Well done Ashrah Choudary

One of my criticisms of Islam, has been the near silence from moderate ledaers when extreme statements are made in the name of Islam.

Muslim MP Ashraf Choudary has added some sanity to the debate about the young woman who has claimed she would rather die than remove her veil.

Choudhary has said the Koran calls for Muslim men and women to dress modestly, but face-covering was more cultural than religious.

Mr Choudary has also said that it is desirable to integrate into local society, become part of local customs, and that New Zealand is not a country for extremists or extremist views.

Thank you Ashraf for the bout of sanity.

Howard wins the Senate

It was confirmed today that the Coalition has won 39 out of 76 seats in the Australian Senate, so from 1 July 2005 (when Senators take office) they will be able to pass laws without support from third parties.

Labor has 28 seats, Greens 4, Democrats 2 and Family First 1.

No doubt Goerge W is hoping for a result just as good.

A little babbage

With permission from Megan, I’m pleased to publish photos of a very cute Finlay Campbell Babbage, weighing all of 3.1 kgs!

Finlay’s great great etc grand father is Charles Babbage who came up with the idea of programmable computers in 1812!

Photos follow.
Continue reading »

Washington Post Blogs

Save the Possums Darling!

I pissed myself laughing when I saw on TV that people in Australia had been protesting against the use of fur at a fashion parade, and the fur was possum fur.

The protesters probably think they are greenies, not realising that possums are an official noxious pest, not some endangered species such as tigers.

A recent media report said that possums eat 20 tonnes of vegetation every night. In fact the correct stat is they eat 20,000 tonnes a night and are one of our biggest conservation threats. If we can make money from killing the little buggers, then all the better.

I see the Auckland Animal Action Group justify their opposition to use of possum fur, because “to wear a dead animal’s skin is disrespectful to the animal”. Well killing our trees is disrespectful also, and the possums started it!

Using dead people

I’m convinced

The Awatere-Huata depositions hearing continues. I’ve heard enough to say bring on the proper trial!!

It was interesting to read that Wi Huata had to be restrained by lawyers after repeated outbursts. When Donna was an ACT MP, many ACT people were very scared of Wi, as he did have a tendency to get physical with people who had upset him. Not a nice man.

BBC on Foreshore

Hitwise Rankings

Alan M kindly e-mailed me the Hittwise newsletter for October as I got a mention. It seems for the last two weeks this blog has been the second most popular local political website. The ACT website was in third place and Greens in first place. I am surprised a blog would be beating official party sites. Does anyone have the full top ten?

“New Zealanders are also turning to the Internet for local political news, views and updates. The most popular local political website this week is the Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand’s site (www.greens.org.nz), rising from 3rd the previous week, and from 5th position in the last week of September. The site is the 445th most popular New Zealand website, a notable increase from 633rd in the last week of September, while in recent daily statistics it rose to 386th on October 11. When compared against political sites from around the world, the Green Party’s website ranks 5th, a reflection of New Zealand’s interest in international politics.

Occupying the 2nd position locally for the second week running, is David Farrar (www.kiwiblog.co.nz), another political blog offering frequently updated news, views and links of a political nature; while in third position is the website of Act New Zealand (www.act.org.nz), falling from the number one spot it held the previous two weeks.

With important political events on the horizon, the Internet is proving a viable place for individuals, and also political parties and organisations to express ideas and share information. Internet users are increasingly turning to the web for information about politics and current events, and are also using it as a platform to express their own views.”

Tamihere vs Richwhite

You know you are in trouble when the best defence your colleagues can come out with is basically “John may be a criminal, but he isn’t as big a criminal as these ones!”.

Mahara Okeroa says that David Richwhite is getting off lightly compared to Tamihere. Well Richwhite has been charged and faces fines running to the tens of millions of dollars. Is Okeroa saying Tamihere should be charged also?

Okeroa also pushes the ridiculous claim that the $320,000 golden handshake was koha, saying that his ancestors once koh’aed a lake and mountains. But did they pay tax on the mountain?

If this is the best defence Labour can think up, it is rather sad.

The veil or death

The NZ Herald reports how a Muslim woman has told a court “she would rather kill herself than give evidence without wearing a veil.”

This does little to reassure me that Islam is not a religion that attracts extremism and has less regard for sanctity of life than is healthy. To value not showing your face over life??

