An effing amazing nature video

Coulter endorses Clinton

Hilarious video of Hannity & Colmes with Ann Coulter insisting that Hillary Clinton would be a better President than John McCain, and that she will campaign for Hillary if McCain is the candidate.

On the other hand I think John McCain will be pretty pleased that he heads into Super Duper Tuesday with warm endorsements from Rudy Guliani and Governor Schwarzenegger.

Hat Tip: The Whig

National pledges to repeal bail law

National has announced that if it wins the election, they will repeal Labour’s new bail law. This does not mean repealing bail – just the changes made by Labour.

Labour’s new bail laws are a cost cutting measure to just keep prison numbers down, by making it easier for people to get bail.  The old law required bail to be given unless there was a “risk” to the public.  The new law requires bail to be given unless there was a “real or substantial risk” which means many more crimes will be committed by people released on bail.

Accused double murderer Chris Kahui is a prominent example of what has happened.  He has breached bail conditions three times, but because he can not be proved to be real or substantial risk, he keeps getting bail.

A huge amount of crime is done by people out on bail.  Why you would then make it even easier for people to get bail – I don’t know.

NBR on telco issues

NBR has two good articles online, re telco issues.

The first one covers industry disquiet over a unilateral change to determination over operational separation of Telecom which would allow the GM of Telecom Wholesale to have 80% of his incentive package to be based on the performance of the overall Telecom group, rather than just on how well his division does.  This gives a massive incentive to treat Telecom Retail in preference to other customers.

The second is that the Commerce Commission is prosecuting Telecom  for false advertising over their Go Large plans.

Barrie Saunders on state sector neutrality

The Dominion Post yesterday had an excellent opinion piece from Barrie Saunders, one of the partners at Saunders Unsworth on neutrality in the public service. I liked it so much I phoned them up and asked if I could blog a copy (as Dom Post does not have it online) and they have kindly sent me through a copy.

The full article is over the break. I wanted to focus here on Barrie’s recommendations:

To restore confidence in the public sector four things need to happen:

  1. CEOs should act as CEOs and push back against any attempt by Ministers or their advisers in respect of the appointment of either staff or consultants, or anything else that should properly be decided in the department.
  2. The State Services Commission should vigorously defend the model against those who seek to undermine it and provide strong support for CEOs who struggle.
  3. CEOs should be appointed on open ended terms, as the Government has generally mandated for the private sector under the Employment Relations Act 2000. This would require a change in the State Sector Act. That extra security would help CEOs deal with inappropriate pressures from Ministers or elsewhere. Open ended appointments would still allow for redundancy in the event of restructuring and incompetence. The very rare cases of a breakdown in the relationship with the Minister would require one or the other to be transferred to another role.
  4. Finally the Cabinet Manual should make it clear that Ministerial Advisers cannot do anything the Minister is unable to do. This is necessary to ensure that Ministers don’t hide behind their advisers when dealing with their departments. A code of conduct for them is another option.

The Hive also liked the article, and says the new SSC head is going to have to play a major role in re-establishing the political neutrality of the public service, and that maybe make a temporary appointment as Commissioner to be a change agent, and a permanent appointment after the election.

The full article is below

Continue reading »

Another Electoral Finance loophole?

This isn’t aimed at the NZ Electoral Finance Act specifically, but Tyler Cowan at Marginal Revolution looks at if one can use prediction markets or insurance as bribery:

What would happen if some famous rich person walked into a presidential prediction market and said: “Hello, I’m selling shorts for candidate A, to the value of a hundred million dollars if he should win. I’m not doing this because I don’t believe candidate A will win, indeed, I want her to win. I hope everyone who can help candidate A win, by campaigning, talking to friends, or even just voting, will buy a short from me (I’m practically giving them away!) and go out and do it with a healthy economic self-interest in their hearts!”

On the subject of electoral finance, Bryce Edwards had another useful post, and also mentioned in a column in the Listener on the issue. In his post Edwards looks at the apparent double standard over political party websites and the closed down Don’t Vote Labour site.

More Wellington wind turbines

Delighted to see plans for more wind turbines for Wellington.  Making use of an infinite renewable resource is great sense. You can’t power a whole city off wind power, but this proposal will generate power for 35,000 homes.

