What will be the shape of the Maori Party deal?

Audrey Young speculates:

The Herald understands one Maori Party MP could become an associate Maori Affairs minister in return for the party abstaining on confidence and supply votes.

To get a bigger role the party is likely to have to support National, rather than only not opposing it.

I’d have some problems with the notion that a Minister of the Crown could abstain on supply and confidence votes for the Government. That weakens the bonds of Government even more. Next you’ll have Ministers able to vote against the Government on confidence and supply.

NBR on the media

NBR editor Nevil Gibson scrutinises the recent media:

We have to say it because no one else will: Almost alone among mainstream media, the National Business Review’s call on the election result turned out to be the best one.

Our summary: “National will easily win a mandate while the Greens become a stronger force on the left. Maori will not hold a balance of power and Winston Peters will be history.”

Yep. A very good call.

The left’s wholesale defeat was not reflected in the spread of commentators and pundits employed across the board. The public broadcasters – both radio and TV –can always be relied on to give Labour any doubt.

But it’s more surprising when private equity-owned MediaWorks chooses to lean even heavier to the left, mainly by hiring National Radio and TV One heavies.

Perhaps the reason Radio Live and TV3’s Sunrise have failed to gain much traction is that their personality mixes have too many of the media’s trendy lefties and not enough of those who reflect the country’s anti-socialist mood. (You can see why Newstalk is cleaning up with its strong conservative/populist line up.)

National truly reflects the heartland, yet the media are continuing down their path of denial by giving more coverage, in newspapers and on radio, to the Labour leadership issue rather than accept the broad mandate for a new broom government is much more newsworthy.

Possibly part of the problem is too many media are in Wellington, where the mood for change was dampened. More talking to people in the provinces would get you quite another feel – something the NZ Herald did with their excellent Simon Collins series.

Labour’s new lineup

  • Leader: Phil Goff
  • Deputy Leader: Annette King
  • Finance: David Cunliffe
  • Foreign Affairs: Helen Clark
  • Shadow Leader: Michael Cullen
  • Senior Whip: Darren Hughes
  • Junior Whip: Steve Chadwick

Congratulations to Phil Goff for achieving his long held ambition, and without even a ballot. He will be a very happy chap tonight. Annette is probably taking up the Deputy more through a sense of duty than ambition. She will be a key person in keeping people happy.

Overall looks pretty sensible to me.

We also have the unusual situation where Clark remains as Prime Minister for another week or so, despite no longer being party leader. I don’t thik there has ever before been a leadership change before the new Government has even been sworn in.

Dim-Post galore

Danyl has been busy, I do not know where to start.

We have Maori Party split over Coalition Deal

The Maori Party have been offered entrenchment of the Maori seats and a review of the Foreshore and Seabed Act in exchange for fifty of their young every month for three years. …

It is understood that Sharples is deeply opposed to the proposed scheme while Tariana Turia is a strong advocate for Key’s right to hunt, kill and mount unemployed Maori youths, describing it as enhancing his rangatiratanga and sending a strong message to young Maori that if they study and work hard they will not be cut down in their prime by Key’s poison-tipped crossbow bolts or torn apart by his pack of savage dogs.

A resolution to the impasse was reached late last night, when the Maori party co-leaders met for a cup of tea to confront the problem. After a short, congenial discussion Dr Sharples drained his mug of Earl Grey and then slumped to the floor unconscious.

And Tizard dismisses ‘rogue election result’:

Outgoing Auckland Central electorate MP Judith Tizard has assured staff and family that she will not be stepping down as an MP in spite of her loss to National Party candidate Nicky Kaye in last weekends General Election.

‘I certainly never heard anything about any election,’ Tizard told the Dim-Post this morning. ‘And if there was something like that going on I like to think I’d be one of the first to know.’

Upon being informed of the results Tizard was quick to dismiss their significance.

‘I don’t think this represents the true wishes of the people of New Zealand or the people of Auckland Central,’ Tizard said. ‘This is clearly a rogue election result with no real impact that the media is beating up in order to sell more papers.’ …

Tizard has also confirmed that she will be maintaining her full contingent of staff and offices, rejecting the suggestion that she would now have to make her own dinner reservations and purchase her own plane tickets as ‘the worst kind of hate speech’.

