The most influential people on the UK Right

Iain Dale has blogged on the 25 most influential people on the right in UK politics.  It’s an interesting concept doing it by political alignment, so it isn’t so much about who is in Government, but about who has sway amongst their own side.

Of course all these power lists are subjective and more entertainment than serious.  I did note with delight that Tony Blair is listed at No 10 on the Right’s list. He was more a right winger than left winger in reality.

The top ten are:

1 David Cameron MP, Leader of the Opposition
2 George Osborne MP, Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer
3 Lord Ashcroft, Deputy Chairman of the Conservative Party
4 Lady Thatcher, Former Prime Minister
5 Steve Hilton, Director of Strategy, Conservative Party
6 William Hague MP, Shadow Foreign Secretary
7 David Davis MP, Shadow Home Secretary
8 Michael Spencer, Conservative Party Treasurer
9 Michael Gove MP, Shadow Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families
10 Tony Blair, Former Prime Minister

I can’t help noting that I’ve actually managed to meet five of the people in the top ten, thanks to my IDU forays.  Three of them have only been meet and greets for a few minutes at functions, but two of them have been through spending a couple of weeks together at conferences.

I was invited over to the Tory Party conference this year, which has just finished, and would love to have made it.   But far too busy.  Next year will be worse with our election but may aim for 2009.  Their conferences leave our ones for dead – amazing spectacles.

Public Policy for Students and Young Ones

The Business Roundtable has a forum tomorrow (Tuesday) night for students and youngish people (I guess under 30) on the subject of “Public Policy: Whose Business Is It?”.

The panel is Labour MP Charles Chauvel, Seaworks CEO Bill Day, and Roger Kerr.

It’s a low key forum to get younger people  interested in public policy issues.  In the best Kiwi tradition beers and pizzas will be provided on the night.  So if you are interested in public policy and/or economics come along.

Date: Tuesday 9 October
Time: 5.30 pm – 7.00 pm
Venue: NZBR, Level 12, Bayleys Building, cnr Lampton Quay and Brandon Street

RSVP to Laura Currie by e-mail or 471 8206.  You do need to RSVP to attend.

I’d love to attend myself (cough they did say youngish cough) but will be in Tauranga tomorrow night.

National and Greens

First Nick Smith attended the Greens conference, and now Metira Turei attended National’s BlueGreens Conference, as reports NZPA.

Obviously a good thing to be identifying areas where one can work together.

I don’t see any realistic prospect that the Greens would choose to support National over Labour.  Bradford, Locke and Norman are “hard left” former communists and even if environmental policies get closer, the other issues remain a big barrier.

if there is any co-operation, what is most likely is an agreement to abstain on confidence and supply votes in exchange for various environmental commitments.  There would be some sense in National offering the Greens such a deal, even if they did not need their abstentions in order to govern.

Air NZ queues

I like the sounds of where Air NZ is planning to go in this article.

Regular flyers will get RFID tags for their luggage and you can place them directly onto a conveyer belt.  Superb – no more queues indeed.

Updated news videos on board domestic flights also good.

What I do wish someone would change, is the security scanning at Wellington Airport.  At Auckland they have it so you do it before the Koru Club, and hence can go straight at boarding call onto the flight.

In Wellington you have to queue up waiting sometimes for ages to get security checked, even after the boarding call.

They should move the security check down into the beginning of the corridor just after the coffee bar.  Should be cheaper also as you have one check for all gates.

User Registration

I’ve just been deleting fake user registrations from spammers. I don’t have to do this, as new users posts are held for approval until they have had at least one post approved.  But I like to know how many actual users who have posted comments we have.

The total is now 789 incidentially.

When I delete probable spammer accounts, it is possible I sometimes accidentally delete a genuine user.   This only happens if it looks highly suspicious and I can’t recall ever seeing a comment from it Here’s a quick guide as to how to minimise this possibility:

  •  Use a .nz e-mail.  I never delete registrations with a .nz e-mail address. I always delete those ending in .ru or .cn.  If it ends in .com, then I look at other stuff.
  • Have your username be something meaningful and not a pharmaceutical product
  • Consider entering something in the name field.  Now this need not be your real name and you need not have it appear with your posts.  It could just be “Not a effing spammer”.

