Back Benches tonight

Tonight on Back Benches our panel is Jeanette Fitzsimons co-leader of the Greens, Peter Dunne United Future leader and Charles Chauvell from Labour.

We’ll be talking about the November 8 election date and what the issues will be, Fonterra and the infant formula scandal in China and whether gangs should be outlawed.

We’ll be Peeping and Peering in Steve Maharey’s office and we have Damian Christie’s News Review.

If you’re in Wellington, come on down to the Backbencher pub between 8 and 8.30pm … we’d love to see you … (the show starts just after 9pm); otherwise tune into TVNZ 7 (on Freeview) or on-line at tvnzondemand.co.nz

The Rule of Law Committee on the Electoral Finance Act

What is the Rule of Law Committee? It is a committee of the NZ Law Society and it’s TOR include:

  • To promote the continued separation of the legislative, executive and judicial functions of government and, in particular, to promote and protect judicial independence;
  • To monitor and respond to rule of law issues arising from proposals, decisions or actions of the New Zealand Government or government agencies;
  • To monitor the mechanisms of government, including constitutional conventions;
  • To maintain a neutral apolitical position;

It is chaired by Austin Forbes QC, a former President of the NZ Law Society.

Another member is Cheryl Gwyn. She is the Deputy Solictor-General for Constitutional Affairs. Incidentially Cheryl has her own Trevor Loudon profile and nothing wrong with that, but it indicates she can’t be written off as a nasty right winger by those who believe in shooting the messenger).

Anyway this Rule of Law Committee has published a summary paper on the Electoral Finance Act. Some useful extracts:

The third party regime, related eligibility and regulated period provisions of the Act together
constitute a clear prima facie breach of the right to freedom of expression under section 14 of
BORA.

No disagreements there.

They then look at justification for any breach:

In the present context, a Court would need to consider whether the regime pursues a sufficiently important social objective to warrant overriding a protected right and, if so, whether the chosen means to that end bear a rational connection and are not disproportionate or excessive.

The onus for meeting those tests lies with the Government. It is a substantial one. The right to political free speech is fundamental to the operation of a representative democracy and intrusions upon that right must be supported by strong and compelling reasons.

However, the Government proffered no evidence to substantiate the need for the legislation at any point during the Act’s passage through its legislative stages. Broad assertions were made about the effect of electoral advertising, but none of the supporting materials that accompanied the Act’s passage (the Explanatory Note and select committee majority report) provided reliable empirical or statistical evidence to back up those assertions.

Nice phrases – the right to political free speech is fundamental to the operation of a representative democracy. And the Government proffered no evidence on the need for the legislation – just broad assertions.

Even assuming a case had been made for legislative intervention, the regime does not appear to
satisfy the proportionality test for establishing a justifiable limit on the right of freedom of
expression. The regulated period seems excessive and disproportionate to the objectives it is
purported to address.

In other words even if (and that is a big if) some sort of law change was needed along these lines, this change was over the top.

Given the issues at stake, it would clearly serve the public interest to have the Act tested in court. Relief might take the form of a declaration of inconsistency, which would not affect the validity or operation of the Act. But a declaration would have immense ‘moral’ force in bringing to the public’s attention the unwarranted intrusion on the right to freedom of political expression. The media and public attention associated with any challenge would be significant.

Now this is a big story. The Right of Law Committee of the Law Society thinks the EFA is so bad, there should be a judicial declaration that it is inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, to draw to the public’s attention how repressive the law is.

The rule of law requires, as a minimum, certain, stable and predictable rules of laws that commend themselves to the sense of fairness of the people. However, the uncertainties that beleaguer the Act are seriously confounding the political process. No one is able to say with confidence whether some forms of political spending constitute election advertising and are subject to the Act’s prescriptive requirements. Given the uncertainties, the rule of law has descended into what an electoral official says is the law (does this or does this not constitute election advertising?). So much, then, for certain, stable and predicable rules of law. The Act is fundamentally flawed and misconceived, and ought to be repealed.

And they call for its total repeal, not just amendment.

A stated objective of the legislation was to encourage participation in the electoral system, but indications are that it is having the reverse effect.

I think the term in vogue is “a chilling effect”

It would be interesting to hear from the Minister of Justice on how this common sense law is deemed by the Rule of Law Committee of the Law Society to be so bad it breaches the Bill of Rights and should be repealed.