Incoming National MP Nicky Kaye has advised she is negotiating a solution with Paliamentary Services, Tizard’s private secretary and an Armed Offenders unit.

Oh that was priceless.

Fisking Slack

David Slack blogs:

You may recall the howls of derision in 2005.

How on earth can you be a minister and remain outside the government? they demanded.

That was then, this is now. This morning’s paper tells me:

Mr Key acknowledged yesterday that he was wrong and “in hindsight” it had worked well.

But David is mixing up two different things. The howls of derision wasn’t about having Ministers from other parties outside Cabinet – it was the insane insistence that this meant they were not part of the Government.

As far as I know ACT and United Future will be Ministers outside Cabinet but they are not going to pretend not to be part of the Government.

Incidentally the insistence by NZ First that they were not part of Government was exposed as hollow when the reps on the Boundaries Commission were appointed – one for the Government and one for the Opposition. They were represented by the Government rep.

Roger Douglas

The common theme on the left blogs seem to be to try and use Sir Roger as a bogeyman for the new Government, even though he won’t be a Minister in it.

I find this amusing as the new Leader and Deputy Leader of the Labour Party will be two of Sir Roger’s former loyal lieutenants.!

Yes Clark and Cullen did serve in Cabinet with Sir Roger, but they were in the Lange faction. Goff and King were definitely in the Douglas faction. Maybe a journalist could ask them whether or not they voted for Douglas to return to Cabinet in 1989, against Lange’s express wishes?

Personally I hope Sir Roger is made Chairman of the Finance and Expenditure Select Committee. He would do a good job holding both Departments and Ministers to account for their spending.

Tidbits

Lots of new MPs in Wellington last night. Two semi-amusing stories.

The new MP for Tauranga dined at the Backbencher, and ordered WInston’s Schnitzel. He insists it was for the Schnitzel, not the name.

Another new National MP told the story of how he got on well with the Green candidate and was invited to their place for a 40th birthday party. He went along and discovered that the 40th birthday was for the candidate’s donkey! Yes, seriously. His kids enjoyed though being able to ride the birthday celebrant!

Incidentally 40 years is pretty good going for a donkey.

The temporary Leader of the Labour Party

The Herald editorial talks about how Phill Goff will be a caretaker or temporary caretaker for Labour.

The decision allows Labour no time to find a promising successor. In the absence of a new face, it will probably elect the capable Phil Goff to lead it for the time being. Mr Goff has many of the attributes of Helen Clark: wide ministerial experience, a good command of all issues, instinctive common sense and a sure political touch. And he is a more forceful public speaker than she is.

But he is not much younger than she is, and as a minister in the 1980s has been on the national scene for just as long. He can never give Labour the fresh image a party normally needs to recover from a long period in power. By the next election Mr Goff would be in much the same position as Bill English was in 2002. As a leading minister in a recently defeated Government, Mr English could not lead National back to office.

Actually a lot worse than Bill’s example. Bill entered Parliament during the 4th National Government and was Leader of the Opposition for the 5th Labour Government. Phil Goff entered Parliament during the 3rd National Government, served as a Minister in the 4th Labour Government, spent nine years in Opposition during the 4th National Government, nine years as a Minister in the 5th Labour Government, and now will become the fresh face of Labour during the 5th National Government hoping to lead a 6th Labour Government to power.

At the next election, Goff and King celebrate the 30th anniversary and 27th anniversary respectively of their first election to Parliament.

So I think Goff and King will struggle to be seen as long-term Leaders. In a way, that is a pity. Goff and King are amongst the more moderate Labour MPs (or have been to date) and should move Labour more towards the centre.  They both are regarded as amongst the more competent Ministers also (even though King’s halo took a beating this year) and should be an effective team working together.

$200,000 more from the Velas

The week before the election saw the Velas donate $200,000 to Labour First, or more formally $100,000 each to the constituent Labour and NZ First parties.

The donation was made on 31 October. The EPMU also donated $60,000 that day. Labour revealed the EPMU donation on 5 November, but held off revealing the Vela donations until after the election. They were able to do this legally as you have two weeks to declare large donations.

This reinforces to me the need for a Commission of Inquiry into the matters alleged in the Meurant papers. I hope the Greens keep pushing for it, and that the new Government agrees.

