The new Parliament

This may change with specials

National

  1. John Key – Helensville
  2. Bill English – Clutha Southland
  3. Gerry Brownlee – Ilam
  4. Simon Power – Rangitikei]
  5. Nick Smith – Nelson
  6. Tony Ryall – Bay of Plenty
  7. Judith Collins – Papakura
  8. Maurice Williamson – Pakuranga
  9. David Carter – List #1
  10. Anne Tolley – East Coast
  11. Murray McCully – East Coast Bays
  12. Lockwood Smith – Rodney
  13. Wayne Mapp – North Shore
  14. Chris Finlayson – List #2
  15. Tim Groser – List #3
  16. Steven Joyce – List #4
  17. Georgina te Heuheu – List #5
  18. Nathan Guy – Otaki
  19. Lindsay Tisch – Waikato
  20. Pansy Wong – Botany
  21. John Carter – Northland
  22. Phil Heatley – Whangarei
  23. Paul Hutchison – Hunua
  24. Shane Ardern – Taranaki-King Country
  25. Richard Worth – List #6
  26. Tau Henare – List #7
  27. Sandra Goudie – Coromandel
  28. Eric Roy – Invercargill
  29. Jonathan Coleman – Northcote
  30. Kate Wilkinson – List #8
  31. Chris Tremain – Napier
  32. Chester Borrows – Whanganui
  33. Craig Foss – Tukituki
  34. Allan Peachey – Tamaki
  35. Sam Lotu-liga – Maungakiekie
  36. Hekia Parata – List #9
  37. Melissa Lee – List #10
  38. Kanwal JS Bakshi – List #11
  39. Jo Goodhew – Rangitata
  40. Jacqui Dean – Waitaki
  41. Paula Bennett – Waitakere
  42. Chris Auchinvole – West Coast-Tasman
  43. Nicky Wagner – List #12
  44. David Bennett – Hamilton East
  45. Jackie Blue – List #13
  46. Katrina Shanks – List #14
  47. Colin King – Kaikoura
  48. Paul Quinn – List #15
  49. Michael Woodhouse – List #16
  50. John Hayes – Wairarapa
  51. Simon Bridges – Tauranga
  52. Amy Adams – Selwyn
  53. Louise Upston – Taupo
  54. Todd McClay – Rotorua
  55. Tim Macindoe – Hamilton West
  56. Aaron Gilmore – List #17
  57. Nikki Kaye – Auckland Central
  58. Cam Calder – List #18
  59. Jonathan Young – New Plymouth

Labour

  1. Helen Clark – Mt Albert
  2. Michael Cullen – List #1
  3. Phil Goff – Mt Roskill
  4. Annette King – Rongotai
  5. Parekura Horomia – Ikaroa-Rawhiti
  6. Pete Hodgson – Dunedin North
  7. Chris Carter – Te Atatu
  8. David Cunliffe – New Lynn
  9. Maryan Street – List #2
  10. Nanaia Mahuta – Hauraki-Waikato
  11. Winnie Laban – Mana
  12. Rajen Prasad – List #3
  13. Ruth Dyson – Port Hills
  14. Trevor Mallard – Hutt South
  15. Lianne Dalziel – Christchurch East
  16. Shane Jones – List #4
  17. David Parker – List #5
  18. Clayton Cosgrove – Waimakariri
  19. Darren Hughes – List #6
  20. Jacinda Ardern – List #7
  21. Raymond Huo – List #8
  22. Sue Moroney – List #9
  23. Mita Ririnui – List #10
  24. William Sio – Mangere
  25. Moana Mackey – List #11
  26. Phil Twyford – List #12
  27. Charles Chauvel – List #13
  28. Carol Beaumont – List #14
  29. Kelvin Davis – List #15
  30. Steve Chadwick – List #16
  31. Ashraf Choudhary – List #17
  32. Lynne Pillay – List #18
  33. Darien Fenton – List #19
  34. Rick Barker – List 20
  35. Carmel Sepuloni – List #21
  36. Stuart Nash – List #22
  37. Clare Curran – Dunedin South
  38. Grant Robertson – Grant Robertson
  39. Chris Hipkins – Rimutaka
  40. Iain Lees-Galloway – Palmerston North
  41. Brendon Burns – Christchurch Central
  42. Ross Robertson – Manukau East
  43. George Hawkins – Manurewa

