Civil Society

Enjoying Sydney

Flattery

As we know imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. You know National’s billboards are great when they inspire dozens of imitators. The only problem is that the imitations are only online, bot at 100 high traffic sites throughout NZ.

But for those who want to have a laugh, here are links to all the imitations I know of:

No Right Turn – Foreign Policy and Health

And more from About Town.

Scoop – modified Nat ones

More from Scoop.

Fighting Talk – various good ones

About Town – Race Relations, State Services et al

And finally from Not PC, some alternative words, but not pictures.

The funniest for me is the foreign policy one and the pride and prejudice one. The lamest is the style one.

As an aside could I suggest that people might want to remove the “Authorised by Steven Joyce” line on the parody ads. Technically they are breaching the Electoral Act by including that line, even as a parody.

Greens and Student Loans

The Greens say student loan debt is growing at $78,000 an hour. Sounds awful until you realise that this is around 20 cents/hour/borrower.

The idea of writing off some of the loan for people who stay in NZ is not novel. In fact it is copied from National’s 2002 policy. But I am unsure what they mean by saying people can get their loan written off by doing unpaid work. Does this mean become a full-time activist for Greenpeace and we will write your loan off for you??

They plan to fund their promises out of the Cullen superannuation fund. This is one reason why I have never liked the fund – leave tens of billions of dollars in a fund which the Government owns, and MPs will try and raid it for their pet projects. Frankly I don’t think anyone under 40 should assume that the fund will be there when they retire.

The Greens also seek to reduce the age for parental means testing. This is an area in which I concur. But to remove it alltogether as they propose would cost $4.1 billion over four years and frankly the Greens are nore likely to endorse battery hen farming than they are to ever come close to being able to deliver this.

If I have this right, the Greens want to do the following:
* Write off all student debt if people stay in NZ
* Increase threshold for student debt repayment
* Suspend interest for those on low incomes
* Make study costs tax deductible for those not getting an allowance
* Introduce a universal student allowance
* Lower age of parental means testing
* Increase parental income threshold
* Increase accomodation allowance by $100/week approx
* Re-intrdouce independent circumstances allowance
* Make all students eligible for the dole over summer
* Reduce student fees to $1,500

The total cost of all this over four years would be around $8 billion at a minimum I calculate. But in reality it would be far far more. Enrolments at the wananaga and the like would skyrocket as students would probably be offered all sorts of inducements to be enrolled when the Government will pay them up to $300/week to study for as long as they like.

And as long as you joined Greenpeace you would get your entire student loan paid off. Even better you would never have to work for money as the Greens support paying a universal living allowance to every NZer regardless of whether they are seeking work or not.

Taxes

Dr Cullen is rather rattled when he has to resort to the Muldoonist label. Umm Michael, Muldoon raised taxes and ran a huge deficit.

Lowering taxes to take account of an $8b surplus is not Muldoonist. It is in fact just plain non-ideological common sense. “We have taken more money off you than we can spend, so have some back”.

Westpac has pointed out that Cullen is planning to increase crown spending from 29.6 per cent of GDP in 2004 to 32.3 per cent in 2009. And even with all that (much of which would be wasteful) there would be large surpluses.

Westpac has also pointed out that more people moving into higher tax brackets since Labour gained power means the Government will have raked in an extra $8.7 billion when its promised tax cuts begin in 2008.

And even if one does need to cut spending for tax cuts, I’ve found a $500,000 start.

Election Date

The NZ Herald talks about Labour’s fears over the the bad budget reaction (an own goal of unprecedented ability), and that this makes 30 July election more unlikely.

I agree.

They pick the next date as 20 August, mentioning the four week recess in late June and July would keep parliamentary scrutiny to a minimum. They are right, but overlook that it would be unprecedented for the PM to call a non-snap election without Parliament having the right to have an adjournment debate and valedictory speeches for retiring MPs. So she would have to call it by say Tuesday 21 June to allow time for this. Also with Nats conference that weekend, it would be great timing for National to start the campaign with the profile of its annual conference.

