Kiwiblog by E_mail!

One can now get a daily dose of Kiwiblog, delivered by e-mail. Why? Well like PC who I stole this from, I don’t know if there is anyone out there who can’t use the web, but hey a daily e-mail works well for Public Address, so worth a try.

I am using Feed Blitz. To subscribe to this blog just scroll down the left-hand side to just below the recent comments. Enter in your e-mail address, and after you click on a link in a confirmation e-mail you’re subscribed.

Now does this mean if I blog 12 times a day, you’ll get swamped with 12 e-mails? No you get just one e-mail with an extract and link to each item I have posted since the last e-mail. So it may be useful for those who just want to check our particular items.

Fun in Parliament

Various stupidities

First of all we have Nick Eynon at Three Point Turn who says:

This renewed call from Treasury to cut taxes is a little out of date don’t ya think?
Didn’t we just have an election a couple of months ago centred on this very issue?
Team Tax Cut lost. Get over it.

Okay Nick, now you may have missed this but Government Departments are obliged to offer their honest advice to an incoming Government. As much as you might want them to lie, that is not desirable.

Let me use an analogy. If National won the election, would you really demand that Te Puni Kokiri in its briefing says “We think the Government should abolish the Maori seats, scrap our department, and get rid of treaty principles in legislation?

Then we have Frog Blog excited because naughty Nandor not just got to mention the Treaty when taking the oath, but wow we he didn’t really take it back and he also made reference to “the people of Aotearoa” which not even the Maori Party did.

I’m sorry but grow up. Who gives a f***. Oh dear we are more Maori than the Maori Party because our non Maori MP used the word Aotearoa!

Incidentially as a Republican I support changing the oath, but there is a process for changing it.

Then we have the About Town crew who think they are really really smart because they did a double dupe. Umm no. You simply lied. Any moron can tell a lie, and because most people will believe someone until given cause not to, of course some people will believe a lie. April 1 is the honourable exception to the rule.

A clever dupe has elements of truth to it. A good example is Random Contributionz who used a real life event (the protests at the Aussie HC) to classify it as a terror test. That was very well done.

Perspectives on terrorism

Crikey yesterday said that the likelihood of a Westerner dying from jihadist violence is around 0.0001%, while the annual probability of an Australian dying of smoking-related causes is 0.1% and Americans are almost nine times more likely to die falling off a ladder than in a terrorist attack.

Hence they lambast the media for having headlines such as “Stockpile of chemicals found in shopping mall”.

I think Crikey fundamentally misses the point. Terrorism has never ever just been about death tolls. It is inane to use that as a focus. Terrorism is about how it affects society and human behaviour. Two bombings in Bali, and that place is now a pariah for many tourists for years to come.

To somehow suggest that the media should not give more prominence to an alleged plot to kill as many people as possible, perhaps by blowing up a local nuclear power plant, than they do to the road toll is ridiculous.

The Press has a good editorial on the issue today. They remind us that the police role in terrorism is dramatically different to traditional crime. Traditionally police apprehend perpetrators after the crime. When it comes to terrorism the challenge is prevent the crime in the first place. Especially when it is 95% likely the perpetrators will be dead themselves. And yes that is why we do need to give the Police and intelligence agencies more powers (but not unlimited – the 90 days detention without trial Blair wanted was too much). Because if we don’t, their role will simply be to tell us afterwards how it happened.

Maiden Speeches Day II

Got the final seat in the gallery for Pita Sharples’ maiden speech. Some good common sense there. At the end his supporters in the Gallery rose and did a thundering waiata and haka. It was very cool to see such passion about having got him into Parliament.

Then we had Maryan Street. I thought she was the best of the four new Labour MPs, even though she got annoying with it being an inaugural, not a maiden speech. Good God – let’s also lobby the ICC to ban the term from cricket, why not.

Paula Bennett’s speech I loved. It was so personal and about her and her life. She spoke about her pride in being Maori, her pride in also being European but most of all her pride in being a New Zealander. Also how she became a solo mother at 18, and how proud she is of her daughter (who was in the gallery) who is also now 18.

Labour’s Darien Fenton spoke. I have to admit I didn’t listen that closely to the Labour ones. She mentioned unions a lot, as another Labour MP did yesterday.

Chris Finlayson’s speech was a great pleasure. Chris was a very successful lawyer and orator before becoming an MP, and showed it in the House. He wonderfully managed to praise and insult Margaret Wilson at the same time (by saying he hoped we would not be losing her as Speaker to become a Supreme Court judge) and bitch-slapped Michael Cullen not once, but three times. Each time by praising one of Dr Cullen’s colleagues such as congratulating David Parker on being appointed Attorney-General and say he looks forward to some good law reform now that we have a lawyer as Attorney-General, not a former history teacher 🙂

Chris also spoke on an issue dear to my heart – about how National has inherited both a liberal and a conservative heritage from the parties which formed us in 1936, and that liberalism and conservatism can work together to produce great outcomes, rejecting that liberalism somehow belongs to the left. Like Chris I am proud to be a liberal conservative!