Green

  1. Jeanette Fitzsimons
  2. Russel Norman
  3. Sue Bradford
  4. Metira Turei
  5. Sue Kedgley
  6. Keith Locke
  7. Kevin Hague
  8. Catherine Delahunty

ACT

  1. Rodney Hide – Epsom
  2. Heather Roy
  3. Roger Douglas
  4. John Boscawen
  5. David Garrett

Maori

  1. Tariana Turia – Te Tai Hauauru
  2. Pita Sharples – Tamaki Makaurau
  3. Hone Harawira – Te Tai Tokerau
  4. Te Ururoa Flavell – Waiariki
  5. Te Tai Tonga – Rahui Katene

United Future

  1. Peter Dunne – Ohariu

Progressive

  1. Jim Anderton – Wigram

I think these are right. Let me know if they are not. Congratulations to the MPs who made it.

For those interested the next candidate on each list is Conway Powell for National, Damien O’Connor for Labour and Kennedy Graham for the Greens.

What might happen on specials?

I’ve just plugged the provisional count numbers into the St Lague formula. The allocation is:

  1. National 59
  2. Labour 43
  3. Greens 8
  4. Maori 3 (+2 overhang)
  5. United Future 1
  6. ACT 5

Now who is most at risk from specials? They are the party that is in List Spot 120. And that is National.

The quotient for National is 951145/117 = 8129.4. And who is in spot 121? Labour with 706666/87 = 8122.6.

Very roughly if Labour pick up 600 more votes relative to National, then they get one more List MP, and National loses one. That is not at all impossible.

But could someone else grab it off National. The Greens have spot 124, being 134622/17 = 7918.9. They would need to gain an extra 3,600 votes (on top of their existing proportion of votes) from specials. That is a bit of an ask, but they have done well on special traditionally.

Now that was a party

Oh what a night. I don’t think I have hugged or been hugged by so many people before. The Young Nats President even managed to lift me off the ground with his hug which was atruly remarkable President.

It is hard to put into words what the emotion was like. A mixture of elation and relief. It has in fact been 18 years since there has been a “clear” victory for the centre-right on an election night.

John Key did a magnificent speech. Funniest line was thanking his kids but then telling them there is no puppy. He was literally surrounded by a dozen DPS – I wonder if he had that many at the beginning of the night!

At Sky City, the party was great. So many good good people, and very kind people. It was almost scary how many people read the blogs religiously and can quote back to you things you said.

And huge cheers for the three new electorate MPs of Paula Bennett, Nikki Kaye and Pesata Sam Lotu-Iaga. Labour lost in Auckland every seat that was losable, and only the hard hard core in West and South Auckland remains.  And outside Auckland Labour has just one seat left in the North Island, excluding red Wellington – in Palmerston North. The South Island is the same with Laboru reduced to holding Christchurch and Dunedin only.

Funniest moment was talking to a few of John’s staff, and one of them asked whether their imminent transfer to the 9th floor meant they would get to take over The Standard. It was hilarious as they started fighting over who would be all-your-base and who would be Irish Bill etc 🙂

Afterwards we went to the Viaduct and carried on there for many hours. I don’t quite recall all the details of the evening but as I got woken up at 7 am this morning and found myself having slept on, not in, the bed I guess I just made it home, but only just.

In a fit of stupidity I agreed a few days ago to do some radio with Kerre Woodham this morning and an interview for Sunday with TVNZ. I may come across somewhat incoherently.

Once again I can’t describe how absolutely great it feels to have won, and won well. A clear victory on the night is a rarity under MMP and one to be treasured.

My thoughts do go out to a number of people, even though our politics differ. I’ve had more than enough experience being on the losing side, to empathise with those who supported Labour and/or the left. It is bitter to spend so many hours working for a party you believe in, and for it not to happen. But that does not mean your effort was wasted – the work of activists and supporters is what makes politics good.

Parliamentary staff have a tought time of it. They all lose their jobs – win or lose. Everyone who works for an MP has their job expire in a month. Now those on the winning side are more likely to get rehired, but it is tough to work for a party that loses – as you lose your job as well as your Government. And there are many good people in Parliament working for Labour.

Finally some sympathy for defeated MPs. If you were a Minister you lose your job, your house, your car, your income as well as being in Government.  That is not easy, to say the least. This weekend will be a weekend for celebration, but also a time to thank them for their service.

List MPs

All three goals achieved

I had three goals for tonight. In order they were:

  1. Winston gone
  2. John Key is PM
  3. Nikki Kaye wins Auckland Central

All three have happened. Commiserations to those who supported unsucessful candidates and parties. It is nice to win, and has been a while!

