Reaction to Government formation

My God there is so much of it.

The Dominion Post editorial reminds us of how in 2002 Clark said New Zealand diplomats would be working to distance the Government from Mr Peters’ “very damaging” views on immigration, especially from Asia yet now has placed Peters in charge of our foreign policy.

Personally I look forward to Peters as Foreign Minister telling us what he will do to support a free trade agreement with China.

The Press calls this a Government born, not out of principle or philosophy but from the politics of desperation. They further describe Peters as Foreign Minister as “a political travesty” decrying that one of the most important Minsiterials jobs has been demoted to being out of Cabinet and gone to “a man who has been prone to rabble-rousing and indulging in populist xenophobic politics.”

The Press also calls this a de facto coalition agreement and condemns the spin of words over substance.

The NZ Herald reports that Clark and Peters are contradicting each other on who suggested Foreign Affairs for him. Peters also repeats his bizarre claim that “the ministerial posts did not mean he was part of the new Government’s executive”. Hello he is a member of the Executive Council!

The Greens label the new Government policies as socially, economically and environmentally destructive.

Vernon Small writes that we may have the bizarre sight of “a foreign minister continuing his attacks on immigration, refugees and a free trade agreement with China, all of which are seen as a cornerstones of foreign affairs”.

UPDATE: And the NZ papers are polite compared to the Aussies. The Australian labels Peters as a “bad joke foreign minister” while the SMH says Peters is “known for his anti-immigration views and protectionist policies”.

New Cabinet

Labour have elected a Cabinet and it has increased from 18 to 21. It will shrink to 20 with Sutton retiring at year end.

So Ministers out are Hobbs, Swain, Hawkins and Sutton (at year end) plus Turia had not been replaced, and neither had Tamihere.

The six new Cabinet Ministers are:

Clayton Cosgrove
Hon David Cunliffe
Lianne Dalziel
Nanaia Mahuta
Hon Damien O’Connor
David Parker

All six are reasonably capable, and will add some vitality to the Cabinet. I am surprised that Tim Barnett is not there as he has been one of the most successful backbenchers in recent times.

Now the interesting thing is how big will the Executive get? A Cabinet of 20 plus Winston and Dunne outside is already 22.

Now if no Ministers outside are sacked you need to reappoint Tizard, Samuels, Duynhoven, Field, Ririnui and maybe Okeroa. Possible also roles for CHadwick and Barnett. Now that could get the executive up to a record 30.

Winner Winston

In one thread Chris Bishop made the point that

Peters won, big time. What Clark has basically done is legitimise what Winston did in 1991 and 1992 and then again in 1997 and 1998 – which is be part of Cabinet/the government but claim the authority to criticise them whenever he wanted to keep himself in the limelight. This led Bolger to sack him in 1992 and eventually led to the break upof the Nat/NZF Coalition in 1998.

Clark has now said Winston can be in government, swan off around the world, but feel free to criticise the government any time he likes, as he’s not bound by the confines of Cabinet Collective Responsibility. This is incredible. Perfect for Winston – every thing he wants. He can now campaign right up until the 2008 election as a Minister but also criticising the government.

And already we are seeing this. It seems that on Campbell Live tonight (according to a comment in this thread) Winston claimed that being Foreign Minister is not being part of the Government!!!

What did they get?

The deals are online. Peters has got quite a lot if we look at the NZ First deal.

* Ensure that the rate of New Zealand Superannuation is set at 66 per cent of the average ordinary time weekly earnings as from 1 April 2006.

* Budget for police numbers to be increased to provide another 1000 police staff over the three budgets of this term with a view to achieving ratios comparable with those in Australia by 2010.

* Continue the practice of annually increasing the minimum wage, with a view to it being set at $12.00 per hour by the end of 2008 if economic conditions permit.

* Support the re-introduction of the Electoral Integrity Act.
Support a New Zealand First bill relating to treaty principles going to a select committee for consideration.

* Support, to a select committee for consideration, a New Zealand First Members bill proposing to lower the age of criminal responsibility to 12 years, and agree that if it has not been successful in the ballot within two years a clause may be incorporated into a government bill in order that the issue can be addressed by a select committee.

