A fallen idol

People may have seen the NZ Herald story on Tuesday, about the song by NZ Idol runner-up Michael Murphy, being a cover, not an original.

Murphy’s manager, Paul Ellis, seems to believe in shooting the messenger and described the person Robyn who discovered the other song as “a person who commits fraud everyday by downloading songs” and further “This guy Robyn obviously went to Kazaa or LimeWire purposely to download the song”.

As it happens I have met (once) the Robyn in question, who is Robyn Gallagher of Secret Passage fame (her blog is one of the very first I started reading years ago).

Now one can not be 100% sure about anything nowadays with the famous Georginas and Miriams out there, but I am almost definite that Robyn is female, not male.

Robyn on the NZ Idol blog points out in a letter to the NZ Herald (which refuses to publish it) that she does not and did not do illegal music downloads, and the song was available free of charge from the band’s website.

So it appears that Paul Ellis owes Robyn a rather big apology. He shot from the hip, he was wrong, and the longer he leaves it the less credibility he has.

Rachel, who created the popular idolblog site, has a summary of the story posted on her personal blog.

Peters named and suspended

On the motion of the Speaker, the House named and suspended Winston Peters today. The vote was 115 – 13 in favour with only NZ First against.

I think Hunt called this one correctly. In fact if anything he should have done it earlier. Peters is notorious for making numerous points of order which wouldn’t know a standing order if it got run over by one. He just uses them to relitigate his original questions.

Now all MPs do this to some degree, but Peters is by at least a magnitude the worst offender. And Hunt has often been reluctant to crack down, because he knows Peters will attack him personally if he does. And true to form Peters threatened to move a no confidence motion in Hunt, if he was named.

Both question times so far this week have gone for almost two hours, instead of the scheduled 60 minutes due to mainly Peters. And considering Helen called a snap election in 2002 on the basis of an average seven minutes a day being wasted on points of order, this might have given her an opportunity to try that same trick again!

The suspension only lasts 24 hours if it is the first naming for this session, which I think it is. The second time is for seven days and the third time on is for 28 days. During the suspension the MP not only can not enter the House, but can not vote, serve on a committee or lodge questions.

UPDATE: Having done further research, I have ascertained that Peters is suspended for the entire week, as it is his second naming this session.

A big whoops

Dr Cullen did a rather big whoops in the House today. He was explaining that the reason the Reserve Bank put up interest rates today was due to strong economic growth.

The only problem is that the announcement from the Reserve Bank is due tomorrow, so Dr Cullen just leaked one of the most commercially sensitive (even if widely predicted) pieces of information he has access to.

I’m sure the money markets will thank him for the insider trading tip-off 🙂

Elect NZ Herald as Mayor

The NZ Herald appears to be so partisan in the Auckland Mayoralty campaign, it might as well stand for Mayor itself.

A while ago it announced it would niot publish any photos of John Banks doing Mayoral duties as this would disadvantage his opponents. Well I look forward to them writing to Helen Clark to inform her that for the 90 days before the next election, they will refuse to publish any photos of her, as it will disadvantage Don Brash.

Now they have published an article whose oinly point is to discredit the Mayor by arguing over whether all the achievements he claims, were due to him.

Now I have no problem at all with claims by candidates being scrutinised by the media. I wish they would do it more often, as it would mean less work for bloggers who often have to do it for them.

But I wonder if we will see this level fo rebutal and scrutiny applied to all candidates. Will there be an expose of who actually does what with Hubbard Foods? Will all of Helen Clark’s statements in the election get a dedicated article analysing any claimed achievements?

Submitting against your Government

There is a first time for everything I suppose, and now we have a Government MP making a submission to a select committee aginst her own Government. I can not recall this ever happeneing before, and I have followed politics since I was eight years old (after watching Muldoon win in 1975).

It is nothing too unusual to just vote against your party on an issue – happens quite often when National is in Government. Less so with Labour, as it is warrants expulsion if you do it without permission.

