The DDT Debate

Last October I linked to a column by Roger Kerr on how many green crusades have been responsible for human misery and environmental damage.

Specifc reference was made to the campaign against DDT with the ideological ban on its use leading to a resurgence in malaria and an estimated 50 million deaths.

Of course many many people attacked such a notion.

Last week the New York Times reported WHO was supporting wider use of DDT across Africa:

The World Health Organization on Friday forcefully endorsed wider use of the insecticide DDT across Africa to exterminate and repel the mosquitoes that cause malaria.

Dr. Arata Kochi, who leads the group’s global malaria program, unequivocally declared at a news conference on Friday that DDT was the most effective insecticide against malaria and that it posed no health risk when sprayed in small amounts on the inner walls of people’s homes. Expanding its use is essential to reviving the flagging international campaign to control the disease, he said.

Too many countries in Africa have shied away from DDT, Dr. Kochi said, because of the nasty environmental reputation it earned in an earlier era when it was widely sprayed on crops — dangers that do not apply when spraying small amounts indoors.

This again highlights what Kerr was saying. Even today some environmental groups are oppossing the use of DDT in Africa, despite the many lives it may save. Their policy remains all pesticides are bad.

Russell and Rodney

Keith Ng and I did a chat session interview with Russel Norman (Green co-leader) and Rodney Hide on the recent perosnal attacks etc in Parliament.

It was Keith’s initiative so I only asked a few questions, and mindful that it was there to get Russell and Rodney’s views, I didn’t challenge them on anythign they said. As it happens I agreed a lot more with what Russel said, than Rodney. Read into that what you will!

Well done Paula

A belated public congratulations to my dear friend Paula Tesoriero on her silver medal in the women’s individual pursuit at the Paralympics world cycling championships.

Paula has never been one to make fuss of her disability. In fact many people have worked with Paula for years and not even realised she has an artifical leg. This has sometimes resulted in hilarious scenes such as a secretary asking Paula why she never wears skirts in summer, because “I am sure you would look so goregeous in them”.

As I said Paula has never wanted the disability to define who she is, and has just got on with achieiving academically, and at work etc. It has been a major challenge for her to train for and compete in something as public as the Paralympics because it is such a change from not ever drawing attention to herself.

I shouldn’t be surprised, but am, that Paula has gone from never having competitively raced a couple of years ago to having competed in and won silver at the Paralympics. Her training and determination paid off.

So a big congrats Paula from a very proud mate.

The Helen & Trevor Show

Gooner at Sir Humphrey’s reminds us that this is not the first time that Travor has done an outraegous attack on National, and Helen some days later then tries to claim she did not approve. You wonder how many times they think they can suck us in.

What is even better about the last time, which related to Mallard’s claim of National being funded and controlled by Washington, is that Clark herself is in Hansard a few weeks earlier as having made much the same claims.

So Clark herself makes the smears in the House. Then a few weeks later Mallard makes similiar claims outside the House, which backfire. Clark then claims to be furious about Mallard’s attack.

Clark loses it

Barely a day after Helen renounced personal attacks, and distanced herself from Trevor Mallard, she has let lose today with this to say about Don Brash:

“Labour regards Dr Brash as a corrosive and cancerous person within the New Zealand political system,”

“From the time he became National Party leader he started his polarizing, extreme attacks and behaviour.”

“He was not fit to be leader”

At the very time people are saying the debate should be on issues and policies, not people, Clark calls Brash “cancerous”.

I’m sorry but is the woman serious? Can she not even see the hypocrisy of accusing Brash of “extreme attacks” in the same interview as she calls him cancerous.

Can anyone read that and tell me they honestly honestly believe Clark did not authorise Mallard’s attacks on Brash?

Also isn’t it unhealthy for Clark to hate someone that much?

UPDATE: And it was just yesterday that she accussed the Auditor-General of smearing her and Labour. So Dr Brash is cancerous and the Auditor-General smears people. A bit of a pattern here about how she describes people who are a threat to her.

Well done The Greens

The Greens have today said they will will not vote for any law that legalises any election spending deemed to be unlawful, and further their MPs and party would pay back any funding the Auditor-General says should not have been spent on election material.

Bravo. Like ACT, are now doing the right thing.

Jeanette Fitzsimons still beleives the AG has been inconsistent in his interpretation of the spending rules, but correctly says it was not right for MPs to use their lawmaking powers to overturn his findings.

This now leaves only Labour, NZ First and United Future refusing to pay it back, or refusing to state what they will do.

A threat to free speech

I don’t have a problem with some sort of cap on third party campaigning during an election campaign, but on Radio NZ this morning Pete Hodgson supported a total ban on third parties being able to criticise political parties.

