Labour Unionist assaults Student

I blogged a photo yesterday of a gruff man who kept trying to block the media from filming any dissent to the Government.

Turns out the man is a senior union official, and in this photo in the Dom Post you can see he is technically assaulting a student, despite the fact the student is on the campus he has paid fees to attend.

And no he was not doing it to protect the PM. I was only a few metres away (and may have even suggested to young David he slips past me to get a better view) and the PM had a large contingent of police officers who were very alert and would have not hestitated to act if they viewed Mr Cassidy as a threat.

Also note that the Dominion Post reports how many of the student supporters were in fact from Labour’s parliamentary research unit. I am sure they were all on their lunch break.

Millsy concedes to corporate overlords

The VRWC Banner

NZ Pundit has come up with the official banner for all members of the vast right wing conspiracy for the next two days. Let’s see it on all the blogs which are funded by either:

The CIA
The Exclusive Brethren
Karl Rove
The Business Roundtable

this weekend.jpg

O’Sullivan: Time for a change

Quote of the Day 14 August 2005

The PM At Vic

Decided to pop up to Vic Uni at lunchtime and see how the PM’s visit went. Took the camera in case there were some good photos of airline pilots and I was not disappointed.

vic2.JPG

Now you have to admire someone who is willing to go to such lengths to make a protest. He was hilarious as he got closer and closer to the front, and finally as he made it there around a dozen flunkies tried to block him from the PM’s view. This sent the media crazy as they filmed him being blocked. I do give credit to the PM thought for her quip about needing a magnifying glass.

Further photos and comments after the break. Make sure you read about the attempt to hide away the taxpayer funded flag!
Continue reading »

The cost of the bribe

I think Dr Cullen and Miss Clark owe the Westpac Chief Economist a big apology, because their official advice from Treasury is a lot closer to his ballpark estimate, than their figures. Let’s all remember how they demonised him and accused him of impure motives. Well we know what motives Labour had – they tried to supress this advice.

Anyway to the figures, which Treasury say “may be understating the true total cost”:

* Annual cost rises to $390m by third year, and to $500m after six years, and by 2019 will be $924m.

* Impact on gross debt is a rise of $2.4 billion by third year, rising to $5.1 billion after six years, and rising to over $10 billion after only 11 years.

* Overall student debt increases under Labour’s policy. So much for Helen Clark kicking the ‘debt monster’ to death. Student debt blows out to $19.8 billion by 2020 verses $14.2 billion under the current student loan scheme.

Funnily enough I think my ballpark estimate was around $10 billion over a decade. Hey Treasury you should hire me 🙂

So boys and girls, next time you see a Labour attack ad saying it is madness to borrow an extra $3.5 billion, just smile and think own goal.

This is almost a rpeat of what Labour did when being kicked out in 1990. They tried to hide the figures until after the election. But this time it is $10 billion worth of hiding.

God bless the Ombudsmen!!

The cost of the bribe

I think Dr Cullen and Miss Clark owe the Westpac Chief Economist a big apology, because their official advice from Treasury is a lot closer to his ballpark estimate, than their figures. Let’s all remember how they demonised him and accused him of impure motives. Well we know what motives Labour had – they tried to supress this advice.

Anyway to the figures, which Treasury say “may be understating the true total cost”:

* Annual cost rises to $390m by third year, and to $500m after six years, and by 2019 will be $924m.

* Impact on gross debt is a rise of $2.4 billion by third year, rising to $5.1 billion after six years, and rising to over $10 billion after only 11 years.

* Overall student debt increases under Labour’s policy. So much for Helen Clark kicking the ‘debt monster’ to death. Student debt blows out to $19.8 billion by 2020 verses $14.2 billion under the current student loan scheme.

Funnily enough I think my ballpark estimate was around $10 billion over a decade. Hey Treasury you should hire me 🙂

So boys and girls, next time you see a Labour attack ad saying it is madness to borrow an extra $3.5 billion, just smile and think own goal.

This is almost a rpeat of what Labour did when being kicked out in 1990. They tried to hide the figures until after the election. But this time it is $10 billion worth of hiding.

God bless the Ombudsmen!!

