User No 4,000

Earlier today Kiwiblog had its 4,000th registered user/commenter register. No 4000 was “shaun”.

That basically means there since I started requiring registrations a couple of years ago, over 4,000 different people have made at least one comment.

Readership has also gone up in 2009. It spiked in January (to my surprise), dipped in February but has been growing steadily the last six weeks or so. For the last month Google Analytics say there were almost 80,000 absolute unique visitors (not visits).

Key warns Aussies

AAP reports John Key is having fun with Australia:

“It’s totally ridiculous for Australians to claim that they have pavlova or Phar Lap or any of those iconic New Zealand items,” Mr Key said today.

“Everybody knows that they’re ours and for Australians to claim ownership of them is quite inappropriate.”

Indeed.

But Mr Key says there’s no doubt that New Zealand can lay claim to the Finn brothers’ band, Crowded House.

“Absolutely,” he said, adding: “On a bad day we’ll lend you Russell Crowe.”

Heh heh. Or on a good day.

He said he didn’t agree with Rove McManus’s recent dig that New Zealand was the “cousin at the party with the short trousers” but conceded his country would always be the younger sibling in the family.

“We’re always going to be the little brother, but a little brother that can play rugby well.”

Nice dig.

Asked if he shared the famously controversial view of former New Zealand prime minister Rob Muldoon that “New Zealanders who emigrate to Australia raise the IQ of both countries,” Mr Key was more coy.

“It would be most impolite of me to confirm or deny that proposition,” he said, laughing.

A small amount of diplomacy amongst the sledging.

And is our little neighbour ready to forgive us for that unsportsmanlike underarm bowl of 1981 that stopped New Zealand batsman Brian McKechnie from hitting a six to tie the match.

“We’ve certainly stopped the counselling sessions,” the Prime Minister said.

“But we are convinced that Brian McKechnie, with a decent bowl, would have hit a six.”

I’m not sure who this interview was with, but am trying to get it on You Tube if it was recorded.

Edwards on Easter

As I had my rant about Easter Trading on Wednesday, today I’ll merely quote from well known left voice – Brian Edwards:

If I were a retailer, I’d be pretty hacked off that in the middle of a recession, with punters keeping their hands firmly in their pockets, I was about to lose two days earnings. And all because a couple of thousand years ago a Jewish preacher and revolutionary was executed in Judea and, according to his supporters, rose from the dead two days later.

I thought it was three days later?

So somehow or other we have come to the position that stuffing your face with hamburgers, pizza or KFC, eating and drinking up large in a restaurant,  going to see No Country for Old Men (R16 Graphic Violence) at the flicks, or watching a rented porno, all constitute serving God, while buying plants or tools to tend your garden on Good Friday constitutes serving Mammon.  Though it’s no longer sinful on Easter Sunday.

Praise be to such a liberal God.

In the first place, religious belief  has no legitimate role to play in lawmaking. When and whether shops stay open must be solely a matter of industrial law and not of religious observance. Holy days and holidays must not be regarded as synonymous.

And Easter Sunday is not a public holiday. It is purely a religious day.

But if we are to have undemocratic and retrograde legislation, let it at least be consistent. Let’s not make absolute fools of ourselves by saying that it’s OK to make money renting videos, selling duty free watches and flogging pulp fiction at airports, but not OK to make money by selling someone a lemon tree or a spade to plant it with.

Either ban the lot and make us all wear sackcloth and ashes for two days, or give every trader and every potential customer the right to make up their own mind on what they’ll do at Easter. I’m for the latter. Let’s open the doors. Let’s breathe the fresh air of freedom. Let’s, for heaven’s sake, grow up!

I am sure there are many areas where I disagree with Dr Edwards, but this is not one of them.

General Debate 10 April 2009

God’s Facebook

Principal Family Court Judge on Instant Portection Orders

NZPA reports Judge Boshier:

The Domestic Violence (Enhancing Safety) Amendment Bill aims to strengthen what the criminal justice system can do to protect victims.

The new orders, which will last for up to five days, can be issued when police do not have enough to arrest an offender but they think the family is in danger.

