Liar Liar Pants on Fire

When Corngate hit the news during the election the PM swore black and blue that she hardly knew anything about it and promised full release of all documents.

It has transpired that not only did she ring her brother-in-law (a scientist) to get advice on the issue, she also received a detailed briefing from one of her advisors on the GE scare. The advisors said that they could not be certain the corn was not contaminated.

Despite the promise of full disclosure, her own Chief Executive suppressed the memo from public release, even over the strong objections of the author. He claims he did this without the PM’s knowledge.

One has to wonder why such a respected civil servant would not comply with the public assurance given by his boss to release all papers. Why he persisted in this even after he received a strong complaint over the supression. Could it be because he knew the political consequences of releasing a memo showing the PM was fully informed of the issue, just hours after she had denied it.

Derek The Fox

Derek Fox shows how he got his nickname of “Derek The Fox” in this article in the NZ Herald where he claims his sudden resignation has nothing to do with the complaint against him by a female staff member, but because of attacks on Maori TV Service by MPs.

In the words of Tui – “yeah right”.

Fox has been handsomely rewarded for his work with MTS. The Govt promised as Chair he would get only $30,000 and instead he got over $100,000, and after hiring John Davy he then chaired the appointment panel which rejected all other applicants so he would be appointed CEO on a very well compensated salary.

If one is to believe Fox that his resignation is unrelated to the complaint, that is a shocking abandonment of MTS – bailing out before they are even on air and having pocketed several hundred thousand dollars.

Please explain!

There appears to be a lot of misplaced sympathy in Australia for Pauline Hanson over her three year jail term for electoral fraud.

I think the term is highly appropriate, not so much for what effectively was the theft of $500,000, but because the fraud basically led to a diferent electoral result than would otherwise have been the case. This is a more subtle form of stealing or rigging an election, and in a democracy such behaviour has to be met with a very stiff deterent.

Let’s face it, I doubt any politican after this is now going to lie over their membership numbers in order to get funding.

Now if only it was a criminal act to pass a special law to re-elect one of your mates who has lost his seat!

Another Maori broadcasting scandal

MTS has had yet another scandal with the resignation of Derek Fox (the man who chaired his own appointment panel!).

When the news broke yesterday there was much speculation that a woman was involved, and the NZ Herald confirms the staff member making the complaint was female.

I can be persauded that it is not unreasonable for the Government to fund some Maori language broadcasting (well for as long as we own or fund TVNZ and Radio NZ) but the history of scandals and incompetence with ATN, MTS, TMP and now even a manager on almost $200,000 within TVNZ to ensure the news is politically correct on maori issues is pushing even my tolerance.

Rodney vs Brian

Russell Brown observes that Brian Edwards should stop his show antics before it gets stopped for him.

Brian Edwards has claimed his show is not a conflict of interest with being PM’s media advisor as it is merely a chat show, not current affairs. But who has he had on to date – Donna Awatere-Hauta, Lindsay Perigo, Rodney Hide, Lynley Hood all politically involved.

A good article is at the NZ Herald.

Unlike Russell I have seen the interview (three times now I enjoy it so much) and the highlight for me was when Brian Edwards lied and said he had no idea who paid him to be Helen Clark’s media coach and Rodney Hide incredulously asked whether he got paid in cash – delicious the visual images of brown envelopes full of hundred dollar notes being passed from Clark to Edwards.

The Fart Tax Blues

Keeping me busy

Spam spam spam spam

Spam has been my major activity in the last three days. No, not sending it, but trying to stop it.

Had a meeting with the DMA (who are anti spam unlike some of their overseas counterparts) in Auckland on Friday to discuss ways to reduce spam. On the way to the meeting read in the taxi a NZ Herald story about Christchurch resident Shane Atkinson who boasted of up to 100 million spam e-mails a day. A further story looks into the ingredients of his penis enlargement pills.

Internetnz decided to lodge complaints with various regulatory authorities and I’ve spent most of the weekend looking through enough penile growth websites to last a life-time, as background for the complaints. Also done a few media interviews on the issue.

The full PR from InternetNZ follows. Should be further updates on this issue on Monday.

INTERNETNZ LODGES COMPLAINTS AGAINST SPAMMER
InternetNZ is lodging complaints against Christchurch spammer Shane Atkinson with three different regulatory bodies.

