Comms/IT Policies

Clark at Canterbury University

It seems not all students are seduced by Labour’s bribes. I was amazed watching the news how many students at Canterbury were booing the PM. It was way more than the dozen ACT or Young Nats who were there, but hundreds of people in the crowd from reports I got from people there.

The PM, unable to handle the crowd, stopped speaking and refused questions, despite having a public address system.
An Act supporter, Stanley Climbfall has blogged a bit about what happened plus heaps of photos. I like the student in the pilots uniform.

Scoop makes its predictions

Sccop has made its predictions for electorate contests.

The summary is:

Northcote: National gain
Epsom: National hold (I think – hard to tell from what they say)
Hamilton East: National gain
Hamilton West: National gain
Tauranga: Courts to decide
Napier: Too close to call
East Coast: National gain
Whanganui: National gain
Wairarapa: National gain
Wellington Central: Labour hold
Aoraki: National gain
Kaikoura: National hold
Otago: National gain
Invercargill: National gain
Te Tai Tokerau: Maori Party gain
Tamaki Makaurau: Maori Party gain
Tainui: Labour hold
Waiariki: Maori Party gain
Te Tai Hauauru: Maori Party hold
Ikaroa Rawhiti: Labour hold
Te Tai Tokerau: Labour hold

So overall Scoop are predicting Labour will lose 13, maybe 14 electorate seats.

Spam Legislation

Nice to see a large e-marketer supporting the anti-spam legislation. Well done AIM Proximity.

One of the victims of spam are legitimate e-marketers as anti-spam technology often blocks their e-mails also, even though people have opted into them.

Also interesting to read that the proportion of Air NZ tickets booked online has increased from 4% to 70%.

Caption Contest

I only discovered today that last Friday David Slack launched a haiku caption contest for the photo of myself enjoying some hospitality in Florida, and Mark locally.

It’s a pity as I would have loved to submit some entries myself. Anyway there were no shortage of them, which Mr Slack has blogged here. Most are funny, a couple as usual are just downright nasty but used to that. Andrew Llewellyn managed an impressive ten entries.

National Radio Politics

Just been listening to what will probably be the final pre-election politics segment with Linda Clark, Matthew Hooton and Peter Harris.

Started off discussing why Peters is doing this smear campaign. Debating whether he is desperate to be the MP for Tauranga or whether his party is risking being under 5% and oblivion.

Hooton and Clark predict he will make 5%, so are puzzled why he is going so dirty. Consensus is it is in his genes.

Comparing approach of Dunne and Peters. Difference is Dunne will genuinely try and make it work. Peters has left wriggle room which he may use to bring down a Government.

Hooton says voters in Epsom should ask why Helen Clark is endorsing the National candidate. Spirited discussion on tactical voting with Harris saying ACT voters should vote National and Hooton saying that ACT are 3% in latest poll and those four seats if Hide wins Epsom could deliver Brash to be PM.

Now discussing polling. Harris and Hooton says public polls are now useless as they are so impossible to reconcile, and they are just creating news.

Peters gets dirtier

There are few things less appealing than an absolutely desperate Winston Peters who four days before the election, and looking to be trounced in Tauranga, is doing a classic smear job.

After having had yesterday’s efforts explode in his face, he is now flying over (or she may be doing it herself) the ex staff member who complained about Bob Clarkson saying “I bet my left testicle that the All Blacks will win:.

My thoughts are two fold. The first are that many employers have ex-staff who do not like them. And if it is correct he sacked her after three weeks, and sued for $250,000 then she is not the most neutral witness.

The second is where this muckraking takes politics? I mean if Peters thinks sexual harrassment is suddenly a big character issue, then would it be in order for a journalist to ask candidates whether they consider an MP having an affair with his or her much younger secretary is sexual harrassment? Should that be reported?

Cullen Key lovefest

The Dominion Post has a lengthy article on John Key, and in a nice break from the mud slinging others have done, reveals that both Key and Cullen like and respect each other. Particularly amusing lines are:

Key:

“I really like the guy, eh. He is obviously really intelligent.” “But I’m not into job sharing, that’s all.”

“On a personal level, I like Michael Cullen. I respect him. He’s achieved a lot and is obviously very intelligent.”

On would he enjoy going out for a meal with him?: “Absolutely. Currently, I’m seeing more of him than I am of my wife, so why not eat together?”

Cullen:

“I don’t think John is duplicitous at all.”

