Labour votes to keep Treaty clauses

Labour have been quite effective in making people think they have made changes to their habit of inserting treaty clauses everywhere, but in reality it has talked the talk but won’t walk the walk. Even the Treaty Education Minister admits that there is no need for his electorate staff to have treaty clauses in their adverts, yet it still goes out with them.

The latest is Labour, Greens and Maori Party voting not to even send to select committee the NZ First bill to remove all references to the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi from legislation. It was defeated 51-63.

Now the bill, being a NZ First bill, was overly simplistic. But it would have been very useful to have it go to select committee, which could then consider in more detail the areas where having treaty clauses is inappropriate. Labour by voting against have shown that they are not resiling from past practice.

As for John Tamihere saying “everyone knew what the principles were”, he must be kidding. The version given by Margaret Wilson in 2002 are simply her opinion, with no weight in law.

Parliamentary Privilege

Retired Appeal Judge Ted Thomas has a column of why the law should not be changed to overturn recent court decisions that an MP saying they affirm what they said in Parliament, is not covered by privilege.

As much as I despair at how some MPs abuse privilege (Peters and Mallard especially) I think it is important to have. And I do think the current court rulings have created somewhat of a nonsense that after an MP says something in Parliament, every broadcaster and person in the land can repeat it, but the MP can not simply say “Yes I stand by what I said in Parliament”. I mean everyone knows they stand by what they said, so you end up with semantic games.

So I tend to favour the proposed law change.

Disunity at the Top

There is confirmation of a major and growing rift between the Labour Government and Labour’s elected Party President.

It started with the Budget backlash being blamed on the President, and now we learn that Dr Cullen has apologised on behalf of Mike Williams to Michael Barnett, yet Mr Williams was totally unaware of the apology on his behalf.

And as I predicted Labour have scored another own goal by grabbing the suggested domain name for the Auckland business campaign. They have merely got an shorter, far better, domain name (www.revup.co.nz) and all the days of publicity over the issue will result in many more people knowing about it, then would have been the case.

Anti-Christian Behaviour

Two articles today caused me to reflecton the vastly different attitudes towards criticism and tolerance of Christianity and Islam.

The first was the the start of the Popetown comedy which takes the mickey out of the Catholic Church. Now I’m all for comedy which takes the mickey out of everyone, and the only issue I would have with Popetown is that it isn’t actually funny or offensive enough, according to Craig Ranapia.

But it did make me reflect on what the reaction would be if such a comedy was directed at Islam. I mean if an (incorrect) report that copies of the Koran had been flushed down the toilet leads to world-wide riots and killings, could you imagine the reaction to a comedy show that showed lampooned Islam, as this show lampoons the Catholic Church. Every member of the cast and crew would probably live in fear for their lives.

And on the same issue I note that Seatoun School Board of Trustees has banned a weekly lunchtime religious studies group from meeting on school property. As long as it is voluntary and at lunch-time, I think it is stupid to ban it. Do we really want school boards banning clubs? Rongotai College had a peace club – should that have been banned if some parents didn’t like it?

I think the comparison here again is if a school had Islamic students, and they asked for a room at lunch-time they could meet in, to do their religious duty (I think have to pray five times a year [day I meant]), it would be unthinkable for permission not to be granted, because that would be discriminatory!!

What just annoys me is the double standards where Christianity is the one religion or minority it is always safe to lampoon or attack. And I say that as someone who detests religious moral crusaders such as Graham Capill and Brian Tamaki.

UPDATE: The Green Frog concurs on the issue of Seatoun School. And I suspect like me, Frog is not overly religious (well maybe it worships Jim Henson), so this is hardly a case of regular church going Christians complaining about the ban, but just basically common sense I suggest.

And more billboards

Drinking Age Vote

The bill passed the first reading by 78 to 41 which is a lot more than most were predicting. I still doubt that it means it will go much further, but we will see.

The Drug Foundation has who voted how on this site.

The voting figures for each party were:

Labour 33:17
National 19:8
NZ First 13:0
ACT 2:7
Green 2:7
United 6:2
Progressive 2:0
Maori 1:0

It is interesting that both National and Labour were 2:1 in favour. Nice to see Don Brash voting the sensible way (criminalising 19 year olds from purchasing alcohol is not a solution).

ACT and Greens were both around 75% against. Eckhoff and Franks form ACT and Ewen-Street and Ward from Greens voting for.

