It’s legal because they changed the law

There has finally been some attention paid by the media to Labour’s “information kit for the over 60s” which their MPs are posting and handing out in the tens of thousands.

Matthew Hooton has blogged on this several times in recent days.

This is a continuation of Labour’s 2005 pledge card strategy where Labour tries to get the taxpayer to pay for material it can use during the election campaign – and also tries to not have it count towards as part of their $2.4 million spending limit.

There are two questions involved:

  1. Is it appropriate and legal for the info kit to be paid for by The Parliamentary Service (taxpayers) for distribution during the election campaign?
  2. Does the info kit constitute an election advertisement under the Electoral Finance Act?

The answer to (1) is that it is legal – but, and this is important, only because Labour, NZ First and Greens rammed through a law change to over-turn the Auditor General’s interpretation of the previous law.

The Auditor-General could well have found, if the law had not changed, that this info kit was electioneering – especially as it was produced and distributed so close to an election. If it was a genuine info kit it would have been produced and distributed last year or even earlier this year.

But Labour First and the Greens changed the law (without even giving the public a chance to submit on the law change) so that only material which explicitly sought support for a party (as oppossed to implicitly) is covered. Under this law change Labour’s 2005 pledge card could be legally taxpayer funded again.

My solution to this rorting of the system is simple – ban taxpayer funding of such advertising in the last 90 days. If it was a genuine info kit then they can produce and distribute it when there is not an election a few days away.

This is all part of Labour’s strategy to hold its most marginal seats. Part One was the Electoral Finance Act to silence new candidates by extending the $20,000 limit in the regulated period from 90 days to all of election year. This is a limit of around 5c/voter/month. Part Two was changing the law so incumbent MPs could use taxpayer funded advertising during the election campaign. It is all designed to keep incumbent MPs in their jobs.

Considering the huge amount of interest in the pledge card last time, it is surprising it has taken so long for the media to cover this issue. Has TVNZ or Radio NZ told their viewers and listeners that Labour and “friends” changed the law to make these info kits legal?

The second issue is whether or not the info kits are advertisements under the Electoral Finance Act. I tend to think they are not. The issue for me is whether MPs should be allowed to use their taxpayer funded budgets so close to an election to be writing and sending stuff to tens of thousands of voters.

I’d cry too

It is not surprising a juror cried as the final days of Nia Glassie were detailed in court – maybe the surprise is that all the jurors did not cry.  Even reading about it in the newspaper is gut churning enough. It is bad enough when any child dies due to abuse or neglect – but this case seems even worse as the abuse was deliberate and for entertainment it seems. The sad details include:

  • Forcibly placed Nia on a clothesline and spun her around until she fell off, twice repeating the action while standing around laughing
  • Put her in a tumble dryer and turned it on, standing by laughing.
  • Forced Nia to take cold baths and then dressed her in soiled clothes
  • Kicking her in the head, causing bleeding between her brain and skull.
  • Leaving her unconscious, having fits and frothing at the mouth for 36 hours before her family sought medical help

I just don’t know how people can do such evil, let alone how others can observe this happening and do or say nothing. The instinct to protect kids is well instinctive in most of us. I guess the sad answer is that those who perform such evil deeds, were probably abused themselves growing up. And that in no way excuses what they did – but it reinforces how vital it is we make a greater effort to break the cycle of abuse.

Winston’s diet

Rob Hosking at NBR reported:

At a North Shore candidates’ meeting on Tuesday, one punter asked a question from the floor about general health, gambling, alcoholism and the like. New Zealand First MP Dail Jones stood up and said it was a question of looking after yourself, eating well, and getting some exercise. “An excellent example of this would be Winston Peters,” said Jones. “His health was terrible until he changed his lifestyle and began eating mainly fish …” That was as far as he got before the audience collapsed in laughter and Wayne Mapp cried “scampi.”

Oh if only someone could have captured that on video. Classic.

Jeanette’s replacement

Jeanette Fitzsimons is going to stand down as female co-leader during the next term of Parliament. That will be one less MP from the enviornmental wing, and she is likely to be replaced by an MP from the communist social justice wing of Norman, Bradford and Locke.

With that in mind a reader has sent me this photo of the likely next co-leader.

Now that’s a watermelon all right!

Campaign 08 on Winston

For professional Winston watchers, the Campaign 08 discussion on Peters is worth a watch – just click play on the main page. Peters refused to appear but Phil Kitchin, Duncan Garner, Vernon Small, Bill Ralston and Barry Soper discuss his highs and lows.