The planned site is in lovely Ohariu Valley, and unlike Makara where many locals were resistant, the locals here actually formed a company and made the proposal to Meridian to use their land for a wind farm. Smart farmers.

General Debate 1 February 2008

Cactus Kate on Ropati verdict

Cactus Kate has an interesting take on the Ropati verdict. She is not sure he is a rapist, but does conclude:

Regardless of the outcome of not guilty, Ropati is not innocent either, he needs some serious help and a kick in the pants from his older brothers who screamed and yelled boarishly at the Court once the verdict was passed down.

Personally the fact the complainant went to the Police immediately, plus the forensic evidence, had me thinking he would be found guilty.

Congratulations to Jacinda Ardern

The Standard reports that Labour’s Jacinda Ardern has been elected President of the International Union of Socialist Youth.  That’s a great achievement. Jacinda is a former staffer in Helen Clark’s office and while I have never met her, I have often heard Labourites rave about how great she is

New Zealand does quite well on the international youth politics front.  Another kiwi, Shane Frith, served a couple of terms as Chairman of the International Young Democrat Union.

A few years ago Jacinda and I were both due to travel to Beijing to attend a meeting of a UN group on youth unemployment (I was representing IYDU) but sadly Jacinda had to pull out at the last minute.  It would have been useful having another kiwi there as I had my wallet stolen the day I was due to leave.

Is this true?

Received the following e-mail:

A sky tech let slip that the free to air channels (tvnz, tv3 etc) are sending commands via their digital sky network that delete series links for their shows off people’s mysky planners. I had noticed that the links to shows like CSI and McLeod’s Daughters were mysteriously vanishing off my series links. Have you noticed it too?  The tech said it was all very hush hush and that you could get an adapter from DSE to stop it.

Now I do know if this is true or not.  It certainly is true that the series link function does start to miss some shows over time and you need to reboot the mysky box to restore them.  I haven’t checked in the past is the deleted series links are just from the free to air channels.  Has anyone else been keeping check and/or know if this is true or false?

National promises incentive to make voluntary loan repayments

National has announced two major policies today on the student loans scheme. They are:

  1. No repeal of interest free loans
  2. To provide an incentive for voluntary repayments, with a 10% bonus on any repayment over $500

These are linked because I am pretty sure you would not do (2) if it wasn’t for (1). Let’s take them in turn.

The interest free loans policy announced by Labour is a bad policy. If you wanted to spend a few hundred million on helping tertiary students it would have been far better to have spent it on student allowances or lowering tertiary fees. The policy is a bad one because it provides bad incentives – specifically the incentive to borrow money unnecessairly (as one can profit from it at taxpayers expense) and the incentive never to make voluntary repayments (as it is zero interest).

But there is a world of difference between introducing a policy, and not repealing something already in place. National has judged that campaigning on a policy of reintroducing interest on student loans would be electoral poison. Also as John Key points out people have made decisions on taking out loans based on the policy.

This does not mean they are endorsing the original policy. If you employ that logic, then you have to claim Labour endorses the 1991 benefit cuts because they have never reversed them. The reality in politics is relatively few policies get reversed with a change of government. Expecting National to reverse the interest free loans policy would be like expecting Labour in 1999 to reverse the 1997 tax cuts.

So you have National having to agree not to reverse the policy. But you still have the problem of the bad incentives it provides. That is when the voluntary repayment rebate comes in. Sure you can’t reverse the policy, but by providing the voluntary repayment rebate, you provide an incentive for people to pay off their debt quicker. And have no doubt many graduates can pay it off quicker – the level of repayments has dropped massively in the last couple of years.

Now it isn’t all good incentives though. While National’s policy does help correct the repayment incentive, it may make worse the incentive to borrow unnecessarily. Because sure as hell if I was a student I would borrow the maximum, and then repay it the next year and bang I am 10% better off. But this is not a new problem. Zero interest already provides the incentive for people to borrow money they don’t need and invest it. But it does exacerbate the problem somewhat.

So the policy gets a tick on the repayment incentive but a cross on the borrowing incentive. It also gets a tick I suspect on the vote for us incentive!

