Hooton on Las Vegas

Matthew Hooton blogs some useful info on the Peters trip to Las Vegas:

The Foreign Minister has confirmed that he made the “sidetrip” when he was in Berlin entroute to Singapore, so some “sidetrip” it must have been.

You can fly from Berlin to Singapore, via Frankfurt, on Lufthansa and Singapore Airlines for the discounted Business Class fare of around NZ$7730.50.  (I don’t know why on earth the HoS would assume, as it did, that Peters would fly economy – he was meant to be working on this trip, remember.)  It is quite an efficient way of getting from Berlin to Singapore, taking a total of around 14 hours.

In contrast, getting even from Berlin to Las Vegas is considerably more arduous, taking at least 16 hours, and requiring at least two stops.  Getting from Las Vegas to Singapore can also be difficult, taking almost 24 hours on United Airlines.  Book Business Class Berlin/Las Vegas/Singapore on United Airlines and it will set you back around $15,500.

To be square with the taxpayer, it seems the Foreign Minister would have had to pay about $8,000 for the tickets alone (and god knows what sort of condition he would have arrived in, in Singapore, after flying halfway around the world and stopping over in Las Vegas for a fight, but he is known for his resilience.)

That is a very expensive diversion indeed.

The average ticket price for the fight was said to be over US$1,300.  So the total cost of the Foreign Minister’s “sidetrip”, paid by him personally, would have been over NZ$10,000.

I hope he enjoyed himself for that amount.  He must be a big boxing fan.

A huge fan.

We must take the Foreign Minister at his word that he personally paid this ten grand.  It would put the whole matter to rest to see the receipts.  And also the dates on them.

Yep that is all that is needed. Just as all Brian Henry needs to do is produce a phone log showing his multiple calls to Owen Glenn.

And it would be also interesting to know if the Prime Minister approved the sidetrip and knew how it was to be financed.  From my memory working for the Trade Minister in the 1990s, prime ministers have to approve all ministerial travel, including sidetrips.  This remains part of the Cabinet Office Manual:

“2.113 Subject to parliamentary or portfolio requirements, and with the prior approval of the Prime Minister, Ministers may occasionally extend overseas visits outside the formal itinerary for personal reasons, provided no additional costs are incurred by the government as a result.

“2.114 Ministers may make personal visits overseas if they obtain the Prime Minister’s prior approval, which will be subject to obtaining leave to be absent from the House. Ministers must also obtain the agreement of another Minister or Ministers to act during such periods of absence. (See paragraphs 2.39 – 2.42.) The Cabinet Office should be advised of any such arrangements.”

Well maybe Helen can clear this all up for us. She would have approved it. As Matthew says this may all be a load of nonsense. So best to expose it for the nonsense it is as soon as possible.

This election is about Trusts

John Ansell requested a billboard yesterday, so the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy leaped into action. First we had this excellent response from Whale Oil:

Now who wants to donate some money to get that up on a billboard? 🙂

And an overseas based reader sends in another version:

Also an excellent effort. Feel free to promote these via blogs, e-mail etc.

As for why the PM declared this election is about trust? Leftie blog Adding Noughts points out she is copying the John Howard playbook as noted by the Sydney Morning Herald:

THE New Zealand Prime Minister, Helen Clark, has taken a leaf out of John Howard’s book, calling an election and immediately defining it as being about trust.

Miss Clark yesterday said the country’s future would be at stake on November 28, when New Zealanders would decide which party they trusted most. …

“I do believe the future of New Zealand is at stake,” Miss Clark said. “I believe that Labour has shown, through its record in office, that we can be trusted with the future of New Zealand.

“It is about which leader and which major party we New Zealanders trust our families’ and country’s future with.”

When he announced Australia’s 2004 election, Mr Howard said: “This election, ladies and gentlemen, will be about trust.” He asked voters to trust him with the economy and interest rates and in the fight against terrorism.

Speaks for itself.

Agenda fact checking

Very amusing to watch the students do fact checking on Agenda. They found:

  • Lockwood Smith was only half right in claiming 80,000 Kiwis had left last year, as did not take account of returning Kiwis
  • David Parker was only half right in claiming they have doubled the compensation to forestry owners as in fact has only increased by 50% on original offer
  • Most amusingly of all they found Nick Smith’s comment that the first policy released by Labour in this campaign was a National policy was 100% correct. They checked both the Beehive website and the Labour Party website and could not find a single 2008 election policy listed.

