Faster, Cheaper Broadband

Firstly well done to Telecom for their new range of broadband packages. There are up to 90% price reductions, and increases in both download and uoload speeds. A good step forward.

It’s amazing what can be done when it is suddenly clear the Government is going to take action, and everyone from the PM to the NBR is saying things have to change. The challenge ahead is to have a market structure where the owner of the local loop has a permament incentive to meet market demand, and not to have to rely on 18 months of commerce commission action etc to get better packages.

And as much as Telecom cheekily plays down the influence of the commerce commission action on these offerings it is worth recalling that they fought incredibly strongly against having the same wholesale fee for residential and business. They lost and this was set at $27 for both. The retail business packages which were as high as $2,400 a month have dropped to under $100.

As I said at the beginning these new offerings look a pretty good improvement. However I haven’t seen full details yet, especially on data caps. If the data caps have not been increased then a connection four times as quick may just use up the monthly data cap four times as quickly!

Australian Welfare

A good article by the Centre for Independent Studies over at the NZ Centre for Political Debate.

The key line that strikes me is that Australia spends $80 billion a year on income support, and personal taxes come to $90 billion a year. So yes almost the entire personal tax take goes on redistributing income – some of it back to those who pay it.

A School Initiative

The SST has an interesting article on Avondale College which has set up a website where parents can check their children’s attendance rates grades and detentions.

Looks pretty sensible to me. This is all data which a parent has an absolute right to know, and means they can be aware of any issues and progress more than twice a year. Hopefully also they can see if problems are developing.

Moxie at Kete Were (eagerly supported by others in the comments) is horrified though. And I thought the reasons given are a wonderful explanation of one of the fundamental differences between many on the left and right:

1. Grades and days off are not the only measures of educational success

Days of our Lives Part II

A week ago I posted links to the ongoing saga of love and hate between four bloggers.

Well it all looked to have had a happy ending when Pink Panda posted on Thursday what appeared to be genuine repentence for her behaviour.

However this post today from Annika suggests it was all a sham. Read about dognapping and car theft.

And then what may be her final post before someone arrests her, from Pink Panda.

The amusing saga has now turned rather sad and somewhat scary.

Blog Snippets

Graeme Edgeler has spotted a story about how the UK Tories’ tactics to defeat the Religious Hatred Bill were modelled on an episode of The West Wing.

Basically they publicly declared the vote was only a two-line vote meaning not compulsory to attend, but then secretly told their own side it was a three-line vote so they all turned up and won by one vote.

If they had not managed a win, then Rowan Atkinson could have faced prosecution for some of his former skits.

Samantha Burns makes the obsevation that “Blogging is like sex. You have to keep it fresh and interesting, or else everyone will get bored and move on.” 🙂

And back home the plagiarism issue between Jason Watson of Keablog and TVNZ’s Chris Harrington has been settled with a retraction and apology. Well done to both parties for not letting it drag on.

Free Speech Threats

No Right Turn reports on how the Swedish Government has actually shut down a website of a (political party) newspaper after it began a competition to find more Mohammed cartoons.

And Sweden is held up as a model by Helen!

Meanwhile the UN is considering making blasphemy a breach of human rights. Yes that’s right – countries that allow blasphemy could end up in before the proposed UN Human Rights Commission. No doubt those countries which censor free speech will never end up there.

Not to be outdone the EU is looking to have a media code which would urge the media to respect all religious sensibilities. And how long will this code remain voluntary?

Series Finales

Now this is a great Wikipedia page – Series Finales. It has a short summary of every major series finale from the 1960s on. My God the memories! Some favourites:

* Blake’s 7 – After being absent for two years, Blake returns and has apparently turned traitor (though this is in fact a ruse). In a misunderstanding, Avon shoots Blake dead, then Dayna, Vila, Soolin and Tarrant are gunned down by Federation troopers. The final shots show Avon surrounded by troopers and raising his gun, then gun shots are heard…

* To The Manor Born – Audrey and Richard marry, and Audrey is once more the lady of Grantleigh Manor.

* Benson – And the Winner is… – Benson runs against Gatling for state governor. The two men sit together waiting for the election results. The outcome is not revealed.