UPDATE: Colin Espiner has a good piece on the policy change. I like this part:

In all honesty, National couldn’t enter an election campaign promising to raise interest rates on student loans. That would have gone down like an empty keg at a student union orientation.

A nice comparison.

Violent crimes by youth

There’s been a few claims and counterclaims about violent offending by young people so I thought I would check the data out.  First of all we have the the publication by the Ministry of Justice called Youth Justice Statistics 1992 to 2006.  Sounds authoritative.

It deals mainly with 14 to 16 year olds.  Why? Because at 17 you are deemed an adult to be tried in an adult court, and below 14 you can’t be charged except for extremely serious crimes such as murder. On page 35 we get the population figures for 14 to 16 year olds.

Then on page 43, a table gives up the Police apprehension figures for 14 – 16 year olds for violent offences.  We see in 1995 it was 2,690. In 1999 it had risen only 0.7% to 2,708.  And by 2006 it had gone up 38% to 3,743.

If one takes the population growth into account on page 44, then the rate per 10,000 population was 167 in 1995.  By 1999 it had declined slightly to 166.  And in 2006 it had increased by 18% to 196.

Incidentially the number of homicides by young people was 22 for the seven years up to 1999, and 36 for the seven years from 2000 onwards.

But back to youth violent crime apprehensions. The graph below shows the trend nicely:

youthcrime.JPG

Now this doesn’t mean it is literally the fault of Government.  Helen Clark isn’t going around leading teenage gangs on a rampage.  But what it does show is the youth violent crime level was steady, and has increased in the last few years, and that this is why new policies and new approaches are a desirable thing.

Annette King blames the moon and the sun

Good God, Annette King seems to be determined to destroy her formerly excellent reputation.  I doubt even George Hawkins would be as insensitive as to blame the tide of murders in January on the “full moon” and “hot summer”.

Even worse it appears she made her comments at the scene of a shoot-out in South Auckland.  She actually stood at the very point teenagers and gang members were trying to gun each other down, and talked about the moon, the sun and the stresses of Christmas.

Simon Power says he is lost for words, but in fact is thanking Annette for a late Christmas present. He helpfully points out some more likely factors:

  • The Justice Ministry says their youth offending team system is a shambles of confusion.
  • The Reducing Youth Offending Programme, run with CYF and Corrections, collapsed after offending rates had not reduced after three years.
  • Labour’s Ministers Group on the Youth Offending Strategy did not meet for three years.
  • We are still waiting for the national truancy register they promised in 1999 and 2002.

A smart Minister can refer to stuff such as seasonal variations, but not as an excuse.  To say

They are not easy to address issues unless we ban Christmas and January

is ridicolous and insensitive.  I really do not think the full moon is why there was a gang shootout at a tinny house.

Moore calls for Electoral Finance Act repeal

Former Labour Party Prime Minister Mike Moore calls for the repeal of the Electoral Finance Act – some extracts:

Dissent is the lifeblood and oxygen of progressive politics. It always has been.

We social democrats trace our history of dissent back through the centuries as we wrung concessions out of the powerful and privileged.

Years after I was elected to Parliament, I read an interview with my mother who told the story of delivering leaflets supporting the workers at night with me in a pram covered with illegal leaflets. As a boy, I delivered ‘No Maoris, No Tour’ leaflets. More recently we saw splendid dissent during the anti-Vietnam War, anti-nuclear and the anti-apartheid struggle. One current minister was ejected physically from the parliamentary gallery for protesting against the extension of the powers of the Security Intelligence Service.

This short history of democratic Labour and dissent is to remind people of Labour’s traditions. Why and how we stand on the shoulders of others in our historic commitment to human rights; freedom at home and abroad.

Why then this historic blunder of the Electoral Finance Act, which contradicts this fine tradition?

Is it all a cock-up or a conspiracy that we have enacted such a repressive, unworkable, flawed law to cover election year activists?

Why should you have to register with the state if you want to oppose or support a political party, or promote public policy? Lawyers have suggested that cartoonists who seek to persuade readers could be covered, even theatre.

Even MPs who voted for the legislation can’t work out how to spend their own electorate allowances.