The emerging Government

The Herald reports:

Act leader Rodney Hide and United Future’s sole MP, Peter Dunne, are likely to get ministerial roles outside Cabinet – a deal structure pioneered by Helen Clark.

I’m not very keen on these sort of deals. My belief is that all but the most minor portfolios should be held by Ministers in Cabinet. Call me a traditionalist but the weakening of collective responsibility is a concern. Now to be fair to Key, he is not weakening it – Clark did. He is just not reversing it.

Peters was an example of how badly things can go – a Foreign Affairs Minister who campaigned against the Government’s free trade deal with China. Dunne however did show that you can make such an arrangement work.

While Mr Hide is making strong comments about the policies, he is also saying he has no bottom lines in the negotiations.

“We were clear in this campaign that we would support John Key as Prime Minister,” he said.

“We will honour that commitment. We’re not about to swing our toys out of the sandpit because we don’t get what we want.”

A very mature approach, and one which will probably please many of their voters who want stability.

Never let it be said Labour doesn’t have a sense of humour

If there was no threshold

Graeme Edgeler has calculated what Parliament would look like if there was no 5% threshold. It would be:

New Zealand National Party – 55 seats
New Zealand Labour Party – 41 seats
The Greens – 8 seats
New Zealand First Party – 5 seats
Māori Party – 5 seats
Act New Zealand – 4 seats
Jim Anderton’s Progressive – 1 seat
United Future New Zealand – 1 seat
The Kiwi Party – 1 seat
The Bill and Ben Party – 1 seat

Now you need 62 seats to be Government. So a centre-right group  would be:

National 55 + ACT 4 + United Future 1 + Kiwi Party 1 = 61/122 – not quite there

And centre-left could be:

Labour 41 + Greens 8 + NZ First 5 + Progressive 1 + Maori 5 = 60/122

So the Government would be decided by the Bill and Ben Party. They would either be the swing vote on every law in a centre-right Government, or they would force new elections by hanging the Parliament at 61 each.

This illustrates nicely why those who call for there to be no threshold needs to see a psychiatrist!

I actually support lowering the threshold to 4% as the Royal Commission recommended, but I don’t fancy a system where almost inevitably the balance of power is held by 1% fringe parties.

Herald on Helen

A fairly well balanced editorial:

Her talents and achievements are well documented in uniting Labour and finding a path of restraining free-market economics while overseeing strong growth, reduced debt and, for all but the final months, admirable fiscal discipline.

As is her peerless representation of New Zealand abroad, a leader of the highest intellect and international credentials impatient to keep this country relevant and connected.

A measure of success will be that the Clark Government’s signature policies will likely survive defeat. Her “fear” expressed on election night of Labour’s achievements being lost in a right-wing bonfire seemed smaller-minded and less confident of her legacy than a realistic commentator would offer.

By winning three elections she did tilt the centre towards the left successfully.

She was simultaneously the best and worst thing going for her party, and its chief strategist for this election. On both strategic and tactical levels she contributed to the “time for a change” mentality that will deliver power to her rival, John Key. This last term Labour blurred in its own mind its interests as a private political party and those of the public. From the beginning, the intransigence over repaying the $800,000 of taxpayers’ money unlawfully spent on the 2005 election for the “pledge card” set a tone of retaining power above all. Things worsened rather than improved after that scandal. The result was the malignant Electoral Finance Act which, stripped of all artifice, was aimed at preventing Labour losing power.

The Electoral Finance Act will be one of the biggest millstones to her legacy. Not just the Act per se, but the way it was done – shattering any bipartisan co-operation over electoral issues. The damage from this, is yet to be fully realised.

Helen Clark’s uncharacteristic failure to read correctly the court of public opinion on Winston Peters and his party’s litany of political abuses has received its jury verdict.

In sticking with New Zealand First to save itself, Labour was guilty by association, guilty on all counts, with no recommendation for mercy. When governments see power as an end in itself rather than a means to an end, voters usually withdraw it.

Making the election campaign about “trust” was another error. While the word stuck, and was thus a successful touchstone for voters, it perversely made them think about many minor issues on which Labour had lost trust. Running a campaign which until the final leaders’ debate was universally negative on the opponent must surely call into question the Prime Minister’s acumen. Sanctioning, if not “running”, the fatal tactical move of trawling 20-year-old Australian court records of a major fraud to discredit Mr Key showed a hollowness unheard of in the early years.

