A second recession?

Infometrics is predicting a second recesson in 2009!

New Zealand has been in recessions since the end of 2007, with negative growth in Q1 and Q2 2008. It is widely expected that Q3 will also be negative.

So Infometrics seem to be saying Q4 might be marginally positive, but then in 2009 Q1 and Q2 will be negative again.

If they are right, the decade of deficits just got worse.

Herald confirms trust not set up at time of donation

The NZ Herald reports:

Mr Henry – who has a close relationship with Mr Peters – said yesterday that the money was held in a lawyer’s trust account until the Susan Couch trust was set up properly and incorporated in September.

The trust account was that of Dennis Gates, another trustee of the Susan Couch trust and also a solicitor for Mr Peters.

So the money owed to the taxpayer went into a trust account of Winston’s solictor and then months later transferred (with interest) to the Susan Couch trust account controlled by Winston’s solictor and barrister.

Mr Henry said he asked for the money for the Susan Couch trust.

“Heaps of idiots turned down donations so I rang up Winston and said ‘hey, I’ve got a charitable trust here which won’t turn you down’,” he said.

Not idiots Mr Henry. People who realise that there is a moral component to this issue – the money is owed to the taxpayer and shouldn’t be given away to pet charities. Also these “idiots” probably calculated that they would lose more money in the long term by accepting the donation.

The setting up of the trust was not yet complete and final clearance from Inland Revenue was required.

So four months after the donations were made, the charity that got half the $158,000 isn’t yet registered as a charity.

I guess they couldn’t find any established charity to take their money.

Colin James on Economy

Northcote

The Herald profiles Northcote. Some extracts:

Mrs Hartley, who retired as a list MP at Christmas, said her loss to the young medical doctor was mainly due to Northcote’s tradition of swinging between National and Labour.

However, community activist Tony Sharrock, who brands himself a left-wing socialist, said Dr Coleman won votes with his willingness to take up the residents’ main concern – the traffic congestion on Onewa Rd. …

Nice praise.

Mr Sharrock: “Jonathan attends everything. He listens and tries to help people when he can, regardless of their political leanings.”

That is the trick to keepng a seat. Build up a reputation as an excellent electorate MP, and you attract support from voters of all parties.

I don’t think Northcote will be regarded as a marginal or singing seat in future.

Minor Leaders Debate

I thought it was interesting how restrained everyone was. Winston, for example, was being very constructive and making serious points. Maybe they all realised the usual squabbling would sit badly with voters in such uncertain economic times.

Not sure if there are any winners or losers from it. How did others find it?

How was your first time?

Peters on Radio

Winston Peters is the (suspended on full baubles) Foreign Minister of New Zealand. Yet he refused to take part in the Radio NZ debate on foreign policy. That is amazing enough. I’d ask the Prime Minister what she thinks of a Foreign Minister who won’t debate foreign policy?

But having been too busy to debate foreign policy, he did find time to ring up Radio Live talkback and attack host Matthew Hooton, journalist Phil Kitchin and others.

I asked Matthew whether Winston actually provided any useful information such as a guarantee the money would go to Susan Couch, despite still being with the trust months after he announced it. Matthew laughed and I realised how ridiculous my question was – asking if Winston actually provided useful information.

Papakura

In Auckland we interviewed three National MPs. First was Judith Collins MP for Clevedon and candidate for Papakura.

Judith became MP for Clevedon after defeating the incumbent MP, Warren Kyd, for the nomination in 2002. She then went on to win the general election by 3,127 over Dave Hereora. In 2005 Judith scored a massive majority of 12,871 in Clevedon. However a big change in boundaries sees her paper majority cut to an estimated 6,820 in the new seat of Papakura. So still far from marginal and Judith is expected to be a front bench Minister if National wins.

Judith says law and order is the biggest issue in her area. Says people just want the crims locked away.Favours looking at a law change to protect shop keepers defending their stores. For the US election, Judith is a strong supporter of John McCain – partly a reflection of her work in NZ with Vietnam Veterans. Says McCain is a man of incredible courage, decency and tenacity. However predicts Obama will win.

Finally she predicts Goff will get there first, but not last long. Personally hopes Cunliffe gets it, and all National MPs are hoping it is Cunliffe!

