Top Debater

Congratulations to Jennifer (Jen) Savage from Wanganui Collegiate who won best overall speaker at the NZ Secondary Schools World Debating Champs.

Fellow New Zealanders Ben Kornfeld was 2nd and Holly Jenkins 4th.

As reported yesterday the team got all the way to the grand final and lost with the closest possible margin of 4-5.  The team captain is Maria English, and Stephen Franks points out (Stephen is on the board of Samuel Marsden – Maria’s school) that Maria has also a member of the N.Z. Secondary Schools Choir and was the winner of the 2008 Rodney Walshe Essay Competiton – the Ireland essay competition.

Bizarre attack from Cullen

Colin Espiner writes in The Press:

In an early sign the campaign could focus on personal attacks, Cullen lost no time in attacking Key, appearing to blame him for the worldwide collapse of his former bank, Merrill Lynch.

“Given his background and the fact that Merrill Lynch has just gone belly up, I would have thought New Zealanders should draw the conclusion that you wouldn’t put a man like that in charge of the New Zealand economy,” Cullen said.

My God that’s so lame. Where do you start.

  1. Umm Michael, John Key stopped working there around eight years ago.
  2. The recent losses are from bad investments primarily mortgages, and John was in charge of currency trading
  3. When John was there, his section of the business was highly profitable – that is why he made so much money. It is called being successful.
  4. Merrill Lynch has written down around $50 billion of investments. However they have not gone belly up – they have been purchased by the Bank of America for US$44 billion – a sum a bit larger than the turnover of the NZ Government.

It really is sad that all Labour has is personal attacks.

Peters safe

Helen Clark has made clear she will not be sacking Winston Peters, and in fact will keep him on after the election. The Dom Post reports:

Prime Minister Helen Clark further distanced herself from Mr Peters yesterday, but set a high hurdle for sacking him by saying it would take a “devastating development” at today’s privileges committee hearing for her to act.

Now this is a bizarre hurdle as the only person appearing today is Brian Henry, who will presumably come up with the fifth or sixth version of events about how Winston knew nothing. Only if a witness hostile to Peters was testifying could there be any chance of a devastating development.

The reality is the phone call and e-mail prove beyond reasonable doubt that Peters knew of the donation, and that he was the one referred to by Henry as “my client” as the times match.

Helen Clark has shown herself willing to condone Ministers who lie not once, not twice, but repeatedly to the public. And then she declares the election is about trust!!

Trust

Natalia Banks

A nice story in yesterday’s SST about Natalia Banks. Natalia is the adopted daughter of John and Amanda Banks and has just started work as a nurse in Auckland City Hospital’s emergency department.

Most will have heard the story of how they adopted Natalia. The short version is they agreed to adopt her, and then just as they were about to go, realised she had two brothers. Rather than split up the family they adopted all three of them!

I remember when he adopted them. It makes me feel very old now that Natalia is 21!

I did like this line from Banskie:

He takes the credit for encouraging her to become a nurse rather than a lawyer. “We saw she was very caring, compassionate and kind and I don’t know too many lawyers who are caring, compassionate and kind.”

Heh.

Want to help out?

Another little request for someone with some time.

My candidates page has been very popular, especially as some parties have not listed candidates on their main sites. But at present it only includes the two major parties plus room for one third party candidate if they look like they could win the seat.

If anyone has a few hours spare, it would be really useful to collate up into an excel spreadsheet the names of the candidates in all 70 electorates for the following parties:

  1. National
  2. Labour
  3. Maori
  4. ACT
  5. NZ First
  6. United Future
  7. Progressive
  8. Kiwi
  9. Family
  10. Pacific

Also would be useful to have the ranked lists for each party. I have some of them in HTML on the existing page but if someone collates them into Excel, then I can publish them side by side.

If you”d be keen to do this, drop me an e-mail and I’ll send you the template.

