Dick Griffin

Richard Griffin is one of those great guys who is very loyal to his friends. I worked with him a bit in the Beehive and you won’t find a more funny person. One of life’s great people.

So my comments here are not critical of Dick, who is loyal to one of his best mates – Winston.

They are more about the media needing to be careful of how they use and describe Dick. On the issue of Winston he is not an impartial commentator. He is one of Winston’s closest mates and even appeared in a campaign opening for him a couple of elections ago. He is an advocate for Winston, not a neutral commentator.

I think it is laudable he stands up for his mate. But media, including Radio NZ, should put his comments in the proper context.

Key hot for Brad Pitt

Unlike Kevin Rudd, John Key has actually answered the famous tongue-in-cheek “Who would you turn gay for” question and nominated Brad Pitt.

On things gay, Rodney Hide has an interesting interview with gaynz.com on his views:

I describe myself as a classical liberal, which means I believe in the paramount freedom of the individual, and that it’s Government’s job simply to uphold that liberty and protect it from the bullies.” …

Nice.

Asked by media, including GayNZ.com, if there was any truth to Peters’ veiled ‘accusation’ in the House that Hide is not heterosexual, Hide famously answered “Not yet,”

Heh.

Where does ACT stand on adoption by same-sex couples, the subject of a Bill hovering on the edges of the House? “I’ve got no problem with gay people adopting kids”, he says. “I’ve got a number of gay friends and I’d rather some of them were looking after my son than a lot of my heterosexual ones.”

Yep.

UPDATE: On gay issues, this story from Austria is quite interesting. It has just been revealed that Jorg Haider, who died in a car crash last week, is gay and was in a relationship with his sucessor as party leader. They led the right-wing Alliance for the Future of Austria.

What I find interesting is that two of the most high profile and sucessful nationalistic and anti-immigration leaders in Europe were both gay – Haider and Pim Fortuyn. Fortuyn was openly gay though while Haider was sceretly bisexual – he had a wife and children.

Electoral Commission on NZ First

The Electoral Commission has done three things in response to NZ First’s 2007 donations return:

  1. It has found the party secretary did not break the law with the 2007 donations return, but is not releasing the full decision as it may compromise the police investigation. They EC point out carefully “The determination is in respect of the actions of the Party Secretary for New Zealand First only, as considered under Part 6 of the Electoral Act.” This suggests that others are under investigation by the Police.
  2. It has published amended returns for 2007 showing $80,000 of donations from the Spencer Trust. At this stage amended returns for 2005 and 2006 have not been published or possibly even received.
  3. It has published a letter from the NZ First Auditor, Nick Kosoof.

No (1) is not a big surprise. The party administrators tended to be kept ignorant of the Spencer Trust. Both the Party President and the Party Deputy Leader have said they were unaware the Spencer Trust even existed.  So I guess the Party Secretary was also unaware of it.

The letter from Kosoof is interesting. He says:

We were advised that the sums totally $80,000 paid to the Spencer Trust were paid not for the credit of that trust but for the credit of the NZ First Party, and were received by the Spencer Trust as an agent for the NZ First Party. As each of the component parts of that sum were from different entities and each was $10,000 or under, they did not require to be returned under the Electoral Act 1993.

This raises many questions:

  1. Who advised Kosoof of this?
  2. Did he have access to the Spencer Trust accounts to verify that each component part was under $10,000?
  3. Did he seek any legal advice on the situation or just take the word of the organisation he audits?

I wonder if NZ First wll file amended returns for 2005 and 2006? I suspect they may choose not to, even though they have acknowledged the 2005 return was false. The EC doesn’t actually have the power to force them to do this.

Electoral Commission on ACT

David Benson-Pope will be happy – his complaint to the Electoral Commission against ACT has been upheld.

Up until 2005 Sir Robert Jones provided free office space to ACT for an out of parliament office. The value was around $20,000 a year.

ACT’s position was:

The Party Secretary acknowledges that the office space was provided “for an Out of Parliament office” used for the Wellington-based list MPs to carry out their constituency work and that the office staff and equipment were funded by Parliamentary Services out of the budget provided for the list MPs.

The Secretary states that the party did not use the office for campaigning or other party purposes, as the party obtained another office for those purposes.

