Replacing Rod Donald

Generally I would wait longer before speculating on the political aspects of the Greens losing Rod Donald, but as there are front-page media stories on the issue, I guess it is fine.

There are four main roles for which the Greens need to find a replacement for Rod Donald. They are:

1) List MP
2) Co-Leader
3) Finance Spokesperson
4) Political ‘Director’

Taking them in turn:

1) List MP

Nandor Tanczos is next on the list. It is likely he will take it up, but he may have to decide soon. If the next person on the list was a new person, he might give way to them, but each of the next two after Nandor are not ideal. Mike Ward is 8th and he is a nice guy but with the Greens already having one of the older average ages in Parliament, bringing back a guy in his 60s would not help them with the youth vote. After Ward is the capable Catherine Delahunty, but if she came in then you would have only one male MP in the Caucus.

So 90% likely to be Nandor, with say a 10% chance they may jump down to Russel Norman at No 10. The more they think about it, the more Norman may make sense though. They were devastated to lose Nandor at the election, but the question now is the skill set needed to replace Rod Donald.

2) Co-Leader

If the Greens didn’t have their stupid gender quotas, they could just select the best person for the job, which in my eyes would be Sue Bradford. But their constitution says it has to be a male. Everyone agrees it will not be Keith Locke unless they have an electoral oblivion wish. Nandor is a possibility, but it will be a huge step up for him. The next male possibility is Russel Norman. Now they could make him a co-leader outside Parliament (with a guaranteed list place next election) but this is a full-time job so the Green Party would have to pay him a salary.

Jeanette has indicated she will probably retire next election. I expect her replacement would be Bradford or Turei. Thus it is important to have an experienced co-leader.

3) Finance Spokesperson

As much as the business community didn’t like Green policies, Donald did a good job in knowing the economic issues, and being able to speak credibly on such issues. There is no obvious successor for this important portfolio unless you go down to Roland Sapsford at No 15. As they need someone in Parliament the safe bet is probably to give it to Fitzsimons but they could try Bradford or Turei out with it.

4) Political ‘Director’

Donald was their main political strategist. He lived and breathed political campaigns. Again there is no obvious successor for this role unless ones goes down to Russel Norman at No 10 who was their national campaign manager.

It will be interesting to see what the Greens do. In their hearts they will instinctively want Nandor back (as reported here) but the more one looks at it, the more bringing in Russel Norman makes strategic sense – it solves both the leadership issue, and the political campaign experience issue.

Televised Opening of Parliament

For those who do not get Sky Digital (Channel 54) you can view the opening (today and tomorrow) at R2. Has just started.

UPDATE: Commissioners have just walked in. Rod Donald’s empty seat is very noticeable.

In theory any three Judges of the High Court or higher can be sent as Commissioners. However they have sent the Chief Justice, the President of the Court of Appeal and the High Court Chief Justice.

UPDATE2: Those who affirmed (I think), not swore are Barker, Barnett, Beyer, Benson-Pope, Blumsky, Brash, Burton, Carter C, Chadwick, Clark, Cullen, Dalziel, Donnelly, Dyson, Fairbrother, Fenton, Fitzsimons, Gosche, Guy, Harawira, Hereora, Hide, Hobbs, Hodgson, Horomia, Kedgley, King A, King C, Key, Locke, Mackey, Maharey, Mahuta, Mallard, Moroney, Okeroa, Pillay, Power, Ririnui, Street, Swain, Tizard, Turia, Turei, Williamson, Wilson, Yates

Those who swore the oath on the bible were Anderton, Ardern, Auchinvole, Bennett D, Bennet P, Blue, Borrows, Bradford, Brown, Brownlee, Carter D, Carter C, Choudary, Clarkson, Coleman, Collins, Connell, Copeland, Cosgrove, Cunliffe, Dean, Dunne, Duynhoven, English, Field, Finlayson, Flavell, Foss, Gallagher, Goff, Goodhew, Goudie, Groser, Hartley, Hawkins, Hayes, Heatley, Henare, Hutchison, Hughes, Jones, Laban, Mapp, Mark, McCully, O’Connor, Paraone, Parker, Peachey, Peters, Pettis, Rich, Robertson, Roy E, Roy H, Ryall, Samuels, Sharples, Simich, Smith L, Smith N, Stewart, te Heuheu, Tisch, Tremain, Tolley, Turner, Wagner, Wilkinson, Woolerton, Worth,

Choudary swore on the Koran, Almost all Maori MPs swore in Maori, Harawira affirmed in Maori and I think tried to add in a reference to the Treaty of Waitangi and had to do it again. Sharples did much the same thing and also had to repeat. Looks like Sutton was missing. Turia just had to repeat it also. I think they know the Clerk will force them to do it again – this way they get to claim they swore to the Treaty but still get sworn in. Wong missing also.