McCarten on a National Cabinet

Matt McCarten looks at a possible National Cabinet. His picks are:

  1. John Key – PM
  2. Bill English – Deputy PM, Finance
  3. Gerry Brownlee – Leader of the House, SOEs, State Services
  4. Simon Power – Justice, Attorney-General
  5. Judith Collins – Welfare
  6. Tony Ryall – Health
  7. Nick Smith – Environment, Conservation
  8. Maurice Williamson – Transport
  9. Peter Dunne – Revenue
  10. Rodney Hide – Education
  11. Murray McCully – Foreign Affairs
  12. Lockwood Smith – Overseas Trade, Associate Finance
  13. David Carter – Agriculture
  14. Anne Tolley – Education if Hide does not get it
  15. Wayne Mapp – Defence and Industrial Relations

Matt gets some things wrong. He claims Simon Power will get Justice and AG as there are no other lawyers on the front bench. As Judith Collins was President of the Auckland District Law Society we can assume she is a lawyer.

Matt also says half the people were in the previous 1996 to 1999 Cabinet. Actually only seven out of the 15 were, but more to the point he has overlooked near certs for Cabinet such as Chris Finlayson and Tim Groser. Pansy Wong has an excellent chance also.

An excellent game

The Gods smiled on me yesterday as around lunchtime I got a phone call from a mate asking if I would be interested in watching the Wellington Lions vs Waikato game from a corporate box. Well that was a tough decision, so happily cancelled previously made plans. A few of us met at a friend’s place just down the road from me. As we walked to the stadium I persuaded them all on how we should lobby to get the bridge from the bottom of Davis Street to the stadium re-established. It would be great for Thorndon residents and cut 15 minutes off the journey.

The first quarter was amazing as the Lions scored four tries to be 26 – 0 up. And they were good tries too – great running and dodging. It was really all over at that point.

Waikato did well to fight back, but never looked like they would win. The final score was 45 – 33, with 12 tries scored in total – a great game to watch. And of course after match drinks were also fun.

Wellington owes Fran Wilde, and others, a huge thanks for making the Stadium happen. It has just transformed sports attendance rates in Wellington.

Very cute watching teams of six year olds playing on the ground before the big match.

Anyway Wellington now leads the points tables with 7 from 7. Next week is the challenge against Auckland for the Ranfurly Shield.

Winston in Las Vegas

The Herald on Sunday reports on questions around a trip to Las Vegas by our Foreign Minister.

Act leader Rodney Hide has raised what he says are “serious questions” over the trip in May last year, claiming several “very credible” sources had told him that Peters’ airfares, accommodation and tickets to the Oscar de la Hoya-Floyd Mayweather fight were paid for by wealthy businessman George Calvert.

But Peters said yesterday that Hide’s claims were a “pile of crap” and challenged him to put up, or shut up. Peters had been in Europe on official Foreign Affairs business at the time and made a private trip from Berlin to Las Vegas to attend the title fight before heading on to Singapore.

Peters says he paid for his airfares and accommodation in Las Vegas and later reimbursed “an acquaintance” who had supplied him with the boxing tickets.

A one-way flight from Berlin to Las Vegas costs about $3500 and fight tickets can vary from anything between $100 and $2500. Laws state MPs should declare all gifts and donations over the value of $500.

Peters can clear all this up by showing receipts for the flights and details of the claimed reimbursement for the boxing tickets.

I don’t know anything about these allegations first hand, but what I have heard suggests the reimbursements only occurred a year later once questions were asked. There has also been some suggestion that the airfares may not have been directly paid for by the Minister and again only reimbursed a year or so later. But this may be quite wrong. This is why this can all be solved by showing receipts for the reimbursements.

If the reimbursements did occur after 31 January 2008, then the 2007 Register of Pecuniary Interests may be incorrect.

I am sure the Prime Minister is concerned about ensuring the Cabinet Manual has been complied with, and will ask someone to verify everything is in order.

“Not affiliated to any party”

The Herald on Sunday reports on how Rochelle Rees has google bombed John Key so a search of NZ sites on “clueless” will bring up his website.

This isn’t terribly difficult to do, especially if it is for .nz sites only. It is far far harder to do it for all searches.

Anyway I found it interesting that the HoS reported:

Auckland computer programmer Rochelle Rees told the Herald on Sunday she emailed friends a year ago, asking them to put links on their websites to Key’s site with the word “clueless” as the link text.

