Nothing to Investigate

Buy NZ owned not made

The Greens look to be changing the “Buy NZ made” campaign into a “Buy NZ owned”. Yes, you can get your products made in an overseas sweatshop, but so long as the company selling them is NZ owned, this may now qualify.

Now personally I don’t care (as I think local manufacturers survive on the basis of their quality, not on the basis of patriotism), but for those who think the Greens were about promoting local manufacturing, they will be sorely disappointed.

Retrospective Legislation

One almost has to admire the spin. Dr Cullen says that he will not be introducing “retrospective” legislation to let his party off paying for the cost of their election plegde cards but instead “validating” legislation.

There is of course no difference, but the hope the media and public are stupid enough to be fooled.

The Greens look to be throwing out what remains of their principles and seem poised to back the retrospective legislation.

Winston Peters actually is talking about doing the correct thing. If you don’t like the ruling, then challenge it in court.

And big kudos to the Herald, for mentioning the Darnton v Clark lawsuit, because this is going to become more pivotal.

This lawsuit was filed some months ago, and any retrospective legislation would cut across that lawsuit which would be constutionally even more horrific. It would also raise issues of compensation for the plaintiffs.

John Armstrong’s column is spot on:

The Prime Minister is instead arguing that it is the Auditor-General who has changed the rules of the game after the referee had blown the final whistle.

This is bunkum. While the rules confusingly allow parties to inform the public of its views, the definition rules out anything that promotes the election of a person or party.

Moreover, Brady warned three months before the 2005 election about not using parliamentary advertising for electioneering or related purposes.

McCully wins

The Court of Appeal has ruled in favour of Murray McCully, over-turning Justice Wild’s ruling that media, but not MPs, could access the court file of the case against Chris Carter. Some quotes:

“…we think that in this instance, the High Court judge was plainly wrong.”

Mr McCully has both a genuine and proper interest in this Court file. His interest is not frivolous or vexatious or merely prurient. He has a real interest, and it is solidly based in the sense that Mr McCully wishes to inform himself (by access to the Court record) as to the nature and basis of the decision made by the Minister, and the basis on which it is said to rest, in the High Court papers. We consider that his “standing” is clear. It is distinctly arguable that he has a greater interest than other citizens, as a Member of this country’s Parliament, to keep himself fully and properly informed, and he has significant public responsibility as the Opposition Spokesperson on Conservation.

PC at work

Peter Cresswell has two great posts at the moment.

The first is about how the Hutt City Mayor blamed the Kelson landslip on climate change (which has become the univeral cause of all problems it seems). However a geologist has found it may have been a leaking council sewer pipe!!

The second is about letters to the NZ Herald on Labour’s refusal to pay back the $446,000 cost of its pledge cards. Of all the letters on the topic, only one was defending the Government. Who was this noble citizen? None other than the husband of Helen Clark’s electorate agent!

I wonder if Helen wrote the letter herself!!

No no no

Hell – NZ Aviation Security have said that flights to the US from NZ may also ban cabin luggage, as is now the case for UK flights.

I fly to San Francisco tomorrow evening and the thought of 12 hours on a flight with no books or laptop is horrendous. Being without something to do for even a few minutes is difficult for me. 12 hours would be like an eternity in purgatory!

At least it is one of the new planes with the entertainment systems. So if deprived of my books I could just play video games for half a day!

Let’s just hope that the ban only applies to the UK and not also the US.

Labour to legislate to over-rule Auditor-General

I never thought I would read this in NZ. Michael Cullen plans to introduce legislation so that Labour do not have to pay back the $446,000 pledge card which has been deemed election advertising by almost every competent authority in the land, such as:

* Chief Electoral Officer
* Electoral Commission
* Secretary of Justice
* Auditor-General
* Solictor-General

NZPA quotes Dr Cullen as saying on National Radio today that Parliament may have to “validate the expenditure”.

If this is not corruption, what is?