Was the “Don’t shout like you do at home” remark deliberate?

NZ Herald Political Editor Audrey Young looks at the attack ad run by Labour against John Key. SHe blogs:

The pictures chosen did get me wondering though. Having chosen such an aggressive photograph of John Key for the first picture in the ad, I wondered whether the Labour leader’s attempt to portray Key in last week’s television debate as aggressive at home was quite the error it appeared to be at the time.

Perhaps it was part of a wider strategy to try to convince the public the John Key you see in public is not the real John Key.

I think Audrey may be onto something here. Clark may well have tailored her comments in the debate to support the theme her attack ads were going to take.

Adam Smith at The Inquiring Mind comments:

… was the Helen Clark attempt to portray Key as some sort of tyrannical figure at home part of a wider strategy as suggested by Ms Young above. Was Helen’s tantrum part of some misbegotten plan? Has Labour embarked on a dirty tricks campaign?

Adam then looks at how after losing the debate Clark accussed Key of losing control and having a tantrum. He concludes:

Perhaps there is something in what Audrey Young is suggesting after all. …

it is fascinating that Audrey Young thinks Clark and Labour fully capable of such a strategy.

Now remind Adam which party is supposed to be employing evil spin doctors. Who is going on about trust all the time?

Personally I have no problem with the TV advert Labour are running. May they keep running it. I do still have a problem with the PM’s suggestion that John Key shouts in anger at his wife and children, and the only thing worse than her saying such a thing in the heat of the moment would be her saying such a thing as part of a deliberate campaign to paint him that way.

A modified Greens scorecard

Huffington Post labels NZ election as “dirty”

The massively read liberal leaning Huffington Post has done a feature on dirty elections. They say that the US election is actually very clean compared to others:

But as far as campaigns, we don’t know dirty.

Picking recent and ongoing campaigns in Nigeria, Russia, Austria, New Zealand, Taiwan and Zimbabwe, they remind that we’re watching a Stepford Wives Tupperware gathering by comparison …

What a wonderful list of countries we are included with?  I guess they have noticed the unrelenting campaign of secret tapes, stolen e-mails, insinuations of being a “domestic shouter”, complaints about temper tantrums etc etc.

Inflation hits 18 year high

Labour is making a habit of leaving office with economic problems for the new Government.

Stats NZ reveals that inflation for the year to September 2008 was 5.1% – its highest level since June 1990. Major contributors:

  • Household Energy 7.5%
  • Hospital Services 7.1%
  • Private Transport 21.5%
  • primary and secondary eduction 5.7%

The monthly food price index also came out today – and it is also at an 18 year high of 10.8%. Major contributors:

  • Vegetables 22.3%
  • Mutton/Lamb 17.3%
  • Bread 16.5%
  • Pasta 18.2%
  • Cheese 42.3%

All fairly common items, to say the least.

Waikato

The Waikato seat replaces Piako, held by Lindsay Tisch. Tisch won it in 1999 as Karapiro with a 5,216 majority. Before that it was held by John Luxton.

In 2002 as Piako Tisch beat Sue Morony by 1,621 and in 2005, extended his majority over Moroney to 8,351. So not really a marginal seat. I estimate on the new boundaries the majority is 6,916.

We passed through Waikato on the way to Hamilton. Blog reader (and commenter) Tauhei Notts offered us a lunch in Morrinsville so we weant off the main track to get there. And when I say off the main track, I mean it. I love having GPS in the car but sometimes it picks obscure back country roads to travel along, and we ended up motoring through all sorts of narrow roads, bypassing all the main centres totally. Took a bit longer but meant we saw some great countryside.

Now it transpired that Tauhei Notts, despite being an ACT stalwart, is an old family friend of Labour’s Jacinda Ardern, and Jacinda has just got back from the UK the previous day. So Jacinda and her mother joined us for lunch.

Jacinda was wonderful company. She is great to talk to (especially about international politics) and was so charming that even Whale Oil was heard to comment that she is far far too nice to be in Labour (whenever Whale meets a Labour MP or candidate he likes, he just assumes they are in the wrong party rather than concede nice people can be in Labour :-). In fact one of the most amusing parts of lunch was having Jacinda politely rebuff Whale’s suggestion that she really was a Tory deep down. Considering Jacinda is the President of the International Union of Socialist Youth, her political convictions are rather firm!

