Fair and balanced media

Iraqi Poll Results

Fascinating poll taken in Iraq of Iraqis.

The right vs wrong direction is +39% positive (that is higher than in NZ!). And the support for extreme religious law is pretty low.

There were a couple of places not polled due to the risk of execution of the pollsters. That would be an interesting addition to the OSH register for my polling company – pollsters may be shot by grumpy respondents.

Justice Scalia on originalism

Associate Supreme Court Justice Scalia delivered a speech at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars on March 14, 2005 and the transcript is online. It is similiar to his Wellington speech so for those who missed that, this gives a good idea of what he says.

Quote of the Day 18 March 2005

Girl in 30s: So what do you know about X?

Guy: Well she has a past:

Girl in 30s: You mean she was the town bike.

DPF: You can’t call her the town bike

Girl in 30s: Hey in my time I’ve done a fair bit of cycling myself, so I can call her the town bike if I want to

DPF: Thanks for giving me my quote of the day

Jim Peron in NZ Herald

Jim Peron has an article in NZ Herald which is worth a read.

Jim makes the good point that NZ has a law which prevents people from referring to many criminal convictions if they are over seven years old. And yet Mr Peron, who has never been charged or convicted of anything as far as I know, is having allegations from over 20 years ago used against him.

I understand NZ First are boasting they have more “dirt”. Unless said “dirt” is evidence of a crime, then I can’t see its relevance. And if they do have such evidence they should be referring it to the authorities, not turning Parliament into the Spanish Inquisition!

Trans-gender law

I am fairly liberal on social issues, but I have to admit I am far far from convinced about Georgina Beyer’s bill which would prohibit discrimination on the grounds of gender identity.

Firstly I have doubts over the wisdom of any law which tries to legislate attitudes.

But the trans-gender issue is a difficult one. I have no problem accepting there are people like Georgina Beyer who genuinely feel they were born to the wrong gender. But also there are cross-dressers who just enjoy cross-dressing. And despite the best surgery now available, one can not change the fact of one’s physical gender assignment at birth (putting aside the rare cases of hermaphrodites and intersexuals), and I am unsure a law can compel people to ignore that fact. Obviously sometimes it is not apparent (I have met a couple of girls who you would never have known were born male) but sometimes it is very apparent, and an employer can have a real dilemma if for example their key sales manager decides to start dressing as a woman and taking hormone treatment, as it will affect customer relations.

The Government is postponing the bill, as it doesn’t want this issue to be an election one, and also reflecting it probably does not have the numbers to pass.

Hate Speech

The NZ Herald reports on the first day of a parliamentary select committee inquiry into possible legislation to ban “hate speech”.

The Government is backing off the idea with an overwhelming majority of submissions attacking the proposals as a threat to freedom of expression and the democratic process.

As NRT has said previously the best solution to hate speech is more speech, not less. Ridicule those who say hateful things, rather than try to remove their right to be heard.

TV coverage of Parliament

While it is an excellent thing that Parliament will supply TV feeds for all sessions of the House and select committees, it is silly to use that as a pretext to ban the media from having TV cameras in the House galleries.

I do support the ability of the House to still set some rules about coverage. Not so much to restrict coverage of MPs, but to not film any protesters in the gallery as to have no rules at all would encourage fringe groups to disrupt Parliament every few hours in the hope of being on TV. The broadcasters have been good about following the rules in place, so banning them is unjustifiable.

Good to see Dr Brash agreeing, and Gonzo gives a good summary of why the proposed ban is a bad thing.

I am less convinced of his call for 24/7 coverage of the Speaker’s Chair, let alone allowing Paris Hilton near it. Britney Spears maybe, but not Paris – we do have some standards down under 🙂

Quote of the Day 17 March 2005

“Criticising Israel is not anti-semitic but applying different standards to Israel is … the problem is I’ve never yet met an Israel hater who didn’t turn out to be a Jew hater — often subconsciously — in practice”

– Ordinary Kiwi on Struggle Street, in this thread, 17 March 2005.

New World Bank President

Since I attended a World Bank meeting last year on youth employment, I have followed news about the bank fairly closely.

