United Future honesty

Rodney Hide highlights an extraordinary column from former United Future MP Marc Alexander where he labels suriviving MPs Judy Turner and Gordon Copeland as useless appendages who made endless soliloquies about the perils of the great moral outrages of the day.

National’s campaign debrief

Going back to hotel rooms

Cathy Odgers comments on the rape allegations against Ronaldo by a French girl.

Cathy asks why women agree to go back to hotel rooms if they are not planning to have sex with them? She isn’t saying that to do so is consent, but why get yourself in such a situation.

Happy Families – not

I am actually in the camp which generally thinks the Government will last three years (mainly because no-one will want to be blamed for pulling it down early) but when you have the Foreign Minister refusing to be photographed with all the other Ministers, and then refusing to smile in the photo with the PM and GG, I really do wonder whether it will last.

Kyoto carbon tax gone

NZ were looking to be the only developed country in the world that actually was still trying to implement the Kyoto Accord, which is now basically dead.

However even NZ looks like it will be walking away, with it being most unlikely the numbers are there in Parliament to pass the carbon tax.

Marketing not substance

The NZ Herald reports that Steve Maharey was appointed Education Minister so he could “use his marketing skills to reinstate faith in the quality of the country’s education system”.

The problem is the system needs more than spin and marketing. It needs fixing.

A classic Mahareyism full of drivel is his statement:

That means teachers supported to do their best, it means young people having expectations, it means assessment systems that are geared towards that, it means getting rid of that tail of people who underachieve so that everyone is getting some results in the system.

This contrasts with the able Dr Cullen who actually talks specifics in tertiary education, saying “Clearly we are looking for reorientation of the sector and a strong emphasis on trade skills and technical skills.”

I expect Cullen will have fixed Maharey’s former tertiary sector in 18 months or so. God knows what will have happened to the school qualifications system by then though.

Who said this?

Every week National Radio has on two former Ministerial advisors on to review the week in politics. They are Matthew Hooton who worked for Lockwood Smith and Peter Harris who worked for Michael Cullen.

Now this week, one of them said this about the new Government:

It

Foreign Ministers around the world

Wikipedia says a foreign minister is often regarded as the most senior ministerial position below that of the head of government (prime minister or president); it is often granted to the deputy prime minister in coalition governments.

In the US, their Foreign Minister (Secretary of State) ranks ahead of all other Ministers in authority and precedence with Thomas Jefferson having been that nation’s first Secretary.

In the UK the Foreign Secretary is one of the four great offices of state.

In Australia it is ranked 5th after PM, Deputy PM, Treasurer and Defence.

In Canada the Foreign Minister is ranked on the front bench.

In Ireland the Foreign Minister is ranked fourth. Likewise fourth in France. In Germany it is ranked second.

In NZ The Foreign Minister is ranked No 28 and is not even in the Cabinet.

The point is that in basically every country in the world, this is one of the great offices of state. I don’t have a problem with Peters being Foreign Minister as much as with the decision to have it outside Cabinet. That is a strategically stupid decision.

Who killed Professor Green in the Conservatory?

The ministerial ambitions of the Greens were killed off this week, and many people have been fingered as the killer – Winston Peters, Peter Dunne, Tariana Turia etc.

However the blame lies elsewhere – the Rt Hon Helen Clark. It is a fiction that she had no choice, and utter hypocrisy to hear her say it was beyond her control.

Here’s four options she had:

1) Get NZ First and the Maori Party to abstain on supply and confidence for a Lab-Green Govt. NZ First had already agreed to do this, and there was no real attempt at all to do the same with the Maori Party.

2) Get NZ First and United Future to abstain on supply and confidence.

3) Get a supply and confidence agreement with the Maori Party giving 61 votes out of 121 for a clear centre-left Govt.

4) Just form a Lab-Prog Government without NZ First and United Future as Ministers. This would not put the Greens in there, but at least would be far less of a slap in the face.

So why did Helen not do any of these things? Because it was politically undesirable in her eyes. She most certainly had a choice and options.

