Labour threatens newspaper with tax for unfavourable reporting

Good God you would think I am making this up. But no Dr Cullen has basically threatened to tax the owners of the NZ Herald more, because he is unhappy with their coverage of the pledge card issue.

Those Mugabe comparisons are starting to have a self-fulfilling impact it seems.

Perhaps this will be Labour’s long awaited tax cuts. Those who vote for Labour pay 30% and those who criticise Labour pay 50%.

Boobs on Bikes

Dick Hubbard has condemned the Boobs on Bikes parade as “morally repugnant” and “degrading”.

Good God, if that is his reaction to a dozen topless women on motorbikes, what does he think of the Hero Parade?

Me, I’m a supporter of both!

Brian Rudman makes the point that Hubbard and co have guaranteed a record turnout and exposure (heh) for both the parade and the expo. Is Hubbard on Steve Crow’s payroll?

Death of the Maori Queen

Opinions on paying back the pledge cards

The NZ Herald editorial is headlined “Why Labour must repay taxpayers”

Labour, in league with lesser parties in Parliament, appears determined to do itself a lasting dishonour by retrospectively validating its use of state funds to produce its election pledge card. The public has already seen this response for what it is: a disgraceful device to save the party a bill for $446,000.

If Labour and a number of small parties force legislation through Parliament to validate this sort of spending retrospectively, it stands to be as memorable as the seven-minute passage of members’ superannuation enrichment some years ago. Incidents such as these remain in memory for a lifetime, to be recalled whenever it is claimed that politicians are a self-serving breed.

It may be hard to write a cast-iron definition of what is policy information and what is election advertising but it is rather like the difference between art and pornography. It may be hard to define but everyone knows the difference when they see it.

The Auditor-General is not alone in finding Labour’s pledge card a misuse of the public fund. The Electoral Commission believed the card took the party over the permitted spending limit, and the Solicitor-General, whose opinion was cited by the Auditor-General, believes the spending on the card not only breached Parliament’s rules but was unlawful.

The rules were set after the last election, which destroys Labour’s claim that this spending goes back too far for any party to be able to pay it back. The Government’s real concern is that the party simply cannot pay the bill; it gives itself away with an attempt by some ministers to turn the case into an argument for full public funding of election campaigns. That would be the ultimate in self service. The party should have recognised the pledge card for what it plainly was. Its only honorable course now is to raise the funds and pay the bill.

The Press is equally firm:

The arrogance of political parties knows no bounds when it comes to the defence of their own self-interest.

Nowhere is this shown better or more flagrantly than in the Government’s suggestion that it will legislate to validate its advertising expenditure which breached parliamentary rules. The public are well used to politicians’ brazen disregard for the rules but, even for them, this marks a new low point. There should be widespread outrage at the misappropriation of public money for political advantage and any attempt to validate this. But adding to this must be deep concern over Prime Minister Helen Clark’s criticism of the watchdogs who have highlighted the inappropriate spending – the Auditor-General and the Solicitor-General.

In particular, Brady has dismissed the farcical argument, especially from Labour, that the money was spent on promoting party policy, which is within the parliamentary rules for leader’s funds, rather than electioneering, which is not. It beggars belief that a campaign gimmick, such as Labour’s $446,000 pledge card, could have any other intention than to solicit votes. So, it is not Brady who is shifting the goal posts but Labour and any other party which votes for validation of this sort of political rort.

Politicians have already acquired a malodorous reputation for protecting their perks and allowances. So taxpayers will be scarcely surprised that Labour is in a state of denial as it scrambles to legitimise its party spending. But in doing so, it is showing a blatant disregard bordering on contempt for the very agencies, which have highlighted the illegal spending. These include the Auditor-General, who is the independent watchdog over public spending, and the Solicitor-General, who provided a legal ruling. Labour’s rejection of their findings threatens to undermine the authority of these offices.

Labour’s defiance in the face of these powerful critics reflects more than a reluctance to refund a substantial sum of money. It is typical of the arrogant political style of this Government which, into its third term in power, has grown increasingly isolated from the public’s expectations of what is fair and reasonable. This is shown by its misuse of public funding in the first place, by its self-serving justifications for doing so and now by its proposal to abuse its office by changing the rules to validate its actions.