Principal Family Court Judge Peter Boshier today told Parliament’s justice and electoral select committee he strongly supported the five-day order as in some places, such as Kaikohe and Greymouth, the court did not sit every day, leaving the victim exposed until it did.

“The real bubble in family violence is Christmas. Every January we are besieged with family violence orders and if you had five working days that would be, I think, a reasonable compromise between civil liberties and the need to be protective,” he said.

I am a strong supporter. I think victims of domestic violence get very little effective protection from current laws.

“What I could not support, if I could say very clearly and strongly, is any notion that there could be a right of a review before a court of that five-day order.

“We would not physically have the ability to cope.”

Some have called for there to be a right of review. It sounds like it is just not workable.

Judge Boshier also urged the committee to give police the power to arrest criminals who failed to attend programmes they had been ordered to go to, such as anger management courses.

Uptake of such programmes was “terrible” and police could only summons people who did not attend to appear before the court, a process Judge Boshier said was cumbersome and given low priority.

“I feel that if police had the power of arrest, they could deal with it instantly,” he said.

“I think it would have the effect of getting non-attenders to programmes much more rapidly.”

Not a bad idea.

Edwards on Henry

Brian Edwards joins the blogosphere and asks what to do with Paul Henry. He looks at how Paul is loved and loathed, and I really like his conclusion:

Who’s right – his critics or his defenders? Both. Henry is an obnoxious prat.  His ego is out of control and, as a broadcaster, so is he. He has done  more than enough to deserve the boot.

BUT he is also one of the most intelligent, most incisive, most accomplished, most polished, and most entertaining broadcasters this country has ever seen.

Can’t live with him, can’t live without him.

Edwards is right. Paul Henry is offensive and at time obnoxious with an ego that could fuel a fleet. But he is also a genius broadcaster.

You have to accept both sides of Henry, to reconcile how you react to him.

On the issue of Stephanie Mills, there can be no doubt Henry behaved appallingly towards an invited guest. If you knew Mills personally, you would especially be outraged by what Henry did (interestingly Mills herself very sensibly did not lash out, but said it is about her issues, not her or Henry).

But while intellectually I know Henry was a brattish prat twoards Mills, I also had tears of laughter as I watched the clip of the show. When you don’t know the target personally, offensive humour can still be very very funny. And for me it wasn’t so much about Mills, but about the train wreck it caused as Henry ignored Ali and his producer, and them seems bemused by the hate mail, and even then his “Oh go from a group” reotort. It was like an episode of Borat.

I’d been having trouble reconciling my intellectual dislike of what Henry did, with my instictive hilarity at the situation. You feel guilty for laughing so loud.

But Edwards get it right, as I said. Henry is both an obnoxous prat and a great broadcaster. Don’t pretend he can be one without the other.

So what does Brian Edwards propose be done:

So what should be done with Paul? Well firstly he should be fronting Close Up. Mark Sainsbury may be a nicer person, but he isn’t a patch on Henry as a broadcaster. He stumbles his way through the programme, is often barely articulate and his interviews are a shambles. But he’s responsible and safe and Henry isn’t.

So here’s my solution.  Mark goes back to his previous job as a political editor. He was extremely good at that. Paul takes over Close Up where he is likely to beat the pants off the much nicer John Campbell. But there’s a proviso. Henry’s contract includes a ‘penny in the jar’ clause. Every time he breaches the Broadcasting Act’s standards of balance, fairness, decency or good taste, $10,000 is deducted from his salaryand donated to the Society for the Promotion of Community Standards. Should work.

Heh, I quite like that idea.

Is Jordan a secret fan of Roger Douglas?

Jordan Carter blogs:

Michael is a smart, funny, warm and caring man who is already clearly one of my party’s more successful finance ministers.

Now this got me curious, as this suggests that Jordan thinks that Labour has had other finance ministers more successful than Dr Cullen. Because he did not say “the most successful”.

Who have been Labour Finance Ministers, and which ones do he think were better than Dr Cullen? The post WWII/1949 list is:

  1. Arnold Nordmeyer 1957 to 1960
  2. Bill Rowling 1972 – 1974
  3. Bob Tizard 1974 – 75
  4. Roger Douglas 1984 – 1988
  5. David Caygill 1988 – 1990

Nordmeyer was the author of the infamous Black Budget that made Labour a one term Government so we can assume it wasn’t him.