I mean it is fine to be devout, but lets look at how we would react if say a devout Catholic proclaimed that if they were forced to miss Holy Communion, they would rather kill themselves?

Or a devout Jew proclaimed that if there is an earthquake on a Saturday he would rather stay inside and die than turn the lights on to find his way out.

Or a devout Buddhist said that if they accidentially ingested meat they would cut their stomach out rather than digest it?

I mean really we would think they are nuts, wouldn’t we?

Not enough journalists shot in NZ

Reporters Without Borders has ranked New Zealand as the ninth best country in the world in terms of media freedom.

Surely they have overlooked Helen’s threats to stop leaking information to journalists who write bad things about her?? I mean sure there haven’t been any reporters killed lately, but come on one knows that if the Government could make Duncan Garner disappear, they would do it.

Australia is 41st and North Korea is 167th. By the time Howard finishes his 5th term no doubt they will have swapped places 🙂

Cuba is 2nd worse in 166th place. We should all rest thankful Jim Anderton never stayed in Labour, or that could be us!

Justice Scalia on Originalism

I attended the speech and coffee at the US Embassy by Justice Antonin Scalia. The room was packed with legal and political people such as Sir Geoffrey Palmer.

Justice Scalia is a brilliant speaker. He made his case for Originalism with great humour, but very strong cogent arguments.

Scalia made a very strong case that Judges should interpret the Constitution as it was intended when it was written, and that if one wants laws to reflect society’s changing morals, then why have five lawyers decide what they are, instead of legislatures or the public.

An example he gave was whether the death penalty is unconstitutional as some argue it is a cruel and unusual punishment banned under the US constitution. Scalia pointed out that when passed, not only was the death penalty applied in every state, it was basically the only penalty. Steal a horse – you hang. They did not have prisons, just jails to hold you before you were hung. So how can you argue that they intended the constitution to outlaw the death penalty?

Scalia made the point that he does not see the court as one which splits on conservative vs liberal lines, pointing out that as an originalist he has voted for example to allow flag burning, when personally he would have liked to have sent the scruffy long haired lout in the case to jail, but he could not do so.

Again Scalia made the point that everytime the Supreme Court invents a right, such as to abortion, or to assisted suicide etc, it removes that issue from the people through their state of federal legislatures. He said today the XIXth amendment giving women the vote would never be passed, as the Supreme Court would probably have ruled without the amendment that there was a constitutional right for women to vote. His point being isn’t it better women got the vote through a constitutional amendment, not the Supreme Court of a few lawyers.

One silly person asked him if he would back Originalism, if say the US had not passed the XIXth amendment. Scalia pointed out that the fact they did, shows Originalism did work (up until around WWII), but also pointed out that even if the XIXth amendment had never been passed, he would guarantee that every state would have given women the vote by now anyway.

Scalia agreed that one can point to good outcomes from a non-originalist Supreme Court, but that one can have good outcomes from a benevolent dictator also. But why should the Supreme Court decide on behalf of all of America what is moral or acceptable?

There was one question on Bush vs Gore, which the Justice was fairly aggressive about, telling the questioner he should get over it. He did make the point that the Supreme Court vote on the main issue was 7-2, not 5-4. And that the Florida Supreme Court had made such a hash of it, he felt it had breached the constitutional requirement that the state legislatures, not the courts, shall determine how electoral college electors are selected.

On the issue of whether the Supreme Court should have heard the case, he almost dripped sarcasm as he asked could anyone argue the election of the President it not important enough, and did anyone think that letting the Florida Supreme Court decide, was somehow a better course of action?

I wanted to ask him about whether he saw anyway to get the lower courts out of the election process, with the Kerry and Bush campaigns in the US having hired 40,000 lawyers for election day to run off to court in marginal counties and states to try and tilt things their way, but decided not to as he seemed not too keen on election issues.

Sir Geoffrey asked a silly question also on whether he was concerned that NZ didn’t not only have no separation between executive and legislature, but also no separation between judiciary in that they can not over-rule the legislature. Scalia sensible swatted it away by saying he is not here to tell other countries how they should run their legal systems.

Justice Scalia is known for not liking video and/or audio recordings of his speeches. Towards the end he got somewhat agitated to see a video camera at the back of the hall, but was reassured it was just a link to the overflow room.

