Free speech, except in West Auckland

Bob Harvey is the Mayor of Waitakere, and a former Labour Party President. He supports the Waitakere Ranges Heritage Bill, while critics say it attacks private property rights.

The bill critics organised a meeting at a local school hall. Mayor Harvey wrote to his colleague Trevor Mallard to try and get the Minister to ban the meeting from the school.

Nice to know there is such a high regard for free speech from Mayor Harvey.

Israel Stand-off

The situation with Israel is starting to get ridicolous, with the Government even blocking a visit by an Israeli military office to attend a fund-raiser for a Jewish charity.

Israel was quite wrong to try and have Mossad obtain fake NZ passports. And the Government was justified to ask for an apology and freeze visits at a Ministerial level. But to block a visit for a Jewish charity is getting over the top.

As pointed out in the article, the Government happily aloows visits from countries whose aim is to destroy Israel, and who regularly undertake state sponsored terrorism.

ACT and Banks

John Banks was a star of the ACT Conference at the weekend, but also made them somewhat nervous and annoyed about his style.

There are some pretty significant pros and cons of having Banks stand for ACT. Off the top of my heard, they are:

Pros
* May significantly increase party vote in Auckland
* Would generate publicity for ACT
* Possibly could win a seat (Very doubtful in my opinion, and I give no credence to talks of internal polls where they will not reveal the company name, questions asked, methodology and results)
* At 2% one tries anything, as you can only go up
* Banks is more fondly thought of, since Hucker became Mayor

Cons
* Banks is not a liberal, and ACT do brand as the liberal party
* Banks is not really a team player, unless he leads the team
* There may be a backlash if Ken Shirley is pushed aside from Tamaki
* Giving Banks a winnable list place would almost certainly be at the expense of a current MP
* Refuses to deny he would like to be leader
* Banks may put off more voters than he attracts

Overall I think Banks as a candidate would help ACT increase their chances this election, but I think they would find after the election that they would have some significant management problems with Caucus, and they may find their long-term liberal brand permanently damaged.

John Armstrong as usual has some good comments.

OIA requests

NZ Herald Editorial

One can’t word it better than the actual editorial which says:

Not for the first time in his long career under parliamentary protection Winston Peters has used his privilege in a way that must be of concern to anyone with a sense of fairness and decency.

Doctor Dress Code

Top Ten Reasons the Israeli Army Discriminates Against D&D Players

Taken from Ace of Spades especially for the Wednesday Nighters 🙂

10. Simply cannot satisfy frequent requests that standard IDF uniform be redesigned to include pockets for “material components”

9. Too many fighters add levels in the “Dorkwad” prestige class, reducing their combat effectiveness

8. Still reeling from the tragedy of D&D playin’ soldiers who advanced on a terrorist position “protected” by a Prismatic Wall
Continue reading »

Jim Peron in his own words

Speeding

Despite what some may think I am not against the Police using speed cameras, and having Police ticket people for speeding.

But up until Hawkins became Minister, enforcement was targeted towards the worst offenders. So for example if you catch someone doing 110 km/hr on the Rimutaka Hill Road you book them, while if they are doing 113 km/hr on the Foxton Straits, you might not take action if it is a fine day. Likewise speed cameras used to be set to target the top 15% of speeds at that location, rather than all cars above the tolerance.

The fact is that the safe limit in a situation depends on the nature of the road, the weather, the car, the driver, condition of the road, are there side roads, how far ahead can you see etc. Now the law could never cope with a different speed limit for every road, which varies in sun or rain so we have a law which sets some general limits. But sensible enforcement (as we had for most of 80s and 90s) would recognise that most drivers do change their speed to the conditions. Hell, on many trips you are changing your speed every 30 seconds to take account of the conditions.

Now the Police in the 1990s did a very good job of targeting the worst offenders, and the road toll drop showed this. Much of the drop is also due to safer cars etc. But what has happened since 1999.

The NZ Herald shows in 1999 that only 2% of tickets were issued to people driving 1 to 5 kms above the tolerance limit or 11 to 15 km/hr over the posted limit. In 2004 this now makes up 41% of tickets!!! An increase from 2,312 to 161,919.

Now as I said I have little problem with ticketing people driving at 63 km/hr in a busy suburban street, but I would if it is someone just keeping up with traffic flows on Aotea Quay at the same speed. Likewise 113 km/hr on some open roads is unsafe, but there are many many roads where it is very safe.