Rowling was Finance Minister during the oil crisis, and has a pretty disasterous record. So presumably not him.

No one could seriously think you would rate Bob Tizard abaove Michael Cullen.

So hence, the only possible conclusion is that Jordan rates Roger Douglas and David Caygill as Labour’s most sucessful finance ministers! 🙂

This will endear him to Leader Phil Goff, as Goff was once Sir Roger’s most loyal disciple. As was Annette!

Cities vs Communities

I regard one of the best decisions by the Government about Auckland, was to expand the second tier underneath the Auckland Council from the proposed six local Councils to 20 – 30 local Boards.

The six local Councils would have been on very similiar boundaries to the existing cities and I dont think they would would reflect communities at all well, despite some assuming they do.

Communities can be hard to define, but we know them when we see them. In Wellington, Thorndon is a distinct community. In Auckland, West Auckland is a distinct community as any Westie can tell you.

But Waitakere City is not the same as West Auckland. Waitakere City includes Piha, which is not West Auckland. It includes Hobsonville which is very different to Henderson and Glen Eden.

The same occurs in Manukau City. People may think Manukau City is about South Auckland. Well South Auckland is very much a community with its own culture and identity. But Manukau City is far larger than that.

Pakuranga is not the same community as Mangere. The rural Botany-Clevedon area has little in common with Papatoetoe.

The move to 20 – 30 local boards, instead of 6 local councils, provides an opportunity for far better reflection of natural communities. And each local board can propose a local targeted rate for their local area, to cover proposed extra services or facilities. Now of course the overall Auckland Council has to agree to them, but if the local Board does a good job of ascertaining the views of its residents, I doubt there will be much second guessing.

Legal Aid

Do you get legal aid when you sue for legal aid?

Stuff reports:

A man convicted for his part in the abduction of his grandson wants legal aid to fund an appeal, despite having $1 million in assets held in a family trust.

The family fortunes of Dick Headley, 70, were revealed in the High Court in Hamilton this week. He was appealing a Legal Services Agency refusal to grant him legal aid.

In December Headley and his daughter, Kay Skelton, 38, were sentenced in the same court.

Skelton was ordered to complete nine months’ home detention and 300 hours’ community work, while Headley was ordered to serve 12 months’ home detention.

The nasty little kidnappers got off lightly.

Headley claims the Legal Services Agency treated him unfairly when it refused to grant him legal aid during those legal proceedings. A legal review panel later found in favour of the agency, a decision Headley’s lawyer claims was an “error of law”.

Headley was appealing that decision in an effort to get legal aid to appeal his sentence.

So do you get legal aid when suing for legal aid?

Hooton on Auckland

Matthew Hooton has an excellent column in NBR (as he unlike me, remembered it was being published today not tomorrow). His description of the problems with the status quo in Auckland is so good, I have repeated an extract here:

Auckland has always been ripped off by the rest of New Zealand, paying far more tax to Wellington than it has ever received back, even including benefits to South Auckland.

The city’s infrastructure has never been a priority. Reefton had electric street lighting before Auckland; the first telephone call was made from Roxburgh; Auckland had to wait for STD to first be rolled out in parts of National’s provincial heartland; and its roading network was never completed because of political priorities in marginal electorates.

Today, the city’s roads remain shambolic; electricity supply is not guaranteed; cellphone calls can’t be maintained driving from Queen St to the airport; public transport is more primitive than in Queen Victoria’s London; Cath Tizard’s opera house stands at the wrong end of town; Auckland couldn’t competently respond to Trevor Mallard’s offer of a free rugby stadium; it idiotically runs a major port at the foot of its CBD, separating the city from the sea and with no possibility of ever achieving streamlined transport links to the country’s manufacturing base; and its kids were recently at risk of losing their elephants because politicians couldn’t agree about funding for the zoo.

If Auckland were some Pacific island, we’d call it a failed state.

