A great speech

People will be surprised at who made this speech after the Uk Parliament voted to allow terror suspects to be held without trial for 42 days without charge:

But in truth 42 days is just one, perhaps the most salient example, of the insidious, surreptitious and relentless erosion of fundamental British freedoms.

We will have, shortly, the most intrusive identity card system in the world, a CCTV camera for every 14 citizens, a DNA database bigger than any dictator should have with thousands of innocent children and millions of innocent citizens on it.

We witness and assault on jury trial – that bulwark against bad law and its arbitrary abuse by the state, short cuts to our justice system will make our system neither firm nor fair and the creation of a database state opening up our private lives to the prying eyes of official snoopers and exposing our personal data to careless civil servants and criminal hackers.

The state has security powers to clamp down on peaceful protest and so-called hate laws to stifle legitimate debate whilst those inside Parliament get off Scot free.

This cannot go on it must be stopped and for that reason today I feel it’s incumbent on me to take a stand.

I will be resigning my membership of this House and I intend to force a by-election in Haltemprice and Howden.

This is not some liberal leftie, but the Conservative Party Shadow Home Secretary, David Davis. Davis is a former member of the SAS and on the right of the Conservative Party economically. He shows a regard for civil liberties is not confined to those of one political persuasion.

Bridges wins Tauranga nomination

Congratulations to Simon Bridges who won a four way contest tonight to be National’s candidate for Tauranga. He won on the first ballot which is a good sign of the respect he holds.

Simon will be an excellent candidate, and work hard for Tauranga.

Sir Bob on Electoral Finance Act

Sir Bob Jones knows a few things about chucking out Governments. He helped throw out Labour in 1975 and also helped throw out National in 1984.

He may be a “rick prick” but he is not a Nat, having last voted National in 1981. Since then he has voted a mixture of Labour, ACT and NZ First.

So what does Sir Bob say on the Electoral Finance Act:

Wellington property tycoon Sir Bob Jones says he has had a “gutsful” of the Electoral Finance Act and he is thinking of testing it with an ad campaign against the Government.

But he is only allowed to place one single newspaper ad unless he registers with the Electoral Commission.

Sir Bob says robust political debate is now being stifled in this country and he has had enough.

This is something I am hearing more and more. The rules are so confusing and unclear, that people are deterred from engaging. And in fact even the parties and candidates themselves have been silenced as they are mainly petrified to spend any money until the last few weeks.

“I’m so overwhelmingly shocked that I should live to see such legislation in New Zealand. I mean, whatever happened to the free joyous participation in the political process.”

The chinless scarf wearers had to be silenced, along with anyone else who might spent money criticising the Government.

Sir Bob says he has not voted National since 1981, but he will be this time simply to punish the Government for the EFA.

He says elections used to be fun but everyone is now too scared to participate.

“This is the most despicable thing I think I have seen in my lifetime in this country, I really do, certainly by any Government… this overwhelms me. I cannot believe it happened.”

He is considering an anti-Government ad campaign to “flagrantly break the law and have them on”.

My goodness. A prosecution and trial of Sir Robert just before the election. That will be popular for the Government, won’t it.

Fair Go on Wheel Clamping

Whale Oil has this clip from Fair Go, highlighting some very bad behaviour in relations to wheel clamping.

It’s a very good example of third termitis. Instead of any empathy or firm commitment to deal with the problem, the Minister. Harry Duynhoven, talks of officials, reviews, studies etc.

And Maurice Williamson makes a very firm commitment as a great contrast.

The challenge for National is not just to win the election, but once in Government try and put off third termitis as long as possible.

Espiner on Cosgrove

Colin Espiner analyses what is happening with Clayton Cosgrove and the Real Estate Bill:

But Jones has been left in the shade by Cosgrove. We’re getting used to the minister’s “I’m gonna run dodgy real estate agents out of town” Bush-isms but things reached a new level this week when the MP for Waimakariri pulled the old “If I’m too tough then too bad” line out of the hat.

“National Party leader John Key has admitted that reform of the sector is needed but he opposes the (Real Estate Agents Bill) because he doesn’t like my tough guy approach,” said Cosgrove with a straight face. Shrugging off what was left of his self-effacement, Cosgrove went on: “If protecting consumers from getting ripped off and supporting honest real estate agents is being tough, then I am guilty as charged.”

Good grief. It’s Cosgrove versus Key at the OK Corral.

I have praised Cosgrove in the past for his tough line in an industry which needs reform, but his ego seems to now be taking over. There are times when you have to talk tough, and times when you need to work constructively and a good Minister knows when to deploy both.