It was hard to keep up so the list above is not authoritative. The rough stats are that 47 MPs affirmed, 71 swore an oath. The % affirming for each party are Labour 65%, National 15%, NZ First 14%, Greens 80%, Maori 50%, ACT 50% and 0% for United Future and Progressive.

Very quick Speaker election – around three seconds. Wilson nominated herself, no-one else nominated, and she was declared elected. She has made brief mention of Rod Donald’s service to the House.

UPDATE3: Speeches congratulating Wilson. Brash recalls she helped him get Reserve Bank job and they used to be on an Auckland unemployment committee together, along with Helen Clark. Finally a moment’s silence for Rod Donald.

The next Green MP

Jeanette has said Nandor has time to think it over, but in fact he may not have much time. Rod had been declared elected an MP, even though not yet sworn in. His death triggers a vacancy under paragraph (h) of section 55(1) of the Electoral Act.

This then triggers Section 134(1) which says the Speaker “must, without delay, publish a notice of the vacancy and its cause in the Gazette”. Further the Governor-General must under 134(2) “as soon as practicable after the date of a notice published in accordance with subsection (1), issue to the Chief Electoral Officer a warrant in form 7 directing the Chief Electoral Officer to proceed forthwith to supply the vacancy”.

Now one can argue we have no Speaker at the moment, but we will have shortly, and even without a Speaker, Section 135 mandates the GG shall act for the Speaker.

The bottom line is that a notice in the Gazette must appear today or tomorrow, and an instruction to the CEO to fill the vacancy must happen at the latest by Wednesday. It arguably might all happen today.

The CEO is then obliged to fill the vacancy using Section 137 which basically says look at who is next on the list, check with the party secretary they are still a member, and then ask the candidate if they are willing to be an MP. The candidate needs to signify his or her willingness to be an MP, or it goes to the next person on the list.

Now Section 137 doesn’t use the terms “must” and “without delay” as with the earlier sections, so there may be some latitude for the CEO to decide not to demand an answer within the hour. But I strongly suspect he would not delay beyond the end of the week. If Nandor is unwilling to signify yes, then he is obliged to ask the next person on the list.

Electorate Split Voting Statistics

I’m not going to review all 69 electorates, but interesting to look at a few of them.

In Tauranga Bob Clarkson got 19% of Labour voters and 69% of National voters. Peters got 40% of Labour voters, 26% of National voters and 93% of NZ First voters. Only 31% of Labour voters voted for the Labour candidate. So if there is a by-election, what will those voters do?

In Epsom, Rodney get 80% of ACT voters, 10% of Green voters, 10% of Labour voters, 60% of Libertarianz voters but most importantly 59% of National voters. Richard Worth got 38% of National voters and 24% of Labour voters. Rodney points out both National and Labour voters disobeyed their hierarchies.

In Wellington Central Hobbs got 77% of Labour voters voting for her, while Blumsky got 82% of National voters? So why did he lose? Well Labour’s party vote was a lot higher than National’s but also Marian got 69% of Green voters, in the Greens strongest seat.

In Nelson Nick Smith gets not only 94% of National voters, but also 14% of Green voters and 27% of Labour voters.

Peter Dunne gets support from both National and Labour. 34% of Labour voters voted for him, as did 52% of National voters. Ironically even 21% of Green voters voted for Dunne.

Anderton in Wigram has 22% of Nats vote for him but 57% of Labour voters.

In Pakuranga Williamson gets not just 84% of National voters but also 11% of Labour voters.

Taking the seven Maori seats collectively, we see 62% of Labour voters voted for Labour candidates but 30% voted for Maori Party candidates. While 85% of Maori Party voters also voted for Maori Party candidates.

And just in Tamaki-Makaurau we see Sharples got 87% of Maori Party voters but also 36% of Labour voters.