Overall I was hugely impressed. A great opportunity to meet the man who might be the next Chief Justice of the United States. The bit I enjoyed the most was when he referred to the other originalist on the court, Clarence Thomas, as “Brother Thomas and I”. Very funny.

Diebold Voting Machine

Civil Unions vs Gay Marriage

David W Young has blogged his opposition to the Civil Union Bill on the basis he wants gay marriage and adoption rights, and thinks passing of the CUB will make achieving gay marriage harder.

Now David’s a fag, and I’m not (well last time I checked anyway) so I should listen to what he says, and see whether there is any hope for misguided social liberals like Russell Brown and myself.

David Young has asked “Will either of them join a fight for full marriage rights? And for that matter, do either of them plan to actually ‘register’ their relationships as civil unions?”

Will if I tried to classify any of my current umm temporary or long distance alliances as civil unions I’d be found guilty under the fair trading act. But when I do meet that gullible blind blond lawyer, yes I’d like to marry her.

But to answer the question, no I won’t have a problem if gay couples can marry also. I’d be quite happy to vote for that. In my ideal world, the state would not marry people at all. The state would recognise registered partnerships, and I would actually give the churches intellectual property rights to the term marriage so some couples can choose to have their partnership called a marriage by getting an appropriate church to marry them. But no legal difference would result from this. So I might have an Anglican marriage and David W Young could get a marriage in a church which supports gay marriages.

I do have some issues around gay adoption. But that is a debate for another day.

David takes the view that civil unions will make it harder to get gay marriage. That view is shared by other gay friends such as Other Pundit and Shadowfoot. It’s a legitimate view, albeit it one I do not agree with. I also note the Colmar Brunton poll found a majority in favour of civil unions, but against gay marriage.

I think that trying to jump the whole way to gay marriage is one step, is unlikely to succeed. As a comparison could one have imagined that if Fran Wilde in 1985 had not only tried to decriminalise homosexual acts, but also tried to ban discrimination, that it would have passed. I suspect it would have been heavily defeated and off the agenda for a decade or so.

Now what did happen is that after homosexual acts were legalised in 1985, the world did not end as many predicted. Tens of thousands of people came out of the closet and almost all NZers ended up working with an openly gay colleague or having a gay friend. And so when in 1993 it was proposed one should not discriminate against someone just because they were gay, it passed with almost no opposition.

I predict the same with civil unions and gay marriage. If civil unions do pass, then society will get used to having legal gay couples, once again the world and western civilisation will not end, and in seven to ten years when someone proposes hey why not allow gay marriages also, it will be quite unexceptional.

Quotes from the National Front

Kyle Chapman is quoted on Stormfront as saying “Just to show how much we are affected by this event, we will increase our numbers of Demos. We will attend more of theirs and we will be at more of their gigs etc.”

Backs up my view that those who started violence against the NF have done nothing except encourage them.

But having had a suggestion to read the National Front bulletin board, boy does it remind me that they really are a vile bunch. Apologies for the following quotes which may get be banned on a few filters, but it is useful to remind people of what idiotic thugs most of the National Front are:

“i feel sick!!! everytime i see a fag ,transsexual or pervert!!! new zealand government must form a law that will terminate gay.”

“Where have the TRUE KIWI’S gone? Its all fricken Asian’s cross breeds… What are we coming to?”

“Hitler transformed his country from the poorest nation in Europe to the strongest nation in a little under 9 years of National Socialist rule. Now it’s little more than a shadow of it’s former glory.”

“Hail to everyone who is opposed to the Civil Union Bill and who thinks gays are an abomination.”

“ill be there for sure, anything for the future of my white children, and my fellow whites”

“gays should be put on a island so they can all f*ck thems selfs to death and get aids. problem sovled”

I really don’t know whether to laugh or cry at such stupidity. Maybe both.

Vint Cerf interview

Donna in court

The trial of Donna Awatere-Huata began today in the Auckland District Court. The SFO has said that “Awatere Huata and her husband Wi Huata used funds from the Government-funded Pipi Foundation to pay for Awatere Huata’s stomach stabling operation and school fees for their children” and also “pocketed the cash from cheques made out to the Pipi Foundation account”.

With the Supreme Court also due to rule soon on the attempt by ACT to dismiss her as an MP, one wonders under what section of the Electoral Act will she be thrown out?

