The Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee

I was delighted to see National announce that if elected, they will establish a Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee. Facing a decade of deficits it would be stupid not to do so. It isn’t good enough to only scrutinise new spending initiatives. At a time where private sector companies are having to make tough decisions, the public sector should not be exempt.

I have to admit that my ideal job would be something like Chief Advisor or Analyst to the Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee. Hell I’d almost do the job for free. And no not because I want to slash and burn – it would be the satisfaction of being able to eliminate low quality expenditure without it affecting public services.  And don’t believe there isn’t a lot of it out there – I’ve chatted to far too many senior public servants who have told me about the waste. By waste, I don’t mean that the expenditure is a total waste of time – just that the benefits from the expenditure are marginal.

Now I don’t actually want a job in Parliament again – eight years in Parliament was enough punishment for one lifetime. But hell even just six months working for the Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee would be enough time to make a difference – I wonder if they would take applicants on a commission basis 🙂

Focus on three Auckland Seats

The NZ Herald looks at Auckland Central, Epsom and Maungakiekie.

Auckland Central:

That is not troubling the motivated Kaye, who is running a vigorous and old-fashioned door-knocking campaign. National Party sources say that although raised in conservative Epsom and Kohimarama, she is more socially liberal and environmentally active than most in the party.

On the other hand, Tizard has more than 40 years of family political history and nous to draw on. Name recognition, strong links with the gay and other communities and being a junior minister in transport and the arts help. Then again, she has received criticism for her now-defunct role of Minister for Auckland Issues.

Epsom:

Worth, who became a list MP, is standing again, but says he is firmly concentrating on increasing National’s party vote of 58.5 per cent in 2005 to 70 per cent.

“How people decide to cast their constituency vote is an issue for them.”

With Act polling well below the 5 per cent threshold to gain list seats in Parliament, National needs Hide to win Epsom and hopefully provide two or more Act MPs for a National-led coalition.

Maungakiekie:

Labour is replacing one unionist (Mr Gosche is a former national secretary of the Service and Food Workers Union) with another, Carol Beaumont, secretary of the Council of Trade Unions. …

Samoan-born Peseta Sam Lotu-Iiga is the National candidate. Not only is he among a new bunch of young, highly educated 28-to-45-year-olds offering new blood and values for National, but he is also part of an attempt to boost the party’s ethnic diversity.

iPredict last week

From iPredict’s weekly newsletter.

A lot of events in the fourth to last week of the campaign. The campaign launches themselves seem to have made little impact on share prices, but the One News Colmar Brunton poll giving National an 18% lead pushed National up from 70c to 73c. National then dropped back on Monday to as low as 68c.

On Tuesday as bad news from the first two days dominated, National dropped to 65c. But then as the debate got underway at 7 pm, National went up 5c during the 90 minute debate and a further 2c later that night to 72c. Labour went into the debate at 35c and at one stage that night had dropped to 25c.

Wednesday saw National launch its NZ Super Fund policy and this was seen as a vote winner pushing them up to 76c by midday, where they have stayed since. So National and Labour are both at where they were a week ago before the Roy Morgan poll pushed them both close together by 5c each.

Majority.Nat has not recovered so well though. Before the Roy Morgan poll it was at 35c and dropped to 17c. Over the week it recovered to reach 28c but still some way off its start.

MP.Peters had an unusual week Over the weekend it went from 36c to 45c, perhaps reflecting a strong campaign launch. But then on Wednesday it collapsed to 35c, recovering to 40c Thursday. There does not appear to be a strong reason for such volatility.

Benson.Pope saw a lot of money lost as it rose early in the week from 24c to 45c as stories emerged he was still doo knocking. But he bluffed well, and his announcement on Monday that he was not standing sent the stock crashing to zero.

Finally we have a new feature – my weekly recommended buy or sell (note I have stock in Obama). My recommended buy would be US.Obama at anything below 90c. The reason for this is not his 7% lead on average in the national polls, but his lead in the state polls. They show him to already have a majority in the electoral college, even if you do not allocate out any of the close races. He has the states, the money, the volunteers and the enthusiasm and he will be the first African-American President of the United States unless he is hit by the mother of all scandals.

All over in the US

Colin Powell has endorsed Barack Obama, and even before that happened Obama has a commanding lead not just nationally, but in the state polls.