And this is the status quo that Labour now has decided it wants to protect?

Labour have been quick to say what they don’t like, but are being very careful not to offer any constructive solution of their own. Would they have Maori seats on the Auckland Council? Depends which Labour MP you listen to according to John Carter who said in the House that a senior Labour MP was reported ruling out Maori seats as recommended by the Royal Commission.

Most questions this session

Who has had to answer the most questions in Parliament at Question Time, during the last three week session?

You would think it would be the Prime Minister or the Minister of Finance?

But no, Labour has asked an extraoridnary 20 questions to David Bennett – who isn’t even a Minister.

Many people are unaware that you can ask a question to a Select Committee Chair, as well as a Minister. And it does not come out of your normal allocation – they are supplementary. However they can only be on issues relating to the processes of a Select Committee.

So a relatively obscure backbencher has answered more primary questions than both the PM and Minister of Finance. Why? Labour seems convinced they will get Bennett to contradict something Nick Smith said about why Nick turned up to the Transport and Industrial Relations Select Committee instead of ACC Chairman John Judge (who was out cycling).

You would think after 20 primary questions and several dozen supplementaries they would have realised they weren’t getting what they wanted.

I thought targeting Bennett was a smart idea intially for a few days, as he did look a bit flustered, and it kept the issue alive. But now three weeks on, absolutely everyone has lost interest and no longer cares.

General Debate 9 April 2009

My annual rant on Easter trading

I doubt there is any law as inconsistent and illogical as our current Easter shop trading laws.

Let us start with the fact this law bans employees from being able to earn extra money. We’re in a recession and times are tough. A shop assistant  could earn say an extra $450 if they were allowed to work this Friday and Sunday. That would be enough money so they could then actually afford a holiday later in the year.

Then let us look at the fact Easter Sunday is not a public holiday. We have a law that bans you from being able to work on a day which is not even a public holiday. It is simply a religious day. Easter Monday is a public holiday and you are allowed to work that day, but in most cases not on Easter Sunday.

Some may claim the law allows people the weekend off. Apart from the fact that the law removes any choice from employees, it does not. People can be forced to work on Easter Saturday. Would it not be far superior to say have a law that says no employee (except essential services) can be forced to work over the four Easter days, but that they can do so if they wish. As present they can be forced to work on at least one of those days, and have no choice about working the other two.

Then we have the anomalies. Where do you start. How about a four square can not open but a Star Mart can? How about the fact a souvenir shop can open but a gift shop can not?  And the garden centre amendment that allowed them to open on Easter Sunday, but not Good Friday?

And that is before we even deal with regional anomalies. Shops in Queenstown can open, but not Wanaka. Taupo is okay, but not Rotorua.

The law is a mess. It is anti-worker and anti-choice. We have a law that stops many workers from being able to earn extra money – some of it as holiday and penal rates. It is nothing to do with protecting workers – it is about compelling them. Workers already have protection from being forced to work on protected days under the Act:

No worker shall be required to work on a protected day or at night. No undue influence shall be applied to any worker in an attempt to induce that worker to agree to work on a protected day or at night. No action shall be taken to discriminate against or disadvantage any worker not wishing to work on a protected day or at night.

Now again Easter Sunday is not a public holiday. It is a religious day. Removing from workers the ability to choose to work that day (if their employers wish to open) does not guarantee them Easter off – they can be forced to work Easter Saturday.

Rotorua MP Todd McClay has a private members bill that is a small step forward. It allows local communities to decide whether or not shops can open on Easter Sunday. Hopefully Parliament will do the right thing and not cave into to the unholy alliance between the religious right and the union left.

Helen Clark valedictory speech

Clark’s valedictory speech is at aroudn 5 pm today, and viewable on Parliament TV, and through the Parliament website.

I have watched (either in person or via TV) every former PM’s valedictory speech from Muldoon onwards – except for Geoffrey Palmer. All very different styles. Muldoon was sad yet powerful. Lange was hilarious. Bolger was excellent talking of prides and regrets and had a farewell from the Maori MPs at the end of it.

Moore was funny but with some bitterness. Shipley was dignified and optimistic.