Bruce Sheppard on the Civil Service

Shareholder activist Bruce Sheppard blogs on the cviil service:

Until quite recently New Zealand could boast an independent civil service that Ministers respected both as to their independence and the quality of advice. It was also a proud and secure service where independence was respected.

Note the until recently.

Politicians also understood that the permanent staffs of various departments should be politically neutral and they also did not interfere in the process of government as executed by the permanent civil services.

In the last nine years under Labour and Helen Clark that has all changed. Political appointments into the civil services are now common, and some have been well documented, the intimidation of the civil service by Ministers is now also well documented and a culture of fear exists in Helengrad.

People think National invented the term. It was someone in the public service, and that is where it is commonly used.

The interference takes the form of removing people not to the government’s liking, appointing people who are and protecting them against all odds. In short Helen’s approach to protecting the undeserving Winston Peters in her cabinet is replicated in the approach to crown employees.

Sounds like a pattern.

Then there is the political appointment of Claire Curran. Direct ministerial interference in that appointment is alleged. Erin Leigh blew the whistle on this and was pilloried by Trevor Mallard in parliament. So much for the Protected Disclosures Act.

Erin Leigh told the truth. For that she got smeared under parliamentary privilege. The target wasn’t even Leigh, but any other civil servant thinking of speaking out.

Also on tomorrow – discuss the brain drain

Benson-Pope all set

I have now added David Benson-Pope to my list of 2008 election candidates.

Homepaddock blogs on a TV3 story about how Benson-Pope was asking the Dunedin City Council where he can erect billboards.

I expect he will announce his resignation from Labour and candidacy just after the adjournment debate, or maybe even during it!

Winston’s story

Poor old Helen. Just like Chris Trotter, she can’t work out what happened. She needs more time.

As a public service to Helen, and all readers, I am summarising Winston’s position below. Winston keeps insisting that he never had any idea at all of the $100,000 donation until 18 July 2008 when Brian Henry told him. So below are all the elements you have to believe, for Winston to be telling the truth.