Then we had Bob Clarkson. Bob was Bob. He detailed his life from his first business deal aged 8, to deciding to stand for Parliament. His line of “When I was 30 I got married,” Mr Clarkson told Parliament. “After 11 years I asked my wife what she wanted for Christmas and she said a divorce. I wasn’t thinking of something quite so expensive.” absolutely brought the house down. I could see Don Brash almost falling out of his chair with laughter. Bob also got in a nice line or two about how Peters threw everything at him, yet he still won and Winston lost.

Again as the speeches are placed on Hansard, I’ll link to them. Interestingly I noted that the Hansard staff were not actually writing anything down during the maidens. I suppose because you don’t have interjections, they can rely on the MP’s supplied speech notes as being a full transcript.

The Death Test

You call a girl high maintenance just once, and she then wants to know when you’re going to die!

Well having now sat the death test, I have established the following:

I can expect to die on Wednesday, August 8th 2046, aged 78.

I am most likely to die from:

Alcoholism (10%)
“Cleaning your Rifle” (7%)
Contagious Disease (3%)
Drowning (3%)

Interesting I die close to Maria – only 18 months apart. It means if we marry we get to have 39 years together 🙂

Today’s Winston story

Today Winston walks out of a press conference in Pusan because he didn’t like the questions.

And does he really think people are so stupid that we will accept the comparison to Lange being a Minister outside Cabinet after he stood down as PM. Lange did not lead a party claiming to be in Opposition, while a Minister, and Lange also did not refuse to sit on Cabinet Committees.

Treasury Briefing

Treasury in their briefing to the Government have made a strong case for reductions in both the individual and company tax rates.

They also have pointed out the awful effect of high effective marginal tax rates which have reached 90% under Labour.

On the other side of the coin, Treasury has also said that the quality of services the public has received has been dubious, despite the significant increases in state sector spending.

What I did have to laugh at is Dr Cullen claiming that Treasury’s policies would lead to students having to pay more. Has he not noticed the 10% increases in fees voted by Victoria University last month?

Great news on Internet Governance

Just been getting reports from people at Tunis and an agreement has been brokered which appears pretty good. The UN or ITU or some other body will not take over the domain name and IP addressing system, which will remain with ICANN.

An Internet Governance Forum is to be established, but it will be for information, discussion and co-ordination. In areas like spam, identity theft etc it is actually a good thing to have a global body which can co-ordinate on these issues.

The compromise is not ideal, in that there is a risk the Forum could try and exceed its mandate in future years, but overall it looks like sanity prevailed.

ICANN has been far from perfect in how it has conducted itself, and should not see this as a licence to maintain bad habits. A lot of this fuss would not have happened if they had made better progress by now on certain issues. But the basic ICANN model is a good one, and far superior to having some UN body in charge where the private sector would have next to no voice.

For the very very keen followers of this issue, I’ve included below the text of the report. It does still need to be ratified but looks a done deal.

UPDATE: The Register has an article. Seems like Condoleezza Rice helped win the day.
Continue reading »

Canberra confused about Peters’ role

Wow such accountability

Maiden Speeches Day 1

Popped into Parliament yesterday to hear some of the maiden speeches. Not hard to find Mark B’s office as it used to be mine!

Tim Groser and Mark Blumsky both gave their maidens yesterday, and while quite different speeches what I like is that largely both of them spoke about issues they are passionate about. Trade for Tim G and Wellington for Mark B. I’ll link to them once the Hansard is up.

I suspect they were both very happy that one doesn’t heckle during maiden speeches. During other speeches the level of heckling was almost deafening.

Good catch-ups with various people at drinks afterwards upstairs, and then later at the Backbencher. Am looking forward today to seeing if any of the new Electorate MPs thank their predecessors – especially in Tauranga 🙂

Not a good start for DBP

Last Friday the Press reported that two beneficiaries were being investigated for claiming single benefits while they were living together on a yacht.

Judth Collins asked the new Welfare Minister yesterday whether benefits were intended to allow people to fund their yachting voyages. Benson-Pope claimed he had no knowledge of any inquiry, despite it having been reported publicly four days earlier.

This seems like an early audition to replace George Hawkins as Minister most likely to not know what is happening in his Department.

NZ Herald RSS feeds

The prosecution’s case

The (Sydney) Daily Telegraph has a copy of the prosecution’s statement against the alleged terrorists. Some very chilling stuff there:

Read the whole thing. Look at the list of items found or ordered such as 165 railway detonators and 10 x 20 litres of sulphuric acid.

Hat Tip: Francis Till

Smart move by the Greens

Definitely a smart move by the Greens leaving cannabis law reform with Metira Turei and giving environment to Nandor. This presumably will have Jeanette Fitzsimons move into the Finance role.

Also pleased to see Nandor retain or get back Comms/IT. Have found him well informed on those issues.

While talking Greens I do think it is somewhat ironic that their gender quota for the co-leadership, no doubt originally introduced to help women, is now discriminating against them. I think there is a lesson for everone here about quotas.