Having said all this, don’t worry too much.  I’ve not heard of anyone complaining their account has been accidentially deleted, and even if it happens takes seconds to set a new one up.

New Youth Drinking Laws

As most will know I was involved in the campaign to stop the alcohol purchase age increasing from 18 to 20.  I thought it was discriminatory, wrong and ineffective.

The Keep it 18 campaign pushed for more work to be done on the supplying of alcohol to people under 18, rather than targetting legal 18 and 19 year olds having a drink at a bar.

Well according to this SST story, the Government is looking at doing just that, and mostly it looks sensible.  My initial thoughts:

  • * The creation of a new offence for an adult to supply alcohol to anyone under 18 who goes on to consume alcohol in a public place – good, but may not catch those 200 string parties which spill onto backlawns and involve Police.
  • A new offence for anyone under 18 to supply another minor with alcohol to be consumed in a public place – yep also good – often older teens supply younger teens
  • Managers of licensed premises will lose their right to sell alcohol if they are caught selling alcohol to minors three times within three years – ouch, pretty harsh.  Maybe too harsh but having a clear line is a good thing.
  • Zero tolerance of alcohol consumption for drivers aged under 20. The current limit is 30mg for every 100ml of blood, lower than the 80mg limit for over-20s – not so sure on this.  The current limit means that one can effectively have barely a drink and be legal, so is close to a zero ban.  I’m not sure arresting someone who had one sip of beer is sensible.  I’d like to see road safety stats on how many accidents are caused by young drivers whose blood alcohol is greater than zero and less than 30.
  • * Tighter rules over which documents those selling alcohol can rely on as proof of a young person’s age – yeah should be passport, driver’s license or that special proof of age card.
  • * Removal of a major loophole used by bars and shops to avoid prosecution for the sale of alcohol to minors. Currently, the law says it is a defence if a shop or bar “believed on reasonable grounds” that the person they were selling to was over 18 – good, retailers should be checking for anyone at all who is even close to marginal.  That may mean age checking anyone who looks under 30.

Will be interesting to see the actual Bill.  I do wonder though why on Earth they are only consulting with support parties, and not all parties in Parliament.  This is not a politically partisan issue.

Borrowing and Debt

Some sensible stuff from Bill English on debt.

National finance spokesman Bill English has signalled his party would increase government borrowing to invest in infrastructure such as roads and water.

Borrowing is the totally routine and normal way to fund some capital expenditure.  That spreads the cost of the expenditure over the lifetime of the asset so that all those who benefit from it fund it, rather than just those in the year it is built.  It’s the whole reason it is capital, not operating, expenditure.

English goes on to say:

 “The real limitation is the cost of debt servicing, not the amount of debt.”

Indeed. You look at what the interest (and the depreciation) will do to your income and expenditure and whether it is manageable or not.

Ralston on Key

Bill Ralston uses his traditional colourful language saying John Key faces his own insurgency from Labour foot soldiers.

He does make the helpful point that neither Labour or NZ First had a manifesto policy on Iraq at the last election. So the issue isn’t (as I said) whether there should have been a mention of Iraq in the policy – it is the quality of the explanation as to why it wasn’t there.

Ralston points out MPs no longer have to just subdue the press gallery reporters, but with more and more reporters turning to blogging, their ability to really use a blowtorch is much greater than in their traditional print mediums. Ralston refers to said reporters becoming wolverines.

To some degree the blogs can be like instant focus groups. You don’t have to wait long to get a feel of whether people think an issue has been handled well or not. We’re a lot cheaper also 🙂

Ralston is spot on with his final para when he says:

David Lange once characterised the financial markets as “reef fish”, rapidly turning en masse this way and that. The media is a bit like that too, and National’s biggest problem will be getting the school to turn back its way.

At some stage the focus will go back on Labour, but for the next few weeks or even longer, National will be under scrutiny, as in this HoS editorial. Getting through those tough periods is what gets you ready for Government.

Top tax rates

Fran O’Sullivan writes on the low level in NZ for the top tax rate to apply, compared to other countries.  I’m going to copy her table but convert it all to NZ$.

  • Australia – 45 per cent at $212,000
  • United States – 35 per cent at $459,000
  • Britain – 40 per cent at $93,000
  • Canada – 29 per cent at $162,000
  • Ireland – 41 per cent at $80,000
  • New Zealand – 39 per cent at $60,000.

