UN Human Rights Reform a farce

The UN voted a few hours ago by 170 to 4 to set up a new Human Rights Council to replace the the Human Rights Commission, “which in recent years has included some of the world’s most abysmal rights violators.”

The new Human Rights Council was proposed to be break from the old Commission which is the words of Kofi Annan “casts a shadow on the reputation of the United Nations system as a whole.”

Sadly this is in fact a cruel hoax where they have done little more than rename the old Council. Let’s look at what Kofi Annan originally proposed:

Member States should agree to replace the Commission on Human Rights with a smaller standing Human Rights Council.

It has shrunk by 10% only from 53 members to 47 members. This is ridiculously large and guarantees that it will continue to have as members some of the worst infringers of human rights. 25 should be the maximum if not even lower.

Its members would be elected directly by the General Assembly by a two-thirds majority of members present and voting.

This would have made it easier to keep the North Koreas of the world off the Council. But this was unacceptable to the member states who watered it down to merely a simple majority.

They have also kept geographical quotas. It has to consist of 13 Member States from Africa, 13 from Asia, 6 from Eastern Europe, 8 from Latin America and the Caribbean and 7 from Western Europe and Others.

Now it is almost undeniable that western european countries (which includes us) have the best human rights records in the world. Dozens of surveys show this. Yet they are restricted to 7/47 seats.

Then it gets even worse. They have term limits of two consecutive terms. This again greatly increases the probability that flagrant human rights abusers will be elected to the Council. For example after six years one will have had 26 African countries as members or becoming members and if someone can find 26 African countries with a great human rights record I’ll be impressed.

There are some minor bright spots such as every country will be subjected to a universal periodic review of their human rights.

But overall the UN has not only backed away from all the substantive parts of the reform proposal, but its compromise has quite possible made it even worse that the previous Human Rights Commission.

It will be very interesting to see which countries get elected. China has welcomed the creation of the Council so that gives us a fair idea!

Myths on the Probationary Period Bill

The hysteria has already set in. No Right Turn claims the bill “would prevent workers from suing for arrears if they are not paid.”

But go the Bill and it says:

However this does not affect the employee’s rights … or action for breach of contract in relation to probationary employment which could extend, for example, to recovery of wages.

A probational employee still has rights under general contract law, just not through the Employment Relations Authority for 90 days.

Graeme in comments on the earlier thread said it meant employers could sexually harass new employees. Again quoting the Bill’s explanatory note:

However, this does not affect the employee’s rights under the Human Rights Act 1993 in the event that he or she suffers discrimination on the various grounds covered by that Act

And NRT has spoken about the WINZ policy of 13 weeks stand-down if sacked and how this will force people into starvation or homelessness. Or if we are rational WINZ will simply amend their policy so that it doesn’t apply to terminations during a trial period.

Something critics have also failed to mention is that one can agree with an employer not to have a probationary period. It is not compulsory – it can be opted out of by mutual consent.

Otago University Code of Conduct

Oh dear I see Otago University is planning to become moral guardian and wants a code of conduct for how students conduct themselves off campus.

They tried this also when I was there in the late 80s and we got the idea killed. I hope OUSA does the same again.

If students break the law, then arrest them and charge them. But don’t start having a public university setting special rules for how students should behave off campus.

Investigate’s Tamihere Interview

Ian Wishart is putting old stories from Investigate onto his blog. A very good idea once they no longer compete with the print edition.

So for the first time we have online in all its glory the John Tamihere interview. And for old time’s sakes, a few quotes:

* The biggest sweatshops we

Work Probation Bill passes

Now this is a major defeat for the Government. Wayne Mapp’s bill to have a 90 day probation period for new employees passed the first reading 63 to 58 as three out of four Maori Party MPs voted for it.

You see unlike the 100 MPs bill which has almost no chance of retaining majority support past select committee stage, this bill could retain its supporters and be passed into law against the Government’s wishes.

Now of course some will scare monger that if such a bill becomes law, then a horde of employers will suddenly turn evil and sack all their new staff at the 90 day mark so their staff never gain enhanced employment protections. This is mickey mouse type lunacy as the costs to emploters to recruit and train up new staff is often very significant. What it will mean is that if you hire someone who just obviously isn’t up to the job you can say within 90 days that it isn’t working without the risk of a huge legal battle.