Bronagh Key

The SST has a bit of a profile on Bronagh Key. Some extracts:

Born Bronagh Irene Dougan on November 14, 1963, John Key’s wife is the daughter of Northern Irish immigrants. Joseph, a Catholic, and Irene, a Protestant, were married in Christchurch in 1960 and worked in the Feltex shoe factory.

“They were hard workers,” Bronagh told Australian Women’s Weekly. “After coming home from the factory, dad would have dinner and go out to work a second job in a hotel.”

And how they met:

A school reunion website identifies a Bronagh Dougan at Isleworth Primary School in 1974. She met her husband at Burnside High School; the 16-year-old was biking to a friend’s house reflecting, reportedly, on a failed economics exam: “I didn’t really know what I wanted to do in life. I was thinking I might join the airforce.” John Key was tutoring her friend’s sister. There was, says one report, an instant attraction.

One version of what happened next has Key taking his mother to dinner at a restaurant where Bronagh was waitressing. He asks Bronagh on a date to the local A&P Show: “While we were standing in the queue for the dodgems, he told me he wanted to be a politician.”

The amazing thing is this didn’t scare her off 🙂

Dom Post on Couch Trust

The Dom Post reports on the trust which has received the money that was owed to the taxpayers by NZ First:

A trust set up to receive half the misspent $158,000 that NZ First was ordered to repay was not registered till three months after Winston Peters announced he had donated the money to charity, documents reveal. …

Mr Peters’ so-called “blood-brother” and lawyer Bryan Henry, his solicitor Dennis Gates, and Mr Henry’s colleague Brian Coburn have full control over how the money is spent, including the ability to pay themselves all reasonable expenses. …

Ms Couch is not listed as a beneficiary or a patron, and the only mention of her is in the title of the trust. The three trustees have full control over where the money goes.

Meantime more fascinating information emerges on the trustees and settlor.  Whale Oil blogs:

Kevin Gillespie is heavily involved in the Trinity Forest tax avoidance case – with links not to the Cook Islands as Winston is so fond of, but the British Virgin Islands. Gillespie held all the directorships for The Trinity Foundation (and related entities) and was a shareholder of The Trinity Foundation

Fact – Winston and his legal advisors are and continue to be involved with an Accountant at the centre of NZ’s largest tax avoidance case where the defendants were found guilty of a $3.7 billion tax avoidance

Now I hasten to add this is tax avoidance, not evasion. So Mr Gillespie personally has not been found to have done anything wrong. But as Winston has spent decades railing against corporates who avoid tax, it is ironic he donates to a trust controlled by his personal lawyers and an accountant in the centre of a $3.7 billion tax avoidance.

There are multiple links to media stories over on Whale’s blog.

Also just to show how small NZ is:

And the individual lawyers involved and named as promoters in the Trinity case?

None other than the same lawyers used by Vela Fisheries in their Court of Appeal case which surprisingly related to – TAX.

A very small world it is.

Dunne backs National

It is significant that Peter Dunne has not just indicated a preference for National, but ruled out supporting a Labour-led Government after the election. There are probably a variety of reasons for this:

  1. Genuine horror at what a very left Government with up to 15 Green MPs would be like. He realised there would be no shift towards the centre if Labour gets re-elected but a big big shift to the left.
  2. A realisation that he may have trouble attracting support from voters wanting to change the Government unless they knew for sure a vote for United Future would be a vote for change. Now one can say that a vote for National, ACT or United Future are all votes to change the Government.
  3. An assumption that in a Government made up of Labour, Progressive, Greens, NZ First and the Maori Party there would be no room for him in a role of any significance.

I welcome United Future’s decision. There are some people who won’t be able to vote National, but would feel able to vote United Future, and now they can do so knowing it is a vote to change the Government.

Also Peter Dunne is a highly experienced and capable Minister, and Governments need those. Dunne’s tax policy of three rates – 10%, 20% and 30% is a very good policy, and I would be happy to have him push that along in Governmeent.

$100 m to aid credit crunch jobless

The Herald speculates that John Key will use some of the $100 million in fees from the bank deposit guarantee scheme as an assistance package to those who lose their jobs during the recession:

Leader John Key hinted at the weekend he would this week unveil a scheme offering support payments and loans to people who lose their jobs during the turmoil.

The payments would be part of a wider move by National to help people get back into the workforce.