On having a meal with Key: “Yes, no problem at all. It’s just that the bastard wants my job, that’s all.”

On Key’s house: “I suppose you could practise your golf driving inside. I think there is a tendency, though John came from a state house background and made his own way up in the world, to look at it from that perspective

NZ Herald and Tilegate

To my great surprise I could find not a single word in the NZ Herald on the Tilegate story (have to call it something!). Also as far as I know it is not in the print edition (let me know if this is not correct).

Now there is a legitimate difference of views on whether what Taito Field did was “dodgy as hell” (according to No Right Turn) or merely extremely bad judgement.

But I wonder how one could make a news judgement that the story isn’t even worth covering? Perhaps those wanting to know could ask the Editor.

To be fair to the Herald, they did cover the Judith Tizard walkout story. And talking of Judith Phil U reveals that this is not the first time Judith has walked off.

UPDATE: By coincidence, 45 minutes after I blogged this, the NZ Herald put this NZPA story up on ther website.

Incidentially the story passes over some vital details – mainly that the overstayer was being paid around $2 an hour.

Armstrong and James

John Armstrong at the end of today’s column says:

Labour is making little secret that its private polling has the party trailing National

So presumably their attacks on any poll which doesn’t show them in the lead as “rogue polls” is just for public consumption?

Meanwhile Colin James has a bob both ways (something he has been good at this election 🙂 by saying his instinct is that “Clark will make it over the line – but never in 12 elections as a political journalist have I been less confident of my instinct”.

James makes the point, which I have also made, is that “if Brash wins: Clark will have lost the unlosable election. An economy going nicely, jobs plentiful, real wages rising and high house prices should have got her home in a canter.”

Add to this that last election National got decimated. People consider a 5% – 10% margin a landslide win, and Labour had a 20% margin. To lose a 20% margin while running a booming economy and having the lowest unemployment in the world speaks volumes about how pissed off people have got with the Government. It is nothing short of a minor miracle that we enter the final week with National in the lead.

If Labour’s leaked polling is correct, then National is set to win more seats than Labour (unless Labour has a last minute smear, which if so will appear Wednesday). However they may squeak in thanks to, ironically, the Maori Party who look likely to have overhang seats. Thus one may have the centre-right win the most votes but the centre-left having more MPs.

I’m making no predictions, other than boy is it going to be close!

NZ First position

Just noted in the Herald story this morning that not only has NZ First said it will support the largest party to form a Government, but that it will be conditional on the Greens and ACT not being part of a coalition.

Sadly it is looking grim for ACT, so the only party likely to be affected by this is Labour.

This means that Labour’s only chance of govering is getting a majority of seats between the four parties of the left. This means a Labour-Progressive-Green-Maori Party coalition. Or Labour-Progressive-Green with confidence and supply from Maori Party.

The most likely alternative is a National-United Future coalition with confidence and supply from NZ First.

I think we can assume that with a Labour-Progressive-Green-Maori Party coalition, a deadline for treaty settlements will be gone by lunchtime.

A nice neutral summary

Rod Oram, the SST Business Editor, did a nice neutral summary for voters on the key business issues. He started it with:

Not since 1984 have National and Labour offered so stark a choice. Now, as then, National embodies the conservative forces trying to hold back tides of economic, political, cultural and social change.

Labour, now as then, embodies the modernising forces trying to help New Zealanders use those tides to their advantage to make a more prosperous and secure country in an uncertain world.

Okay so National is out of touch and trying to hold back change, while Labour is working to make NZ a more prosperous country. Extremely balanced.

Rod goes on to also provide a brief summary of the Leader’s speeches (what this has to do with business I do not know). He says how Brash delivered a “a generic tub-thumper that could have come from any centre-right party anywhere in the world” while Clark “gave one of her most passionate performances. There was no mistaking the rich content and context of the speech it was unmistakably, powerfully New Zealand.”

Also never one to let facts get in the way, Rod also says that “Labour’s core membership is not much larger than National’s”. Well I’ve never heard having around 20% as many members described as “not much larger”. Some others would call it minuscule.

I miss the days when the endorsements were done purely as editorials, and not reported as “news”.

A new standard of accountability?

Helen Clark got elected promising a new standard of accountability. Now for those who missed the TV One news, let’s see how this issue meets these new standards?