Never has an election campaign been so negative or personal. Think I am exaggerating. Name any other election campaign where every single television advertisement was negative? Not a single positive advertisement? And then think again if you can recall when 100% of the negative ads were not attacking on policy, or on a party’s record, but targetting the leader personally as untrustworthy. The ads in themselves were not the most negative we have seen – in fact far from it. But to run an entire campaign of nothing but negative attacks aimed personally at the Opposition Leader is unheard of – and it is a good thing it did not work – in fact backfired.

A new way to end an interview

Was on the phone to Radio NZ being as part of The Panel discussion with Jim Mora and Brian Edwards. We were discussing John Key’s options with Maori Party and ACT, then suddenly I heard some bells in the background, and it seems the fire alarm went off at Radio New Zealand.

As they said they had to go, I told them I hoped it was a false alarm!

How did the pollsters go?

So how did the pollsters go? I will do an updated post once we have final results, but here is the situation for now:

Actual TVNZ TV3 Herald Fairfax Morgan
National 45.5% 47.0% 46.0% 47.9% 49.0% 42.0%
Labour 33.8% 35.0% 33.1% 36.4% 31.0% 34.5%
Green 6.4% 9.0% 9.0% 5.8% 8.0% 10.0%
NZ First 4.2% 2.4% 3.4% 3.9% 3.0% 4.5%
Maori 2.2% 1.3% 2.7% 2.3% 3.0% 2.5%
United Future 0.9% 0.0% 0.2% 0.7% 1.0% 1.0%
ACT 3.7% 2.5% 2.8% 1.8% 4.0% 4.0%
Progressive 0.9% 0.0% 0.3% 0.2% 0.0% 0.0%

There are numerous ways one can judge accuracy. We’ll look at results for each party, the results for the National-Labour margin and then finally the average they were out overall.

National – TV3 were closest – just 0.5% out

Labour – TV3 and Morgan were both closest – each out by 0.7% but on different sides

Green – Herald were closest – 0.6% below. The cloest above was Fairfax at 1.6% too high.

NZ First – Morgan and Herald both 0.3% out – one above and one below.

Maori – Herald near dead on at 0.1% too high

United Future – Fairfax and Morgan both just 0.1% too high

ACT – Fairfax and Morgan both 0.3% out only

Progressive – No one had them close – TV3 closest at 0.3%. This is because people vote for Anderton’s name on the ballot, not Progressive, I suspect.

National-Labour gap. It is (for now) 11.7%. TVNZ had it at 12%, TV at 12.9%, Herald at 11.5%, Fairfax at 18% and Morgan at 7.5%. The last two were pretty far out. The other three can all be pretty pleased. I won’t call a winner until final result.

Average difference – If you average the difference for all eight parties, then the average “out” was 1.4% for TVNZ and Fairfax, 1.2% Morgan, 1.1% Herald and 0.9% TV3. But this is a bit misleading as it treats being 1% out for 50% the same as being 1% out for 5%. For the final results, I may look at whether they were within the margin of errors.

In the end four of the five polling companies correctly picked a centre-right Government without needing the Maori Party. Roy Morgan was the only dissenter, but to be fair to them their poll was done over two weeks, while the others were done over a few days from the end of the second week to middle of the last week.

The new MPs

So who are the new MPs?