NZ First were 100% in favour, which for me is proof positive it is a bad bill 🙂

The secular wing of United Future – Dunne and Alexander were against.

G-Man on Speaker Wilson

Send some MPs to Hell

Yes it’s true. You can vote to send some MPs to Hell, thanks to Hell Pizzas Hell Poll.

You can vote in seven different categories with the choices being:

Envy – Don vs Clark
Wrath – Tamihere vs Peters
Sloth – Nandor vs Bill
Gluttony – Rodney vs Parekura
Pride – Donna vs Prebble
Lust – Gerogina vs Tariana
Greed – Dover vs Mallard

Was easy to decide who to vote for, except in the last two categories. Went with Georgina and Mallard in the end.

Make sure you click on each MP also to hear them speak.

Very fun and very cool. You can vote once per day on each category.

Burn baby burn!

Chris Trotter on evening the odds

Veteran left-wing commentator Chris Trotter has a fascinating column in the Independent. As their links only last for a week I’ve included the story over the break.

Trotter makes several points:
* The Opposition’s newly erected billboards speak eloquently of a quantum shift in National’s propaganda capability.
* A fortnight ago rumours flew around the capital that the Prime Minister’s hitherto highly effective propaganda team was on the verge of mutiny and, some whispered, disintegration
* Six years of unprecedented spending on health and education have not produced the anticipated results.
* New Zealand’s bureaucratic structures would appear to have an inexhaustible capacity to absorb taxpayers’ dollars

And best of all is this gem:

The more forthright critics of this creeping bureaucratic paralysis have even given it a name. Rather unkindly, they call it “Mahareyism.”
Continue reading »

Drinking Age

It looks like Matt Robson’s bill to increase the age of purchase for alcohol to 20 will pass its first reading.

The issues around teenage drinking are to do with education and enforcement. It is stupid to criminalise 19 year olds going to the pub, because there is a problem with 14 year olds getting drunk at private parties.

It’s a bit like raising the age of sexual consent to 25, because too many 15 year olds are getting pregnant.

I suspect the bill will die in select committee, as it should.

Parasitic Pokies

John Minto has found a new campaign target – this time parasitic loan sharks and ‘pokies’.

Now I will happily agree loan sharks charging 20%/month are parasites.

But I am quite confused as to how pokies “extract $92 million each year from the Manukau region”. Do these pokie machines jump out and hold people up? Do they forcibly extract money by stealing wallets?

Interest Rates

Dr Cullen is trying to scare-monger that tax cuts under National will be inflationary and lead to interest rate hikes. This misses the point that $1 of spending is more inflationary than $1 of tax cuts.

It is also risable that suddenly now Dr Cullen is worried about interest rate increases. Interest rates have gone up a whopping seven times in the last 18 months. And why? The OECD blames it on the run-away Government spending.

Big Brother is coming

In a couple of weeks I am going to follow NZ Pundit to MT 3.1 and also as a consequence registration will be required for people to leave comments.

Registration is easy and you just need to set up a login, display name, password and working e-mail address.

People can stay anonymous – you can set your login and display name to be whatever you like. And if you do not want me knowing your home or work e-mail, just set-up a hotmail address.

What it will allow me to do is more easily ban the w***ers like ztev, who will have to set up a whole new e-mail address everytime, rather than just change IP addresses.

I suggest people get in early and register with Type Key now. The change-over will probably be weekend after next.

Wilson lets Benson-Pope off

I have to say I was naive, and never for a second did I consider the Speaker may not refer the Benson-Pope issue to the Privileges Committee, but she has refused.

I thought it was beyond dispute that it would go to the Privileges Committee, as the facts were so clear cut. DBP denied some very specific allegations in the House, and since then several former students have come forward to say they were true.

It is in no way the Speaker’s job to decide who is telling the truth. That is for the Committee to consider. But when faced with numerous witnesses saying that DBP lied to the House, it really is unthinkable that the issue would not be referred for consideration. I can’t think of a more clear-cut case for referral.

I thought Speaker Hunt was the most partisan Speaker ever, but as Rodney says a new low has been set. This really is shameful.

Abortion Law

The lawsuit against Abortion Supervisory Committee could be very interesting.

It is certainly true that effectively New Zealand has abortion on demand. And it is also true that law was designed to allow them on grounds of danger to physical or mental health only.

There is certainly a case to be made that if NZ wants abortion on demand, then the law should explicitly state this.