The Maori Party are in fact voting for Labour at this point. Helen could have got them on board for the full term by agreeing to repeal the F&S Act. She could have got abstentions for a lot less than that. But Clark believes being associated with the Maori Party is electorally unpopular so she *chose* to label them last rank off the cab (which funnily enough is what she also did to Winston in 2002) and to not form what would have been a clear left wing Government of Labour, Greens and Maori Party.

The fact her and Turia don’t like each other is irrelevant. Neither did Bolger and Peters in 1996.

Likewise Helen in no way needed to make Peters and Dunne Ministers. They did not demand it. She could have formed a Government without rubbing the Greens face in it with those appointments. But she wanted more than a majority on supply and confidence. She wanted deals on the Speaker and Select Committee Chairs.

So all this I had no choice sentiment from the PM, is simply spin. She chose to exclude the Greens from Government because she didn’t want to be associated with the Maori Party. Now I’m not saying that I disagree that it was the better choice to make, my point is though is that is was most definitely a choice.

Too stupid to drive

How did the media predictions go?

The NZ Herald, Dominion Post, and The Press all helpfully made predicitions on portfolios this morning. So how did each go?

NZ Herald

* police to Phil Goff – wrong went to King
* Mallard may be named the new Health Minister – wrong went to Hodgson
* Goff may also get an associate finance job – right
* Hodgson may get a role in education – wrong
* Maori Affairs Minister Parekura Horomia is nevertheless expected to keep his job – right
* Maharey may get the economic development job – wrong went to Mallard
* Parker is tipped for Attorney-General – right
* Remaining executive positions outside the Cabinet, expected to remain at seven – wrong went to eight
* Rotorua MP Steve Chadwick is expected to win a spot as a minister outside the Cabinet – wrong
* as is list MP Winnie Laban – right
* Mahara Okeroa is considered another likely winner – right
* Associate Transport Minister Harry Duynhoven is likely to keep his job – right
* Labour chief whip Jill Pettis could be another contender – wrong
* Mita Ririnui is unlikely to be returned to the Executive – wrong
* Dover Samuels’ position is uncertain – wrong – retained

Of 15 NZ Herald predictions, nine were wrong and six correct.

Dominion Post

* Dover Samuels not expected to retain his position as a minister outside the Cabinet – wrong
* tipped to be replaced in the police portfolio by former foreign minister Phil Goff – wrong
* Goff is also tipped for an associate finance role

Winston wrong already

Winston has claimed that the increase in superannuation from 65% to 66% of the average wage (for a married couple) will mean $18 a week extra or $939 a year extra.

However this is obviously wrong as that suggests the average wage is $93,900.

A married couple (both retired) get $470.32 a week. If this is 65% of the average wage then 66% will be $477.56 or $7.24 a week extra ($377 a year extra).

So this calculation by Winston is about as credible as his contention that he is not a member of the Government despite being its Foreign Minister. Perhaps he is like the Minister of Magic in Harry Potter and us muggles are just too dumb to work it out.

Full Ministerial List

The Beehive site has the full ministerial list (pdf) and a PR with the changes.

Once again Clark has broken her own record for the largest ever Executive. I am surprised again that she has kept non performers such as Samuels and Tizard on at the expense of Barnett and Chadwick.

Other changes, not commented on in previous posts are:

* Ruth Dyson becomes Minister of Labour

Not good for employers.

* David Cunliffe becomes Minister of Immigration, continues as Minister of Communications and of Information Technology, and will be an Associate Minister for Economic Development.

Pleased Cunliffe retains Comms and IT. The Ass Econ Dev will sensibly tie into it also.

* David Parker will be Minister of Energy, Minister of Transport, Attorney General, and Minister Responsible for Climate Change Issues.

That’s an impressive range for a new Minister.

* Nanaia Mahuta will be Minister of Customs, Minister of Youth Affairs, and Associate Minister for the Environment and Local Government.

This is barely a job. This is payoff for getting the Seabed & Foreshore legislation passed.

* Clayton Cosgrove will be Minister for Building Issues and Statistics, and Associate Minister of Finance, Immigration, and Justice.

Main portfolios are not much but some useful associates.