For those who can’t watch it, I’ll probably live blog any noticeable parts.

THE SPEECH:

Starting now. I note Jonathan Hunt is in the House, next to the Speaker’s Chair. Clark says she has mixed emotions. Enrolled at Auckland Uni in 1968. Talking of big issues in 1968 such as Vietnam War, nuclear testing, South Africa.

Says Kirk’s independent foreign policy inspired her. Referred to Radio Hauraki breaking state radio monopoly by broadcasting from a boat in Hauraki Gulf.

Never imagined being PM when young, as senior politicians were all elderly men. Now paying tribute to Hunt and Anderton for getting her involved, plus Kirk again. She was foot solider in 1972.

Grew up on a farm in Waikato. Wider family had many political allegiances. Parents initially surprised by her political direction, but always personally supportive and now fully politically supportive. Mum too ill to be hear but 87 year old Dad is in gallery. Pays tribute to them both. Lots of clapping.

Stood in 1975 in Piako against Gentleman Jack Luxton and he was a Gentleman. Advice to young people in politics is to start off by running in a seat they probably won’t win as you learn a lot. Success is seldom instant, and quick wins can fade quickly.

Referred to how Muldoon said in his valedictory was how many more women were now in Parliament and how he found them somewhat frightening. Clark says it was mutual – especially if you tried to interject him 🙂

Attracted to politics by desire to make a difference. Has a sense of gratitude for opportunities NZ has given her. NZ was an escape for many from the class bound order of the UK. Detests social distinction and snobbery. Hence dislikes titular honours.

Focused in first six years on Mt Albert. Grateful to them. Chaired Foreign Affairs Select Committee and highlight was anti-nuclear law. Now talking about various Ministerial things she did. Helped bring in seven day trading (yay).

Plague on both your houses (National and Labour) in 1992 and 1993 saw MMP introduced. Lots of defections to minor parties in mid 1990s. Labour lost support to NZ First and Alliance and in mid 90s a poll had Labour on 14% and Clark on 2% as Preferred PM. In hindsight surprised concerned delegations to her door did not occur more often.

1999 saw Labour/Alliance Government with Green support. Believes they have made life better for many New Zealanders.

In last term in particular big focus was sustainability and believes it is vital for our international credibility. Jewel in crown was transfer of Molesworth Station to DOC to preserve for all NZers.

Talking about heritage projects like Te Ara.

NZers now very familiar with settlement of historical grievances and important they continue to be settled. Also apology to Samoa was important as was apology to Vietnam Veterans for what they endured in lack of recognition and support.

Proud that Maori are now significant economic stakeholders in NZ. Has enjoyed engagement with all the ethnic communities. Says it is inevitable that we will become a republic – not if, but when.

Pleased we stayed out of Iraq War but also that have rebuilt relationship with US. Big commitment to peace keeping.

Regards selection as UNDP Administrator as reflection on not just her, but NZ’s record internationally.

No regrets but it is time to go and let others lead. 2008 result was disappointing but in a democracy must respect the people’s will.

Never a solo act in politics. So many people have supported her. Her parents gave best possible start. Her sisters and their families always supportive of Peter and her. Peter has been a staunch supporter of her career, no matter how unpleasant it got. Lots of clapping from all sides.

Mt Albert backed her for 10 elections. Thanks to all those, esp Mt Albert electorate committee. Also electorate office staff – esp Joan Caulfield.

Thanks to all in Labour at all levels. Special thanks to Cullen. Friendships will be life long. Expects many texts and even the occassional tweet. Very well timed joke.

Thanks Jim A. Then Jeanette from Greens. Also honourable relationships with Dunne and Peters based on common interests. Also acknowledge Turia and thank her.

Relationships with National and ACT less significant. But acknowldge Key and Hide for their courtesy, especially recently. And previous MPs such as Paul East. Also talks to Bolger, Palmer and Moore.

Thanks DPMC CEOs and Cabinet Secretaries by name.  Also thanks MCH and Ministerial Services. Enjoyed work with SIS and GCSB. Trusts them and their staff. They work in the interests of NZ.