As I calculated after the Australian budget this year, you pay less tax in Australia at around every income level up until $240,000 or so.

VUWSA 2008

A week overdue with the story, but did want to record the outcome of the VUWSA elections.  The turnout was massively higher than previous years and the A-team were heaving defeated.  And one has to always respect the will of the voters.

Interestingly, incumbent President Geoff Hayward was also defeated, which probably disappointed Young Labour whose members otherwise won many Exec positions. How they work with Joel Cosgrove next year remains to be seen. Cosgrove has to be congratulated for running an energetic campaign which won him the job.

It’s a bit harsh on Geoff Hayward who struggled all year with a divisive Exec.  But I suspect he will be glad in hindsight not to have won and to be moving on.

Also congrats to Chris Bishop who beat Sonny Thomas by two votes for the role of student rep on the University Council. Commiserations also to Sonny.

I had blogged that I thought the Salient coverage was unfair, so in all fairness I should link to the response from Editor Steve Nicoll. It sounsd like the Returning Officer wasn’t too happy also – will be interesting to read her formal report if it is published.

I’ll actually be seeing most of the Salient staff tonight, as I am a guest at the Aotearoa Student Press Association (ASPA) Awards dinner tonight.  I was a judge (one of three) for the best columnist award.  Should be a very fun night.

Span retires

Span has announced she is retiring from blogging.

I’ve always enjoyed Span’s posts because they tend to be thoughtful, relevant and free of malice. Obviously the number of issues we agreed on was few, but I listed her in my list of top NZ political blogs which I put together for a UK publication a couple of months ago.

Span also did useful community stuff like take over the monthly stats for me.

It would be an interesting exercise to chart the average lifetime of a NZ political blog.  Sites like NZ Pundit and About Town which I thought would last for ages, have both departed.

Conservative Republicans

In New Zealand, republicanism is more associated with the left than the right. Much the same in Australia. The interesting thing though is that some of the most prominent republicans tend to be conservatives – Malcolm Turnbull in Australia and Jim Bolger in New Zealand.

Lewis Holden blogs that in Canada it is quite different though. The most left wing party, the New Denocrats, are most against a republic. And those most in favour are from the Conservative Party of Canada.

The reasons for this it is thought, is that some left wing Canadians think being a Republic will make them more like the United States. I always find it interesting how much of the Canadian psyche is about not being American.

September Visitors

No time to do a full stats report, but here are some of the most frequent visitors:

  • Parliament 6,661
  • Vic Uni 4,361
  • Otago Uni 2,463
  •  IRD 2,095
  • Ministry of Social Development 1,191
  • Bell Gully 942
  • Treasury 939
  • APN (Herald) 796
  • TVNZ 560
  • National Library 534
  • NZX 127
  • Police Complaints Authority 127

Husbands as Taonga

The attempt to stop a deportation by lodging a treaty claim that the husband is a taonga and protected under the Treaty is of course not serious.  It’s a publicity stunt, and the Waitangi Tribunal has sensibly declined to even hear the case.

I can understand why some Maori leaders are annoyed at the claim.  Vexatious claims just stir up antipathy in the wider population

Similarly unhelpful is when some fraudster starts selling passports or permits and claiming they have the right to do so under the Treaty.  It just undermines support for genuine Treaty claims.

Field to appeal

Field is saying he will appeal the decision to allow charges to be filed.  His chance of success must be close to zero (that comment relates to this stage only, not to eventual guilt) and if he does appeal it will be simply to delay things as long as possible.

A minor inaccuracy in the Herald article. They state he can not stand if he is convicted.  Unless he is in jail he can stand, even with a conviction.  But if the conviction occurs prior to the election, then he loses his seat immediately and a by-election is called (unless it is within six months of the general election).

Quotes on Iraq

Fran O’Sullivan provides some very useful quotes from Clark and Goff on how the war in Iraq is over.  A pity other media did not research these earlier on and ask some pointed questions:

Goff:

Government was considering to ensure New Zealand played its part in humanitarian and reconstruction efforts in post-conflict Iraq.

“We should all, however, acknowledge with great relief and satisfaction that the conflict was short”“New Zealand supports the establishment of the Governing Council of Iraq and welcomes the passage of this new resolution. It provides a sound basis for the engagement of the international community in the post-war reconstruction of Iraq.”