“More than anything, it’s fun,” said Rees, who said she was interested in politics but not affiliated to any party.

I found that interesting. For I could recall two things about Rochelle. One is that she is involved in Auckland Animal Action. The other is I was sure she was a member of Young Labour. And sure enough a quick Google search, and I find the answer on my own blog!

So Rochelle just last year was not just a member of Young Labour, but was elected onto its National Executive. So how is that not affiliated to any party?

I also found it amusing that that they are trying to suggest with their Google bombing that John Key is clueless. The bombing works better if it is an attribute that many people will agree with. They should have gone with “swallowing dead rats” or something. Because look at Key’s achievements:

  • Hugely successful career in the private sector
  • Rose to the top job in his area (global head of foreign exchange) in a company with 60,000 staff, $100 billion a year turnover and assets in excess of $1 trillion.
  • So popular with his staff, colleagues and competitors than the SST couldn’t find a single person to speak badly of him, despite the fact he was in an industry with legendary rivalry
  • Appointed to the Foreign Exchange Committee of the New York Federal Reserve
  • Successfully challenged an incumbent MP for the Helensville 2002 nomination
  • Made Opposition Finance Spokesperson after just two years in Parliament
  • Unanimously elected National Party Leader after just four years in Parliament
  • Within six months of being elected Opposition Leader, overtook Helen Clark as Preferred Prime Minister
  • Has consistently polled as the most popular Leader of the Opposition since records began over 20 years ago

Need I go on?

UPDATE: Rochelle, far from being someone just interested in politics, was a candidate for City Vision in the local body elections. Also she was endorsed by the Labour affiliated EPMU as a preferred candidate. And her e-mail address is @primary.geek.nz which is mainatined by Labour Party member and The Standard owner – Lynn Prentice.

I have no problems with Rochelle having some fun Google bombing. Good on her. But once again we see the traditional pattern of behaviour where someone is portrayed as just “interested in politics but not affiliated to any party”, when the reality is quite different.

UPDATE2: The Herald on Sunday have updated their story and Rochelle has commented below. She says she told the reporter she wasn’t currently affiliated. And Lynn Prentice happens to be her uncle!

Rickards as a lawyer

The HoS has a copy of the letter Louise Nicholas wrote to the Law Society about why Clint Rickards should not be admitted to the bar. She says:

She also wrote it was “absolutely shameful” that Rickards publicly supported co-accused Brad Shipton and Bob Schollum immediately after the trio were acquitted and criticised the police.

“For this man to stand on the steps of the Auckland High Court and publicly announce that ‘my good mates Shipton and Schollum should not be in jail, they are good men’ is absolutely shameful,” wrote Nicholas.

I would have thought the ability to get up and proclaim that guilty men were innocent, is a pre-requisite for being a lawyer!

Las Vegas

Laura Ede

I noticed quite a few clicks coming through to Kiwiblog from searches on the term “Laura Ede”. So I checked the term out in Google, and sure enough Kiwiblog is the top site that gets returned for searches for Miss Ede.

Second top is the NZ Herald, with this article in today’s paper on her.

Ede describes her job as:

She said she was now responsible for Mr Glenn’s global finances and the business-related matters of running his Monaco-based yacht with its four crew, and administration of the Glenn Family Foundation.

“I have a wide authority for Mr Glenn to take actions that I know he will require. He has learned that he can trust me and rely on me.”

I know someone who is also an EA to a billionairre, and the job is one of huge trust and importance. It can be somewhat all consuming, but never boring.

A quick start

Was very impressed yesterday to see around 20 members of Stephen Franks’ campaign team out with placards at the intersection of Lampton Quay and Bowen Street. They must have arranged it in the few hours between the announcement at 12.30 pm and my bus going past at 4.30 pm.

Some photos from Stephen’s Blog:

The Young Nats out in force.

It was a good intersection they picked as you are literally in the middle of the traffic.

And some smart use of a construction site to get visibility.

The campaign didn’t feel real until I saw them all out campaigning!

Such guts

Paula Tesoriero picked up her third paralympics medal yesterday in literally blistering heat, getting bronze for the 25 km road race:

Tesoriero was not able to stand on the dais to receive her medal as a result of heat exhaustion in blistering temperatures. She will spend a day in bed to recover fully from her ailment.