Any payment or support would be targeted and carry a time limit.

It would also probably be aimed at middle-income earners who have commitments such as mortgages but no savings to carry them through a period without work.

Smart thinking, if correct.

More on leaders’ campaigns

The Inquiring Mind has a copy of a graphic from the Herald looking at the facts behind Helen’s sneering at Key’s campaign as hermetically sealed.

So if we total up both weeks we have:

  • Walkabouts – Key 11 to Clark 3
  • Large advertised meetings – Key 2 and Clark 2
  • Smaller community meetings – Key 5 to Clark 4
  • Workplace type visits – Clark 10 to Key 7
  • Photo Ops – Clark 3 and Key 3

John Key’s personality test

The SST asked John key and Helen Clark to both do a Myers-Brigg type personality test. Clark of course refused, but Key was a good sport and did the 20 question test, which identified him as a “go-getter”.

The SST have published the full list of questions, options and answers. I’ll comment on what my answers would be also:

Section 1: Planner or Spontaneous?
1) When you go on holiday, what do you prefer to do?
Plan every detail in advance
Plan a rough itinerary in advance, leaving some time free
Look at a few options in advance, but only really decide when you’re there
You rarely plan, just book at the last minute and go with the flow

I am more go with the flow. In fact sometimes decide destination on the day by tossing a coin.

2) What statement best describes how you do your regular grocery shop?
You make a detailed list of everything you need to buy
You make a rough list to jog your memory
You don’t make a list, as you think it’s a waste of time
You don’t do a regular shop, you just go when you need to

Same. I do regular shop but no list.

3) You’ve been to a furniture store and have come back with some flat-pack furniture, like a wardrobe or a desk that you have to assemble. What are you most inclined to do?
Before you start, you check that all the components are there and that you have the tools you will need
You read through the instructions carefully first and then follow them step by step
You scan the instructions, although you don’t always follow them exactly
You leap in, only referring to the instructions if you get stuck

I only will refer to instructions after many hours of trying without them!

4) Which description fits you best?
You are a perfectionist and can’t leave anything unfinished
You need time, over-prepare and hate pressure
You’re scatty, forgetful and disorganised
You put things off till the last minute and are often late

I’m none of those really. Sometimes a perfectionist but sometimes put things off.

5) What happens when your local supermarket moves the food to different aisles?
You would notice and it would really bother you
You would notice, but you simply change the order in which you shop
You would notice, but it wouldn’t bother you as you have no set routine
You probably wouldn’t notice

Agree – very annoying.

Section 2: Facts or Ideas?
6) Of the following options which one describes you best?

Realistic
Efficient
Imaginative
Visionary

I would go for efficient for me.

7) How do you usually give directions to your house? Do you
Provide a step-by-step list of directions for the entire journey?
Draw a really detailed map that shows things like street names and roundabouts?
Just give general directions?
Sketch a rough map, as too many details can be confusing?

I send them a Google Maps location so guess that is step by step.


8) Which set of words best describes you?
Practical, thorough and stable
Realistic, enthusiastic and spontaneous
Inventive, imaginative and original
Creative, dynamic and adventurous

Probably the same – enthusiastic and spontaneous.

9) Which of these best describes how you do your supermarket shopping?
You usually go up and down the aisles in exactly the same order
You read and compare labels and prices
You’re attracted to new things or special offers that catch your eye
You vary the way you go round the supermarket depending on what you feel like buying

Same – special offers work on me. But I do always travel the aisles in order also.

10) Look at the picture below. Write down on a piece of paper what you see. Allow yourself about 30 seconds for this. Now choose which statement best describes what you noted down:
Is it a list of what’s in the picture?
A story about what’s happening in the picture?
Have you tried to find the hidden meaning in this picture?
Or lots of ideas inspired by the picture?

Section 3: Heads or hearts?
11) Which set of words best describes you?
Analytical, logical and objective
Decisive, driven and energetic
Caring, helpful and supportive
Complex, thoughtful and sensitive

That is hard – I put myself as analytical but also complex and thoughtful. Probably analytical, logical and objective is the best fit.

12) What would you do if you had to decide between two homes to move into?
List your ideal features and compare which place has the most
Compare the good and bad features of both
Go with your gut feeling about which is best
Think about how each place affects the other people in your life

Definitely gut feeling. You can not decide a home based on a list.