Cellphone towers

MacDoctor blogs on cellphone towers and NIMBYs. He comments on a Vicky Webb who is terrified by a cellphone tower 45 metres away from her as she is so scared of RF radiation she does not have a microwave:

Ms. Webb you can relax. At 45m, the cell tower is producing less EM radiation than the signals from the TV and radio stations that are currently sleeting through your house. This poor woman is having a complete melt-down here because of the insane amount of complete disinformation circulating about cell phone towers, mostly on the internet. Disturbingly, I note that some MPs seem to be buying into the myth. This is not at all helpful.

That is a Green MP he links to. The anti-science party. He then fisks further:

Quote: Ms Grey, a Nelson environmental lawyer and scientist, said companies could put up towers as long as they were within New Zealand electromagnetic exposure limits. She questioned the standards, saying Austria’s, Russia’s and China’s were more than 100 times stricter.

Macdoctor: Note the world leaders in EM reduction here – Austria, Russia and China? Perhaps Austria doesn’t like the towers because they are ugly – this is it’s way of getting them to be smaller. Russia and China probably don’t like them because they don’t like cell phones. At any rate, Ms Grey is not telling us that everybody, except Austria, Russia and China, follows the accepted international guideline of 0.08 watts/kg, which is 50 times lower than the lowest level that could conceivably have any effect. She then uses this dumb observation to plug for stupid legislation:

It is a pity we only get this information in a blog, not in the main article.

Quote: She said the proposed National Environment Standards for Telecommunication should be amended so all cellphone towers and phone masts within 500m of any house, school, preschool or hospital were designated as non-complying and communities would have to be notified before they went up.

Macdoctor: This means there would have to be a full resource consent process for virtually every cell-phone tower. Say goodbye to cheap cell-phone coverage. Say goodbye to improvements in coverage in marginal areas. Say goodbye to competition for cell phone use. And all for a spurious piece of junk science.

The Greens say listen to the scientists when it comes to climate change, but the rest of the time they seem to scaremonger against science – anti GE, anti cellphone towers etc etc.

Not a headline you want to make a typo on

Hooton’s beliefs

Matthew Hooton did a good post on Friday about his political perspective and beliefs. The full post is worth a read as he includes a recent speech he did. He comments that sometimes the different political tribes can never understand each other, quoting something Chris Trotter said:

“There live among us a reckless and very dangerous minority who use their triennial vote not as a tool – with which to construct a better future – but as a weapon. For these sociopathic individuals, the ballot is valuable only for the pain and suffering it is able to inflict upon the individuals and groups they despise. They seek to punish these people, by facilitating the election of political parties whose policies are most likely to fulfill their twisted fantasies of violence and revenge.”

Like Matthew I doubt such people really exist in politics – these sociopathic individuals with twisted fantasies of violence and revenge. But Chris Trotter semes to genuinely believe they do. Presumably so do some others in the “left tribe”. How very sad for them.

A big cheer for the media

Winston did a speech on Friday, where he attached the media endlessly. This is a deliberate tactic to try and go up in the polls as journalists are not much more popular than politicians. Winston’s entire career has been built on attacking unpopular groups.

Now I have been known to criticise the media from time to time myself.  And when it is justified I’ll keep doing that. But for today I want us to reflect on the debt of gratitude we owe the media for letting the public learn the truth. Without the media, we would probably never know:

  • That the Vela Family have donated $230,000 to NZ First
  • That Owen Glenn donated $100,000 to cover Winston Peters legal costs
  • That the Spencer Trust even existed
  • That Winston’s parliamentary staff solicit money for him/NZ First
  • That Owen Glenn says Winston solicited the $100,000 from him and asked for it to be kept confidential
  • That NZ First has filed false donation returns to the Electoral Commission
  • That NZ First has received many donations from big business, contrary to their claims
  • That NZ First uses a trust to hide the identity of donors – a practice it criticises other parties for doing

Winston said in his speech:

Except in rare and exceptional circumstances, or a ratings war, there is one group who will not be the subject of a concerted campaign of vilification and disparagement by the media.

That group is the media itself.

They are like a school of piranhas circling society, seeking to slash, tear, maim and destroy anything that shows any signs of weakness, non-conformity or heaven forbid – criticises the media.