Cosgrove made a couple of other quite extraordinary claims during the week, too. First, he said real estate agents had met top Fairfax executives in an attempt to heavy them into writing nicer things about the industry, and threatened to pull advertising if they didn’t agree.

Then he said National had stitched up a secret deal with the institute to overturn the Real Estate Agents Bill if it got into government. He even hinted the institute was funding part of National’s election campaign.

He made these claims without any proof, besides the hearsay claim of an anonymous real estate agent-turned-informer, who claimed he’d heard institute president Murray Cleland tell a regional branch meeting in Palmerston North about it.

Hmmn, is that the same anonymous person who told Trevor Mallard about the anonymous American bagman?

And of course National MPs have met with the institute – as have Labour MPs, and indeed MPs from all parties. It’s called lobbying. What Cosgrove is trying to say, however, is that meetings with the Government are fine, but meetings with newspaper executives or the National Party are immediately suspicious.

Having done some lobbying myself (for InternetNZ mainly) one often meets with MPs on select committees outside the formal meetings. It is totally standard practice, and usually invaluable to increasing understanding of the issues. And normally you get a sympathetic hearing but no  guarantees, as parties need to undertake their own discussions at Caucus level on how they will ultimately vote.

One of the reasons for Cosgrove’s anger could be the fact that his bill is losing support. NZ First has indicated it has problems with it, National says it won’t vote for it, and neither will United Future or Act.

But he may be the victim of his own moderate success as a politician, too. The tough-guy routine works OK for a while, but at some point change needs to be effected by getting alongside your enemies, not trying to run them out of town all the time.

Cosgrove could probably have kept both National and NZ First onside with a little attitude change on his part, but he doesn’t appear to have cottoned on to this yet. If he wants to become more than just an attack politician, Cosgrove needs some lessons in diplomacy.

I think Clayton would be wise to listen to Mr Espiner. It would be a shame if some needed reforms do not happen, because of the way he manages the Bill.

The Secret Really Sensible Sentencing Trust

Oh this is hilarious. Labour MP Russel Fairbrother has set up a “Really Sensible Sentencing Trust” to argue against sending criminals (except the really really bad ones) to jail.

Labour list MP Russell Fairbrother announced the formation of the group, but would not reveal who was involved.

“I’m not authorised to give names.”

That is priceless. It is a secret trust, heading by a Labour MP. Who might be the secret members. Here are my guesses:

  1. David Bain
  2. Scott Watson
  3. William Bell

The group consisted of people who believed that only the worst of the worst criminals should be sent to jail.

The rest were victims of a competitive society focused on private gain at the expense of public good, and they should be supported in the community with taxpayer funds that would otherwise go into keeping them locked up.

Oh if only more Labour MPs would say what they really think. Please can someone ask Phil Goff if he agrees that criminals are in fact not criminals but the real victims, and a “competitive society” is in fact the evil criminal responsible for their actions.

“Inherent in competition are a small number of winners and a larger number of losers. All the evidence tells us it’s from the losers in this competitive model that we fill our prisons,” Mr Fairbrother said.

“We’ve seen the income gap increase as the market economy takes hold, and, with the increase of disadvantage, the prison population grows.”

Now the prison population has grown under Labour, so is Fairbrother saying this is the fault of Dr Cullen’s economic policies?

I really hope National ask some questions to King and Goff when the House resumes on whether they agree with the secret lobby group formed by one of their colleagues.

And anyone want to start a book futures market on the result in Napier at the general election. Can Chris Tremain get a 10,000+ majority in what used to be one of the safest seats for Labour?

UK and France

I’m in the United Kingdom and France for around 13 days from 18 June to 1 July. Mainly road tripping in the UK, and attending an IDU conference in Paris after that.

If UK readers are keen to catch up for a beer, let me know.  I should be in the south of England until around the 21st and in London from 22nd to 24th.

General Debate 12 June 2008

Greens spot carbon target change

The ODT reports that the Greens have spotted what appears to be a unilateral agreement by the Government to reduce the carbon equivalent emissions target for the agricultural industry from a 20% reduction to a 10% reduction.

What will be interesting to watch is how the Greens will end up still voting for the Government’s Emissions Trading Scheme despite it being watered down repeatedly. Even the original scheme was derided by Greenpeace as achieving almost nothing.

But I predict the Greens will still vote for it. They have never shown an ability to play hard ball, which is why they keep getting taken for granted.