13) If your friend started dating someone you really disliked and asked you what you thought about their relationship, what would you do?
Be up front and honest about what you think
Try to be tactful  but still be truthful about what you think
Try not to hurt their feelings, changing the subject if necessary
Avoid hurting their feelings, telling a “white lie” if necessary

I’m in the upfront and honest category.

14) If you are with a group of friends and an argument breaks out, what do you tend to do?
Face the dispute head on
Try to find an answer to the problem
Try to meet everyone’s needs
Anything to avoid hurting people’s feelings

Try to meet everyone’s needs.

15) When you have to make a difficult decision, what is most important to you?
Arriving logically at the best choice
Being as fair as possible
Doing the right thing according to your own beliefs and values
Getting the approval and agreement of others

Doing the right thing according to my beliefs and values.

Section 4: Extravert or introvert
16) When you are out with a group of your friends, how much of the talking do you usually do?
Hardly any at all
A little less than most
Quite a lot
Almost all

Somewhere between quite a lot and almost all.

17) When it comes to expressing yourself do you
Hold back more, listening to others before speaking?
Think before you speak?
Think out loud?
Use your hands and facial expressions a lot?

I think out loud – far too often.

18) What are you like when you have to meet a group of new people?
You stick with the people you’ve met before
You spend your time thinking about how to keep the conversation going
You aim to mingle with as many new people as possible
You just go out and have fun

I sort of aim to mingle with as many new people – I like meeting new people.

19) Which set of words best describes you?
Cautious, thoughtful and loyal
Inquisitive, independent and contained
Lively, enthusiastic and energetic
Expressive, talkative and friendly

Hard one again – very very loyal but not very cautious. Highly independent and inquisitive so go with that one.

20) If you are in the middle of something important and the phone rings how do you usually react? Do you
Ignore the phone, or let the machine pick up?
Take the call, but deal with it as quickly as possible?
Answer it as you welcome the chance to talk to someone, but keep it brief?
Answer the phone enthusiastically and be up for a long conversation?

I ignore the phone now, but only if the caller is less important than what I am doing 🙂

So how many did I get the same as John? Only 7/20!

Tacky

There are some questions the media should not ask – no matter’s whose spouse they are. The HoS asks Peter Davis:

I ask if they shower together, to conserve water. “No! No, no – we don’t use much water at all.” …

This leads to an inevitable question – does he like sex?

“Arr … err … hello, that guy took interest in what you just said,” says Davis, referring to another pedestrian.

Well, do you like sex? He mumbles for a moment. “Well that is a personal part of my life … and I don’t want to talk about that.”

I’m with Peter Davis on this one. I know there is a fascination out there with the Clark and Davis relationship. But really. Would a journalist ask Bronagh Key if she showers with her husband and whether she enjoys sex?

I actually feel very sorry for Peter Davis for all the shit he has to put up with. Helen is PM and a fair target, but he isn’t unless he gets involved politically (which he does from time to time – in fact my blog byline comes from a letter he wrote to the editor re the NZ Herald).

Oh and advance warning for comments – demerits will be handed out liberally for inappropriate comments. The issue is whether the media should be asking such questions – not what you personally think of their relationship.

Mayor Williams vs Whale Oil

North Shore Mayor Andrew Williams has objected to Whale Oil referring to him as “mental” and demanded he stop doing so, or he will tell Cameron’s father on him.

The Mayor should know that if you want to get Cameron to stop, you don’t threaten him with his father – you threaten to tell his mother!!!

Labour’s literacy standards

The hydra

A hydra normally has seven heads, not five. Whale Oil has kindly provided this illustration.

There is a serious point to the talk about the five or seven headed Hydra.

We are in the midst of the most serious global financial crisis for 70 years. Getting through it with minimal harm will not be easy.

A Government of Labour, Winston, Anderton, the Greens and maybe Maori Party is not one likely to cope well. Half of them want to abolish the Reserve Bank Act. Half of them don’t care about government debt. All of them want huge amounts more spending. Do you think they could credibly exercise fiscal and monetary discipline? Do you think they could make hard, even unpopular calls, if deemed necessary for the NZ economy?

Hermetically sealed or not?

Helen Clark seems to spend most of her time whining abotu John Key. First she suggested he shouts at his wife and kids. Then she said he was out of control and had a temper tantrum. Then she said his campaign was hermetically sealed.