Electorates

A number have fallen or are likely to:

  1. Auckland Central by 1,181
  2. Hamilton West by 1,704
  3. Maungakiekie by 500 with 80% of booths gone
  4. New Plymouth by 300
  5. Otaki by 1,422
  6. Rotorua by 4,369
  7. Taupo by 5,345
  8. Waitakere by 1,059
  9. West Coast Tasman by 975
  10. Te Tai Tonga by 665 to Maori

This reduces Labour electorate seats to 21.

Election Results Thread

The average of the polls

The final average of the public polls from Curiablog is:

  1. National 59 (46.8%)
  2. Labour 44 (34.6%)
  3. Green 10 (8.1%)
  4. ACT 3 (2.6%)
  5. Maori 4 (2.4%)
  6. United Future 1 (0.5%)
  7. Progressive 1 (0.2%)

National/ACT/United Future = 63/122 seats
Labour/Prog/Greens = 55/122 seats

If you take a weighted average of just the last five polls released this week, then National and Labour lose a seat each to ACT and Greens respectively, so not much change to the overall balance.

So if the average of the public polls is correct (and I am not saying it will be), then who will be in and out of Parliament?

The only seats projected to change hands on the basis of boundary changes or public polls are Taupo, Rotorua, and Palmerston North. Personally I think there will be more movement than that, so this is not a prediction – it is just reflecting the seats that had had polls showing a change.

National

  1. John Key – Helensville
  2. Bill English – Clutha Southland
  3. Gerry Brownlee – Ilam
  4. Simon Power – Rangitikei]
  5. Nick Smith – Nelson
  6. Tony Ryall – Bay of Plenty
  7. Judith Collins – Papakura
  8. Maurice Williamson – Pakuranga
  9. David Carter – List #1
  10. Anne Tolley – East Coast
  11. Murray McCully – East Coast Bays
  12. Lockwood Smith – Rodney
  13. Wayne Mapp – North Shore
  14. Chris Finlayson – List #2
  15. Tim Groser – List #3
  16. Steven Joyce – List #4
  17. Georgina te Heuheu – List #5
  18. Nathan Guy – List #6
  19. Lindsay Tisch – Waikato
  20. Pansy Wong – Botany
  21. John Carter – Northland
  22. Phil Heatley – Whangarei
  23. Paul Hutchison – Hunua
  24. Shane Ardern – Taranaki-King Country
  25. Richard Worth – List #7
  26. Tau Henare – List #8
  27. Sandra Goudie – Coromandel
  28. Eric Roy – Invercargill
  29. Jonathan Coleman – Northcote
  30. Kate Wilkinson – List #9
  31. Chris Tremain – Napier
  32. Chester Borrows – Whanganui
  33. Craig Foss – Tukituki
  34. Allan Peachey – Tamaki
  35. Sam Lotu-liga – List #10
  36. Hekia Parata – List #11
  37. Melissa Lee – List #12
  38. Kanwal JS Bakshi – List #13
  39. Jo Goodhew – Rangitata
  40. Jacqui Dean – Waitaki
  41. Paula Bennett – List #14
  42. Chris Auchinvole – List #15
  43. Nicky Wagner – List #16
  44. David Bennett – Hamilton East
  45. Jackie Blue – List #17
  46. Katrina Shanks – List #18
  47. Colin King – Kaikoura
  48. Paul Quinn – List #19
  49. Michael Woodhouse – List #20
  50. John Hayes – Wairarapa
  51. Simon Bridges – Tauranga
  52. Amy Adams – Selwyn
  53. Louise Upston – Taupo
  54. Todd McClay – Rotorua
  55. Tim Macindoe – List #21
  56. Aaron Gilmore – List #22
  57. Nikki Kaye – List #23
  58. Cam Calder – List #24
  59. Malcolm Plimmer – Palmerston North

