Campbell interviews Dunne

Scoop’s Gordon Campbell continues his series of interviews with party leaders. This one is with Peter Dunne.

Campbell: The evidence for the prosecution would be the story that you started reading Hansard when you were twelve –

Dunne : Fourteen.

Good God, I didn’t start until university!

Campbell: Do you think any of the Christian-based parties will cross the 5 % threshold this year?

Dunne : No. United Future is not in that camp, not any more.

Campbell: You’ve been through your prayer meeting phase ?

Dunne : Well, we were never really in it. I certainly wasn’t. But we had some people who imagined that United Future could become New Zealand’s version of the Taliban.

Harsh rhetoric, but similar to what Mark Blumsky said, based on his experiences there also.

Dunne: Yes, and my own view is, that in today’s circumstances for a whole variety of reasons, technology being amongst them, the procedure of a woman, her doctor and two certifying consultants is somewhat cumbersome. I think probably, you should be looking at the woman, her doctor and informed consent. I have a very strong view that – and I appreciate the moral issue involved here – but the moral issue is actually the individual’s morals. I don’t think it’s a matter of the state imposing a moral code. I mean, there is a moral dimension as to whether you should have an abortion and that issue is still there – but that’s not a call that the state should be seeking to make on behalf of the people involved.

A pretty sensible view in my opinion.

Campbell: You’ve governed with Roger Douglas before. Would you like to again?

Dunne : No.

Campbell: Why not?

Dunne : Roger was dynamic to work with in the circumstances of the 1980s, which was big ideas, bold change et etc. The problem with Roger and the whole Act Party is that they’re trapped in a time warp, at the point when Roger was sacked. The world has moved on. The implicit mantra is that if we all went back to 1987 and picked up where we left off, things would be different. Its rubbish.

ACT people won’t like this, but Dunne does have a point here. There is sometimes a lack of reality about where NZ is at today, as compared to 20 years ago. The sense of crisis of the 1980s is not the same challenges we face today.

Campbell: If the Emissions Trading Scheme involves any extra costs whatsoever to taxpayers, would you oppose it?

Dunne : I want to know what those extra costs are, for a start.

Campbell: Understood. But from your statements, it sounds as if there is anything at all extra on household costs. you will oppose –

Dunne : If there’s anything extra that is not properly compensated then yes, we would oppose it.

Pretty clear.

Campbell: Is there one thing left that you want to achieve before you leave Parliament ?

Dunne : My personal biggest ambition in whatever time remains to me is the whole question of national identity, constitutional change and the path towards a republic. On the weekend I set out a timetable by which we could, if not get there, at last resolve the issues…. by 2017.

And that would be good. Labour’s shattering on the constitutional conventions over electoral law have pushed me 100% towards supporting a written constitution, to safeguard fundamental rights.

The UN Human Rights Commission 9/11 conspiracy appointment

The NZ Herald carries an NZPA story on NZ’s campaign website for a seat on the Human Rights Council. Again, we should avoid any involvement with this body.

The Human Rights Council has appointed Richard Falk to a six year term as a special investigator on Israel. Falk is ideal for the job because he believes suicide bombing is a human right, and also wrote the preface for a 9/11 conspiracy book. You know the ones which say 9/11 was really done by the US Government.

But after Falk compared Israel to the Nazis, you knew his appointment was guaranteed. The Times looks at what this means:

… let’s say, for one moment, that the objective of the Human Rights Council was actually to improve human rights in, let’s further say, the occupied territories. Would you employ someone who has made utterances that ensure that all of Israeli public opinion – including that part critical of its Government – would unite 100 per cent to resist him? Of course you wouldn’t.

The implication of this logic is simple. The UN Human Rights Council doesn’t give a toss about the human rights of the Palestinians in the sense of wanting them upheld. Its majority is far more interested in using Israel as a stick to beat the US with, or – in the case of Islamic states – as a bogeyman to dampen down domestic discontent.

This is the core point. The Human rights Council has no interest in improving human rights.

So Falk thinks 9/11 was an inside job, supports suicide bombing and compares Israel to Nazi Germany. What other views does he have:

In a February 16, 1979, op-ed for the New York Times, Mr. Falk praised Ayatollah Khomeini and bemoaned his ill treatment in the American press. He wrote, “The depiction of him as fanatical, reactionary and the bearer of crude prejudices seems certainly and happily false.

The NY Sun goes on to note a few months later 52 diplomats were taken hostage for 444 days.

Dom Post on Winston’s donations

The Dom Post editorial does not approve of the secret donations:

Lest anyone has forgotten, it should be remembered that the donation is not a donation in the commonly understood sense of the word. It is NZ First’s response to having been caught misspending $158,000 of public money during the 2005 election campaign. …

But giving $158,000, taken from the public purse, to outside organisations does not constitute repayment of a debt. Nor does refusing to name the recipients, something he had previously undertaken to do, lend credibility to the exercise. Mr Peters says he has decided not to name the charities because he does not want them bothered by the “prying media”.

That is a one-fingered salute to those who hold to the quaint notion that politicians should be accountable for how they spend public money.

It is also unsatisfactory. Who is to say that NZ First does not regard the Re-elect Winston Campaign in Tauranga or, for that matter, NZ First itself, as charities?

By retrospectively changing the law, the Government obviated the legal requirement for politicians to repay the money they unlawfully spent. But the moral obligation to comply with the law of the day remains. NZ First has not met it.

If no other benefit arises, Mr Peters’ reluctance to do the right thing serves as a useful reminder of how a politician positioning himself to once again act as a post-election kingmaker, operates.