There were 18 states in 2004 that had a margin of victory of less than 10%. Every single marginal state, except Arkansas, has Obama in the lead in state polls.

Obama needs 269 electoral votes to win. At present he has 286 locked in and 364 likely. It would need something massive to happen to stop him.

GST to 15% and top income tax to 45%

Labour have left the economy with a projected decade of deficits and the latest economic news, coupled with Labour’s massive spending promises, could push the country into a structural deficit.

Top tax expert John Shewan has looked at what might have to be done to break out of Labour’s decade of deficits. He says GST might need to go from 12.5% to 15.0% and the top tax rate from 39% to 45%.

Is this what Labour has planned for its December mini-budget?

Breakfast

Was on TVNZ’s Breakfast this morning chatting about social networking in the election campaign.  Went okay but said one stupid thing – that Obama had raised more money on the Internet than NZ’s GDP. The moment I said it I realised I was out by a couple of orders of magnitude.

Recieved a phone call while walking home afterwards from a retired lady wanting to know if I was related to a Captain Roger Farrar, who had helped her during WWII. I explained that my immediate family are not related to any other Farrars as our name was anglicised from Feuer after leaving Austria.

She them exclaimed “Oh you must be Jewish, I thought you were from Television”. I laughed that the nose must give it away. It seems the other Farrar she knew many years ago was also Jewish – Scottish Jews. Of course I’m not actually Jewish as the Jewish ancestry comes from my father’s side and it only counts if it is on the mother’s side.

Government to fund Destiny Church

Rodney

The HoS reveals what many have known – Rodney is dating one of NZ’s top squash players – Louise Crome.

Not sure how it is a relevant media story, but will no doubt generate a week’s worth of stories in the women’s mags. Might explain how Rodney keeps so happy no matter what the polls say 🙂

Kerre on Work for the Dole

Kerre Woodham supports Tariana Turia on abolishing the dole.

It’s an idea that could have only come from the Maori Party. If Act or National had suggested this, we’d have all been leaping up and down and accusing them of heartlessness.

But the idea of working for the dole has some merit.

I would hate to see us operate as some other countries do, where people either work or die. But when you’re working every hour God sends, it’s galling to think of healthy, able-bodied people collecting money from the taxpayer for doing nothing.

All the people I’ve spoken to on the radio who’ve been unemployed for any length of time say it’s soul-destroying. Their confidence diminishes by the day, they become lethargic and unmotivated and a sense of worthlessness pervades.

There’s never enough money – rather than being grateful for the money they get from the state, they feel aggrieved that it’s not more and they become alienated from the community.

On the other hand, work is good for the soul. I’m not sure about the make-work schemes – they’re extremely expensive and if the workers feel they’re just marking time, doing something pointless, they don’t even get the satisfaction of a job well done.

Making it easier for employers to give somebody a chance might be the way to go. Given how difficult it is to fire someone who doesn’t work out, and given the speed with which employees contact lawyers when they’re shown the door, many small business owners are justifiably wary of taking a chance on someone whose CV might be a little patchy.

So Kerre supports work for the dole and grievance free trial periods. Her conversion from a latte liberal to a member of the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy continues.

HoS on Spammers

Pleased to see a newspaper devoting an editorial to the case of the alleged NZ spammers:

Even the most liberal among us might find the phrase “hanging’s too good for them” leaping to our lips when we read about the case of the Christchurch-based spammers.

Send in DIck Cheney I say!

The men sent more than two million emails to New Zealand addresses in 2007, though presumably they spammed a lot of people overseas too, since they made $3.3 million for their “work”, which would have meant $1.65 a delivery if it had been only local.

Yes, they would have sent billions globally during that time. Response rates are well below 0.1%

Nice work if you can get it? Not really. Even the most intermittent web user detests spammers as something akin to pond scum, not least because they seem to have such a low opinion of their target market: they assume, for example, that all of us – including women – are deeply disaffected with the size of our penises and will happily drop what we are doing so we can sign up for a herbal enlargement programme run by con artists in Mauritius.

They are pond scum. And the best thing that will come from the court case is getting their pictures in the media. It was community disdain in 2003 that got Atkinson to at least publicly claim to stop spamming.

Regrettably the court will have to apply the law, but if ever there was a case in which the punishment should fit the crime, this is it.