The rape conviction rate

The Herald reports on the law commission inquiry into sex cases, and the recommendation that an inquiry be held into whether there is a better way to conduct such trials than the adversarial one.

I have no problems with this, and am generally supportive of changes which are less “brutalising and distressing” for complainants.

However I get worried when I read:

Sir Geoffrey said there was also concern at the high number of acquittals in rape cases.

There may be a high number of acquittals because the Police policy now seems to be to prosecute no matter how flimsy the evidence. Any suggestion that people should be more easily convicted despite a lack of evidence is somewhat chilling.

As I said, no problems with changes to make it more complainant or victim friendly. But any move to make it easier to get convictions would be of concern. We should not throw away all principles of guilty beyond reasonable doubt just because most people think Clint Rickards unfairly was found Not Guilty.

Two years jail in Finland for Insensitivity towards Islam

A disturbing case from Europe, where Seppo Lehto has been jailed for two years for hate speech, including violating religious sensibilities.

Now the man in question is an objectionable racist, He is an extremely offensive individual.

But just as I don’t support David Irving going to jail for denying the Holocaust, I don’t support Seppo Lehto going to jail for saying offensive things. I recall the words of Noam Chomsky who said something along the lines of there being no virtue in defending popular speech.

Unless the speech is directly inciting violence or criminal acts, it should not be a crime to say offensive things which upset religious sensitivities.

Geddis on Electoral Finance Act

Associate Professor Andrew Geddis had an article appear in the latest issue of the Otago Graduate magazine on the Electoral Finance Act. Geddis is one of the leading academics on electoral financing, and one of those most commonly quoted as to the problems with the old Electoral Act. He is generally, I think it is fair to say, a supporter of more comprehensive regulations on political financing.

This makes his comments on the Electoral Finance Act more noteworthy. Some extracts:

  • The Electoral Finance Act has caused damage to our electoral process that now needs fixing
  • A good portion of the blame fir the present situation lies with the legislation’s authors
  • The way the Labour-led Government went about enacting those reforms was ill-considered and overly rushed
  • It is hard to see how Parliament alone can now put the matter right

I have attached the full article as a pdf geddis-efa-article so people can read it in full, and not just my extracts.

Food Inflation

Heh

A solid choice

One of the Government’s initiatives has been the setting up of an industry wide body in the ICT sector. Previous attempts have not been supported or successful, but we do now have a Digital Develoment Council which has representatives from up to a dozen ICT groups such as NZCS, InternetNZ, TUANZ, Women in Technology, Business NZ, Local Govt NZ, the 20/20 Trust etc.

Many people are sceptical, given previous failures, and will be looking closely to see how well it performs.

A good indicator is the appointment of its first Chair – Fran Wilde.

Fran is what one calls a heavyweight – in that she gets things done and you don’t want to be in her way trying to stop her. Fran is a former Wellington City Mayor, current Wellington Regional Council Chair and also was CEO of Trade NZ.

No one person is a guarantee of success, but as I said Fran has a very good track record of doing, not just talking.

Kiwiblog Advertising

I’m pleased to announce that advertising on Kiwiblog is now handled by Scoop Media. They do advertising for their own news site, plus Kiwiblog and Public Address, so online advertisers can easily advertise on all three sites, or pick individual ones.

Kiwiblog is not cheap to run. Putting aside my own time, Inspire Net spend may hours supporting the site, doing upgrades and providing a grunty server to host it. Oh yeah plus 100 GB or so of traffic a month. So they now get a portion of the advertising revenue as compensation.

Please do support the advertisers, if you are interested in their goods or services.

And anyone interested in advertising should contact Chloe at Scoop.

Espiner on photo gaffe

Colin Espiner covers the photo gaffe fairly:

As Kiwi as apple pie? Labour’s photo gaffe is just one more embarrassment the Government didn’t need at the moment.

Prime Minister Helen Clark’s right when she says the fact that Labour used an American family to represent it in an advertisement promoting the Budget is “a storm in a teacup”.

After all, the fact that Labour uses clipart and stock images in its advertising is hardly a revelation. Most advertising agencies lean heavily on stock images. They’re much cheaper, and more convenient than setting up a photo shoot every time you want to produce an advertisement.

Newspapers and magazines use them all the time when they are looking for a generic shot to illustrate a story. And there’s nothing wrong with it.