The law is covered in the Crimes Act 1961 – specifically Section 187A(1), paragraph (a) which states:

“That the continuance of the pregnancy would result in serious danger (not being danger normally attendant upon childbirth) to the life, or to the physical or mental health, of the woman or girl”

There are other grounds relating to if the child would be seriously handicapped, is the result of incest or rape, the mother is retarded.

Personally I don’t think legislative blocking of abortion is desirable or effective, but the issue here is whether the practice complies with the legislation.

A silly thing to do

Labour learnt that Auckland business groups were planning to campaign on the lack of progress on roading, and a draft strategy included having a website called www.revupthegovt.co.nz

The business groups had not yet registered the domain, as the strategy was only draft, so Labour went and registered it. Technically registered to David Talbot who bizarrely is the candidate for Clutha-Southland, yet lives in Wellington!

Oh wait, now all is clear – his biography says he works for Marion Hobbs.

Now such a move is really very very silly. It will totally piss off the business groups, such that where they may not have proceeded with the campaign, they now may. But also it will be ineffective as there are dozens of other domains they could use for their campaign.

Personally the ethics of grabbing a domain, on the basis of a leaked document outlining its planned use by another group, is very dubious.

More billboards

Don’t forget Doonegate

Do you all remember how the PM refused to release transcripts of her calls with the SST, but somehow one of them made their way to the Press which semi-supported her version of events, claiming she said “go back to your source”.

Well an alert Peter Metcalfe has noticed the Press has now retracted this report!!

I presumed the Press had seen a copy of the transcript, but instead it appears they were misled. By whom I wonder? The mystery thickens!

Health Outcomes

Heather Roy has done some very good work comparing the increase in health funding under Labour, to health outcomes.

Core health spending has skyrocketed by $3.5 billion under Labour – from $6.1 billion to $9.6 billion – yes a massive near 60% increase.

But what has happened to waiting list and operations?

* Waiting lists total 180,000 a number described by Annette King in 1999 as

Don’t forget Doonegate

Do you all remember how the PM refused to release transcripts of her calls with the SST, but somehow one of them made their way to the Press which semi-supported her version of events, claiming she said “go back to your source”.

Well an alert Peter Metcalfe has noticed the Press has now retracted this report!!

I presumed the Press had seen a copy of the transcript, but instead it appears they were misled. By whom I wonder? The mystery thickens!

Greens get personal

The NZ Herald reports how one of their retiring MPs, and it seems a number of members, feels the party dilutes it environmental message with its focus on cannablis law reform and Maori rights.

They also report how the Greens who pride themselves on policies not personalities have thrown that away and basically called Don Brash a sexist and racist. Sigh!

“Women understand that in Don Brash’s … vision of New Zealand, their rightful place is in the kitchen”

I’d like to be around when someone tells Judith Collins that, whom he has promoted. Just because both the demoted MPs were women, makes it ludicrous to suggest he thinks a woman’s place is in the kitchen. He rolled Bill English as Leader, and Bill is a man, so does that make him anti-man? What drivel.

Fitzsimons also said “Dr Brash also wanted all Maori to be just like Pakeha in every respect”

Really – I must have missed that. But hey let’s just make it up and portray your oppoents as racist and sexist rather than you know actually debate policies.

Pay-as-you-drive

The UK Government is looking to scrap fuel tax and replacing it new satellite technology to monitor vehicles to create a “pay-as-you-drive” charge.

I think this is very much the way of the future. There are privacy issues to overcome, but I like the concept of paying more to use certain roads at peak times etc.

Vanity Fair’s Proust Questionnaire

Spotted on Aaron’s blog.

Note; ANyone thinking of filing this in, is probably best to read Cathy first on why it is a dumb idea. As for me, well I do dumb well sometimes!

What is your idea of perfect happiness?

Waking up next to someone, and every morning falling back in love with them.

Which living person do you most admire?

My parents.

What is the trait you most deplore in yourself?

Paranoia (even when justified!)

What is your greatest extravagance?

International Travel.

On what occasion do you lie?

I tell temporary lies to play jokes on friends often. I can be evasive and sometimes deliberately leave a misleading impression when necessary. Apart from the normal white lies in one

Iraqis strike back

According to this story, it seems likely the source for Winston Peters’ latest allegations is someone who has lost lawsuits against the two men named by Peters as being high officials in Saddam’s regime.

If this is true, it beggars belief that Peters doesn’t try to verify such sources and claims before repeating them in Parliament.

As fiscal conditions permit …