Let the young men keep their $200,000. Let them handwrite (no photocopies, please) apologies to every household – wired or not, just to be sure – in the country.

And let them deliver them. By hand. On foot.

I like the way they are thinking!

More on Yang Liu

The HoS has more details on Yang Liu:

  • donated $5,000 to Cabinet minister Chris Carter’s Te Atatu electorate
  • donated $5,000 to National
  • Had letters of support from Dover Samuels and Pansy Wong. Wong says she never knew of the issues around his past, while Samuels does (but not sure when) and says they are politically motivated from China
  • His citizenship application took three years to approve as officials were against it, but SHane Jones granted it, over-riding his officials
  • Liu was wanted in China for alleged embezzlement
  • Charged in Australia with operating bank accounts under a false name and in November 2006, the Supreme Court of New South Wales ordered Liu to forfeit more than $3.3 million

Liu’s restaurant has hosted fundraisers for Asian candidates from Labour, National and ACT. It seems clear that he built up connections across the political spectrum. The two key issues are:

  1. Did any MP write a letter of support knowing about the false passports, the court orders in Australia?
  2. Why did Shane Jones grant him citizenship?

After smacking, tuckshops and showers, now it is your number of kids

The Greens, proud champions of regulations for showers, have their brightest and boldest policy – a zero population policy.

In fact it is even worse than that – they want negative population growth so NZ can have room for Pacific Island climate change refugees.

Rodney Hide has the best comment:

Act leader Rodney Hide said it was a first step toward zero-population growth. He suggested that perhaps if parents planted a field of trees, they might be able to have twins.

Yes, you will have to build up enough carbon credits in order to get permission to have a child.

And Tariana:

Maori Party co-leader Tariana Turia said it was a case of “middle-class” Greens trying to tell others how big their families should be.

“Tell them to go to China where there is a One Child policy. But don’t start trying to control fertility and social engineering like that here.”

The defence:

Greens population spokeswoman Metiria Turei yesterday denied it was an attempt to discourage people from having large families. She said awareness of the impact their families had on resources and the environment would allow parents to make an “informed decision” about their family size.

For fuck’s sake. Having kids is the biggest decisions parents make anyway. Having Metira tell families they need to make an “informed” decision is as offensive as laughable. What she means is she wants people to feel guilty if they have kids as kids use up scarce resources.

There is a problem with over population globally, but for most of Europe the problem is under population – not enough children are being born to replace those dying.

The replacement fertility rate is 2.1 children per woman. Current fertility rates according to the UN are:

  • Greece 1.33
  • Russia 1.34
  • Germany 1.36
  • Italy 1.38
  • Canada 1.53
  • Australia 1.79
  • UK 1.82
  • France 1.89
  • NZ 1.99
  • US 2.05

So NZ already has a declining population growth from fertility, being under the replacement rate of 2.10. And we are at the top end of European countries. So where is the global population growth happening:

  • Niger 7.19
  • Palestine 5.09
  • Tonga 3.83
  • Pakistan 3.52
  • Saudia Arabia 3.35
  • India 2.81
  • Libya 2.72

So let’s make sure we have this right. NZ already has a shrinking population from fertility. But in order to allow India, Libya, Saudia Arabia, Pakistan and the Niger to carry on with their over-populating, NZ families should have less children.

The Greens policy even includes:

Facilitate the development of regional population plans, in partnership with local tangata whenua.

So what the fuck will a regional population plan be?

They also advocate:

Support initiatives to raise awareness amongst parents and potential parents regarding the issue of sustainable global population levels.

What this means is taxpayer funded bureaucrats working on pamphlets and seminars to frighten parents off having more kids. Can you imagine every school in NZ having some dour faced do gooder preaching to all the kids they they should not have children, in order to save the planet.

How about a nice pamphlet “About your foetus and save the planet today” – have that in every doctor’s surgery.

The Greens are saying of course it will be up to each family to decide for themselves how many children they have – but nevertheless they want to run education programmes and awareness initiatives to help those parents make the right decisions.

New Labour billboard

Labour’s official billboard.

Labour’s new billboard done by Whale and myself to reflect the citizenship scandal 🙂

Is there anything not for sale by Labour? Taito Field was allegedly selling off immigration permits in exchange for free work on houses, and now we have allegedly privileged treatment given to an applicant for citizenship who was a Labour party donor.