What I am saying here, won’t come as a surprise to many within Labour – but Jacinda is one of their real stars.  This is reflected in her stellar list ranking of 20, which would see her come in on a party vote of 25% for Labour. I suspect she will move up the ranks quickly.

She isn’t going to dent Lindsay’s majority this time. But as a native of the Waikato she will be an effective List MP for the area, and at a future election when the tide is going out rather than in for National, she could make it a close race. Definitely worth watching out for.

Rotorua

I’m around a week behind with blogging from the blogmobile, so will be doing a series of catch up posts over the next two days.

It is lots of fun out on the road, but fitting in time for driving, work for my business, blogging the national stuff, meeting and interviewing locals and then actually blogging about them has been hard.

Anyway back to Rotorua. which was the weekend before last. Rotorua as a city tends to be Labour voting, but on the new boundaries is marginally National. It has a high Maori population and at the local markets I would have said it was 50/50 Maori and non-Maori.

So it was interesting to observe the warm reception John Key got there – lots of people wanting to chat to him, even sing to him.

John was a good enough sport to give us a quick interview, above. He cited the economy as easily the biggest issue for NZers. He also endorsed parts of the NZX plan (and this was prior to him announcing the NZ Super Fund policy which was in there) except for capital gains tax. John said 2002 was his first ever election – he was a prefect at school but that was “selected by the Gods higher up”.

He was cautious on McCain vs Obama but did say McCain was a strong supporter of NZ, but sure Obama will be also. He didn’t rule out offering Sarah Palin a role in his administration if she didn’t make it to Vice-President in the US. His tax cuts did go on the legendary block of cheese and for the final question he chose Goff over Cunliffe – but did predict Goff would not be there long.

Todd “Boris” McClay is the local candidate – and also cooks up great bacon and eggs at midnight! He was born in Rotorua and returned to NZ after many years in Europe, including representing several Pacific states to the European Union.

Todd picked crime as the biggest local issue from his door knocking. I asked Todd how a non Cook Islander ended up as their Ambassador to the European Union. Todd artfully pointed out he was made an Honorary Cook Islander a few years ago in gratitude for his services, so he may be our first Cook Islands MP!

Internationally Todd is backing Obama as he is about the future. On the tax cuts he,like many candidates, is without income so gets nothing from tax cuts but if he was working would invest them in KiwiSaver. And finally he picks Michael Cullen ahead of Goff and Cunliffe for the future!

Steve Chadwick was there also. Sadly Steve wasn’t keen to take part – a pity because this is all light hearted stuff – nothing tough or nasty. Anyway Cameron got some footage of Steve refusing.

Rotorua has been held by Chadwick since 1999, winning it off Max Bradford with a 4,978 majority. In 2002 she extended that to 7.744. This got knocked back to 662 in 2005 and on the new 2008 boundaries it is marginally National by 366 votes.

This is one of those seats National would expect to win if it becomes Government. Chadwick is No 30 on Labour’s list and would come back in on 32% of the vote, so should be back regardless. McClay is 54 on National’s list and would come in on around 45%.

Vincent Heeringa on Labour’s economic policies

Vincent Heeringa has published an article called The First 3,000 days:

Labour swept to power in 1999 promising to transform New Zealand into a world-class, knowledge-led economy. Instead, they reverted to ‘Old Labour’ habits of taxing, regulating and centralising.

Anyone remember their goal of the top half of the OECD?

Today, it’s Labour’s turn to look flat-footed. Its stuttering, knee-jerk reaction to John Key reveals a Cabinet empty of fresh talent and ideas.

Does he mean their policy of borrow and smear?

In ’99, Labour swept in with an agenda to transform the New Zealand economy. … Most importantly, it declared that ‘economic transformation’ would lead us to a knowledge-based, world-class economy. Optimistically, Labour promised to get us into the top half of the OECD by 2011.

Oh yes that’s right – all the buzzwords and goals.

Labour knew what had to be done to get New Zealand’s economy off the road to nowhere, but has done far too little, much too late. Despite a good start and despite being armed with full knowledge of what transformed the similar economies of Ireland and Finland, Labour surrendered the task through a lack of willpower and ideas. When it was time to step up, Labour reverted to type.

So long as there was enough economic growth to fund their spending promises, they saw no reason to transform the economy.

The greatest failure, in my view, is that Labour’s rhetoric about transformation has proven to be just that. Fancy talk. The Growth and Innovation Framework was dropped around 2004. Of the three major task forces established in design, ICT and biotech, only design continues. The science and research that was to emerge from such a framework has simply not occurred. In fact, the science system may be in a worse state than when Labour took power.