  1. Laura Ede is lying when she says Peters called Glenn on 5 December 2005.
  2. Laura Ede is also incompetent as she sent Owen Glenn an e-mail asking him to phone Peters back, when Peters never called.
  3. Brian Henry did call Owen Glenn in late November 2005, and Owen Glenn is lying when he says he never spoke to him.
  4. Brian Henry can not prove this call because he was staying in a motel at the time, and he can not remember which one it was.
  5. Brian Henry as a barrister, does not keep receipts of his expenses, as that would tell him which motel he made this disputed call from, and the bill would have details of the calls made.
  6. Owen Glenn is wrong when he says he spoke to Peters after that alleged 5 December call, and they discussed the electoral petition.
  7. Owen Glenn is a liar when he says there is no way he would have ever donated $100,000 to Winston’s legal fees, without the request having come from Winston.
  8. Owen Glenn did call Peters on 14 December 2005, but they never discussed a donation. Owen Glenn is lying when he says beyond doubt they did, and the fact they even discussed it in enough detail that he upped the donation from $70,000 to $100,000.
  9. By pure coincidence Peters called Brian Henry one minute after that phone call, but they never discussed money or the donation.
  10. Also by pure coincidence Brian Henry e-mailed Owen Glenn 40 seconds later his bank account details, as he had his memory jogged about the earlier conversation with Glenn (the one Glenn and Ede deny and Henry can not providence any evidence of).
  11. It is normal when asking for a donation to just send bank account details.
  12. The reference to “Further to the call between you and my client at 1.30 pm” did refer to Winston, after claiming it did not, but no donation was discussed with Winston. Brian Henry mentioned the call by accident, and in reality it had nothing to do with the donation.
  13. Even though Henry now says the reference to “my client” must be Peters, there is still a mystery second client who originally put Henry onto Glenn, and this mystery client will not reveal their identitiy even though doing so would exonerate both Peters and Henry. Their need to remain secret is so powerful that it outweighs the fact he or she could clear Peters and Henry from potential disgrace.
  14. Paul Moroney (brother of Labour MP Sue Moroney) is lying when he did an affidavit witnessing Peters thanking Glenn after Glenn asked if he got the money. Glenn is also lying when he recounted the thank you at Karaka.
  15. Owen Glenn donated $500,000 to Labour, $100,000 to Winston’s legal bills and lent Labour another $100,000, but then turned on them because they did not make him Consul to Monaco and because his lawyer once testified on behalf of Fay Richwhite, his lawyer coached him to perjure himself at the Privileges Committee.
  16. Glenn never ever mentioned to Winston Peters in all their other meetings and conversations that he had donated, as Glenn is of course known as the soul of discretion.
  17. When the media reported Owen Glenn in February 2008 as having donated to another party, Brian Henry never clicked that he was referring to the $100,000 Glenn gave Henry for Peters’ legal fees.
  18. Winston Peters never thought to check with Brian Henry if he had received money from Owen Glenn and that this is what he could be referring to.
  19. Even after the Prime Minister rang him and told him that Owen Glenn said he had donated money, Peters still didn’t think to check with Henry.
  20. Peters also had no curiousity about why Glenn would tell the Prime Minister he had donated money, and never thought to ask Owen Glenn (whose number he had). Despite being genuinely in the dark about the donation, he never thought to check with Glenn.
  21. Brian Henry let Winston go into a press conference and deny that NZ First had received any money at all from Owen Glenn – not even a dollar, and did not feel he had an ethical, moral or professional duty to tell him of the personal donation to Peters’ legal expenses.
  22. Brian Henry was aware the Winston Peters was considering appointing Owen Glenn as Consul to Monaco, and did not think the fact Glenn had donated $100,000 to Peters’ legal expenses was something that should be disclosed.
  23. After the NZ Herald on 12 July printed the e-mail from Owen Glenn, Brian Henry still said nothing to Peters despite it being glaringly obvious what he was referring to.
  24. Winston Peters genuinely believed the e-mail was fake, even though the Prime Minister had told him of her personal conversation with Owen Glenn where Glenn stated he had donated to Winston.
  25. Winston Peters was not denying the e-mail’s accuracy because he knew the donation was to his legal fees, and not NZ First itself. He still at this point in time had absolutely no knowledge of any assistance from Glenn in any form.
  26. Winston Peters never thought of doing the obvious when the e-mail was printed and contact Owen Glenn to ask him if the e-mail was real, and what the hell he was on about?
  27. Winston Peters never wondered why Steve Fisher was so desperate to make sure Owen Glenn did not contradict what Peters said?
  28. Even after Brian Henry saw Winston denying everything, claiming the e-mail is fabricated and calling Audrey Young a liar, he still didn’t think he needed to urgently inform Winston that the e-mail was referring to the $100,000 donation for the Tauranga electoral petition in Peters’ name.
  29. It took Brian Henry seven days to manage to talk to his close personal friend and long standing client, to let him know that he had information which verified the e-mail in the Herald, which is why they waited until 18 July 2008 to announce the existence of the donation.
  30. Winston Peters at no stage ever knew of the donation until 18 July 2008.

This is an update on a earlier list I did on19 July.

And as I pointed out them, to beleive Winston’s story you have to believe not some of the above, but pretty much all of the above.

This is basically the story that the Prime Minister finds so compelling she can not make her mind up whether or not it is true or not.

UPDATE: As the Prime Minister is still striggling with this very difficult decision, she may like to also read John Armstrong’s column.

Just as the Moon is made of cheese and fairies live at the bottom of the garden, Winston Peters’ lawyer, Brian Henry, wants to believe that the now notorious phone call from Owen Glenn to Peters never discussed a donation from the business tycoon to pay the legal bills of Henry’s client.

I think this indicates a degree of scepticism. John is obviously finding it difficult to believe the story above.

However, the rest of us don’t live on Planet Winston where black is white, white is what you want it to be and the story changes as fast as the shop-until-you-drop former Philippines first lady Imelda Marcos changed her shoes.

It’s a funny thing. When you tell the truth there is normally no need to then change your story.

Enviromental Forum in Wellington

And the poll leader is ….

Well the dogs have voted, and their favourite toy is:

4th Mark Sainsbury 8%
3rd John Campbell 11%
2nd John Key 19%
1st Helen Clark 61%

So a runaway lead for Helen so far. But are people buying her toy as a sign of affection or because they like sights like this:

Is the dog tenderly fetching her to bring to theri owner, or is she about to start chewing?

We’ll update later this week with even more sales figures.

Encouraging enrolling and voting

NZPA reports on how the Electoral Enrolment Centre is encouraging the 250,000 people not enrolled to do so, so they can vote. 16,396 votes were disqualified in 2005 as people were not enrolled.