Split Voting Statistics

The CHief Electoral Office has now published the split voting statistics for the election.

Overall 28.7% of voters split their votes, down from 39.0% in 2002. National voters were the most ‘loyal’ with 84% of national party voters also giving National the electorate vote. Labour was at 78%.

Looking at party voters for each party, we have:

ACT: 23% also voted for ACT candidate and (sensibly) 59% for National candidates.

Green: 25% also vote for Green candidate, 57% for Labour candidates.

Maori: 73% also voted for MP candidates, 14% for Labour candidates

NZ First: Only 31% voted for NZF candidates, 32% for National cands and 20% for Labour cands – suggesting NZF voters are more centre-right.

UFNZ: 34% voted for UFNZ candidates, 16% for Labour cands and 40% for National cands.

30 km/hr CBD limit

I’m generally supportive of the idea of lowering speeds within the CBD to 30 km/hr. Certainly one shouldn’t drive faster than that down Lampton Quay.

My only reservation is how they define the CBD. It should exclude Aotea Quay etc, and also the roads to the south of Dixon Street which tend to be safer.

Rod Donald stories

MP Deaths

It has been a long time since an MP died in office, let alone one as young as Rod Donald. Off memory it has been 20 years since an MP died in office, with the last three being:

Bruce Barclay died in 1979, leading to Geoffrey Palmer entering Parliament

Frank Rogers of Onehunga died in 1980, replaced by Fred Gerbic

Basil Arthur died in 1985 with National’s Maurice McTigue winning Timaru in the by-election.

Oh my God

Just been texted by Lin Nah to be told Rod Donald has died of a heart attack. The last person I would expect. I’m stunned. He was only 48.

My sincere condolences to all of Rod’s family, friends and colleagues. I had met Rod several times over the years and genuinely liked him. Parliament will be a lesser place without him.

On a minor note, he will be replaced by Nandor Tanczos as a List MP. Poor Nandor also – a horrible way to become an MP again.

UPDATE: NZ Herald has story online.

UPDATE2: Scoop has a few more details. Funeral on Thursday.

UPDATE3: Condolences can now be left on the Greens’ Blog.

UPDATE4: NZPA has a summary of comments from the other party leaders.

A silly story

The SST tries to set a trap for Wayne Mapp by asking him his views on a bakery and shop which calls itself Golliwog. They run a sub-head which says “Wayne Mapp, is offended but local Maori seem unconcerned about a Bay of Plenty shop that calls itself Golliwog”.

However what Wayne said is quite different. He correctly says the requests for comments was probably a smart trap to catch him out, and all he says is that some people may find it quaint, others may find it offensive and personally he wouldn’t use the word but ” it is a free country and why would we stop a business that no one is complaining about”.

An absolutely sensible response and a lightyear away from the sub-head suggesting he is offended, while local Maori are not.

And as for that claim local Maori are not – well they only interviewed two. One said it was not offensive and one said it was. So their sub-head is wrong on both counts.

I don’t want an debate on golliwogs, I just wanted to highlight that the SST seemed to have as headline in mind, and have tried to unsuccessfully fit the story to match. Bizarre.

A far better story is Finlay Macdonald’s A-Z of political corectness.

Democracy by Michael Frayn

On Friday night I went to Circa to see the play Democracy by Michael Frayn. It was an excellent play – highly recommended, and even nicer it was free as I was officially going as Mark Blumsky’s date 🙂

The play is about Willy Brandt, and his eventual resignation as German Chancellor when it is revealed one of his closest aides has been a long-term spy for the East German Stasi.

There is a cast of ten, all men, and they do a great job of portraying Brandt’s inner circle and the ups and downs of the era.

If you want a good night out, well worth going to. Around two hours in total, plus a break. A Daily Telegraph review is typical.

Why did the chicken cross the road?

Blair has done a NZ blogger version of the traditional jokes. It’s really really well done – capturing most people perfectly. Highlights are:

Aaron Bhatnagar:
The chicken was forced over to the far side of the road by the Council’s neglect of basic infrastructure in maintaining the near side footpath. No road crossing would have be necessary under an ACRN-led council.

Not PC:
Because the government tried to stop her.

Sir Humphrey’s:
The chicken had no alternative. We have documents showing that Helen Clark deliberately and secretly manipulated the chicken’s egg-laying statistics to cover up her inefficient management of this particular poultry farm, thus defaming the innocent chicken and forcing its departure.