Labour has determined that the longer-term political damage from legislating to protect itself would be less than if it admitted it was wrong and repaid the money. This is the latest instance of Labour’s cynical and unhealthy, power-at-all-costs political approach which has become all too common.

Ouch, one can almost get blistered reading it. And then David Slack from Public Address comes up with an equitable way for Labour to pay the bill:

Total cost of pledge cards: about $400,000.

Total number of Labour MPs – 40 or so.

“Donation” per head. $10,000

Hurt? Of course it would hurt. But they might want to consider how much more hurt they might do themselves by passing retroactive legislation of such gob-smacking self-service.

Criminal Justice Changes

There’s a fair number of proposals in the Government’s announcement today so let’s take them one at a time.

Before that though I should point out that the PM’s surprise at falling levels of recorded crime and rising prison populations is easily explained. Most recorded crime is minor and does not attract prison. Violent crimes are the ones which tend to get people into prison, and they have been increasing steadily since she became PM.

Establish a Sentencing Council – 6/10

On balance it is probably a good thing to have the Government more directly involved in sentencing guidelines because then they can’t blame sentences just on Judges. The negative is it may politicise it more.

Increase parole eligibility from 1/3 to 2/3 of a sentence – 8/10

I am being generous here as it was Labour in 2002 which made 1/3 sentence possible for many crimes. And it should be greater than 2/3 – say 90% or so.

The official estimate is the average time served will go from 62% to 80%.

Reduce the length of sentence by 25% – 2/10

No, no no. This means the very worst criminals who misbehave in prison and get no parole will be getting out 25% earlier. Mad.

Home detention will be established as a sentence in its own right – 6/10

Seems sensible, but careful it remains restricted to those not posing a risk.

New sentences of Electronically-Monitored Curfew. and Intensive Supervision – 6/10

Again looks sensible. However final judgement will depend on how it is used and applied. The worst case is a Government tight for money uses it Sentencing Commission to set guidelines which has convicts being given curfew instead of prison, despite the risk to the community.

Two new drug and alcohol treatment units in prisons – 8/10

Only qualification is how effective are the current units?

Overall the big negative is cutting sentences by 25%. This will see the very worst offenders out earlier. The back-down on parole is welcome, but has taken far too long.

The other stuff is all potentially beneficial, but it will depend on the implementation. And Corrections Department hasn’t exactly been a model of perfection in recent times.

Captured Cameraman

One of the nice things about being in a hotel room in the US is both falling alseep to and waking up to Fox News 🙂

Hence I heard before most about the kidnapping of two of their employees. However it was only a few hours later than I realised one of them is a Kiwi, and Anita McNaught’s husband.

I am sure everyone hopes they are released without harm.

Holocaust cartoon exhibit launched

As he promised to do, the Iranian President has opened a exhiibit of more than 200 Holocaust cartoons.

Reaction to date:

Deaths = 0
Embassy Burnings = 0
Calls for Executions = 0
Violent Marches = 0
Non-violent Marches = 0
Calls for UN treaty to ban cartoons = 0
Protests from heads of states = 0

Speaks for itself basically.

UN Secretary-General

Audrey Young wonders how National reconciles its statement saying they would support Helen Clark for the UN Secretary-General job, with their statement that she has presided over the most corrupt Government in the last 150 110 years.

As Rodney Hide points out, the latter could be seen as excellent training for the former 🙂

Turning to the merits of a Clark candidacy itself, I have to say I think it would be a stretch. Clark has some obvious competencies and is no slouch at foreign affairs (though I disagree with her strategic outlook and views). I could see her being a credible candidate for one of the various UN agencies, and she would probably do a reasonably good job with them.

But the job of UN Secretary-General itself is incredibly challenging. You need to retain the confidence of all five permanent SC members, you need to be able to manage the huge bureaucracy, and you need to be able to work with heads of states of all kinds. I don’t think Clark will be seen as operating at that level. Mainly because NZ is such a small player we don’t get involved in serious stuff like someone in South Korea does.

Of course the job is not just chosen on competence, but geopolitical lobbying. It will be interesting to see who is chosen in the end. The process appears to be more transparent than in the past where only the Big 5 decided. US Ambassador John Bolton has introduced some welcome transparency.