I am a big fan of everyone eligible to vote, doing so. But maybe we can look at how best to promote enrolment and voting. Below are the official advertisements in NZ for enrolling:

All very worthy. But now check out this US advertisement promoting enrolment and voting:

I don’t think one needs to do a poll, to work out which one will be most effective at getting the attention of young people (who are the largest segment of non voters). I’m sure some NZ celebrities would be willing to help out for a good cause!

Hat Tip for Alba ad: The Standard

NZ Herald on “chilling effect” law

The NZ Herald comments on how the Electoral Finance Act has taken the fire out of the election:

This month, the head of the Electoral Commission confirmed what had already become apparent in the run-up to polling day on November 8. The Electoral Finance Act had had, said Dr Helena Catt, a “chilling effect on the extent and type of participation in political and campaign activity”. Her comment acknowledged the dearth of activity normally present during election campaigns as interest groups vigorously put their points of view.

Some will say this was always the intention – to make it harder for people to criticise the Government.

Understandably, the association has reacted strongly, saying it will likely legally challenge the commission’s verdict. “The decision … says, in effect, it is illegal to promote any views that oppose those of the government or an MP such as Mr Mallard in an election year,” it said.

A happy coincidence for Labour!

The real culprit here, however, is not the commission but the wording of the act, which probably left it with no choice. Not for no reason is Dr Catt now lambasting a “difficult law”, significant parts of which are “obscure” and hard to interpret. Not for no reason is she now using exactly the same language that critics, such as the Herald, were using as the legislation was rushed through Parliament without reflection or consensus.

And Dr Catt herself warned the law was unclear before it was passed. The three parties that forced it through have no defence.

Unions helping Labour

The NZ Herald reports on how Labour authorised and may have to include the cost of two CTU ads which promote Labour and attack National.

Labour, and Labour candidates, should be very careful about accounting for union activity on their behalf. Such as this one below:

Here we have a Service and Food Workers Union car (and presumably staff) helping erect Labour Party hoardings in Rimutaka.

Gooner at No Minister has a similar story, sighting an EPMU vehicle being used in hoardings in Northcote.

Labour seem so short of volunteers that they can only get their hoardings up with union staff and vehicles.

Will the unions declare the cost of their vehicles and staff as a donation to Labour? Will Labour include the costs of said staff and vehicles in their expense declarations?

If union staff were doing this in their own time as volunteers, there would be no question of this being an expense. But by using union cars, and doing it during work time, I think there is a reasonable case that it becomes corporate assistance and a market rate should be calculated for what the car and manpower would cost.

Keep the photos flowing and mark down locations, dates and times. They may become evidence!

I love the AA!

A tyre blew out today on Aotea Quay. Pulled into the BP station and called the AA. They were there within 15 minutes and all changed within 5 minutes.

AA membership is the best “insurance” you can have. I don’t use them often but they are great for when you do need them.

Two new Labour Party sites

Labour has started to deploy two party websites, on top of the taxpayer funded labour.org.nz.

There is labourparty.org.nz. It looks like it will be a permament site for the party organisation. Quite a nice design – the red isn’t that awful bright red, and lots of white space.

Easy for people to join or donate to the party.

The site is not quite finished – a few pages come up with errors. They have a blog there but no RSS feed for it yet.

The campaign site is www.labour08.co.nz. I’m not such a fan of this one – too many colours and a bit crowded.

The site lists candidates and policies. The policies section is more a rehash of what they have done with a lot of “We will continue” rather than anything new, but it is a start.

Winston’s story

This Tremain cartoon, taken from Homepaddock, sums it all up.

The TVNZ midday news saw political reporter Jessica Mutch try to explain what the Peters/Henry story now was, and you could see the palpable disbelief.

Colin Espiner blogs a line he stole from brother Guyon:

My dear brother Guyon has pinched a few lines off me over the years, so I’m going to nick one of his: The only testimony Brian Henry could have delivered before the privileges committee today that was less credible is if Winston Peters’ lawyer had simply said: “My dog ate it.”

Well the dog ate the phone bill from the mystery motel he claims to have ring Owen Glenn from!

New Zealand First insiders and Peters himself had talked tough over Henry’s recall to the committee this morning, claiming to some journalists that the lawyer would provide evidence this morning that refuted Owen Glenn’s version of events. He did nothing of the sort.

Indeed, everything Henry said and offered this morning in the way of evidence simply corroborated Glenn’s version of events.