But to not just vote against the bill, but to actively lobby against it, is almost unheard of. And to make a formal submission to a select committee which effectively says the Government is racist and a thief is literally unheard of.

Helen Clark may claim “I don’t have any problems with it.” but does anyone think that Damien O’Connor wouldn’t be expelled from Labour if he had made a submission to a select committee against the Government’s forestry policies?

The legislation’s progress will be very interesting. It is effectively a confidence issue, and if Labour can not pass it, they will have to call an immediate election. But if they do pass it, most or all of the Maori seats will fall to the Maori Party.

Helen blames Jim

Oh it was priceless listening to the House yesterday as Rodney Hide asked Helen Clark if she still stood by her Govt’s claims that Sovereign Yachts sweetheart deal for former defence land was a “dream come true” for the “jobs machine”.

As most will know, there is mroe chance of Saddam Hussein being found not guility than there is if Soverign Yachts creating 350 jobs.

So Helen declared that the quotes “are not from me. That is the language of the Minister for Economic Development”. Hilarious as she shafts Anderton.

As expected Rodney has already posted the transcripts and his comments on his blog.

Compulsory insurance

I was rather disappointed, but not surprised, to see the Insurance Council suggest that the solution to home owners not insuring their properties, is to make such insurance compulsory through rates.

If people choose not to insure their properties, then that is their decision (as are the consequences).

As the sensible President of LGNZ said: “If I was in the insurance industry and one-third of the population wasn’t insured, I’d look very closely at the products and packages,”

Compulsory insurance will remove all incentives for the insurance industry to be competitive.

Moore vs Bush

Peter Ellis wins vs RNZ

Peter Ellis had won with a complaint to the BSA in regards to allegations RNZ aired.

The BSA ruled that RNZ seriously breached standards of fairness and balance in broadcasting anonymous allegations of very serious criminal but unspecified offending in such a way they would have been impossible to defend. The allegations were not substantiated nor critically examined.

The Ellis case will, in years to come, be regarded as an injjustice on the same scale as Arthu Allan Thomas. Phill Goff has refused to have a full royal commission into this case. One of the unintended but beneficial side effects of a National victory next year, is that it is likely there will finally be a full investigation into the Ellis case, and associated issues.

Nigel’s back

My Labour reshuffle

The Dominion Post has an article on the possible details of Labour’s year end reshuffle.

Basically they are tipping Hawkins being a goneburger, Mallard to drop education, King retain health, Burton becomes Speaker, and possible promotions for O’Connor, Chadwick and Fairbrother.

At this rate, Moana Mackey will be the only Labour MP not to have an appointment of some sort!

If Labour wanted to be bold, they would cut the deadwood. Here’s my list of what a smart PM would do:

Maharey – Education (parents do not like Mallard)
King – make Speaker
Hodgson – Health (he was a vet, so that’s a start)
Mallard – Welfare (Maharey never looks credible when trying to talk tough)
Hawkins – dump (for obvious reasons)
Parekura – move sideways, perhaps Associate Foreign Affairs where incomprehensible statements are normal.
Tamihere – Maori Affairs
Burton – move sideways, perhaps Hodgson’s old portfolios
Barker – dump (not a performer)
Tizard – dump (does nothing but social functions)
Samuels – dump (only there as a make up for being dumped the 1st time)
Duynhoven – dump (listens to LTSA)
Field – dump (has no full portfolios)
Robertson – make Minister of Health (yes I am joking)
Barnett – promote
Cosgrove – poison
Chadwick – promote

It will be interesting when Hunt gets appointed High Commissioner. He may have one of the shortest terms ever.

Hysteria

No Right Turn has rather hysterically labelled National, the National Front, on the basis of a press release saying “Labour can no longer sit on the fence. The Government must now make it clear where it stands on Maori issues and the place of the Treaty – so the public can make an informed choice about our country’s direction.”

Sigh, this is the intellectual equivalent of calling someone you don’t like a Nazi.