There are dozens of others listed but they are all meaningless reviews.

So Peters can claim he got a superannuation increase (less than what they would have got with National’s tax cuts though) and 1,000 extra police. A semi-commitment to a minimum wage level of $12 and surprisingly bringing back that hideous piece of legislation known as the Electoral Integrity Act.

In return Labour have got NZ First to agree to vote for urgency motions and Speaker, and have done a deal on select committee chairs.

The Progressive Party gets nothing at all except a seat for Jim in Cabinet. That is their only requirement. Hilarious.

United Future seem to have not a single specific except stuff which wasn’t going to happen anyway like cannabis reform or hate speech legislation. Oh wait they have got an agreement to reduce the age of parental means testing for student allowances. That is good.

The Greens have very little. They agree with NZ First on minimum wage. Some meaningless mumble on GE,

In return the Greens agree to be poodles on procedural motions etc.

NZ First have clearly got the most out of this – they have got actual specifics they will be able to campaign on. The other parties have little because most of what they have is stuff people will assume the Government would have done anyway.

Finally we have a Government

The speculation was right. NZ First and United Future are in, and the Greens are out. Winston Peters now represents NZ to the world.

Clark seems to be creating a number of new constitutional conventions. The article states:

Both positions will be outside of Cabinet allowing them to disagree with the Government on issues outside of their portfolio areas.

This is in contradiction to the cabinet manual which makes it clear there is no difference in collective responsibility if Ministers are outside Cabinet.

Secondly an entirely new position of spokesperson for the Government has been created and given to the Greens. This seems to be the equivalent of Peters and Dunne getting to eat the roast ham at the top table while Jeanette and Rod get the jelly-meat so they don’t starve.

Thirdly it looks like it is being claimed that it is only a Labour-Progressive Government. The convention has been that any parties represented in the Executive as Ministers are recognised as part of the Government.

Fourthly (and this one isn’t something Clark is asserting) the article claims National and ACT will be the official opposition. Not so. The Greens and the Maori Party will be also, as they do not hold ministerial roles.

Plagiarism?

Salient’s Top Five

How do you know that a deal’s been done?

Tom Scott hits the mark

Union membership up

The NZ Herald reports how union membership is up 17% in the last five years.

Various union people are quoting that it is because they are better organised, doing good things etc.

It couldn’t possibly be at all related to the fact it is now illegal to not join a union if you have a collective contract?

Or the fact that the taxpayer bribes civil servants with thousand dollar bonuses to join a union?

Dissension in the ranks

The NZ Herald is reporting that NZ First President Doug Woolerton has resigned in protest at Peters breaking their election promise and accepting Foreign Minister in a Labour led Government.

Now this is huge if true. Doug Wollerton has been known as the most loyal Winston person there is. This is not like Tau Henare disagreeing – this is Winston’s longest serving most loyal organisational person.

The Dominion Post also reports that it is looking more likely Dunne will also accept a Ministerial role.

So a Labour-Progressive-NZ First-United Future coalition Government will have 61 votes. They will also have the Greens on confidence and supply for 67 votes.

One almost has to feel sorry for the Greens. By not being in Government, they may struggle to show relevance at the next election. Any policy gains they claim will be minuscule compared to what NZ First seem to have wrenched out of Labour.

If this gets confirmed in the next few days I look forward to all the Labour blogs celebrating Winston as a Minister again.

What is National doing?

I’m well out of the loop being overseas, so I’m guessing as much as anyone what National’s game plan is. There are two major possibilities:

1) It is continuing to talk to the minor parties to ratchet the pressure up on Labour, so that they are forced to do deals which undermine their credibility

2) It really wants to form a Government supported by ACT, United Future, NZ First and the Maori Party.

Now if (1) is the case then National is doing a brillant job. Forcing Clark to kill Cullen’s credibility by increasing the superannuation level and making Winston a Minister instead of the Greens will be poison. Not sure if this is what will happen, but that is the latest speculation.