Mr Peters has made a reasonable fist of being foreign minister, though as a minister outside Cabinet who opposes New Zealand’s landmark free trade deal with China he is an international oddity. But voters know he remains a law unto himself and one whose principal priority appears to be to ensure he is reinstalled as foreign minister whichever party heads the next government.

Says it all really.

How will Labour get the votes for the ETS?

Labour has 49 votes and needs 61. Add on Jim Anderton and you are at 50.

NZ First will back the scheme. They will mainly be looking for some payoffs for their support base. This gets Labour to 57 votes.

The only way to get to 61 from there is either the Maori Party (4) or the Green Party (6). Taito Phillip Field by himself makes no difference.

The Maori Party is facing great pressure from Maori forest and land owners. The select committee has said it agrees with some of their concerns but has mainly left it to future Ministers to set regulations, rather than guarantee things in the legislation- and I am not sure that will be enough.

The Greens are asking for agriculture and energy sectors to enter the ETS at an earlier date. It is hard to see the Government agreeing to either of these, so the question is will the Greens blink first and support the scheme even if they gain only tokenistic changes?

The Herald covers some of the issues.

Colin Espiner in The Press labels the ETS a “big green cash machine”

Treasury figures released yesterday show officials expect the Government to reap $21 billion from its controversial emissions trading scheme (ETS) over the next 20 years and it could make as much as $42.6b under some scenarios. …

The projections show that by 2030 the Government’s coffers could swell by up to $42b assuming a carbon price of $100 a tonne. …

Ironically, the worse the country performs at meeting its Kyoto commitments the more money the Government makes, since industry would be forced to buy more carbon credits.

NZ has no chance at all of meeting its Kyoto commitments, so I would look for those windfall profits to occur, if it is passed in its current form.

Blog Bits

Barnsley Bill blogs on the 35 kg stone which was flown first class to China as it was culturally insensitive to have it in the hold.

Frog Blog has a look at parties on Facebook. Frog has even found a Winston for PM group – but with slightly less members than the Bring back the Good Night Kiwi group.

American Thinker mentions NZ’s Trevor Loudon, and his work on Obama’s past.

Dim-Post looks at the options for Labour with the ETS:

  1. Rush the hastily amended, highly complex legislation into law by buying off the Greens and Winston Peters, paying a high political price now and ensuring at least six months of dire headlines as horrible mistakes and unintended consequences in the law are bought to light repeatedly embarrassing the government right in the middle of an election campaign they’re already losing.
  2. Admit the bill is dead and face a couple of days bad news focusing on the failure (which you can mostly blame on National).

And his prediction:

Scenarios like this are when Clark’s ultra-competitive personality undermine her own self-interest and that of her party – she’ll press for a parliamentary victory even if it is spectacularly pyrrhic one.

NZ’s campaign to join the abusers on the Human Rights Council

There are many worthy bodies in the UN system, that we can and should participate in. Our last spell on the Security Council was excellent for NZ and good for the UN.

However the Human Rights Council is a body we should be avoiding. Even the UN Secretary General has criticised it. Within just months it is becoming as discredited as its predecessor body. This is because they watered down all the reforms.

We can achieve nothing of use on this body. We will just get to condemn Israel several times a day, ignore Sudan, Zimbabwe and Syria and get to join Iran in telling off the United Kingdom for its treatment of women.

To my horror, not only is New Zealand standing for a spot on the Human Rights Council, we are actively campaigning for it, and have the campaign website.

Now at first I thought it was a joke – would we really use text messaging type English for a domain name of votenz4hrc.org. But alas it is a real genuine site.

The only way to reform the Human Rights Council is to deny it legitimacy by refusing to participate until it does genuine reform. Changing from within totally failed with its predecessor.

I’m tempted to start a “Do Note Vote for NZ” campaign. Not because NZ doesn’t have an excellent record on human rights, but because I don’t want that excellent record to lend legitimacy to a Council which is home to some of the worse abusers, and fails consistently to confront countries like Zimbabwe as the Government there is literally murdering its opponents.

How much money is being spent by MFAT on the campaign to win a seat? I can think of much better uses for it!

National on ETS Bill

Some quotes and comments from National’s minority report (included in the select committee report):

The National Cabinet in 1999 decided that an ETS was the right way forward on climate change policy. We expressed concern when the ETS approach was dropped in favour of a carbon tax when the current Government took office. We promoted an ETS in our Bluegreen Vision document in 2006. We supported the Government’s decision, in principle, in favour of an ETS last year and voted for the first reading of this Bill. However, the rushed legislative process has resulted in a Bill that has major deficiencies.

I have to say that I am not sure a carbon tax wouldn’t have been the better short-term measure. The problem with the one the Government proposed is it was punishing people for their debits and refusing to give people anything for their credits (ie forestry).

The importance of getting this legislation right cannot be overstated. This Bill represents the most significant economic reform since the deregulation of the economy in the late 1980s. The NZIER analysis indicates that the ETS in its current form will cost 22,000 jobs and a loss of $900 million to the economy by 2012 and a loss of $5.9 billion in GDP by 2025. The Government’s own analysis by Infometrics concludes job losses of 50,000 from the scheme.

And unemployment is forecast to reach 6%, even without this.

Committee members received over 1000 amendments to this 237 page Bill only three days prior to its final deliberation. There has been no serious engagement by Government members on the critical issues to New Zealand in this Bill, as evidenced by the 24 different Government members that have subbed onto the Committee throughout the process.

Just like the EFA.

ETS should be designed around the more modest goal of ensuring New Zealand does its fair share in reducing global greenhouse gas emissions.