* Judith Tizard continues her existing responsibilities as Minister of Consumer Affairs and as an associate across a range of portfolios, as well as becoming Minister Responsible for Archives New Zealand and for the National Library.

Wow, she may have to turn up in the mornings now.

Overall though some pretty good moves by Clark. I suspect the Maharey appointment may come to be the one she most regrets. However it may be deliberately a challenge – if he manages to restore confidence in the qualifications system, then he gets to replace Helen as leader when she retires.

Oh yes in other news, Jill Pettis has also announced she is standing down as Chief Whip. Either Darren Hughes will get promoted from Junior Whip or maybe go to one of those who missed out like Barnett?

Portfolios Announced

According to Scoop, the press conference announcing portfolios has begun.

So far we have:

Steve Maharey new Minister Of Education

Oh my God. The man who did more to destroy tertiary education quality than any other Minister now gets the rest of the education sector to play with.

Michael Cullen new Minster of Tertiary Education

Much more sensible. Cullen may be the only one who can sort out the total mess left by Maharey.

Pete Hodgson new Minister of Health

Also sensible. He has the background generally and it is not a flashpoint.

David Benson-Pope new Minister of Social Development

Not sure how that will go. He may be okay – a challenge for him.

Also Newstalk ZB reports:

Annette King picks up police

Anyone is an improvement on George

Mark Burton is the new Minister of Justice.

Hmmn – could be a weak area for them.

Phil Goff, gets Defence and Overseas Trade Negotiations.

Not a big change.

Jim Anderton loses Economic Development but picks up Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries.

Anderton already did a lot in Forestry so that is sensible. Not sure how he will go down with farmers though.

Clarke out

The UK Tories have just had the first ballot for their next leader and the results were:

David Davis 62
David Cameron 56
Liam Fox 42
Ken Clarke 38 (and eliminated)

The big winner is David Cameron. He got 16 more votes than the 40 pledged him to him, while Davis got 5 less than he had publicly pledged.

And as Clarke, not Fox fell out, this means Cameron is basically guaranteed to make the final two members vote as he will I estimate get 30 of Clarke’s vote which will put him to over 80.

It is possible Davis may not even make final two. Fox is going to aggressively target Davis and if he gets ten defections, he will go into the final round.

It’s hard to sum up for people back home how much publicity there has been about David Cameron. For the last week every newspaper (I love having eight papers a day to read) has been doing major stories on Cameron refusing to confirm or deny that he may have used drugs while at university. Far from damaging him, he has gained huge public support for refusing to say, including from many media. And even the fact everyone assumes he did of course once take drugs, this actually makes him seem more normal to younger voters.

Then it came out that he had a close relative who had a heroin addiction and he had been helping him through that – making him look Mr down to earth. This then got complemented by two page profiles on him in all the papers. None of the other candidates have been quoted on anything other than whether they think Cameron should answer the question or not.

The final turn was when a photo got published of his campaign manager George Osborne, the shadow Chancellor, with a woman now known as “Miss Pain” who is a dominatrix claiming they once did cocaine together. The photo though is from when he was 22, and she was dating a friend of hers so doesn’t prove anything. Was a bizarre aspect to the whole thing.

Anyway the drugs issue has died down and the next vote is on Thursday, After that it goes out to 300,000 members to vote.

Someone is pleased

Coalition Winners and Losers

Okay we previously had the election winners and losers. Now it’s time to look at who are the winners and losers from the coalition negotiations.

Major Winners

Helen Clark. Clark has basically six parties voting with her, which gives her a decent majority. More importantly she has locked in enough votes to make sure she has a tame speaker. Do not under-estimate how important it was for Clark to have a Speaker who will protect weak Ministers. She also has enough votes to go into urgency on whim, and to lock the opposition out of any significant select committee chairs. Clark has also escaped with only NZ First extracting specific commitments and have fobbed most of the others off with reviews.

Winston Peters. Peters gets all the perks and powers of office, yet escapes all the responsibilities. He doesn’t have to attend meetings, he can attack the Government whenever he wants and he doesn’t even have to support them in critical areas tied to his portfolio like trade and immigration. Plus Peters has got enough policy concessions he can campaign next time on having delivered to the voters he will target.