Clark:

“The Security Council resolution provides for those countries like ours, which did not participate in the war and are not occupying powers, to play a role in Iraq without acquiring the status of occupying powers.”

“The Government has always said that New Zealand was prepared to play a role in post-conflict Iraq”

And never forget – if the war in Iraq is not over, then Helen Clark sent NZ troops into that war.  You can’t have it both ways.

Oliver on National

Paula Oliver in the NZ Herald has some good advice and thoughts:

National will have to be careful which battles it picks to differentiate itself from Labour before the election.

Key refers to some core principles of the party that won’t change – tax cuts, smaller government, a tougher stance on law and order, mutual obligation on welfare, and a fundamentally greater trust of the private sector to play a role.

He acknowledges that if National looks too much like Labour there is little point in voting for his party, and he knows he won’t get to the ninth floor of the Beehive with tax cuts alone.

That list is a good start.  I would also add on a preference for targeted assistance over universal subsidies.  I think this is crucial – one can do so much more if you target assistance to those genuinely in need rather than give out welfare payments to people earning $120,000+.

It would have been a lot easier for National to have had a debate about partnering with the private sector in health and education if deputy leader Bill English hadn’t, just days before, tested the waters for partial SOE sales.

Public private partnerships is one battle National does look likely to fight, particularly in the area of building infrastructure.

Even senior figures in Labour acknowledge such a policy could potentially be sold to voters.

In education and health, there is a feeling that if National’s political management improves it could convince people not to be scared of greater private sector involvement.

Parents may not be too worried who built the school that little Johnny goes to, as long as there is one handy to home and its standard of education is good.

Patients, too, may not worry who removed their gall bladder as long as the pear-shaped item is gone.

Indeed.  A minority of New Zealanders are worried about the means of better education or healthcare.  The majority are focused on the outcomes and not that worried about the means fo achieving those better outcomes.

Exes

If you ever think you have a bad relationship with your ex, I am sure it is not as bad as Charlie Sheen and Denise Richards:

CHARLIE Sheen has branded his ex-wife Denise Richards an “evil, jobless pig,” after allegedly sent the actress a vicious, abusive email. According to Fox news.com, Sheen fumed: “You are a pig. A sad, jobless pig who is sad and talentless and sad and jobless and evil and a bad mom, so go f**k yourself, sad, jobless pig.”

In another email, Sheen is said to cruelly taunt Richards about her mother, who is currently being treated for cancer. He wrote: “Go cry to your bald mom, you loser.”

I pity the kids.

Field to stand trial

Newstalk ZB reports:

 The Chief High Court Judge has given permission for police to lay criminal charges against Mangere MP Phillip Field The Chief High Court Judge has granted leave for police to prosecute Phillip Field.

Police had to seek a determination from the High Court as to whether they can proceed with the 15 counts of bribery they are seeking to lay against the Mangere MP.

Justice Randerson says the material presented is sufficient to grant the leave to prosecute. He says the allegations against Mr Field are extremely serious and there is strong public interest to see them fully tested in a Court of Law.

Justice Randerson says he is satisfied no improper pressure has been brought to bear on the investigation of the alleged offences, or the decision to prosecute.

Taito Phillip Field will not be the only one worried.  I think Damien O’Connor has a lot of questions to answer on what he was told, and when.

And let us remember, that Helen Clark and Michael Cullen have both said the only thing Field is guilty of, is being extra helpful to his constituents.  We’ll find out if a jury agrees with them.

New Blogs

Molesworth and Featherston in their latest issue, noted:

Blogging back

We’re fascinated to watch Labour’s fightback in the blogosphere, with the launch of a partyaligned blog, The Standard. Labour has trailed among bloggers, leaving commentary on the left to the likes of more left No Right Turn and the Greens’ Frog Blog. Commentator Russell Brown’s Public Address is the granddaddy of New Zealand blogs, and sympathetic to Labour, but National has been reaping the gains of an enormous readership for David Farrar’s Kiwiblog – its daily readership rivals a modest daily newspaper.