NZ Herald on Winston

The NZ Herald slams the Government’s decision to allow the Foreign Minister to not even be a member of the Cabinet External Relations and Defence Committee as “ridiculous”.

The editorial points out NZ First could have chosen to support Labour without insisting on a Ministerial job for Mr Peters, and that his role “becomes more ludicrous by the week”.

They conclude by saying “If he wants to pretend he is Foreign Minister the least he could do is contribute to the decisions he must defend. Otherwise he declares his job a sinecure – all status, no responsibility.”

Also on the same note well done to presumably National Research Unit who found old quotes from Helen Clark on on NZ First such as “the coalition partner from hell”, “like a parasite, which feeds on its host and in the end becomes indistinguishable from it”.

I like the way the Government is always referred to as the Labour/NZ First or Clark/Peters Government. You can see the pained expressions on Labour MPs faces everytime it is repeated.

Well done About Town

Super Hero Hair Cuts

Nude swimming with Bob

Heh now this in inspired and funny. Bob Harvey was auctioning off a naked swim with him as a fund-raiser for the Auckland Philharmonia.

Cameron Brewer from Newmarket Business Association won the bidding for it, and has donated the prize to Judith Tizard, Dich Hubbard and two other local mayors to help the local body leaders get to know each other better and “expose and get to the bottom of issues” 🙂

Kazakh humour

I was very amused to read on Aaron’s blog that the Kazakh government is threatening a lawsuit against Sacha Baron-Cohen (better known as Ali G) for his character of Borat Sagdiev.

It seems they object to his assertion that cow-punching is a national sport, and their wine is made from fermented horse urine 🙂

Winston’s new trade policy

I really should blog less on WInston but it is such a target rich environment at the moment. However I feel a bit guilty as it is like shooting fish in a bowl!

Rodney has pointed out that Winston is no longer against trade, only trade with countries we have a trade deficit with.

Now just think what would happen if every country adopted this as policy – umm no trade at all.

And just think. With Winston’s policies you might have no computers in NZ if computer manufacturing countries do not buy more of our lamb and beef than we buy of computers from them.

National MPs by Region

An issue within National for some time has been geographical spread of MPs, especially in terms of the five Regions of Northern, Central North Island, Lower North Island, Canterbury/Westland and Southern. One of the things the List Ranking Committee looks at si a fair spread, but it can be difficult to get it right as you make assumptions about total level of vote, and what seats one may win.

In 2002 the number of MPs per Region, plus their percentage share (and a comparison of the overall percentage seats per Region) was:

Northern 13 48 % (35%)
CNI 5 19% (18%)
LNI 2 7% (21%)
CW 5 19% (16%)
Sthn 2 7% (10%)

Total 27

So three regions about right, LNI well under the population share and Northern well over.

Now in 2005 the following net gain in seats per region was

Nthn 6 (all on list)
CNI 3 (all elects)
LNI 6 (4 elects, 2 list)
CW 3 (all list)
Sthn 3 (all elects)

Total 21

So now looking at regional distribution we have:

Northern 19 40 % (35%)
CNI 8 17% (18%)
LNI 8 17% (21%)
CW 8 17% (16%)
Sthn 5 10% (10%)

Overall this is now pretty spot on. I’d say the List Ranking Committee should be pretty pleased with the outcome, as should the new MPs of course 🙂

National MPs by Region

An issue within National for some time has been geographical spread of MPs, especially in terms of the five Regions of Northern, Central North Island, Lower North Island, Canterbury/Westland and Southern. One of the things the List Ranking Committee looks at si a fair spread, but it can be difficult to get it right as you make assumptions about total level of vote, and what seats one may win.

In 2002 the number of MPs per Region, plus their percentage share (and a comparison of the overall percentage seats per Region) was:

Northern 13 48 % (35%)
CNI 5 19% (18%)
LNI 2 7% (21%)
CW 5 19% (16%)
Sthn 2 7% (10%)

Total 27

So three regions about right, LNI well under the population share and Northern well over.

Now in 2005 the following net gain in seats per region was

Nthn 6 (all on list)
CNI 3 (all elects)
LNI 6 (4 elects, 2 list)
CW 3 (all list)
Sthn 3 (all elects)

Total 21

So now looking at regional distribution we have:

Northern 19 40 % (35%)
CNI 8 17% (18%)
LNI 8 17% (21%)
CW 8 17% (16%)
Sthn 5 10% (10%)

Overall this is now pretty spot on. I’d say the List Ranking Committee should be pretty pleased with the outcome, as should the new MPs of course 🙂

NZQA consistency

Well it looks like there is still a hell of a long way to go before faith in NZQA is restored. Look at this story:

* School pupil’s geography essay marked as excellent by his teahcer
* Essay won a national geography award as judged by university lecturers
* Essay also selected for publication in official jouran of the Geographical Society
* However NZQA moderation declares essay did not meet required standard and should have received a failed grade