People are going to test this law, perhaps get a terminally-ill person in a hospice to be an agent. A heroic defence was suggested, that is the law of common sense. Unique in world jurisprudence – tell that to the judge or electoral commissioner who closed down an anti-Government webpage. The blogger wouldn’t give his address because he lived at home and might upset mom. Is this silly or sinister? Both.

My plea to the party I love is to just repeal the act. Accept it’s wrong in substance and principle before it hurts us further and does the exact opposite of what’s intended by encouraging big money to circumvent this law. J’Accuse.

I expect the usual suspects will attack Mike Moore, rather than listen to his message.

Editorials go 3-0 to Key

The Herald editorial today:

When the Prime Minister heard her National counterpart’s “state of the nation” speech on Tuesday she suggested it had been revised over the previous few days. Laden as it was with programmes to tackle youth crime, it could have been a rapid response to public concern and laudable for that. But in fact Mr Key’s proposals were accompanied by extensive referencing and policy research. It was the Prime Minister’s address yesterday that seemed to have been spiced at the last minute.

Parliamentary staff often come in for criticism.  When a party falters, the leader’s advisors are often first to be blamed.  On this occasion it is appropriate to acknowledge the fine effort put in by the parliamentary staff – the “extensive referencing and policy research” was useful and reassuring.  The challenge will be to keep that standard up for future announcements.

It featured a proposal to require every child to remain in formal education or training courses until the age of 18. This sounds like a drastic increase in the age of compulsory schooling and seems to mean that 16- and 17-year-olds could no longer leave for fulltime work. But Helen Clark says it is not a simple lifting of the leaving age and young people would still be able to start work from age 16 so long as they were enrolled in some sort of “structured learning”. Enrolment sounded more important than terms of attendance.

Under questioning yesterday she seemed not very sure of several implications and concedes that it is an idea that still needs refinement. In other words it is a long way short of a workable policy worth putting to the electorate.

Indeed, there were no details at all. I presume the usual suspects will do OIA requests to find out what level of analysis had been done before the announcement was made.

Policy makers must not elevate the most worthy economic aims above the interests of the individual. While education overall serves the greater good, its primary responsibility is to serve the individual, allowing every person to reach their potential. Compulsory education is for children. The age at which they can begin taking responsibility for their own development may be open to debate, but 16 seems reasonable.

Helen Clark talks of offering them a range of training “paths” that would satisfy the requirement to be enrolled in education to 18 and she envisages employers, polytechs and private training centres helping in some way. But the proposal is vague, the purpose dubious and the implications disturbing. Give the young incentives to learn, not compulsion.

As I said yesterday, there is a consensus that the status quo is unacceptable.  Both Labour and National have proposed different ways of dealing with the problem, allowing people to weigh up the competing proposals.

The Press also looks at the policies in an editorial and concludes:

National’s youth education policy is the more flexible and more likely to ensure that greater numbers of teenagers improve their skill. In difficult areas of social policy, this sort of balanced carrot and stick approach is more likely to succeed than quick-fix solutions, such as raising the leaving age or introducing boot camps.

And making it 3-0, the Dom Post says:

…Miss Clark’s attempt to crash Mr Key’s party by delivering her own “state-of-the-nation” speech a day after his has failed. It is National that looks to be the party of ideas, Labour the party playing catch-up.

Mr Key’s promise to get tough on youth crime while beefing up government and community-based initiatives to turn around troubled young lives is a practical and thoughtful response to an issue that is top of the public mind. It is also one that suggests the party is putting more effort into policy development than it has for some years, and that it has taken the trouble to go and ask those on the front line what works best.

By contrast, Miss Clark’s speech – a recitation of historical economic data and a promise to boost teenage participation in formal education – sounded like something cooked up around the Cabinet table to spike National’s guns.

I suspect there is a happy mood in Rotorua today.

Carter considering list only

The NZ Herald reports that David Carter may not stand for the new Selwyn seat as he wants a candidate who can unite the electorate.  Carter had been selected as the candidate, but in an unusual move nominations were re-opened after complaints about the selection process.

Selwyn is a very safe seat for National, so whoever gains the nomination will almost certainly become an MP. David Carter is pretty much guaranteed a high winnable list spot also.

According to the article, there are 12 candidates likely to seek the nomination.  If that is the case a pre-selection committee will reduce that number to five (at which time the names can be made public) and then a full selection meeting of local delegates.