The Secretary claims that the party did not benefit from the provision of the office space and
therefore did not need to declare it.

In a way this is really about whether a donation to a parliamentary section of a party counts as a donation to the party. The consequences of this ruling could be quite large, as any MP who gets a cheap rate for their out of parliament office may be covered by this.

The Commission ruled that the parliamentary section of a party is considered part of a party, and the free rent was a donation that should have been declared. The deadline for prosecutions has expired, luckily for ACT. They have asked ACT to file amended returns for the affected years.

Some will claim a moral equivalence with NZ First. That is nonsense. There is a reasonable argument (even though they lost the argument) about whether free OOP office space for MPs (which by definition should not be used for political or campaign activity) should be included as a party donation. There is no argument over receiving large sums of money directly and not declaring them.

This does not mean ACT can not be criticised for their decision. If I was in their shoes I would have pro-actively asked the Electoral Commission for a ruling on whether free office space for an MPs office constitutes a donation to the party itself. Erring on the side of caution is sensible when it comes to electoral law.

Electoral Commission on Tui

The Electoral Commission has saved me from becoming the most hated man in NZ, and found that the Tui billboards are not election advertisements – but only just!

I asked the EC to rule on the Tui billboards after reading their determination that the EMA ads against KiwiSaver were election advertisements because they can not take into account the intent of the ad – only the impact.

The interesting thing is how close a call they say it was:

As a result the Electoral Commission formed the view that the billboard in question sits just outside of what could reasonably be regarded as encouraging or persuading voters to vote or not to vote in a particular manner, and is therefore not an election advertisement for the purposes of the Electoral Finance Act.

They went out of their way to say the billboard sits “just outside” being an illegal election advertisement. I think it shows hiw far reaching the EFA is, even though it has stopped just short.

Also the EC seems to suggest that Tui escaped only because of their unique place in NZ society:

While there is no exemption for humour as such, because of the long-standing and unique
background of the Tui advertisement series, the Commission does not consider that the billboard in question is likely to have an abiding impact on the thinking of members of the public.

In other words this is not much of a precedent for other satire.

Stuff poll manipulation

A reader writes:

I have been watching every stuff poll that has something to do with a political topic over the last few weeks and every one has started out one way and then low and behold 12 hours later it has completely skewed the other way.

This is not surprising. I have blogged on this stuff several times previously. The media need to be more pro-active in not just detecting and preventing fraud, but also in exposing those who do it. Even though these polls are unscientific, they are reported on and seen by many people.

Generally the polls all start out favouring the nats and then magically skew the other way, and not by a little, were talking massive swings. Now from a statistics point of view, this is not generally possible.

Yep – this is a pattern, always the same way.

Here is an example that i have emailed into stuff.co.nz today. I live in London, and last night the poll “National MP Lockwood Smith’s comments about Asians and Pacific Islanders were …” was dramatically on the side of ‘Fair Enough’ and ‘Undiplomatic but no big deal’. So i get to work this morning and have another look at the poll and low and behold it’s completely flipped again.

So i thought i would take some sample data:

Hard data is always useful.

At 12:20 am (NZ Time)
Racist (12485 votes, 56.7%)
Fair enough (3893 votes, 17.7%)
Undiplomatic but no big deal (5653 votes, 25.7%)

At 2:20am (Nz Time)
Racist (15215 votes, 61.2%)
Fair enough (3922 votes, 15.8%)
Undiplomatic but no big deal (5715 votes, 23.0%)

Difference
Racist +2730
Fair enough +29
Undiplomatic but no big deal +62

And here we are at 2:45am, when most kiwis are snug in bed and the ‘Racist’ side is still climbing a a rate of a vote every second or so.

That is absolutely damning. Fairfax should not just take measures to eliminate those fake votes, they should expose the IP address the multiple votes are coming from.

Now i know that stuff polls are not scientific in any way but if someone is doing this intentionally and i believe they are they are trying to skew public opinion because if they see that 70% of the population is voting a different way to them they will start to think that maybe they are wrong. There are a lot of people that look at these polls and in an election where every vote counts, if only a few change their votes because of ‘supposed’ public opinion, then we have a big problem.

The NZ Herald had to fix up their polls a little while ago because of tampering, so now it looks like stuff should do the same.