National

  1. Steven Joyce – List – likely to be the Honourable Steven Joyce shortly
  2. Sam Lotu-liga – Maungakiekie – hugely respected and over-turned a huge majority. One day will be National’s first Pacific Minister.
  3. Hekia Parata -very very well connected in Maoridom. Not going to be a Minister straight away but will be talking to the Maori Party a lot.
  4. Melissa Lee – already highprofile as the host of Asian downunder.
  5. Kanwal JS Bakshi – needs to convince everyone that the immigration issues raised before the election are not going to be a problem. Adds diversity as New Zealand’s first Sikh MP.
  6. Paul Quinn – Paul will be a good parliamentary brawler in the debating chamber and also be a most welcome addition to the Parliamentary Debating Team. Hekia will beat him into Cabinet, but not by much I reckon.
  7. Michael Woodhouse -Dunedin’s new National’s List MP. His private sector health background will see him on Tony Ryall’s speed dial.
  8. Simon Bridges – Tauranga – the giant killer. Simon will be the most popular MP in Parliament (including with Labour MPs) for killing Winston off in Tauranga.
  9. Amy Adams – Selwyn – the selection battle was harder than the general election battle. Well thought of by those who have dealt with her professionally.
  10. Louise Upston – Taupo. Achieved a huge majority and should keep the seat for the foreseeable future.
  11. Todd McClay – Rotorua. Also achieved a good majority but not as safe as Taupo so will focus on his seat. Can now bring his father out of protective custody 🙂
  12. Tim Macindoe – Hamilton West. This was Tim’s third go at Parliament and would have been his last if he had not made it – but he did. Will be very focused on Hamilton issues.
  13. Aaron Gilmore – List – didn’t win Christchurch East but with a likely Dalziel retirement in 2011, will go all out to snatch it next time.
  14. Nikki Kaye – Auckland Central. Arguably the most popular victory in the country, after Tauranga. I had one former Clark staffer say something along the lines of “Thank God for that” when it was confirmed Nikki had won AUckland Central. Auckland Central remains a red/green seat and Nikki will be very focused on being an outstanding local MP to retain it in 2011.
  15. Cam Calder – List – will have a nervous ten days waiting to find out if he keeps his list place or not.
  16. Jonathan Young – New Plymouth – one of the biggest surprises was his defeat of Harry Duynhoven. A very genial and dedicated worker who put in the hard yards.

Labour

  1. Rajen Prasad – List- may have been a Minister if they had won but now is just going to be a wasted figure in Opposition as his age suggests he is here for one or two terms only. Helped Labour with the Indian vote.
  2. Jacinda Ardern – List- highly respected and regarded and will be a very effective Opposition MP. A near cert for Cabinet once Labour gets back in. Has international responsibilities so may have a lower domestic profile initially.
  3. Raymond Huo – List – a very good fundraiser for Labour. Don’t know enough on whether he will suit the parliamentary environment.
  4. Phil Twyford – List- already a seasoned politician and another future Minister. He will rise quickly.
  5. Carol Beaumont – lost what was an ultra safe seat for Labour. Mixed views on her tenure with the CTU. Will perform better than some of the other unionists turned MPs though.
  6. Kelvin Davis – List – Labour have lost Mahara Okeroa and gained Kelvin Davis. That is a good exchange.
  7. Carmel Sepuloni – a lot of people are excited about her. Young, female, Pacific and a bit dynamic I hear.
  8. Stuart Nash – like Twyford, very likely to rise through the ranks. Has some real charisma.
  9. Clare Curran – Dunedin South. CHallenge for her is to establish herself an an excellent MP and disassociate herself from previous controversy.
  10. Grant Robertson – Wellington Central – Grant will be one of the strongest Opposition MPs in attacking the Government. 100% political. Likely unoffical ringleader of the 2008 intake.
  11. Chris Hipkins – Rimutaka. Like Grant, also a 9th floor staffer. He won Rimutaka narrowly and will be focused on building up that majority.
  12. Iain Lees-Galloway – Palmerston North. Did well to beat Malcolm Plimmer who was ahead in a newspaper poll and had high name awareness having stood previously. The only seat Labour won which surprised me.  Don’t know much about him.
  13. Brendon Burns – Christchurch Central. Very talented, but not universally popular. Main focus will be on building up his majority, but likely to have a backroom role in Labour communications despite being a new MP.

Green

  1. Kevin Hague – former CEO of a District Health Board. A strong performer who should do well and may even appeal to some non Greens voters.
  2. Catherine Delahunty – well liked within Greens, but opponents will enjoy citing some of her radical previous statements.

ACT

  1. Roger Douglas – needs no introduction from me. Key challenge for Key and Hide is to find him something useful to do.
  2. John Boscawen – will be prominent over repealing the Electoral Finance Act.
  3. David Garrett – will not be a minister but may end up having some influence on Government’s law and order policies

Maori

  1. Rahui Katene – Te Tai Tonga -main challenge is to emulate her four colleagues and take the seat from a narrow victory to ultra-safe.