Just as important as their enormous readership, though, the blogs are influencing editorial content. Where they once drew their cues from mainly from talkback, reporters are now also daily watching the main blogs as straws in the wind. It helps give editorial weighting to the salience of issues. Labour scored a hit with a brutal (and unfairly edited) video of John Key at the Porirua weekend market. National have owned this space for a while. Blogs aren’t new any more, but their political sophistication, reach and influence is growing.

The challenge partly is also how many stay around after an election. It’s usual as the election gets closer for mroe blogs to appear, but many of the “left” ones took off the moment the election was over. They’re just there for the votes.

Now a group of people seem to be so worried about Kiwiblog that they feel the need to have set up their own blog whose sole role in life is to psycho-analyse Kiwiblog. Hey it’s a free world, and if it brings joy to them – well keeps them off the streets I suppose.

Unfortunately for them though, they have over-active imaginations which would make them eligible for a 9/11 conspiracy group membership.

In one post trying to analyse why I post about VUWSA from time to time, they actually went through the photos from my birthday party, recognised one person there as a former manager of the Vic Uni Union (not VUWSA) and in the best Pink Panther traditions speculated that perhaps he was behind why I posted about VUWSA and not other student associations. I do no exagerate when I say both Chris and I were laughing so hard at this, that it almost hurt. I mean one needs to normally pay for this level of comedy. The geniuses at work ignored the obvious answer that doh I live in Wellington and VUWSA is my local association.

Then in another post, they conclude that my disapproval of National dropping bulk funding, is a smokescreen to cover up that National promised more support to private schools. Okay so get this – the fact I blogged on the parts of National’s policy I disagreed with, and didn’t cover the parts I agreed with – is seen by them as running interference for National!!

The problem with the authors is they are so blindly loyal to their cause, that they really really can not comprehend such a thing as honest opinion.

I was bored enough a few days ago to quite a quick browse though the last fortnigth or so of posts from me. They include:

  • Linked to Espiner story heavily criticizing National
  • Embedded and dispayed an anti John Key video
  • Supported a union organized anti Burma march
  • Quoted Hooton praising Labour on climate change
  • Criticised National’s handling of health discussion paper
  • Advocated for a Republic (out of step with most Nat MPs)
  • Praised Govt’s telecommunication reforms
  • Praised Govt consultation on compulsory third party car insurance
  • Given favourable review of Chris Trotter book
  • Supported Labour and Green candidates in local elections
  • Post on Labour’s climate change policy where I disagree with National’s policy
  • Agreed with Helen Clark with her criticism of John Key re Clint Rickards case
  • Linked to NRT post about how National may still struggle to form a Government
  • Declared Helen Clark a winner from the Zaoui decision
  • Gave Wally of the Week to a National MP
  • Disagreed with National on voting for party pill ban legislation
  • Said Clark was right not to accept O’Connor resignation

Now don’t get me wrong. I have my biases and my sympathies. I make no claims to be objective. But this blog is about me saying what I think on anything that is of interest to me. It isn’t part of any masterplan. I don’t get talking points from anyone at all. I don’t analyse every post with a filter about how to make National look good. I actually treat my readers with far more respect than that.

So any analysis which starts with a presumption that it is designed purely to gain votes or support for one party, is going to permanently stay flawed. But hey as I said it’s a free world.

UPDATE: Half Done previously covered this also.

National’s Foreign Affairs Policy

Okay finally had time to actually catch up with and read National’s Foreign Affairs Policy Discussion Paper.

Two aspects of it should fo course have been no surprise to anyone.  They had been announced many months or even years ago.  The decision not to reinstate an air combat wing was policy in the 2005 election, and the no change in the nuclear free law was announced in late 2006.  So how restating these is a surpise I don’t know.

The paper states:

The real political debate in the future will be about implementation of external policy strategy – not an deological debate about fundamental objectives.

And I think that is generally correct.  Most areas of foreign policy are bipartisan. Once upon a time Labour was pro protectionism and ant free trade.  No more.  Likewise National once saw ANZUS as our key foreign and defence relationship while elements of Labour wanted to join the non-aligned countries.  Now both are in the centre.

The big change in emphasis for National is to look after the Pacific as a “senior player” rather than being a “junior player” in wider spheres.  To quote:

More importantly, greater focus on the South Pacific is required. We understand this is already the main target area for development assistance – National simply wants to push existing logic further down this track. We will not renew certain aid projects in distant regions that are not grounded in any realistic appraisal of New Zealand’s interests or our capacity to make a difference.