Jane Kelsey

Spin Alert

Compulsory taxpayer funding of political parties is a hard package to sell, so Labour has started to call it, get this “democracy funding”.

Forcing me to fund the Labour Party, and calling to democracy funding, is to be blunt akin to having the locals thugs demand protection money to not burn down my store, and calling it insurance funding.

Both Labour and National managed to raise enough money to spend the maximum they were allowed to under law. There is no need to steal further money from the taxpayers.

UPDATE: Tony Milne responds, and Red Letter does a pros and cons post on taxpayer funding.

Spin, spin, spin, spin

Good God Clark is trying to spin the issue of the pledge cards so badly, she could set herself up as a wind turbine and power a few hundred homes. Where do we start, with her quotes in the NZ Herald

As much as $350 million spent by all parliamentary political parties over 16 years may be implicated in the Auditor-General’s report:

Okay the PM would have us think the Auditor-General is an insane maniac who has come up with some impossible new rule, which invalidates a third of a billion of expenditure. She is wanting people to fall for the TINA trap – There Is No Alternative but to change the law because gee whiz you can’t have $350 million paid back.

The Auditor-General has not said all expenditure during the three months he audited was illegal. In fact if you take away Labour’s spending, then I would say less than 5% of expenditure has been found to be illegal. And that is at the time where you might expect it to be worse.

She sought to distance parties from any blame in the funding row, saying that the dispute, in essence, was between the Auditor-General and the Parliamentary Service – the bureaucracy that administers Parliament.

Most parties, during the three months that AG audited, had 90 – 99% of their expenditure approved as okay. Just one party – Labour – has had a massive amount found not to be okay. Don Brash managed to not spend a cent illegally, while Helen Clark’s bill is reputed to be not just $450,000 but I hear as high as one million dollars!

“What I am taking exception to … is any inference that our party set out to break rules. Absolutely not. People set out to work within the rules.”

As you read this, remember that three weeks before the election they were informed by the Chief Electoral Officer he considered their pledge cards to be election advertising. Even worse they then promised the CEO that they would include them in their return of election expenses and reneged on that promise once they had been re-elected.

She also firmly backed the concept of transparent state funding of political parties as the best outcome from the debacle.

If Helen is not allowed to steal funds for her re-election campaign, then she will legislate to legalise such theft in future.

“It should be remembered that one of the reasons the National Party is so sanctimonious about the last three months of the election campaign is that it had vast amounts of money from the Exclusive Brethren and very large corporates.”

Translation: We couldn’t raise as much money legally as National, so we used the taxpayer instead.

Also remember that her party had a $500,000 donation from a foreign billionaire. And she dares to talk about vast amounts of money.

Oh I’ve just seen that the NZ Herald article itself also labels Clark’s meanderings as spin, and helpfully provides their own translations. I didn’t even realise that when I started reading the article. The claim that $350 million is at risk was so obviously an outrageous spin, that I started blogging at that point!

59% say Field should go

A One News Colmar Brunton poll has found voters want Field to resign by a 2:1 majority.

I’m surprisingly not quite in the resign camp. I think the issue of cheap labour on his houses might just fall short on the mandatory resignation scale. Maybe – if it had been admitted to, and apologised for.

What is unforgivable though is what appears to be the cover-up to the Ingram inquiry. Now we still don’t know the full truth of what happened. So I don’t want Field gone. I want an inquiry with powers to discover the truth.

Remember it would take one phone call to Qantas from a properly authorised investigator or inquiry to ascertain if Field has been telling the truth or not.

Sentencing Guidelines

I may be mis-reading this, but I think the Government is about to propose halving all serious crime sentences.

According to the NZ Herald, they are going to increase the threshold for parole from one third to two thirds. This is good.

But they say the Government doesn’t actually want people in prison for longer, so sentence lengths will decrease to compensate for the parole.

So if some-one was sentenced to nine years jail for rape, they could currently get out in three years. This new system looks like suggesting they only get sentenced to four and a half years jail, so they can still get out in three years.