This should be of great concern to people. In their hatred of the Brethren, Labour may end up banning all criticism during a campaign. Look at this transcript from Radio NZ;

HODGSON: Well, I haven’t seen the draft of any law, I haven’t seen any cabinet papers, but the law would work in such a way that that advertising, one assumes would become forbidden or if it happened, would need to be included in the cap of the party who had benefited. Now, the more likely of those is that you would simply forbid it, that you would simply say you’re not allowed to have a campaign.

PRESENTER: You see, that appears at first glance to be an astonishing attack on the democratic rights of any organisation or individual wishing to express their views at this time?

This could stop Federated Farmers protesting against the fart tax if it was close to an election, Greenpeace unable to campaing against parties that allow GM food etc.

A very very bad sign from a Government that already is known for being intolerant of sustained criticism.

Myths about the Exclusive Brethren

I’m no fan of the Exclusive Brethren, and believe their involvement in the 2005 election probably damaged National more than it helped it. However the line peddled by Labour that they spent $1.2 million on pamphlets and Brash knew about this is not correct.

Zen Tiger provides a handy rebuttal of three myths about the EB’s involvement.

My biggest criticism of them is that they did not call a press conference before the first pamphlet went out, announced what they were doing and why. It is the hiding the identity aspect which goes down so badly – as with the distribution of the NBR article on Hubbard last local elections. Quite legitimate to distribute a newspaper article, but one should be open you are doing it.

MPs written questions

The new parliamentary website makes it very easy to do stuff like find out how many written questions MPs have asked in this term of Parliament.

I am quite a fan of written questions. MPs can and do use them to find out info on their portfolios and also to dig up information for use in speeches, media releases and policy papers. They have to be answered in five days and hence are a lot quicker than the OIA.

As it has been a year since the election I have gone through and collated the number of questions asked by each MP (excluding the Chief Whip, Deputy Speaker and the LOTO) not in Government. That is 65 MPs.

Now I hasten to add that this is just one measure of an MPs activity. Some are superb debaters in the House. Others do more OIAs, others do lots of press releases, give lots of speeches etc. The point is not to judge an MPs total performance off this one indicator.

The key stats for all 65 MPs are:

Mean: 239 questions
25th percentile: 75 questions
Median: 131 questions
75th percentile: 352 questions
Minimum: 0 questions (Harawira)
Maximum: 1,536 questions (Power)

Now the mean per MP for each party is:

ACT 331
National 289
United Future 275
Green 103
NZ First 71
Maori 44

The full list in order from most to least is over the break:
Continue reading »

Tell Me Lies

Police say PM was followed!

The Police have confirmed that the PM and/or her husband were followed in an incident they investigated. How-ever it wasn’t the Brethren behind it but a media organisation!!!

The Police won’t name the media organisation, but I am sure they would have informed the PM of the identity. So hopefully the PM will name the media organisation involved.

Now we are not allowed to place bets over the Internet, but if we were allowed to, here’s what my odds would be on which media organisation it is:

Investigate Magazine 3:1
Sunday Star-Times 5:1
Sunday News 7:1
Herald on Sunday 9:1
TV 3 12:1
Dominion Post 15:1
NZ Herald 20:1
Newstalk ZB 25:1
The Press 30:1
Radio Live 50:1
Television New Zealand 400:1
Radio New Zealand 500:1

Denials from said media organisations are welcome and will be accepted!

PM accuses Auditor-General of smearing Labour

This should be the real story today, and was highlighted by Graeme E in a comments thread. On Close Up last night the PM said this about the Auditor-General:

On the pledge card, let me say for the record, the Auditor-General, Mr Brady, gave an unqualified audit certificate, total sign-off, to the same spending under the same relevant rules last election; and I ask what is fair, what is consistent, about him changing his mind and smearing the reputation of my party and other political parties

Now this borders on unconstitutional. To have the PM attack an Independent Officer of Parliament in such a way and accuse him of “smearing” (Helen’s favourite word to describe anything that makes her look bad) is outrageous. Even worse is he can’t defend himself. The rare time he has explained his report, the PM has also attacked him for daring to talk publicly – yet she partisanly attacks this most independent of offices.

Helen also ignores that the Auditor-General tried to meet with her before the election and she refused. He publicly warned all parties to be very careful and she proceeded with a pledge card which four different agencies have declared to be election advertising. She had the choice of asking him to vet it, and she didn’t.