Labour

  1. Helen Clark – Mt Albert
  2. Michael Cullen – List #1
  3. Phil Goff – Mt Roskill
  4. Annette King – Rongotai
  5. Parekura Horomia – Ikaroa-Rawhiti
  6. Pete Hodgson – Dunedin North
  7. Chris Carter – Te Atatu
  8. David Cunliffe – New Lynn
  9. Maryan Street – List #2
  10. Nanaia Mahuta – Hauraki-Waikato
  11. Winnie Laban – Mana
  12. Rajen Prasad – List #3
  13. Ruth Dyson – Port Hills
  14. Trevor Mallard – Hutt South
  15. Lianne Dalziel – Christchurch East
  16. Shane Jones – List #4
  17. David Parker – List #5
  18. Clayton Cosgrove – Waimakariri
  19. Darren Hughes – Otaki
  20. Jacinda Ardern – List #6
  21. Raymond Huo – List #7
  22. Sue Moroney – List #8
  23. Mita Ririnui – List #9
  24. William Sio – Mangere
  25. Moana Mackey – List #10
  26. Phil Twyford – List #11
  27. Charles Chauvel – List #12
  28. Carol Beaumont – Maungakiekie
  29. Kelvin Davis – List #13
  30. Steve Chadwick – List #14
  31. Ashraf Choudhary – List #15
  32. Lynne Pillay – Waitakere
  33. Darien Fenton – List #16
  34. Damien O’Connor – West Coast-Tasman
  35. Judith Tizard – AUckland Central
  36. Mahara Okeroa – Te Tai Tonga
  37. Martin Gallagher – Hamilton West
  38. Clare Curran – Dunedin South
  39. Grant Robertson – Grant Robertson
  40. Chris Hipkins – Rimutaka
  41. Brendon Burns – Christchurch Central
  42. Ross Robertson – Manukau East
  43. George Hawkins – Manurewa
  44. Harry Duynhoven

Green

  1. Jeanette Fitzsimons
  2. Russel Norman
  3. Sue Bradford
  4. Metira Turei
  5. Sue Kedgley
  6. Keith Locke
  7. Kevin Hague
  8. Catherine Delahunty
  9. Kennedy Graham
  10. David Clendon

ACT

  1. Rodney Hide – Epsom
  2. Heather Roy
  3. Roger Douglas

Maori

  1. Tariana Turia – Te Tai Hauauru
  2. Pita Sharples – Tamaki Makaurau
  3. Hone Harawira – Te Tai Tokerau
  4. Te Ururoa Flavell – Waiariki

United Future

  1. Peter Dunne – Ohariu

Progressive

  1. Jim Anderton – Wigram

I stress again these are not predictions. They are what the public polls indicate, but polls have not been done in all seats.

The last four months

I’ve been tracking the public polls on a date and size weighted average since the beginning of July. The graphs of these are below:

When new polls come out, they cause the spikes. National declined over July from 54% to around 50% and then stayed there until the beginning of the campaign in early October. There was a jolt down to 48% initially but then generally held up finishing at 47%.

Labour has two good months in July and August going from 31% to 37%. But then they flatlined and decreased slightly ending up at 35%.

The Greens had a bad July to Septemer falling from 75% to 5% and hovering around the threshold. But the campaign period worked for them and they had a very steady rise over a month to finish at 8%.

NZ First started at around 4% and at times looked like getting 5%. The various scandals pushed him down below 3% and he has flatlined there for the last two months. A small lift in the final days but finishes at 3.2%.

Maori Party has changed little hovering between 2% and 3% – their focus has been the Maori seats.

ACT in July were at 1% and stayed there until the end of August and they have had little lifts through ending up at 2.5% and may go higher on the day as they made 3% in the final week’s polls.

United Future and Progressive are both basically flatlined – United Future at around 0.5% and Progressive at around 0.2%.

Election Eve

Had a fun time out drinking last night. A very mixed group with Chris Trotter (wearing a Labour rosette!), Keith Locke (Greens), Joe Hendren (Alliance/NDU) and a couple of UNITE staffers plus Ben Thomas (NBR) and Hamilton Blonde (SAHM-WLP).

We were at Galbraiths and I was disappointed to learn I missed Helen doding a flying visit at 6pm. But regardless was a good time with lots of interesting conversation. We all wrote election predictions down on a beer coaster. God knows who has it – I can’t even recall what I predicted.

Today I need to do three things – haircut, vote and swot up on 2005 results – not in that order.