That is why National has advocated, in contrast to the Government’s goal of carbon neutrality, a 50% reduction in New Zealand’s 1990 greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. This goal is in line with that of the new Australian Government which is committed to a 60% reduction in emissions from 2000 levels by 2050, and that proposed by US presidential candidates. National believes our -50% by 2050 goal should be included in the purpose clause of the Bill.

There is zero benefit in being more pure than the rest of the world. We absolutely do not want to be a laggard, as there are serious trade risks with doing so. But punishing NZ families just so one canpick up UN awards is crazy.

National’s second concern is the windfall profits to the Government from the way this ETS is designed. Officials have advised the committee that the scheme will generate an estimated $21 billion in revenue to the Government from the sale of emission permits. This is double that provided in the Budget 2008 tax reductions.

He giveth with one hand and taketh away with the other. To be fair I think the $21 billion is over a longer period than the tax reduction costing. But nevertheless it should be revenue neutral in my opinion.

There are also additional indirect windfall gains to Government from its electricity State Owned Enterprises. Meridian has advised the Committee of an increase of $750 million in its valuation as a consequence of the ETS. Including Mighty River Power, the windfall gain to the Government from it SOEs will be in excess of $1 billion. This is significantly greater than the latest projection of New Zealand’s Kyoto liability at $481.6 million.

Down with the greedy power generator owners. Oh, wait – they’re the Government.

Climate change is not an excuse for the Government to profit at the expense of businesses and consumers who are already under budgetary pressure. The scheme can and should be redesigned to be fiscally neutral by transparently returning any windfall profits from the ETS to consumers and taxpayers.

Sounds a good principle

National’s fifth concern is that the Bill discriminates against SMEs that will not be eligible for free allocation of emissions units. New Zealand is very dependent on SMEs for its economic strength and the design of the ETS needs to better recognise them. The initial proposal of a 50,000 annual tonne threshold would eliminate all but New Zealand’s largest emitting industries. The Committee discussed a lower threshold but no decision was made and the question has been left to regulations. This issue is too important to the successful functioning of New Zealand’s ETS to be deferred. Parliament needs to take a direct interest in the competitiveness and survival of our SMEs.

Hmmn so Labour and Greens are supporting a bill which gives free allocations to big businesses but nothing to small businesses. Will Winston vote for this also?

The Bill fails to resolve the issue of how to deal with the uncertainties in the estimate of animal emissions that officials advised may vary from 50% above or below estimates. A market cannot function efficiently with this level of estimate uncertainty. The Bill fails to resolve the issue of whether the point of obligation is to be at farmer or processor level. This is a fundamental design issue that needs resolution by Parliament rather than being deferred to regulations. It is as though New Zealand wants the international accolades for a comprehensive ETS when it is just a shell with none of the necessary machinery to make it function. It is all very well in theory to have agriculture included in the ETS but the detail needs to be worked through so Parliament can be confident it will work in practice.

In other words we just want to pass the law before the election, even though vital details are being left undecided.

New Zealand’s fishing industry exports 92% of its output, earning $1.3 billion per annum. It is an energy intensive sector with fuel making up around 40% of the operating costs of vessels. The Bill provides for an allocation of units to sectors such as dairy, meat, cement, steel, forestry and aluminium, but excludes the fishing industry. This arbitrary exclusion does not seem well justified.

A further concern is the incentive to use foreign fishing vessels that will not face the cost of the ETS for imported fuel. The 1980s and 1990s saw a decline in the use of foreign fishing vessels and crew to New Zealand’s advantage. This has reversed over the last five years. This Bill may inadvertently encourage ongoing job losses for New Zealanders and the replacement by foreign vessels. The last minute amendments to address this problem are inadequate.

Our ETS is going to be great news for foreign competitors.

Electricity is a sector in which the Government’s climate change policies have failed. Far from moving New Zealand towards the goal of 90% renewables, the proportion has fallen from 72% in 1999 to 66% in 2007.

Yep.

National’s first concern is security of supply. Many submitters from industry believed the moratorium would put this in jeopardy. That these provisions are being advanced in the middle of a winter power crisis defies common sense.

Repeat after Mr Parker – there is no crisis.

The distinction in the Bill between new power stations being either base load or peak load is nonsensical. Ironically, New Zealand’s biggest greenhouse gas emitter, Huntly, was built as a peak load station in 1987, and technically another could be built under the exemptions in this Bill.

The Greens have said much the same thing, even though they support the ban.

National sees no place in New Zealand for any new coal generation until such time as carbon sequestration technology becomes viable.

Makes sense.

The smart way to provide an incentive for renewable energy over thermal generation is through the price signal of an ETS. That is why we have consistently advocated that electricity be the first sector to be introduced to an ETS. It provides a signal every day to the electricity sector to favour renewable over thermal, and not just when building. It avoids the artificial distinctions between peak and base load stations. The ETS will encourage substitution for more efficient thermal generation where possible, and for the earlier retirement of old, dirty technology. It is noteworthy that renewable generator Meridian and the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment have rejected the moratorium.

The trouble is having a ban fits much better on a pledge card.

National supports the 90% renewable energy target. We have confidence that the pricing signal of the ETS, as well as National’s proposed reforms of the Resource Management Act, will give the impetus to new renewable generation without the arbitrary and inefficient moratorium proposal in this Bill.

Once the RMA is reformed, then renewable energy projects can be built quicker, and that will be the best way to reduce demand for thermal power.

This Bill requires substantial amendment if New Zealand is to have a workable emissions trading scheme. National cannot support it in its current form. The Government decision to defer implementation by two years means there is time to get this legislation right without having to delay implementation.

Exactly – there is no rush.