All the spin about how this is necessary to validate almost 20 years of expenditure is not the opinion of anyone in authority, just of the MPs affected. It is an untested assertion which if the MPs think is true, they could test in court.

If they do introduce “validating” legislation they sure as hell better not pass it quickly under urgency. I for one want to make a select committee submission, and I suspect so will tens of thousands of other people on this.

It’s ironic. You buy the election by deliberating over-spending. And then you use your continuance in office to amend the law to validate what you did.

More fake photos

Little wonder that respect for the big news agencies is plummeting as more and more evidence comes out they run fake or staged photos routinely, unwittingly serving the aims of the terrorist organisations that arrange them.

Have a read of EU Referendum and also watch the video below (Hat Tip: LGF)

Legalised Theft

The Auditor-General and Solictor-General find that Labour’s $446,000 pledge cards are electioneering (wow what a surprise), so what is Labour’s response?

Not to pay it back, no. But to propose state funding of political parties, so they can do it again in future, without challenge.

Now look as a (semi-retired) party activist, state funding is superb for people like me. I’ve spent 20 years doing the following:

* Buying $100 raffle tickets for prizes I don’t even want
* Spending dozens of hours organising sausage sizzles, quiz nights, movie outings to make a few hundred dollars
* Attending numerous over-priced cocktail functions, just so I can “meet” an MP (never mind I was seeing them almost every day at work anyway)
* Trying to sell raffle tickets to my friends, and them guiltily when falling short buying the rest myself
* Responding to HQ direct mail appeals
* Donating to local campaigns
* Hand delivering letters to save on postage

Now hell you have to be mashochistic to not want state funding of parties if you are an activist. It’s like nirvana. But it’s wrong all the same.

It’s good for a party to have to work hard to earn its money. It’s good that when you are out of touch with your supporters that your funding declines. It’s good that your sucess is linked to how many dedicated activists will sweat and toil for the party. They all help keep a party honest.

A party which is less reliant on its members and activists, is a less democratic party. Having to work hard for your funding is good for the soul. Student Associations are a classic example of what happens when you just get your funding given to you without having to earn it.

The old cellphone driving ban

Once again there is a call for a ban on cellphone use while driving, this time on the basis that motorists attempting a road obstacle course while talking on a phone were found to be more impaired than those at the legal alcohol limit.

Now I don’t dispute the research done by Dr Susan Krumdieck, or the proposition that cellphone use in cars does make a driver somewhat more distracted.

But I do dispute that this makes a case for banning all cellphone use.

Look if I was about to do an obstacle course in my car, I’d not want to be on the phone also. But an obstacle course is an extreme example of what you face on a road.

There are times when I will speak on my phone in the car. If caught in very slow moving traffic, or say on a motorway with little other traffic etc. But there are often times when I won’t, as conditions get too challenging. If it is raining, and especially if visibility is impaired, then I’ll make the judgement call that it is unsafe to be distracted and will ask people to call back later, or not answer.

And this is my problem with any sort of ban – it judges all motorists as being unable to take a sensible approach to risk management. And motorists do this many times a day. You speed up and slow down in response to the conditions all the time.

Xtra Helpdesk moving to the Philippines

British Muslims

UK Channel 4 has published a poll of 1,000 British Muslims. Some key results:

* 48% never attend a mosque, while 10% attend seven or more times a week
* 30% would like to live under sharia law and 54% under British law
* 28% would like to see Britian become an Islamic state
* 78% support punishing the people who published the ‘Danish cartoons’
* 49% think British people who insult Islam should be arrested and prosecuted
* 9% of respondents could be classified as hardcore Islamists, and this does not vary greatly by gender, age or social class
* Only 29% of Muslims believe the Holocaust happened as history teaches it
* 45% of British Muslims believe 9/11 was a conspiracy between Israel and the USA, with only 20% saying it was not a conspiracy
* 22% of British Muslims thought the 7/7 bombings were justified
* 56% say there is no truth at all to the idea Islam treats women as second class citizens
* However 55% say wives should always obey their husbands

Bloody Terrorists

Heathrow Airport has closed after authories arrested 21 people in the UK, in relation to an elleged plot to blow up up to ten aircraft, while they are over major cities in the US and UK – hoping to maximise civilian casualities.