Four Things

Sarah from This Chick (in a welcome return to regular blogging!) has tagged me with the Four Things meme so here goes.

Four jobs I’ve had:
1. Medical Laboratory Assistant and Researcher
2. Secretary
3. Historian
4. Kitchen Hand

Four movies I can watch over and over:
1. Shawshank Redemption
2. Life of Brian
3. Ever After
4. Dukes of Hazzard (heh kidding – actually Kill Bill Vol I)

Four places I’ve lived:
1. Dunedin
2. Wellington
3. Barrie, Ontario, Canada for a month!
4. Wellington again so will list suburbs which has been Island Bay, Roseneath, Karori and Thorndon

Four TV shows I love:
1. The West Wing
2. Boston Legal
3. House
4. Blackadder

Four places I’ve vacationed:
1. Cairns, Australia
2. Fiji
3. Reikorangi, Kapiti Coast
4. Florida, USA

Four of my favorite dishes:
1. Crayfish
2. Chicken Noodle Soup
3. Spaghetti and Meatballs
4. Chicken Cordon Bleu

Four sites I visit daily:
1. NZ Herald
2. Stuff
3. Crikey
4. Bloglines

Four places I would rather be right now:
1. Bali
2. Port Douglas
3. Berlin
4. Estonia

Four bloggers I am tagging:
1. Kellie
2. Paula of Celebrating Mediocrity
3. KiwiGirl
4. Maria von Trapp

Eddie McGuire

Unless you watch the Australion version of Who Wants To Be A Millionaire? on Prime TV, you may now know who Eddie McGuire is, but he has just become the CEO of the Nine Network in Australia.

I’ll make a rare prediction. If he suceeds at his new job one day he will be a senior Cabinet Minister, if not Prime Minister of Australia.

Personally I’m a bit annoyed at his job change. WWTBAM was pretty much the only quiz show I watch, and that was largely due to McGuire who was a great host.

Political Suicide

Any possibility John Banks had of becoming Auckland Mayor again, has I suspect died with his idiotic comment on his talkback show that the Robert Hewitt survivial story is a hoax.

You just don’t make claims like that without some evidence or experience of your own. I am all for being sceptical or even asking questions (not that in this case I have any scepticism at all) but you don’t just assert something may be a hoax without some proof of inconsistency.

Trade Boycotts

It is incredibly gratifying to read sentences such as “The New Zealand Federation of Muslim Associations has been at the forefront this week of lobbying Middle Eastern ambassadors to persuade their political masters not to impose sanctions”.

It shows recognition of the fact that New Zealand does have a free press, and that seeking to punish an entire country due to the decisions of a free press in that country is quite wrong. It is a different situation to seeking a boycott to protest a Government decision one doesn’t like such as asking to boycott China because of their invasion of Tibet.

How-ever as is always the case, there are sad exceptions such as recent immigrant Asif Naim who actually has written to the Khaleej Times in Dubai calling for a boycott of NZ products.

I wonder how well a New Zealander would do if they moved to Pakistan and called for a trade boycott of Pakistan because they objected to a story in a Pakistani newspaper. I suspect they would be arrested or worse. To say Mr Naim is ungrateful would be putting it mildly – he is quite willing to exploit our liberal traditions of freedom of speech to try and punish all NZers for the fact we do have freedom of speech.

Pussy-Whipped

Heh only a female journalist could get away with using the term pussy-whipped in an article. Fran O’Sullivan writes:

Are the New Zealand authorities so pussy-whipped that they have to wait until four months after the election to throw the book at Labour for what looks like a clear raid on the Government purse to help finance its campaign?

Also a good read is the Dom Post Editorial headlined Sugar junkies in charge of lolly shop, which I guess is a more politically correct version of alcoholics in charge of a brewery.

Audrey’s predictions

NZ Herald Political Editor Audrey Young has made some predictions as to whom will be doing what in three years times.

She predicts Cullen will be Speaker, saying this is an ambition of his. Never knew that. His replacements to be Goff as Deputy Leader and Mallard as Finance. Shane Jones will be Maori Affairs, Maharey will be on the way out and Hobbs wil have retired for Grant Robertson (ex NZUSA).