You have to wonder what sort of morons talk up in advance evidence that actually proves their Leader lied, and corroborates what Owen Glenn said. Either they didn’t know what Brian Henry was going to say (which means they have blind faith) or they didn’t understand how damning it would be for Peters and Henry.

In my opinion, Henry offered doubt today but it was not reasonable.

Indeed. Reasonable doubt means exactly that – is it reasonable. No reasonable person can really doubt that Peters has lied. And as it so happens the Privileges Committee does not even need to satisfy the criminal standard of “beyond reasonable doubt”. They merely need to satisfy “on the balance of probabilities”.

Will this finally be enough for Clark to sack Peters? I doubt it.

I doubt it also. She needs Peters after the election, so that means minor stuff like lying the public, lying to the media, false declarations, and lying to the Privileges Committee are all forgiveable by Clark.

UPDATE: NZPA quotes the Laboru Party MPs trying to defend Winston:

Labour MPs said the way Mr Glenn and Mr Henry referred to each other by first names in emails showed familiarity.

So these MPs have no shame? no standards at all? They are so desperate to protect Winston (and incidentially declare their largest ever donor to be a liar) that their defence is that first names were used in emails.

This is so pitiful, I won’t even bother pointing out the gaping flaws in their argument. I’ll let readers do that for me.

Bipartisan behaviour

As both US presidential candidates try to position themselves as an agent of change in Washington, the Washington Times looks at the legislative records of McCain and Obama to see who has been the best at working across the aisle with Senators from the other party:

Mr. McCain has been more likely to team up with Democrats than with members of his own party. Democrats made up 55 percent of his political partners over the last two Congresses, including on the tough issues of campaign finance and global warming. For Mr. Obama, Republicans were only 13 percent of his co-sponsors during his time in the Senate, and he had his biggest bipartisan successes on noncontroversial measures, such as issuing a postage stamp in honor of civil rights icon Rosa Parks.

So McCain has been able to team up with Democrats consistently and on bis issues such as campaign finance and globalwarming. Obama’s record is almost never working with Republicans except on non controversial issues such as postage stamps.

Cullen paid $570 million over valuation

Duncan Bridgeman at NBR has written on the purchase of Dr Cullen’s train set:

Documents posted on the Treasury website reveal that in late 2006 officials valued the New Zealand’s rail system at $120 million, some $570 million less than the price the government paid for the business in July this year.

Yes we paid around six times the estimated value of the trains. My God.

The papers reveal that in December 2007, government agency ONTRACK made an indicative offer for equity held by Toll NZ of up to $350 million.

So Toll pushed Dr Cullen up from $350 million to $690 million. No wonder they call it the sale of the century.

Campbell Live on billboards

Campbell Live had a very amusing segment on election billboards (and incidentially in the main TV3 news bulletin they twice showed the online billboard showing Helen and Winston holding hands together). Well worth viewing.

John Campbell’s comments in summary were:

  • National billboard disguised as an Air NZ ad, or spend your tax cuts on air travel
  • Labour billboard modelled on North Koran campaign with President Helen, the great leader herself. Joked they removed “or else” after the words “Party Vote Labour”
  • Greens have best billboard so far by a mile

Mike Hutcheson’s comments in summary were:

  • Nat billboard was written by an undertaker – wave goodbye to higher taxes, not your loved ones!
  • Hutch suggested better billboard would have been “Hi Tax, Hi Oz” and the health one should be “Beds not Bosses” or “Beds not Bureaucrats”
  • Campbell said Labour’s billboards do not seem to be as airbrushed as normal, and Hutcheson says it is stupid that they take the public for fools by putting up an image that doesn’t look anything like the Helen Clark people see every day. Why would you say the campaign is about trust, and then have billboards which don’t look like you.
  • Also loved the Greens billboards – very professional

Public Service Alert

Game on in Australia

A few days ago Peter Costello announced he will contnue with his plans to retire from politics, and not take up the Liberal Party leadership which would has been his for the taking.

Now Liberal Leader Brendan Nelson has called for a leadership ballot, to force Malcolm Turnbull to challenge or pledge loyalty. Turnbull has confirmed he will challenge. Nelson beat Turnbull in an upset victory last year.

In theory Nelson should be toast as he has massively low approval ratings, and his colleagues have little confidence in him.

But Turnbull, while talented, is very unpopular with many of his colleagues. It is likely Nelson will retain the leadership. A pity to some degree, as I think Turnbull has many good ideas and policies in terms of economic reform.