Will it be:

a) Section 55(1), Paragraph (d)
b) Section 55A(3), Paragraph (b)
c) Section 54(2), Paragraph (b)

Five guilty on Pitcairn

Just in is that five of the seven men charged with sex crimes on Pitcairn Island have been found guilty. The count is:

Steve Christian: guilty of five counts of rape
Randy Christian: guilty of four rapes and four indecent assaults.
Len Brown: guilty of two rapes
Dave Brown: guilty of nine indecent assaults.
Dennis Christian earlier pleaded guilty to three indecent assaults

Jay Warren was found not guilty on all charges.

Gordon McLauchlan will not be happy!

I was about to beat up the NZ media for the fact that it was being reported in Australia first, but I see the NZ Herald now has a story up. The NZ Herald tends to update more often than Stuff during the day.

Wrights Hill Fortress

For many years the Wrights Hill Fortress was one of the best kept treasures of Wellington. Judging by the number of people I know whom I ran into up there today, it is now more well known.

They only open to the public five times a year, which works really well. Most years I will govisit at least once, normally to show someone around who ha snot seen it before. I especially enjoy the irony that the big gun cannon that was installed there, was sold in 1960 to Japan 🙂

A few photos of the various views from Wrights Hill are below.
Continue reading »

Spirituality and the RMA

The Principal Environment Court Judge has lauded the RMA as ideal. No wonder we have such problems, when one of the most resented pieces of legislation is seen as without flaw by the main Judge who interprets it.

Judge Whiting defends the Environment Court’s recent time limit on the diversion of Whanganui River headwaters for electricity saying “that to Maori groups, severing the headwaters of their rivers is a sacrilege” and “that Maori have always believed the spiritual realm interacts with the physical, seeing natural resources as part of themselves.”

I believe spiritual beliefs should not be a basis for legal rights. I don’t care if they are Catholic, Buddhist or Gaia. I will respect people’s beliefs, but I object to those beliefs having the force of law behind them.

And lets be honest how many Maori honestly honestly believe that taking water from a river upsets the spirits?

The 2001 Census showed us that Maori religious affiliations are falling rapidly – from 79% in 1991 to 68% in 2001, and taking into acocunt those who objected we have only 335,000 out of 525,000 (63%) Maori stating a religion.

Now the largest is Anglican with 75,000 and Catholic on 68,000. Neither of these religions say that you piss the Gods off if you take water from a river. Ratana has 45,000 and they might believe that, but they represent less than 10% of Maori.

US Domination now complete

Stop digging John

John Tamihere should consider the old proverb that one should stop digging when you are already in a hole.

The claim that the $320,000 golden handshake was “koha” and he felt obliged to take it in case he was deemed cultually unsensitive, runs a real risk of drying up remaining public sympathy for him. It is just trying to be too cute by half.

It would be interesting to know what the Trust income for 1999 or 2000 was, to see how big a percentage $320,000 is. If the normal CEO salary was $90,000 it is equal to 3.5 years of salary.

Good old Gilbert & Sullivan

Friday Night was spent at the State Opera House enjoying a couple of good Gilbert and Sullivan operattes and then dinner at the Curry Club afterwards.

I only got into Gilbert and Sillivan a few years ago, when a friend was singing in Mikado. This was my 4th G&S and I am determined to see them all.

Trial by Jury was very short – only 45 minutes. The chorus singing was not always spot on, but Celia Falchi played the role of Plaintiff Angelina very well, and Chris Whelan was well cast as the towering Judge who ends up marrying the Plaintiff.

The Sorcerer was much longer, but was so funny the time flew by. Kimberly Smith was quite stunning as Aline – her singing was excellent. Lloyd Scott was up to his usual high standards as Wellington Wells, the Sorcerer. I enjoyed the plot of the Sorcerer with a bit of a moral about what goes wrong when people try to interfere in relationships!

Overall a very worthwhile night out, finishing at 9 p.m. which was a good time to pop into the Curry Club for dinner. They do not take bookings so it is always a good choice for a Friday night. The $25 banquet saw us all full up.

Not Happy

Got up this morning to find around 50 blog spams had appeared overnight. Even worse each one was from a different IP address, so I could not remove them in one go, but had to remove each of them manually. This was not a quick job, and put me in a fairly foul mood having to spend a fair bit of the morning hitting delete keys.