The Government has shown considerable duplicity on treaty and Maori issues, and it is quite legitimate to call on them to state their position. Representing this as a hoice between Maori and Pakeha is quite wrong. The Massey University survey last year showed that the majority of Maori backed time limits on treaty claims, crown ownership of the foreshore etc.

Maori Poll Margins of Error

In the NZ Herald Helen attacks the poll showing Labour behind in thge Maori seats.

Let’s take a look at her claims one by one:

1) “”What you are seeing though on the party vote, and you may see on the electorate vote, is people who have never voted Labour… coming in behind this particular party,”

Now in this poll Labour has 23.3% on the party vote. The previous poll they had 34.8% so that is an clear drop in support. Also at the last election Labour got 54% of the party vote in the Maori seats, so any way you look at it, Helen is wrong.

2) “If you divided fewer than 600 people by seven (Maori seats) you don’t get a statistically valid sample. It’s absolute nonsense,”

Here Helen is on stronger ground. 598 respondents divided by seven seats is only 85 per seat and that is a massive 10.9% margin of error.

However in In Tai Tokerau the Maori Party has 42 per cent (10.7% margin of error) against Labour’s 20.5% (8.8% margin of error) and Waiariki 38.2% (10.6% moe) against Labour’s 18.6% (8.5% moe).

So in those two seats, even with such a small sample, it looks grim for Labour. In the other four Labour held seats, it is not possible to conclude much.

National’s plans

The SST also has an interesting interview with Don Brash where he outlines some thoughts on health policy, MMP, future reshuffles, campaign targets and potential coalitions.

The headline and lead sentence state “I’ll quit as leader if we lose next election: Brash” and “Don Brash says he will quit as National Party leader if he fails to lead the party to victory at the next election.”

However I can;t see in the article that he actually said that. He agrees a loss, “could well” be the end of his leadership and “If I can’t [win], I am dispensable – and I absolutely accept that.”

But that is quite different from saying he will definitely quit if he loses. Would be useful to get clarification of exactly what he did say, as the above quotes can apply to all leaders (except Winston who is leader for life).

SST on spam

Is this what the TVNZ Charter meany by quality?

The new TV One show, described as a Game of Two Halves meets current affairs, will see Hosking head one team and radio broadcaster Michael Laws the other.

So instead of serious news and current affirs, we get Mike and Mike hosting a quiz show about current affairs.

Prisoner Compensation

As a society we are failing victims of crime, when they read in the paper that the person who killed their husband etc gets $55,000 compensation for his treatment in prison, yet they never received any compensation for the original crime.

However the solutions are not that simple. Phil Goff’s proposal that any prisoner who wins compensation for being mistreated, should have to pay it to former victims, would set some very bad incentives. It would almost be encouraging prison guards to beat up prisoners, so that damages would be paid to the original victim.

One solution is for prison officials to act within the law. It is unbelievable that the corrections department did not get legal advice on whether their behaviour management regime was legal. Why has the Government not done mass sackings?

Another solution is to recognise that one does need some flexibility in dealing with the worst prisoners, and amend the law (but not retrospectively). Obviously torture and beatings should never be condoned, but the prison authorities do need some ability to punish prisoners who offend, and to protect themselves and other prisoners. The media reports of the compensation are very light on details on what actually happened. I am unsure that extended solitary confinement by itself is or should be illegal. The recent changes by Labour to give prisoners a long list of rights may just lead to further lawsuits.

However one does need to have some mechanism to discourage prison authorities from mistreating their prisoners. Personally though I would rather it was sacking and prosecuting the staff involved, rather than paying compensation.

No Right Turn is so disgusted with Phil Goff he is urging people not to vote Labour, something Just Left is not happy with.

Labour behinf in all seven Maori seats

Helen Bain’s first article for the SST is to report on a a Marae-DigiPoll survey which indicates her former boss, John Tamihere, and his colleages may be toast at the next election.

“Asked which electorate MP they would vote for if an election were held today, 35.7 per cent of respondents said they would vote for a Maori Party candidate, while 26.3 per cent said they would vote for a Labour candidate.”