Teacher approves kids attacking National billboard

The Smoking Gun

Keith Ng has gone through the student loan papers which Michael Cullen tried to supress, and has found and highlighted what is the real smoking gun. To quote Mr Ng, the Salient news editor, directly:

This is the costing that Labour went public with, and the assumptions are downright dishonest

The focus has been on Treasury’s initial costings, but the real scandal is the second set of costings where Dr Cullen ordered the Treasury to use his assumptions, rather than their own. And his three main assumptions he ordered Treasury to use were:

* voluntary repayments will continue at the rate at which they occur under the current scheme

* the percentage of the $150 [weekly] entitlement for living costs drawn [down] does not increase

* draw down rates increase in the following manner: [a <1% change in fees borrowing over 4 years] Now one can have a sensible debate about the extent of the change to borrowing patterns (such as whether takeup for FT students will move from 69% to 95% or 85% or even 80%) but Cullen ordered them to assume basically no change at all!! The most indefensible of Dr Cullen's instructions is that Treasury should assume there will no change to the rate of voluntary repayments. I dare anyone at all to argue that with interest free loans, there will be *no* slow down of voluntary repayments. If you believe that, then I have a bridge for sale. This is saying that graduates will use surplus cash to pay off a loan on which they pay no interest rather than pay off their mortgage quicker. It is incredibly dishonest. Only slighly less dishonest is the instruction that the amount of money being borrowed for living costs will not increase. And finally you have the instruction on how many more people will take up loans. As I said you can have a rational debate about the extent of any extra uptake, but Cullen instructed that Treasury assume that the increase by only 1%, *over four years*. If this was the united States, the term impeachment would be coming to mind. They lied about whether Treasury had costed the policy, they supressed the advice Treasury did provide, and they then instructed Treasury to use Dr Cullen'as assumptions which are to quote Keith downright dishonest.

I can not beat his summary which is:

In short, it’s been rigged to make the scheme look as cheap as possible, and Cullen specifically asked for it to be like that.

I hope the media pick up the significance of this issue. It is not a case of two sets of reasonable assumptions, where say Treasury is saying 26% more FT students will take out loans and Cullen is saying 15% will, and to be honest who can be certain which is closer. The Cullen assumptions are just nonsensical, basically saying no change at all, and designed to fool the public until after the election. This is the man who was in the 1990 Labour Government which did the same thing with the BNZ and the surplus which wasn’t. Leopards do not change their spots.

The Chief Ombudsman deserves a knighthood for his decision to force Labour to release this information.

Finally please note I have not read the released material myself, and am basing my comments on Keith’s analysis, but I heard John Key refer last night to similiar issues, so if John Key and Keith are agreeing this time, I reckon it is safe 🙂

Ombudsman kicks ass

Question of the Day

Fairfax Polling in Wellington

It is interesting to try and reconcile two recent Fairfax Polls. Their poll published on Saturday showed Labour ahead of National by 19% in Wellington Central on the party vote.

However’s today nationwide poll has a breakdown by region and has National ahead of Labour by 1% in Wellington.

Now these are two polls done by the same polling company and presumably the same methodology.

Now one was in Wellington Central and one has a breakdown for Wellington, which I presume is Mana, Ohariu-Belmont, Wellington Central, Rongotai, Hutt South and Rimutaka.

But of these seats WC was 2nd highest last election. Hutt South had a 27% Labour-National gap in 2002, Rimutaka 30%, Rongotai 28%, Mana 30%, Ohariu-Belmont 12% and Wellington Central 17%.

So if National is leading by 1% in Wellington generally, the chance it is 19% behind in Wellington Central is almost zero. Basically it would be saying that National is actually ahead of Labour in Rongotai, Mana, Rimutaka and Hutt South.

So as reluctant as I am to criticise a public poll (and note I made no criticism at the time, even though I was very very surprised by the results), I have to conclude that the two polls by Fairfax are incompatible, and the Wellington Central one looks suspect.

Having said that polls can very much be self fulfilling prophecies, so as usual I am not making any claims about results. But as I said, the two Fairfax polls really contradict themselves about what is happening in Wellington unless you believe National is 19% behind in Wellington Central, but leading the party vote in Mana!!

Case closed

In case there was any remaining doubt about the neutrality of Dr Jon Johansson, they disappeared today with his appearance as a guest blogger on Public Address where he basically calls for people to not vote National and reject a path lacking in even “basic decency”.

Now as I have said many times, Dr Johansson has just as much right as the Exclusive Brethren to have a view, and share it.

But absolute shame on the media who have continued to use Dr Johansson as a neutral commentator on Brash and Clark, when it has been manifestly clear he opposses Brash absolutely.

Again there is no issue with having opinionated commentators. Michelle Boag, Bob Harvey and Chris Trotter are prime examples. But they are well flagged in the public mind as being partisan, and their comments can be weighed up against that.

Dirt on Winston

I have been swamped with e-mails from people with alleged dirt on Winston. Please stop now – there is enough for a book. Send it to someone with parliamentary privilege!!

Cathy Odgers does blog on the irony of Peters being the person to be throwing mud of this sort.

Student Loan Calculator

Just reposting a link to my student loan calculator (an excel file) which shows almost every student can pay their loan off faster under National than Labour (for $38,000 starting salary, would need loan of over $100,000 to do it faster under Labour).

Stident Loan Calculator

Maharey sums it up

Thank you Steve Maharey for articulating everything wrong with Labour. In this week’s newsletter where he is detailing what is wrong with National, he complains:

It wants a future where people make their own decisions about their own money.