The solution is not that difficult.  Fairfax staffers should be monitoring their polls, as this reader has done, and take action when they detect obvious fraud.

I sometimes have people try to do bulk multiple voting on my own blog polls. Generally I notice it within an hour or two, and reverse it. And I expose where it was done from – for example a VUWSA computer was used one time to do it.

A quick follow up. It’s now 4:20am NZ time and i have taken the next sample. This data is from 2:20am – 4:20am

At 4:20am
Racist (18051 votes, 65.1%)
Fair enough (3934 votes, 14.2%)
Undiplomatic but no big deal (5742 votes, 20.7%)

Difference from 2:20am
Racist +2836
Fair enough +12
Undiplomatic but no big deal +27

Beyond any doubt, And I just had a look myself at 6.40 am and the growth in the last two hours has been:

Racist +3080
Fair enough +6
Undiplomatic but no big deal +20

The reader who sent this to me has also e-mailed Fairfax/Stuff. I’ll publish any response from them.

CTU Anti-National Ad

Will the over 60s info kits catch some Labour MPs out?

Matthew Hooton quotes Andrew Geddis on the info kits, with Andrew saying that they are not election advertisements as they are orange not red and don’t mention Labour.

Hooton points out though that Phil Goff, unlike his colleagues, has described himself as the “Labour MP for Mt Roskill” on the cover of his info kit.

This raises the possibility that for Phil Goff (but not other MPs) they will be counted as an election advertisement and hence an election expense. And if he has already spent more than $16,000 then he may have broken his spending limit. If that is the case he could lose his seat.

So if Phil Goff wins Mt Roskill, I am sure lawyers will be looking very closely at his election return.

And I wonder why Goff stuck Labour on his cover, when it seems most of his colleagues did not?

Today’s Dim-Post

The best comedy and satire about the election is online. Danyl has some gems today:

  • While speaking to a small group of army medics in Waiouru John Key announced that Dr Lockwood Smith’s plane has been shot down over the sea of Japan
  • The Green Party held a photo opportunity at Pauatahanui estuary in Mana electorate at which co-leaders Russel Norman and Jeannette Fitzsimmons pitched Green fiscal policy to a thick film of marine algea.
  • New Zealand First leader Winston Peters met with police detectives and the Reserve Bank to discuss his plans to stimulate the New Zealand economy by printing more money; the detectives have confiscated a Macintosh computer and two color printers from New Zealand First offices.
  • Maori Party co-leader Tariana Turia announced that the removal of Tin from the periodic table of elements would be a bottom line for any coalition deal with a major party.

The sad thing is that Winston’s monetary policy is not very different to the above!

In Ponsonby yesterday

A while ago we realised we had a bit of money left over in the Free Speech Coalition coffers, plus a bit more had come in during the year, and we are morally obliged to spend it before the election.

The hypocrisy of Labour and NZ First voting for the Electoral Finance Act on the grounds of transparency around donations, and then having NZ First revealed as having filed false donation returns is too much to ignore. And Helen keeping Winston in the baubles of office despite the Privileges Committee finding that he lied about the $100,000 Owen Glenn donation shows that Helen’s rhetoric around the Electoral Finance Act is as false as Winston’s rhetoric.

So using the very fine creative talents of Mr Ansell and others, we took what had just been a blog billboard, tidied it up, and turned it into a real life one.

And there it is proudly on Ponsonby Road.

There will be one going up in Wellington also, and we have a slightly different one going up in Tauranga which we think will be popular! Stay tuned.

Garth George on freedom

An extraordinarily good column by Garth George about the election and freedom:

This election is all about freedom – the freedom of the individual to live his or her life with as little interference as possible from the state, its politicians and minions.

It’s all about being loosed from the tyranny of dogmatic “do-it-my-way-or-else” socialism, which contends that the state knows best how to spend our money, how we use our property and how we run our families.

It’s all about freedom from fear – from the anxiety generated by the doom and gloom merchants, the Greens in particular, who demand that we circumscribe our lives in certain ways because if we don’t the world will melt and come to an end.

It’s all about freedom from guilt. We want to be able to fill up our cars, turn on our heaters, light our homes, run our taps (and showers), eat our food, smoke a cigarette, have a few drinks, sell land or buy or develop property without being made to feel guilty.