Also thanks MFAT for support on so many issues and summits and visits. Privilege to support NZ Defence Force and seeing their work overseas.

Thanking PM’s Office – Heather Simpson, Alec McLean and others. Also Police/DPS for keeping her alive! They are unsung heroes. Also kudos to VIP Drivers (I agree they rock). Privileged to continue using them, so not an end.

27 years since her maiden speech at 32. Said greatish wish was to have contributed ot making NZ a better place for peopel to live in. She thinks she has played her part – has been a privilege and an honour. Wishes Goff and Labour best for the next election and NZ the best for challenging times ahead.

All over. Clapping and hugs. Key gave a cheek kiss. Now given a Maori cloak by Nanaia.

Speech was very good. Covered the whole life, not just the achievements as PM, which makes it more interesting. No masively stand out moments, but nothing you can fault either. No bitterness or sniping, and no defensiveness.

2008 Spending and Votes

2008spendvotes1

This spreadsheet above looks at what correlation there is between advertising spend on behalf of a party, and how many votes they got. The first column is the party’s declared advertising (it does not include candidate advertising) and the second column is how the costs of any broadcasting paid for by the Electoral Commission. So the third column is the total advertising spend on behalf of the party, and then divided by the number of votes they cost, what he spend per vote is.

The variation is huge – from 29c a vote to $55 a vote. Take the two extreme minor parties. The Bill and Ben Party got 13,016 votes with under $4,000 of spending. While Social Credit got one tenth as many votes despite spending 20 times as much money.

Most focus will be on the parties that do make it into Parliament, or have a serious chance of doing so. Of those National spent the least per vote – $3.04. So hardly buying your way to power.  ACT spent the most at $14.57 a vote, followed by Progressive at $12.80 a vote.

The Greens and NZ First both spent over $10 a vote, two to three times that of Labour and National.

Money is useful in politics. But it is far from a dominant factor. Policies, leadership, media reporting, volunteer effort, membership levels, smart use of IT, MPs behaviour all have (in my opinion) a greater influence on electoral outcomes than merely money spent.

Backbenches Easter Trading Special

Tonight’s Backbenches will debate our archaic and inconsistent easter trading laws where shops in some areas can open, but not others. And you are not allowed to earn money on Easter Sunday (which is not a public holiday) but can on Easter Monday (which is a public holiday).

The MPs are:

  • Todd McClay – National, Rotorua
  • Steve Chadwick – Labour, ex Rotorua
  • John Boscawen, ACT
  • Sue Bradford, Greens

Also appearing are:

  • Charles Finny, Wgtn Chamber of Commerce
  • David Kiddey, Hutt Chamber of Commerce
  • Andrew Little, EPMU National Secretary
  • Melanie Sergent, Powerhouse Community Church Minister
  • Michael Smith, Caritas Aotearoa New Zealand (do gooding doolies)

As usual screens on TVNZ7 just after 9 pm, or watch live at the Backbencher.

Easter Trading debates always amuse me as you get an unholy coalition of the religious right and the union left, combining forces to stop employees from being able to earn extra money.

Other Board Appointments

Most of the focus yesterday was on Dr Cullen’s appointment. There were some other interesting ones.

The Dom Post reports that Don Brash was appointed to the Transpower Board and Judy Kirk to chair the Lotteries Commission.

Transpower is a good choice for Don. It’s the only SOE that he doesn’t believe should be sold off at some stage 🙂

The Lotteries Commission is the traditional repository for senior party officials, and Judy has six years of board chairmanship skills to bring to it so her appointment is no surprise and I would say uncontroversial. I would caution though that National should never get to the stage they did in the 1990s where every single member of the Board was a senior National official. That was an awful look.

I have blogged in some detail in the past on Government Appointments. The summary of my advice was:

  1. Never have those with political connections forming a majority or even close to a majority on a board.
  2. Unless someone was already a professional company director (or widely seen as possessing similar skills), they should not be appointed to more than a couple of boards.
  3. Appointees must bring genuine value to a board – their appointments must be based on merit, even if they have political connections.
  4. The more important a board, the more critical it is that the apointees be top class.