Oh and in related news, Whale Oil has a leaked copy of the new sentencing guidelines:

Forgery: Not in the public interest to prosecute

Fraud: Not in the public interest to prosecute

Speeding: If a Labour minister it is not in the public interest to prosecute

Assaulting Children in your care: If a Labour minister it is not in the public interest to prosecute, otherwise the full extent of the law applies.

Taking bribes and “favours”: Slap on the hand with a wet bus ticket.

Stealing taxpayer money: What money, we just changed the law to “validate” that.

Sadly all too true.

Lord Stevens on Islamic Terrorism

I normally would not quote an article from News of the World, but the article by Lord Stevens, former Met Police Commissioner is so spot on.

Lord Stevens is regarded as a man of huge integrity. He rocked the establishment by determining there was collusion between the British Army, the Royal Ulster Constabulary and loyalist terrorists in the murder of Irish nationalists. He is currently heading the investigation into the death of Princess Diana.

In his NOTW article, Lord Stevens lays down a challenge to the British Muslim community:

WHEN will the Muslims of Britain stand up to be counted?

When will they declare, loud and clear, with no qualifications or quibbles about Britain’s foreign policy, that Islamic terrorism is WRONG?

Most of all, when will the Muslim community in this country accept an absolute, undeniable, total truth: that Islamic terrorism is THEIR problem? THEY own it. And it is THEIR duty to face it and eradicate it.

To stop the denial, endless fudging and constant wailing that somehow it is everyone else’s problem and, if Islamic terrorism exists at all, they are somehow the main victims.

Because until that happens the problem will never be resolved. And there will be more 7/7s and, sometime in the future, another airplane plot will succeed with horrific loss of innocent life.

He also lashes out at the reluctance to profile, saying:

I’m a white 62-year-old 6ft 4ins suit-wearing ex-cop—I fly often, but do I really fit the profile of suicide bomber? Does the young mum with three tots? The gay couple, the rugby team, the middle-aged businessman?

No. But they are all getting exactly the same amount and devouring huge resources for no logical reason whatsoever. Yet the truth is Islamic terrorism in the West has been universally carried out by young Muslim men, usually of ethnic appearance, almost always travelling alone or in very small groups. A tiny percentage, I bet, of those delayed today have such characteristics.

He defends charges of racism, saying:

All this would suggest the blindingly obvious—that terrorism is a major problem for the Muslim community of Britain. Of course, there will be instant squealings that this is racism. It’s not. It’s exactly the same as recognising that, during the Northern Ireland troubles that left thousands dead, the IRA were totally based in the Catholic community and the UVF in the Protestant.

And that, most importantly, IRA terrorism only began to draw to a close when that Catholic community it was based in decided as a whole that it was no longer prepared to back violence as the only way forward. Interestingly, it was Catholic revulsion over republican terrorist atrocities such as Enniskillen and Omagh that fuelled that change.

Finally he sets the bar for what is needed:

Well, Muslim terrorism in Britain is based in, has its roots in, and grows in, our Muslim community. The madmen of 7/7 and other suicide bombings didn’t hide among the Hindu communities, worship in the Sikh temples, recruit at Catholic churches, did they? It may be true that events in Iraq have angered sections of the Muslim community. I have no doubts, whatever Tony Blair says, that it was a catalyst. I also think it’s entirely fair for Muslims, if they wish, to vocally oppose Britain’s continuing involvement there.

I can recognise, too, that recent events in Lebanon inflame some people, and they want their voices of protest heard. The absolutely unacceptable problem is that this opposition is used by too many to turn a blind eye to, or excuse, terrorists in their midst.

Blasting a passenger airliner out of the sky, killing hundreds of innocent men, women and children, is NEVER acceptable. Under any circumstances. There is NEVER an excuse.

A terrible tragedy costing Muslim lives in Lebanon or Iraq or Afghanistan is never ever an excuse for terrorism here.

It is totally unacceptable, totally wrong. What one party perceives as a wrong, no matter how strongly they feel, does not, in turn, justify another wrong being done to avenge it.

And until every single member of the Muslim community believes that and preaches that—from an ordinary parent to imam or madrassa teacher—terrorism can’t be beaten.

More prison blog extracts

Tim Selwyn continues to blog from prison, or more accurately to send letters to Bomber who puts them on his blog for him.

