over e-mails

The Dom Post reports that National has called in the Police over the stolen e-mails. Good. It should have been done months ago.

Nixon lost the presidency over covering up a burglary of DNC HQ for useful information. In more recent US elections tapes of debate prep have been “leaked” to the opposing candidate and they are always treated as a police matter and in fact not handing it back is judged unacceptable by the electorate.