Atkinson has been identified in the media as being responsible for the sending of up to 100 million spam e-mails a day to promote his penis enlargement pills.

InternetNZ Vice-President, David Farrar, said that complaints are being lodged with:
– The Commerce Commission for breach of Section 10 of the Fair Trading Act 1986, relating to misleading conduct in relation to goods.
– The Ministry of Health for breach of the Medicines Act 1981
– The Privacy Commissioner for breach of the Privacy Act 1993

“Mr Atkinson is an unrepentant spammer who believes that those who don’t want to receive spam should not connect to the Internet. InternetNZ disagrees that connecting to the Internet is a license for Mr Atkinson to promote his penis
enlargement pills to every man, woman and child’s e-mail address he can find” said Mr Farrar.

InternetNZ has been considering investigating the possibility of advocating for NZ legislation to combat spam.

“If nothing is done to stem the tide of spam, we will start to lose Internet users as they become overloaded with junk mail. It is estimated that just over 50% of all email travelling the Internet is now spam”. said Keith Davidson, InternetNZ President

“If spammers believe there is nothing wrong with spamming, then legislation will become a definitive requirement in New Zealand. Many other countries have passed or intend to pass anti-spam legislation. While New Zealand has been able to rely on industry self regulation and a high degree of co-operation between ISP’s in the fight against spam, it is becoming apparent that further steps towards legislation may be desirable if attitudes like those of Mr Atkinson
exist.” according to Mr Davidson

InternetNZ urges the appropriate regulatory authorities to prosecute Mr Atkinson to the maximum extent permissible under current laws.” concluded InternetNZ Vice-President David Farrar

ENDS

Agreeing with Russell

In a rare occurence, I am agreeing with not one, but two things Russell Brown is saying in Hard News yesterday.

Russell sums up the Edwards funding issue well by saying “But writing a highly familiar letter to the Minister of Broadcasting – a recipient of your media training services – seeking a policy change in one’s own personal interest is simply off.” and also.

Russell also writes about Jonathan Marshall’s “tabloid” website and how someone has set up a site on Mr Marshall now. It seems Marshall now appreciates how appearing on TV isn’t an automatic right to be stalked as his lawyers have sent a letter to the latest site asking them to take it down. Hopefully there are some lessons beign learnt here.

The truth comes out

The NZ Herald reports a damning story by NZPA about how Harry Duynhoven told some constituents that he was happy for there to be a by-election but that Labour was worried it would take a hammering over the foreshore and seabed issue.

Now some people have not been convinced that this is a big issue. But just think about the precedent that we have allowed this Government to not just set, but get away with.

We now have a precedent that the Government can retrospectively amend the electoral act to avoid an election, because the timing is politically inconvenient.

Clark has already shown a willingness to have an early election on the filmiest of grounds (that seven minutes a day of points or order were making the Government unmanageable), and now she has cancelled an election on equally flimsy grounds. Arrogance doesn’t even come close to the epitaphs I am thinking of.

But what about the level of rates Helen!

Helen Clark has waded into the ARC rating debarcle and declared that the problem is “the system adopted by Auckland Regional Council was biased against lower and modest-income people and shifted the rates burden away from business on to residents.”

What she doesn’t mention or condemn is the outraegous 34% increase in the total rate take. That is the bigger issue, but it is usual for the left to squabble about how to divide the pie up, rather than concentrate on how big (or small in this case) the pie should be.

Of course having led a Government which has increased on introduced 18 taxes or levies (and seven more on the way), Miss Clark is hardly likely to decry the ARC following her lead. In fact it seems their main sin is that unlike the Government they haven’t socked it enough to business.

And incidentially what has caused the 34% increase. A public transport levy to support a system that 95% of Aucklanders will never use. But that’s an issue for another day.

Painful but fun!

Just returned feeling very bruised and needing a kidney transplant, from go-karting in Petone. A very fun way to spend the evening with competitive masochistic friends.

OSH would have heart attacks to know that halfway through my brake snapped off. Took me a while to notice it also due to lack of use! Eventually decided the ability to stop without ramming something solid was useful so swapped cars. Had fastest lap-time of 31 seconds.

Hope I made sense!

Just got interviewed by Radio NZ for an item of Internet Political Campaigning. Will play on Monday after 8.00 a.m.