This is all a cover. What Winston is really angry about is the fact the the public now know the truth about how NZ First is funded. Without the media Owen Glenn’s donation would never have been made public. Without the media, NZ First would still be filing false donation returns to the Electoral Commission. We owe the media thanks for being willing to endure abuse and threats from Peters, so the truth will emerge.

Pipped at the post

I demand a recount!

The NZ Secondary Schools Debating Team did amazingly to win 11 games in a row to get through to the Grand Final of the World Champs.

They went up against England, proposing the motion:

This House would expand the permanent membership of the UN Security Council

And they lost 4-5. Most decisions are unanimous, so to have four Judges say your team was best and five Judges give it to England is literally as close a call as you can get.

Any congratulations again to the team for a superb set of results. To represent your country while at school is a huge achievement in itself, let alone to make the world champs grand final.

On the Conditions and Possibilities of Helen Clark Taking Me as Her Young Lover

The play “On the Conditions and Possibilities of Helen Clark Taking Me as Her Young Lover” has returned to Downstage, as people may see from the advertisement on the right.

When I first heard about this play, I thought I would rather play lawn bowls than go see it. But then just as the season in Wellington was ending, I started to hear good things about it. Then I read Che Tibby’s review and rang up to try and get tickets on the final night. They were all sold out. Che said:

The play is extremely well-written, extremely well-acted, and contains more gems, illuminations, satire and outright slap-your-knees-you’re-laughing-so-hard moments that you’ll feel rewarded just for turning up. Unless you work in Parliament, in which case you’ll want to perhaps wear a disguise, so as not to be seen laughing at what is a very heavy satire of the Labour Party and incumbent government.

The political jokes run thick and fast in this lecture, along with a number of outright lewd references to many people who are not Helen Clark (they don’t actually cross that line). There are even some fantastically arcane political science jokes in there, which only me and the two people sitting next to me (whom I did not know!) got.

So, there’s something in there for everyone. It’s extremely not-PC, it’s fast moving, and it’s actually funny.

I was pissed off I missed seeing it. But then it opened in Auckland. So I extended one of my trips to Auckland to stay on for it. And it was fucking hilarious. Don’t be mistaken by the title into thinking you will not enjoy this is you are right of centre. There were National MPs in the audience laughing as hard as anyone.

The star is commanding as he takes the audience through his powerpoint presentation on why Helen Clark should take him as her young lover. He comes across as so earnest and sincere (the scary thing is he may be just that) about the proposition that it is just hilarious. I liked the play so much I got a copy of the book and got him to autograph it.

Downstage have asked me to include this letter from Richard Meros below, which I’m delighted to do so. If I have the time I’m going to go again, and I really do recommend it to anyone who has a robust sense of humour. You will not stop laughing. Remember it is on this week only until 20 Septmber 2008.

Kia Ora Tatou, I’m Richard Meros and I have a Dream.

Our proud nation has laboured too long under a barely discernible pendulum wobble from Labour to National, National to Labour, so on ad nauseum. Yet we yearn for, and deserve, something greater. Through meticulous research I have drawn an inescapable conclusion: that only my personal engagement with the electoral process – and with our noble Prime Minister – can herald the glorious future of our South Pacific Utopia.

My acclaimed pamphlet of romantic political philosophy, On the Conditions and Possibilities of Helen Clark Taking Me as Her Young Lover, provoked howls of acclaim when published in 2007, and I have committed to share the “powerpoint” version of my book the length and breadth of New Zealand before Election Night 2008. Why? Because I care.

This life-changing lecture has toured across Aotearoa; enlightenment comes now to Wellington.

I encourage you, your friends, hapu, colleagues, book-groups, iwi and families to attend my presentation at Wellington’s Downstage Theatre (from 12-20 September) where my vision for a New New Zealand under a New Helen Clark, Warrior Princess, will be presented using the latest exciting digital communication technologies.

The engagement is strictly limited to 10 lectures only, and to encourage your passionate participation in the democratic process I am offering a complimentary bottle of Montana Brut Cuvée, (whimsically liberated from a recent National Party Conference) to every party of six or more who books.