Once the high profile conferences finished, so did the strategy it seems.

But while the Australians have deployed public–private partnerships in infrastructure and state services, this government reverted to the old Labour policies of taxing, regulating and centralising. It now owns ACC, Air New Zealand, KiwiBank, KiwiRail and four power companies. The government has turned the idea of private ownership of strategic assets (even as partners with the state) into an anathema and hobbled crown entities with high dividends and restrictions on how they can raise capital.

No other left-wing Government in the OECD has such a hatred and aversion to the private sector. NZ Labour are miles apart from Australian Labor and UK Labour.

And whereas the Blair government re-energised its public services and brought in much-needed entrepreneurship and investment by working with the private sector, Clark’s Labour has simply added more bureaucrats. Total government spending has increased from 36.1 percent of GDP in 2000 to 41.4 percent last year.

It gets worse than that. The recent PREFU shows total government spending increasing to 45% of GDP next year. The tax increases in Labour’s planned mini-budget to cover this will be massive.

Heeringa then looks at individual indicators:

  • Standard of Living: slipped from 20th to 22nd in OECD
  • Productivity: annual labour productivity growth of 1.1% half of the 1990s and below OECD 1.8% average
  • Savings: praises KiwiSaver but says why did they wait until 2007
  • Innovation: NZ ranks just 25th in our ability to use innovation to develop new and unique products
  • Tax: No tax cuts until 2008 – and a unnecessary tax increase in 2000
  • Infrastructure: Not enough power due to planning restrictions, are extending copper network when fibre is needed.

So low marks all around. And Heeringa is no “hard right” commentator. If anything, a but Labour-friendly.

Hat Tip: Homepaddock

A nice polling resource

Focus on Fibre plans

Paul Winton writes on broadband plans:

In early 2008 both Labour and National admitted that, for communications, ‘the market’ just wasn’t going to get us there. In March, National trumped Labour by announcing an ambitious $1.5 billion investment into fibre-to-the-premise broadband to 75 per cent of premises over the next six years. About a month later, Labour announced a smaller investment of $325 million into broadband infrastructure.

Neither plan is perfect. Relative to National, Labour’s plan lacks scale and clarity of outcomes. Conversely, the National plan could significantly change the landscape if designed well, but equally, if done poorly could scare away investment.

Which is why presumably National has said it will get expert advice on the best way to implement a fibre to the home network.

Telecom’s slow rollout using copper technology is perfectly reasonable for them. They’re going as fast as shareholders will allow them to and there’s no reason for them to accelerate it.

Sadly for New Zealand, if we continue to roll out fibre at this rate we won’t get the sort of capabilities our close Asian neighbours like South Korea have until about 2040. Many in New Zealand think a thirty-year lag is a bit much to swallow.

There is no doubt we will end up with fibre to the home for most of NZ. The question is by when. Do we want to be one of the last OECD countries to have widespread fibre, or one of the first? Will there be economic and environmental benefits from early deployment? I think so obviously.

So what happens first under, say, a National-led government?

The first thing is to get people around the table. Those people would probably be Telecom, perhaps a consortium of lines companies and a group from overseas. There will need to be some form of RFP process, development of a long-term regulatory framework, and finally a clear assessment of what the government dollar is investing in and what returns it will get.

If designed well, with the good of the country in mind, the National programme will launch New Zealand to the front of the pack globally and create a competitive, world-class communications sector.

If done poorly we will continue to lag behind our peers and suffer the consequences of living in a nation with communications asthma.

Not much there I disagree with.

NZ Herald on banking crisis

The Government continues to dither on whether to extend the depsit guarantee scheme to include wholesale borrowing. The NZ Herald Editorial notes:

Yet local banks must renew loans as they fall due if they are to have money to advance to businesses that need it to pay wages and bills. With the global financial system nervous and near frozen, it may be hard to raise the money when it is needed, particularly if other countries are underwriting their banks’ borrowings.

The simple reality is we are too small to not give the guarantee, when other countries have done so.

Many will have applauded the National Party leader’s offer to work with the Finance Minister in developing a response to the crisis. Not as many will have appreciated Michael Cullen’s refusal to do more than keep John Key and his finance spokesman, Bill English, briefed on progress.

Indeed.