As for whether or not it was “approved” in 2002, she shows ignorance of a role of an auditor. Putting aside the fact the rules changed in 2003, an auditor does not individually see or vet every single transaction. Parliament spends $100 million or so, and there is no evidence that the AG was even aware that the 2002 pledge card was paid for out of taxpayer funds. Their role is not to check every single transaction – they do a random sample generally.

So lets leave behind all the dirt dumping which have been a desperate distraction from this issue. Who thinks it is acceptable for the Prime Minister to accuse the Auditor-General of “smearing” her party? Shouldn’t the Speaker or the State Services Commissioner be rushing in to defend the Auditor-General? The SSC calls for Opposition MPs not to attack Govt Dept CEOs so surely he should say the same when it is the PM.

No organised bile

Clark again tries to portray herself as the victim, and claim personal attacks are no part of Labour strategy. Her problem is that not only do her Ministers and MPs undertake them constantly, but one of her most senior colleagues explicitly said we will dish up dirt unless you lay off on the pledge card. It wasn’t implicit, it was explicit.

As the Dominion Post says today, “But the time for taking a stand was not yesterday or even last week. It was the day he and Mr Benson Pope first started flinging dirt. That would have sent a signal to her colleagues that there were lines they should not cross.”

And further at the very same time as she is condeming the rumours about her and her husband’s sexuality, her parliamentary colleagues are pushing to media rumours about a National MP’s sexuality – falsely claiming he has left his wife and children to move in with his gay lover. Yes seriously – Labour MPs are pushing that rumour. It is also false. And Labour MPs for over a decade have traded in speculation about the sexuality of various National MPs so again the PM’s new found standards are rather late.

And despite journalist after journalist having stated the Davis US rumours have not been pushed by National MPs, Clark continues to inists they were. Her proof – that Don Brash had lunch with Bridget Saunders, and Saunders then referred to them in a column. Good God guilt by association. Saunders has denied they discussed the rumour – in fact the lunch was to discuss global warming.

One area where I agree with clark is her description of the SST owing her an apology. They took the Investigate story (which in fact was almost a non-story) and made it their front page lead. Speculation is they thought the Investigate article was going to be much more significant than it really was, so they tried to scoop them. A big miscalculation.

Marina Society wins legal action

NZPA is reporting that the Whangamata Marina Society has won its legal action against the Conservation Minister Chris Carter and Justice Fogarty has ruled that Carter must reconsider the application to build the marina.

The marina society has also won costs.

Can Carter be seen to make a neutral decision next time as the court has effectively ruled that he was biased and did not follow correct procedure last time? Can the public have confidence in Carter carrying on in this portfolio?

Clark does a u-turn

In today’s NZ Herald Helen Clark declares “her heart sank” when Mallard started to dish dirt, and that what Mallard did was not part of Labour’s strategy. This is absolute crap, and very very easy to disprove. It also comes around a week too late to be credible.

Clark sat smiling in the House when both Mallard and Benson-Pope alluded to the alleged affair.

Clark allowed headlines for days on end that Labour were prepared to reveal dirt if National did not stop the attacks over the pledge card.

Clark herself alluded to knowledge of the stolen e-mails and with a smirk teased the media and public with wait and see what is in them.

At the same time the media reported that Labour and NZ First were debating whether to publish all or just some of the e-mails, as some of them were thought to be very personal.

Labour’s strategist Pete Hodgson was asked on Agenda whether they resiled from what Mallard said, and he did not disown Mallard’s tactics but instead said that if National calls Labour corrupt over the pledge card, then they will hit back with everything they have.

And finally you had a sneering smirking Prime Minister declare that because of the news of Brash’s alleged affair, she regarded Brash as unable to tackle her in the House on questions of integrity.

Now sorry you do not have all of the above happen on your watch, and then as you realise the public are offended by your tactics, suddenly try to distance yourself from it. Clark had every opportunity to close down the Labour campaign and she did not. As much as we all like to kick Mallard (and often deservedly) anyone who thinks a very senior cabinet minister acts on his own is these things is dreaming.

Listen to it while you can

According to Lindsay Mitchell, Helen Clark has called for the media to stop giving space or radio time to right-wing commentators. She has specifically complained about Radio NZ allowing Matthew Hooton on the air.

Matthew I am sure will take this as the highest compliment that Clark wants him closed down.
So go listen to Matthew and Laila Harre before Helen gets it closed down.

Wishart defends

Gambling

Mobile vs Fixed Line Broadband

I am a huge fan of mobile broadband. My Vodafone 3G card allows me to connect to the Internet almost anywhere populated in NZ. However I have never regarded mobile broadband as a replacement for DSL over the cooper local loop. Others have argued the existence of mobile broadband means the local loop is not a monopoly.