If (2) is the case, well I’m somewhat nervous and sceptical about the desirability. Don’t get me wrong it would be wonderful to throw Labour and Clark out of office. Really really wonderful.

But I suspect that such an arrangement would be electorally hazardous. No matter how much can make an intellectual justification of an issue, I doubt the average voter who decided to support National due to the Orewa speech, thought an arrangement with the Maori Party was what they were voting for.

According to this SST article the two big issues for the Maori Party are not abolishing the Maori seats, and repealing the foreshore & seabed legislation. Now the simple fact of the matter is that there is nowhere near a majority in Parliament to abolish the Maori seats. So agreeing not to do so, is simply recognising reality. And National voted against the F&S legislation so voting to abolish it isn’t radical. The harder issue is what, if anything, do you replace it with?

But again I don’t think it is whether you can intellectually justify the policies. It is what he public perception will be.

Whether National is serious about (2) I don’t know. According to the SST it is all on, but the Herald on Sunday pooh poohs the idea and quotes Clark as saying it is a spoiling tactic.

As I said at the beginning, for scenario (1) it is working brillantly. It is great to see Clark’s job made harder. The fact that we have entered week five without an agreement shows how hard it is. If scenario (2) is being seriously pursued, I just hope due caution is being shown. Sometimes you have to lose to win!

A good bus trip

The bus back from Oxford to London yesterday was a very nice one which actually has a few tables and power supplies. So I thought I’d fill up the time by watching the latest episodes of Desperate Housewives from the US.

I’m watching it on the laptop, but with the sound turned down low so as not to disturb other passengers. However as conversation below shows, it did:
Continue reading »

Now that was a party!

Slowly recovering from the Oktoberfest party which I went to last night at Clint’s invitation. A long time since I’ve been to an all you can eat and drink night.

I got many photos, most of which will never be published of table dancing, bench surfing etc etc.

Was good to catch up with not just Clint (former President of Prebble’s Rebels, but also his ex-flatmate Gav and Matt McInnnes who stood for ACT in Invercargill).

Party finished sometime after midnight and while I did mange to find a tube station and catch the right tube, I sort of, umm, fell asleep on the tube and woke up past my station. Whoops. Never mind eventually got home to West Hampton.

UPDATE: Some photos below and after the break

bv7.JPG

Two of the charming waitresses. They even joined in the dancing!
Continue reading »

Is it a coalition if Ministers are outside Cabinet?

It is getting fascinating that it seems like NZ First is keeping open the possibility of a Brash-led Government. It still regard it as highly unlikely.

Anyway NZ First in soem media appear to be suggesting that if they accept appointemts outside Cabinet, this would somehow mean they are not in coalition. Bzzzt. Wrong.

Section 2.19 of the Cabinet Manual says “Ministers outside Cabinet have full legal powers as Ministers, and may be appointed to full portfolios. They have the same overall role, duties and responsibilities as Ministers inside Cabinet, and are bound by the doctrine of collective responsibility

And 3.21 says “Acceptance of ministerial office requires acceptance of collective responsibility.”

So it will be interesting to see if Labour and NZ First try to portray it as not being a coalition.

Presents

Interesting survey published in the NZ Herald about whay boys and girls want for Christmas. The top ten list for girls is:

1. Cellphone
2. iPod
3. Money
4. Clothes
5. Dog
6. Car
7. Laptop
8. Horse
9. MP3 player
10. Book

Now Miss Ten already has a cellphone, ipod, money, clothes (unlimited amount), a car (sort of), laptop, MP3 player and lots of books.

So I guess this means for Christmas I should get her a dog or a horse!

Another Kiwi champion!

Jordan on the labour market

Jordan proposes a number of changes to employment law, and actually labels them as adding flexibility. Sadly they do not but seem to be a mirror of French and German policies which have seen unemployment shoot up to 10%.

Taking them in turn:

* the right to agree flexible working hours, consistent with the needs of the business.

Umm Jordan, this right already exists and it happens every single day. You don’t need to change the law to do this – you need employers and employees to agree – that’s all.