General Debate 8 November 2008

Ten reasons to vote to change the Government tomorrow and to vote National

  1. The New Zealand economy is facing the most challenging international circumstances since the 1930s. To get through it with a minimum of damage to people’s jobs and incomes will require a Government that has an unrelenting focus on economic growth – just as Kevin Rudd does.
  2. Winston. If Governments get away with tolerating Ministers who blatantly lie, then the message it will send is that you get rewarded for lying to the public, The behaviour of Peters has been a disgrace, and only exceeded by the Prime Minister’s tolerance and defence of it. It will be healthy for Labour to get punished at the polls, so that next time they are in this situation their response will be not to tolerate corruption instead of making excuses for it. Rewarding Labour with a fourth term for covering up for Winston would be an awful message to send.
  3. Healthcare. The ideological jihad against the private sector must stop. It is literally killing people. A coordinated approach to using all the resources out there will lead to better outcomes for those who need top quality healthcare.
  4. Tax. If Labour is returned it is almost inevitable they will massively increase taxes in their secret December mini-budget. They have shown an inability to keep a lid on spending over the last nine years. The best you can get under Labour is that they will not cancel the tax cuts already legislated. Under National you will have a Government that knows it is spending your money and will work hard to reduce taxes so families have more in their pockets.
  5. The Electoral Finance Act. Need more be said. National will repeal it immediately (while leaving in place transparency around donations). Labour will make it worse, exempt their own MPs from much of it, and introduce full taxpayer funding of political parties.
  6. Law & Order. We saw this week that Brad Shipton gets out in under three years for a pack rape with a sentence of almost nine year. Sickening. But this is no accident. Labour deliberately changed the law in 2001 to allow rapists and violent criminals to get parole after one third instead of two thirds of their sentence. I have no idea why, but they did. We don’t necessarily have a lot of criminals in NZ – we just keep letting them out to keep committing crimes. National will I am sure will be tougher on criminals. Labour have said they see no need for further changes and that the status quo is acceptable.
  7. Public Service Independence. Where does one start? The Police Commissioner hounded out of office on Helen Clark’s lies (this is beyond dispute). Madeleine Setchell and Erin Leigh. The attacks on the Auditor-General for doing his job over the illegal Parliamentary spending. The disgraceful behaviour towards the Director of the Serious Fraud Office because he exposed the truth about Winston’s donations. A neutral and independent public service is preferable to the US model where politicians appoint their supporters to everything. Throwing out Labour will help restore an independent public service.
  8. Education. By the time kids are at secondary school, it is too late if they can not read or write. Their future prospects are blighted and wasted. National’s focus on early detection and intervention for children who can not read, write or count could be the most important thing they do. National will spend more money on eight year olds that can’t vote than 18 year olds that can.
  9. Moderation or Radicalism? A John Key led Government will change direction and policies from Labour, but not radically so. The focus will be on improving economic growth, jobs and incomes. National looks to make up around 95% of a National-led Government. The alternative will be an unstable radical Government where Labour makes up less than 75% of it, and economic growth will be well down the list of priorities of its coalition partners. National, ACT and United Future may disagree somewhat on the policies for economic growth but they all see them as vital. The Green Party sees economic growth as a necessary evil, and to be tolerated only under duress. Chris Trotter said that a Labour/Green/Maori Party Government would be the most leftwing Government in 70 years, and he was right.
  10. John Key. He will be a great Prime Minister. Give him the chance to prove it.

I decided to stop at 10. I should probably also mention the 75% of homes to have fibre within six years as another reason. This is achievable and it will make a huge difference to New Zealand in terms of competitive advantage, plus changing where and how we work.

No matter who you vote for, make sure you vote tomorrow.

DPF from somewhere near Cambridge!

Kiwis in London

If you’re in London and looking for a place to watch the election, there’s an Election Day Champagne Brunch being held on Saturday at 10am downstairs at The Southerner pub, near Temple tube. A plasma screen has been specially wired up to watch coverage via the Internet.

Supporters from all parties are welcomed and expected. The event has been organised by the Kiwi Greens in London.

Afterwards there’s the opportunity to watch the end of the Lord Mayor’s procession which passes by outside The Southerner; the Lord Mayor’s show finishes with a firework display at 5pm from a barge moored in the Thames.

Saturday 8th November, 10am – 2pm

The Southerner, Essex Street, Temple, WC2R 1AP http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&hl=en&q=Essex+Street%2C+Temple%2C+WC2R+1AP%2C+London%2C+United+Kingdom

http://www.facebook.com/event.php?eid=28986285735

ACT

Strengthen the Coalition! Party Vote ACT

John and I are talking. Now it’s your turn to have your say.

You want to dump Helen Clark. You can vote either National or ACT.

Voting National will dump Helen Clark. Voting ACT will dump Helen Clark AND dump her policies.