The freedom from guilt and fear – so true.

There are times I want to strangle Mr George for what he writes, and times I want to buy him a beer 🙂

OCR drops 100

The Reserve Bank has dropped the Official Cash Rate by 100 basis points, as many had predicted.

This is the biggest ever single movement – previous moves had been as high as 50 basis points but never a 75 or a 100 before.

The Governor says:

“With weaker short-term growth and sharply lower oil prices we now expect that annual CPI inflation will return to the target band of 1 to 3 percent around the middle of 2009. However, we still have concerns that domestically generated inflation (particularly in labour costs, local body rates, electricity prices and construction costs) is remaining stubbornly high.

The domestic inflation is what causes the risk of stagflation.

“Consistent with the Policy Targets Agreement, the Bank’s focus will remain on medium-term inflation. Should the outlook for inflation evolve as projected we would expect to lower the OCR further. However, the timing and extent of OCR reductions over the coming months will depend on evidence of actual reductions in domestic cost pressures as well as how the global financial developments play out.”

I can think of some domestic costs that could be reduced!

National’s Sentencing Policy

National has now released its full sentencing, parole and bail policy. Key elements:

  • No parole for the worst repeat violent offenders – those sentenced at least twice to prison terms of five years or more (already announced)
  • Life without parole to be made available to Judges as a sentence for the worst murderers
  • Substantially increase penalties for causing the death of a child when there is a history of neglect
  • Makes the point that assault on a child currently has a maximum two year penalty – one year less than the maximum three years for wilfully ill-treating an animal!
  • Review whether to maintain home detention as an option for violent and sexual offenders
  • Reverse Labour’s changes to the bail laws that made it easier for people to get bail – even if they have broken bail conditions previously
  • Increase from $7,500 to $50,000 the maximum amount that can be in dispute and heard by the Disputes Tribunal, allowing more time in District Courts for criminal cases

I imagine there would be only one or two murders a year which are so heinous that a Judge would sentence someone to life without parole. They may be people who might never have got parole anyway, but this means the family of the victims do not have the trauma of having to submit to the Parole Board every year on why so and so should remain in jail. It truly gives the victims’ family a life sentence also.

UPDATE: A useful example from the comments:

As much as Labour try to trumpet the Sentencing Act 2002 as ‘getting tough on crime’ they fail to mention the Sentencing amendment Act 2007 which is anything but.   3 defendants appearing on their 8th, 9th and 10th drink drive charges respectively. Under the new senting guidelines of the 2007 Act, home detention and community detention are to be considered for suitability in all drink drive cases before the imposition of imprisonment. Despite one defendant having been imprisoned on both prior occasions and despite blowing 2.5 times the legal limit (Twice the level he returned at the last time he received jail) and crashing into a parked car, none of the defendants received anything more than 6 months community detention (Essentially means they are curfewed at night). Another defendant received 16 months imprisonment for his 31st burglary conviction…

So previously these repeat drink drivers were sent to prison (totally appropriate for a 8th or greater offence) but now they just get community detention which means they can carry on drink driving until they kill someone. Remember to have been convicted eight times of drink driving, you have probably driven drunk on more than 1,000 occassions as most people get checked less than 1 in 100 times they are out.

Kate Sutton

The Herald has a nice interview with Labour candidate (and party vice-president) Kate Sutton. Kate talks about her current job:

So here she is in Landco’s 28th floor suite, hired for her command of public policy issues, Auckland growth problems, local government and potential public-private partnerships.

Besides Stonefields, the company is doing a development at Long Bay on North Shore and Ngunguru in Northland where she is negotiating a land swap with the Department of Conservation.

“Developers can be seen as bad guys,” she says, “but there are some developers out there who are working for the good of communities.”

It is her job to help convince communities of this.

“But I have to believe it. It is not a spin job – I couldn’t do that.”

Not too many Labour candidates would work for property developers! Labour will be stronger if more of their candidates have worked in the private sector – at least for a while. I’ve worked for Government, in private sector, for a charity and for myself and you learn and need very different skills in each situation.

TVNZ7 has an Epsom debate on tonight – Kate is the only non MP, appearing with Rodney Hide, Richard Worth and Keith Locke.