But Dr Cullen’s position has to be recognised. To bring National into the decision-making would be almost an admission that it will be the next Government and neither major party in our system could be expected to make that concession before an election.

Or it could just be a realisation we are days out from a general election, and that regardless of the outcome, a bipartisan approach is prudent during this period.

National insiders claimed the bank governor, Alan Bollard, had wanted to brief the Opposition on the original decision in advance, but Mr Key did not make an issue of the Government’s refusal to do so. He shows a refreshing lack of interest in the petty side of politics and does not make too much of the advantage he could claim for his intimate knowledge of the finance industry.

A refreshing lack of interest in the petty side of politics. A strength some mistake for a weakness.

Police for South Auckland

It is interesting to see Labour argue against having half the new Police recruits going into South Auckland – as National is proposing.They are saying it may take Police from elsewhere. Annette King has said:

“National says how good its policy would be for south Auckland, but it doesn’t say how bad it would be for the rest of the country.”

A cynical person might conclude this is because Labour knows most people in South Auckland will vote Labour no matter what – so why actually risk unpopularity in other areas – they may have less crime – but they have more swinging voters.

And you have to give kudos for National. Their vote in South Auckland is miniscule. The pledge to have 300 more front line staff in South Auckland can hardly be seen as motivated by votes. It would be all too easy for National to think let’s forget about South Auckland – after all most people only go through it on the way to and from the airport.

So I’m quite pleased National is putting doing the right thing over what may be the most popular thing.

Cactus Kate rates the hot male candidates

Cactus Kate rates the male MPs and Canidates for hotness. Those who make her list are:

  • Rodney Hide (ACT)
  • Shane Jones (Labour)
  • Hone Harawira (Maori)
  • Paul Quinn (National)
  • Nathan Guy (National)
  • Darren Hughes (Labour)
  • Russel Norman (Greens)
  • Shane Gallagher (Greens)
  • Ron Mark (NZ First) – she compares him to mini-me
  • Stuart Nash (Labour)
  • Chris Tremain (National)
  • Todd “Boris” McClay (National)
  • Charles Chauvel (Labour)
  • Chris Finlayson (National)
  • Grant Robertson (Labour)
  • Simon Bridges (National)
  • Mitch Lees (Libertarianz)

A very balanced list – 6 National, 5 Labour, 2 Greens, 1 ACT, 1 Maori, 1 NZ First, and 1 Libertarianz

The Kiwiblog Files

Scrubone at Half Done has done a very brave thing – he has gone through years of Kiwiblog archives, and pulled out all the best posts about what the Government did wrong. This is a great resource.

On this page he has 2003 and 2004 summarised.

And on this page he has January to May of 2005.

They really are a great summary of the times. He should apply for a grant to have them turned into a history textbook 🙂

Let him know if you can help get them updated to the current time – 2006 will be very interesting especially.

600 more frontline Police

National has released its policy on police numbers:

  • recruiting and train 600 extra police officers from 1 January 2009. This is 224 on top of current plans.
  • By 2011 having one police officer for every 500 residents, and keep this ratio as population grows
  • 300 more Police in frontline roles in South Auckland (Counties-Manukau) by the end of 2010
  • Cost $18.5 million
  • Only 21% of new recruits under Labour have been allocated general frontline duties. All 600 under National will be allocated to the frontline with half going to South Auckland (Counties-Manukau).
  • Roll out Canterbury’s persistent-offender programme, which targets crime families, to other districts, subject to a positive evaluation of the trial.

They also talk of focusing road safety on blackspots and at risk drivers, rather than blanket ticketing which has doubled under Labour from 560,427 to 1,038,109.

The least surprising decision of recent times

After many weeks (actually minutes) of consideration and discussion, the Greens have announced their intention to support a Labour-led Government. I predicted this some time ago as their criteria made it impossible to get any other result – not a single criteria had anything to do with creating wealth.

You now have four parties dedicating to re-electing Labour First. They are Labour, NZ First, Progressive and Greens. A vote for them is a vote for Helen and Winston.

Two parties are dedicated to a National-led Government – National and ACT.

Two parties say they could go either way – United Future and the Maori Party.

A photo from Mt Maunganui

Louise Crome

An enthusiastic reader has e-mailed me these pictures of Louise Crome.

I happened to be chatting to Rodney this morning and he told me how he called Louise up after the story in the Herald on Sunday and told her they have to start dating now, seeing the media already think they are. He didn’t tell me what her reply was 🙂

Just the daughter