Armstrong on Labour’s spending

Thank God some media are focusing on the substance of policies and spending promises, rather than merely the style of symbolism.

John Armstrong does a first class analysis:

Increasingly, the story of the 2008 election is a tale of two election campaigns.

The first campaign has everyone pretending nothing has changed and it is business as usual. The other campaign accepts everything has changed in the wake of the global financial crisis.

Stuck fast in the first campaign are most of Parliament’s minor parties. They are becoming increasingly irrelevant to the main action. They are in denial that the party is over.

They continue to promise to spend money on this or that. But they are not going to be able to extract the requisite cash from the two big parties in post-election talks. There simply is not going to be any money spare.

ACT is probably the only minor party happy about this – they want to cut spending. With a decade of deficits there is not enough money for the major parties spending priorities, let alone the minor parties.

The minor parties have not adjusted to that reality. As a result they are finding themselves ignored.

The minors should concentrate on policies that go beyond spending. I know this will be very hard for the Greens, but money does not grow on trees – not even carbon credit generating trees.

It is a different story for the major parties. National accepts the party’s over. Labour knows the party’s over. But it is hoping some voters haven’t noticed.

In the pretend campaign, Labour continues to spend money it does not really have, this week targeting students, their parents, beneficiaries in part-time work and the elderly.

There is no way Labour can deliver on their promises, unless they hike taxes which in a recession is suicidal. Labour knows a fourth term would be their final term anyway, so they don’t care about broken promises, so long as they get that magical fourth term.

The spending was clearly planned before international financial markets went into free-fall and the Treasury produced far gloomier forecasts of the state of the Government accounts.

Despite Budget surpluses turning into ongoing deficits, Labour continues to roll out new spending, using the fig-leaf of a three-to-four year phase-in period for new policies to try to hide its embarrassment from those questioning how this squares with the party’s claim to be fiscally responsible.

And remember PREFU was done before the latest developments in the credit crisis with global credit drying up.

National is justifiably arguing that Labour is asking voters to write it a blank cheque. Without figures or forecasts, voters are flying blind.

Labour is behind in this election, however. It has to go for broke.

National is being far more cautious because it is the one looking more likely to have to clean up the mess. Its stimulus is principally $1.4 billion-worth of tax cuts which it would bring forward to next April, when it believes the economy will most need it.

National is being transparent about how big its stimulus will be. Labour isn’t. Only a week or two ago Labour accused National of being fiscally reckless with its tax cuts. National can now fire that charge straight back.

Labour is going for broke – but it is the country that will be broke. Ten years of deficits is close to the deficit being structural. Add on an extended recession and Labour’s billions of extra spending and you mey get that structural deficit we had in the 70s and 80s – endless borrowing and debt – wiping out the gains of the last two decades.

Helen ahead in one set of polls

The Herald has been running a series of online polls on the party leaders. All unscientific but some fun.

  1. Herald character poll: Which of these politicians would you rather be stranded on a desert island with? – Key 40%, Hide 17%, Clark 15%, Fitzsimons 12%
  2. Herald character poll: Which of these politicians would be most likely to help an old lady across the road? – Key 33%, Hide 17%, Fitzsimons 12%, Clark 12%
  3. Herald Character Poll: Who would be the best standup comedian? – Hide 45%, Peters 39%
  4. Herald Character Poll: Who would you rather have administer first aid to you? – Key 42%, Fitzsimons 24%, Clark 16%
  5. Who do you think won the leaders’ debate tonight? – Key 73%, Clark 27%
  6. Which of these politicians would be most comfortable on a marae? – Turia 73%, Key 11%,
  7. Do you think John Key had a tantrum during Tuesday’s debate, as alleged by Helen Clark? – No 80%, Yes 20%
  8. Herald Character Poll: Which politician would be most likely to shout at home? – Clark 42%, Peters 27%, Key 11%,
  9. Herald Character Poll: Which politician would be most likely to call noise control if you were having a party? – Clark 36%, Fitzsimons 16%, Dunne 13%,

So Helen won the poll for most likely to shout at home and to call noise control on a party 🙂

Counting up Labour’s borrow and spend

The PREFU shows us Labour is leaving us with a decade of deficits. But despite forecasts showing the Government will need to borrow money fpor the next 12 years or so, they have gone on making huge spending promises.