State of the Parties

So how are things looking for the parties. Let’s take things in reverse order:

Progressives

Did better than expected on 0.9% – enough to avoid overhang but well off getting a second MP. The party is effectively over and doesn’t really serve any useful purpose now they are in Opposition (in Government they did have a somewhat different brand to Labour). I will not be surprised to see Anderton rejoin Labour during this term and Progressives windup. Anderton presumably will retire next election.

United Future

Like Progressive, United Future is basically over. Enough votes to avoid overhang but well off a second MP. Peter will have got a bit of a nasty shock that his majority has been slashed to under 2,000 and this is probably his final term as I expect both National and Labour will aim to win the seat next time.

Maori Party

Not that good an election for them. It could have been worse – they did win Te Tai Tonga but they are quite gutted not to win Ikaroa-Rawhiti especially. Their party vote barely lifted and they don’t hold the balance of power. However if they are sensible they will negotiate an abstain on supply and confidence with National in exchange for some policy wins. Their big challenge will be differentiating from Labour’s Maori MPs to give people a reason to keep supporting them. There is a remote chance they will take up Ministerial positions outside Cabinet – they will be worried doing so will risk Labour winning seats back off them. However they can make the case that National could have governed without them, and by accepting the roles they got to deliver some wins to Maoridom.

New Zealand First

It is all over. Winston won’t stand again in Tauranga and unless National did something monumentally stupid like cut super, NZ First won’t stand anywhere.

I suspect Ron Mark will become Leader and maybe give Rimutaka another try, but it is doubtful they’ll make 1% without an incumbent MP and/or Winston.

The big question is where will NZ First voters go? National? Labour? There is in fact an opportunity for a new party to hoover up the NZ First, Kiwi Party and Family Party that got 5.1% between them. They all have social conservatism in common. If United Future disappears also, then you may have up to 6% looking for a home.

Greens

In some ways the Greens are the big losers from this election, despite getting two more MPs. But they had polls showing them getting up to 11.5% and they only got 6.4%. Labour lost bigtime also, but at least they got to spend nine years in Government. The Greens have spent their first nine years locked out of Government and now face say another six years in Opposition where they will struggle to compete with Labour who will agree with them on most issues now. And when Labour do come back in, the Maori Party will have a stronger negotiating position than the Greens.

On the positive side they did get two more MPs and maybe could get a third. Delahunty is seen as an exremists, but Hague is a solid performer and Kennedy Graham could add to theri voter appeal.

ACT

The result is a total vindication for Rodney Hide. If ACT has not grown their number of MPs, they would have become like the Progressive Party – doomed to die with the Leader. But they have grown ACT so that it is a credible force for the future. This is great not just for ACT but the centre-right. Without ACT long-term there would be just four parties – Labour, Greens, Maori and National. Under that scenario centre-right Govts will be rare. With ACT in the picture it is more balanced.

The challenge for ACT is to get some policy wins from National. With 5 MPs they need to be able to show they delivered to their supporters. But they need to balance that with not forcing John Key into doing anything that could be seem to betray those who voted for him and his leadership.

ACT should also push for two Ministers – Rodney and Heather. They make up 1/12th of the Government so they should get 1/12th of the Executive which is two Ministerial roles. Heather would be a very competent Minister I am sure.

Labour

Clark and Cullen have resigned. It is a mark of their political judgement that they have decided to step down immediately. Staying on for even six months would just have meant a period of destabilising headlines.

Phil Goff will be the new Leader I predict. If the ballot has been delayed even a year, then maybe not. But I suspect he may be elected unoppossed.

The interesting thing will be Deputy. It has to be a female or a Maori to keep factions happy. I somehow can’t see Goff happy with Maryan Street as his Deputy (and I see she has ruled herself out) so suspect Annette King could take the job. However they are both from the right-leaning part of Caucus so there may be opposition to that. King is widely regarded by all her MPs though. Jones is a possible for Deputy but making him Deputy would lead to speculation as to when he will roll Goff.

Goff will get one chance only, like Mike Moore. If he does not win in 2011, then others will be ready by then. There is even a chance he would get rolled before 2011 if they do not perform in the polls.

Goff is a very capable politician, but his big problem is he entered Parliament under Muldoon. It will be hard to brand him as the fresh face for the future when he has been an MP for 30 years by the time of the next election.

If Labour are smart they will make Cunliffe Shadow Finance Minister.

