GB vs GG

I think Gerry Brownlee did us a favour by highlighting the weaknesses in our constitutional conventions, but he did aim at the wrong target. It’s the PM not the GG at fault.

Lewis Holden and No Right Turn have both written good pieces on the problems with our current arrangements. Go read.

Under our current conventions the GG really has to follow the advice of the current PM, even if a caretaker (unless it is clear the PM would lose a confidence vote in the House). We rely on the PM’s integrity to respect the conventions and not for example refuse to resign office if they have lost the confidence of the house.

The problem is that Clark, like Muldoon, shows a willingness to ignore conventions which stand in the way of power. If we had a written constitution it might usefully have a clause which says the parties with MPs as Ministers form the Government. Common sense. But as the convention is not binding, Clark has trampled on it, destroyed the notion of collective responsibility and allowed a situation to develop where we have the farce of yesterday with NZ First MPs claiming they are opposition MPs (as they voted poodle like with the Government).

Broadband Targets

One welcome part of the speech from the throne was:

With respect to ICT, my government will be advancing policies to ensure that the telecommunications sector becomes more competitive and that we achieve faster broadband uptake in line with our competitors.

The Commerce Commission decision on unbundled bitstream will help to some degree. However Telecom has claimed the pricing model is unlawful which means they may seek a court review of the final determination, if unchanged.

I think Telecom are playing a very dangerous game. It is very clear they will not meet their target of one third of broadband connections being wholesale through other ISPs. Hence they have somewhat audaciously have claimed they never actually agreed to that as a target!! The Commerce Commission and the Government are far from impressed and have rebutted the claim.

If I was Telecom I would stop fighting the UBS determination (note I appeared on behalf of InternetNZ in support of the draft determination so I represent an interested party, but my comments are honest opinion). The reason why they should is that when they fail to meet their target, they can say to the Minister “Well the Commerce Commission determination (due mid Dec) has just come out and this will increase uptake, so there is no need to look at any further regulatory measures, and let’s just see in six or twelve months where we are at”.

But if Telecom do seek a court review of the Commerce Commission determination then it will not be made available until well into 2006. And the Government having promised pre-election to take action will have no option but to look at further regulation. So Telecom faces a very real possibility of winning the battle but losing the war, as the rules of engagement will be changed by the Government.

It’s back

Just when we thought the nasty little party hopping law was dead and buried it came back into Parliament yesterday as a present for Winston from Labour.

Even though the law proved useful in getting rid of Donna Awatere-Huata, it flaws do not exceed its benefits. Donna would have gone anyway when convicted. The legislation gives far too much power to party leaders to evict dissident MPs from Parliament and Peters is obviously worried about his own caucus.

Labour have agreed to vote for it, but NZ First and Labour/Prog only have 58 votes. It needs the Maori Party or United Future to vote for it to make it to select committee. Let’s hope they don’t.

No tax cuts

Labour ruled out tax cuts in the next three years in the speech from the throne. They still push the myth they are unaffordable despite the fact the surplus for the last three months alone is a massive $2.6b. Yep for just three months.

To blow a possible $10b surplus, the number of madcap schemes to throw money at is going to multiply exponentially.

Red Cross to adopt Red Diamond

Fascinated to read that the International Red Cross Movement is looking to add on a Red Diamond as an authorised symbol. This is a good thing.

Almost all countries use the Red Cross. And contrary to what Reuters says this has nothing at all to do with having Christian traditions. It is simply the reverse of the Swiss flag – no more, no less.

However for several decades some countries, mainly Muslim, have used a Red Crescent as they did (wrongly) see the Red Cross as a Christian symbol. And Iran for a while even had a Red Lion with Sun as a symbol.

To complicate things further the Israel Magen David Adon Society doesn’t want to use a cross or a crescent so they have used a red shield (star) of David and not been an official member of the Red Cross Movement.

So adopting the red diamond – which has no religious significance at all – will allow Israel to join if they adopt it, and also possibly over time may lead to all countries moving to this symbol so we have one universal symbol.

Incidentally the supreme Conference of the Red Cross which makes these changes is not simply a meeting of reps from the ICRC, the IFRCRC and national red cross/crescent societies. The 192 states who have signed the Geneva Conventions participate also.

At some stage I should blog more about the Red Cross. It was a fascinating place to work and does so much good in the world. Over 300,000 staff world-wide and with a unique mission, principles and role.