Drinking Age

There’s an interesting suggestion in the NZ Herald that the drinking age could remain at 18, but the age for purchasing takeaway alcohol be raised to 20.

I’m adamantly against raising the drinking age to 20, but would be far more comfortable with just the takeaway purchase age being raised to 20.

Making it a crime for a 19 year old to have a drink or two in a bar is daft. But most of the problems from youth drinking is from parties where teenagers have purchased bottles of spirits etc so a higher age there is not necessarily such a bad thing.

Germany has an interesting system. You can (going off memory) buy beer and wine at one age (16 I think) but can’t buy spirits until either 18 or 20.

Dr Cullen becomes Dr Sullen

Well not quite but the NZ Herald does devotes its editorial to the fact Dr Cullen has gone from the witty happy Dr Cullen we all know and love to the old and grumpy man now nicknamed Dr Sullen by some local blogs.

Cullen at his best is simply hilarious. I’ve seen a room full of partisan Labour hating National staff in hysterics as Cullen’s wit has eviscerated a National MP. Sometimes you just can’t help laughing, even when turned on your own side.

But the NZ Herald is right that the witty Dr Cullen is seen less and less, and the grumpy Dr Cullen seen more and more.

Mind you to be fair – if I had to defend David Benson-Pope, I’d be bloody grumpy also!

UPDATE: Just had pointed out to me that the advert which appears next to the editorial is for the Herald’s TV supplement and is titled “Grumpy Old Man” with a profile of the Speaker of the House in Commander-in-Chief. Very amusing placement.

Australian News

I like how the Australians deal with MPs who use taxpayer funds improperly for party political purposes. The ICAC recommended the Department of Public Prosecutions consider laying charges for obtaining money by deception.

That would make Helen pay it back!

Still in Australia we have a Ministerial driver who had a road rage incident and pulled a gun out and punched a motorist. I can’t imagine any of VIP drivers losing it like that. and I’m pretty sure they don’t drive with a gun!

And finally we have a security guard who got $3.5 million for being bullied at work. At first upon seeing the headline I thought this was an outraegous amount of money. Having now read what he actually had to endure, it sounds pretty reasonable.

No of Electorate MPs

As I have said previously one of the problems of reducing the number of MPs to 100 is that over time we will have less and less List MPs, almost guaranteeing overhang situations where we lose proportionality.

Basically so long as the North Island grows faster than the South Island (SI seats are set at 16) then the number of electorate seats will grow. This happens every five years after each census.

Now I’ve gone to the official Stats NZ projections from the 2001 census. They have projections up to 2026 for NI and SI populations and projections up until 2016 for NI and SI Maori populations (which affects the Maori seats).

Now this has allowed me to do some projections as to how many electorate seats there would be (based on 2001 census) after each census. Using medium growth assumptions it is:

2006: 71
2011: 73
2016: 74
2021: 76
2026: 77

If however the South Island followed a low growth path and the NI high growth then the no of seats would be:

2006: 73
2011: 78
2016: 82
2021: 86
2026: 90

This has been based on 60% of Maori choosing to go on the Maori roll. If this percentage increases then the numbers grow slightly more.

So even if one did decrease the number of seats to 100, you would almost be forced to increase it again in the next 10 to 20 years.

Democrat Presidents

I was watching this 1976 Gerald Ford campaign ad (love the music!) and that got me thiking that from 1969 to 2009 there would have been only 12 out of 40 years with Democratic Presidents.

In the 40 years before that though it was Republicans who only managed 12 out of 40 years.

Go back another 40 years for 1889 to 1929 and its is reveresed again with Republicans in for 28 years and Democrats for 12.

1849 to 1889 had it evenly split. 20 years of Democrats, 16 years of Republicans and four years of a Whig President.

Holocaust Cartoons

Power Line reports that the Iranian holocaust cartoon contest has over 700 entries to date. One can only quote their conclusion:

Apparently the world’s cartoonists don’t much fear that rabbis will issue a fatwa, or that rampaging mobs of Jews will burn down their houses.

2,049 years ago

Today is the Ides of March. 2,049 years ago Julius Caesar was murdered.

I originally was going to post he was killed 2,050 years ago but then remembered there was no 0 AD. That is why of course millenium celebrations should have been held 31/12/2000 not 31/12/1999.