All who compete at the Paralympics are awesome role medals. So far the NZ team has won nine medals (Paula is one third of that!) and four more days to go.

TVNZ report on the worthy stand in for Paula:

She was taken to hospital for a precautionary MRI scan so a stand-in was needed for the medal ceremony.

This position was taken by her husband Chris Bishop who probably deserved some reward for the stress he’d been though watching his wife!

Chris is the most amazingly supportive partner for Paula, and definitely her number one fan. I knew both Chris and Paula before they started dating. In fact we spent some time trying to convince Paula that we thought Chris was interested in being more than just friends with her.

Paula kept denying this, and kept asking us what made us think this. Finally one day we confessed “Well mainly because Chris has told us he is” 🙂

A final reminder – friends and fans can vote for Paula on the TVNZ site. You’ll go in for a chance to win an Mitsubishi Outlander, and the top scoring competitor gets one also.

Helen rules Winston in

The Herald reports:

She said she would not rule out dealing with anyone after the election besides National and its “handmaiden” Act.

This is very important. A vote for Labour will effectively be a vote to keep Winston in Government. It doesn’t matter how many times he lies, it doesn’t matter how many false donations returns are filed, she’ll still have him in Government.

After weeks and weeks of claiming she has to wait for due process, she shows she has made her mind up. Unless Winston is actually in a jail cell, she”ll deal with him. She knows that he lied to her and to the public. The whole country knows he lied. But Helen says no problems.

Once upon a time, Clark had some standards. She referred to Peters as the “Le Pen” of New Zealand. Now she will forgive him any crime or sin. He could call for mass deportation of Asian immigrants, and Helen would not rule him out.

I love it that Helen has said this is an election about trust. As one commenter suggested:

You can trust Helen to keep Winston’s secrets

Indeed.

Just don’t call it a quota

One of the reasons trust in the Police keeps dropping, is when the hierarchy act like politicians.

The Herald reveals a memo from Waitemata road policing manager Superintendent John Kelly:

In the August 12 email, Waitemata road policing manager Superintendent John Kelly sets out ticket targets for his district’s highway patrol officers in five “fatal” offence categories.

The categories are speeding, alcohol, restraints (e.g. seatbelts and child carseats), dangerous/careless driving and high-risk driving.

Each fulltime-equivalent officer is expected to issue 1420 tickets a year, including 560 for speeding, the email says.

With 225 traffic officers on New Zealand roads, that means 875 tickets should be dished out to motorists throughout the country every day.

And the email points out in bold type that the figures are “the minimum expectation”.

It’s damn obvious there is a quota. What else do you call a minimum expectation?

Mr Kelly told the Weekend Herald the figures in the email came from the national quarterly performance report, and were averages only.

“There’s no quota,” he said yesterday. “There’s nothing that says, ‘You will by God go out there and write out 25 tickets an hour for speeding’ or anything like that.

No, the quota is not an hourly quota, but it is still a quota. We get the truth elsewhere:

However, National Party police spokesman Chester Borrows said Mr Kelly’s email confirmed the existence of quotas “yet again”.

“What running a quota does is concentrate on getting tickets and it doesn’t concentrate on harm reduction,” he said. “Police will give tickets to people where it’s easy to catch them rather than where the real fear of death or injury is.”

Police Association president Greg O’Connor also said the reality was that quotas existed.

“Every police officer knows that police have quotas and wryly smile whenever they see senior police stand up and say they don’t.

“They are dressed up many other ways but the reality is that there is an expectation of members that are out there, that they will write so many tickets to certain categories.”

Mr O’Connor said quotas were “essentially wrong” because they impacted on “that most important element of policing, which is discretion”.

And the deceptive language used by the Police hierarchy just undermines confidence in them.

Shaun Tan’s response to the EPMU

I blogged earlier this week the EPMU’s reasons for dismissing Shaun Tan, and linked to their reasoning and evidence.

I’m happy to do the same for Shaun Tan with his response to them. He has provided me three documents.

  1. tan-response – a 13 page word document responding to the allegations
  2. tan-emails – a copy of e-mails referred to in the main response
  3. open-letter-to-epmu-members – an open letter from Shaun to EPMU members

The full documents are worth a read. The first section of the response is:

These unsatisfactory references stemmed from my stint at Finsec, where I was employed for a 12-month fixed-term contract. I was battling health issues at the time, so it is despicable for the EPMU to be publicising my private health matters in this manner – especially when I have now overcome these.