I think I managed not to come across as too much of a blithering idiot. but you never know until you head what actually gets played.

Two good weekly reads

Two good weekly reads I can recommend. One is mccully.co put out on Fridays by Murray McCully. It is always funny, often controversial and widely read “apprehensive colleagues, even more apprehensive members of the Government, media and defamation lawyers”.

St Molesworth also appears most Fridays and does a good job of copying the famous Dave Letterman’s Top 10 lists with home grown versions. The latest list is “Top 10 Winston Peters explanations for the taxi incident” and is appended below. No 9 is especially good!
Continue reading »

Margaret Wilson must go

Attorney-General Margaret Wilson must go. The Attorney-General is NZ’s top law official and the convention for almost 1,000 years has been that they put the law above politics when making decisions such as appointing Judges, deciding what cases to prosecute etc.

Despite the “unambigious” opinion of the Solictor-General that Dynhoven’s seat fell vacant on 11 June, Wilson voted to over-ride the opinion of her own legal Chief Executive in a shocking display of partisanship. She has just told all of NZ that she effectively has no confidence in the legal reasoning of her own Solictor-General.

Wilson claims it was a “valid if courageous decision to declare the law ambiguous”. About as courageous as a weasel.

And this is the woman who next year may appoint all seven Judges of the Supreme Court of NZ. Her record to date of appointments such as De Bres, Bathgate, Henry and Fortain is about as bad as one can get. There can now be no doubt at all that Wilson will choose to ignore the advice of the Solicotor-General and Chief Justice and appoint her own partisan mates as Judges.

Harry’s gone but may be back

Both the Solictor-General and the Privileges Committee have advised that Harry Duynhoven’s seat fell vacant on 11 June due to his application to gain or restore Dutch citizenship.

The report of the Privileges Committee is worth a read and the Solictor-Generals advice will be on http://www.national.org.nz later today.

Labour and others believe that MPs should be above the law and in an outraegous and totally undemocratic move are going to force a special law through Parliament under urgency to effectively re-elect Duynhoven to Parliament without a by-election. This is a terrible precedent for Parliament to set.

So what are we banning?

An interesting article by former Labour Cabinet Minister on the breakup of ANZUS. He remarks that New Zealand’s anti-nuclear legislation was now sustained by “nothing more than historical symbolism and popular nostalgia”.

I find it hard to disagree with this when you consider the facts.

1) Only US subs have nuclear missiles on them anymore
2) No ships in the US fleet apart from aircraft carriers or subs are nuclear powered anymore
3) The US nuclear subs don’t tend to really visit very often, as their job is to stay out of sight, and those with nuclear weapons on board would still not be eligible to visit, if we amended the law to allow power but not weapons
4) US Aircraft carriers tend to be pretty busy and don’t come down this part of the world very often, and many of them wouldn’t fit into our harbours anyway!

So what exactly are we banning again? If we amended the legislation to remove the ban on nuclear powered ships (and hence remove a major thorn in our relationship with our allies) we would probably have such a ship visit at best once every forty years or so.

For those not convinced, try looking at it another way. If we didn’t have such a ban in place, and someone today proposed a ban on nuclear powered ships visiting NZ, it would get laughed away as there are basically no ships to ban.

Also worth remembering the entire US fleet lets out less radiation in a year than Auckland Hospital does in a day IIRC.

Rodney made me cry

Rodney Hide’s e-mail newsletter on the Euthanasia Bill achieved two things for me:

1) It made me cry (I did know Martin Hames)
2) It persuaded me that if I was an MP, I should have voted for the Bill

Rodney’s newsletter doesn’t appear to have a web archive so I’ve included the text below – I am sure Rodney will not object. It makes me sad reading it again.
Continue reading »

It just gets worse

Once you get the Government involved in commercial enterprises like banking you just know it won’t be able to resist meddling to favour the enterprise they own.

Following on from the $40 million additional taxpayer funds put into Kiwibank, the Government is now guaranteeing $106 million to mortgage seekers.

However this is not just for anyone. Two big conditions. To get this government guaranteed mortgage you must:

1) Borrow off Kiwibank
2) Generally be a criminal or a beneficiary

Another great triumph for the average kiwi.