Staggering. What more need one say? How dare people want to “make their own decisions about their own money”. You are meant to give it all to Steve and Helen and Trevor to decide for you.

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

Tauranga Antics

This Rod Emmerson cartoon is a pretty good summary of why Peters is resorting to his desperate tactics.

The Herald editorial is well worth a read. It however makes one mistake in saying that the accusation of over-spending could, when determined, affect the election result. It won’t.

If Bob Clarkson wins Tauranaga, as is highly likely, and an electoral petition did find he had over-spent his budget (an accusation that is strongly refuted) then the seat would merely fall vacant and there would be a by-election. Now Peters might win the by-election but he would not retrospectively qualify for List MPs from the previous election (if NZ First had failed to make 5%).

The final sentence of the editorial says:

He seems be going out with a last flourish of the dubious art of character assassination.

Something worth reflecting on also, is Peters’ use of stolen information. Peters handed out IRD documents relating to Clarkson’s tax affairs.

Mad Maharey

Maharey, one of the architects of the “If you vote Don Brash the kid gets killed” billboard campaign has gone one better.

He has told people to vote Labour or the alternative is what the folks in Louisiana got.

Yes that’s right vote Labour or a hurricane will kill you and you family. And there will be a plague of locusts also no doubt.

As Whale Oil points out, Louisiana is controlled almost entirely by left-wing politicians.

But that is not the issue. The issue is the sad sorry sight of Clark and Maharey grasping on every issue they can. Clark wants to spend her entire last week talking about Iraq and a 20 year old piece of legislation. Maharey wants to scare monger about hurricanes. Where is Labour’s vision for the future? Their vision is to scare people.

Health Targeting

Unless you live is Disneyland, you will accept that it is impossible to fund all healthcare, so the issue for Governments is how to target the funding to get the best outcomes for New Zealanders.

Now Labour’s GP funding policy is to be blunt bizarre. They have set up a system where you get a $27 subsidy based on where you live. Each PHO area is assessed on the number of low income, Maori and Pacific people living there. So even if you are a millionaire, you get the $27 subsidy because you live in an area with a PHO subsidy.

But it gets even worse. On the West Coast, a very poor area, their PHO does not qualify for the subsidy. Because they do not have enough Maori and Pacific people living there. However Rotorua (average family income $48,034) qualifies while West Coast-Tasman (average family income $43,783) does not.

So to be blunt Labour’s plans discriminate on race and target on where you live, not individual circumstances.

Now what will National do? While hard to follow we glean the following from this NZ Herald article:

* Increase subsidy for low and middle income families from $15 to $30
* Increase threshold to qualify for subsidy from $$20,275 for single person to $30,000 and from $45,498 to $55,000 for a family with two kids
* Not implement a universal subsidy for people aged 25 to 64 who earn above that level
* Have the subsidy dependent on your income, not on how many poor, Maori or Pacific neighbours you have

Under Labour a millionaire living in the right area will get a $27 subsidy while a poor person living in the wrong area will only get a $15 subsidy. Absolutely buts, which is why the Medical Association has endorsed National’s policy even though they probably would gain more from universal subsidies as planned by Labour.

There are times I like the Maori Party

Helen’s new standard

Helen Clark has defended one of her Ministers who hired an illegal over-stayer to work for him in Samoa for $1.20 an hour or $54 a week.

She has said he was just “being helpful”.

Now could you just imagine if say this was former National MP Arthur Anae who had done this. Helen would be on the front page calling him a sweatshop operator. No less than a dozen unions would have come out and condemned it as exploitation, and proof National wants to abolish the minimum wage.

The issue is simple. If a constituent comes to you in desperate need of help, you don’t take advantage of their situation to save tens of thousands of dollars by asking if he will work for you for next to nothing.

Both the Prime Minister and this Minister of the Crown see nothing at all wrong with this. It highlights their unfitness for office. I repeat that Jenny Shipley sacked a Minister for immigration conflict of interest issues in 1999, in the week before the election. Clark does not sack him, but praises him.

And just to add to the ethical issues, the NZ Herald has an e-mail suggesting Field’s wife is on the payroll, which is illegal under parliamentary rules.

Small Business Minister

Tv One just had an item on the two men competing to be Small Business Minister – Rick Barker and Lindsay Tisch.

I would observe that Lindsay is obviously far more suited to be the Small Business Minister 🙂

And not just because he has run three small businesses, while Barker was a full-time Union official.

National on brink of victory

A Fairfax poll of 1,085 people taken up until Monday has National ahead of Labour by 6% and in the words of The Press “a step away from the Treasury benches”.

Leading Labour 43% to 37%, a National-United Future Coalition would have 57 seats, and with confidence and supply from NZ First 65 votes out of 120 to 123 seats in Parliament.

The Dom Post says “Don Brash is poised to become prime minister”.

However still three days to go.

Distractions