The correct way forward is for the Government to table a substantive amending SOP in Parliament to address the major concerns with the Bill. These amendments should be sent alongside the existing Bill back to the Select Committee for submissions, careful analysis and final deliberation. The Bill should then be advanced through its second and third readings. It would be possible to conclude this process prior to the General Election but it is more likely to be done properly in the less politically charged post election period.

Politically it would be easier for National to have the ETS passed under Labour as it could blame them for anything that goes wrong.

National will proceed with an ETS amended in line with this minority report if we are successful at this year’s general election. We would work as co-operatively as possible with other political parties to achieve this. Our objective is a widely supported and robust ETS that will deliver on New Zealand’s ambitions for a responsible approach to climate change and a strong economy.

Even if Labour passes the ETS before the election, it would make sense for National to amend it afterwards to cover those areas of concern such as Government profiteering from it.

Climate Change ETS Bill reported back

The Government’s Climate Change (Emissions Trading and Renewable Preference) bill has been reported back by the Finance and Expenditure Select Committee.  It is 328 pages long and has over 1,000 amendments which means the Government will of course try and pass it as quickly as possible.

Even the commentary to explain the changes takes up over 50 pages. This is the biggest change to our economy since GST I would say, and it is silly to rush it through because of the election, instead of making sure it is right.

Look what happened to the Electoral Finance Act when they didn’t allow submissions on the revised bill? They are going to make the same mistake again. The changes from the original bill are significant enough that stakeholders should be given a chance to have their say on them.

It is worth remembering that the Government has already delayed the effective implementation of the ETS until 2011 (except for Foresty), so we have lots of time to get the ETS right. There is a difference between delaying the Bill and delaying the ETS itself.

Treaty Settlements Ministers

Grant Robertson comments on the suggestion by Te Pumautanga o Te Arawa that all future Finance Ministers should also be Treaty Negotiation Ministers also.

Dr Cullen has made admirable progress, and should be congratulated for it. I suspect his job was made easier by the fact that he got to replace Mark Burton who showed the same skills at Treaty Negotiations as he did with Electoral Finance.

I would not tie the job into the Finance Minister job (even though Bill English would do a fine job) but I agree with Grant you do want Ministers who are motivated to do the job and have some mana. National has at least three people who could contribute very well to the portfolio.

Chris Finlayson is the current spokesperson and has worked in the Treaty area professionally before he entered Parliament, and has good relations with many prominent Iwi leaders. Georgina te Heuheu is a former member of the Waitangi Tribunal, and was NZ’s first female Maori lawyer. The other person whom I would advocate should be included (I think the portfolio is important enough one should have one or maybe two associate Ministers) is Tim Groser. Tim is a highly experienced negotiator in the trade field, and at the end of the day a large component of Treaty settlements is a commercial negotiation.

Firefox Download Day 2008

Mozilla wants to set a world record for most downloaded software in 24 hours, with its release of Firefox 3.0 on 17 June 2008.

Download Day 2008

Follow the link above, and register (takes 5 seconds) to be part of World Download Day. You will then get an e-mail when Firefox 3.0 is available for download.

Those already with Firefox will need little encouraging to get the latest version. A great opportunity for IE users to take a step up. You’ll just love the plugins etc.

Hat Tip: Dave Gee

Fed Farmers

Congratulations to Conor English on his appointment as CEO of Federated Farmers. Conor is a former CEO of the Property Institute, and has a farming background.

Conor is one of Bill’s many brothers. He is of course his own man, and people should not assume their politics are identical. Conor, if I recall correctly, has none of those left wing tendencies that Bill occasionally gets 🙂

Hat Tip: The Hive

Winston on Agenda

The interview with Winston Peters on Agenda was quite fascinating, and worth going through in detail. He seemed to be at great pains to get across the message that his criticisms of National in no way mean he can’t support them forming a Government after the election.

Of course my view on having a Government reliant on Winston is akin to receiving chemotherapy. It’s damn painful and nasty, but slightly preferable to dying 🙂

Now let us look at the interview:

GUYON ESPINER
Well Winston Peters let’s cut to the chase on that question will you be contesting the Tauranga seat?

WINSTON PETERS – Leader, New Zealand First
Look the New Zealand First Party’s about to announce a tranch of candidates right around the country that’s part of our public relations strategy and we’ll have to wait until then.

This makes it quite clear that the decisions have been made, and it is just a matter of PR that it is not yet announced. With this in mind I have now listed Peters as a candidate for Tauranga in my 2008 Candidates list.

GUYON Okay will the public get to know who those charities are?

WINSTON Look I wrote to the Speaker with the full list and the letters of introduction to those charities, if the Speaker wants you to find out that’s fine but I do not think that they should become the victims of snooping prying media interest.

The Speaker has stated she wants Parliament more open and parts of it come under the Official Information Act. So in good faith I expect her to make the list available.

GUYON Are you perhaps hinting that you’ve done your work in that portfolio and maybe want to move on to something else?

WINSTON No I’m merely hinting that I found it an exciting challenge and an enormously difficult complex job both in getting the resources for this country to have for the first time for a long time the capacity to properly image sell itself and help our exporters, has been a great victory and I’m pleased about that, but I wouldn’t want to see it challenged because we’ve barely got back to where we were when Tallboys had the job. What’s sad is what happened in between in terms of lack of resourcing.

The reference to Talboys is interesting. Peters at his heart is a Muldoonist – authoritarian on both economic and social issues. He sees the late 70s as a golden era and rejects most things post-Muldoon such as Asian immigration, asset sales, free trade, monetary policy etc. This is why he attracts older voters – they like him hark back to the 70s. Winston’s aim is to turn the clock back. And like his mentor, Muldoon, he makes expensive promises to retried persons regardless of whether the country can afford them.

