Nice detective work
The Greens have discovered that the anti-Green pamphlet put out by the Exclsuive Brethren is basically a copy of one done in Australia.
Frog has revealed he is an avid Sunday News reader (probably reads Truth also) and has blogged a summary of their celebrity endorsements.
Labour has the vote of the lovely Jo Cotton. Didn’t stop her singing at the National Party conference though!
The Greens get Deborah Manning’s support. No doubt Ahmed Zaoui’s also!
But ACT have the most interesting supporter – porn king Steve Crow. Now is he just a supporter or does he also donate to the party? And if so, is it cash or goods and services? š
The Greens have discovered that the anti-Green pamphlet put out by the Exclsuive Brethren is basically a copy of one done in Australia.
Many predicted that even after last week’s press conference, NZ First’s position would not be clear, and it is so.
I, like many, took what Peters said to mean he would vote to allow the largest party in Parliament to form a Government.
But some of his MPs are saying they are simply going to abstain on every vote of supply and confidence, which means it will be the largest bloc, not the largest party that benefits.
John Armstring calls on Peters to clarify their position. There is significant difference between the two policies, and they may affect the outcome.
Personally I think everyone should hope they get under 5% and wiped out. Fighting Talk has 12 very good reasons not to vote for NZ First.
The ODT has a story about how 18 obscene messages threatening violence and rape againat Katherine Rich were made last Thursday.
Words almost fail me. Appalled doesn’t even come close.
This should be very easy for the Police to trace, unless done from a public call box. I hope they make arrests very quickly.
The two guys who did this are scum. No nitch that – they even give scum a bad name.
The SST is speculating that if National wins that former Labour MPs Graham Kelly and Jonathan Hunt may be recalled from their posts in Ottawa and London respectively, and replaced with former or current National MPs.
Certainly if National win, I expect Hunt will be home by lunchtime!
However the SST has missed another political appointment. Sandra Lee in Niue. And I could think of no-one better to replace her than Jim Bolger š
The SST has an article on the background of National’s and Labour’s candidates.
36 of the 65 National candidates have a background in business compared to 5 out of 82 for Labour.
National also has 11 lawyers. Not sure if this is a plus or minus š
Labour has 28 teachers or academics and 17 unionists.
Heh – got sent this in the e-mail:
Talking of Pete Hodgson, below is a copy of a letter to the ODT editor that I have been sent. Not sure if ODT printed it:
Sir,
I have always admired Pete Hodgson as an excellent MP and an honest, straight up and down, sort of a person. Until now that is!
I read with growing astonishment the front page story (ODT, Wednesday, September 7, 2005) regarding his manhandling of a woman protestor on the University of Otago campus yesterday.
I was there. His account of the incident is disingenuous at best. The facts, from this witness, are these:
After the pep rally for Helen Clark staged by OUSA (in breach of every fire and OSH regulation ever thought of) the Prime Minister left the building and was surrounded by a rugby scrum of reporters, camera people and Labour supporters – at least three deep all around. On the outskirts of this melee a handful of protestors held up signs with pointed slogans such as “Speed Kills.” Labour supporters, who I can only describe as thugs, roughly tore these from the hands of the women (but were gutless when it came to the male protestors).
One typical bully whom I confronted when I witnessed this behaviour loudly proclaimed that, as a Labour supporter, he was opposed to free speech. He then claimed, “At least I’m honest about it.” As though that exonerated him from guilt. He approached me in an aggressive manner and attempted to intimidate me but, when I stood my ground he, like all bullies, backed down.
Back to the press melee surrounding the PM. Mr Hodgson claims that the assualt was protecting Helen Clark from… something as Mrs Flannagan was too close. False, no one could get close because of the media scrum. She was on the outskirts of a crowd and at least three metres and eight to ten people, away from the Prime Minister. She was holding up a sheet of paper (not a placard or a potential weapon but a sheet of painted paper) and trying to get into camera shot from the cameras photographing the Prime Minister.
Next, Mr Hodgson claims that his victim called out, “I’m not going to hit her.” This is absolutely false. The words I heard Mrs Flannagan cry out were, “I am being assaulted by a Cabinet Minister.”