If the public must know, I was battling severe sleep apnoea at the time. This is a condition that causes you to fall asleep uncontrollably at unforeseen moments. So when the EPMU refers to my ‘lack of focus’, this would be in reference to my occasional spells of dozing off in the office while at Finsec.

I tried explaining this to the union, but it was not accepted – and was in fact dismissed as a lame excuse. This is despite sleep apnoea being a genuine, recognised and serious condition. I have documents from the Sleep Apnoea Clinic at Mercy Hospital to demonstrate that I indeed had a sleep study done there last year, and that a report was generated based on their findings.

For a union to persecute someone for a health condition is both morally repugnant and inimical to the principles of fairness and equality they are supposed to embody and in turn promulgate. Their actions are akin to disciplining someone because he has been diagnosed with a terminal illness.

And a later section responds to the e-mails with ACT people:

The EPMU have raised my e-mail correspondence with ACT personnel as a breach of work policy. Yet, one of their senior managers, National Education Officer Ross Teppett, lists his EPMU e-mail address on a Wellington Central Labour Party newsletter in his capacity as the co-ordinator of hoardings for Labour candidate Grant Robertson. The fact that Mr Teppett lists his work e-mail address in such a manner indicates that he is likely to be sending and receiving Labour e-mails during work time, and via work equipment.

Again, the EPMU demonstrates its blatantly duplicitous treatment of staff. Or worse: they have unwittingly acknowledged that they are not a third party.

It appears that the EPMU do not have a problem with these (and other) goings-on – except, of course, if it is ACT e-mails that are being sent and received. Perhaps the reason for this disparity in treatment is because the EPMU is intrinsically linked with Labour; thus, campaigning for Labour during EPMU time using EPMU equipment constitutes engaging in EPMU work.

Off memory too the (possibly former) Labour Electorate Chair for Northcote put out Labour Party press releases listing his EPMU address as a contact. This was a few months ago announcing the candidate I think.

I’ve blogged both sides to the story, and am not making any assertions or predictions about the outcome of any ERA decisions on whether the dismissal was justified.

The election dates

  1. Parliament dissolves on Friday 3 October (just three days before it happens automatically)
  2. Writ Day is on Wednesday 8 October – this is what triggers the actual election
  3. Nominations Day is Tuesday 14 October – this is the day all nominations and party lists must be in by.
  4. The election is on Saturday 8 November 2008
  5. The official results and writs must be declared and returned by Saturday 22 Thursday 27 November 2008
  6. The 49th Parliament must convene no later than Saturday 3 Thursday 8 January 2009 (in reality it will almost certainly meet before Christmas. )

Possible election date announcement

Helen Clark has called a press conference for 12.30 pm.

The 9th floor won’t say what it is about, but most are picking she will announce the date of the election.

This will be great. It will mean we are in the campaign period with Winston still surgically attached to her.

UPDATE: It is on November 8, as long predicted.

Clark says she will be campaigning on trust. I hope she will campaign with her Foreign Minister. I also hope she campaigns on how she knew the truth about the secret donations from Owen Glenn for six months and said nothing. How a Labour MP almost certainly told her three months ago that there was a witness (the MP’s brother) to Winston thanking Owen Glenn for his secret donation, and she still said nothing. And about how her party president authorised the secret donation back in 2005.

I cannot walk away from the truth

That is the quote from the brother of Labour MP Sue Moroney. He says:

Champion horse trainer Paul Moroney says he approached Owen Glenn with his recollection of Winston Peters thanking him for the $100,000 donation because “I cannot walk away from the truth”.

Mr Moroney said when the story broke and he saw Mr Peters’ continued denials he realised he had crucial knowledge. “I said to people: ‘I am staggered by what’s happening here’.”

He then made a “personal decision” to tell Mr Glenn what he knew knowing he was coming to New Zealand to appear before Parliament’s privileges committee – but never spoke to him directly, dealing only briefly with an assistant.

So he was not asked by Glenn to confirm Glenn’s story. He came forward on his own volition, because he could not walk away from the truth.

Mr Moroney said he expected a backlash from the racing community as Mr Peters was a popular minister.

“This is not about the racing industry. This is about the truth. And I cannot walk away from the truth.”

And he told the truth even though it was not in his best interests to do so.

This is a key point to remember.