But political parties need to be extra careful, particularly when they are using powerful images of families on advertising in an election year. …

But as a politics watcher it intrigues me because it tells me that Labour is no longer looking after the basics. It’s politics 101 to double-check pictures and artwork and testimonials used in political advertising. All political parties have (or should have) fixers whose job it is to make sure that, if a family picture is used in adverts, they are A: New Zealanders B: supporters of the policy being advertised, and C: not convicted criminals or child molesterers.

The brochure story is a storm in a tea cup. But it also neatly illustrates how Labour is no longer the well-oiled political machine it once was.

One of my first jobs in Parliament was putting our propaganda publications and certainly some of those used library stock images. In fact on occasion one would deliberately used an overseas photo so one wouldn’t have the problem that the person pictured in it would turn out to be an opponent of the Government. Hillary Clinton had this problem when the young girl in her 3 am TV ad turned out to now be a young student who was an activist for Obama!

But generally one would only use overseas photos for non important background images. If for example there is a pamphlet on health care, you might want a dozen medical themed photos in a montage and some may be from overseas.

If the photo is the centrepiece of the main Budget publicity pamphlet, then we would go local. Our preference generally was photos actually taken by a staff member who was out with the PM as we knew the background to the photo and who to contact in terms of the subjects in there.

I also recall some hilarious discussions when we found out (before publication) that the photo of a happy Maori family were in fact Hawaiian! Yes, it got changed in time.

Finally a useful economic problem!

More on right vs left characterisations

I pinged Jordan yesterday for what I thought was a simplistic ascribing of selfishness to those who are not of the left. Jordan has done a clarification which I think reflects the situation better, even though I still disagree that the right want to constrain the poor.

If I was to attempt some generalisations it would be that the right focus too much on incentives and not enough on the short-term while the left do not focus enough on incentives and on the short-term over the long term.

To take one example – the widely disliked market rentals in the 1990s. If you look at the issue in terms of incentives and the long-term, having accommodation assistance delivered to low income families by way of supplement would be fairer than having your level of assistance decided by who your landlord is. It was never about making poor people pay more – in fact total assistance increased off memory.

But where National fell down is not looking at the short-term effects, in its desire to get the long-term incentives right. It was seen as callous for the plight of the family who suddenly had big rent increases on the property they had lived in for years.

I know of no-one in National who thinks the state does not have a role in helping low income families meet their living costs. But as I said what National may have been guilty of is being indifferent to the short-term pain imposed by its policies.

Likewise Labour often (in my opinion) looks at the band-aid solution rather than the core problem, which means they do stupid stuff such as interest-free student loans rather than more sensible ways to help students such as lower tertiary fees or increase allowances.

Another difference in world views tends to be the degree of faith or optimism in the ability of the state to fix problems. Views on the right tend to view the state as ranging from a necessary evil to competent in some areas, but not all. And views on the left probably range from competent in some areas but not all to favouring the state over the private sector at every opportunity.

This is why people on the left and right come up with different solutions (in my view) and different priorities. Not that one side are selfish and one side are not.

Wire-tapping in Italy

Civil Libertarians may have an unusual ally – Italian PM Silvio Berlusconi.

The Telegraph reports that at any one time in Italy 130,000 phone lines are being recorded by authorities, with a total of 3,000,000 Italians spied on every year.

Berlusconi has said a new law will ban the use of wire-taps except in investigations into terrorism and organised crime with illegal wiretaps carrying a penalty of up to five years in prison.

Italy has a population of 60 million, so this is the equivalent in New Zealand of a bit over 8,000 phone lines being tapped at any poin in time and 200,000 NZers being spied on by the state every year.

And people complain about the US Patriot Act!

More on abortion

No Right Turn posted yesterday some links on the abortion law issue. He chided The Standard for (at the time) not having posted on the issue, and if he allowed comments I was going to suggest it was because they hadn’t found a way to blame John Key for it yet!

The Standard now do have a guest post by Julie Fairey with the title “If you’re against abortion, then kindly don’t have one”. Very true. If only they would apply the same logic to Easter trading – if you’re against it then kindly don’t shop on Good Friday!

A story in The Press yesterday demonstrated to me the gap between our laws, and our practice. To quote:

Christchurch GP Pippa MacKay, who performs abortions at Lyndhurst Hospital, said women needed access to safe abortions.

“For as long as people have been having sex, there have been abortions,” she said. “Unplanned pregnancies won’t go away because abortion is illegal. That would be putting women’s lives at risk.”

MacKay said she was disturbed by the implication that she and other doctors were not operating within the law. “As far as I’m concerned, I apply the law. If someone says to me they will suffer depression if they have a child, then I accept that.”