The Herald has counted up the numbers and finds that Labour is planning to spend a net $3.65 billion more. Now this is simply not possible. They will have to increase taxes to do this, or break their promises.

More Dim-Post

The Dim-Post has an excellent write-up of the Aro Valley meeting. Some extracts:

Radio New Zealand announcer Bryan Crump has taken the evening off work to act as moderator – he warns the crowd that while heckling is encouraged he will not tolerate any ‘Hooton’s’.

Heh he has become a word.

For ACT Heather Roy who demands to know if there are any undecided voters in the audience. One woman puts her hand up. Roy exceeds the two minute time limit and is the first candidate to get drenched – but certainly not the last – while the gleeful crowd chants ‘zero tolerance’. Crump assures her that the water-pistol is ’scented with rose-water’. ‘It bloody is not,’ Roy replies.

Classic.

For RAM (Resident Action Movement) Grant Brooks. It is hard to hear Brooks over the members of the audience shouting ‘Baaaaaaa’. He announces that RAM is a serious player in the upcoming election and the rest of his address is drowned out by laughter.

This is what I like abotu the meeting – they heckle regardless of political leanings.

For the Kiwi Party Rebekah Clement, a young and attractive candidate and the crowd is intrigued when Bryan Crump announces that he has watched her ‘nice thing on YouTube’.
Clement: The Kiwi Party is a new Party . . .
Heckler: It might not fly!
Clement: And I want to be part of it because a lot of young people feel that they can’t make a difference in politics . . .
Heckler: You can’t!

Heh.

The two ‘major party’ candidates were asked about the Treaty of Waitangi. Stephen Franks gave the most considered reply of the night and actually addressed the question. Franks tended to over-complicate his replies and it was often hard to figure out what he was trying to say. His Obama-like emphasis on nuance might make him a good MP but it is not an effective strategy when you have two minutes to explain something to 300 jeering hippies with a water-pistol trained on the back of your head.

A good point!

In another post Danyl also comments on debates:

Neither Clark nor Key made McCain’s mistake – the person who came closest was Clark with her absurd and offensive comment about Key being used to shouting people down at home. Both candidates ran very defensive strategies in which they positioned themselves to look calm, strong and leaderlike; Key effortlessly exceeded the expectations set for him. Clark didn’t hurt herself in the debate but she didn’t help herself much either, and she did damage her image with her foolish (but totally characteristic) attacks on John Key and Mark Sainsbury the next day.

Clark and her supporters seem to genuinely believe in their cartoon depiction of John Key as some sort of malign, demonic super-rich psychopath, just as the US Republican Party imagines Barack Obama as being a deranged radical Islamic terrorist. But when people encounter Obama on TV they see a calm, articulate, slightly pompous and sometimes tedious former law professor; when we see Key we see a genial, occasionaly bewildered and safely anodyne Kiwi boy made good. Their political enemies are trying to sell us something we simply cannot believe in.

A very astute observation, in my opinion.

Dom Post on Clark

The Dom Post Editorial observes:

It started with a Labour ambush in Auckland and continued with a robust but dignified television debate. Well, nearly – Helen Clark did feel compelled to tell John Key “you might be able to shout people down at home, but you can’t shout me down”. Clearly, Miss Clark was finding Mr Key a somewhat tougher opponent than his predecessor, Don Brash, who famously and, as it turned out, foolishly, held back from talking over Miss Clark in the 2005 debates because that was the gentlemanly thing to do.

And here is what is interesting. TGIF did an analysis of the debate. They found Helen Clark had 16 successful interjections against John Key and Key had only 13 in return. Also Clark spoke for a minute 30 longer over all. Most ineteresting was that the moderator and jorunalists asked three times as many “challenging” questions to Key or tried to cut him off as they did Clark.

So Clark just could not handle the fact someone was standing up to her.

But it didn’t really descend into a catfight till the prime minister discovered the political commentariat did not share her view that she had wiped the floor with her less-experienced opponent. Miss Clark, brimming with the ego and self-esteem that fuel the best of politicians, is convinced her problem was not that Mr Key had done well.

Yes we really saw the nasty side come out. And we see her inability to concede weakness again today in response to the poll results:

Miss Clark made it clear she did not believe the result.

“That doesn’t reflect the trend in other recent polls,” she said.

Interestingly it is an almost identical result to the poll immediately before it.