I don’t see a eight week campaign being likely. In theory the PM could recall Parliament in July, but this is normally only done for things like the Iraq war, and it would undermine the image of not going early.

So I am now going to pick September 17 as most likely.

At the end of the day, the PM will call an election the moment Labour have some upwards momentum, which is probably a clear couple of weeks of no scandals, and at least three positive poll results. So it still could be July 30 if the next two weeks go well, but unlikely.

Bad News for the Greens

John Armstrong points out that the NBR poll may be worse news for the Greens than Labour.

A number of commentators have said that the Greens may not make 5%, with the Maori Party attracting some support, and the risk of Green supporters voting Labour to keep it up in the polls.

So not only do the Greens face the (at this stage only possible, certainly not probable) elimination from Parliament, but the hopes of a Labour/Green coalition are fading. Rather than the major partner to Labour, the Greens may be one of only four or five parties supporting the Government, if it is even Labour.

The bottom line is can one imagine any Green polices getting passed if it is Winston Peters with the deciding vote?

A Labour/NZ First Government could be even more hostile to the Greens than a National one!

Heh

.xxx

ICANN has approved in principle the creation of .xxx as a new top level domain for the Internet.

I think this is a good move as it creates an area of the Internet which filters can reliably block for children, without having false positives that most filters use. Of course not all adult sites will move there but I suspsect a fair few will.

Also while on ICANN good to see that ICANN Board are not just blindly voting to give Verisign .net for another six years. The process has been seriously flawed, and criticised by even the Chairman of the group which drew up the evaluation criteria.

NBR poll results and seats

Applying the electoral calculator, and assuming party leaders keep their seats, and that the Maori Party win 5 electorate seats, the poll result and Parliament would be:

National 38% 48 seats
Labour 37% 46 seats
NZ First 12% 15 seats
Green 5% 6 seats
Maori 2% 5 seats
United Future 1.9% 2 seats
Progressive 0% 1 seats

Total 123 seats

National and United Future have 50 seats. Labour/Progressive/Maori/Green have 60 seats. You need 62 for a majority so NZ First gets to pick.

National/NZ First would be 63 seats by itself. On the left Labour/NZF would be 61 seats so would need Progressive, Green or Maori support.

In terms of National, if that was the election result then everyone on the list down to Ravi Clarkson Musuku at 48 would be an MP.

MASH

Lately I’ve been doing an all nighter around once a week, as I try to juggle blogging with the election, InternetNZ and oh yeah earning an income. This week I am onto my third all nighter (posting times should make it easy to work out what nights the other two were) as I try to finish various things before having to head to the airport at 5.00 am. I suspect only sleeping every second night is not a good idea, but you do get used to it.

Anyway the upside is that by chance I discovered TV3 has MASH on at 1.30 am. Tonight was I think the saddest episode of them all – the one when Henry Blake gets discharged but his plane home is shot down. I’d forgotten how great MASH was, and how especially powerful that episode was. Such a shock ending also with no hint it was coming.

At some stage I must get hold of the entire MASH series. I need to do something with my new 250 GB external hard drive 🙂

Kiwiblog Stats

May was the month I cracked 100,000 visits over the month. Came close in April but not quite. June is off to a good start with over 4,000 people on the 1st.

The exponential growth of previous months has slowed down though and I suspect visitors will not grow much more from here on in. We’ll see.

kiwiblogmay05.JPG

National ahead in latest poll

TV3 has just announced that tomorrow’s NBR/UMR poll shows National leading Labour. UMR incidentially is the company which also does Labour’s polling.

Last month Labour was ahead by 7% (41% to 34%) while tomorrow they will be behind by 1%. I do know the actual figures but it is impolite to reveal them before NBR does.

It is going to be an interesting few months.