Electoral Finance Act in Court of Appeal today

The Court of Appeal is hearing today an appeal in the case John Boscawen has brought against the Attorney-General over whether the Electoral Finance Act is consistent with the Bill of Rights Act.

I blogged back in June the High Court decisions:

As I said earlier the protection of parliamentary privilege saw the challenge to the Electoral Finance Bill dismissed. The similar case against the Electoral Finance Act also was dismissed on the grounds it was asking the Court for an abstract ruling (ie just asking whether the EFA breached the Bill of Rights Act).

The hearing today is before Appeal Justices Glazebrook, O’Regan and Arnold. Originally it was to be heard by just one permament Court of Appeal Judge and two High Court Judges, but now all three Judges hearing it are permament members of the Court of Appeal – possibly an inidcation of the importance of the case?

A copy of the appellants submission is here: boscawen-submissions-ca.

What was sought:

In the High Court proceeding, the appellants sought declarations that provisions in the Electoral Finance Act 2007 (“EF Act”) were inconsistent with fundamental civil and political rights affirmed by the Bill of Rights Act. As the offending provisions in the EF Act germinated from the original Electoral Finance Bill (“EF Bill”), the appellants also claimed that the Attorney General should have drawn them to the attention of the House of Representatives during the legislative process. The appellants sought declarations that the Attorney breached his statutory duty under s.7 by failing to do so.

And what happened in the High Court:

Clifford J in the High Court granted the Crown’s application and struck out the ASOC in its entirety. Clifford J expressed reluctance to make declarations of inconsistency, particularly on an abstract basis, without clear jurisdictional guidance from this Court1. He also followed the 1994 High Court decision of Mangawaro Enterprises Limited v Attorney General (“Mangawaro”)2, and obiter dicta comments from McGrath J in Awatere Huata v Prebble (“Awatere Huata”)3 and found the Attorney General’s exercise of statutory power under s.7 to be non-justiciable.

Most of the argument will be around whether the Court can make a declaration of inconsistency regarding a law and the Bill of Rights Act. To date no court has done so, but Boscawen cites previous judgements that have alluded to the desirability of doing so. It will be an interesting outcome either way.

Another migration record

Stats NZ have released their monthly migration statistics. They note:

  • 500 more PLT departures in September 2008 compared with September 2007
  • In the year ended September 2008, there were 82,300 PLT departures, up 7,600 (10 percent). (an all time record)
  • Net PLT migration was 4,400 in the September 2008 year, down from 8,300 in the September 2007 year. The latest figure is the lowest since the October 2001 year (1,700).
  • A net inflow of 40,800 non-New Zealand citizens and a net outflow of 36,400 New Zealand citizens were recorded in the year ended September 2008.
  • Compared with the September 2007 year there were 5,900 more PLT departures of New Zealand citizens and 1,700 more PLT departures of non-New Zealand citizens.
  • The net PLT outflow to Australia was 33,900 in the September 2008 year, compared with 26,200 in the September 2007 year. This is higher than previous peaks in the January 1989 year (33,700) and the December 1979 year (33,400).

The above is all from the Stats NZ commentary. Now let’s look at some data over time.

This shows that the number of permament and long-term departures is at an all time high. As a percentage of the population it is not yet at the peak but has climbed from 14 per 1,000 to almost 20 per 1,000.

That is quite high. Over a generation (30 years) that is 600 out of 1,000 people who would have left – and most won’t return.

If we look at just the last five years – since the current trend began, we see a few things:

  • PLT departures up from 55,000 to over 82.000 in five years – a 49% increase
  • PLT departures of NZ citizens up from 38,000 to almost 60,000 – a 57% increase
  • Net PLT departures of NZ citizens up from 10,000 to around 36,000 – a 254% increase

I don’t show the net PLT figures for all travellers as the rate of inbound migration of non citizens is decided by Government policy and can be set as high or low as the Government wants.

Espiner says no chance of Maori-National coalition

Colin Espiner has been talking to Pita Sharples and on the basis of that conversation says there is no chance of a Maori-National coalition – a gutsy call:

Sharples wants to improve the lot of Maori. He wants to do this from a position of power, believing, unlike the Greens, that the best way to do this is from government.