Fresh thinking is required on development assistance strategy. The phrase ‘poverty elimination’ has become a mantra. It owes its place to larger international debates in the United Nations where Africa, in particular, presents intractable problems for donors and recipients alike. We respect the reasons for that internationally, but the situation in the South Pacific is different. Certainly, poverty is part of the region’s problems, but the bigger picture is to enhance the political and economic sustainability of our neighbouring states.

A National Government will not stand by and watch the creation of a sub-class of New Zealand citizens in the Cooks, Tokelau, and Niue.

A welcome emphasis on exporting:

  • Adjust NZ Trade and Enterprise activities to make it less bureacratic and more focused on exporting and offshore activity.
  • Expect Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade posts to make support of exporters their most important priority. 

Overall the policy is pretty non controversial (as expected) but does reflect a desire to be more tightly focused on trade access and on the Pacific.  The greater Pacific emphasis is new, and to be fair one than Winston Peters has also pushed.  By helping keep the Pacific secure, we increase our relevance to major players like the US, and it is no coincidence the US Navy is returning to the South Pacific after an absnece of many years.

This then leaves Iraq.  I want to deal with that in two parts – should it have been in the policy, and John Key’s statement that the war in Iraq is over.

Taking the latter first – what John said was of course technically correct but it was politically naive to say it because it is all too easy for people to ridicule out of context.  Part of being sucessful in politics is the ability to use language that is not easy to attack.

Coming on the back of three other events managed sub-optimally, the overall fortnight comes across as reasonably shambolic.  Any of the events in isolation would not be a hige thing, but when you get them all together, it starts to shake confidence in the political management. Colin Espiner’s blog post doesn’t mince words but is pretty fair on the issue.

In the comments on Colin’s blog, Craig Ranapia notes that Helen Clark herself has differentiated between the war phase and the post-war phase:

Iraq did not meet our criteria for intervention in 2003 and we did not participate in the war there. We did, for one year, send New Zealand Defence Force engineers to do civilian reconstruction work, believing that was consistent with the United Nations mandate established in the course of 2003.

Where I will disagree with Colin, is on whether Iraq should have been signifcantly mentioned in the policy because it is”probably still the greatest conflagration in the world at present”.

The only question left in Iraq is at what pace coalition forces leave.  There probably isn’t a single Govt in the world that doesn’t already have troops there that is considering sending troops in. There are no decisions about Iraq for New Zealand to make. There’s a lot of lessons to be learnt from what happened in Iraq, but in terms of current decisions for New Zealand – there are none.

Dewar gets four and a half years

NBR on Kiwiblog

The satirical In Tray column of NBR devotes its entire column to Kiwiblog this week. Their article is below, and not just does a good job of taking the mickey out of me, but also several regular commenters:

HELPING A PENGUIN 669 words Oct 5th 2007 12:30am Finance/Nbr

Deloitte infrastructure specialist Paul Callow backs the use of private-public partnerships
From the country’s leading online political forum … Kiwi Blog

Had a nice experience this morning. Just finished reading briefing papers from Bill and John and other National Party friends, and thought it might be good to walk along Oriental Parade to think about new company strategy for Curia. Strolling by the sea I saw an animal in some distress! Went over and discovered it was an injured penguin!! Had to stop talking with Helen on my mobile about latest Curia poll results to help the poor creature. Called vet who promptly arrived and treated it.

So now I’m back in my jim-jams and sitting at the computer thinking about the penguin I saved and feeling pretty good about it. Isn’t life grandy and dandy?

Posted by David P. Farrar I 8:14am October 5th, 2007 I 32,667 Comments >>
Miss Ten Says:October 5th, 2007, 8.15am
Good on you David!
Wellington Guy Says:October 5th, 2007, 8:16am
Way to go DPF. Good to see people caring for less fortunate animals. Cheers.
Sonic Says:October 5th, 2007, 8:17am
Funny that. While rich National Party supporters and their AmeriKKKan friends deplete the worlds resources theres old David saving the little penguins. Remind me again, how do you spell hypercrite?

whaleoil Says:October 5th, 2007, 8:19am
It’s “hypocrite.”
Sonic Says:October 5th, 2007, 8:20am
Thanks for the tip knucklehead. Could you tell us how to spell “Burmese hunta” while youre at it? I’m sorry but while youve been speaking the military goons in Asia have put even more pressure on the windpipe of democracy. … and what does everyone here want to talk about? Penguins? Please!?!?!

dad4justice Says:October 5th, 2007 8.21am
forget about burma. the best way for Aunty Helen and her Liarbour friends to fix THIS country would be to call an election today and hand over the rains of power to the National Party.