1) A Thai over-stayer contacts Labour Minister Taito Philip Field for help when his wife and child were deported

2) At the meeting Field learns the over-stayer is an tiler, and asks him if he can go out and tile his house in Samoa

3) He paid the tiler somewhere between $60 and $100 a week, well below minimum pay rates in NZ. I look forward to the CTU condemning this sweatshop operation!

4) He then made a personal representation to Immigration Minister Paul Swain [actually Associate Damien O’Connor] to grant work permits for the over-stayer and his wife.

5) The Minister granted the request, noting “It is not my normal practice to intervene in the established immigration application process, however I have decided to make an exception in this case”.

So Taito Field got his house in Samoa tiled cheaply, and the over-stayer got a personal request to the Minister who intervened in the established process to make an exception for them.

If Taito Field is still a Minister by the end of Tuesday, it will say a lot about Helen’s new standards of accountability.

People may like to recall that Jenny Shipley in 1999 also discovered ethical breaches by a Minister in relation to immigration issues. Despite being a couple of days before the election, she sacked him.

Oh this is so sad

Winston is desperate to retain Tauranga so let it be known he had dirt on Bob Clarkson, and it was spicy involving sex allegations.

But what did the man who once dealt in scandals involving hundreds of millions of dollars, manage to produce?

A 2002 newspaper article where an employee got upset after Mr Clarkson said “I bet my left testicle the All Blacks will win on Saturday”.

This was Winston’s smoking gun???

This is beyond pathetic. It is almost sad and pitiful. A new level of desperation.

VUWSA Elections

Well the VUWSA elections start tomorrow, and after my influential advice last year :-), I have been getting requests from concerned students as to whom they should support this time.

The official list of candidates is here.

President

The two main candidates for President appear to be Gareth Robinson and Nick Kelly. Now Gareth is by all accounts a sensible young man, while Nick Kelly is a communist.

However Gareth is being a bit greedy by standing for not just President, but also Education and Welfare Vice-Presidents. Shades of Muldoon 🙂

And personally I think there is a lot of merit in having communists in power. They remind us why capitalism is so good, and Nick would give me lots to blog about as he leads a weekly protest march against the Government.

So I’m leaning towards endorsing Nick, mainly because it may win an award for least welcome endorsement 🙂

Education Vice-President

Gareth would be a sound pick for this.

Welfare Vice-President

Jono Newton is standing on a campaign of accountability, which is going to be very important when dealing with Ngai Tauira’s requests (or demands) for funding.

Treasurer

Hu, Jia is the sole candidate and seems like he can count so a safe bet.

Women’s Rights Officer

I’ve been told Kristen Paterson is quite good, but as she doesn’t have a biography online can’t really compare.

Uni Council Rep

The very diligent and hard working Roy Baker is my pick.

General Executive

Don’t know too much about the candidates, but I am informed that commerce students are rather under-represented, so on that basis useful picks might be:

Jonathan Huntington
Jia Hu (Alvin)
Christophen (CJ) Hunt

Most importantly, vote – no matter who it is for. The greedy bastards steal $100 a year off you, so you might as well have a say in who administers it!!

Mr Pontell

A guy called Jonathan Pontell has been claiming to be some sort of strategic advisor for National on the Linda Clark show. Russell Brown has his doubts.

For my part I have never ever heard of this guy. Not that people should take that as authoritative, because I don’t have any official role in the campaign, and there may be many people I don’t know.

But more to the point, if a political party hired an advisor, do you really think the deal would involve him going on TV and radio to tell everybody about his winning theories?

The point about paying for an advisor, is that it is your advisor. The fact that the guy is all over the media should let you draw your own conclusions as to whether he is working for anyone, let alone National.

Orwell would be proud

The Government used to have a number of categories for recording the outcomes of people on waiting lists for elective surgery.

One of those categories was deceased – thus giving us a total for the number of people who die on waiting lists, awaiting operations.

But this will not do in Helengrad, so they have reclassified patients who die, as “patient removed due to changed patient circumstances”!!!!

Well yes being dead certainly is a changed circumstance.

Petrol Tax Relief

National has announced further tax relief today – a temporary reduction in the petrol tax by 5c a litre. This will take effect on 1 October 2005 and last until 1 April 2006, when National’s tax cuts will take effect.

The $100 million cost, will not be funded by reducing investment into roading, but out of the extra GST which has been collected due to the record high price of petrol. The net fiscal impact will be negligible.

The bottom line is that the Government has stood to gain almost $100 million more in GST over the next six months from the high petrol prices, so rather than invent loopy ways to spend it, National will give it back through reducing the petrol tax.