The US Department of Homeland Security has set the threat level for flights originating in the UK to “red” – the first time.

Now I’m scheduled to fly into the USA on Saturday. God it is going to be a nightmare with this level of security. Even worse for my friends from London whom I am meeting there.

But still a minor hassle compared to what would have happened if the plot wasn’t stopped. However I see as a temporary measure one can not have any cabin luggage at all, except for a passport and a wallet!

All paid up

nznpcheque.JPG

Well National has paid up the amounts identified by the Auditor-General as requiring repayment by its MPs. WIll Labour do the same for its pledge cards? Remember Labour were told well before the election that the pledge cards were considered an “election advertisement”. They even agreed to include the amount in their election return (an agreement they later reneged on).

Economic Mismanagement Penalties

The deputy head of a stae owned bank in Vietnam has been charged with “losing state resources through economic mismanagement” and faces the death penalty.

God could you imagine if one had such a crime and a penalty in New Zealand. I mean Steve Maharey would have been executed years ago for all the tertiary education scams.

Hat Tip: Tim Blair

ZB on Competition

Oh this is so wrong …

Union memberships

It is interesting to read that the rate of union membership in the private sector has dropped to a miniscule 9% (was 48% in 1990), yet in the public sector is a massive 68%.

But it is little surprise. You see people get bribed in the public sector to join unions. Here is how it goes. Ministers instruct CEOs to accept a pay settlement which includes a higher level of pay if an employee is a member of the union and on a collective contract. They call this “partnership”. Then your average civil servant, who is by no means dumb, looks at option A of no bonus cash and option B of say $1,500 bonus cash and they choose option B which requires joining the union. So then $400 of the $1,500 goes to the union as a membership fee. And then the union passes a portion of it either directly onto the Labour Party, or they spend it campaigning for Labour in the election. It’s a nice wee circle.

The 9% membership level in the private sector I think shows that most people don’t see the benefits of being in a union outweighing the costs. There are situations where being a union member is a very sensible idea, and I’ve even helped a few people join in the past when they were faced with a “bad boss”. When you are 19 it can be hard to stand up for your rights. As you get older and more experienced you often find you don’t need someone to advocate on your behalf.

The other factor in the low membership might be the buoyant job market. When unemployment is this low, employees can have more power than employers. If you have a crap employer then you find another job and quit. The employer may then struggle to replace you, and hence have a higher incentive to keep staff happy.

A Parliamentary Code of Conduct

I have had misgivings for some time over the growing view that the solution to the Field issue is a parliamentary code of ethics. I seem to recall some quote along the lines of you only need a code of ethics when you don’t have any!

The NZ Herald editorial today makes some great points:

A code is being contemplated now only because the Government fears to act more strongly against one of its own, Taito Phillip Field. It is a lame attempt to suggest that the code Mr Field appears to have broken was unclear, when it was not. All MPs know, surely without having to be told, that they do not accept any form of private payment for their public work.

There are two sides to any written code of conduct. On the positive side, it clarifies certain principles that its adherents must observe; on the negative, it permits anything that is not expressly forbidden.

Parties that propose a formal code in these circumstances do Parliament the ultimate disservice. It leaves the impression that Mr Field’s dealings with prospective immigrants were not unusual and that other members need reminding that they must refuse personal favours. What else is the public to infer?

This is the key really. Field’s action were not in any grey area. This talk of a code gives cover to his appalling judgement, by suggesting his judgement was not lacking. The Prime Minister still refuses to let the truth be known about the extent of Field’s actions. Labour can agree to
refer the issue to the Privileges Committee for investigation, or the PM, with no doubt unanimous support from all party leaders, could establish a commission of inquiry with actual powers to investigate.