Another interesting aspect is that Phil Goff a couple of weeks ago, unwisely complained that National was engaging in a witch-hunt against Labour Party supporters. His whinging was because Tony Timms and Polly Schaverien were not reappointed to Meridian Energy Board.

The appointment of Cullen should show how stupid his whining was. But to further highlight how off the beam he was, I quote from Simon Power:

“Joanna Perry (Genesis), Polly Schaverien (MetService) and Ian Donald (Transpower) have been elevated to deputy chair,

So Polly Schaverien has been elevated to MetService Deputy Chair despite being a former Labour Researcher and Mallard staffer. So again where is this witch hunt Goff complained about?

National – Greens MOU

Busted Blonde has a nice little scoop – that National and Greens wll today announce an MOU between the two parties.

I doubt it will include any voting commitments but will identify some areas they can work together such as home insulaton.

Now as readers will know, most Greens policies scare me so badly I need to take Imodium after I hear of them. And they want to ban anything Gaia doesn’t approve of.

But there are some areas where their policies have merit, and it is sensible to have National and Greens formalise a way they can work together in those areas they do agree.

It is a bit of a win-win as the Greens gain relevance rather than just be a lonely voice in Opposition, and National gets kudos for showing a willingess to work constructively.

I just hope John doesn’t get carried away and appoint Sue Bradford as the new Children’s Commissioner 🙂

UPDATE: The MOU is online. Greens get some reaonable stuff. In agreed policy areas they get access to Ministers and departmental officials for briefings and advice and get input into Cabinet papers. The laeders will meet quarterly to review progress. Agreed areas of work are home insulation, energy efficiency and regulation of NZ natural health products. More areas may be added later.

As I said above, this reflects well on both parties.

Stephen Jennings

Was a real privilege to listen to Stephen Jennings deliver the annual Sir Ron Trotter dinner last night. Somehow ended up on the Chairman’s tables so was only three metres away from the podium.

A sad note was that for the first time ever, Sir Ron himself could not attend due to ill health. His family were there in numbers though.

Jennings is a former Treasury economist who before the global recession was worth $6 billion, so he has done well for a Taranaki boy.

Jenni McManus covers some of his thoughts on Stuff:

If New Zealand jettisons MMP and elects leaders who can move beyond placating minority interest groups, it might have a chance of arresting its 50-year decline and competing globally, he says.

Well there will be a vote on MMP in the next couple of years. Ironically the popularity of the Key Government may save MMP. With Winston gone, and a stable popular Government, a lot of people may say why change?

Since 1980, he says, economic power has begun shifting from the so-called rich countries of the West to emerging markets such as the former Soviet Union and Yugoslavia, Cambodia, Angola, Greece, Tanzania, Botswana, Ireland, Bhutan, Singapore, India, Malaysia, Indonesia, Chile, Sri Lanka, Vietnam, Lebanon, Trinidad and Tobago, Mozambique, Poland, Guyana and Tunisia.

Jennings spoke a lot about the opportunities we will have from a few hundred million more peple moving into the “middle classes” world wide.

“Today there are 5.5 billion people living in countries with growth rates higher than the average in the G7.”

Yep, they are catching up.

Mr Jennings is no fan of what he calls “missionary economics” the attempt to superimpose the “unadulterated adoption” of institutions and forms of government on countries with different economic, social and historical frameworks.

“The most successful emerging market businesses have evolved in a manner that is highly adapted to their local environment.”

Jennings clarified that the rule of law, property rights, independent judiciary are all very important but you can’t impose a model – it has to evolve.

New Zealanders needed to start talking about why the World Economic Forum ranked New Zealand 51st for burden of government, 67th for the extent and effect of tax, and 90th for hiring and firing practices.

Sadly I don’t see great improvements ahead. Maybe with time.

The country needed political leaders who could lead and manage change. “They need to be able to make policy choices quickly and efficiently,” Mr Jennings says.

“We know what kind of political behaviour our current constitution generates: gradualism, populism and the quasi-corruption arising from disproportionate pandering to tiny minorities.”