Immediately after the incident She was shaken, upset and very angry.
I would suggest that this uncharacteristic behaviour on behalf of Pete Hodgson, and the subsequent clumsy and mendacious self justifications are proof positive that Labour is running scared in the election race and now no longer care what boundaries they cross or who gets hurt as they cling desperately to power.
Shame on them and shame on Pete Hodgson for sinking to such depths.
Yours faithfully
David Bisman
Belleknowes
Dunedin
National has launched Operation Police Rescue. Now personally I think all you need to do is sack George Hawkins and one will be 90% there, but some sensible extra ideas are pledged:
* Boost the police front line with a target of the Australian police-to-population levels. In 2002 these were 230 per 100,000
* Recruit experienced, retired staff to join the 111 communications centres
* ensure all traffic patrols are directed to respond to 111 emergencies.
* Abolish parole for all repeat and violent criminals so police are not continually chasing career criminals and locking them away.
* Scrap quota ticketing for traffic offences so traffic policing to focus on killer roads and killer drivers, not ticket quotas.
* Take DNA from everyone arrested.
* Cut form-filling demands. Recent reports show that on average an officer fills out 14 forms for each domestic lock-up.
* Lower the age of criminal responsibility to 12; move offenders to the Youth Court after two family group conferences; and establish parenting orders to support parents of persistent young offenders to learn skills to deal with their children.
The SST talks to the neighbours of the Brashes and the Clarks. Fluffy but interesting. It shows Je Lan to be the truly lovely person she is.
Only two things could make a better birthday present that the SST poll showing National with a 7% lead.
One involves Eva Longoria (from Desperate Housewives) and a tropical island resort.
The other is a poll confirming that Winston Peters will lose Tauranga.
The Herald on Sunday have come to the party for the latter, with a poll showing Bob Clarkson has extended his lead over Winston Peters from 8% to 11%!
Peters losing Tauranga is essential to good Government in NZ, whether National or Labour-led. You see even if NZ First make 5%, they will be missing the safety net of an electoral seat. And as Don Brash says, NZ First can be very unpredictable. But without Tauranga they will know that if they stuff up by playing stupid games (as they did in 1998) they will then be wiped out at the next election.
Now I just have to wait and see if my third birthday wish comes true š
Almost phoned up CYPFS to report some child abuse yesterday! Was in town and ran into one of Helen’s staff members. He was accompanied by around a dozen kids aged five to ten, all with red balloons. I then noticed they were Labour Party balloons as the kids all started chanting “Go Labour”. Those campaign activists are getting younger by the day I commented to him.
Said flunky’s response was they were in fact on their way to a birthday party and had just run into Labour OB candidate Charles Chauvel and spontaneously grabbed balloons and rosettes from him. I gave benefit of doubt and decided not to call CYPFS š
Patrick Crewdson in the HoS has made his picks as to who will win ten contested seats. In fact IMO there are around 20 seats which may be swapping hands, but I’ll leave it to others to speculate.
Crewdson picks are:
Aoraki: Labour hold
Epsom: National hold
Hamilton East: National win
Invercargill: National win
Northcote: National win
Tamaki Makaurau: Maori Party win
Tauranaga: National win
Te Tai Tokerau: Maori Party win
Waiariki: Maori Party win
Wellington Central: Labour hold
In a SST poll take mainly or totally after the Exclusive Brethren saga, National has actually increased its support to take a 7% lead over Labour.
As I commented on the Wellington Central poll, there is often a disconnect between issues that are important to the political activists, media and civil servants in Wellington and the rest of the country.
On this poll National are well placed to form a Government, and a relatively stable one being National/United Future with confidence and supply from NZ First. A Labour-led Government would need support from five or six parties.
It is a fascinating election to follow, and predict, as there are six key issues which may determine who is in Government, being:
* Will National or Labour gain more votes?
* Will NZ First make 5% and/or win Tauranga?
* Will the Greens make 5%?
* Will ACT wil Epsom?