GUYON In 2005 it was the same in that you went with the largest party and formed a government which had the fewest number of parties within it, now is that your stance going into this election again?

WINSTON Well I think that the more parties you have the more problems you’re going to have and the real difficulty in New Zealand politics today is that not enough people have learnt that as much as this glamorous romantic talk about doing your own thing and going your own way, the people of this country want a government, they might criticise the government all the time but what distinguishes New Zealand as a first world country is that it has a stability about it, even in this present circumstance and fewer parties makes that easier to happen.

I have always said this was a major factor for his 1996 decision. He preferred a two party arrangement to a three party arrangement with the Alliance also. On current polls Labour could only possibly form a Government with the Greens, Maori Party and NZ First. That means Winston would be just one of four significant parties in Government.

GUYON I want to get this very clear because there are people, journalists, members of the public, who listen to you in parliament, they listen to you criticise the National Party and think oh he couldn’t work with them, but I just want to get it very clear that your position is based not on personalities but that you again on what you call the constitutional convention with the largest party has the first right to form a government. …

WINSTON Just because you’re reminding people of who did what where and when and making sure the voters don’t forget what might happen in the future because of things in the past doesn’t mean that you are necessarily not going to go into some sort of a governing arrangement with people.

I took that to be unusually clear, and significant.

RAWDON We’re now here with the panel to continue the question line. I just want to start off Minister and ask you that hypothetically come coalition talks what sort of concessions will you be asking for National and will they include the team who’s there, you were just talking about the 90s team?

WINSTON Well look you can’t start telling some other party how to organise its internal operations that’s not what the discussion’s about, in fact it’s an unacceptable way of approaching negotiations, so most certainly I’m not, I’m just making the comment that that is what the difficulty John Key faces as at the moment.

Again, pretty clear. He does not like the MPs from the last Government, but in no way if he saying he won’t work with them.

JOHN ROUGHAN – New Zealand Herald
You were asked I think about whether you would still talk first to the party that wins the most votes at the election.

WINSTON I wasn’t but the answer’s yes I will.

JOHN` You would. Talk first but not necessarily go into coalition with that winning party if you like?

WINSTON Well no party says that or we have said any party that is in our position has – and that goes for the other parties as well – has had more than one proviso.

Now Peters is correct one can not give a guarantee that one will support the largest party, because you then destroy all your negotiating ability. So what does talk to first mean?

The cynical say it means you start negotiations with the largest party 30 minutes before you start negotiations with the second largest. I don’t think that will happen though. People will expect to see a serious attempt at forming a Government with the largest party. But it may of course just not be possible. The economy may be so weak that an incoming Government can’t meet the spending promises that Winston will want.

COLIN ESPINER – Christchurch Press
But they have Mr Peters just listened to you say some fairly negative things about National and it’s well known that you have some problems with people on their front bench. Now let’s look at the polls…

WINSTON No no I don’t have problems with people on their front bench, I have problems with their past record and what they believe, I’ve given you examples.

Again, he goes out of his way to make the difference clear.

JOHN How much change would you make to the Act then, would you completely widen the criteria for the Reserve Bank or would you take the Reserve Bank’s authority away altogether.?

WINSTON I’d change the export, I’d change his criteria to ensure that unlike the policy ties agreement that Dr Cullen and I tried to write for him which in my view ignored, he must have regard to economic growth, he must have regard to exports, he must have regard to employment and the general health of the economy as much as inflation …

That’s also pretty significant. He has just accused Dr Bollard of being in breach of the Policy Target Agreement.

Ironically I think Dr Bollard is in breach also – for not keeping inflation low enough, while Winston thinks he is in breach for not keeping inflation high enough!

RAWDON Do you think an embassy in Stockholm’s a good investment?

WINSTON Of course it’s a great investment it’ll pay off hugely in time, and very quickly, here are from Iceland all the way to Finland five of the world’s most successful economies in one place, why would we not be part of that market when we’ve got so many similar values to them. We have not made the investment in the past, I can remember Tallboys trying to advocate to the National Party way back in 1971 that they must do this, I’ve picked up the message I hope they have.

Note the harking back to the 70s again.

Broadband performance

The Commerce Commission report on broadband performance in Q1 of 2008 is here.

The retail market shares are:

  1. Telecom 65%
  2. TelstraClear 11.5%
  3. Vodafone 9.7%
  4. Orcon 7.2%
  5. Slingshot 6.5%

The best city in terms of broadband performance was Hamilton with Auckland and Dunedin 2nd=, then Wellington and Christchurch. Here are the top five for each city in order:

Auckland

  1. TelstraClear DSL
  2. MaxNet
  3. Kiwi Online
  4. Inspire
  5. WorldxChange

Hamilton

  1. Orcon
  2. Compass
  3. WorldxChange
  4. Telecom
  5. Slingshot

Wellington

  1. TelstraClear Cable
  2. MaxNet
  3. Inspire Net
  4. TelstraClear DSL
  5. Actrix

Christchurch

  1. TelstraClear Cable
  2. Snap
  3. MaxNet
  4. WorldxChange
  5. Inspire Net

Dunedin

  1. Orcon
  2. Compass
  3. Telecom
  4. WorldxChange
  5. Vodafone

They do not just mention speed, but a variety of performance indicators.

My home connection in Wellington is with Ihug, now Vodafone. They are third lowest in Wellington and I do have to say since they were taken over I have found the performance disappointing. I love their mobile products, but may look at moving my home connection at some stage.

Govt tries to do something on petrol

In a fairly desperate attempt to look like it is doing something, the Government has said there will be an inquiry into petrol prices – an inquiry that has oh no terms of reference and no chair (they say one has been appointed but his or her name is a secret!).