Owen Glenn saying that Peters solicited the money does not advantage Owen Glenn. If anything it has disadvantaged him. Paul Moroney saying he witnessed Peters thanking Glenn does not advantage Moroney, it disadvantages him.

Winston Peters saying that he knew nothing about the money advanatges Peters massively.

Mr Moroney said he realised he had put his sister, Labour MP Sue Moroney, in an “awkward position”. He had informed her of his knowledge about three months ago without telling her the full story.

Now who thinks that Sue Moroney would not have told Helen Clark that her brother witnessed Winston thanking Glenn for the donation?

Obama’s Electoral Map

Dispatch from Helengrad

This week’s Dispatch from Helengrad is online at NBR.

The summary grades are:

  • Labour get a C+ and best play of the week for passing the ETS (before you howl at me, go read why)
  • The Reserve Bank gets a D and worst play of the week for long-term inflation
  • Winston of course remains scandal of the week, but it is downgraded from an A+ to an A- as he should have been sacked by now
  • I give myself an E for risking the fury of Tui fans everywhere by asking the Electoral Commission to rule on whether their “When Winston says no, he means no” billboard constitutes an election advertisement under the Electoral Finance Act.
  • And I give best blog analysis of the week to Nevil Gibson (who just happens to be the NBR editor!) for analysing NZ’s performance in the World Bank ratings of which countries are best to do business in.

Feedback and comments can be made over at NBR.

The Editors have no doubt

All three major daily editorials today are on Peters, and none of them believe him.

The NZ Herald::

The silly thing throughout has been that had Mr Peters told the truth at the outset, no harm would have been done. Nobody could have really believed his career survived on his small party’s membership fees. Had he admitted, when asked, that he had needed help with a legal bill, who could have blamed him?

But Mr Peters’ instinct was never to be candid. He seemed to have a congenital aversion to the straight answer. Invariably he treated questions from the press as a personal affront, to be met with verbal jousts, semantic denials and obfuscation. His “testimony” on Wednesday night confirmed one other peculiarity about this former lawyer – he is remarkably inarticulate. Swallowing words, blurring the point and scrambling sense. This, wilfully or involuntarily, contributes to the fog of evasion. His appearance failed to rebut a single piece of Mr Glenn’s evidence.

Telling the truth would have been much wiser in hindsight for Peters.

Enough of him. New Zealanders should consider today what a debt we owe Owen Glenn. He cared enough for his good name in this country to come here and clear it. In doing so he will surely rid us of a politician who misused his considerable talent and charm to mislead the public on important policies, sow fear and suspicion of change and survive on a populism that has turned out to be not only destructive but dishonest.

Destructive and dishonest. Not a bad summary.

The Dominion Post has had enough of what it calls this nonsense:

Mr Henry insists that Mr Peters was not the “client” referred to in the e-mail and, therefore, Mr Peters should be taken at his word when he says he did not ask Mr Glenn for money.

Before Mr Glenn produced his phone records, that was an improbable, but conceivable, explanation of events.

It is no longer, unless Mr Henry expects the committee to believe that while talking to Mr Peters, Mr Glenn was also conducting another conversation with someone else who just happened to be making representations on Mr Peters’ behalf without the MP’s knowledge.

Yes, he was on two phone calls at the same time. Well this is what Helen Clark seems to believe.

For too long, he has trifled with the truth and danced on the heads of legal pins. By doing so, he would like his supporters to believe he has simply been refusing to dance to the tune of petty bureaucrats and the news media.

But what he has, in fact, been doing is showing contempt for Parliament, the law and the public. Remember, it was an audience member who asked Mr Peters at a Grey Power meeting in July to explain why NZ First had not declared money received from the Spencer Trust, a shadowy legal entity administered by his brother Wayne.

Mr Peters replied that: “Everything that [NZ First] was required to do within the law has been done,” has now been shown, by the party’s own admission that it broke electoral law, to be false.

Indeed. And there may well be others laws broken with their false returns.

And the Press calls the PM an obfuscator and ditherer:

The Prime Minister, Helen Clark, continues to obfuscate and dither over whether to sack the suspended Minister of Foreign Affairs, Winston Peters, says The Press in an editorial.

Again the key issue is not whether she will sack him. It is whether she will rule him out post-election.

Now, despite the compelling evidence presented by Glenn which Peters abysmally failed to rebut, Clark continues to suggest there is enough there to cause her to have doubts. This is nonsense. Clark is failing to act not because there is any real doubt any more, but out of political calculation, because she may need Peters in future. In doing so, she badly compromises her own reputation for political integrity.