Filling up a large car now costs almost $100. Of that $100, 42% is made up of government taxes.

Move to scrap Holocaust Day

How to win an election

Promise to to privatise the Post Office.

Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi has won a huge mandate with 276 seats out of 480. Add on his allies and the Government will have 304 seats.

The postal service is a US$3 trillion business. I’d love to be the company handling the sale with the standard 1% commission 🙂

I doubt NZ Post would fetch as much sadly.

The poverty industry

The poverty industry have invented a measure of poverty which means that they can claim poverty is always a problem, unless one has a communist economy where all incomes are equalised.

That is because poverty is measured as relative to median income, not against purchasing power (which would be more useful).

Marginal Revolution’s Tyler Cowen notes that the official poverty rate in the US (12.7%) is higher than in 1974 (11.2%).

However in those 30 years, the following has happened:

* Real per capita income is over 60% higher today than in 1974.
* unemployment rate is lower
* percentage of adults with paying jobs is distinctly higher.
* Proportion of adults without a high school diploma has halved from 39% to 16%
* In 1972-73 only 42% of the bottom fifth of American households owned a car, now it is 75%
* In 1970 26% of “poverty households” lived in “crowded” homes, now 6%
* infant mortality fell by almost three-fifths over those same years, to 6.7 per 1,000 births from 16.7 per 1,000.

So what does this mean? It doesn’t mean all is wonderful in the US, but it does indicate that life is a lot better off today for most “poor” households than it was 30 years ago, despite there being an increase in the official number of people in poverty.

The conclusion is that poverty rates, as currently measured, are almost useless as an indicator of well-being.

Another good present

Now this would have been a good present – an Ann Coulter talking doll.

It has 14 phrases it repeats. My favourite is:

“Why not go to war just for oil? We need oil. What do Hollywood celebrities imagine fuels their private jets? How do they think their cocaine is delivered to them?”

Very sad

A gentleman called Matthew Pullan saw a guy repeatedly punch a woman in the face as she cowered on the backseat of a car.

Fearing that she was going to be killed, he did the decent thing and intervened by asking the guy to stop.

It was possibly not a huge surprise that the thug then tuned onto Mr Pullan and spent 15 minutes beating him to a pulp.

What is truly sad is that the woman who was being beaten up, then got up and joined in the assault on Mr Pullan for 15 minutes. She kicked him in the head a dozen times and stomped on his face while yelling racist abuse at him.

Next time someone sees a guy beating a woman up, and decides not to intervene, one can blame Tessa Jean Edwards for it.

Broadband Pledge

I was rather surprised that the NZ Herald made Labour’s “aim” of cheap fast broadband their front page story, because in reality it is a non-story.

Firstly to be fair I should add that generally I have been supportive of changes made by Labour in the telco and IT areas. The introduction of the Telco Commissioner has had some benefits for example. And I think David Cunliffe is a very campable and committed Minister.

However it is a matter of record that Labour refused to unbundle the local loop, despite their own Comms/IT Minister (then Paul Swain) recommending that they do unbundle. He got rolled at Cabinet.

The article is careful to avoid any spoecific pledge or promise. It says:

* aims for $1-a-day access
* pledges to get tough on Telecom
* a regulatory review of Telecom’s wholesale broadband business
* suggested that a “Chinese wall” arrangement could result through amendments to the Telecommunications Act.
* we are saying that we’re going to seriously look at how far we will go
* policy did not specifically include reopening the unbundling issue

As one can see it talks about aims, reviews, suggestions, looking at issues etc. Not a single actual specific. A masterpeice of spin.

Now absolutely fair effort of Labour to repackage work in progress, and make it sound like something new. That is what parties do. I am somewhat amazed however that the NZ Herald treats this as front page news.

Arrogance Personified

This is almost too good to be true.

An MP turns up to a meet the candidates meeting. The premises owner (it was at a bar) announces there are no media present. The MP then exclaims “Whats the point of coming here then?”.

The MP is randomly selected as first to speak. She gets up and asks “How many here are non-partisan or undecided?”. Only a few raise their hands. So said MP then says “”I hope you give your party vote to Labour, but I’ve got better things to do, like doorknock parts of Point Chevalier, I’m leaving now.”

If you haven’t guessed who it is, go check Aaron’s blog out.

If they are so arrogant now before the election, think how bad they would be if they get a third term?