The Institute of Professional Engineers, in a submission headed by Telecom’s former chief technology officer, has put some useful numbers to this debate.

IPENZ say NZ would need 100,000 cellphone towers (which I reckon would take around 1,000 years under the RMA) to provide 5Mbps connections to 90 per cent of New Zealanders using wireless technology.

Mobile broadband is a great thing, and complements the fixed line broadband well. It is however not a nationwide solution.

Clark on Davis

I felt very sad last night watching the news. The Prime Minister should never have to be answering questions on her husband’s sexuality, and I genuinely felt sorry for her for having to do so.

I wonder what the hell the SST was thinking in running the story, and making it their front page lead. Sure Investigate Magazine had an article on the election night kiss, but that didn’t mean it was newsworthy. When Investigate did a cover story on Clark’s own sexuality, it was ignored by the other media. When they did their July issue regarding an alleged US incident, it was ignored by all other media. And this latest issue covered something that had already been shown on TV a year ago.

I think hard questions should be asked of the SST as to why they dragged the PM’s husband into this. They need a better answer than “it was in Investigate”.

Now the PM of course is trying to blame National for this. While of course there has been gossip as there always is, I refer people to Guyon Espiner on TVNZ last night who said that of all the many people who have raised this issue with him, none of them have been a National MP or affiliated to National.

In the Dom Post Clark specifically blames National and the Brethren. Now as I have said the National link is not there (I know National have been very careful in avoiding the Investigate story, have not asked any OIAs or PQS to verify it etc) but I have also heard that the Brethren have been involved in spreading the rumours. if correct they should be condemned for this and quite frankly told to piss off. Some-one needs to tell the Brethren the best contribution they could make to politics is to stay away from it.

Now because Ian Wishart, the Brethren and National all oppose Labour, some may be inclined to think they are allied together and each responsible for what the other does. The best analogy I can think of is between Churchill and Stalin in WWII. Sure they were all determined to beat the Nazis, but this didn’t make Churchill responsible for what Stalin did. And no I am not calling Labour Nazis – this is just an analogy.

Why there will never be peace in the Middle East

I almost fell off the couch with laughter when watching the TV News last night. As many will have seen, some Muslims have been offended by the Pope’s remarks about Islam, where he quoted a former Pope as basically saying it is evil to convert people by teh sword – ie he was speaking out against violence.

Now what was hilarious wasn’t even the irony that violent protests and death threats are the response to a speech against violence. No it was the banners and chants.

You see TV news reported that thousands filed into the straeets to chant “Death to Israel, Death to the USA”.

Yes that is right. The Pope offends Muslims, and the response is “Death to Israel”!!! I know they have these wacky conspiracy theories that the Jews control most things, but do they really think the Jews control the Roman Catholic Church???

And death to the USA?? I could understand Death to Italy or even Death to Germany, but Death to the USA because of what a German Pope says?

After spending several minutes laughing at the TV screen, I finally realised there will never ever be peace in the Middle East. “Death to Israel” is just the knee-jerk chant and solution to every problem.

Peter Davis

According to the SST Investigate Magazine is publishing tomorrow a story on Peter Davis, on the basis of the election night photo showing him being kissed by Ian Scott.

This is all very silly and very stupid and I said so a year ago when Prime first showed the footage. To quote myself:

This is one of those issues I was inclined to not even comment on this, but there are posts appearing on other blogs, so I figured it was better to add some balance, rather than do an ostrich.

Some people are already getting excited about the rumour that Holmes tonight (830 pm on Prime) will show footage or stills of a kiss between Peter Davis and a man on election night.

From what I understand it is pretty obvious that Peter Davis was taken by surprise, and it is all relatively harmless. In fact from the photo I have seen, it may just be a kiss on the cheek.

I don’t think a public party with every media in the country in attendance is the sort of place where you act indiscreetly, if there is anything to act indiscreetly about. Seriously, think about it. If you had a secret boyfriend, would you be kissing him in front of 30 journalists and several TV cameras.

Also I imagine everyone there was pretty pissed and in a celebratory mood, and photos afterwards often take things out of context. If my partner had just been re-elected PM for a third time, I’d be pretty happy and doing stupid things.

To use an example of the last one, a couple of years ago an organisation I am involved with had a major league piss-up to celebrate a very successful sale. Myself and others drank a lot of ouzo that night. The next day I didn’t recall much of the previous night, but was amused to hear there were photos of me dancing with a staff member. I assumed it was the incredibly gorgeous female staff member, but instead the photo was of me dancing with the not so gorgeous male staff member 🙁

And no that is not a sign of repressed anything, just signs of too much alcohol!