Sonic Says:October 5th, 2007, 8:22am
Don’t you mean National Socialist Party???
gd Says:October 5th, 2007, 8:23am
No he meant “National Party” loser.
Sonic Says:October 5th, 2007, 8:24am
Only fascists talk about saving penguins when there are so many other important things happening. Do you think decent people would be sitting around talking about penguins if we were in Nazi Germany during the 1930s?? No, they would be speaking the truth to power!

Tane Says:October 5th, 2007 at 8:24 pm
And while we’re at it, what was John Key and the National Party’s position on the Iraq War again?!?!
MarkB Says:October 5th, 2007, 8:24am
Hi David, Sorry I’ve been out of touch, but I’ve been very busy saying my goodbyes to everyone here in Parliament and realising again how hard it is for someone like me to hate everyone. Do you think it’s too late for me to contest the mayoralty this year? I have some new photos of my eyebrows a very clever publicist (hint hint!) could use for publicity! Cheers, Mark

Redbaiter Says:October 5th, 2007 at 8.26am
And while we’re at it, what was John Key and the National Party’s position on the Iraq War again?!?!
Bad bad bad comprehension there junior. The real point is that the Greens and the Liarbour Party are supporting a bill that has universally been described as the worst piece of legislation that’s ever been passed anywhere since the time of the Nazis!!!! Youre all leftie scum and I hope you all die!!!!!

David P. Farrar Says:October 5th, 2007 at 8.26am
Hey, could you all PLEASE keep the conversation a *little* more civilised? I’ve got a really exciting post coming up about what happened a few moment ago when I went to the bathroom!!!!

Sonic Says:October 5th, 2007 at 8.27am
You know what? If I wasn’t a weeny little nerd with a $70K a year job to hold down as a political party researcher I would pick up a gun and shoot every one last of you worthless Nazi scum dead!!!! After torturing you all slowly first!!!! Hahahahahaha!!!!

[Continues all day and night]

The Electoral Finance Bill and the Bill of Rights

One of the mysteries of recent time has been how on Earth the Crown Law Office said the Electoral Finance Bill did not breach the Bill of Rights. The Human Rights Commission and the New Zealand Law Society have strongly disagreed. In fact it is laughable that a Bill which would require a protester to file a statutory declaration for their protest placard could be seen to even be a marginal call for breaching the Bill of Rights.

Now the Crown Law Office is meant to be the custodian of the Bill of Rights. The independent watchdog who blows the whistle on proposed laws which may breach these rights. Yet somehow amazingly they did not do so in this case. The opinion, done by the human rights team leader Val Sim, said the Electoral Finance Bill did not breach the Bill of Rights.

This opinion has been trumpeted in Parliament by Justice Minister Mark Burton. The Human Rights Commission would label it “a dramatic assault on two fundamental human rights” and the Law Society has said it is “inconsistent with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990” but the Government just paints this as lawyers disagreeing because they have their Crown Law opinion.

The Government also suggested that the Law Commission could help sort of some of the minor drafting issues with the Bill. Nothing majorly wrong – just a few tweaks by the Law Commission.

Now as NBR reports, Ms Sim has this week been appointed to the Law Commission. And who appointed her? None other than Mark Burton.

What sort of injury?

Sideswipe had this item:

Bureaucracy in action: This message was distributed to Waitemata DHB staff: “Following an injury to a staff member earlier this year it has been recommended that an improved type of toilet roll dispenser be introduced. Over the next few weeks a contract carpenter will be replacing toilet roll dispensers throughout the organisation commencing at Waitakere Hospital. We apologise for any inconvenience caused while this work is undertaken.”

Okay, so what sort of injury do you suffer in a toilet, and how is it stopped by having a different type of toilet roll dispenser?

One has to really wonder if the existing toilet roll dispensers are so dangerous they all need replacing, or was the accident just freakish?