National

Key has a number of challenges and opportunities.

He needs to do a deal with ACT that works for both of them. Gives ACT some wins, but doesn’t undermine his centrist brand. However having said that, people have to realise the public did not vote for a National Government – they did elect a National-ACT Government (plus United Future).

His other challenge is the Maori Party – it would be a coup to bring them on board as Ministers. This is ironic as most PMs would rather keep all portfolios for their own party, but long-term having Sharples and Turia as Ministers would send a message about working with the Maori Party. It would also allow National to do some stuff in welfare, that they could not do by themselves.

Putting together the Cabinet is the next challenge. To put it bluntly there are too many contenders and some will be disappointed. Key will need some of the 1990s Ministers for their experience and stability, but signal to those MPs that they should not expect a six to nine year term in Cabinet this time around – more likely 2 – 3 years max, so that going into 2011 the majority of Ministers are from the 2002, 2005 and even 2008 intakes.

A fourth challenge is a large Caucus of 59. But unlike 1990, there is no long tail of Gilbert Myles types to manage. One or two may present some challenges but generally the new intake is talented and ambitious. That may be the longer term challenge – keeping them happy as Government backbenchers whose main job is to move “That the motion now be put” in committee of the whole debates 🙂

The 2005 intake will also need some managing. A few of them will make Cabinet but most won’t – yet. They will probably be the Select Committee Chairs as Ministers in waiting, and these appointments will also have to be negotiated with other parties.

Winston

A nasty delay

No I am not talking hospital waiting lists or traffic jams. I’m talking hangovers.

Woke up this morning with the Mother of all Hangovers. But I wasn’t out drinking last night. Yes, it was Saturday Night’s delayed.

I’m glad elections are only once every three years!

A blue country

Parliamentary Demographics

Some interesting demographics looking at the 122 provisional MPs:

  1. 18 Maori MPs, 14.8% of Parliament
  2. 5 Pacific MPs, 4.1% of Parliament
  3. 6 Asian MPs, 4.9% of Parliament
  4. 41 female MPs, 33.6% of Parliament

The number of Maori MPs is down slightly as NZ First had three Maori MPs. The number of female MPs is up three to an all time record of 41.

What is interesting is the demographics per party.

For the first time ever National has as many Maori MPs as Labour – six each. Plus there are five Maori Party MPs and Turei in the Greens.

But in another first, National has more female MPs than Labour – 17 to 16. Now National has a bigger Caucus, and as percentages it is 29% to 37%, but it is still a historic first to have more in absolute numbers.

MPs going

National

  1. Mark Blumsky – retired
  2. Katherine Rich – retired
  3. Bob Clarkson – retired
  4. Brian Connell – retired
  5. Clem SImich – retired

Labour

  1. Tim Barnett – retired
  2. David Benson-Pope – not reselected
  3. Mark Burton – defeated in Taupo
  4. Harry Duynhoven – defeated in New Plymouth
  5. Russell Fairbrother – defeated in Napier
  6. Martin Gallagher – defeated in Hamilton West
  7. Mark Gosche – retired
  8. Dave Hereora – defeated
  9. Marian Hobbs – retired
  10. Damien O’Connor – defeated in West Coast-Tasman
  11. Mahara Okeroa – defeated in Te Tai Tonga
  12. Jill Pettis – retired
  13. Dover Samuels – retired
  14. Lesley Soper – defeated
  15. Paul Swain – retired
  16. Judith Tizard – defeated in Auckland Central
  17. Louisa Wall – defeated
  18. Margaret Wilson – retired

Labour lost seats by back in on list

  1. Steve Chadwick – lost Rotorua
  2. Darren Hughes – lost Otaki
  3. Lynne Pillay – lost Waitakere

New Zealand First

  1. Winston Peters – defeated in Tauranga
  2. Peter Brown – defeated
  3. Dail Jones – defeated
  4. Ron Mark – defeated
  5. Pita Paraone – defeated
  6. Barbara Stewart – defeated
  7. Doug Woolerton – defeated

United Future

  1. Judy Turner – defeated

Independents

  1. Taito Philip Field – defeated in Mangere
  2. Gordon Copeland – defeated

So that is a total of 33/121 MPs leaving Parliament, and hence 34 new MPs entering. I’ll look at the new MPs later.