The Hawkins policy of removing all discretion from the Police does little for road safety, a lot for revenue, but most of all has been responsible for a huge upsurge in antipathy towards the Police, and that is a pity as the vast majority do a very fine job.

Yay

TV Rantings

As many of my friends know, I love The Apprentice and can’t get enough of it. Comments about reality TV rotting the brain are not needed, as I have plenty to rot thank you 🙂

Someone just showed me an episode of the The UK Apprentice. It is the exact same format as the main The Apprentice. I thought I would also love or at least like it, but I detest it. It is awful. The only difference is that Donald Trump plus his assistants George and Carolyn have been replaced by Sir Alan Sugar and a couple of flunkies whose names I can’t even recall.

But that difference in casting is everything. It changes it from an addictive show, to a nauseating one. I am surprised by how little the format matters, as oppossed to casting. Trump just has presence and charisma which makes the show.

While on the TV front, I should pose a public health warning regarding the 1st episode of the 9th series of Southpark. Now I love Southpark and have almost every episode ever made. But this episode had even me grossed out, and turning away from the screen. The theme is Mr Garrison having a sex change, and you really don’t want to know what they did with the left over parts. It was still very very funny, but not one for the faint hearted.

The ever growing surplus

The surplus is getting so large that Cullen has ordered the Treasury to stop mentioning it in their monthly PRs, and they have tried it hide it in the crown financial accounts by sliding it down the page.

For seven months it is now at $5.3 billion. If linear (and it won’t be), then the surplus for the year could be as high as $9.1 billion. That is a surplus of over $6,000 per family, over $100 a week in over taxation. Take away the contribution to the Super Fund and one still has over $4,500 per family of over taxing.

Labour refuse to say at what level of surplus they would lower taxes. They said $3 billion is not enough, $4 billion is not enough, $5 billion is not enough. They won’t even come out and say okay at $10 billion, then we could afford to lower taxes. It’s like an alcoholic trying to have just one last drink.

The budget this year will almost be obscene with spending promises in a desperate attempt to lower the surplus. The spending of course will sound noble and good, but much of it will be very low quality such as we have seen in the tertiary sector.

A good article on Stuff also.

Coming Home

Overseas Aid

One of the changes under Labour were to make the aid division of MFAT semi-independent so that aid programmes would not be used to advance foreign policy.

MPs are reported today as being concerned the two are still linked.

I will play devil’s advocate and say why should they not be linked. Lets be honest our $240 million can not solve 1% of the world’s poverty so why not spend it where it can be of most advantage. I mean Howard’s masterful $1 billion tsunami package was as much about foreign policy as aid.

I also get nervous when I see a Labour MP saying “New Zealand Aid needed to work on building support for trebling aid to the international target of 0.7 per cent of gross national income”.

No they should not. NZ Aid is a Government Department/Agency. It is not their job to get involved in what is a very political decision – our level of total aid. It is like saying the job of the Ministry of Education is to build support for spending more on education.

Happy International Women’s Day

Fidel Castro has given 100,000 rice cookers to Cuban women, to mark International Women’s Day.

Hmmn I now have the inspiration for the perfect birthday present for Miss Ten 🙂

I was shocked to see Cuba has an average salary of only $12 a month. Mr Robson must have forgotten to mention this when he was singing their praises with his last visit.

Two Jim Peron Interviews

Jim Peron has given two in depth interviews dealing to the Peters allegations. One is at Gaynz.com and the other longer one at Scoop.

I am not the most neutral commentator when it comes to Peters, but my impression is that this has backfired fairly badly.

The media, almost to a person, are appalled, and they have been reminded that there is a very dark and nasty side to Peters. In recent times he has been portrayed as fun, a bit of a dag etc.

The link to Rodney is so flimsy, even if Peron had broken any laws which he has not, that it makes it look like what it is – a willingness to destroy someone’s life just to take a shot at Rodney. And I think Rodney has gained a lot of kudos for not distancing himself from Jim, but going in to bat for him.

I think this really does qualify as a new low point in politics. If I had to say something nice about Peters this week, the best I could come up with is “Makes McCarthy look good by comparison”.

Police discriminate against men

The Police have said they may prosecute organisers of the Boobs on Bikes ride around Palmerston North’s Square.

Now I have no particular position on said bike rally, but what floored me was the Police statement which said:

“… offensiveness is determined by various factors, including the number of women and children who see and object to it.”

So if men are offended by it, they do not count? Wow offensiveness is now determined only by women and children.