This isn’t a comment on Selwyn specifically, but I always regard it as a healthy thing when a National held seat with no incumbent re-standing has a vigorous selection contest with at least five candidates. And from what I can tell, even the safe Labour seats are attracting enough interest to have selection contests – again a healthy sign.

All but a handful of National’s electorate candidates would become MPs on current public polls (as National rules allow only five list only candidates), so it is important that National has quality candidates in even the strongest Labour seats.

Island Bay

I grew up in Island Bay, and I still go to Island Bay Medical Centre, so on Tuesday popped over to get a Hepatitis A shot.

ib1.JPG

This is the main road, The Parade, and the main shopping centre.  Island Bay is a fairly long yet skinny suburb.  The Parade runs from one end of it to the other for 2 – 3 kms. But almost all of Island Bay is within a few 100 metres of The Parade.

It’s got a good local school, and very good regular buses into town.  If I ever settle down and do the family thing, I could well move back to Island Bay.   It was a great place to grow up with lots of parks (well one less after a school was built on on one of them) and the beach.

Unlimited Potential Predictions

Unlimited Potential had their now annual New Year predictions function last night, and it was lots of fun. It was held at the Chamber of Commerce on the 28th floor of the Majestic Centre. The views from there are quite stunning – a lot better than a normal 14th floor or so view because you literally have nothing blocking the view of the city.up1.JPG

My five predictions for 2008 were:

  1. The new National/Maori Party Government will announce a nationwide FTTM programme – Fibre To The Marae
  2. Telstra will sell Telstra-Clear to Vodafone
  3. The “in” gadget will be those with broadband, mapping, GPS and messaging type capability
  4. Facebook will overtake Bebo as NZ’s preferred social networking site
  5. We will have our first ever prosecution under the anti-spam act

The predictions are of course not 100% serious. Philip Fierlinger won the most support with his prediction of robots taking over the earth 🙂

Mauricio is still predicting the Queen will abdicate.  I didn’t have the heart to tell him that she believes she has a divine duty to reign, and would never abdicate!

The event, as usual, was good fun with the normal drinks and Hell Pizza.  A full crowd of around 120.

Armstrong on Clark Speech

A pretty fair summary from John Armstrong:

There can be no quibbling. The Prime Minister has delivered. No question. Today’s speech announcing that every teenager will have to stay in school or some other form of education or training until they are 18 will prove to be a quantum leap in terms of upskilling the workforce.

Helen Clark had to come up with something big as a riposte to John Key’s rival state of the nation address yesterday. She has shown Labour is still capable of coming up with the “big ideas” that she sees as an essential component in the party’s re-election campaign.

Clark will be happy with that, and it is indeed fair to say it is a new big idea (well now for this Govt).  Armstrong then compares the two speeches:

Whether the Prime Minister has trumped Key is another matter entirely.

Clark clearly envisaged the content of her first major speech of the year would prove to be a victory for substance over style when placed alongside the populist line Key was expected to pursue in his.

So there must have been a sharp intake of breath in the Beehive when Labour read Key’s speech and discovered he was canvassing the very same subject matter and floating a similar-sounding policy.

Key seemed to have gazumped Clark, neutralising the major thrust of her speech before focussing on youth crime as the major strand of his.

As I said, it is a good thing both parties are laying out different policy visions.

No Right Turn decides to smear

You know last year I always gave No Right Turn out as an example of a superb blog.  A clear left wing view point but principled, and focused on policy not personal attacks etc.

Maybe it is having done away with comments (which he is entitled to do so) but his tone and style have changed in the last year and moved far more to name calling and slogans over analysis.  It’s a pity because as I said I always held it up as a model for a effective respected political blog.

I’m not going to catalog the various stuff over the last few months, but I can’t ignore today’s example where he labels the idiots who have again attacked Helen Clark’s electorate office with a brick as “the kiwiblog right”.

That is an outrageous smear.  It would be like me labelling Tim Selwyn’s attack on the same office as the work of the “No Right Turn left” because both Tim and Idiot/Savant opposed the Foreshore and Seabed Act which his brick throwing was about.

It is a matter of record that I condemned the first attack when it happened.  I even got attacked by People Power (who did it) for my condemnation.