A Green challenge

Russell Brown in reviewing the Ewen-Street defection to National, comments that GE is the wrong issue for the Greens to be brandishing as an example of National being unable to change – because every party in Parliament (except maybe Maori) is oppossed to the Green Party stance on GE.

Russell poses what I thought was a good future challenge on GE:

We haven’t had the real GE debate yet. That will come when we’re presented with a GMO – a grass, or a tree – whose environmental benefits are so compelling that we will really have to make a decision. It will happen, and I would have to think that it is more likely that it will be the Greens’ 100% refusenik stance that will be challenged, and not the broader Parliamentary consensus.

Marriage is healthy

Joe Lieberman

It is likely that the US Democrats will gain control of the House and maybe the Senate later this year. However the growing power of the hard left “Kos” faction may yet prove to be their Achilles Heel.

2000 VP Candidate Joe Lieberman has just lost the primary for his senate seat, and will now stand as an independent. His crime is to be a against pulling out of Iraq (the same position as Hillary Clinton). I regard it as a sad day when the Democrats have effectively said “You can’t disagree with us on Iraq and remain a member of this party”. Many on the “right” in the US disagree with the GOP position on the war, but are not hounded from the party.

It will be interesting to see if Clinton is now targeted to change her position on Iraq. If she doesn’t she may fail to get the nomination. But if she does, she may make herself unelectable at the main election.

And the winner is …

Okay some good research done by readers on whether any past Government’s can compete with this one for the title of most corrupt.

Amongst the serious entries (had to be as good as covering up MPs having immigrants as unpaid labour, refusing to pay back money, deliberate breaches of electoral law etc.), we had:

* Holyoake years for mini-cartels and import licenses. But as this is still current Green and Progressive party policy, and was universal policy in the 60s this is ruled out.

* Lange Government for selling off two French Agents for $500,000. But as no personal gain was involved doesn’t qualify as corrupt.

* Muldoon for usurpation of Parliament (Fitzgerald v Muldoon), This isn’t bad having parallels to Darnton v Clark) but again no personal gain for Muldoon involved – he was merely illegally implementing election policy.

* Peter M nominated a series of foreign corrupt Governments ranging from Jean Chretien to any Nigerian Government.

* Lange Government for hiding that the BNZ was almost bankrupt, and that the country had a $5 billion deficit. Not so much corrupt as incompetent.

* Grant M makes a strong case for the Hall Government with settlers bribed with confiscated land

* Vogel and Seddon also pick up some nominations

* Don Brash chimes in with agreement that Vogel, Hall and Seddon may have been more corrupt than the current Government so amends his statement about this Government being the most corrupt *ever* to merely “The Clark Labour Government is the most corrupt government in the last hundred years.” 🙂

* Finally Cardinal Walsingham chimes in with a nomination for Hall also

So the consensus is that the Hall Government is the most corrupt ever, and the Clark Government is only in second or third place. Mind you if people give her a fourth term, I am sure she can claim the mantle off the good Sir Joseph Ward!!

Auckland Super City

Legal Challenge re Election Spending

The NZ Herald has an article this morning quoting Winston Peters saying (correctly) the Auditor-General’s decisions could be challenged in court, and that any party could seek a declaratory judgment from the High Court.

I would have thought this was the perfect time to mention there is in fact a lawsuit before the courts, on this exact issue. It is seeking a ruling from the High Court as to whether Helen Clark’s authorisation of the pledge cards from taxpayer funds was legal.

I am mystified why the media continue to ignore the lawsuit. The Solicitor-General and Auditor-General have apparently come out and effectively agreed with the plaintiff, so the lawsuit has to be considered as having a very good chance of success.

Perhaps at Helen’s next press conference, someone could ask Helen why she has not yet filed a defence with the court?