A less charitable person might say it confirms her own political integrity reputation!

Having worked hard before his appearance to confuse the issue by suggesting that Glenn might somehow have misremembered events or got muddled, Labour continues, by pointing to minor discrepancies or errors, to try to generate a smokescreen around his evidence and cast doubt on it. But unless there is some dramatic new evidence that has not yet been revealed, no honest, objective observer who saw and heard Glenn this week, and watched Peters’ reply, can any longer doubt the matter.

It is ironic that Helen Clark whines and whines that National should not be on the Privileges Committee. Because if any group of MPs could be seen to be acting as advocates for one side, it is the Labour MPs who seem to be unpaid Counsels for Winston Peters.

The New Zealand First party itself has shown, by the evidence that has now emerged of inaccurate election donation returns not just once but in election after election, that it too apparently believes it does not have to play by the same rules as everyone else. This has happened so often that it is hard escape the belief that it is a deliberate tactic designed, for electoral advantage, to bamboozle the party’s supporters about the source of its income.

The rhetoric of parts of Peters’ privileges committee evidence, suggesting a malign conspiracy against him, was clearly a warm-up for what is likely to be the theme of his election campaign. It must be hoped that voters have the sense to see through it and ensure that we have had the last of him in government and of New Zealand First in Parliament.

That would indeed be a good thing.

The pundits have their say

As amazingly it looks like Helen may not sack Peters at all now, three journalists have their say. First Audrey Young compares the testimonies:

There is one piece of evidence that could possibly salvage Peters and Henry and that is a record of a phone call, if one existed, from Henry to Glenn in the last three months of 2005.

It would not be hard for Henry to authorise his phone company to release that to the committee in order to save his “blood brother” and himself.

Any half decent lawyer would have produced this weeks ago. Actual evidence, as oppossed to conspiracy theories, are what is needed. If such evidence is produced, I suggest the Privileges Committee should ask the phone company in question to authenticate the evidence.

Doubtless there are some holes in the testimony of both Glenn and Peters but on the whole, you could drive a Tonka toy through Glenn’s and a Mack through Peters’.

Nicely put.

Peters suggested that just because some people at a lunch at the Karaka sales did not hear Peters thank Glenn for his donation, then he couldn’t have thanked him.

Or that because Peters has good manners (well, especially where wealthy folk are concerned) if he had known about the donation he would have thanked Glenn for it.

Yep, that was his serious argument. That he would have thanked Owen earlier than Karaka if he knew of the donation. This is why I compared it to a five year old.

Once Clark reads the transcript of the hearing, she will see that Peters does not really have a defence.

Or just read the NZPA story on how he gave three different explanations during the one session.

Colin Espiner blogs:

The difference between his testimony before the committee and that of Owen Glenn was stark. Glenn relied on facts – emails, phone logs, sworn statements from witnesses. He went through his evidence carefully and methodically. He answered questions directly, without embellishment. There was no exaggeration. He stuck to his story. He was a very credible witness.

Peters, on the other hand, led the committee a merry dance. He disputed virtually every point of Glenn’s evidence, but with nothing besides his own self-described faulty memory to back up his evidence. There were no phone logs, no emails, and only a statement from his own lawyer in his defence – and even that appeared to contradict Peters’ evidence to the committee.

On television later that night, Peters looked half-way believable in the short clips that were shown. But to sit there and watch him desperately try to explain why his lawyer Brian Henry had emailed Glenn with his bank account details just minutes after Peters had finished speaking to the billionaire was to witness a drowning man gasping for air.

He floundered, he splashed, he spluttered. But in the end Peters simply couldn’t find any credible explanation for Glenn’s hard evidence. The best he could come up with was that he might have told Henry to email Glenn, at Glenn’s request, but he had no idea why or what for and didn’t think it proper to ask.

Frankly, if the committee members believe that then they also believe in the tooth fairy.

Yet Helen still clings on to Winston.

And Bill Ralston:

He admits having a phone conversation with Glenn but cannot recall if money was discussed. In fact he thinks they didn’t discuss money. What then did they talk about? He cannot recall.

Within minutes of that phone call Brian Henry, on the advice of his “client”, emailed Glenn with bank account details for the money to be paid. Peters has no idea whom the “client” might be that Henry refers to and no idea why Henry might be sending bank account details to Glenn.