I/S is free to adopt whatever style he wants on his blog, and I am sure my approval doesn’t count for a lot.  But when he deliberately tries to smear me with something I have never supported and explicitly condemned in the past – well that’s reflects far more on him than me.

McCain wins Florida

John McCain has won Florida by around 4% over Mitt Romney.  It was a close race for a key state.  Florida was a rare winner take all state so McCain got all 57 delegates and now leads the delegate count. It was also a closed primary so it showed he can win without the votes of Independents.

Rudy was a distant third on 15% and his campaign is over before it really started.  A bit of a pity as I like the fact he was a Republican who was liberal on religious and moral type issues. But he should withdraw now and endorse McCain.

McCain is the only Republican candidate with a chance of beating Clinton or Obama. I hope he gets the nomination. Looking at the polls he is ahead by around 9% in both California with 173 delegates and New York with 101.  But Georgia, Illinois, Missouri, Tennessee and Arizona have 308 delegates between them and little polling there. New York is winner takes all so very impt.  McCain is on 32%, Rudy 22% and Romney 14% so if Rudy withdraws McCain should win easily.

I think we still have Maine to go before Super Duper Tuesday.

The first score

Of course partisans from both sides will argue their camp, but Martin Kay of the Dom Post gives the score as:

Is that it?

Prime Minister Helen Clark’s response to National leader John Key’s state of the nation speech was hardly the torpedo she had been expected to loose off in the opening engagement of the election.

Instead of sinking Key with a headline grabbing-announcement of her own, Clark has invited voters to compare what’s on offer from the two main parties. And Labour is likely to come off second best….

In the opening salvo, then, it is John Key 1, Helen Clark, 0.

A vigorous debate in the comments section.  I recognise many of the names (waves to Tony (congrats on the wedding) and Conor).

A new political party

A new political party is being formed.  It already has 100 members and should reach 500 easily.  It doesn’t have a name yet, but does have a process for choosing a name:

It was decided that we should auction off the right to name the Party on Trademe. Although if this is not successful it is most likely we will go with Aotearoa Nautical Alliance of Laughter, Peoples’ Independent Movement Party or Democratic Aotearoa Freedom Troop.

My personal favourite is the Aotearoa Nautical Alliance of Laughter as it gets across the core elements of NZ identity, our grand oceans as we are an island country and the NZ sense of humour.

There are three key policies so far.  The first is the zero income tax, with the state gaining revenue by nationalising all vice:

The Yet to be Named Silly Party of New Zealand, is dedicated to bringing about a tax situation where you as a consumer would pay NO personal tax. We would go about doing this by creating State Owned Enterprises and Quangos that would have a monopoly on vice. We would have state pornography websites, brothels, drugs, strip joints, poker dens, we would even bring back BZP.

The Greens always say we should tax bad things instead of good things like income.  Well this goes one step further.  Don’t just tax bad things – take all the money from them.

Then a promise to repeal the anti-smacking law:

Another keystone of our policy will be introducing the Anti Anti Smacking Bill into Parliament. This would allow you to discipline your children if you have an NCEA, unit standard, or tertiary qualification in spanking.

I predict NCEA standards in smacking will be keenly sought after.

Finally the tourism policy:

One of the main Policies was turning the West Coast of the South Island into a homosexual holiday Mecca. We would shut down all mines, cease all logging and build massive gay spas, bars and amusement parts. This interlocks with our foreign policy of promoting homosexuality internationally to prevent further explosions in population. With more homosexuals in the world, and with Westport becoming a haven for homos, NZ will rake in the tourist dollars. CHA CHING!

The Porter Report in the early 1990s said the key to development was identifying and developing key clusters around your natural strengths. This policy fits in with that ideally.

Other minor policies include all legal cases being settled by reference to Wikipedia, 18 years paid maternity leave and outlawing the Dewey Decimal System.

I think this will be a very successful party with modern innovative polices for the 21st century.

My hotel burnt down!

Just had an e-mail to tell me that the hotel I am booked into in India next month has had a major fire!

My travel agent is trying to find me a replacement.  I should at least be glad it didn’t happen when I was there.

On a different issue, can Lee C contact me on an e-mail which works.