The good news is Destiny NZ is supported by just 0.2 per cent of voters on both Maori and general rolls.

I do have to laugh at Tamihere complaining that the Maori Party runs Maori TV. Serves them right. He also predicted that if Turia was ever appointed Maori Affairs Minister it would be “the kiss of death of race relations in this country.”

It will be very interesting how Labour ranks their Maori MPs on their list. Because that may be the only way back in for some.

Kerry is such a dick

I am starting to think that Kerry is a moron. After a Senator from his own party rips his Senate voting record to shreds, his only comeback is “Nah nah nah I went to Vietnam and Dick and George didn’t”.

This story on Yahoo News covers his response.

He says he is “not going to have my commitment to defend this country questioned by those who refused to serve”, totally missing the point that speaker after speaker never questioned his commitment, they questioned his judgement.

He went on to say “The vice president even called me unfit for office last night. I guess I’ll leave it up to the voters whether five deferments makes someone more qualified to defend this nation than two tours of duty.”

If Kerry thinks a tour of duty in Vietname qualifies him to be President, he is desperate. I don’t give a shit over what he did 30 years ago in a jungle. What matters is his total inability to articulate a clear position on the major issues of the day, and a voting and speaking record in the Senate for 20 years that demonstrates such poor judgement, not even Kerry is willing to defend his own record. He just keeps harping back to “I’m a war hero so you must vote for me”.

I wish I had seen this

Greg Dixon’s weekend in the Herald, recall Susan’s wood clumsy interview with Jack Black:

“I have got a couple of young boys at home, Jack, you know, who are young teen boys, and when I said I was coming down, my ex-husband was very thrilled about Naomi [Watts], but actually my kids were more interested in you. And I just wondered about you and this thing with young boys … ” at which point the entire room went ape. When the sniggering died down, Black responded: “You’re thinking of the other wacko Jacko.”

Hilarious.

New depths of depravity

Last night it looked like most of the children held hostage in Russia were okay, and the siege had ended with the terrorists trying to escape.

I can’t describe my sadness to hear this morning to hear at least 150 are dead, with some reports suggesting it might be as many as 600.

Whilere there may be some recriminations against the Russian Government for how they handled the siege, my anger is reserved for the dregs of humanity who think that killing children is a legitimate bargaining tactic.

Damn

One of the really nice things about being self employed has been not having to get up before 7 a.m. for the last five months.

But today I am, as I’ve contracted to work two days a week for a few weeks, helping out in a role until they make a permament appointment. So my Friday mornings are no longer a time for rest and relaxation 🙁

Outing

Two US politicians have been outed (not counting the NJ Governor who outed himself) by Blogactive (link courtesy of Russell Brown).

Now personally I tend to despise outing people against their will. I think that even the most public figure has a right to privacy in their bedrooms.

The possible exception is hypocrisy. For example if someone campaigns on an issue, then they may open themselves up to some scrutiny. I don’t care which MPs are having affairs etc.

Ed Shrock has quite the race to get re-elected to Congress, with his outing. As this article points out he was a cosponsor of the proposed amendment to ban gay marriage, oppossed non-discrimination employment laws and favoured ending the don’t ask don’t tell policy in the military saying: “

$21 million and no plan

The Auditor-General has published his report into Labour’s planned $21 million publicity splurge on their recent budget.

It basically finds that the amount budgeted had no strategy behind it, process was not followed, and has been inconsistent. This is strong stuff from the Auditor-General who is always very reserved in his comments.

McCully has set out some highlights.

Larry does a whoops

I saw this on Scoop:

“United Future fisheries spokesman Larry Baldock unreservedly retracts his statement of Tuesday, 31 August, headed “NZ Fishers betrayed by Greens, ACT and ‘Ashraf’ Peters”, in respect of the comments that related to Mr Peters.”

Luckily Scoop still has the original.

It would be interesting to know what part was incorrect.