Minor Winners

Jim Anderton. Anderton is back in Cabinet despite bringing no extra votes to the table. And it sounds like he will get a more significant portfolio.

Don Brash. Don doesn’t have to try and explain away a National-ACT-United Future-NZ First-Maori Party agreement to his party, the press gallery and the public. Shudder.

Rodney Hide as he just sat back and enjoyed the games.

Minor Losers

Tariana Turia. She may have overplayed her hand with considering National, and may find it hard to make progress on any issues.

Peter Dunne. Despite becoming a Minister, things are not rosy for United Future. They got almost nothing in policy terms, and two terms of propping up Labour Governments could finish them.

Major Losers

Rod & Jeanette. They got the photo op, but got shafted on everything else. Their policy wins are ridiculously light. Not a single thing that Labour wouldn’t probably do anyway. But they have nowhere to go but announce they want people to buy local goods, while Winston represents NZ to the world.

Is Transmission Gully back on?

The Dominion Post repeats Peter Dunne’s claim that Transmission Gully is back on the agenda. I’m not so sure.

Dunne deserves praise for kepping the profile of the issue alive, but I’m not sure what the Government has agreed to is anything more than a restatement of their current policy which is that in theory the local body leaders can decide what to spend the northern access money on.

However the reality remains that the amount of funding has not shifted, and only one option is affordable due to this, and it isn’t Transmission Gully.

Personally I think the local bodies should call the bluff of the Government, pick Transmission Gully and then force the Government to pay for it later by threatening to blame $500 rate increases on them if they don’t!

Ihug Broadband

Good to see Ihug (my ISP) coming out with some cheaper prices for broadband at 2 Mb/sec in anticipation of a final Commerce Commission determination.

They are offering is for under half Telecom’s price at $30/month. However not for high volume users as it will have only 500 MB/mth limit which is very small. However for $10 more you get 4 GB/mth which is better. Personally I want an ISP which will give me a price for no volume limit at all – true flat rate.

But well done Ihug on taking this step.

Christian Heritage Director finally quits

Reaction to Government formation

My God there is so much of it.

The Dominion Post editorial reminds us of how in 2002 Clark said New Zealand diplomats would be working to distance the Government from Mr Peters’ “very damaging” views on immigration, especially from Asia yet now has placed Peters in charge of our foreign policy.

Personally I look forward to Peters as Foreign Minister telling us what he will do to support a free trade agreement with China.

The Press calls this a Government born, not out of principle or philosophy but from the politics of desperation. They further describe Peters as Foreign Minister as “a political travesty” decrying that one of the most important Minsiterials jobs has been demoted to being out of Cabinet and gone to “a man who has been prone to rabble-rousing and indulging in populist xenophobic politics.”

The Press also calls this a de facto coalition agreement and condemns the spin of words over substance.

The NZ Herald reports that Clark and Peters are contradicting each other on who suggested Foreign Affairs for him. Peters also repeats his bizarre claim that “the ministerial posts did not mean he was part of the new Government’s executive”. Hello he is a member of the Executive Council!

The Greens label the new Government policies as socially, economically and environmentally destructive.

Vernon Small writes that we may have the bizarre sight of “a foreign minister continuing his attacks on immigration, refugees and a free trade agreement with China, all of which are seen as a cornerstones of foreign affairs”.

UPDATE: And the NZ papers are polite compared to the Aussies. The Australian labels Peters as a “bad joke foreign minister” while the SMH says Peters is “known for his anti-immigration views and protectionist policies”.

New Cabinet

Labour have elected a Cabinet and it has increased from 18 to 21. It will shrink to 20 with Sutton retiring at year end.

So Ministers out are Hobbs, Swain, Hawkins and Sutton (at year end) plus Turia had not been replaced, and neither had Tamihere.

The six new Cabinet Ministers are:

Clayton Cosgrove
Hon David Cunliffe
Lianne Dalziel
Nanaia Mahuta
Hon Damien O’Connor
David Parker

All six are reasonably capable, and will add some vitality to the Cabinet. I am surprised that Tim Barnett is not there as he has been one of the most successful backbenchers in recent times.