Jumping sides

Have just heard that retiring ACT MP Deborah Coddington will not have to move far for her new job. She will be in the press gallery!!

Deborah has been hired by the Herald on Sunday as a ‘feature writer’ based in the press gallery.

Somewhat ironic that the Liberatarianz Party has two members or former members in the press gallery, but never any in the House itself 🙂

In Sydney

I’m off to Sydney, with the SO, for four days holiday from tomorrow morning. Yes I followed the advice from this thread.

As usual when overseas, blogging will be reduced but not stop all together.

The hotel has a swimming pool on the 45th level roof, so expect some good scenic shots 🙂

National Billboards

Okay I have below copies of the eight versions of the 100 or so billboards which have gone up around the country. And these ones are confirmed official!

The NZ Herald has a story on them.

My favourite one is the Tax Cut one closely followed by the 111 one. The nice thing about there being a variety of them is people actually start to look out for them, and see if they can spot one they haven’t yet seen. Only blog readers here will get to see them all at once 🙂

They are converted from pdfs which has reduced the image quality on some. They look much better in real life!

Perhaps I should run a poll on which ones people like best?

Cabs Cops Billboard.JPG

Excuses Exams Billboard.JPG

Health Spending Billboard.JPG

Iwi Kiwi Billboard.JPG

Tax Cut Billboard.JPG

Violent Criminals Billboard.JPG

Welfare Billboard.JPG

Who Decides Billboard.JPG

How Labour thanks the Greens

The Greens save Labour’s butt over the Prisoner Compensation law, so how does Labour repay them. Read this transcript of Dr Cullen in the House:

Hon Dr MICHAEL CULLEN: As we all know, freedom of expression in our sense does not exist in China. But it is probably true to say that things are better now than they were when my old friend Keith Locke was an enthusiastic supporter of the Chinese regime.

Keith Locke: I wish to make a personal explanation with regard to the statement the Minister has just made that I have been a supporter of the Chinese regime. At no time have I supported the Chinese regime. I have always pushed for multiparty democracies. I have defended Chinese dissidents over many years. The Socialist Action League, a political organisation to which some people in this House sometimes refer to and that I belonged to over 20 years ago was, as the Minister will know, a very strong critic of the Chinese regime, because that regime was undemocratic. The Minister is implying that I was in some ways a Maoist and was supporting that regime, and I object to that totally. I ask the Minister to withdraw and apologise.

Hon Dr MICHAEL CULLEN: I withdraw and apologise. I do correct myself. The member was not, indeed, a Maoist; he was a Trotskyite.

With friends like this, who needs …..

Sunset clauses

Labour and the Greens have done a deal over the prisoner compensation bill.

Now the bill will be an awful unprincipled piece of law. How do I know this? Because it has a sunset clause which means it expires in a few years.

Whenever the Government needs to scratch an electoral issue by passing bad offensive law, it sticks in a sunset clause so the law does not remain on the books for long. They just want to be able to say before an election that have ‘handled’ an issue.

The most well known legislation with a sunset clause is the Electoral Integrity Act which gives party leaders and caucuses the ability to expel dissident MPs from Parliament. It will expire at this election. Not a single MP, outside Jim Anderton, really thinks that this is a good law.

Cullen threatens journalists

Most of the media attention has been on the fact that Michael Cullen named the wrong TV station when he launched an attack on them yesterday.

However I think the most interesting part of this story is that the NZ Herald reports him as warning the press gallery they were at Parliament only with the permission of the Speaker.

This reads to me as a threat to journalists that if they displease the Government, then the Speaker may remove their accreditation.

Can anyone spell Muldoon?

Peters targetting Iraqis

Barmy Army Guide

A new pick-up line

Well thanks to PC World, I have a new pick-up line I can use on girls. No longer do I have to resort to “Hi I’m an uber-blogger” when impressing potential girlfriends, but I can now say “Hi I’m the 13th most powerful person in the NZ Internet”. Bound to work for me, eh!