* How many overhang seats, if any, will the Maori Party have?
* Will Jim Anderton’s seat of Wigram be an overhang seat?
So it is a brave person who predicts a Government at this stage.
But anyway as Miss Ten texted to me this morning, a very nice poll to wake up to for my birthday š
UPDATE: The Herald on Sunday also has a poll out showing Labour in the lead. The poll is not online (HOS for some reason never put their lead story online). SST has a sample of 540 and has Nats ahead by 7% and HoS has a sample of 400 and Labour ahead by 4%.
At some stage I think I may have to dig out and blog my 1998 memo to the PM and Ministers on why different polls can show such wildly different results.
No Right Turn has been collating and updating a list of public electorate polls. I’ll link through to it every so often. So far on the basis of the public polls, the following seats would change hands:
Aoraki – Labour’s Jim Sutton to lose to National’s Jo Goodhew
Invercargill – Labour’s Wayne Harpur to lose to National’s Eric Roy
Otago – Labour’s David Parker to lose to National’s Jacqui Dean
Te Tai Tokerau – Labour’s Dover Samuels to lose to Maori Party’s Hone Harawira
Hamilton East – Labour’s Di Yates to lose to National’s David Bennett
Hamilton West – Labour’s Martin Gallagher to National’s Tim Macindoe
Also NRT does not have these polls listed, but we have:
Tauranga – NZ First’s Winston Peters to lose to National’s Bob Clarkson
Tamaki Makarau – Labour’s John Tamihere to lose to Maori Party’s Pita Sharples
Waiariki – Labour’s Mita ririnui to lose to Maori Party’s Te Ururoa Flavell
Bill English is understandably upset that the Secretary of Education and Acting Head of NZQA have sent out a letter, just seven days before the election, to every parent reassuring them that there will be no repeat of the Scholarship mess of last year and that the system is designed to help all students achieve to the best of their ability.
During the six week period of an election campaign, there are strict protocols about communications from Government Departments. It is either the height of stupidity or a deliberate malicious act to send such a letter out in the final week of an election.
It doesn’t matter whether or not it is part of a pre-planned communications plan. The question is whether there was any compelling reason for the letter not to be sent after the election. Unless the answer is that there was, then the timing is grossly inappropriate.
A second Timaru Herald poll confirms that Jim Sutton looks likely to lose his seat despite a massive majority of around 6,500.
Having Trevor close down your local schools is never a popular move.
The NZ Herald has a good article on possible coalitions and what policy similarities there are, and what differences there are:
The option with the largest differences is (despite the spin) Labour and Greens, being:
Free-trade agreements
* Any commercial release of GM organisms into the environment
* Sending defence personnel to hotspots such as Afghanistan
* Barriers to foreign investment and land sales to foreigners
* Role of intelligence agencies and in the international intelligence-gathering network
* Cutting beneficiaries out of Working for Families payments
* Reforming cannabis law
* Joint regulatory agencies with Australia, such as food standards and therapeutic products
If there is a Labour/Green Government, then I expect it would end up like Labour/Alliance did – the minor party torn apart. And the reason for this is not that the MPs will not be pragmatic, but their supporters will not be and in fact can not be.
Green supporters, like Alliance ones, are passionate about foreign and defence issues especially. And they will find it intolerable to be part of a Government that has the SAS in Afghanistan working with the United States. They won’t care about the consequences of not working with the United States because they honestly think the United States is the most evil country in the world.
Remember this is the Green Party which a few days after September 11 led a march against the United States taking any retaliatory action at all. In their world the US would still be sending notes to the head of the Taliban asking them to co-operate or we will write a harshly worded press release.
And also no matter how much one has an agree to disagree policy, signing a free trade agreement with China would put huge pressure on any Government with the Greens in there.
Wellington City Council spokeswoman Trina Saffioti said there were a “million” activities prohibited under bylaws.
One day it will be quicker for Councils to list what activities are allowed, rather than the millions not allowed.
Radio NZ is held by the right in about the same esteem as CBS is held in the US. Shockingly biased. Not in a deliberate way, but in the sense that the worldview of almost all their management is somewhere squarely between the Greens and the Alliance.