Also Labor’s one year reign of total government is over. Since they won the federal election they were uniqely in government in all eight states and territories as well as federally. That has ended in Western Australia though.

The Liberal Party got 38.5% and Labor 35.8%, plus Nationals 4.9% (and Greens 11.9%). The Nationals only contested a few seats and won four seats giving the balance of power.

Now you might think this means an automatic victory for the Libs, but WA is the one state where the Libs and Nats are not formally aligned, so just like in NZ in 1996 the major parties bidded for the Nats affection and they negotiated deals with each party. They finally opted to go with the Liberal Party.

UPDATE: Turnbull won 45-41. This is good.

Henry changes story

From Stuff:

Winston Peters has produced a phone record which backs up billionaire Owen Glenn’s timeline of events around a $100,000 donation towards the New Zealand First leader’s legal costs.

His lawyer Brian Henry today conceded to Parliament’s privileges committee the pair’s recollection of events was poor and their earlier story did not now seem correct.

And not just their earlier testimony under oath, but everything they have said is cast into doubt.

The email, produced by Mr Glenn, shows Mr Henry referred to the phone conversation with “my client” at the precise time of the phone call.

Mr Henry has previously denied the “client” was Mr Peters.

But today in a video-linked appearance before the committee Mr Henry changed crucial parts of his story.

He acknowledged that Mr Peters must be the client referred to.

Now remember he denied multiple times Peters was the client. He denied this directly to the Privileges Committee.

Phone records from Mr Peters which he promised the committee last week and which were released today show Mr Peters called him one minute after he finished talking to Mr Glenn.

Mr Henry’s email was sent one minute after his phone call with Mr Peters ended.

The truth comes out. Not that it wasn’t already out for 99% of NZ.

Mr Glenn has said Mr Peters asked for the $100,000 donation in their phone call.

But Mr Henry today gave the committee a different explanation, although he acknowledged he had little recollection of the actual events.

He said he had spoken to Mr Glenn in either late November or early December asking for a donation.

Prove it. Where is the phone log?

He said the phone call from Mr Peters on December 14, which was presumably coincidental, reminded him to follow up with Mr Glenn, which he immediately did.

“That jogged my memory to seek a donation,” he said.

This is just so much bullshit. Their story has changed so many times, to fit the facts, it is just beyond belief.

Now let us make this simple for Helen:

  1. Owen Glenn phoned Winston at 1.27 pm
  2. That call ended at 1.33 pm
  3. Winston phoned Brian Henry at 1.34 pm
  4. That call ended at 1.39 pm
  5. At 1.40 pm Brian Henry sent Owen Glenn the bank account details for the donation

I am sure Helen or Michael Cullen will find a way to put it all down to an innocent explanation.

UPDATE:

NZPA also report:

Mr Glenn has denied having any dealings with Mr Henry, prompting calls for Mr Henry to produce phone records to back up his claim.

But Mr Henry said the call was made around the time of Mr Peters’ Tauranga electoral petition, between November 22 and December 1, 2005, and he was staying in a motel that only kept phone records dating back to 2006.

Well this is very easy to resolve. The motel may not have kept phone records, but Telecom certainly will have. Not that there is any real doubt, but if the Privileges Committee thinks Henry is telling the truth (this time!), then they can easily verify it by asking Telecom (and Telecom cannot refuse) to supply the phone records for those 10 days for the motel. Telecom keep these records for at least seven years.

Will Helen commit to a fulll term?

Bill Ralston blogs on an exchange on radio with Helen:

On Friday on my Radio Live Drive show I asked her, if she did win an historic fourth term, would she serve the entire term of three years as Prime Minister?

There was a lot of waffling from Helen about her being physically fit and not thinking about retiring.

I pressed the PM, saying “not contemplating or thinking about retiring” was not the same as assuring voters she would stay the course in any fourth term.

She did not give a categorical answer.

Now despite the current polls, it is possible that Helen will be able to put together a Labour/Anderton/Winston/Greens/Maori Party coalition and remain Prime Minister.

But would she stay for a full term, if she won? Or would she hand over to David Cunliffe halfway through? Should the public know they may be voting for Prime Minister Cunliffe as well as Prime Minister Clark, if they vote Labour?

Who won what

It is hard to know who did well at the Qantas Awards as each broadcaster focuses on the awards they won. So as a guide, here are the awards for each channel.