St Molesworth: Top 10 priorities for the new minister of foreign affairs

St Molesworth this week: Top 10 priorities for the new minister of foreign affairs

My favourites:

1. Call Paul Holmes to get a list of his best darkie jokes.

4. Demand that he be introduced at functions as “Foreign Minister of New Zealand but not a member of the Government”.

5. Support application of British American Tobacco to become a member of the UN.

10. Force MFAT to put out an advisory against all non-essential travel to Tauranga.

2005 Durex Global Sex Survey

Well the results of the 2005 Durex Global Sex Survey are in, and let’s see what they say about us Kiwis. On a side note can I express my disappointment my company did not get asked to conduct this survey 🙂

Main findings are:

* second highest in world for one-night stands
* have sex 114 times a year – ahead of global average & Australia
* Kiwis fourth highest in world for unsafe sex
* third highest in world for number of sexual partners
* Queenstown New Zealand’s sexiest city
* Daniel Carter voted our sexiest man
* Nicky Watson our sexiest woman
* two-thirds of Kiwi women have faked the big ‘O’

Now 65% of have had unsafe sex, and women more likely than men. Bad.

The average number of sexual partners is 13.2 The 0.2 must have been a premature sufferer 🙂

And for frequency 114 times a year is just over twice a week. Hell that barely covers the weekend!

Other useful stats are that 26% have tried a threesome, 53% have had sex in a park (heh do botanical gardens count) and 3% have joined the mile high club. 15 have captured the moment on film.

Harder to beleive is Nicky Watson being most attractive female. I mean she used to be stunning but lately, well not the same. Hmmn hard pressed to say who I would rank higher though.

Oh yes the Durex site has more results including

* 42% of NZers have used handcuffs or blindfolds (or both 🙂
* Kiwi average foreplay time is 19.4 minutes – poor Thais are 11.5 mins
* NZers ranked Angelina Jolie at 24% as most sexy internationally followed by Britney Spears at 17%. But where is Jessica Simpson??

Call for Clark to emulate Bush

Internet Governance

The debate about the future of ICANN and Internet Governance has expanded from the few thousand people who normally take an interest, to some serious players indeed.

No less than Kofi Annan wrote a column for the Washington Post on the issue, saying the UN doesn’t want to control the Internet.

Now I’m not going to do a full fisking of the article, because in fact much of what Mr Annan says is true. There are areas such as cybercrime and spam where a co-ordinated international approach is desirable. However he skips over the main problem.

However the debate is not about which Government should have control of the Internet, but whether any should. Yes the US does have a historical approval role for the root zone, but they have never failed to act on a recommendation from ICANN. While they have not behaved perfectly (they wrote a letter on .xxx they shouldn’t have) they generally do not interfere with the Internet, and do leave it to ICANN. And if in fact the US Govt did try to meddle politically with the root zone (say try to delete the Iran country code) then it is highly likely the root server operators and/or most ISPs worldwide would refuse to honour the change. A lot of Government do not realise that ISPs only voluntarily use the ICANN root zone as the authoritative one.

Now over time it is desirable that the US Govt give up their role in terms of approving changes, even though it is really a rubber stamp. However this should not be transferred to some UN body. Because if you do so, I can guarantee that some Governments will try and use that body to interfere. Absolutely guaranteed. For example China and Zimbabwe would be demanding domain names which are disrespectful of heads of state be de-registered. Basically it would be a vehicle for national governments to not just set policy over their part of the Internet, but over the whole thing.

So what is the way forward? Ultimately it for a private-public partnership such as ICANN to be able to make changes to the root zone without Government approval. ICANN is flawed in many ways, and at times depresses even fervent supporters. But it is stiill the best option out there. Somehow we need to get ICANN credible enough that the US Congress will allow the US Government to fully delegate the management of the root zone. This is not a small challenge.

In the past few weeks ICANN has done some bad, some good. They have settled some lawuits from Verisign (which is good) but in doing so have given Verisign the right to keep the .com registry pretty much forever, and with far less restrictions. Bret Fauseet in an open letter points out why this is a bad move. On the positive side they have just appointed Susan Crawford to the Board, who is highly respected by many within civil society. They have also done some politically smart stuff like more international diversity in other appointments, including an Iranian to the at-large committee to represent users. I hope he won’t get shot for agreeing to serve 🙂

Finally those who are still with me may want to read an excellent interview with Professor Lawrence Lessig on the issue, as he explains things better than me!

Also for a more US-centric view is this piece in the Wall Street Journal from Senator Norm Coleman called “Beware a Digital Munich”.

Sir Kenneth Keith

The election of Sir Kenneth Keith to the International Court of Justice is no small thing. A very rare honour – more for Kenneth than for NZ.

National MPs have added their congratulations with Chris Finlayson noting he was taught by Sir Kenneth at Vic, and Wayne Mapp trumping that with having had Sir Kenneth as his PhD supervisor!

I worked at the Red Cross National Office in the early 90s and Sir Kenneth was our advisor on international humanitarian law. He was hugely respected not just within NZ Red Cross, but also by the Internetional Movement.