Party Vote ACT to make our streets safe: Three Strikes and You are Out.

Party vote ACT to dump the dopey Emissions Trading Scheme.

Party Vote ACT to cap the growth in government expenditure: stop the waste.

Party vote ACT for ACT’s top five MPs; not National’s bottom five.

Strengthen the Coalition: Party Vote ACT!

(Note the above is a guest post by Rodney Hide)

United Future

If people want a change of Government on Saturday, there are only three parties you should vote for. Any other vote may help bring about a Labour/Progressive/NZ First/Green/Maori Party coalition that would be the most left wing Government in 70 years.

The three parties that will lead to a change of Government are National, ACT and United Future. I invoted all three party leaders to send me something on why people should consider vote for them. First is Peter Dunne:

If the polls over the past year, talkback radio, comments on the campaign trail and my own political experience are to be relied upon, then the New Zealand electorate is in the mood for a political change.

This means that on Saturday, the voters will deliver a right-leaning Parliament and National will hold the majority of seats.

Having made that fundamental decision, voters will face the second choice: what flavour of right-leaning, National-led government do they want?

The parties that provide that flavour are UnitedFuture, ACT, the Greens, the Maori party and the Progressives (assuming this is New Zealand First’s final campaign).

The other small parties like the Kiwi party, the Family party, the Legalise Aotearoa party and all the other single issue parties are focussed on single issues like hitting children or getting stoned and can be dismissed as wasteful depositories for your party vote.

The Greens and the Progressives are locked into Labour, so a vote for them is not a vote for change.

That leaves us and ACT committed to working with National, with the Maori party dodging about in the middle.

By elimination therefore, the strategic choice is between UnitedFuture and ACT.

ACT is claiming it will put backbone into National, but it looks more like an ideological straitjacket from where I stand.

Roger Douglas’s 20-point plan that ACT is offering dates from 1987 and represents yesterday’s solutions to yesterday’s problems.

By contrast, UnitedFuture promotes ideas, not ideologies and is focussed on policies that promote jobs and the welfare of families – the cornerstone of our society.

Instead of looking backwards and yearning for yesteryear, we look forward to a simpler, fairer tax system; a health system that uses all its public and private resources so all New Zealanders get first-class healthcare; a tertiary education system that loads up our graduates with knowledge, not debt; a business environment that encourages innovation and growth; and a physical environment that’s clean and healthy for New Zealanders to revel in.

The conclusion is straightforward: party vote UnitedFuture for a change in government, a change you can trust will lead New Zealand forward.

Next up will be ACT.

Labour loses appeal against misleading ad

Hail and Snow

Espiner predicts National victory

Colin Espiner blogs his final thoughts:

It’s all over bar the shouting. As the parties wind up campaigning with a final flurry of handshakes and campaign rallies in Auckland tomorrow, the final polls have come in and the verdict is unanimous: National should win on Saturday.

I say “should” because National has the polling in its favour, it has the momentum, and it is riding the “time for a change” mood that still exists, despite Labour leader Helen Clark’s claims that it has evaporated in the wake of the financial crisis.

Even TV3’s usually Left-leaning TNS poll puts National in the box seat, and actually has Labour’s support down rather than up. It appears as if Mike Williams’s trip to Australia last week to dig dirt on John Key might end up being more costly than Labour had budgeted for.

You know how damaging it is when Helen is on TV saying people should realise they are voting for her, not Mike Williams. Wow that is crapping on him from a big height. They should also realise that Williams is one of her closest friends, her personal choice for party president, the Labour Campaign Manager, in touch with Helen several times a day and she knew all about his attempted smear tactics.

But in Key she met her match on the campaign trail. He was relaxed, friendly, polished, and did not make the sort of blunders Labour was counting on. He surprised Clark by bettering her in the first television leaders’ debate and confidently held his own in the next two as well, blunting Labour’s major advantage in the campaign – Clark’s debating skills.

That first TV debate was a defining moment. It made a huge difference.

In the last few days we’ve had another secret tape, but I have to say that the outing of the taper’s identity as Kees Keizer, a Left-leaning man with links to the Green Party, has done Labour more harm than good. Even though the party was not directly involved, it looks a little desperate. I understand there was another tape – of John Key himself – but either TV3 has chosen not to air it, or Mr Keizer is concerned about a potential backlash from handing it over.

There is immense anger about the vile little tactics of Keizer. Not just from the political right, but those who are not political. And I think Colin is right – this little campaign has backfired on the left.