His latest post is fascinating. I’m quite amused that the Corrections Department allow Tim to slag off the prison warden and guards in such colourful terms.

With his sunglasses propped atop his boofy hair, white trousers and boat shoes it was a look that died in the early ‘90s where I come from.

His manner is somewhere between an ungracious maths teacher and a disappointed car-yard owner chastising his salesmen.

Throughout this time he fidgets : clenching his keys and coin change with his hands thrust deep in his straining white pants, with his billowing gut hanging out over the top like a giant blob of golden syrup ready to drop

Well everything in Klink’s hyperactive, neurotic imagining is a stand-over or potential stand-over I was quickly learning.

Tim also gives us an invaluable insight into how effective prison security is:

Well for a unit with more cell phones than an Auckland high school and more cannibas than a Northland one

All we need are photos of the nicknamed Colonel Klink!

Anti-Spam Technology

The Dom Post has an article on five NZers who have set up a firm which is “able to block all spam”.

This gets me somewhat curious. Firstly I should say that I praise anyone who is helping offer solutions to the spam problem, and also those who set up their own business. Good on them.

But I query a claim of “blocking all spam”. Quite simply it is not possible unless you are offering a service which blocks all e-mail from unknown recepients. You can get 99.99% blocking but I know of no-one who claims 100%. Also the more you aim for 100% the more false positives you get.

The other thing which raises slight warning bells is their claim that their system is better because rather than just filter spam, it bounces it back to the sender. As most spam is forged this just results in innocent third parties or their ISPs getting pelted with bounce messages.

Like I say the company looks to be providing a good product and is doing well. But I don’t think claiming a product can block “all” spam is useful marketing.

Greens Polling

Phil U at Whoar claims the TVNZ 3% poll rating for the Greens is due to the choice of Russel Norman as co-leader.

Now it should be noted that Phil campaigned against Mr Norman, and is hardly a neutral commentator on this. And it is also too simplistic to tie a poll rating (esp from just one poll) to one factor. However it did get me thinking – what impact is Russel Norman making in the media?

Google News has almost no mention at all. Excluding PRs on Scoop, there is only a mention on Newstalk ZB and Hawke’s Bay Today.

And for the sake of comparison, Nandor Tanczos on Google News has 11 news items.

This is not to suggest Norman is not working hard – he in facts does many PRs a week. Just the reality that non MPs find it very hard to get press coverage.

Fake Documents

Wayne Mapp makes an excellent point in his criticism of the Labour Department for not investigating Taito Phillip Field, with their reliance on the Ingram Report to say nothing in there indicates an employment relationship.

Mapp highlights that Ingram found some of the documents he was given were fake, or to quote him, he had “cause to consider the authenticity” of them. And that Ingram found the testimony given by the Labour Party Chair who claimed to contract out the painting as unreliable.

This is where the Government truly passes the boundary from sleazy to corrupt. The issue is not the original el cheapo favours Field had done for him, but the cover-up.

The PM’s inquiry, which was given no powers, found it was lied to, and given fake documents, amongst an obvious orchestrated cover-up. Having had your QC investigator report back that there is a cover-up, and that further investigation by a body with powers is needed, the Government has done nothing.

Remember there were 45 unfavourable references to Field or his associates in the report – many to do with an inability to get to the truth.

Helen Clark hides behind two excuses for why she won’t have a proper inquiry. The first is the cost of the Ingram Report at almost $500,000. But this is rubbish. Firstly the Govt squanders more than that almost every day. But more importantly the reason Ingram cost so much is because he had no powers and was so frustrated at getting to the truth. And Clark was asked to set up a more powerful inquiry in the first place and refused.

The second excuse is one doesn’t want the PM to be able to set up inquiries into any MP at any time. That somehow this would be an abuse of office. Now sure one doesn’t want a Muldoon type figure launching investigations into MPs willy-nilly, but there is a simple way forward – that the PM launches a commission of inquiry when there is sufficient evidence of concern, and when the MP’s party leader agrees.

We saw this with Colin Moyle – Labour agreed to the commission of inquiry set up by Muldoon. And the rationale for its need – the evidence which suggested Moyle had not told the truth – just as the Ingram Report strongly suggests Field and associates have not been truthful.