Every vote counts.

Richard Meros

As an added bonus, I will be launching my newest book, “Beggars and Choosers: The Complete Written Correspondence Between Richard Meros and Creative New Zealand Volume One” after the first lecture on Friday night.

Book online now at www.downstage.co.nz (or telephone 801 6946). Our operators are standing by.

An executive Mayor for Auckland?

The Herald reports:

There is a strong case in Auckland for the political model that produced Boris Johnson, and before that Ken Livingstone, as Mayor of London, says a leading expert on local governance.

And to be effective, a directly elected Auckland mayor should have executive powers, possibly a four-year term and be supported by a cabinet, said Robin Hambleton, professor of city leadership at the University of West of England in Bristol.

I am quite attracted to this proposal. It does work well in London, and it allows the public to elect someone with the powers to make change or implement a manifesto, and likewise gives the public the power to sack someone and change course. The Mayor is held accountable by the Assembly

The full paper by Professor Hambleton is here. It’s an interesting read and only 38 pages.

Enrol enrol enrol

The election is nearing

You really know the election is close when Labour sends Goff in to start talking about banning gangs.

If they were serious about this they would have asked for reports and studies from Departments about how to do it, what are the issues involved. But instead we are told:

Mr Goff told the Herald he was personally evaluating the ban, and if it worked, “then I’m 100 per cent in favour of it”.

Okay so the Corrections (not Justice) Minister is personally evaluating the South Australia ban. That tells you everything we need to know about how totally unserious they are about it. Just a soundbite.

The Herald points out:

Changing their tune:

“To say that if we outlaw [gangs] by law, that will happen, is, I think, dreaming.”
– Police Minister Annette King, March 16, 2006

“If it works, then I’m 100 per cent in favour of it.”
– Corrections Minister Phil Goff, yesterday

Let us see if it will be in Labour’s law and order policy.

Newspaper websites

Once upon a time both the NZ Herald and the Stuff websites would be all updated at or shortly after 5 am each day. But something seems to have happened to both recently.

If one goes to the NZ Herald Opinion section, there is nothing since Saturday. None of the HoS columns are listed there, let alone today’s columns and editorial.

And the Dominion Post editorials are no better. Friday’s editorial is the last one listed. And in their main Opinion section, the most recental editorial is six days old.

The ODT however has today’s editorial online. Go ODT.

Dim-Post on United Future

The Dim-Posy has done a party profile of United Future. Hopefully this will be of a series, and Danyl will cover all eight parliamentary parties plus the Family, Kiwi and Taito parties.

Some extracts from his excellent profile:

Founded In: 2000 AD as the scriptures foretold

Policy Achievements: Creation of Families Commission, nationwide marketing campaign for Families Commission, improved car-parking and creche facilities for Families Commission Staff. Proven history of improving business card design for Families Commission management.

Party Leader: Hon. Peter Patrick Caiaphas Dunne

Early Life: Born and raised in Pohatu Marine Reserve, attended Canturbury and Massey University, was voted audience favourite at Napier Marineland 1974-77.

Strengths: Can kill a grown man with a single stroke of his mighty flippers.

Weaknesses: Can easily become entangled in discarded plastics.

Campaign Strategy: Speak on behalf of the great silent majority of New Zealanders who have never heard of him and will vote for somebody else.

Very good. I can’t wait to see National’s.

Fiji Government wins complaint against Radio NZ

The Fijian Government complained about an interview with Michael Field on Nine to Noon on 7 March 2008. Radio NZ rejected the complaint so they went to the BSA. And they won.

They’ve sent me a copy of the decision: bsa-decision-28-8-08 (large pdf) that upholds four complaints of inaccuracy.