To give credit to the Greens co-leaders, they did do a press release yesterday explicitly stating they do not condone the use of secret tapings such as Keizer did. Labour has refused to condemn the tactis, and indeed they seem to have set their campaign strategy on the knowledge of what was on some of the tapes.

The balance of probabilities suggests that Key will be our next prime minister, and that we will know this on Saturday evening, without having to wait for the Maori Party to decide for us.

It would be good to have a clean result, so at this time of financial crisis, a Government can be formed quickly. I actually think National will have a better relationship with the Maori Party if they do not have to rely on their abstentions – because then any policy agreements will be based on genuine agreement that they are good policies to pursue.

The final Dispatch from Helengrad?

In what may be my final Dispatch from Helengrad, I look at the polls and adjust them for how far out each poll was in 2005:

The polls do not always get it right, so can we trust the four polls out in the last 24 hours that predict a National-led Government? Didn’t the polls get it wrong last time?

It is true that some polls in 2005 did have a result that was significantly different to the election result. However last time the polls were split with two polls predicting National victory and three a Labour victory. In 2008 the four election eve polls are all saying the same thing – a National-led Government. There may be a Morgan poll out today also, but as of writing it has not been published.

In an analysis not done anywhere else, I am going to look at what the four polls predict for each party, and what happens if you adjust their polls by the margin they were out by last time.

Comments and feedback can be done over at NBR.

A confused Dim-Post

Poor old Danyl is confused and not sure who to vote for. Danyl is a leftie, but one with a sense of right and wrong. He describes his options:

I refuse to vote for the Labour Party on the grounds that it would be an endorsement of their (baffling) loyalty to Winston Peters, a corrupt dishonest bigot. (Think about this weeks charade with the helicopters and ask yourself what inane gibberish this drunken idiot has been telling our trading partners and allies over the last three years.

And even on the eve of the election Helen Clark is defending Winston and saying he has done nothing wrong and been the victim of a beatup. I don’t know how a single leftie could vote for Labour tomorrow and regard it as a principled act. I 100% understand voting for the Greens if you are on the left, but how can those who have spent years campaigning against money in politics be so “We don’t care” about the fact Helen has all but endorsed Winston’s behaviour.

Based on their performance in the campaign I have no confidence in the National Party to competently run the country; Key’s going to win anyway so if he proves me wrong and does a good job he can have my vote in three years time.

Ouch. But an honest opinion. I think Danyl may be surprised at how things turn out, but we’ll see in three years what he thinks.

I’d vote for the Greens – because I care about environmental issues – but their most effective MP by far is Sue Bradford who appears to have no interest in the environment whatsoever but is highly effective at promoting her far left social justice agenda – one that I largely disagree with. I also have huge problems with their basic approach to government which is to simply outlaw anything and everything they find objectionable. On top of that I suspect they’d fund their terribly worthy social justice policies by taxing me into oblivion.

The Greens seem to specialise in two things – spending as much money as possible and banning things they don’t like. If there is a hydra Government then they will be terribly upset that there is no money left for all their spending promises. Unless they massively increase taxes, they won’t be able to spend.

Hence having failed to get a spending binge, we will get a banning binge instead. Chris Trotter said a Government with such a strong Green presence in it will be the most left wing in the last 70 years. So I suspect the list of things to be banned will be truly ambitious.

I find this pretty frustrating. All I ask for is a baseline of competence and for a party to at least pretend that they are going to govern in good faith. Neither of our major parties comes close. Anyone who runs an election campaign as worthless and disgusting as Labour’s shouldn’t be allowed near pregnant women or children let alone the machinery of power, while National’s MPs have been gleefully telling any idiot who wanders up to them with a hidden microphone that they do have a secret agenda and they’re going to ratfuck the voters of this country as soon as we’re dumb enough to elect them.

I think Danyl is overly harsh here on the National MPs. I actually think almost all the secretly recorded comments are quite unexceptional – exactly what you expect from informal conversations at a social function. I do agree the Labour campaign has been very bad – they may be the only campaign in recent political history to have run 100% negative TV ads.

General Debate 7 November 2008

All four polls agree

Two more polls out, and over on curiablog. All show a National-led Government on their poll, but most show a small change could give the Maori Party the decision.

On a size and time weighted average of all polls National/ACT/United Future have 64 seats and need 62 to govern.

If you take account of the last four polls only, the change is Labour drops one to 43and ACT gains one to four.