More on Rod Donald

Frog Blog has a link to the Tom Scott cartoon which is nicely done. The “Born 1957 – Recycled 2005” sort of hits the spot.

Also their condolence book is up to 314 entries.

Lindsay Perigo’s tribute is also well worth a read. Very nicely done.

Finally there is the somewhat baffling news that Rod did not die of a heart attack. It may take weeks or months for full autopsy results to determine cause of death, which will make it hard for his close friends and family. I would have thought there wasn’t a lot which can suddenly kill a 48 year old, but I am not a doctor.

The Susan Wood ruling

Scoop (which is invaluable for finding documents like this) has a copy of the ERA ruling in the Susan Wood vs TVNZ case.

It is very clear from reading it that Wood is now a permanent employee on $450,000 a year. After 1 January 2006 it can be varied, but only by mutual consent.

Now the media should not be letting Helen Clark escape with a no comment on this issue. Because the Government is directly responsible for TVNZ breaking the law – in two ways.

Firstly the Government changed the law in 2000 with the Employment Relations Act. Prior to the law change the Court of Appeal had ruled that if an employer and employee agreed to a fixed term contract, it was legal. It did not need to be justified. Labour legislated to over-rule the Court of Appeal and specifically made it much harder to have fixed term contracts. One had to have genuine need for a fixed term contract – such as working a project which will end.

So Labour changed the law to stop an employer being able to say well the contract has expired, now you have to agree to new terms to stay on.

Then we had the issue of high salaries for TVNZ staff. Led by no less than Helen Clark the Government called the salaries obscene, board members were given a humiliating dressing down by Maharey and the board were left under no illusion that they must reduce salaries or be sacked.

Now we see the problem. The Government as legislator passed laws to make it illegal to unilaterally reduce salaries. Yes the Government as share-holder forced TVNZ to try and unilaterally reduce salaries.

The Government needs to be held to account for this and asked how they expected TVNZ to carry out its wishes, without breaking the law? Quite simply it is near impossible if someone is willing to assert their employment rights as Susan Wood did.

Chat-Up Lines

The NZ Herald has an amusing articles on chat-up lines. Now I am not at all a user of chat-up lines – I prefer just to talk to people normally to see if we get on. However I was amused by the line researchers suggested worked best:

“Is that a ladder in your tights, or a stairway to heaven?”

Now I’d be interetsed in comments from females especially about how they would react if someone tried that line on them. Would it be:

a) Laugh at the line and invite them for a drink
b) Slap them
c) Reply with “Yes but my heaven is reserved for bad boys only” and pinch their arse
d) Tell them to piss off
e) Other ______

If it was the US, not France

I’ve been trying to imagine what the media coverage would be like if instead of black and muslim youths rioting in France, it was black youths rioting in the US for 12 days?

I imagine CNN and other media would be giving it 24 hour around the clock coverage.

I imagine there would be several dozen commentators all saying that this shows how deeply flawed, repressive and racist the US is.

I imagine there would have been at least ten days of non-stop calls for Bush to be blamed for the riots.

I imagine there would be gloating from various dictators around the world.

I imagine there would be an influx of moonbats to the areas where rioting is happening to support their oppressed brothers.

As the rioting spread from one city to many cities, the media would have invented new levels of hyperbole about how the country is now in the second civil war.

Have I missed anything? Oh yes, don’t forget how it would all be Bush’s fault again.

Connell apologises

The Toy

Well SMS technology now allows us to buy parking tickets, use coke vending machines, get flight updates etc but there is no limit to human ingenuity.

To keep in love via sms with your loved ones, we have The Toy!

Hat Tip to London Underground where comments suggest people will be looking for tube travellers who look far too happy!

A beautiful gesture

Gestures like this give me hope for the region. So many go from grief to hatred, but thankfully not all:

The organs of Ahmed Ismail Khatib, 13, the Palestinian boy shot Thursday by IDF soldiers in the West Bank town of Kabatiya near Jenin, will be donated to six Israelis.

Ahmed was shot after soldiers mistook his toy gun for a real one. Still, his parents decided to donate the organs

For Star Trek fans

I posted on Saturday that Star Trek was the longest sci-fi series, requiring 22 days of viewing time.

For the die hard fans out there, Jacqueline has found Amazon has “The Ultimate Star Trek Collection, which includes all the episodes of all the live action series (The Original Series, The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, Voyager, and Enterprise) and all the movies”.

Only US$2,500!

Australia Terror Attack

Random Contributionz blogs that 15 November is the date when Australia may face a significant terrorist attack. The Australian High Commission in Wellington is listed as one place under threat.