But Sharples is a man possessed. He’s possessed by the knowledge that no matter what the Maori says or does during its current courtship dance with the National Party, his followers know only one party – Labour. He’s frank about this, and when you push him, he admits that the chances of the Maori Party entering into any sort of coalition arrangement with National is extremely unlikely.

I’ll go further. I’ll say this: the Maori Party will not go into a coalition government with National. If I’m proved wrong after the election, I’ll print out this blog and eat it, live on webcam.

That in itself should be incentive enough for such a coalition 🙂

Note that I’m not saying the Maori Party won’t offer confidence and supply to National (although I think this, too, is highly unlikely) or that it wouldn’t consider abstaining to allow National to govern. But I believe a coalition is out of the question.

If Colin is right, then Helen Clark is going to be very happy.

At the end of our conversation today, Sharples conceded that it would be much easier for the Maori Party if Labour won the most votes on election day. He’d rather deal with Labour, too, I suspect. Even if Labour isn’t the major party, Sharples would look to a deal that included New Zealand First and the Greens first.

As a last resort, if the “other door” was completely shut, the Maori Party would talk with National, Sharples told me, but even then he was doubtful about whether the Maori Party’s supporters would back such a deal.

I am just imagining a Labour/Greens/Maori/NZ First Government trying to cope with the financial crisis and live within its means. More likely are huge tax increases.

So with two and half weeks of the campaign to go, it’s Labour, NZ First, the Greens, and almost certainly the Maori Party on one side. And National, ACT, and United Future on the other. ACT is probably good for four or even five seats, but United Future will be lucky to get more than one.

That means National needs to get very close to 50% of the party vote to have any hope of forming a government.

Or National has to agree to something that the Maori Party want – and that Labour won’t or can’t agree to. I’m thinking seabed and foreshore legislation here.

The maths is cruel, but there you have it. The polls mean very little against the reality of MMP. The only message National should be pushing now is this: If you want to change the government, you must party vote National. Virtually anything else (except ACT) will see Clark reinstalled in Premier House for a fourth term.

I agree that is the desired message.

Some may be surprised

Was on Larry Williams just before six pm. Larry was defending recent utterances from National MPs, and I was criticising them!

The point I tried to make is it is not just about whether something is true or not. For example it is of course true that new roads built with a PPP will have tolls on them and sure the toll could be $3.

But the issue is whether one even wants to talk hypothetical prices on hypothetical roads. This allows Labour and/or the media to conjure up images of every road into Auckland having a toll on it. And many people do not read beyond the $30 a week toll headline.

TV3 did an item on Lockwood’s comments and talked to some local employers of seasonal labour and they said much the same thing as Lockwood. However my criticism still stands – in an election campaign you have to think five seconds ahead of what you say, and avoid giving needless ammo to your opponents.

Woolerton shamed by Glenn saga

NZ First MP Doug Woolerton has revealed that he felt shamed by the Owen Glenn saga and that he thought the Privileges Committee did its job:

The Owen Glenn donation scandal, which almost capsized Winston Peters, deeply embarrassed his NZ First colleague, Hamilton MP Doug Woolerton.

List MP Mr Woolerton made the revelation during last night’s Waikato Times candidates’ debate for Hamilton East.

He was responding to a question from the floor on the subject and dropped characteristic good humour to answer openly and honestly.

“I was hugely embarrassed. That was unfortunate but the parliamentary committee did its job,” he said.

Doug will be gald NZ First has already had their list ranking!

It is good to see some signs of intelligent life in NZ First – I mean no-one (not even Helen) really could have heard all the evidence and think there was anyway Winston was telling the truth about not knowing.

More blog poll results

Since my last summary in July, many more blog polls. The findings were:

  1. Tax Cuts – 76% say cut income tax, 17% say cut GST and 7% neither
  2. Universal Allowances – 66% support universal allowances and 37% parental means testing
  3. Winston and Owen Glenn – 73% said Winston knew all about the donation, 20% said Winston suspected it but was careful not to ask, 14% say he knew nothing and 5% say he knew about the donation but not the amount
  4. Registered Parties – 34% said there were 20, 26% 18, 19% 14, 15% 16, and 5% 12. I can’t recall anymore what was the correct answer for back in July.
  5. Rodney Hide – 19% thought Rodney was gay, 38% said he wasn’t and 43% said “not yet”
  6. Election Date – 48% correctly predicted 8 November followed by 27% for 15 November
  7. US Election – 49% back McCain, 38% Obama and 13% other
  8. National’s Benefits Policy – 41% say step in right direction but wimped out on real reform, 35% say good policy and 18% call it beneficiary bashing plus 8% want no benefits for anyone
  9. Olympics – 31% said the Ever-Swindells had the best performance, 25% choose Mahe Drsdale, 20% Nick WIllis and 19% Valerie Vili
  10. ACT’s No 5 – the favourite pick was Cactus Kate at 18%, Jim Hopkins at 15%, Lindsay Perigo at 15%, Owen Glenn at 14% and DPF at 10%
  11. Election Date No 2 – a second poll in September saw 45% pick 8 November, 31% 15 November and 25% 18 October
  12. Minor Party not to make it – the top choice for minor party not to make it back was NZ First at 38%, then Greens at 30%, ACT 15%, Maori Party 9%, Progressive 4% and United Future 3%
  13. Sack Winston – 88% said Clark should have sacked Peters
  14. Government’s ethics – 83% say less ethical than previous Governments, 9% more ethical and 8% equally ethical
  15. Why Winston not sacked – 63% say Helen not sack because of what he will say or reveal, 33% say in case she needs him after the election and 4% because she genuinely thinks he told the truth
  16. 2008 MP of the Year – Rodney Hide at 48% with Bill English 2nd at 24%
  17. 2008 Labour MP of the Year – Winston Peters scoops it at 58% ahead of Michael Cullen at 22% and David Cunliffe on 20%
  18. 2008 National MP of the Year – John Key with 50% ahead of Simon Power with a credible 32%
  19. 2008 Minor Party MP of the Year – Rodney Hide at 63% and then Pita Sharples at 23%
  20. 2008 Press Gallery Journalist of the Year – Audrey Young scoops 57% and Colin Espiner 2nd on 20%
  21. 2008 Public Servant of the Year – Owen Glenn may not have got Consul but he gets 46% with SFO Director Grant Liddell next on 32% and then Electoral Commission CEO Helena Catt on 22%
  22. National’s Tax Cuts – the most popular rating or mode was 7/10 on 17%. The mean was 5.7/10 and the median was a 7/10
  23. National Super Fund Policy – the plan to have 40% invested in NZ had 38% strongly agreeing, 28% somewhat agreeing, 21% strong disagree, 9% somewhat disagree and 9% neutral

I have marked what my personal responses were in italics, so people can see when I disagree with the majority.

Stupid

Stuff is reporting comments from Lockwood Smith that at best are stupid and at worst offensive:

“There are some skills in the vineyard that some people are perhaps better at,” Dr Smith was reported saying in the Marlborough Express newspaper.

“For example some of the pruning…some of the Asian workers have been more productive…because their hands are smaller.”

Dr Smith said employers should not be solely responsible for teaching or funding training that prepared workers for life in New Zealand.

“Some of them are having to teach them things like how to use a toilet or shower…I don’t think the employer should have to pay for that work.

The RSE scheme is 78% Pacific Island, so the latter comment is being seen as referring to Pacific Islanders.

Lockwood has apologised for his comments, which were repeating what employers had told him:

“My comments, regarding the extent to which employers, under the RSE scheme were being required to provide life skills training to RSE workers, were simply reporting the strong concerns expressed to me by many employers.

“These reported concerns have been expressed in the media previously, and there has been strong advocacy for future changes to the scheme to deal with them.

“Presented in the way they were, I can see that my reported comments may have caused offence. I sincerely regret that because it certainly was not my intention.

Lockwood should not have made the comments, regardless of what employers have told him. Firstly racial generalisations in public are rarely helpful – even if accurate that many Asians do have smaller hands.

The comments on some RSE workers needing teaching to use a toilet or shower are more unwise, in fact quite offensive. I am sure it is true that some workers have needed this teaching, but Lockwood’s mistake was to repeat this anecdotal evidence without any context at all – is it 1% of RSE workers, 10% or 50%? By just referring to anecdotal evidence, it allows people to assume it is a massive problem – something I suspect it not correct. Certainly I would be offended if I was an RSE workers by those comments as it tars them all with the same brush.