Just Left/Jordan Carter:
Given the number of diffuculties experienced by the chicken recently, it is amazing that it performed as well as it did in getting from one side to the other. Overall a pleasing result for the chicken.

Tumeke!:
The chicken crossed the road as an act of defiance against the state in order to claim its rightful territory. Ake ake ake!

And of course my one:

David Farrar:
There was a conference across the road and it was necessary for the chicken to attend. The exotic hens present had nothing to do with it.

Very well done Blair.

State House Rentals

As unpopular as it is to say so, linking state house rents to the income of the tenant, instead of the value of the property is seriously flawed.

We see this again today where some people are actually making more money from sub-letting their state houses, than they pay in rent. This is not the intent of government policy, but inevitable.

You see if a tenant pays the same for a one bedroom apartment as a four bedroom apartment, they have no incentive not to stay in the four bedroom apartment and make money out of it.

Some people will rant on about the evil of market rentals, but they overlook that these were coupled with the accommodation supplement, which does take account of both income and costs. It is a far fairer way to deliver support to low income NZers, than income related rents.

Remorseful?

Enemies of free speech

The FCC in the US, in a fit of madness, is considering whether to regards blogs as media and regulate them. Yes to express an opinion on your personal blog might mean you’d have to register etc.

There was a bill in the US House which would put blogs off limits from media regulation. It needed a 2/3rds majority to suspend the rules to adopt it. It got 225:182 and fell short.

Republicans voted in favour 179:38, while Democrats voted 46:143 against.

Science Fiction Series Length

Wikipedia is a treasure trove. I try to read at least a dozen articles a day. To read all 800,000 articles before I day I really need to do 20,000 a year which would be 60 a day.

Anyway there is a wikipedia article on the more well known sci-fi series, and how long it would take to wacth the whole series continually.

Blake’s 7 would take 1 day, 19 hours and 20 minutes.

Buffy on the other hand would take 7 days, 19 hours and 42 minutes (Have actually watched every buffy episode in order, but not non-stop).

Doctor Who comes in at a massive 12 days, 19 hours and 20 minutes.

The biggie is Star Trek. To watch every TV show and movie would take 22 days, 7 hours and 52 minutes. If one was to watch it for eight hours a day, it would take two months to get through it all!

Back to normal

The Connell saga

The Connell saga is not dying down, with Brian accusing Don Brash of a “selective retelling” and saying he will confront Caucus on Tuesday.

Where will this end up? There are a number of possibilities. The broad options are:

1) Rehabilitation

Connell apologises, gets portfolios back eventually, gets stuck into his portfolios, works feverishly at any chance to attack the Government and if National wins in 2008 gets a Ministerial position.

Comment: Not looking likely.

2) Obscurity

Connell doesn’t apologise, but doesn’t continue to criticise publicly. Diligently works at being good local MP, and remains backbench National MP for Rakaia.

Comment: A possibility. However Connell has said he thinks he is PM material, and is unlikely to ever be happy just being the MP for Rakaia.

3) Challenge

Connell continues to snipe, but not enough to warrant formal disciplinary action. However seen as ineffective and isolated and is challenged in 2007 for the 2008 nomination.

Comment: Also possible. However keeps issue in the media, and means possible negative publicity closer to next election.

4) Suspension

Either Caucus or the Board suspend Connell, and he is blocked from seeking re-nomination.

Comment: Not a long-term option. A suspension has to be either revoked (as with Maurice) or lead to expulsion, otherwise keeps issue in media.

5) Expulsion

If criticisms continue unabated, Connell’s party membership is revoked and he becomes an Independent MP.

Comment: This will result in bad publicity now, but mean the issue disappears from public eye in a few months. Independent MPs find it very hard to get any publicity at all, they are almost invisible in the House, and unless their departure was on the basis of a policy breach to set up a new party, little long-term media interest.

6) By-election

Connell resigns or is expelled from National and seeks a new mandate in a by-election.

Comment: Can not be ruled out. Connell has referred to his majority several times and obviously thinks he could win a by-election. Personally (and having worked for the previous MP for Rakaia for several years I know the electorate quite well) I think National would very easily win the by-election, especially as Mrs Shipley (who is still very beloved there) would I am sure endorse the official candidate. If National stood an existing List MP such as Kate Wilkinson, then National would gain Katrina Shanks as the next List MP.