There has been huge interest in who will be picked as the new World Bank President, and an excellent blog has been covering all the stories and possibilities. In fact several directors of the bank have said the blog is is “consistently much more up to date on the issue than they are sitting in Washington at bi-weekly board meetings.”

Incidentially Bush has just nominated Paul Wolfowitz as the World Bank President. Even for a Bush supporter like me, I have to say this is a somewhat bizarre choice as he is a highly controversial figure with no background in poverty relief and development.

Despite the demonsiation by the extreme left of the World Bank, it is actually very much a left leaning organisation, with mainly liberal staff. If Wolfowitz is confirmed I think there would be a huge exodus of staff. Perhaps that is the plan?

Dominion Post Editorial

The Dominion Post Editorial hits the button when it comes to National and ACT.

“It is perfectly reasonable for ACT to point out to National supporters that if they want tax cuts sooner rather than later, Kiwibank sold, less restrictive labour laws and welfare spending cut, they should consider voting for ACT.

But it makes no sense to personally attack the politicians they would have to work with in a centre-right government, bail out the prime minister or call attention to disharmony within National’s ranks.”

Fooling the People

Rodney Hide has an excellent article in the NZ Herald about Dr Cullen’s attempts to cover up the level of surplus.

I am sure Dr Cullen knows that not a single person with any background in accounting or economics really believes him, but he is banking on the fact that over half the population have no idea about the difference between accrual and cash accounting.

In the House yesterday we were reminded that Labour tried this trick in the 1980s when they claimed the proceeds from asset sales as income to claim the budget was balanced. National took office and found in fact a $5 billion deficit was projected and later passed the Fiscal Responsibility Act which was designed to ensure that this sort of shonky accounting could never happen again.

15 years later we have Dr Cullen doing exactly the same trick, but this time to cover up a surplus, not a deficit.

Sleeping Ministers

The footage shown on TV3 of Education Minister David Benson-Pope asleep during question time must be the visual impression of Labour’s handling of the education portfolio – asleep at the helm while $1.75 billion went out the door on uncompleted sub-degree courses.

In fact I can see a nice campaign ad in my head already:

Shot 1: Voice: Christchurch Polytech claimed $15 million to produce a CD, and what did the Government do?

Shot 2: Picture of Education Minister asleep in Parliament.

Shot 3: Voice: Eastern BoP Polytech claimed $4 million for radio sing-a-long courses, and what did the Government do?

Shot 4: Picture of Education Minister asleep in Parliament.

Shot 5: Voice: Funding for TWOA ballooned from $4 million to $239 million in five years under Labour, and what did Labour do to investigate?

Shot 6: Picture of Education Minister asleep in Parliament.

Shot 7: Voice: Wake up the Labour Party and elect a National Government that won’t sleep on the job, and will bring back standards into the education system.

Shot 8: Background images of National Leader and Education Spokesperson meeting teachers, students and parents.

A former National MP, Annabel Young, was photographed in 2000 yawning, and quite a few people were upset with the photographer for taking the photo as it was close to midnight during what had been an almost seven day debate under 15 hour a day urgency on the Employment Relations Bill. Who would not have a yawn. A world of difference to a Minister being asleep during the only hour of the day that most Ministers even sit in the House.

An Assistant Commissioner in court

It is a first for NZ, to have an Assistant Commissioner of Police charged with serious criminal offences.

It is good the court did not gave name supression to those charged, probably because everyone would have found out within hours anyway as it has been so publicised.

I suspect it would now be a bad thing for me to offer any views on outcomes in advance of the trial, so I will content myself to uninformed commentary on the Michael Jackson trial instead!

AUSA

Xavier has labelled the Vice-Chancellor of Auckland University a “fucktard”.

I would not have thought it was the most constructive thing for a member of the AUSA Executive to say about the Vice-Chancellor they lobby on student’s behalf, but he is entitled to his view.

How-ever what I find hard to comprehend is why some student politicans seem to always put the interests of their members behind their wider political loyalty.

Xavier is supporting a 30% pay increase for university staff. As a Labour supporter one is of course meant to always support anyone at all who wants a huge pay rise. Just as I guess I am always meant to support tax cuts.