Well the Herald has compared schedules:

At the end of the first week Helen Clark said Mr Key’s campaign was “hermetically sealed” and he was staying out of reach of the public, while she and Labour were “out there taking the risks”.

Yesterday, she said he was having public meetings “stacked with National Party supporters”.

The Weekend Herald ran a rule over the leaders’ schedules and went on the road to ascertain whether Helen Clark was right – and to assess whether “public” encounters are genuine public meetings or restricted to supporters in a show for television cameras.

The results show Mr Key has increased his number of genuine public meetings since that first week. But his schedule in the first week was no less public than hers in terms of “risking” running into unfriendly voters.

Mr Key is also outstripping the PM on public walkabouts and has tended to enter enemy territory more than Helen Clark.

He did a 90-minute public walkabout in the streets of Papatoetoe – Labour’s territory – to promote his law and order policy and also visited a decile one school near Gisborne for education policy.

But Clark just does not give up:

Helen Clark’s claim that National stacked a public meeting attended by more than 600 people in Pukekohe with its supporters is rejected by the local MP Paul Hutchison.

He said the meeting was advertised widely, including in the local paper and on billboards and posters and the ads said all were welcome.

She really seems to be in denial.

The Susan Couch – Crime Victims Charitable Trust

Kiwiblog readers have been doing detective work and have discovered the Susan Couch – Crime Victims Charitable Trust was registered only a few weeks ago on the 10th of September 2008.

It’s trust deed is online at the Companies Office.

The trust deed was signed on 15 August 2008 and the application was signed on 20 August 2008. But Winston announced the donation around 16 June 2008. So how did he make a donation to a trust that seemingly was not then formed?

The contact person is Brian Coburn of Hesketh Henry in Auckland. He is one of the three Trustees. The other two are Brian Henry and Dennis Gates.

Yes two of the three Trustees are Winston’s personal lawyers – his solicitor and his barrister!! Half the $158,000 has gone to a trust run by both his personal lawyers.

The settlor is Kevin Gillespie, an Auckland Accountant. Gillespie, Henry and Gates are all Directors of Goldman Henry Capital Management and in business together. They had some problems with the Securities Commission in 2004 incidentally, after the Commission found their prospectus did not comply with securities law and omitted a material particular. The investment statement was also found “likely to deceive, mislead, or confuse with regard to particulars that are material to the offer of securities”.

The Trust objects include “such other objects which the Board from time to time declares provided that such objects and purposes are charitable and involve the support and rehabilitation of crime victims”.

Board members can get remuneration for services rendered to the Trust. In fact it specifically allows such remuneration even if the work only comes about by virtue of being a Trustee. Note I am not suggesting any Trustee has received any money – just that as with most Trusts, they can.

There is no reference to Susan Couch in the trust deed, except being the name of the trust. Couch is not listed as the Patron, and the three Trustees have total power over the Trust.  She is not listed specifically as a beneficiary either. Again the Trustees have total discretion over who the money goes to (so long as within the objects), and Couch has no rights or say at all. So the Herald is wrong when they say it is “A trust for Susan Couch”.

A deeply cynical act

Few acts are more cynical than NZ First’s giving $78,000 to The Susan Couch and Crime Victims Charitable Trust (trustee: Brian Henry) instead of repaying the taxpayer the $158,000 of taxpayer money illegally spent by NZ First in the 2005 campaign.

What is even worse, is that the $78,000 isn’t really from the members and grossroots of NZ First. The Vela Family donated $80,000 to NZ First in late 2007, to allow this donation to be made.

So what you actually have is a very wealthy, foreign domiciled, racing industry family has donated $80,000 to NZ First (whose Leader has forced the Government to pur massive funding into the racing industry) so they could give the money to the Susan Couch trust – and claim this is somehow paying the taxpayer back.

I joked at the time that they had probably donated the money to the Spencer Trust. Instead it has gone to a trust partly controlled by Winston’s lawyer. Ms Couch will be Patron of the Tust which suggests she won’t even be a Trustee herself – are there other Trustees?

To be fair to Brian Henry, he has been acting for free for Ms Couch in her fight to sue Corrections, and he is definitely on the side of the angels on this occasion for his actions to help Couch. While critical of Henry’s statements and actions over Owen Glenn, I make no such criticism in regards to this issue.