The Government is also looking at a Fuelwatch scheme where oil companies post tomorrow’s prices on a website. This is based on the Australian scheme. Well people should be aware of the controversy in Australia over the scheme.

In some rural areas it may lead to higher fuel prices! And what does the Federal Resources Minister say on the scheme:

The debate flared today after the leaking of a letter sledging the Federal Government’s Fuel Watch scheme by Resources Minister Martin Ferguson.

Mr Ferguson slammed FuelWatch as an anti-competitive waste of money in a letter sent to Consumer Affairs Minister Chris Bowen and copied to Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, Treasurer Wayne Swan and Finance Minister Lindsay Tanner.

And more from Ferguson:

“Your assertion that Fuel Watch will be pro-competitive is unsubstantiated and ignored the very substantial evidence that it is anti-competitive,” Mr Ferguson wrote. “I remain more concerned about the substantive elements of Fuel Watch, which I believe will seriously damage the Government’s economic and regulatory reform credentials.” …

Mr Ferguson wrote that independent service station owners in Perth had opposed Fuel Watch and that since it had been introduced, some had gone out of business.

If Fuel Watch is the answer, then we are asking the wrong questions.

The reality is that movements in the global price are far far larger than any local costs and/or taxes. Rather than trying to dupe consumers that there is some silver bullet, we need to make sure people can afford the cost of petrol which means higher after tax income.

Winston says he has made 10 secret donations to charities

Newsroom reports that Winston has stated that NZ First has made $158,000 in secret donations to charities, in lieu of paying The Parliamentary Service as all other parliamentary parties have done in relation to spending identified by the Auditor-General as illegal.

The party set about donating the money to other charities and it is understood that up to 10 have received a slice of the money after approaching the party.

NZ First is not intending to publicly name the charities so they are not put under pressure for accepting the money, but it has provided the list to Ms Wilson.

However nothing stops the media from asking various charities if they have accepted money from NZ First.

So NZ First is the party of transparency which receives secret donations, that then turn out not be a donation at all, and also makes secret donations.

Bank economists

After Michael Cullen attacked bank economists as talking up their own banks’ interests, the SST has looked at whether it is true. Extracts:

“It’s absolute bollocks,” says Westpac chief economist Brendan O’Donovan. If bank economists were seen to be always trying to talk their business up “and not talking the reality of the situation, then our credibility’s out the door and no one will listen to anything we say”. …

BNZ chief economist Tony Alexander says some of the policies he publicly espouses are not in the bank’s interests. He advocates a fixed interest rate levy, which increases whenever the Reserve Bank puts up interest rates. This effectively removes fixed interest rates. …

ANZ chief economist Cameron Bagrie says the material produced by the bank’s economists “is not the bank’s thinking. No, it comes out of the economics team led by myself but it’s not reviewed by a higher order of the bank”.

The team had to give its customers honest forecasts. Sometimes the bank management had “grimaced” at some of his statements. …

The bank economists’ case gets support from a perhaps unexpected corner Council of Trade Unions (CTU) economist Peter Conway. …

One reason the bank economists got a lot of media attention, Conway says, was that they were “very good”. They had a lot of resources and could quickly produce well-informed commentaries on a variety of subjects.

Bank economists clearly have some constraints on their freedom to speak, but so do other economists. Conway can’t publicly criticise the economic position of the CTU. Reporters, says Conway, need to “shop around” and get the views of economists from a variety of backgrounds.

In other words Dr Cullen was shooting the messengers.

Congratulations Nick

North & South survey

The Herald on Sunday has some amusing results from a survey commissioned by North & South

  • 28% name Key most attractive to the opposite sex
  • Jeanette Fitzsimons most popular choice of babysitter
  • Winston Peters most popular dinner guest but also most likely to stab you in the back (probably at the same party!)
  • Petrol prices are greatest concern
  • Combined Maori and English version of the National Anthem is preferred

Ralston on Peters

Bill Ralston sees an end:

You can never write off Winston Peters. That well worn cliche is trotted out by commentators at every election. Except, this election, I believe at last we can write off Peters. I suspect even he is no longer confident of ever again being “happy as the MP for Tauranga” and at age 63, he is wistfully eyeing the prospect of retirement from politics in October.

I would just make the point that not winning Tauranga does not mean retirement for Peters if his party makes 5%.

National has just selected its candidate for Tauranga, Simon Bridges, the party’s electorate chairman and a Crown prosecutor. He is half Peters’ age.

Bridges’ youth neatly underlines the fact that Peters is a political dinosaur, a throw-back to the era of his mentor and role model, Rob Muldoon. Bridges was barely born when Muldoon was Prime Minister and Winston was first on the hustings.

That National is willing to put up someone more than just a lame stooge means it is serious about winning the electorate and it is confident Peters and New Zealand First are dog tucker.

National certainly is serious about winning the electorate. The outcome is of course up to the voters.

There is an air of desperation about the New Zealand First leader these days, as if he senses his old magic is no longer working. He and his party have repeatedly tried to pull the race card, particularly on immigration, but for once have found little response from the electorate.

However, it does not stop Peters having a knee-jerk reaction any time anyone mentions foreigners in a positive way.

Indeed.

Peters seems unable to comprehend the statistics that show migrants have a higher rate of employment, higher incomes, pay more tax and are less likely to go to prison or get a social services benefit than the average Kiwi.

His anti-Asian rhetoric, which was so politically advantageous in the 1990s, is increasingly falling on deaf ears. Over the past couple of decades, New Zealanders have come into much greater contact with their Asian neighbours and no longer fear them.