Need help for a 21st, ask Jim!

That nice Jim Anderrton has been helping an English family, including arranging for their daughter to come to NZ to hold her 21st birthday here.

The couple were judged bankrupt last week, and owe around $9 million.

This is why I have such doubts about all these business assistance programmes. The Government does not have a great track record of picking winners. Hope it was a good 21st though.

Coasting under NCEA

If anyone thinks the only problem with NCEA is the Level 4, they should read this article.

The good news according to David Benson-Pope is it is only the students in the middle who are affected. Oh that is nice – only 80 – 90% are affected and the top and bottom 10% are fine.

ACT Candidates

The NZ Political Process

1) DPF has idea. Link the silly 5% in 05 pay claim from the unions to the fact that many families will have a 90% effective tax and abatement rate under Labour’s policies.

2) DPF blogs on Tuesday morning how a 5% pay rise for someone on $50,000 may bring in only $5.30/week extra if they have a couple of children etc.

3) National Finance Spokesperson in House that afternoon asks Question 10 on that exact issue. Mallard looks confused.

4) Finance Spokesperson also puts out press release on issue.

5) The Dominion Post and the NZ Herald both run articles on the issue.

6) In House on Wednesday National Leader asks Question 2 on issue. PM confirms that it is correct that someone with two kids on $50,000 who gets a 5% pay rise will only keep 10% of it (if sole income and gets accom supplement), and the Government will pocket the other 90%.

7) DPF sends invoice for services rendered to the Global HQ of the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy, and also to the CIA.

8) DPF is even more smug than normal, and notes he has started to refer to himself in the third person, a trait previously most identified with Helen Clark. This worries DPF.

IRA has novel way of saying sorry

The IRA has become somewhat unpopular amaongst even its own supporters over the involvement of its members in killing Catholic Robert McCartney after a bar brawl.

To show how sorry they are, the IRA has offered to execute up to four of its members who were involved in the killing.

I suspect membership is about to start dropping rapidly in the IRA. This is not a bad thing of course.

Silly Student Debt Comparisons

An article in The Press on student debt has some of the silliest comparisons I have seen.

First of all it proclaims that 13.2% of NZers now hold loans compared to 1992, the first year of the scheme, when it was 1.6%. Well hello!!! Of course there will be far more people with loans after ten years of operation, tha after just one year. It would be impossible for there not to be.

Then it also proclaims that in 1992 the average debt was $3,628 and now it is $14,424. Hmmn so a debt reflecting multiple years of borrowing is greater than a debt of just one year of borrowing. Quick alert the Nobel Prize Committee for Mathemathics.

We deserve better analysis than this.

Jim Peron

I was watching Parliament during Q time yesterday and was horrified to see Winston Peters once again do his old trick of making outraegous allegations against someone, to help further his political career.

Peters has a long history of making allegations under parliamentary privilege, and being totally unable to back them up with evidence. He has destroyed many a person’s reputation this way. In this case he really was just doing it to try and have a go at Rodney Hide who has blogged that Jim is only being attacked because he is gay and a friend of Rodney’s.

Jim is the Executive Director of the Institute of Liberal Values and owner of Aristotle’s Bookshop. I’ve met Jim (and his partner) through ILV, and they have my sympathy for having to endure this.

Peters said he would front up to defend his claims on TV, but as is usual for him refused to do so and the facts which are coming out show he has done his normal trick of gross exagerration, with an example being he has labelled Aristotle’s a pornography shop on the basis that 2% of its stock might be adult material. Using that as a precedent, Peters has just turned every dairy owner in NZ into “pornography traders”.

Media coverage on Stuff, TVNZ and the NZ Herald.

Relationships Bill Vote Details

Tim Barnett’s ofifce kindly sent me the Hansard for the vote, and I have calculated that the votes in favour and against by party are:

ACT 4 – 5
Green 9 – 0
Labour 50 – 1
Maori 0 – 1
National 8 – 18 (1 no vote)
NZ First 0 – 13
Progressive 2 – 0
United Future 1 – 7

Total 74 – 45 (1 no vote)

The ACT MPs in favour were Hide, Coddington, Roy and Shirley.
The sole Labour MP against was Taito Field.
The eight National MPs in favour were Key, Mapp, McCully, Rich, Simich, Sowry, Williamson and Wong with L Smith not voting.
The sole United Future vote in favour was Peter Dunne.

I suspect the third reading will be closer, but still a very healthy margin.