But that doesn’t change the fact that NZ First should be paying the taxpayer back, not making charitable donations on our behalf, and that having decided to make such donations they are ill-advised to make the major donation to a trust controlled by their lawyer.

Yang Liu’s private VIP citizenship ceremony in Parliament

The NZ Herald reports:

A Chinese man granted citizenship against the advice of officials and wanted in his homeland for “large-scale misappropriation and embezzlement” was given a VIP citizenship ceremony at Parliament.

Yang Liu, also known as Bill Liu, was granted his citizenship in August by ministerial prerogative.

He became a New Zealander at a private citizenship ceremony in the Maori Affairs select committee room, officiated over by Labour MP and former Cabinet minister Dover Samuels.

And who is Yang Liu?. The latest TGIF from Ian Wishart reveals:

His real name, confirmed for the first time in this country by TGIF Edition, is indeed Yongming Yan

Even worse, an informant resource report to the Immigration Service last year, but apparently ignored by Associate Immigration Minister Shane Jones, provides detailed information on Yan’s involvement at the head of an Asian organised crime syndicate, which “paid large cash sums to various ministers and delegates indirectly through secret anonymous accounts

Now whether this is correct or not is one issue. But what is not in dispute (it seems) is that Shane Jones knew of these allegations, as the were part of the file officials had who fought against citizenship. So why did Jones ignore this?

Tonight, TGIF Edition can also reveal that one of Yongming’s former associates in this country – Shane Phillips – was a Labour Party campaign manager, and his brother Daniel Phillips works in the office of Associate Immigration Minister Shane Jones – the man who gave ‘Bill Liu’ citizenship against the recommendations of officials who’d investigated his background.

Shane Phillips is also known as Shane Te Pou, and in 2000 Helen Clark vetoed his appointment to a ministerial job. Also:

There are fresh allegations this week, including that ‘Liu’ (in reality, Yan Yongming) may have donated cash to the campaigns of Rick Barker and Dover Samuels.

And Wishart has unearthed some interesting aspects of donations to Dover Samuels:

A further $5,000 was given to Dover Samuels by the oddly-named ‘Tamaki ki te Paki Wu’, apparently residing at a house in Derrimore Heights in Manukau City.

So, according to the official documents, two separate Wu’s slipped a total of eight grand between them into the Dover Samuels campaign fund. But who was this mysterious Mr Tamaki Wu? A check of the Manukau address Dover had given for him provides an added twist to this story: it was registered not to Mr Wu but to Daniel Phillips – Dover’s former private secretary now working for Associate Immigration Minister Shane Jones. So $5,000 had come to Dover from the address of a man whose brother was involved with Chinese
businessman ‘Yang Liu’ (real name Yan Yongming), yet the money was not in Daniel Phillips’ name, but a person or entity named Tamaki Wu.

There is also a suggestion that an anonymous $5,000 donation to Rick Barker was from Yan.

The issues raised here can not be dealt with by a departmental inquiry. Departments can not investigate their own Ministers. A fully empowered commission of inquiry should be set up to investigate this. The key tasks should be

  1. To verify the real identity of the man granted citizenship by Labour Ministers over the protests of officials
  2. Does he have a criminal record, and what is the nature of that
  3. Determine the full extent of his donations to all parties and candidates
  4. Why Ministers both refused to revoke his residency and further granted him citizenship against the strong advice of officials

No money for the kids

This week’s Dispatch from Helengrad:

The kids (the minor parties) are getting excited over what their post-election pocket money will be, but they do not seem to have realised that Mum and Dad have run out of money just paying for their own treats.

Parties such as the Greens, Maori Party and NZ First have scores of high spending policies, and don’t seem to realise that they are unlikely to get any of them. The cupboard is now just bare.

My scorecard is:

  • Best Play of the Week: Labour gets a C- for belatedly halting their big spending promises
  • Worst Play of the Week: Greens get a D for their criteria for post-election support
  • EFA Breach of the Week: ACT gets a D for their lack of disclosure over free rent
  • Scandal of the Week: Yang Liu is sitting on a B- but due to be upgraded to an A+ if allegations that he is an Asian organised crime boss hold true.

Comments and feedback can be left over at NBR.

Recognise the vandals