This is true, but remember unlike the big parties Peters is not worried by how much he offends 90% of NZ. He is targeting just 10% and needs half of them.

Addictive

The Rudd Government

I have had a fairly benign to positive view of Kevin Rudd as Australian Labour under his leadership seem so much more moderate than NZ Labour. And he cut taxes in his first budget – unlike Helen who raised them, and didn’t cut them until budget No 9.

I was intrigued to listen to Andrew Bolt, talk at length on Kevin Rudd a few months ago, Bolt, was dismissed by a few people here as ill informed because he is a conservative commentator. But what I found interesting is that his criticisms were not that Rudd is left wing, but that Rudd is inclined to ill thought out populist ideas which annoy his colleagues and that he is ill disciplined.

I have to say the more time goes on, the more I regard Mr Bolt as having been very insightful with regards to Rudd. I’m not saying the Rudd Government is pursuing bad policies (overall quite good), and the Liberal Party leadership is near unelectable, so I still regard Rudd as the best choice (until Turnbull steps up anyway). But Rudd’s proposed EU style Asia-Pacific Union seems to be exactly what Bolt was speaking about.

There has been considerable comment in NZ that Rudd didn’t even consult New Zealand over his proposal, which is just plain stupid. Helen Clark has fairly astutely fired a subtle barb back without it coming directly from her lips, as Fran O’Sullivan notes.

Audrey Young also blogs on the issue, and quotes Greg Sheridan:

Sheridan has written an excoriating column this week against Kevin Rudd’s recent forays into foreign policy – after just six months in office. Rudd is just completing a visit to Japan.
It is a column with which Clark may have some sympathy.

”KEVIN Rudd is in danger of turning what should be his greatest strength into a serious weakness,” writes Sheridan.

”I refer to his weird and increasingly ratty habit of announcing foreign policy initiatives of soaring ambition and utterly amorphous content on the run, half baked, with no detail and no credible prospect of success.

”In the past week alone we’ve had Rudd threaten to “take the blowtorch” to the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries to produce more oil and lower prices, nominate [former diplomat] Dick Woolcott to reform Asian security and trade structures, and now appoint Gareth Evans to head a commission to end nuclear proliferation and secure nuclear disarmament.

”If you announce twice a week that you’re going to save the world and you manifestly lack the means to give the slightest effect to your pronouncements, the world soon loses interest. The chief casualty is your credibility.”

The test for Rudd will be how well he learns from his mistakes.

One of Rudd’s Ministers is Craig Emerson, whom I had the pleasure of meeting last year at CIS’s Consilium conference. He is now the Small Business Minister (a portfolio we could do with here).

He gave an excellent speech to the Sydney Institute two days ago. Some extracts:

… the role of policy makers is to allow the market to create prosperity and out of that prosperity to expand opportunity, not the welfare state. In the market democracy so fashioned, citizens enjoy freedom, self-fulfilment and sovereignty over the state, not subjugation to the state through financial and regulatory welfare.

This is the philosophy of like-minded people whom I call market democrats – the modern Labor champions of the traditional Labor values of prosperity, fairness and compassion. Market democrats harness the power of the market for the public good.

Not a bad term – market democrats.

But as a new recruit to the ALP I again began to ask: is there truly a conflict between self-interest and moral behaviour and is there a conflict between morality and markets? …

But self-interest is not synonymous with selfishness. An athlete is not selfish for wanting to win a tournament, but is self-interested. A singer is not selfish for wanting to win Australian Idol. An artist is not selfish for wanting to win the Archibald Prize, nor is an author for wanting to win the Booker Prize. A scientist is not selfish for wanting to achieve a breakthrough ahead of other scientists.

Athletes, singers, artists, dancers, authors and scientists are self-interested but this does not make them selfish. Some may be arrogant and rude, some selfish, others humble and altruistic, but all are self-interested. Without self-interest, economic and social progress is impossible.

A very useful differentiation between self-interest and selfishness.

Labor was making itself the party of competition and compassion. Out of the proceeds of growth, the Hawke government was lifting school completion rates, supporting the parents of poor children to keep them at school. My moral questions were being answered through the competitive yet compassionate philosophy of the Hawke and Keating Labor governments – a philosophy that sat easily with Adam Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments and the Wealth of Nations. There was, I concluded, no inherent conflict between markets and morality.

How nice to have a reference to markets without a sneer, as one would get in NZ.

Competitive markets reward effort, risk-taking and entrepreneurship and they encourage innovation essential to the growth of a market economy. The forces of competition create pressure on businesses to be efficient and to come up with and apply new ideas for application in producing goods and services valued by consumers.

Yet markets are chaotic and wasteful. Predicting the prices produced by markets is always hazardous. Markets force businesses to close, wasting the building renovations and obliging employees to seek work elsewhere. But far more wasteful and chaotic are central planning and governments pretending to be good at running businesses in so-called mixed economies.

In other words markets are not perfect, but they are generally a lot better than the alternatives.

If poverty in Australia is no longer primarily a poverty of incomes but a poverty of opportunity, the goal of a fairer society is best pursued through a more equal distribution of opportunity than through a more equal distribution of income. A nation’s people are not better off if all live on equally low incomes. Of course it is unfair if the rich get richer while the poor get poorer. But why should governments seek to prevent the rich from getting richer if the poor also get richer as a consequence of the wealth creation process?

And he shoots bullets through the arguments of the poverty industry who use a definition which means poverty will never be solved.

Many Australians earning below-average incomes choose to forego higher pay in favour of spending more time with their families and friends or just relaxing or playing sport. By doing so they are making measured income inequality worse but, through free choice, they are making their own lives better.