But more to the point look at the response from the two Leaders when they get a bad poll result. John Key got last week a poll result showing the lead had fallen to 3%. He did not attack the polling company, insist it must be wrong. He merely said that he had always said the polls would move around a lot during the campaign. While Clark constantly attacks any result she does not like.

And meanwhile Clark has gone from offering “professional commentary” on the election debate to professional commentary on John Key’s campaign. If only she would answer questions on where the money is coming from for all these promises she is making.

Citizenship Scandal?

Just listened to Ian Wishart on Newstalk ZB with Larry Williams. The story seems to be:

  1. A Chinese gentleman has had problems with Australian immigration as he travels under different names, different passports with different dates of births.
  2. This was known to NZ authorities
  3. He applied to be a NZ Citizen
  4. DIA recommended he be turned down due to the multiple aliases
  5. The Minister approved it, despite the dodgy aliases and the recommendation
  6. The gentleman’s application was supported by a Labour MP and is known to a couple of Ministers
  7. He attended a fundraising function for Labour and probably donated to them, but impossible to know for sure as they do not record who donated what – people just throw cash into a hat or something.

This is all off listening to Ian on the radio.

The big donors this year

The Electoral Commission has updated its register of big donors – those who have given over $20,000 in the last 12 months. The donors in size are:

  1. ACT – Alan Gibbs – $100,000
  2. ACT – John Boscawen – $100,000
  3. Greens – Stuart Bramhall – $57,276
  4. Greens – Christopher Marshall – $44,571
  5. Greens – Jeanette Fitzsimons – $34,611
  6. National – John Key – $30,000
  7. National – Road Transport Trust – $30,000
  8. Greens – Sue Kedgley – $21,792
  9. Greens – Bryan Forde – $24,750

Interesting that along with ACT, the Greens are the party of big money – not just small $50 donations. That is $180,000 they have had in from just five donors. They are fortunate to have such wealthy party members.

Last chance to register

Tomorrow is the final day people can register to be third parties. From tomorrow it will be too late, and if an issue arises that you want to spend money on advocating for or against, you will be restricted to just $12,000.

Take an example. Think if the Government announced this Monday rather than last Monday their $150 billion bank deposit guarantee. And think if you were in an affected sector and thought the scheme announced would be a disaster because (for example) it includes finance companies. The cost of getting it wrong could be billions. But you would be restricted to spending $12,000 advocating against a $150 billion bank deposit guarantee scheme unless you managed to do it without criticising the parties advocating it in a way that could turn voters off them.

Coalition Building

The left’s plan to win despite getting less votes

Laila Harre details how the left plans to win the election, even if they get less party votes.

Union secretary Laila Harre told delegates the Greens and the Maori Party had been “our strongest backers” on key issues such as ending lower pay for young people and keeping shops closed at Easter, with Labour “a very close second” on both issues.

In a closed session with the MPs afterwards, she said the only way to prevent a National-led Government, based on an average of recent polls, was for the Maori Party to win all seven Maori seats, creating an “overhang” above the 120 MPs elected through proportional representation.

But it would then be critical for the Maori Party to use its seats to keep Labour in power.

Under FPP Governments sometimes got formed that had less popular vote than the Opposition. But FPP was not a proportional voting system. It was not meant to reflect a national vote – it was a series of local contests.

MMP is very different. It would be outraegous for a Government to be formed that got less party votes than the Opposition as its main virture is proportionality. I’m not talking just the two big parties here, but the combined vote.

Take this election result based just on party vote:

  • National/ACT/United Future 51% – 62 seats
  • Labour/NZF/Prog/Greens/ – 47% – 56 seats
  • Maori Party 2% – 2 seats

There are 120 seats normally so National/ACT/United would form a Government having got 51% of the vote and 62/120.

But Laila Harre’s plan for the left is for the Maori Party to win all seven seats, despite a party vote that entitles them to just two seats, creating an overhang of five seats. Then you have:

  • National/ACT/United Future 51% – 62 seats
  • Labour/NZF/Prog/Greens/ – 47% – 56 seats
  • Maori Party 2% – 7 seats

Now the Maori Party would have two choices here. Support the parties that got 51% of the vote or go with Labour (as Laila wants) so that they get 63/125 seats despite getting 2% less votes than the Opposition.

This would give Labour a fourth term. It would also spark such a backlash that I suspect both MMP and the Maori seats would disappear within a decade.