100 MPs Bill

Looks like the bill cutting Parliament to 100 MPs will make it to select committee. That of course doen’t mean it will become law but it is right to allow the public to make submissions on it.

It looks to pass the first reading by 61 votes to 60 with National, NZ First, ACT and Maori Party in favour and Labour, Anderton, United Future and Greens against.

As I blogged in February, I don’t support the bill and may even make a submission to the select committee on it.

Today in Parliament

Leave granted for Parliament to sit until midnight Thursday to pass a land transport bill. Normally it would rise at 10 pm under urgency but by extending the time it means a Friday sitting is avoided.

Q1 is Nick Smith to Chris Carter on what talks he or his office had which led Bob Harvey to say the Minister would turn down the Marina proposal. Carter confirmed he did speak to Harvey but denies he said anything improper.

Nice supp. from Smith – “Does he consider it due process to tell your mates in advance what the decision is, get them to arrange e-mails in support, and then use the existence of such e-mails as justification for his decision!”

Q5 on Christchurch Polytechnic was great. First of all we find that no money has been repaid yet for the $15 million Cool IT course despite 3% completion rate only. And then Ron Mark asks Cullen whether he can confirm that the Polytechnic has purchased art works painted by no other person than the outgoing CEO. Cullen looks bemused and said he would welcome any such information.

Overall mostly fairly boring.

Office Banter

Frit has posted a copy of some e-mail banter at his workplace. Like him I also enjoy e-mail banter at work – makes the job far more enjoyable if you can.

Some of the e-mails between staff at Parliament were hilariously offensive. Insults (all between friends) would be limited only by one’s imagination and if the e-mails had ever been sighted by the human resources department they would have probably all died from heart attacks. One former chief press secretary used to even photoshop people’s faces into images and sent them around. I once appeared in place of the new born son of an MP.

Most staff worked well over 50 hours a week so letting off steam didn’t impact productivity. However occasionally the flame wars would go over the top. One Friday I recall returning from lunch to find around 75 e-mails in the inbox all as part of a thread taking the mickey out of me which had just started when I left.

I’ve actually kept pretty much all my e-mails from them. Might make a good publication one day 🙂

Leaders’ Health

A very long but fascinating article at Oxford Journals called:

Diseased, demented, depressed: serious illness in Heads of State

The author is The Rt Hon Lord David Owen. Lord Owen is a former British Foreign Secretary with medical training so he is in a unique position to give first hand opinions on what ailments various world leaders had.

He concludes by stating:

On balance, I believe there should be provisions in place in a democracy to ensure that before voting any candidate for Head of State or Government into office, whether for the first or for subsequent elections, the general electorate should know the results of an up-to-date independent medical examination. Relying on a politician, ambitious for office, to reveal their true health or on their own personal doctor, family or friends is not sufficient.

10,000 yesterday

Another wee milestone of sorts yesterday. For the first time had over 10,000 visits in a single day. In fact had 10,471. Not sure why so many yesterday as no big event was on, so presume just part of the standard ongoing growth.

dailyblog.JPG

As one can see there is a lot of variation from one day to the next.

NZ Portrait Gallery

The NZ Portrait Gallery used to be on the ground floor of Bowen House. In fact in the space where the temporary Debating Chamber was.

I didn’t realise it had moved out until I saw this RNZ story today. A pity as it was a nice location for it.

Anyone know what the space is now used for?

State House on $113K

NZPA reports that one state house has an *after* tax income of $113,602 amongst its tenants. This is double the average *pre* tax household income.

Now if one had a fair accommodation assistance policy where who owns your house doesn’t matter, then this wouldn’t be a concern.

But Labour reintroduced a policy where those in state houses get far more assistance than low income NZers with private landlords. This means that this blocks a more needy family from getting the lower rents.

The sensible solution is to go back to delivering accommodation assistance through the accommodation supplement only (so no discrimination based on who the landlord is) but failing that then Housing NZ needs to either evict tenants when they rise above a certain income level, or preferably sell the house to the tenants or a private sector landlord and use the money to buy more housing stock to help those on lower incomes.

UPDATE: Whale Oil helpfully converts those after tax incomes into pre tax incomes so comparisons are more useful.