Is he talking Winston and Grey Power? 🙂

Looking on the bright side …

Still fairly ropable about the decision re Cullen, but looking on the bright side I am amused that Dr Cullen will now be working for Jim Bolger, Tuku Morgan and John “Rich Prick” Key.

Slightly cheering me up also is the talk that quite a few in Labour are pissed off also, with his decision to take up a Government Board role. By departing before the Mt Albert by-election (his valedictory is 29 April), it will make the issues around candidate selection more transparent to the public as Damien O’Connor will be an MP before Mt Albert goes to vote.

I’ve also made lots of money on iPredict investing in the probability that Clark and Cullen would both be gone this year.

And with Clark and Cullen gone, we get a new Father of the House. Initially I thought this would be Phil Goff as he was elected in 1981 – the only Muldoon era MP left in Parliament now.

But he lost his seat in 1990, so his time only counts from 1993. Mr Speaker will in fact become the Father of the House when Clark and Cullen go. He came in in 1984. So did Mallard and King but they also spent 1990 – 1993 out of the House. And for those who like trivia, Jacinida Ardern is the “Baby of the House”.

UPDATE: Rodney reminds me that Sir Roger entered Parliament in 1969! Of course he had a small break from 1990 to 2008!

UPDATE2: Actually Jim Anderton and then Peter Dunne will become Father of the House. They also entered in 1984 and were swown in before Lockwood as it is done in alphabetical order. I only looked at the two main parties as the minor parties were all set up in the 1990s, but of course they both entered as Labour.

Blog Bits

Some good tidbits:

  1. The Finsec Union backs Bill English! It is over his comments that as the Government is now guaranteeing some of their risk, their margins should be lowered.
  2. The Tailor of Panama Street has a rare piece of good news from the UN Human Rights Council. The investigator into Gaza allegations is not an anti-semitic nutter like some of their previous investigators. That means any findings will have some credibility.
  3. Andrew Sullivan blogs on being a green conservative. He reviews the issues around climate change really well, and the big difference between what the IPCC says and what Al Gore says. His conclusion is to favour carbon and petrol taxes over the bureaucracy of a trade and cap scheme such as an ETS.
  4. Andrew Geddis at Pundit gives National two and a half ticks for their process for reviewing electoral law.
  5. The above named Tailor also looks at whether John Hood will be the next Secretary of Foreign Affairs. He comments “One suspects that Murray McCully will see five years of doing battle with the dons to try and overhaul 900 years of Oxford tradition as a fairly useful apprenticeship for dealing with the much larger challenge of reforming MFAT.” Hood is certainly a possibility, but I understand he may be a bit too political for the Government. The name I have heard as the appointee is NZ Post CEO John Allen.  As the Tailor says though – can he afford the pay cut?

Decisions on Auckland

The Government has announced its decisions to date on Auckland Local Government. There is a dedicated website – www.auckland.govt.nz –  with info. Note my disclosure statement.

The structure is to be:

  • One unitary Auckland Council for the region
  • One Mayor, elected at large, with governance powers
  • 20 Councillors, 8 at large and 12 from wards
  • 20 to 30 local boards as the second tier of governance
  • Local Government Commission to determine ward boundaries and number and shape of local boards
  • No Maori seats (unless voted for by the public)
  • Continue with a three year term
  • No Minister or Cabinet Committee for Auckland but an Auckland Transition Committee to be chaired by Rodney Hide.

I am very pleased that they have replaced the proposed six local Councils with a larger number of smaller local boards, that will provide better community representation.

Also pleased to see the Local Government Commission set all the boundaries, so they are presumably of equal size. I would prefer no at large Councillors, but they have at least reduced the numbers.

The Maori Party will presumably not be happy that there will be no dedicated seats for Maori. The Government has said Maori representation will continue to addressed by the Local Electoral Act which allows 5% of electors to demand a poll on establishing a Maori ward. So I guess the message for supporters of Maori wards is to go off and get 5% of Aucklanders to sign a petition for one. If they do, then a poll could be run with the 2010 election about adding them on. Sounds like a smart compromise – leave it to the people.

Overall the decisions look to be a good improvvement on the Royal Commission report, especially the introduction of smaller and more local boards to keep local government local.