This is just nuts. Compared with the clear concise testimony given by Glenn to the committee, backed by physical evidence, Winston Peters’ statements lack any credibility and he produced no physical evidence to rebut Glenn.

Nuts indeed.

It makes Richard Nixon look like the model of integrity and truth.

A second medal

Well done to Paula Tesoriero for winning a bronze paralympics medal to go with her gold. And she didn’t do a face plant this time!

Her final race is tomorrow – the 25 km road race.

A reminder that friends and fans of Paula can vote for her on the TVNZ site. The paralympian with the most votes wins a Mitsubishi Outlander and everyone who votes goes into a draw to win one themselves.

The 2008 dog toy poll

Most readers will recall around a decade ago Masterpet produced the very popular Winston Peters and Paul Homes dog toys. They took the country by storm, and even today you see them pop up on Trade Me.

Well I’m pleased to announce that Masterpet have brought the toys back for the 2008 election, and both Helen and John get a toy of their own.

Now Masterpet, sharing Kiwiblog’s sense of humour, has decided to turn the dog toys into an election poll. They will be providing regular sales figures to Kiwiblog, and we’ll be doing updates to see which politician is the most popular with the pets!

This is non-commercial on my part. I’m taking part because it is good fun. And Masterpet is not endorsing my political leanings – they chose Kiwiblog as the readers here seem to enjoy the lighter side of politics.

So all you dog owners out there, you can buy a John toy or a Helen toy for less than $10 at speciality pet stores and vet clinics as well as selected supermarkets. They sold out quickly last time, so it may be a fun race to see who can sell out first. And every toy sold will count as a pet vote for that MP.

Masterpet has provided some tips for dog owners:

  1. Remember your purchase is part of a political poll – your vote counts
  2. Wear suitable ear protection when supervising your dog’s playtime with the toy. As with real politicians, the squealing can become quite deafening.
  3. Keep dog on a leash if around real politicians. Masterpet does not accept any liability for dog toy mistaken identity.
  4. When choosing a toy, take your dog along with you. Man’s best friend doesn’t like political ideologies thrust upon him/her more than the next person.
  5. If your dog destroys the politician in the first five minutes don’t hold this against your dog – the media do it every week!

I did also ask Masterpet why they only did a Helen and John dog toy, as a Winston toy could well prove popular again. Their response was:

As the leaders of the two major parties, it’s pretty much guaranteed that Helen or John will become next Prime Minister. We considered producing another Winston Peters like we did in 1997 but felt, given recent events, he‘s already destined to become ‘dog tucker’.

Heh.

I should receive the first set of sales figures on Monday, so the first poll results will be Monday or Tuesday next week. Let the pets decide!

NZPA on Winston’s contradictions

NZPA have done an excellent job detailing how Winston couldn’t even keep to the one line, last night.  Very good research on their part to go through the transcripts and recordings. They say:

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters last night gave several different positions on the crucial phone call and email at the centre of the conflict between he and billionaire Owen Glenn’s testimony….

Mr Peters’ responses

1. He said money was not discussed in the call and he did not recollect Mr Glenn asking for Mr Henry’s bank details, but conceded the latter was possible.

“That’s the only logical conclusion that one can come to. That he (Glenn) asked for the details and that’s why it is mentioned in the email.”

He said it was “fair” to presume Mr Henry was talking about him when he referred to “my client” in his email.

2. At another point he said he believed Mr Henry’s reference may have related to another client who had solicited the donation in an earlier call.

“Mr Henry … in his last evidence to you points out that the person involved in the set up of Mr Glenn making this donation was not Winston Peters. That’s the light in which you should see that email. That’s the only conclusion I can come to.”

But he appeared to contradict that by arguing it was Mr Henry who initially solicited the donation from Mr Glenn.

“I believe now that Mr Henry had called him on 5th of December to solicit the funds.”

Mr Henry himself has in letters to the committee — most recently three days ago, before the full email was revealed — asserted the client referred to in the email is not Mr Peters.

3. Mr Peters also said the email did not refer to his conversation with Mr Glenn as it referred to a call made at 1.30, whereas Mr Glenn’s six-minute call to him started at 1.26.

This is why people who were there labeled it pathetic. It was grasping for straws.

Mind you looking at Labour in the House today attacking Owen Glenn and agreeing with Winston, I have to say I think Helen may be now moving to keep Peters on.