Now Dr MacKay has honestly explained how almost all doctors interpret the law. They ask the woman wehther having the pregnancy would cause them depression, the woman says “Oh yes it will” and the doctor says “Okay”.

Now it really is a farce. I mean it is hardly utilising 10+ years of medical training to just ask someone if hypothetically they would be depressed and use an affirmative response to judge them at “serious mental risk”. A receptionist could do the same, or even an online form.

I don’t mean this is any way as a criticism of Dr MacKay (who is a very respected practitioner) – it just shows how much of a gap there is between the law and how it is operated.

We have de facto abortion on demand in NZ, and have had so for some decades. The thought of forcing a woman to continue with a pregnancy against her will is repugnant to me. So why continue with the charade of requiring two doctors to certify if someone “qualifies” for an abortion if we know all they do is ask “Would having an unwanted baby depress you”.

While an update of our abortion laws might be a painful experience to go through, I have little doubt the vast majority of NZers would support and vote for abortion to be safe and legal on demand. I would also hope one could look at how to reduce the level of abortions through education and counselling as there is a difference between being pro-choice and pro-abortion.

In my experience with abortion debates, no-one who is pro-choice or pro-life is open to persuasion to change their views. WIth that in mind could I suggest that comments might more usefully be focused on the pros and cons of having a law change.

Newspapers all love planned cellphone ban

Sigh, all the newspaper editorials are supporting the proposed ban on non handheld cellphone use in cars. I hope none of them ever have reporters whom they call while out driving to a job!

The Dom Post says:

Driving while using cellphones reduces safety margins. Those who assert they know the difference between safe and unsafe use of phones should ask themselves if they are equally confident that the testosterone-loaded 18-year-old rushing from football practice to meet his girlfriend will show the same good judgment when his phone beeps as he approaches in the opposite direction.

I would retort that 18 year old will simply break the law anyway.

The Press says:

Cellphone use is such a highly visible, plainly dangerous activity that targeting it directly sends a clear road-safety message to drivers. Specific messages are more effective than general ones.

So what has been the impact in countries which have banned callphones? Has the number of deaths and accidents due to distractions dropped, compared to before the ban?

And the Herald says the ban is too timid:

For years, the Government’s failure to ban the use of handheld cellphones while driving has been a complete puzzle. So compelling is the case for outlawing the dangerous practice that any delay appears untenable.

It proposes that the penalty for breaches of the ban would be a $50 fine and 25 demerit points. But American research suggests that so ingrained is the habit of texting and dialling that modest penalties might not be enough to discourage drivers from using cellphones. That seems a reasonable conclusion, especially given that strict enforcement will be difficult. To have an impact, a penalty of at least $150, plus demerit points, would be necessary.

Or how about jail, like with drunk driving? I mean we hear that it is just as bad a distraction, so lets lock up anyone who uses a cellphone in a car – that will be a real deterrent.

Equally compelling is the fact that at least 45 countries, including Australia and most of the European Union, have outlawed handheld phones. In Britain, indeed, matters have moved on to increasing the penalties imposed on motorists whose cellphone use causes the death of a fellow road-user or pedestrian.

This is a very different thing. If one actually causes a fatal accident due to a decision you made to use a phone, then you should face the full force of the law.

Dirty Canadians

An amusing story about certain diplomats unable to give blood on World Blood Donor Day.

The Australian High Commission was unable to give blood as he lived in the UK between 1980 and 1996 and may have mad cow disease!

And the German attache can not give blood as he has a Canadian girlfriend!

It turns out Canadians are very dirty and one has a risk of heterosexual HIV from them, so you can’t give blood if your girlfriend is Canadian. Hilarious.

A glimmer of hope

The Press reports:

Sharples said the Maori seats should go eventually, but the impact of the Maori Party showed it was important to retain them for now.

If the debate is about when, not if, that is a good thing. As I have said previously, I think a lower threshold, as recommended by the Royal Commission on the Electoral System, is a more appropriate way to deal with issues of Maori representation than keeping the seats.

What would be interesting would be to ask Dr Sharples what criteria he would use to judge when the time was right for them to go.

MPs and traffic

The NZ Herald has a story alleging Far North MP John Carter swore at a traffic cop when the officer alleged (incorrectly) his car was unregistered.

It’s not a big story, and John has said his behaviour was inappropriate, which he regrets.

Both MPs (and candidates) have to be angels when it comes to on road behaviour. I recall a few years ago an MP telling me regretfully that the thing he misses most about, is that he can’t give an idiot the fingers if they cut in front of them dangerously!