I was in at InternetNZ today and heard hysterical laughter coming from one of the offices. They had just discovered this month’s PC World which had a ‘power list’ of the 20 most powerful or influential Kiwis with the Internet. Theresa Gattung was No 1, Douglas Webb No 2 and I was listed at No 13. My reaction was to join in the hysterical laughter. The only redeeming feature was one of the INZ staff was listed at No 19 to keep me company.

Once I finished laughing I read the article. Against my better judgement it’s included over the page. In one sense it is nice that InternetNZ is getting recognition for the work we have been doing in the last couple of years. However I’m just one of a large team of volunteers and staff, and would never ever claim sole credit for what INZ has been achieving. But it is the nature of these lists they pick people, not organisations.

Anyway have a laugh if you want to, but please do not take it seriously. I don’t, and I hope no-one else would.
Continue reading »

May 2005 NZ Political Blog Statistics

March 2005 NZ Political Blog Statistics

A big increase in posts and comments this month for some blogs!

A big thanks to ever growing number of people who sent their stats through – a real time saver.

Posts/Comments

Lite Bloggers

Middle of the Road 1 0
James Gribble 3 1
Benzylpiperazine 3 2
Number 8 Wire 3 3
Three Point Turn 3 6
Right kind of girl 3 9
Excruciatingly Correct Behaviour 3 38
MediaNZ 4 0
Pacman 4 2
Left and Lefter 4 6
Dog Biting Men 4
Kiwi Pundit 5 6
Resistant Soy 5 10
Some Other Guy 5 10
ACT on Campus 6 10
Bertrand Bargolias 6 20
Dave Gee 7 2
Looke 7 3
Kiwi Jew Pundit 7 10
Poll Dancer 7
Sparrows are cool 8 5
Craig Ranapia 9 1
Observationz 9 5
Joe Hendren 9 8
Peachy Blog 9 10

Medium Bloggers

Maramatanga 10 6
Genius NZ 11 0
Gareth Robinson 11 4
Gman 12 11
It’s Actually Thursday Minister 14 15
VUWSA Pres 15 31
Darkness Network 16 0
Hard News 16
Blu Blooded 17 8
Fighting Talk 18
Peter Metcalfe 19 29
Big News 22 18
Radical Space 22 42
sagenz 24 17
Tumeke 24 59
Cathy Odgers 28 131
I hate socialism 30 54

Heavy Bloggers (more than daily)

Home, throne & altar 32 45
Kea Blog 35 11
Andrew Falloon 35 26
Spanner 35 179
Holden Republic 38 41
Daily Bork 39 3
NZ Paradigm 39 56
Jono’s Random Rants 48 58
Bloggreen Aotearoa 55 44
Just Left 55 1012
Zen State 58 51
Philosphy et cetera 59 24
About Town 59 198
Philosphically Made 80 224

Need a life bloggers

Prime Minister 102 61
Aaron Bhatnagar 110 573
Silent Running 113 1015
Frogblog 122 414
No Right Turn 129 543
Rodney Hide 141 1570
David Farrar 192 2452
Not PC 194 476
NZ Pundit 199 843
Sir Humphrey’s 342 1608
Whoar 409 24

We have 11 over the 100/month mark.

The total number of posts on NZ political blogs this month was 3,163 (2,574 in April) with 12,143 (8,396) comments made.

The average (mean) number of posts were 47 with 193 comments whiule the median was 17 posts and 18 comments.

Watch TV3 tonight

Miss Universe

Something wrong when it is a gay friend who msns you to tell you that Miss Canada has been crowned Miss Universe! At least Canada has some defence to all the Southpark jokes.

She is 23, born in Russia, and is a classical pianist and composer.

Now people would be disappointed if I blog about Miss Universe with no photos, so one below and a couple more after the break!

canada3.jpg
Continue reading »