So watch Prime tonight and have a wee laugh. But please lay off the conspiracy theories.

It saddens me that Investigate is fixated with Peter Davis (who is not a politician) and see it fit to run this story. I will make the point that Ian Wishart deciding to publish something is not the same as a National frontbencher getting up and threatening to reveal dirt, and then revealing such dirt in the debating chamber..

The Sunday News also refers to another Investigate story on Davis regarding alleged behaviour on a US trip. Again I think it is deplorable to publish this stuff without proof and while Ian Wishart has done some very good journalism with his Tamihere, Benson-Pope and Parker stories, his continual focus on sexual orientation undermines all that.

Now some may claim that this proves National is as bad as Labour at muck raking. Again I repeat that Ian Wishart is not National. You can not compare what he does with the actions of senior cabinet ministers and the PM.

It is certainly true that at a conversational level Nats do sometimes discuss matters concerning the PM and speculation associated with that. Hell I have even done that myself . But not just about the PM. The Coddington-Kerr stuff gets discussed, the Prebble affair, who kissed who at last night’s party etc. People like to gossip and no-one is immune.

There is a significant difference between gossiping and between deliberately trying to dish dirt in public by way of press conference or shouting it out in the debating chamber. And I had the opportunity to discuss the various allegations flying around at the moment with a senior gallery journalist yesterday. He confirmed that Labour MPs and their staff on a constant basis encourage journalists to expose the (alleged) Brash affair and also have been pushing a very nasty false story about a National MP and his family. I then asked in regard to the Davis rumours whether National MPs ring up pushing the rumour, encouraging them to run a story. I was very gratified that the response was “You know, I don’t think I have ever had a National MP talk to me about that (US trip) rumour”.

This is not meant to portray National MPs as pure angels, and all Labour MPs as filth peddling scum. In fact most Labour MPs are pretty decent people. But Labour made a very deliberate decision to expose the (alleged) affair of Dr Brash, and that did set a new low. They pushed the nuclear button and at some stage there will be consequences of that.

One blog has already published a scurrilous list of rumours about high profile journalists (no I am not linking to it), and the next step could be one about MPs. That would be a very bad thing, because MPs should be allowed private lives, but this is the problem when you let the genie out of the bottle.

Today’s Brash round-up

The Herald on Sunday has a Digipoll which shows Brash has actually gone up in the Preferred PM ratings.

The HoS has an interview with Diane Foreman and Megan Williams (whose name has been flying about also this week). Williams confirms when both her and Brash were single, they went out.

Kerre Woodham comments from her self-described former “hard-drinking, self-obsessed slapper” role to say she won’t be condemning the actions of any man. Or woman.

Matt McCarten writes that he believes Brash won’t survive, but that this will be bad news for Clark.

Irene Chapple in the SST writes that if there is a change, it will be unchallenged to John Key, but that it won’t happen prematurely.

Matthew Hooton writes in the SST that in facing the difficult decision of how to deal with Brash’s alleged infidelity, National must be sure not to create any media diversion from Labour’s almost pathological inability to obey the law or tell the truth.

Hooton also points out that Mallard may be a casualty of this, in that the public would now never accept him as Finance Minister. This could well be true, but may be a bit unfair to Trevor as there is little doubt he was acting under orders or permission from Helen.

Did you know?

In 1999, a massive 74% of Labour’s donations were anonymous – totalling $824,375. Yep almost one million dollars.

In 2002 Labour’s level of anonymous donations was only $55,000 less than National.

So Labour are absoluite hypocrites when they claim that these anonymous donations are bad, are wrong, and must be stopped. They have happily taken them in. They have explicitly not amended the law to stop them, as they could have done at any time since 1999.

So why are these donations suddenly a bad thing? Simply because Labour didn’t get as many as National this time around. Suddenly this major funding source for Labour becomes a bad, evil thing.

So my question to Helen is if you are now against anonymous donations so much will you hand back all the ones you have happily banked?

Today’s News

I was going to do the normal summary and extracts from stories, columns and editorials, but National Home have already done it so go read.

I agree with them that there was a startling difference between TV One and Three news last night. TV One played it straight and reported on Brash, reported a poll and then had commentary from Espiner.

TV Three was to be blunt pretty disgraceful. They mixed in opinion and reporting all the way through. They asserted as fact things very much in contention, and their whole story was almost a campaign against Brash.

The editorials today are pretty negative on whether Brash will stay on. My view, as I expressed on Agenda, is that with an election two years away, nothing is going to happen too soon – people are going to wait to see where the story goes, how the polls move, and how well National and Brash do when the House resumes in four weeks.