For National Young predicts a Key/Collins leadership.

She predicts Winston Peters will not stand for Tauranga again, and NZ First will not make 5% and be wiped out!

For the Greens she predicts Russel Norman as co-leader.

Christoper Harder

Who said this?

Just as almost everyone is comdemning Labour for their deliberate over-spending on the election campaign, a white knight comes to the rescue. Now guess which neutral impartial expert said the following:

* The over-spending showed rules around campaigning needed a re-think (translation: the rules are at fault not Labour)

* $400,000 is not much money compared to a US campaign which can spend $500 million (ignoring that as a proportion fo legal expenditure it is a huge over-spend)

* Campaigning is a constantly evolving process (Labour are just ahead of the times!

* National had help from the Exclusive Brethren

* The over-spending didn’t affect the result anyway

* Labour won not due to the extra money but because they were more clever and got out the vote

So which neutral impartial expert said all this. Guess.

Christoper Harder struck off

The New Zealand Law Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal has struck off controversial Auckland solictor Christopher Harder from the law practitioners roll.

Now he has the spare time perhaps he can fly to the Middle East and negotiate an end to the violence over the Danish cartoons. For those who don’t know Mr Harder has a history of flying uninvited into situations offering to negotiate a truce or something. Normally he gets arrested or deported for interfering!

Whoops and Spin

The reply to all function on e-mail has got a few people into trouble over the years and the latest is a media boss. You see it all started with a simple e-mail by the editor:

From: Editor [names have been deleted]
10/02/2006 09:14a.m
To All Staff

Morning all. Just a wee announcement to confirm or deny the rumours
depending on what you’ve heard – xxxxx has resigned from
aaaaaa to go and work for bbbbbbbbb. I have ads out currently seeking to hire a replacement senior journalist. yyyyyy will step up to deputy editor. Tx Editor

The publisher then sent a note to the editor, and accidentially replied to all so it went back to every staff member saying:

From: Publisher
10/02/2006 09:49a.m.
To Editor
cc All Staff

Hi Editor,

Can we discuss yyyyy taking on the role of Deputy Editor
Publisher

Oh dear oh dear. You have just told all the staff you doubt both your Editor’s judgement and the new Deputy Editor. And you don’t want to lose them as well as the person who has just left. So quick in seven minutes the spin arrives:

From: Publisher
10/02/2006 09:56a.m.
To All Staff

Seeing that I have cc’d everyone on the email!!! I might as well email
what I wanted to discuss.

I want to make a separate announcement in regards to yyyyy re: how brill
yyyyy is and that we are very excited that he has stepped up to the plate
and look forward to his work this year. Also to thank xxxxxx for her
dedication and input and wish her good luck for the future.

Publisher

Well the publisher must be very glad the employer is a limited liability company so in the event of any lawuits, you’re protected from personal liability!

When were Labour told?

Just had some useful clarifications on when Labour were told that the pledge cards etc constituted election activity.

Prior to the election National complained to the Chief Electoral Office that they were electoral activity (as defined by the Act) and they broke the law by not having an “Authorised by” statement on them. The Chief Electoral Officer considered the matter and advised *prior to the election* that he considered they did constitute election activity and referred Labour to the Police on that matter.

Now despite having already been told by the Chief Electoral Officer that he considered the pledge cars as election activity, Labour carried on calculating their spending as excluding them.

Then after the election the Electoral Commission (a different body) got Labour’s return and formed the same view as the Chief Electoral Officer that the pledge cards were election activity and hence has also referred Labour to the Police for the different offence of over-spending.

So Labour were already in possession of the advice from the Chief Electoral Officer that these pledge cards constituted election activity, when they decided to carry on spending over the limit, despite the almost inevitable likelihood that the Electoral Commission would form the same view as the Chief Electoral Office and deem them to have over-spent.

I wonder if the very small level of fine available was a key factor in deciding to risk it?

Questions that should be put to Helen

Following on from yesterday’s coverage about Labour’s over-spending which is here and here I have a list of questions which I would put to the Prime Minister if I was a journalist:

1. Did the PM attend any meetings at which it was discussed whether the pledge card should be included as campaign expenditure, and was any other MP in attendance?