Now the interesting thing is how big will the Executive get? A Cabinet of 20 plus Winston and Dunne outside is already 22.

Now if no Ministers outside are sacked you need to reappoint Tizard, Samuels, Duynhoven, Field, Ririnui and maybe Okeroa. Possible also roles for CHadwick and Barnett. Now that could get the executive up to a record 30.

Winner Winston

In one thread Chris Bishop made the point that

Peters won, big time. What Clark has basically done is legitimise what Winston did in 1991 and 1992 and then again in 1997 and 1998 – which is be part of Cabinet/the government but claim the authority to criticise them whenever he wanted to keep himself in the limelight. This led Bolger to sack him in 1992 and eventually led to the break upof the Nat/NZF Coalition in 1998.

Clark has now said Winston can be in government, swan off around the world, but feel free to criticise the government any time he likes, as he’s not bound by the confines of Cabinet Collective Responsibility. This is incredible. Perfect for Winston – every thing he wants. He can now campaign right up until the 2008 election as a Minister but also criticising the government.

And already we are seeing this. It seems that on Campbell Live tonight (according to a comment in this thread) Winston claimed that being Foreign Minister is not being part of the Government!!!

What did they get?

The deals are online. Peters has got quite a lot if we look at the NZ First deal.

* Ensure that the rate of New Zealand Superannuation is set at 66 per cent of the average ordinary time weekly earnings as from 1 April 2006.

* Budget for police numbers to be increased to provide another 1000 police staff over the three budgets of this term with a view to achieving ratios comparable with those in Australia by 2010.

* Continue the practice of annually increasing the minimum wage, with a view to it being set at $12.00 per hour by the end of 2008 if economic conditions permit.

* Support the re-introduction of the Electoral Integrity Act.
Support a New Zealand First bill relating to treaty principles going to a select committee for consideration.

* Support, to a select committee for consideration, a New Zealand First Members bill proposing to lower the age of criminal responsibility to 12 years, and agree that if it has not been successful in the ballot within two years a clause may be incorporated into a government bill in order that the issue can be addressed by a select committee.

There are dozens of others listed but they are all meaningless reviews.

So Peters can claim he got a superannuation increase (less than what they would have got with National’s tax cuts though) and 1,000 extra police. A semi-commitment to a minimum wage level of $12 and surprisingly bringing back that hideous piece of legislation known as the Electoral Integrity Act.

In return Labour have got NZ First to agree to vote for urgency motions and Speaker, and have done a deal on select committee chairs.

The Progressive Party gets nothing at all except a seat for Jim in Cabinet. That is their only requirement. Hilarious.

United Future seem to have not a single specific except stuff which wasn’t going to happen anyway like cannabis reform or hate speech legislation. Oh wait they have got an agreement to reduce the age of parental means testing for student allowances. That is good.

The Greens have very little. They agree with NZ First on minimum wage. Some meaningless mumble on GE,

In return the Greens agree to be poodles on procedural motions etc.

NZ First have clearly got the most out of this – they have got actual specifics they will be able to campaign on. The other parties have little because most of what they have is stuff people will assume the Government would have done anyway.

Finally we have a Government

The speculation was right. NZ First and United Future are in, and the Greens are out. Winston Peters now represents NZ to the world.

Clark seems to be creating a number of new constitutional conventions. The article states:

Both positions will be outside of Cabinet allowing them to disagree with the Government on issues outside of their portfolio areas.

This is in contradiction to the cabinet manual which makes it clear there is no difference in collective responsibility if Ministers are outside Cabinet.

Secondly an entirely new position of spokesperson for the Government has been created and given to the Greens. This seems to be the equivalent of Peters and Dunne getting to eat the roast ham at the top table while Jeanette and Rod get the jelly-meat so they don’t starve.

Thirdly it looks like it is being claimed that it is only a Labour-Progressive Government. The convention has been that any parties represented in the Executive as Ministers are recognised as part of the Government.

Fourthly (and this one isn’t something Clark is asserting) the article claims National and ACT will be the official opposition. Not so. The Greens and the Maori Party will be also, as they do not hold ministerial roles.