But there is absolutely no way that a 30% increase in staff wages will not result in huge fee increases for the very students AUSA represents. Believing that the Government would increase tertiary funding by 30% (well the staff component of 30%) to pay for it, is like believing in Santa Claus.

Xavier takes pride in working with AUS on common goals. I sometimes wonder how common the goals are though. Xavier even supports his members having lectures disrupted by strikes, so that the university will be forced to agree to the 30% opay rise, and hence put up fees.

Quote of the Day

The IRA

I have never been a fan of the IRA (unlike a certain female half-Irish acquaintance who is even more unreasonable on this issue than most). In fact in my first year at university in 1986, I discovered the Otago University Students’ Association was funding an IRA support group and I wrote letters to the NZ SIS and Mrs Thatcher informing them of this. I still have the replies somewhere 🙂

Since September 11, much US support for the IRA has disappeared. And then many were shocked when it was revealed that the IRA had pulled off a huge bank robbery, as the only thing you need that much money for is arms.

The final straw for many is their killing of an IRA supporter, botched offer to execute the killers, and not veiled threats to the victim’s sisters to be “very careful” with their criticism.

When you have even Senator Edward Kennedy cancelling talks with Gerry Adams, citing “the IRA’s ongoing criminal activity and contempt for the rule of law” you know they are in trouble.

Frankly it’s about time too.

John Tamihere and the SFO

I am very glad for John Tamihere that the SFO has decided that “the evidence in relation to his involvement in the matters that I have investigated does not support the laying of charges”.

I never thought that he had personal involvement in the stolen $100,000. While some disagree, I think that Tamihere acts with good motivations, and I like him as a person.

However that is not to say he has been “cleared” and holds no responsibility for what happened. The man charged is a very good friend of his, his former electorate chair and was appointed by Tamihere as Chief Financial Officer. And Tamihere did authorise the payments.

I am on the board of two organisations which turn over a few million dollars, and in that role have to approve major invoices and sign cheques. I pretty much always question staff when there is a significant invoice (more than $1,000 or so) from a new supplier and ask what services were provided etc. This is a fundamental responsibility. And to sign off $100,000 of invoices on your final day in office to organisations you have never ever heard of is incredibly reckless. And this is effectively taxpayer money which was stolen.

Any claims by Helen Clark that John Tamihere has been vindicated is applying the minimum ethical standard, which is that he did not himself steal the money. But as CEO he has not been vindicated for his role in what happened, let alone the wider issue of taking a huge golden handshake when he had said publicly he would not.

Animal homeopathy a strategic priority

As further proof of the total failure of Labour’s tertiary education policy, we learn that tax-payer has been funding out of the strategic priorities fund courses such as art of health which includes:

“understanding the effect of colour on the human soul, metamorphosis and transition which will be explored through transition in colour and movement as well as through myth, poetry and fairy tales”.

Who needs doctors, scientists, mechanics, engineers etc when we can have this. And remember people Labour can not afford to give NZers even a single dollar of their tax back, because they are funding programmes like the “homeopathic needs of cats, dogs and budgies”.

Also remember as they try to blame officials for this, that Steve Maharey set up the Tertiary Education Commission and appointed the entire board. And that this has been going on for years.

Jackson trial all but over

It may be premature, but from the sound of this report, it will be almost impossible for Michael Jackson to be found guilty beyond reasonable doubt.

Personally I think Jackson is a bit of a freak, having never had a normal life. He doesn’t know proper boundaries with kids. But this family has smelt of scam for money all along, and I am surprised they prosecuted with such a weak case.

But still many more weeks of trial to keep us entertained.

Relationships Bill passes 76 to 44

Quote of the Day

800,000 standing up for freedom

This image is stolen from Powerline, showing an amazing 800,000 Lebanese pro-freedom demonstrators. An incredible sight. Huge.

lebanon.jpg

UPDATE: Wow according to the CIA, Lebanon has a population of under 4 million. To have a quarter of your population turn up is a huge show of strength.

The Tomatina Festival

Wellington Central

The Dominion Post has a good wee article on Wellington Central, and the sensible attitude being taken by Stephen Franks and ACT.

Nice to also see candidates being positive about each other.

Mark’s campaign launch is later this month, and I’ll post details for those keen to come along – it’s going to be great fun.