2. Did the PM approve the material which was funded out of the Labour Party Parliamentary Budget?

3. Who made the decision to not count the pledge card as campaign expenditure, despite having declared it as such in 1999 and 2002? [I now have conflicting info on whether it was included in their 1999 and 2002 returns so this may not be valid]

4. How did her party decide that an election pledge card would not qualify as campaign expenditure?

5. Did her party seek any advice from electoral authorities about whether the pledge cards should be included as campaign expenditure and if not, why not?

6. Is it correct the Electoral Commission/Chief Electoral Office told Labour before the election that their pledge cards must be included as campaign expenditure and that Labour simply decided to ignore them?

7. Her party president has said the law is unclear and needs clarifying. Why then did her Government not amend the law after the 1999 or 2002 elections as part of the traditional select committee review of the election?

8. As the Electoral Office has found the expenditure to be campaign related, will the PM

How hard was it to survive at sea?

In the earlier thread on Robert Hewitt surviving 75 hours at sea, some people thought it was nothing special as he had food, a wetsuit and the water was 20 degrees. In fact even suggested that most healthy adults could survive five days if they did not encounter hungry sharks.

But this story on the Dom Post makes it clear it is quite extraordinary, some calling it the stuff of legend. And Hewitt was already badly hallucinating and had drifted around 40 kms north before drifting back south again.

VWRC expands

Great to see the Australian based Centre of Independent Studies has established a policy unit to concentrate on NZ issues. I am a huge fan of the work the CIS does and they play a valuable role in public policy debates.

Also congratulations to Phil Rennie who has been appointed their policy researcher. Phil is the only person to have ever been a co-blogger on this blog, albeit very briefly!

No Right Turn is not so happy of course!

Woeful Retirement Savings

We rank towards the bottom of the developed world for private retirement savings, saving only one quarter of what US citizens do.

One of our problems is that people believe the state will be able to provide them with everything they need in retirement, when the reality is that even with the Cullen Fund the level of state super is limited and not sustainable at age 65.

I’m surprised that the average age NZers start saving for retirement is 32 as the return is so much higher if you start saving from your 20s or even better from the age of 12 as I did 🙂

Since I started working I’ve been putting into superannuation funds a relatively high proportion of my income. I want to be able to have a fun retirement regardless of whether there is a state pension. In fact with acclerated mortgage repyaments and superannuation and insurance payments, I end up with less than 50% of my net income available for spending.

Two-tier Internet

Some US Telcos want to be able to start dividing Internet traffic into two tiers, based on if they get paid a premium.

This is somewhat akin to a Telco saying that when you make a phone call, they will deliberately have a slow connection with lots of static on the call unless you pay them an additional fee.

Vint Cerf is one of the two people who created the main protocol the Internet runs on. He is regarded as the Father of the Internet (and incidentially will be in Wellington in late March). He testified this week to a US Senate Committee on why what the US Telcos want goes against the fundamental principles the Internet was built on which have made it so sucessful.

If this issue doesn’t send you to sleep, go read what Vint said.

Also worth reading Peter Griffin in today’s NZ Herald who does a nice plain English explanation of it all.

Labour overspending continued

In a lame spin attempt Labour Party President Mike Williams has said on TV One that he is pleased to have the issue investigated so they can get some clarification. How-ever the issue has always been very clear.

You see in both 1999 and 2002 the Labour Party included the cost of their pledge cards as election expenses. This has not been an area of great ambiguity. Have a look at the Electoral Act Section 214B.

Specifically 1(c) which says “encourages or persuades or appears to encourage or persuade voters to vote for the party” – and tell me that one can claim a pledge card could not be included.

To make it worse for Labour they were warned before the election numerous times that the pledge cards and other taxpayer funded material should be included in their return. Now a sensible party does what Bob Clarkson does when it becomes clear your spending is under scrutiny. Just to be safe you restrict your spending so you are safe even if the interpretation goes against you.

Labour made a very deliberate and calculated decision to reclassify pledge cards as not being included as expenses. They were warned numerous times about this and chose not to keep their other spending down to compensate.

Cruising with Lee Tamahori