So all Helen Clark PM needs to do is get permission of Helen Clark Labour Party Leader and she could announce a commission of inquiry today. So long as Clark refuses to have a proper investigation, then the corrupt label remains.

$163K for police anti-porn

Wasteful Auckland Spending

In San Francisco

Despite the recent heightened security, has turned out to be one of the best plane trips yet.

After leaving the Koru Club in Auckland there was a further security check just before the gate and I estimate there could be 30 minute delays there for some people. However as the SF flight leaves 30 minutes before the LA one, we got taken to the front of the line and only took a few minutes. Shoes had to come off, and a manual inspection of everything in my laptop bag but to be expected.

A final security check as you board the plane – just a visual ID.

I was in real luck on the plane. It was one of the new 777s and I have previously blogged how incredibly well designed the business class section is. Well even better there was one spare seat, so I was allowed to monopolise that one also by setting up my laptop in the spare seat (I had heaps of work to catch up on) and having my seat as a bed, so I could alternate backwards and forwards without having to move everything.

As there was power for the laptop, I didn’t read much on the flight. Almost finished “The Lords of the North” by Bernard Cornwell – a historicial fictional novel set in the time of Alfred the Great. Also watched a couple of Buffy episodes on their inhouse system.

I never saw Seven Periods with Mr Gormsby when it screened on TV, but managed to get hold of some copies of Series One I could view on the laptop.

My God it really is hilarious. It pokes fun at every sacred cow, and the Steve character is truly loathsome. The kids are great, and David McPhail hits he mark perfectly as Gormsby. It’s been a long time for there to be such a good local comedy – I just need to find Series II now.

Anyway back to the trip – landed in San Francisco and unlike LA, got through in around 10 – 15 minutes to the taxi stands, and now all checked in at the King George Hotel. The hotel is a basic three star, but very well priced (ie cheap) and located, plus has free broadband in the rooms which clinched it for me. I am outraged at how many hotels back home charge $35 for 50MB of broadband.

Blog Power

In the US especially, the power of blogs continues to increase. The defeat of a former VP candidate in his own party’s primary is largely credited to blogs and online activism. That’s a huge scalp, with Daily Kos claiming some credit.

And on the right, look at Little Green Footballs. Charles Johnson is hated by many on the left, but the LA Weekly summarises:

Johnson caught Dan Rather trying to swing a presidential election, and now he’s blown a giant hole in the credibility of the world’s largest news service. As a result of his work, Reuters has been forced to delete all 920 Hajj photographs from its database, tighten its filing drills and institute a new policy whereby all Middle East photographs will be checked by the editor-in-charge on the Global Pictures Desk before release. Johnson achieved all this in, oh, about 48 hours.

Airports okay

Well to my great surprise Auckland Airport has never been quicker. It took me less than five minutes from arriving at the international terminal to making the koru club lounge. The security check was more thorough but quite quick.

The problem actually came at Wellington Airport where they said that the laptop would have to be checked in. The instructions change by the hour it seems, but upon checking I got the okay for my laptop but the cellphone had to go into the suitcase. So my plans to call a few people from Auckland didn’t happen.

I think we have a gate check to go through also. And could be quite intrusive at the other end but as it is San Francisco not Los Angeles, that may help.

I’m in San Fran for four days and then driving with friends to Carmel, where Clint was once teh Mayor!

A jew hater and stalker

Nic Miller has set up his own blog, where he declares:

Jews, Judaism and the Israeli people are not welcome in this country. Jews are a slap in the face to the human race.

Nor normally I would say Mr Miller is a retard looking for attention, and is best ignored. However one can only be concerned that he is publishing names, addresses, phone numbers and house photos of several Jewsih individuals in Wellington. This is not illegal, but clearly intended to intimidate.

Mr Miller was in court last year, over an alleged assault on three Somalis.

UPDATE: Well that was quick. The four posts with photos and details of Wellington Jews have been removed in the last couple of hours.

UPDATE2: The site is the lead story for the Sunday News. Miller adds to his collection of quotes with “They should have been exterminated” and “Jews being in New Zealand is harassment to me. They do not belong here.”

A solution to the Israel/Lebanon conflict