Letting rapists out early

The Government seems to excel in convincing people they are doing one thing whin in fact they do the opposite. Take last year’s sentencing act which they claimed was a response to the 90% referendum vote for tougher sentences. How many people realised it allowed criminals to get parole after only one third of their sentence now.

The Act has also been so badly put together that not even the Court of Appeal can work out what it means. They have asked Parliament to “rewrite Section 86 more clearly” as they saw `major problems” and could `foresee this subject being a fertile source of difficulty for some time to come, both for sentencing judges, and on appeal”. In the normal diplomatic language of the courts, this means it makes no sense and is contradictory. This is what happens when you use Acts to try and con people that you are doing what they want.

One Appeal judge described a section of the Act as “inept drafting” and “something like the Hampton Maze”.

Euthanasia Bill fails first reading

Peter Brown’s Death with Dignity or Euthanasia Bill failed to even make it to select committee after failing its first reading by 57 votes to 60.

Personally I’m somewhat disappointed as I beleive a select committee debate and submission process would have been worth-while. Personally I am not sure how I would eventually vote on the Bill if I was an MP, as my instincts are to support it, but I do have a concern coming from a medical family background about Doctors having a role of anything other than preserving life. Having said that passive euthanasia is very common and indeed sensible.

The voting breakdown on the Bill is interesting with the majority of Labour MPs actually voting against (some what surprisingly). The breakdown by Party was:

Party – For – Against – Abstain/No Vote

Labour – 25- 26 -1
National 7 – 20 – 0
NZ First 9 – 3 – 1
ACT 6 – 2 – 1
Greens 8 -1 – 0
United 1 – 7 – 0
Jim & Matt 1 – 1 – 0

Greens most in favour at 89% and United most against at 88%. The sole Green MP against was Ian Ewen-Street and sole United in favour Marc Alexander.

MP for Courtenay Place

The MP for Courtenay Place, Rt Hon Winston Peters, is not being charged by Police over the dispute with a Somali taxi driver.

In terms of the public relations side to the issue, it was rather unfortunate for Mr Peters that the Somali taxi driver turned out not to be some barely coherent recent immigrant, but a well spoken if accented gentleman who has done five years post university study in New Zealand. The Dominion Post concluded “No matter what gloss NZ First tries to apply to this debacle, the party’s leader behaved abominably and demonstrated the depth of his dislike for foreigners. If not a racist, he is certainly a bully. ”
Continue reading »

We’re all racist!

According to Dr Cullen Bill English is racist for calling for legislation to exert exclusive crown ownership of the beaches and seabed.

Apart from the infantile stupidity of calling anyone who disagrees with Laboru a racist, Dr Cullen’s problem is that Mr English is merely calling for what Helen Clark and Margaret Wilson promised to do a few weeks ago before their Maori Caucus woke up. So does that make Helen and Margaret racists also?

And does it make the 50,000+ people who have signed a petition at www.beachesforall.co.nz calling for the same also racist.

It would be nice to live in a country where one can disagree on issues relating to the Treaty of Waitangi and not be called racist.

That Duplicity again

As a prime example of the duplicity which seems a hallmark of the Government, we have the scandal over whether the Immigration Service lied to the media over a suspected terrorist.

The Minister (Dalziel) claims the Spokesman didn’t technically lie because the NZ Herald asked whether a suspected terrorist arrived last night and he had arrived a few days earlier. I mean can you believe it – how many suspected terrorists do we get here. Whoops sorry – you mean that terrorist – I thought you were referring to an entirely different one.

As it transpires it now appears that the Immigration Department Spokesperson also lied to the Ombudsman, so the saga is far from over.

What does it take to get sacked?

The NZ Herald reports that the Immigration Department Spokesman wrote a note to his colleagues about how they had all “agreed to lie in unison” about an immigration issue, and expressing disappointment “The others caved in” which presumably means they told the truth.

At a time when the British Government looks almost ready to fall on the basis of claims that Blair’s adviser had exaggerated the issue of WMDs and Iraq, we have back home the admission of a conspiracy to lie to the public and media and the NZ Government’s reponse is merely that he was being flippant!!

Why is this not an immediate resignation – either for the staff member concerned or for those who do not sack him? An admission of a conspiracy to lie should be the main story on every media outlet but it seems to be ranking well below the death of some US entertainer.

Perhaps Winston had it right and New Zealand has just become used to such duplicity.