Please note I am not endorsing any particular course of action, just highlighting what they appear to be. I certainly hope it can be sorted out quickly and beneficially to all parties.

The Press raises the issue of whether this will lead to support for bringing back the party-hopping legislation. I agree with The Press that it should not.

Keeping the Internet UN free

The Heritage Foundation has published an opinion piece on why the Internet should not be put under UN control.

Many of the argments have been made elsewhere, but one notable feature is the highlighting that this is not the first time repressive countries have tried to use the UN to clamp down on freedom of expression. In the 1970s they tried to use UNESCO to create a “new world information order” which would license journalists, create an international code of press ethics, and increase government control over the media.

Driver Distractions

The NZ Herald asked for reader feedback in light of the Police calling for a new offence of being distracted by driving. Some very amusing comments:

* Aki Nawaz managed to complete Donkey Kong on a Nintendo Gameboy when driving from Hamilton to Auckland.

* Marcia has “done a crossword puzzle, done my boyfriend, done my hair and make up, texted people, eaten breakfast, brushed my hair and my teeth, smoked, got dressed for work”. Marcia goes on to say that this was all on the one trip. I presume she brushed her teeth after doing her boyfriend!

* Michelle has painted her toe nails!

A New York mugging

Safe Crimes for Criminals

The Police has usefully published a list of crimes they are now too busy to investigate. This will be very useful for criminals, as they now know what crimes they can commit with minimal risk.

Commercial burglary, repeat break-ins, fraud, theft from cars and shops, and criminal damage are now all effectively penalty free.

This of course is unrelated to the fact that NZ has less police per 10,000 people than Australia, UK and US.

Peters on Iran again

AFter Iran called for Israel’s destruction all our foreign minister could muster was to read out MFAT’s note saying the comments were unhelpful. Should qualify for an award for under-statement.

After howls of criticism Peters has got MFAT to give him some new words – we are up to “inflammatory and unacceptable”. Getting better.

Missing a chance to stamp his mark on the portfolio, and show he isn’t just a news reader behind an MFAT teleprompter he claims “New Zealand takes an open-minded and even-handed approach to UN voting on Arab-Israel resolutions” on the basis of “our voting record has been closely aligned with the Nordic countries and broadly aligned with the EU”.

Does he not know the EU is dominated by French foreign policy which is massively anti-Israel?

Maharey excuses

NRT rightfully lashes Steve Maharey for his pitiful excuse for ignoring OIA deadlines, something labelled by the Ombudsman as subverting democracy.

Maharey, the man who wants to be PM, claims meeting the 20 day deadlines would require so much overtime by his staff, it would make them sick.

NRT rightfully points out that one easy solution is simply to hire more staff, if that is the problem (I guarantee you it isn’t). Ministerial office budgets are huge.

The other option is to simply let the Department respond to the OIA request without interference from the Minister’s office. Maharey’s staff only have to spend time vetting information going out, because the Minister is worried it will be politically embarrassing. Then they have to invent reasons to decline it, until they get over-ruled.

So on all fronts Maharey’s excuses are incredibly lame. If this man ever became PM, he would be even more arrogant and thinking himself above the law than the incumbent.

The problem with TVNZ

Many of the problems TVNZ currently has can be attributed to the fact it is state owned. Take the current court case with Susan Wood.

If TVNZ was a privately owned company, no-one would be that interested in how much their presenters and reporters are paid. Sure a bit of prurient interest but you wouldn’t be having the Prime Minister instructing the board through the media that they have to reduce salaries.

But we have had this. And so a politically appointed Board has to cut salaries or face being sacked themselves. So they refuse to agree to salaries above a certain level, regardless of the commercial or legal rationale for it.

Now the Government has also passed a law saying you can not put people on fixed term contracts without a very good reason, and can’t just use fixed terms contracts as a way to screw employees over and lower their pay rates unilaterally.

So where does that leave TVNZ? They either have to (arguably) break the very law passed by the Government and unilaterally reduce pay rates, or they have to obey the law and end up getting sacked by the very same Government.

Despite the charter, which confuses rather than changes things, TVNZ is a commercial organisation. Political governance sits badly with that. If they turned TV One into a non commercial public service broadcaster and sold off TV2, they would have far less problems.