Now I have been a pretty strong critic of the Commodore and his Government myself. But there is no reason to make things sound worse than they really are there. The four items the BSA upheld were:

  1. Radio NZ were wrong to state the management of Fiji Broadcasting was military appointed (the Board is unchanged from before the coup)
  2. Radio NZ were wrong to broadcast that a journalist had been given just 8 days notice to leave Fiji when it was 21 days
  3. Radio NZ was wrong to state a Judge who got mugged had publicly criticised a report which upheld the legality of the coup. There was no evidence the Judge had done this, yet alone if it was linked
  4. Radio NZ were wrong to state the Judge’s house was burnt down, when it was not

Radio NZ do not have to broadcast a correction. The publication of the finding is meant to be “punishment” enough. The BSA hasn’t actually got around to putting it up on their website yet despite the decision being made on 28 August 2008.

Go NZ Go

The New Zealand Secondary Schools Debating Team (supported by Russell McVeagh) have just won the world champs semi-final against Scotland and are through to the final.

This is the first time since 1995, NZ has made it through to the grand final. 39 teams have been competing from all over the world.

The team is:

  1. Maria English (Captain, Samuel Marsden)
  2. Holly Jenkins (Sacred Heart)
  3. Jennifer Savage (Wanganui Collegiate)
  4. Tom Chen (Hillcrest High)
  5. Ben Kornfield (King’s College)

Their topics to date have been:

  1. This house supports military intervention to deliver emergency aid in humanitarian crises’ – beat Greece 2-1 opposing
  2. This House would ban strikes by workers in essential state services – beat Estonia 3-0 proposing
  3. This house would ban the use of unethically obtained data in scientific research – beat Bangladesh 3-0 proposing
  4. This House would make humanities subjects compulsory at undergraduate level – beat Japan 3-0 opposing
  5. This house would make the directors of multinational companies personally liable for environmental abuses committed by their companies in the developing world – beat Scotland 3-0
  6. A debates I don’t know topic for won 3-0 against Singapore
  7. This house believes that governments have a duty to bail out failing financial institutions – beat Slovakia 3-0
  8. A debates I don’t know topic for won 3-0 against Indonesia
  9. This House believes that heads of government should be required to have a parliamentary majority to govern – – beat Netherlands 5-0 (octo-final)
  10. This House regrets the holding of the 2008 Beijing Olympics – beat Ireland 4-1 (quarter-final)
  11. This house would drop all US sanctions on Cuba – beat Scotland 7-0 proposing (semi-final)
    The final motion is:

This House would expand the permanent membership of the UN Security Council

NZ goes up agains England in the final. It is being held at the Reagan Centre in Washington DC and will commence at 6.30 am NZST on Monday.

Winning 11 debates in a row is an incredible result. Best of luck to all of the team and support crew for the final.

Clark starts nasty

It’s good having Hooton blogging, because he often covers something before I do, so I can be lazy and quote him:

Tonight’s TVNZ and TV3 news coverage of the first day of campaigning was a clear win for John Key, with the networks showing the National leader attempting to cross the traditional political divide (which positions him as a unifier) by going to the Otara market, in contrast to their coverage of Helen Clark’s efforts to smear him and play class war (positioning her as a hater and wrecker).  TVNZ highlighted Clark’s claim that Key’s day campaigning in South Auckland was “a tribute to his power of self-delusion” while TV3’s preferred quote from her was “I suspect he was a bit like a tourist there. He should have stuck to what he really believes and gone to the Northern Club.”  What a nasty piece of work she came across as.  This is not the way to win an election.

A nasty piece of work indeed. Imagine a National Prime Minister telling a Labour Opposition Leader to fuck off out of Remuera because he/she doesn’t fit in, and should stick to Cannons Creek or something. Cheap, and nasty indeed.

But as Matthew points out, we are usefully being tutored on the difference between negative and dirty:

Already, of course, the Prime Minister’s Office is saying that what Clark did today was “negative” but not “dirty”.  A nice attempt to try to spin the situation – but still, after one day, I would say it is Key 1 Clark 0.

The part I found most amusing from the linked post is this part:

While we’re on the topic, when Helen Clark said ‘hard hats on’ to Labour supporters, contrary to what the commentariat seem to think,  that did not mean ’get ready for a dirty campaign’. It meant ‘get ready to work hard’.

How incredible. They know what the Prime Minister meant by her comments. Is this mind reading at work?