* more annual leave (the hedonistic Germans get six weeks, plus public holidays!)

Barely is the ink set on the increase to four weeks, and already a clamour for more. Is there a limit to how many weeks employers should pay people noy to actually work? At present it can strecth to two months out of every twelve with annual leave, public holidays and sick leave.

Big employers can handle extra annual leave requirements with some ease as they have so many staff. But let me tell you in a small business, it is bloody difficult and this would help cripple some small businesses.

* the right to sabbatical leave or leave without pay, say after two years in an organisation, to allow people to do the big OE or whatever but have a job to come back to (hard in small orgs but easy in big ones)

Again there is no need for Governmet here. Many organisations give staff leave without pay for extended breaks. Sometimes though they refuse because it will be too damaging for that organisation. By legislating you mandate a one size fit all approach.

* Statutory requirements for overtime pay on hours over a limit (44?) each week, and a bias towards shortening the working week for those who want this.

Yeah that has worked so well in France and Germany.

* Stronger requirements for management to consult with workers, and include them in business planning and decision-making.

Even better let’s just nationalise all businesses and hand them over to the workers.

What amazes me is how Jordan prescribes the most interventionist labour market regime possible, and calls it adding flexibility. Only in 1984.

M&F on Negotiations

Molesworth & Featherston is predicting that Clark is going to stitch up a deal with both United Future and NZ First so she can govern without even having to rely on the Greens.

We expect a Government to be formed over the weekend, and certainly not later than Tuesday, which will see Mr Peters and Mr Dunne in ministerial roles, the Greens as close to no confidence as they can get without breaking their commitment not to bring down a Labour-led Government and a tax-cutting policy plan in place that will humiliate Michael Cullen to the point where you wonder why he would bother to stick around.

Having seen the boos and hisses that United Future and NZ First get from Labour activists at public meetings, it will be fascinating to see how the party reacts of this prediction is accurate.

.parliament.nz recommended for approval

Winston on 7 September

An alert reader has sent me this extract from Winston Peters’ speech in Rotorua on 7 September 2005:

I am announcing today that New Zealand First will not be going into a formal coalition with either Labour or National.

Just to be sure there is no misunderstanding of what I am saying let me be clear

Happy 80th Birthday Mrs Thatcher

Today in the UK it is Margaret Thatcher‘s 80th birthday.

Growing up in the 80s, it is hard to over-emphasise how inspiring Thatcher and Reagan were. Not just for what they achieved in their own countries, but especially their role in standing up to the evil which was the Soviet Union. At the time this was deeply unpopular with many calling for unilateral disarmament of the west – a policy which would have been a disaster if implemented.

In France earlier this year I noted how nice it was that some streets were named after Winston Churchill. I am informed this is common throughout Western Europe.

Likewise I am also informed that streets and places named after Thatcher are proudly displayed all over Eastern Europe. A very fitting tribute to a woman who helped gain them freedom. Kuwait remember her fondly also.

The Telegraph has a lovely article on her, with quotes from many people.

Sigh!

A different sort of protection order

Often in cases a Judge rules that the defendent can get bail but must stay at least 100 metres away from the victim etc etc.

I’m sorry, but I did have to laugh at this (NZ born) person whose bail conditions include not going within 50 metres of any pet shop, or entering any rural lands!!

Hat Tip: Cathy Odgers

Minister Winston again

The coalition negotiations get more amusing by the day. The latest story is that Winston will get to be a Minister after all!

How pissed off would you be if you are a left wing voter and Winston is a Minister but the Greens are not?

And Winston’s credibility is starting to look flaky again. Let’s look at all the contradictions.

1) Would abstain. Then became will vote for cofidence and supply.

2) Would not play parties off against each other. However has seemingly asked National to match Labour’s offer.

3) Said would not support Government with the Greens (or ACT) in it. Now won’t commit to that.

4) Said there had been no discussion of being a Minister. Now it appears he is set to be one.

If Winston is a Minister it means all his question time in the House has to be patsy’s and he has to defend the Government. Oh yay.