In an election campaign, the need for discipline is paramount. Especially in an election where there will be few being spending policy announcements, so stuff like this can end up as a big story for many days.

John Key I have no doubt is bloody angry with Lockwood – both for the comments per se, but also the timing. An option that will be in play is whether the comments merit sacking Lockwood – Roar Prawn certainly thinks this should happen.

I think it is a close call. It would be very sad for Lockwood’s career to end on such a stupidity. He has been a very hard working and diligent MP and Spokesperson – exposing many a wrong-doing in the Immigration Service. We do need to be careful not to demand MPs be without fault. I am not saying one should do a Helen and keep Winston with the baubles of office no matter what he says or does. But few MPs never ever stuff up.

On the other hand, not sacking Lockwood may cause the comments to be more than a one day issue, and sometimes you have to be pragmatic and just accept politics can be very harsh. Sacking Lockwood would also reinforce to National MPs the consequences of stupid utterances in election campaigns.

There are only 17 days left before the election. This means that what positive news National wanted to get out today, will be over-shadowed by this. Stupid indeed.

750 at a public meeting

I just noted at the bottom of this Dom Post article that John Key had 750 people attend a public meeting in Pukekohe last night. That’s a huge number of people.

Pukekohe is not a wealthy area – the median family income is $60,800, marginally above the NZ average of $59,000. And on the Degree of Deprivation scale from Wellington School of Medicine, they are around a 7 – with 1 being least deprived and 10 most deprived.

So getting 750 people anywhere is rare – but in Pukekohe is quite extraordinary.

Will Labour reveal their tax increases policy before the election?

Smart readers will have noted Labour have been very careful not to rule out tax increases after the election. They have said they will not reverse their current tax cuts, but they have left open introducing new taxes, or a new “rich rich prick” tax rate of 45c for those who earn over $100,000.

The Herald reports that Labour have basically already spent their contingency spending money for the next three years. This means that if Labour is re-elected they will either have to go through three years of making no spending promises or they will put up taxes.

Yesterday Dr Cullen said strong leadership was needed to ensure the overseas crisis did not lead to a “depression” in New Zealand.

“Labour is simply not prepared to let that happen,” Dr Cullen said.

“We will bring forward spending on infrastructure to create real jobs and build the potential for future growth … now is not the time to slash spending as our opponents are proposing.”

The hypocrisy of these statements are massive. Up until a few weeks ago Dr Cullen was attacking National’s plans for increased infrastructure spending. Cullen and Clark said it was madness and lunacy. They have done the mother of all u-turns.

But he also gets it wrong about “slashing spending”. Yes National will look to eleiminate some low quality spending – but the major change it is making is reducing the amount of money going into KiwiSaver in the short term. Now Dr Cullen is saying that in a recession you need increased activity to help you out of it – well that is exactly what National are doign by temporarily diverting some money from savings into spending and tax cuts – both of which help minimise a recession.

So by Dr Cullen’s own logic, National’s policies will provide a greater short-term stimulus to the economy. You save more in the good times and you save less and spend more in the tight times – exactly what National is doing. Cullen just can not admit that his 4%/4% KiwiSaver policy is nno longer suitable for today’s economic climate – it was a policy for when we had massive surpluses.

The minor parties and the Internet

Michelle Sullivan continues her rating of the parties and their websites. In her earlier article she gave National an A and Labour a C+ for their web strategies.

  • NZ First – same design since 2002 – a D
  • ACT – website okay but needs tweaking, not enough use of social networking and You Tube – a C
  • Maori Party – simple website, little content – a C
  • Family Party – a shiny website, too American, but will be popular with many. No grade given
  • Green Party – expected big things but underwhelmed. Suggest more video on front page. Overall good and gets a B grade.
  • United Future – nice three column setup. Blgo is integrated into site. Also like minipolls. A solid B.
  • Progressive – unusual design – some will like it. Little content – C-.

So the overall rankings would be:

  1. National A+
  2. Greens B
  3. United Future B
  4. Labour C+
  5. ACT C
  6. Maori C
  7. Progressive C-
  8. NZ First D

That is pretty close to the rankings I gave out earlier this year in various presentations I did on the issue. I had Greens and National the top two but Greens higher. I also had Progressive and NZ First as the bottom two.  I did have ACT over Labour though but still around the middle.