Indeed. And incomes are also very tied to age and experience. Demanding that an unskilled 19 year old should be earning 60% of the average wage of 40 and 50 year olds with 20 – 30 years experience is madness. It is about opportunity.

The goal of market democrats is prosperity and fairness through opportunity for all in a market economy. Market democrats strive for a more equal distribution of opportunity. If opportunity is equally distributed, incomes in the future will be distributed more equally. Prosperity and fairness become partners not rivals.

I like how Emerson can say what I think, but state it so well.

But for those out of the workforce who have income-earning prospects, perpetual income support payments without any effort to remedy the causes of disadvantage are not the pathway to a prosperous, fair society; they are a perilous road to welfare dependency, low self-esteem and servitude to the state.

When was the last time a NZ Labour Minister spoke about welfare dependency?

Seeking to use industrial muscle to gain pay rises in excess of productivity growth is inflationary and ultimately self-defeating. Modern unionism can involve offering a bundle of services that are attractive to members. These services can extend beyond representation in workplace bargaining to support for lifelong learning, financial, tax and legal advice and advice on superannuation, private health insurance and even personal counselling services.

A wonderfully clear statement that The Standard will hate. Pay rises without productivity growth lead nowhere.

In a market democracy governments should serve the people instead of seeking to subjugate the people to the will of government through high taxes and heavy regulation. By allowing markets to reward hard work, risk-taking and entrepreneurship without unnecessary interference, market democrats advance
freedom and self-fulfilment.

Serve not subjugate.

Market democrats think of markets first and, only where necessary, strengthen or complement markets with efficient regulation. In a market democracy, regulation is justifiable in strengthening markets and remedying market failure.

Exactly, regulation is basically a last resort. Which is why I supported it in telecommunications. There was massive and clear market failure after 15 years of waiting. But it should always remain the last tool, not the first tool, that Governments reach for.

But the previous conservative government thought of regulation first, presiding over what the Business Council of Australia describes as the creeping re-regulation of business. This is why, in a process initiated by Kevin Rudd, Lindsay Tanner and I are so vigorously working with the States and Territories in cutting back overbearing, inconsistent and overlapping Commonwealth and State business regulation.

While in NZ we get review after review of the need to reduce regulations ignored by the Government

Now not everyone in Australian Labor shares his viewpoint. But my God wouldn’t it be nice to even have a single NZ Labour MP who gave speeches like that.

The Irish No

The European Union has had voters in Ireland reject the Lisbon Treaty, after the earlier EU Constitution was also rejected by voters in several countries.

Only Ireland was allowing (in fact was forced to) their citizens to vote on the Treaty, but the rejection by that one country means the Treaty is dead (unless they want to throw Ireland out of the EU).

The no vote was 54.3% which was more decisive than expected. Both the major parties plus the major media in Ireland were campaigning for a yes vote.

Not surprisingly the EU Referendum blog has lots of commentary and coverage.

Simon says

The Herald reports of the selection of Simon Bridges as National candidate for Tauranga last night:

National’s new Tauranga candidate wants to avoid getting personal in his election campaign.

Simon Bridges, who won selection last night, told the Weekend Herald he did not want a battle with his likely foe, New Zealand First leader Winston Peters.

“I want to earn votes from Tauranga by presenting a positive, ambitious case, not getting into a slanging match,” Mr Bridges said. …

“I think people want more dignity from their politicians, and I’m not going to be playing in the gutter.”

Mr Bridges said Tauranga residents had voted for change three years ago when they elected Mr Clarkson after 21 years of Mr Peters as their MP.

“People are tired of the politics of the past. Tauranga is now a modern and vibrant city and it wants an MP to match.”

Indeed. It is about the future vs the past.

Rising living costs were a major issue for young families and seniors in his electorate, and Tauranga residents had told him they wanted firm action on law and order.

Mr Bridges said he had a strong understanding of the latter after working as a Crown prosecutor in the city for the past few years.

He holds a law and arts degree from the University of Auckland, and a Masters in Law from Oxford University.

He plans to resign from his job and work full time on his campaign.

Winston Peters is on Agenda tomorrow and he may confirm his candidacy then.

Audrey Young blogs on Tauranga also:

In Simon Bridges, Peters faces a young, new face, someone who more represents the sort of change National is projecting nationally through leader John Key.

That will be a tougher contest for Peters. The mood for change has stubbornly persisted in the polls for almost two years in nationwide polls and there are perhaps as few as four months to go to the election.


UN tells off UK

Norfolk Blogger (a Lib Dem) reacts with understandable anger to the UN Human Rights Council chiding the UK for its failings.

Sir Lanka, a country slammed by Human Rights Groups for its extrajudicial executions thinks the UK should ditch the monarchy as it is anti human rights. Now I am a republican but I don’t think the UK needs to be told buy the UN what form of Government to have.

Syria, a country with one party rule, complains about discrimination against Muslims. Syria only restricts freedom of speech, press, assembly, movement, association and oh yeah religion.

But the highlight must be Iran complaining about the UK’s record on sexual discrimination. Here is how Iran treats women:

  • If a woman is killed (say in a car accident) her family is paid only half of what they would get if a male is killed
  • The testimony of a male witness is worth twice that of a female witness
  • Women can not travel by themselves without written permission of her father or husband
  • Women get only half the inheritance amounts men get
  • Women who are raped are deemed guilty of extra-marital sex unless there are four Muslim male witnesses to the rape

And Iran sits on the UN Human Rights Council lecturing the UK on its sex discrimination record. It would be funny if it wasn’t so very very sad.

There is a rumour NZ is going to seek a place on the Human Rights Council. I sincerely hope we do not. We should not add legitimacy to this farce.