Whether or not there is a clear result, will depend on turnout primarily. If people want a change of Government you have to go vote for it.

TV Polls

Curiablog has details of the two TV polls tonight. I epxect we will get tomorrow a Herald, Fairfax and Morgan poll also. The curiablog average has been updated for tonight’s polls but I will do a final update tomorrow morning.

Both polls show that National/ACT/United Future can form a Government, but that it is possible the Maori Party can hold the balance of power. The Greens are up strongly and in TV3 Labour dropped away a lot.

Chris Trotter on Alt TV this week said that on current polling a Labour/Green/Maori Party Government would be the most left-wing Government New Zealand has had for at least 70 years.

And he is correct. With the Greens at 10% they would not be a minor coalition partner but would pull the Government greatly towards the left and away from economic growth (which they don’t even like much). Of a Cabinet of 20, the Greens could expect five or six places, or in other words every current Green MP would become a Minister – including Keith Locke, Sue Kedgley, and Sue Bradford.

So it a clear choice for voters as we head into the election. As we face unprecedented economic challenges, it is a choice of a National-led Government that makes up 95% of the Government, or what Chris Trotter calls the most left-wing Government in 70 years.

Auckland Central

Readers might enjoy this podcast of Auckland Central candidate Nikki Kaye on The Edge this week.  It’s quite hilarious I thought – typical Edge irreverence.

Also NZPA have just done a piece on Nikki out on the campaign trail:

Auckland, Nov 6 NZPA – If power walking wins election campaigns then National’s Auckland Central candidate Nikki Kaye will be strolling into Parliament on election day.

The 28-year-old lawyer strides down the streets of central Auckland and up into Ponsonby trying to eat into Labour MP Judith Tizard’s majority of around 3500 on redrawn boundaries….

Ms Kaye has been doing it the old-fashioned way — knocking on doors and walking the streets.

It is a difficult electorate to target.

It has a high proportion of under 30-year-olds making up many of the more than 21,000 apartment dwellers in the city.

Many of them are not natural National voters, but they are courteous to the wanna-be MP and many say to her face they will be voting for her.

One Maori woman says “give me balloon and you’ll get my vote”… Ms Kaye gladly hands over the National blue balloon.

“Look even if you don’t vote for me and I do get elected, here’s my card if you ever need any help,” Ms Kaye said.

She cuts a confident figure, similar in size, style and politics to the retiring National front bencher Katherine Rich.

Her supporters say they have hardly seen the Labour machine on the ground.

For both candidates it could be a political struggle to the death, as they are both unlikely to get in on the list on current polling.

Ms Kaye grabs another voter by the hand, thanks her for her vote and moves on … trying to power walk her into Parliament.

I think a lot will come down to how Greens supporters vote. They will give the Greens their party votes. They then have to choose whether to put Judith back in, or an socially liberally environmentally friendly National MP who will be a voice within Government, or to vote Greens with both ticks.

UPDATE: Toad (who is a senior official of the Greens) has made the following comment in the thread below:

I’m not an Auckland Central voter any more (I was until about 18 moths ago), and as almost everyone here knows, I am a Green activist.

Judith Tizard is the biggest waste of space imaginable. I’ve lived in that electorate for most of my life, and the only decent MP it ever elected in that time was Sandra Lee. Before that we had Prebble! Enough said (before I say something defamatory).

I think Green voters should vote Green with both ticks in that electorate. If that means Nikki Kaye gets elected, then I could live with it. Tizard should have been pensioned off.

But why did the Nats rank Nikki Kaye as low as 57 on their list? If she were a bit higher, she would have been guaranteed election on the list anyway, and Nat supporters could then vote for the Greens’ Denise Roche in the electorate. Together we could have consigned the Minister of Wine and Cheese (and Wine, and Wine) to political oblivion.

This is something the Nats and the Greens could have worked on. Pity we missed the opportunity.

Media Mentions

Mediawatch on Sunday did a spell talking about blogs and included a chat with me, and an extract from the Two Helens ad Whale Oil and I did.

Last week I did an extended interview for around 10 minutes with Eric Young on Sky News. Was lots of fun. The dog toys even made an appearance. Also I discovered that Eric wears jeans with his suit and hides it from the camera 🙂

And Ali Ikram had some fun on Sunrise last week with our the two Helens ad.

I’m also on One’s Breakfast around 8.20 tomorrow discussing the campaign and the election.