Whangamata Marina

A fascinating development yesterday with a revelation that former Labour Party President Bob Harvey told people three days before Chris Carter made his decision to overturn the Environment Court that “the Minister has got the balls to go ahead and stop the marina going ahead at Whanga.” and goes on to ask people to e-mail their opposition to the marina.

Just as interesting is that all these e-mails, which were orchestrated, are now quoted by the Minister as proof that his decision is supported. As Sandra Goudie pointed out in the House the more reliable survey is that done of every household by the Waikato Times showing local residents supported the marina by over three to one.

Text Bullying

Having worked with Netsafe for several years I’ve been aware that text bullying has been a signifiant issue for some time. It is tragic that it has taken the death of a 12 year old to highlight the issue.

I do think one has to be careful about how much one expects a telco to do. Technical innovations such as being able to block certain numbers would be very useful but I get alarmed when I read this story in the NZ Herald.

A parent complains that Telecom wouldn’t disconnect his daughter’s name as he was not the user. He then goes on to say getting his daughter’s consent was impossible. “Can you imagine the screaming match if I tried to physically take the phone from her? It’s a social lifeline.”

Umm so you want Telecom to disconnect your daughter because you are not willing to take her phone off her to protect her from text bullying?

Dirt Dishing

Well Dr Cullen went all macho today once again threatening to “dish dirt” on National MPs unless they are nicer in the House.

The ironic thing is that Labour of course dish dirt all the time. Cullen has several times said things in the House without a shred of proof such as Judith Collins’ expenses at the Casino Control Authority or false allegations against David Henderson.

But nevertheless it is probably useful for me to share my views on dishing dirt. The first thing is that not all dirt is equal. Politicians and media like to label anything which has an MP in the gun as dirt but there are several shades.

The true dirt is that of a purely personal private and non criminal nature which is merely designed to embarrass. This is stuff like an MP is having an affair or an MP visits prostitutes, gambles a lot or is secretly gay. Unless there is severe hypocrisy involved, then touching this stuff is a big no.

Then there are MP driven allegations against other MPs regarding actions taken prior to becoming an MP which would reflect badly on them today. This is when MPs themself make the accusations which may be based on leaked documents. An example is Tuku Morgan and his $89 underpants.

Then you have allegations about former conduct where others are the accusers and the MPs co-operate with them. This is the case with Benson-Pope. Hide and Collins were not the ones making the accusations – they came from many separate former students who mainly were just annoyed he was denying them all together.

Then you have accusations about current actions of an MP, but not directly related to them in their roles as an MP. An example is getting into fist fights, urinating in corridors, drink driving etc. The key between this and the first do not touch category is this category has something happen in public where one or more members of the public witness it and are aggrieved – or the law has been broken.

Finally you have accusations about their conduct as an MP. The classic example is Philip Field using constituents needing migration assistance for cheap labour. This is in fact not dirt in any way but exposing incompetence or corruption. Also accusations from other categories can move into this area if like with Benson-Pope they end up lying to Parliament about it.

If Labour go ahead with their silly threats, then I suggest people look closely at what sort of dirt it is. I suspect it will be mainly from the first or second category and that really will be opening a can of worms.

Face Recognition Page

This is quite cool. You can go this face recognition site, upload a photo, and it tells you which celebrities you most look like!

So of course I’ve just uploaded a few. The matches are:

Miss Ten: Shania Twain 75%, Julia Roberts 74%, Eva Longoria 74%, Charlize Theron 74%, Jennifer Aniston 73% [Anyone detecting a pattern here]

DPF: Ernest Hemingway 62%, Joshua Jackson 60%, Hugh Jackman 58%

Helen from Estonia: Rachel Hunter 61%, Meg Ryan 56%

Rodney Hide: Ricky Martin 72%, Jack Nicholson 66%, Michael Collins 61%,

Helen Guergis: Ricki Lake 71%, Renee Zellweger 70%, Demi Moore 68%, Courtney Cox 64%

Everyone Counts

The Kiwi Expat Association (KEA) wants us to think of New Zealand as not just the four million living here but the one million or so living overseas. Absolutely.

They have a little survey to register where our expats are living. If liiving overseas go to their website and spend a couple of minutes there filling in their 12 question survey. If you want you can also fill in an unofficial census form so they can compare stats of expats to the official census stats when published.

They already have about 16,000 registered.

For The West Wing Fans