News and Current Affairs

TV1

  1. Qantas Best News – One News
  2. Best News or Current Affairs Presenter – Mark Sainsbury (Close Up)
  3. TV Journalist of the Year – Mike Valintine and Hunter Wells (Sunday)
  4. Best News Reporting – Lisa Owen (One News)
  5. Best Current Affairs Reporting for a daily programme  – Robyn Janes and Steve Hopkins (Close Up)
  6. Best Current Affairs Series  – Sunday
  7. Best News Camera – Jared Mason (One News and Close Up)
  8. Investigation of the Year – Mike Valintine and Hunter Wells (Sunday)

TV3

  1. Best Current Affairs Reporting for a weekly programme or one off current affairs special – Sarah Hall, Paula Penfold, George Murahidy and Catherine Hallinan (60 Minutes)
  2. Best Current Affairs Camera – George Murahidy (60 Minutes)
  3. Best News and Current Affairs Editing – Paul Enticott (60 Minutes)

So a pretty compelling victory for TV1 over TV3. Now for General TV:

  1. TV1 – 7 awards
  2. TV2 – 4 awards
  3. TV3 – 12 awards
  4. C4 – 2 awards
  5. Maori TV – 1 award
  6. TVNZ6 – 1 award

TV3 takes aways the honours here – winning more than TV1 and TV2 combined.

Elect the President

Over 1,300 people voted in the initial ballot for the yet to be created position of President of New Zealand. The ten candidates have been reduced to five. Those who dropped out were:

  1. Sir Douglas Graham
  2. Sir Robert Jones
  3. Sir Kenneth Keith
  4. Don McKinnon
  5. Vincent O’Sullivan

The five remaining candidates are:

  1. Professor James Belich
  2. Jim Bolger
  3. Dr Claudia Orange
  4. Dame Kiri Te Kanawa
  5. Sir Wilson Whineray.

Both lists are in alphabetical order.

Voting has now opened for the final ballot to select a President from the five remaining candidates.

You can vote online here. It is a ranked preferential ballot, so rank your top choice “1” and your bottom choice “5”. Voting closes on Friday 31 October 2008 so we will get to find out who our fictional President is a week or more before we find out who his or her Prime Minister will be 🙂

Vegas Issues

The latest news on Winston’s trip to Las Vegas confirms that Helen Clark is operating two sets of standards – one for Winston, and for other Ministers. Winston could rob a bank in broad daylight, and Helen would happily keep him on.

Let us go to the Cabinet Manual, section 2.113:

Subject to parliamentary or portfolio requirements, and with the prior approval of the Prime Minister, Ministers may occasionally extend overseas visits outside the formal itinerary for personal reasons, provided no additional costs are incurred by the government as a result.

Now it is as clear as it can be, that Winston Peters was required to get Helen Clark’s permission for the sidetrip to Las Vegas. Clark says she only learnt of it two weeks ago. Now by itself this isn’t a hanging offence, but what it illustrates is how Clark operates a totally different set of standards with Peters. Peters knows Clark won’t touch him, so he doesn’t bother with minor stuff like accountability or rules.

There is also some confusion about whether or not Clark did know more than two weeks ago. Whale Oil alleges that the unapproved side trip was discussed at the MFAT Divisional Officers’ Meeting which includes PM’s foreign afairs advisor from DPMC. So if Clark did not know, then her Department did.

Matthew Hooton also reports that George Calvert has denied paying for the sidetrip to Vegas. Now the lanugage used here (and one has to be suspicious when it involves Winston and friends) suggests the denial only applies to the airfares – not necessarily the accomodation and match tickets. Because if someone other than Peters did pay for them, and the cost was over NZ$500, then Peters has breached (again) the Register of MPs Pecuninary Interests and the Cabinet Manual (again).

Queen Bee asserts that the taxpayer originally paid for the flights and the accommodation. which is what caused all the fuss in MFAT. The money was repaid, but it is not known when – was it after questions were asked?

The best case scenario is that Peters has broken the Cabinet Manual, and Clark has demonstrated she has will not enforce any rules on Peters, so long as he votes for her. The worst case scenario is that the taxpayer paid for personal travel, it was only refunded when found out, and also gifts in excess of $500 were not declared. It is important to stress that there is no public proof of the worst case scenario at this point in time. Only the best case scenario has been proven. The worst case scenario can be proven false in just five minutes with the appropriate receipts.