Now it gets really dirty

Prog Blog is an unofficial blog on behalf of Jim Anderton’s Progressives.

Last week they did a blog post about a quote from John Key saying “Young people are a group I’m passionate about”.

They commented beneath that

“So is Gary Glitter”

The post has now been deleted but it is still in Google Cache.

Someone e-mailed me this a few days ago but I only noticed the e-mail today. Some other blogs highlighted this earlier.

Hmmn, and even though the page has been deleted, it still shows up on their main site.

I think media should be asking the Hon Jim Anderton who writes Prog Blog for them, and does he condone comparing John Key to paedophile? Will someone offer an apology at the very least?

People said this would be a very dirty campaign, but not even I thought it would be that dirty.

NCEA Maths

You know you have a problem when even the PPTA is claiming NCEA is too easy when it comes to core numeracy and literacy. Here are some sample questions:

1. 5 boys share a bag of 55 lollies. How many lollies does each boy get?

2. There were 60 cows inside a shed. 18 walked outside. How many cows were left inside the shed?

3. 38 x 6 = ?

4. David has 35 stamps. Bruce has 70 stamps. How many stamps do they have altogether?

For these ones they could use calculators:

5. Write these percentages as decimals: 34% 52% 8%

6. Write these decimals as fractions: 0.5 0.03 0.95

7. Betty got 13 of the 20 questions correct in a biology test. What percentage did Betty get?

8. Gary ate 25% of a cake. What fraction of the cake did he eat?

The PPTA says that students three years younger than year ten could pass this test. I can only agree with them. There is nothing even remotely challening. It is very basic addition, subtraction and fraction conversion. Hell I could do that at around eight years old.

Coddington attacks Hide

Wow. I guess it is no surprise,but Deborah Coddington seems to really not like Rodney Hide, as the fomer Caucus colleague lets rip:

This week was very exciting for me because on Tuesday, after 12 months of abstinence, we finally got a television, just in time to watch the news with Glenn’s appearance before the committee in Wellington.

It’s a fabulous telly – big, flat screen and beautifully crisp, coloured pictures – but with such precision also comes shock.

The first thing we saw was Rodney Hide, just behind Owen Glenn, nodding, frowning, or shaking his head at committee members.

“Can we send the telly back now?” I asked my husband.

“I’ve suddenly remembered why I didn’t like watching.”

So the dislike is so strong, she hates even seeing him on TV?

I mean, it’s bad enough waking to Morning Report’s obsession with Hide’s Joe McCarthy-like allegations, but at least you can’t see him.

Then she compares him to Senator McCarthy. Never mind that if it were not for Winston’s complaint we would have never learnt from Owen Glenn that Winston solicted the $100,000 himself.

One year without television and suddenly he looks, to me, remarkably like Lockwood Smith. Do they share a personal trainer?

If anyone thinks Deborah is making a compliment, you are mistaken.

A cynic would say Hide snaffled a front-row seat to piggyback Glenn’s television coverage, but that’s unfair. The poor chap’s obviously hard of hearing and vision-impaired, and needs a forward position to understand all the proceedings, in case his pals Geoff, Sean or Duncan call for comment.

But someone could teach him sign language, or make a television series, Signing with the Stars, so poor Rodney needn’t camp outside the committee room for hours to bag the best seat.

I would have thought a former MP would know this. Rodney did not have to queue up at all. All MPs have the right to attend a committee as an observer, and they can just go in, when everyone else was queued up in advance. I know this for I was at the front of the queue and Rodney did not turn up until quite a bit later, and just went in, as did the other MPs.

On Wednesday night, when Winston Peters fronted to try to rebut Glenn’s evidence, there was Hide again, looking a little less chipper, but by this time even my horse felt sorry for him – clearly Hide hadn’t left his seat since Tuesday.

A bit like the urban-mythical one-arm bandit players at SkyCity Casino who don’t leave their stools for a comfort stop, Hide was looking desperate, cold and wasting away.

Umm no. Ask any journalist if Rodney has been looking any of those things. Could not be further from reality.