We saw one sign this week when Sean Plunket was spoken to by management because he was too confrontational to Jeanette Fitzsimons. I would bet a large amount of money that if the interview had been with Don Brash, he’d be getting a round of congratulations from around the office.
Another is today’s revelations that Radio NZ management’s big idea to deal with issues of bias, is to to preface contributions from political commentator Jane Clifton with a disclaimer informing listeners her boyfriend is Murray McCully.
And staff like Plunket and Linda Clark who objected to this were censured by management for objecting. Mad mad mad.
I don’t recall them starting Chris Laidlaw’s show with a disclaimer every week that he is a former Labour MP. I don’t recall them starting Brian Edwards with a disclaimer he trains the PM and Ministers up on how to avoid answering questions. I don’t recall them stating the head of their election unit is a union activist every time he is on air.
This reminds me of the time the BBC put out an edict banning staff from mentioning that Labour Cabinet Minister Peter Mandelson was gay.
Note that my criticisms of Radio NZ are not criticism of individual staff. Their current press gallery head is very fair and professional for example. The criticism is at the management culture.
A good sign of an interesting individual is when their middle name is”Thankyoufornotbreeding” as it is for Robert Atack, standing for the Direct Democracy Party.
Mr Atack has just been fined $1,500 for vandalising a National billboard.
Mr Atack also had an interesting letter to the Dom Post published on Thursday. It reads:
I am holding you and The Dominion Post responsible for suppressing the truth and not informing people about peak oil and all its repercussions … when we at Direct Democracy are one of the only parties telling the truth.
You will pay for this in the future. I guarantee it.
And I will have the law and the people behind me when I come for your skin. I will be demanding my pound of flesh, and I will take any blood that comes with it.
You are damning [sic] your children to rot in hell. You are gutless trash.
I’m just disappointed Mr Atack is standing for the Direct Democracy, not the Green Party, with his fellow believers in peak oil š
The Silent Running blog has been down for a day and may be for a bit longer. They’ve had some unexpected technical difficulties.
The Dominion Post today shows Labour and Hobbs with a very significant lead of 16% in Wellington Central on the electorate vote and 19% on the party vote.
Obviously a disappointing result, but the campaign continues with an aim to maximise both the party and the electorate vote.
I wouldn’t take Wellington as a weathervane for the rest of NZ. Many public polls have shown that for example National has had a 10% lead in Auckland yet a 15% gap in Wellington. NZ is not a homogenous country. Nevertheless I doubt anyone is expecting this weekend’s polls to show National 8% ahead again š so the focus will be on how close it is, and what may happen in the last week.
TVNZ have released a One Colmar Brunton Poll. It shows it closer than it was before the campaign started, but still a very significant gap
Worth 44%
Hide 30%
Nash 20%
Incidentially the party vote shows how blue-ribbon the seat is with the party vote being:
National 63%
Labour 25%
ACT 4%
NZPA has a useful summary of the Leader’s Debate last night. I have to admit I didn’t want to watch it as I thought Brash would not have had time to get prepared for it, with the Brethren issue having blown up so large in the last two days.
However he did very well, both under the circumstances, and generally. NZPA sums it up as “National leader Don Brash, under siege over the Brethren pamphlet scandal, kept his cool and put in a confident performance on TV One’s leaders debate.”
Quite a few bloggers have commented the same. Will be interesting to see if it affects the polls much, esp some of the contributions from minor party leaders.
Heh just noticed on Rodney’s blog that during an interval when Helen complained to Mark Sainsbury that she hadn’t had a fair go, Rodney quipped that she should pop up to the cockpit to complain š
I wondered whether the idiot who threw the pie at Marian, was seeking her out, or was going to get whichever candidate came out first.
According to a local, there was a note in the pie making it clear it was aimed at Marian. I don’t know how reliable the witness is as it seems somewhat beyond coincidence she just happened to be there to film it and also just happened to look through the pie and find the note. It will be interesting if TVNZ show the footage.