As the next door neighbour of the High Commission, I will be rather pleased if there is no attack. However on a totally selfish front it does partially block my view 🙂

UPDATE: For those convinced John Howard is exagerrating the terrorist threat just so he can take civil liberties away, a story has broken in the last few minutes about the arrest of 15 people whom police allege were in the final stages of a large-scale terrorist attack.

UPDATE2: More details at the Australian

Select Committee Chairs

The NZ Herald has a list of the proposed select committee chairs and deputies. First advice is to ignore the deputies as significant – they have absolutely no power unless something goes badly wrong.

The other key aspect, not yet known, is whether the committee may face tied votes and hence need the chair’s casting vote [Roney advises me they no longer a casting vote]. Even without that though the chair sets the agenda and has considerable power.

National MPs look set to chair three ordinary select committees plus two specialist ones. Katherine Rich gets Commerce, Pansy Wong Government Administration and David Carter retains Primary Production. Simon Power to chair the Privileges Committee and Richard Worth Regulations Review.

Sue Kedgley has got Health which could be a major irritation to the Government. Brian Donnelly as chair of education will be moderate.

Having made every electorate or former electorate Maori MP a Minister, the Chair of Maori Affairs goes to very low profile Dave Hereroa. Shane Jones gets a big vote of confidence with Finance and Expenditure. Di Yates as chair of foreign affairs has potential disaster written all over it.

The Listener’s Power List

The Listener has again hopped on the trend of publishing power lists and has done a 50 most powerful for NZ. NBR has the full list.

Such lists are pretty meaningless. You probably could do a useful top ten, but thinking there is some difference between No 41 and No 42 is silly. A more sensible way to doo these things would be by groupings – uber-powerful, very powerful, pretty powerful etc.

Having said all that, let’s talk about the rankings and areas of disagreement.

1 – Helen Clark (last year – 1) – agree

2 – Michael Cullen (3) – agree

3 – Don Brash (6) – disagree – no opposition leader is that powerful

8 – Theresa Gattung (21) – agree – seems to be able to get Helen to stop local loop unbundling despite a Ministerial recommendation in favour

21 – Heather Simpson (33) – disagree. Heather should be in the top ten or top five. Heather is the difference between those who mistake the perception of power and actual power.

Common Sense seems near

NZPA have a report saying that Brian Connell does not plan to quit the party and regrets things got as big as they did. This is a positive sign for a good outcome tomorrow.

Heh someone did suggest to me earlier today that a great fund-raiser for National would be to web-cast tomorrow’s Caucus meeting with a $5 pay-per-view subscription 🙂

Celebrity Death Matches

The Margaret Mahy Blog suggests some NZ matchups:

* Mark Ellis & Dean Barker Vs Mathew Ridge & Adam Parore
* Polly from ZM’s morning crew Vs Ray “Sugarfoot” Sefo –
* Dave Dobbyn Vs Neil Finn
* Alison Mau Vs Rene Wright
* Martin “Bomber”Bradbury Vs Mikey “Havo” Havoc
* Simon Dallow Vs John Campbell
* Greg “the King of Pukekohe” Murphy Vs Steve “Coast to Coast” Gurney
* Peter “the Mad Butcher ” Leitch Vs Bob Jones Vs Alan Duff
* Helen Clark Vs A pack of wild dogs

Remember these are not my suggestions – I’m just reporting them!

Wood wins court case

It appears that Susan Wood has won her court case according to this NZPA story.

However the RNZ story says her $450,000 salary will expire at the end of the year. I’m not quite sure what this means. It could mean that her employment can cease at this date, but the NZPA story suggest the Court accepts she is a permanent employee.

Certainly a bad look for TVNZ and especially the Board who basically instructed TVNZ management to illegally unilaterally cut salaries.

A Liberal Latham Diary?

The Latham Diaries rocked the Australian Labor Party with their vehement criticism (and more) of former colleagues.

Well according to Crikey (who have kindly given me a subscription to the daily e-mail which normally has 30+ stories in it) the former Leader of the Tasmanian Liberals may be planning the same. Read this letter from the current leader to the former leader:

Dear Bob,

It would appear from newspaper articles, that you intend to publish a book, presumably a memoir of sorts.

It is important to me that you understand clearly what my position is, prior to publication, on any material contained in your book which is designed to damage me personally, my family or me in my current office as Leader of the Opposition. I have taken high-level legal advice on this matter.

Based on the timing of the release of your book, I take it that you will be seeking to inflict damage of some sort, so I give you fair notice that, if you rely on gossip, rumour or innuendo etc in order to damage my reputation or character I will be taking immediate action in the Supreme Court to recover exemplary damages. Any allegations you make against me, based on first hand or second hand information will need to stand up as clear